<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ахвяруйце Ахвяруйце штомесячна

Orthodoxy & Heresy

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

In Lecture 5, the rule of faith, orthodoxy and peracy, the prayer today will be from climate of Alexandria. We have met climate several times, particularly in the last lecture because climate is one of the most important of the apologist of the early church and a very influential church father. This prayer, which is in the syllabus, is an interesting one for one thing, there are some unusual names for God, such as teacher or instructor, and charioteer of Israel, names for God that we would not normally use, but not inappropriate names for God. Notice too that when climate is praying about what it means to have come into the Lord's church, he says that we have sail tranquilly over the billows of sin. It doesn't strike me as being quite the right way to say it, at least I have not sail tranquilly over the billows of sin, but we'll pray it anyway in the words of climate. I suppose there is a certain tranquility and a certain rest that we experience, I know there is even in the midst of struggles with temptation and sin and suffering. So we'll think of it that way as we pray these words from climate, and notice how he struggles to express in words the doctrine of the Trinity. We have not yet come to the Council of Nicaea about a hundred years after climate of Alexandria when the church is able to put together its faith in the doctrine of the Trinity in ways that commended themselves to most Christians, but at this point Christians are still struggling to express that doctrine. We don't fully understand it, but at least we have words that we can use orthodox words that the church has approved of after the Council of Nicaea, but as I said this takes place a long time before Nicaea. So with those words about the prayer, we will now pray, join with me as I read these ancient words from climate of Alexandria. Congratulations, O instructor, to us thy children, father, charioteer of Israel, son and father both in one, O Lord. Grant to us who obey thy precepts that we may perfect the lightness of the image, and with all our power know Him who is the good God and not a harsh judge, and do thou thyself cause that all of us who have our conversation in thy peace who have been translated into thy commonwealth, having sailed tranquilly over the billows of sin, may be wafted in calm by thy Holy Spirit, by the unethical wisdom, by night and day to the perfect day. And giving thanks may praise and praising thank the father and son, son and father, the son, instructor and teacher, with the Holy Spirit all in one in whom is all, for whom all is one, for whom is eternity, whose members we all are, whose glory the heavens are, for they all good, all lovely, all wise, all just one, to whom be glory, both now and forever, amen. So we come to this lecture today, we're going to talk about some of the heresies that arose in the second century, and caused great concern for a long time in the early church. One modern writer has spoken of the second and the third centuries as a time of productive confusion in the history of the church, and I expect as you have read the text and as I have been talking about early church history, we do see a good bit of that confusion, but these people are pioneers leading the way in doing the great work of defending the faith, and of stating the faith, and of living the faith, and we honor them for that even though they make many mistakes, it is a time of productive confusion, this is certainly true in the area of doctrine, what should Christians really believe, how should they express their faith, what is right and what is wrong, a lot of ideas floating around, they call themselves now Christian, not just pagan ideas and Judaism and Christianity, but varieties of Christianity began to develop, and the church has to try to decide what really is allowable, what is true, and what is not, gradually there was an answer to that question, and we call that answer orthodoxy, the orthodox position of the church, it means right belief, and we call everything else heresies, originally that word simply meant an opinion, a party, a group, but eventually it comes to mean something that is wrong, something that is opposed to true teaching. Question is often asked which came first, did orthodoxy come first, followed by the heresies, or did the heresies arise first, and the church in response to the heresies moved to create what we call orthodoxy, one modern scholar has put it this way, in early Christianity there was no such thing as orthodoxy, but only different forms of Christianity competing for the loyalties of believers, this man believed that there were a lot of ideas out there, and finally some of those ideas, one, either the ideas of the Roman church, which became the strongest church, were imposed on the entire church, or in some way certain ideas, one, so in his point of view the heresies come first, a lot of ideas, and then gradually one idea, which is called orthodoxy, in that particular way of reading history the orthodox are simply the winners, and the heretics are the losers, well I describe that not because that's my view, but I want you to see that question is one that people have given great deal of thought to, but the early church fathers did not view it that way, the early church fathers said that orthodoxy came first, and then the heresies, the heresies are the innovations, the new things, orthodoxy is not, eusebias of cesarea put it this way orthodoxy does not have a history, it's true eternally, heresy has a history, having arisen that particular times through particular teachers, so you can date the beginning of montenism and marcianism and some of these other heresies that we're going to talk about, but orthodoxy doesn't have a beginning, you can't date it, and orthodoxy is eternally true, but heresies come later, well we have to think about that a little bit too because I think we have to be a little more nuanced in our answer to this question, certainly don't think we should say the heresies came first, just a lot of ideas out there and somehow the church decided to take some of those and reject others, nor can we go the other way and say that orthodoxy was always there just like it comes to be held eventually in the church. Eusebias said that heresies the work of the devil to darken the radiance of the universal and only true church, so in his view truth is there, it's always there and the devil is busy trying to create some kind of confusion by bringing in these heresies, it's a kind of negative view of the role of the heresies and certainly that is true, saying Augustine those sees it somewhat differently, Augustine says the rejection of heretics brings into relief what God's church holds and what sound doctrine maintains. That certainly sees heresies as bad and destructive but as having a place in God's providential plan for the church, the church holds truth, but perhaps not clearly, not expressed directly and explicitly until the heresies attack and then the church is forced to discover its own truth, to put into words the truth that it has held. So I think we could look at it this way, I'll illustrate it with this chart, there was orthodoxy but orthodoxy implicit, not fully spelled out, not understood or stated clearly, such as in the doctrine of the Trinity, the first Christians believe that Jesus was God, they knew that the father was God, they believe the Holy Spirit was God but they had not yet come to understand their faith, that is how they could believe that each of these persons is God and yet they're only be, as they also believed, one God. That's going to come because of heresies that develop that force the church to really try to understand what it already believes. So I illustrated this way orthodoxy and quotation marks at implicit early orthodoxy is there in the very days of the beginnings of the church based on the teachings of Jesus and the apostles but then the heresies come in and then in response to the heresies orthodoxy now is underlined, it's clearer it is more fully understood and adequately defined. So with that introduction let's look at three, the three most important heresies that came into the church in the second century, Gnosticism, Marcianism, and Montinism. Gnosticism is something we need to think about for a few minutes because it plays a very significant role in the history of the church. There are various types of Gnosticisms, some related more to Judaism, some were anti-Christian but many of the Gnosticisms were Christian Gnosticism. So we have now a Christian heresy people claiming to be Christians who hold to some variety of Gnosticism. Gnosticism was a very dangerous opponent of orthodox Christian faith because it threatened to suck Christianity into the general amalgamation of religious views, a process that as we have already said was going on in the Roman world at that time. Synchrotism was the big word and religions tended to put together features from other religions to create a synchrotistic faith to mix in the teachings of the philosophers and to produce something that was considered better and Gnostic certainly were doing this. Gnosticism was also intellectually sophisticated and attractive to many people because it did draw on certain elements of Greek philosophy, blood for knowledge, certain depreciation of the physical and of the human body, ideas that were out there in intellectual circles. I suppose we could get a sense of this when you think of a modern professor at the university saying, well, science tells us such and such, supposed to be the last word, not the Bible, not tradition, science. Well, the professors back at Alexandria and Athens and other places in the Roman world would hold up this Gnostic faith that way. Gnosticism teaches such and such and it was dangerous because it was considered intellectually up-to-date and modern. It was also as I've already suggested very diverse and many, many different kinds of Gnosticism. It's just a big word that includes certain religious ideas that had certain things in common but very different approaches to those ideas. Dangerous, diverse to keep the Ds going difficult. It was hard to handle this religion. The church fathers wrote many books against the Gnostic in order to try to answer the Gnostic religion that was attractive to many people and actually drawing many Christians into its ranks. Ironia said Gnosticism is like the mythological hydra, the snake, the many heads. You cut off one head and two more grows. So you can answer one point of Gnosticism, there are others that come up. But having said all that, I think we can, for the sake of simplicity, talk about three basic ideas that Gnostic's Hill, the Christian Gnostic's so-called Christian Gnostic's. The first is dualism. The Gnostic's believe that there were two powers, not one, not a single god but a good god and then an evil god and they were somewhat equally matched. They also believe that it was the evil god, not the good god who created the universe because the universe is bad. It's full of sand and evil and trouble and this world is bad, physical body is bad, everything material is bad and salvation is to try to escape from being captured in the body and in the world and rise to the realm of the spirit world. An ancient philosopher has summed up the Gnostic's, this way. The Gnostic's think very well of themselves and very ill of the universe. Pretty good summary. They didn't like what they saw out there. Creation is a kind of cosmic goof created by a foolish god, a demi-erge. They called him, and many of the Gnostic's identified him with Jehovah of the Old Testament. He is the one that made this mess in which we live and he is not the same as the true eternal god. But with the demi-erge created the world, he accidentally put within human beings some sparks of divinity. So even though we're part of this material world, we have a divine nature that is related to that higher world and salvation means escaping from the material world into the higher spiritual world. Well, how are we going to do that? And here's where the Christian Gnostic came in because they said Christ will help us. They believed in Christ but not a Christ who was a real man. The Gnostic are docedic in their Christology. That means that Jesus appeared to be a man but he really wasn't. He just took the appearance of the form of a body but he is part of the spirit world. If he took a body, then he would be trapped like the rest of us. So Christ, who is not a real person but a divine spirit, comes down to help us escape from our material bodies and enter the realm of the divine spirit. He doesn't do this by being crucified for us that has no relevance for the Gnostic. He does it by coming to teach us the secret way out of this entrapment and into the spiritual world to help us find our place back. And that's quite a struggle. You read the Gnostic's rather exciting reading in a way because to make that journey from this world up to that world, you have to go through all kinds of traps and problems and encounters with the rulers of the various stages of that journey. In fact, one of the so-called Christiannostics of Alexandria said there are 365 different steps you have to take and you need a secret word or some secret knowledge for each of those steps in order to overcome the ruler of that Ion in order to advance to the next. Others don't have 365 stages but they all have a number of stages. Paul Tillich in writing about this describes it this way, what the Savior, what Jesus does in Nosticism, is somehow to use white magic against the black magic of the planetary powers. It's almost like a second century version of Star Wars in which this spiritual creature against great odds is trying to make his way out of this world a very dangerous journey. But a necessary one to finally escape the world of matter and rise to the world of spirit. Now let me just summarize all that by the next point in the outline for the Nostic salvation is by knowledge, not by faith, it's not by God's grace, it's by knowledge. Jesus is one of the sources of that knowledge. One of the church fathers said the key text in Nosticism was seek and you will find. The Nostics were always seeking and they thought they found they would find the secret word, the password that would enable them to rise to another level. Perhaps you have heard of the gospel of Thomas. It's been talked about a good bit these days. It is an early gospel in quotes, not one of the canonical gospels, but written perhaps in the late first century, it was discovered at Nagamadi in Upper Egypt in 1945 and the people that promote the Jesus Seminar like to think of Thomas as the fifth gospel. They will use the gospel of Thomas along with the canonical gospels in order to make their judgments as to what are the true and authentic words Christ. Whether church has never accepted the gospel of Thomas as true gospel, it's really a Nostic gospel. But the gospel of Thomas will put on the lips of Jesus some of the things I have just been saying about Nosticism. It is not a book that we would accept as authentic, but as a book arising out of this heresy in order to give some legitimacy to the teaching of Nosticism by saying that Jesus said certain things that have a kind of Nostic ring. It might seem that this is all very strange and all very archaic that Peter Jones who teaches out at Westminster Seminary, California is written a book called the Nostic Empire Strikes Back and by that he means the New Age movement. He finds many similarities in the New Age movement to ancient Nosticism. A heresy of self-deification has returned with a vengeance in the New Age movement according to Peter Jones. And if you are interested in that topic and in seeing the links between ancient Nosticism and this modern heresy, I would certainly commend to you the writings of Peter Jones. Now let's come to a second heresy, similar to Nosticism in some ways, very much influenced by Nosticism, but one that created something that caused the church to really begin to be concerned about doing something about its idea of the canon. You see until the church is clear on what books it holds to be the word of God, it's going to be a problem to be able to deal with heresies, the gospel of Thomas, it's going to be left out of the canon because it doesn't qualify as we'll see later, but until the church can make that clear, it's going to be an ongoing problem. And the heresy of Marcianism was the heresy that prompted the Christian church to realize that it had to move more quickly in solidifying its view of the canon. Marcian was actually the son of a Christian bishop of Asia Minor. He came to Rome in the middle of the second century and in Rome he began to develop his ideas. It was a mixture of Christianity, Nosticism, and Dostaticism.

The hero for Marcian was Paul. Epiphruse has said that only Marcian understood Paul in the early church and he misunderstood him. That's a kind of bleak statement, but there's some truth to that because we really don't get anyone that seems to grasp what Paul was all about until we get to say the guest. But Marcian did see at least that Paul was against the law, but he misunderstood him by thinking that was the Old Testament. Paul was for grace, against works, against the law. Marcian got that idea that did not fully understand it properly. He took some of Christianity and he mixed it with Nosticism. He held that the evil Old Testament God was the creator and that the true God was the father, two gods, and the Old Testament God created a bad world with insects and fear spiced and sex. Now the things that Marcian did not approve of. To Marcian matter was evil and the flesh was abhorrent. To tell you and perhaps gesting a bit with Marcian and one of his writings said and yet Old Marcian in what way were you born? By having two gods, the church fathers, Arneas and the others, and it was Arneas who wrote the most against Marcian. By having two gods, Arneas said Marcian really has no God. I think that's an important idea that the church fathers latched on to. If you have two gods, more or less equal, you don't have any God because there's no one then who is the true and supreme God. Arneas said that Marcian divides God into two and so puts an in to deity. And then like the Nostics, Marcian also had a dosetic Christ without human birth and without a material body. It's interesting that when he comes to take the gospel of Luke, which he believes is the gospel that should be viewed as the authentic one, the canonical one. He combines Luke 3-1 with 4-31, so that his gospel of Luke begins this way. In the 15th year of Tiberius Caesar, Jesus came down to Capernaum, leaves out everything about the birth of Jesus. And says in the 15th year of Tiberius Caesar, Jesus came down from heaven to Capernaum. You can see the Nostic and the Dostetic attitude expressed in that way of beginning Luke's gospel. But the most important thing for us in our history of church, study of church history, I think, is that to support these ideas, Marcian created a canon. He said, these are the true books and these are not true books so we can only use these particular books in order to base our teaching on. Of course, with his ideas, there was no Old Testament. Students, through my years of teaching here, have created some church history pigs for me, and I've added a few of my own and occasionally a church history pig will show up. So here's Marcianite pig creating the canon. Greg Palato, the student a few years ago, drew this pig. Marcianite pig creating the canon. So over here, he's got in his except box, Luke, altered some blood, and Paul, 10 pistols, Paul, that's his Bible, kind of a small one, but that's it. Over here, he's got Old Testament, everything else. So even though the Christian church, the Orthodox church did not accept any of this as true, you can see how this heresy helped to stimulate the church, to really consider seriously what is the canon and what books should we accept and what books should we not accept. We'll come to see what the church did about that next time. But right now the third of these second century heresy's monotonyism. Monotonyism began in Frigia, that was an area of Asia, Asia Minor, we call it in the middle of the second century, and it had certain emphases need to think about. Some ways monotonyism is not really, doesn't really belong in the same list, narcissism and marcionism or clearly heresy's. Monotonyism was a little more difficult to identify and to evaluate, but the church eventually considered monotonyist teaching as a whole to be heretical as well. Let's look at the points of monotonyism. There was a stress in monotonyism on the Holy Spirit. Now the time we come to the middle of the second century, a prophecies have started to disappear in the church and the extraordinary works, the miracles that we see in the New Testament and some of which are reported along with prophecies in the early post-New Testament period, seen to have gone. Now there could be two responses to this. There could be the response that many Christians have come to that the Lord discontinued these things. They had served their purpose and as the canon was eventually created, the works of the extraordinary works, the miracles that were there to undergird the canon and help to establish the beginnings of the church, dropped off and so did prophets. It's one way to look at it. It's not the way monotonyists looked at it. Monotonyists said these things have ceased because the church has lost sight of the Holy Spirit. The church has become worldly. It's even during a time of persecution but there could be let-ups, you know. So during period of peace people have settled down and they don't really believe the power of God anymore and in the work of the Spirit. So monotonyists began to emphasize the Holy Spirit. He said the dispensation of the Son, Jesus, has now come to an end and we're in a new age, which we could call the dispensation of the Holy Spirit and the Holy Spirit still speaks. And his words that he speaks are words that should be understood as the words of God, just like Holy Spirit spoke through Paul. He's still speaking now. Who is he speaking through now, but he's speaking through me? And a couple of my associates, Friska and Max Amila, two prophetesses who worked with mountainous in Asia Minor. I won't read some of those statements that are attributed oracles, attributed to mountainous and his associates. Some of them sound pretty much like verses in the Bible that we know, but others go far beyond that and say I'm the mouthpiece of God even on one occasion, mountainous is supposed to have said, I am the Lord God omnipotent dwelling in man. But anyway, there was this emphasis on continuing revelations of the Holy Spirit. It comes very early, doesn't it? History of the Church. But second emphasis is stress on the end times. Belief in the eminent return of Christ was apparently waning somewhat in the Church. After all, it had been 100 years, it's been 2000 years now, but 100 years in Christ had not come back. And so people were losing sight of that return of Christ according to mountainous. So he began to put a great deal of emphasis on the eminent return of Christ. He is coming soon to set up his kingdom, in all places in Frigia, in Asia Minor, just my hometown. Here's another church history pig, mountainous pig with a message from God, repent at the end is near. I heard a story once of a man who knew like an old prophet had a sign that he was holding up that said, the end is near and will be for some time to come. Well, here is the mountainous emphasis on the end times. And then mountainism stressed, very strict discipline. Someone said that person really could not be allowed to continue in the church and stress on holiness, stress on asceticism, rigid lifestyle. There are many followers of mountainous, particularly in Asia Minor. In fact, in some towns, everyone became a mountainist. So the whole church became mountainous in certain parts of Asia Minor. Then it spread to North Africa and many people in North Africa became mountainist. Those were the two centers for mountainism. The thing that really surprises us is that the church father Tatolian became a mountainous. And people have puzzled over that all the way down to the present as to why Tatolian would join this sect or this branch of the Christian church, or as he thought at least for a while, a true expression of the Christian church. In the spreading flame, Ethath Bruce writes this, a Dominican scholar wants remarked to me in the course of a conversation about Tatolian, that it was amazing that such an intelligent man as he should have been led away by a movement like mountainism. It's one point of view, but it might equally well be said that there must have been something of more solid worth than mountainism than is generally supposed since it appealed to such an intelligent man as Tatolian. So I pretty much have to leave it there, not sure why, Tatolian join mountainism. The way I have presented it, which is the standard approach to mountainism, makes it sound, I think, as a movement that would not have appealed to someone as careful in his thinking as Tatolian, but perhaps mountainism was in some ways better than I have made it sound. I certainly there were some true concerns there, concern for holiness, concern for church discipline, belief in the coming of Christ, a concern that the church not lose sight of the power of the Holy Spirit. So those are appropriate concerns that the mountainist may well have focused on, but it seems to me that the way they handle those particular issues led them into error. Now I want to wrap this up briefly and we'll come back to what the Orthodox Church did in response to all of this in the next lecture. The task of Orthodoxy is clear. It's to state the faith. What do Christians really believe? You can see how important it is to do that. And what books do we hold to be part of the Bible? And who has the right to say what is right and what is wrong?

And the church had to do that while realizing that what had to be done could not in one sense be done perfectly and fully. I quote Hillary of Quattier in his book on the Trinity, the eras of heretics forced us to deal with unlawful matters to scale perilous heights to speak unutterable words to trespass on forbidden ground, compelling us to air in daring to embody in human terms, truths which ought to be hidden in the silent veneration of the heart. So the church has to do two things it wants to see Christianity as a state of all religion with content. This is what it means to be a Christian. We hold these things. We have a creed. We can say these words and set forth what we believe to be true without thinking that we have exhausted the mystery and that we have every single thing solved and we have been able to cross every T and not every I. But with these heresy swirling about in the second century, gnosticism, mountainism, marcianism, and others on the way and wedding converts, it was urgent for the church to state and defend its views to get to the place where that orthodoxy is underlying and clear. And the church will do this in three ways by creating a canon, by establishing a creed and by moving toward government with bishops and our next lecture will look into all of that. The grass withers, flower fades, the word of our God will stand forever.