<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Fyala Fyala Mwedzi

Old Testament and Redemptive History, Continued

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Last time we were talking about the New Testament, use of the Old Testament, and we'll do that here in just a moment. What I'd like to do first, though, is, of course, pray before we start class. Shall we do that? Father, as we come to you at the beginning of this class, we do not do so in a perfunctory way. We realize that it is not appropriate for us to approach you in prayer as a mere exercise on the way to doing other things. Rather, we approach you as the God of the universe, who has gifted for your church the revelation of yourself, that you have done so from the very inception of creation that even in the fall, you did not revoke your revealed presence from your people. But that through time you have chosen an elected sum to be agents of you reflecting you to the world. We are thankful that we live in an era that is on this side of the supreme revelation and the incarnation of the Son of God in Christ Jesus our Lord. We would desire to worship Him and all that we do, and in this class as well, in your wonderful name we pray. Amen. Okay. Let me make sure this one. You guys can hear me, right? Sorry? Okay. I got thumbs up. When we finished last, we were going through our handout on the New Testament uses of the Old Testament, and you will remember that I made the point that there are many different ways that the New Testament uses the Old Testament. And in doing so, I think it is basically in keeping with the very spirit of the Old Testament itself. I should mention to you that there is a whole area of study that is kind of outside of our provenance here, which has to do with the way that the Old Testament uses the Old Testament. So, for example, with the law coming before the prophets, most of the prophets, the result is that you have the prophets using the Old Testament law, picking up elements of it, prophets follow in sequence from one another. You know, Haggai and Malachi were on the other end of a long string of Old Testament prophets, and so they will pick up on sayings of previous prophets and use them in various ways too. So, the Old Testament uses the Old Testament. Of course, Jewish people, prior to the first century and throughout the first century and later, I have considered the Old Testament to be their scriptures, and rightly so. And in the process, I have used the Old Testament both to consider how to live and to reflect on God and who God is and His revealing presence, etc. So, when we get to the time of the New Testament using the Old Testament, we shouldn't see this as something like somebody, you know, Peter and John were sitting around one day and they were kind of like, well, you know, we need to talk about the Christian faith, the other people, what should we do? Maybe we should use the Old Testament, right? This was something that had long been done in Judaism up until that period, and so when they speak into that context, they are speaking to people who are, you know, fully aware of some of the interpretive methods that they're using, and also who are fully interested and engaged in the way that they are employing the Old Testament to speak to the Messiah, namely Jesus. So, we shouldn't just kind of assume that this came out of the blue. I had, I'm in Roman numeropart 3, New Testament uses of the Old Testament. We had already talked about the retelling of Old Testament story and the use of exemplary characters from the Old Testament, both as good examples and as bad examples. And we were just going to head into the moral law. If we look at Ephesians chapter 6 verses 2 through 3, we will see one use of the Old Testament law. Verse 1 says, children obey your parents in the Lord for this is right. And then it says, honor your father and mother, which is the first commandment with the promise that it may be well with you and that you may live long on the earth. Now that is a quotation from the Old Testament as you would recognize from the Ten Commandments, right? So here he is actually taking one of the Ten Commandments, and he is saying this instructs you in how you as parent and child should relate. Now notice I didn't say even this still instructs you. Some people assume that law ceased with Jesus. That is a definite overstatement. If you say that law ceased with Jesus, then it is almost as if you are implying that it has no import in the Christian life. And yet Paul cites the law itself as being directly applicable to Christian behavior and to the relationships between children and fathers. Children and parents. So there we have the Old Testament moral law being used as an illustration. If we look at Romans 13, 8 through 10, we see a similar thing going on with the law. Oh nothing to anyone except to love one another for he who loves his neighbor has fulfilled the law. For this you shall not commit adultery, you shall not murder, you shall not steal, you shall not covet. And if there is any other commandment, he has just quoted the Ten Commandments right, it is summed up in this saying, you shall love your neighbor as yourself, which is from elsewhere in Leviticus. Love does no wrong to a neighbor, love therefore as the fulfillment of the law. Now in doing so, Paul is not only indebted undoubtedly to the Old Testament, but to Jesus himself because you know of Jesus' statements about the greatest commandments in the Old Testament to love the Lord your God and the second is like to love your neighbor as yourself. So we see Paul picking up both on the Old Testament and on the teachings of Jesus. But like Jesus, he is saying that the law is applicable to our relationships with one another, at least in some respects. And we would see a similar thing in James 2.11. On the other hand, if one reads through the book of Galatians, there's all sorts of aspects of the law that Christians don't do anymore. You are not required to circumcise your children, you are not required to avoid pork, you are not required to only eat with Christians and avoid Gentile pagans. These kind of expressions of the law don't apply anymore. So much so that when Paul starts talking about the nature of the law, he speaks of it as if it was in use to Christians in bringing them to Christ in a way that speaks to the law as being the Greek word is pedagogue, the one who leads you from your home to the place of instruction. That's what the law does for Paul. Paul will even speak in Romans 10 of the expression the end of the law, Romans 10.4. The question is what is the end of the law there? It is a very complex question. We also saw Jesus say that though he does not abolish the law, he also fulfills it and those might be two different responsibilities. So what's going on? Well, there have been books and books written about the law and the relationship of the Christian to the law. But there is a long held distinction that comes out of the magisterial reformers, the reformed tradition, that speaks of three different uses of the law. And I want you to be aware of these because I think it can help you synthesize your relationship as a Christian to the mosaic law. So those are listed on your sheet there. The so-called three uses of the law. Now there are other matrices that also come out of the reformed tradition but I find this one to be particularly helpful. There it distinguishes between the civil use of the law which restrains and promotes righteousness and society. And you know that this has got to be right because I quote Latin to you there. This has got to be, you know, area-dyte teaching because it has Latin expression extra. Those are the traditional terms, Latin terms, coming out of the reformed tradition. But the idea of the Ussus-Qualis, the civil use of the law, is that without law people being sinful would trample all over one another. And so throughout the ages there has been law but God graciously gave to his people in the mosaic legislation laws that constrain behavior in society. And that can serve as a model, although we have to be careful, of some of the ways that we should restrain similar sin in society. Now there is also a very careful teaching within the reformed tradition that the civil use of the law does not continue in all of its force. So all of the use within the social relationships within Israel need not continue into the present period but the principles from that form the basis for civil society. So I want to speak kind of to both areas there. And certainly when God gave the mosaic law it had a proper use in Israel to restrain sin and promote righteousness in society. The next use of the law is the use, the conviction of sin. This is the Ussus pedagogicus, which you see the very word pedagog there. This comes directly from the concept that you have in Paul in Galatians, that the law is our pedagog, that it leads us to Christ. And in this regard the law brings humans under an awareness of sin. And you see this use of the law especially applied in Galatians and in Romans to express that the law convicts us of our sense that we know we need Christ. But then in the reformed tradition from which Presbyterianism springs there is also what is known as in other terms as the third use of the law which is the Ussus pedagogicus which is the law as rule of life. It reminds believers of duties and leads them in the way of life everlasting, if you would. So it instructs us in the kind of righteousness that God has always expected from his people. So three different uses of the law. Now let me illustrate that by returning to a text which we looked at earlier and I think this has a very strong interpretive matrix that could be very useful to you guys. When we looked at Matthew 5 and the teaching of Jesus and he says that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the scribes and Pharisees you shall not enter the kingdom of heaven. And then he describes the kind of righteousness that is required afterwards and there you'll recall I mean we talked about it several weeks ago but I've mentioned it repeatedly since. No longer does the law merely restrain us in civil reaction interaction. You shall not murder doesn't just have to do when you bring a murderer to the court. It also speaks to our internal state of anger anytime that we are angry with somebody else in a wrong way. We murder them in our hearts. That's what Jesus teaches. This takes an outward civil responsibility and turns it in on us to an internal responsibility. And in the middle of it I think we should have two reactions. One is we should say I am a sinful wretch because undoubtedly I have been so angry with people in the past that effectively I have infringed on the kind of righteousness that Jesus our Savior requires. That is conviction of sin. At the same time in an instruct us into the kind of people that we ought to be not just in terms of our civil legislation with one another certainly we should legislate against murder. But we should also as God's people now redeemed by the cross live holy lives before him in such a way that we put off anger to use the phrase that comes from the Apostle Paul. I don't know about you but I personally struggle in this area quite a bit and so the law accomplishes three purposes right there. Civil it creates it says you know you can't actually kill somebody if you do kill somebody there should be ramifications. Secondly it convicts of sin because it makes us aware of just how sinful of people we are. And that's our need for the salvation in the cross and thirdly it instructs us in how we ought to live as God's new people. We could do the same thing if we went down to Jesus's discussion about adultery and lust. If we went down to his discussion about making oaths and if we went into his discussion about loving your neighbor. All of these things instruct us in multiple ways and if we apply the three uses of the law I think it makes a lot more sense. So one last statement then on this section in the Sermon on the Mount. Some have wanted to say that this part of the Sermon on the Mount is the old dispensation of law and is no longer applicable in the new dispensation of grace because it demands too much righteousness from us. That's the old dispensation line. Some people in the reform camp look to this statement of this is you know you're righteous and surpasses the Pharisees well that is too much. Therefore what Jesus is trying to do is lay down such a difficult law that it just convicts of sin so that you just turn to Christ. Well I want to say that's too extreme as well because if you see that there are multiple things going on in the Sermon on the Mount and in the whole Old Testament law itself then you'll recognize that all of these dimensions are important in the Christian life and all of these dimensions are picked up upon in the New Testament. But perhaps the civil least of all because they're not making civil law there. Any questions on that. That's right. I would then take the idea of the righteousness exceeding that of the Pharisees. Largely what seems to be going on later in chapter 5 is the Pharisees were saying under what civil cases do we bring somebody to court? And so you see the civil use of the laws assumed here. Jesus says no the righteous needs to exceed that of the Pharisees which convicts us of sin because if we were a Pharisee it would have been very difficult to consider that we kept the law because the Pharisees were very strict in many respects. But even then we might have gotten away with thinking well I've never murdered anybody because I had not actually pulled the trigger. But Jesus now says no it's worse and so that really does convict of sin and so in that sense the surpassing of the righteousness of the Pharisees makes us realize how much more sinful we are than we thought we were. On the other hand I think he would then come to you as a question and say look you in your holiness before the Lord need your righteousness needs to exceed that of the Pharisees as well because internally you really should not commit that sin of anger or that sin of lust or whatever it is. Is that good? Yeah. Paul is referring to as the law is not able to make you do what it requires. So the law is not able to make you holy. The law is not able to permit you to live up to the standard with the law itself requires. The law just establishes the standard and so Paul describes the law as holy because it is good it is a good and gracious gift from God. But you're right the law does not give us the ability to keep the law. The whole nature of the argument that you refer to in Romans 8 and also in Romans 6 it is the spirit of God that lives in us that is then able to make it so that we as Christians have any hope of then living a holy life before the Lord not as our means of salvation but as a means of giving thanks to the Lord and honoring him in a way that is truly holy in our lives. So it doesn't become our means of salvation is what comes after it. So it's very important here that the third use of the law does not say that as the rule of life it makes them live holy lives. It reminds believers of duties. It leads them in the way of instructing them in the way of life. So in other writings on the third use of the law the word that comes up again and again is that it instructs us. You, Tony, want to be God's children child. You want to live holy in a way that honors him. You need to know that the kind of anger that you and I and others struggle with is wrong and that we need to constantly return again and again to God in repentance and asking his forgiveness, asking the forgiveness of the person that we've wronged and allowing the Holy Spirit to work in us to change us. But the law still instructs us in that regard. So there's still that third use of the law there. It's one of instruction. Yeah, Psalm 119. Yes, we can love the law because it frees us to see our need for Christ but it also gives us true and good instruction in how we ought to live and we should love it for that reason as well. What you said is that the law works in two ways. It convicts us of sin but it also shows us the standard of righteousness which through the Holy Spirit we seek to obtain in this life through our sanctification. And I think we would all recognize as Christians that we are not going to attain that standard of perfection in our lives today. That is our hope of glorification with the Lord that when we go to be with the Lord he will work in us in a way that we can. But we don't stop trying. I mean if you want a quick statement of all of that it's Ephesians 289. I mean at the very end in verse 10 the very famous statement of it's by grace that you have been saved through faith and that not of yourselves is the gift of God not as a result of works that no one should boast. Our works cannot bring us to God we need grace because we are convicted of our sinfulness and what Paul has just done in previously in chapter 2 of Ephesians is convicted people of their sin and shown them that the law shows them that they are sinful that they are dead and their trespasses incent. But then verse 10 for we are his workmanship created in Christ Jesus for good works which God prepared beforehand that we should walk in him. It is God working in us to enable us to do the works that he prepared beforehand that we should do. But then how do we know what those are? Well in part Scripture instructs us in that regard. Yeah go ahead Kira. Well we are in the sense she uses the phrase filthy rags righteousness. The Scripture does describe our righteousness as filthy rags. That's because the law convicts us of sin because we realize that when we thought we were doing fine I haven't killed anybody I have not committed adultery. Then the law comes back to us and says that there is an internal state that is beyond that. I mean there is a little love of your neighbor which should have been convicting enough in the Old Testament but then Jesus brings the law to even more fulfillment by saying adultery is a matter of the heart, murder is a matter of the heart. So you then see how filthy our righteousness is on our own merit we do not deserve to be in the kingdom of God. That's one level of righteousness. The other aspect though is Christians are still called to be saints. We are called saints positionally but we are called to sanctification as well. So we are called to live holy lives unto our Lord. Now we can't do so in our own strength and we can't do so in a way of achieving our salvation. We only do so as a response to God through the Holy Spirit for his saving work in Jesus. Yes. That's a very good point. The law is, shows, displays the character of God and thus it displays the character of the people that are being recreated into God's image. And thus the glory of God in his righteousness and the way that we should seek to glorify him by imaging him in that regard. All right. One last question. Yes. The suggestion is that the law is a, you suggested a fourth use that is the fruit of faith, etc. Well I think that's actually what's intended in some respects under the third. Although I would not describe the law as the fruit of faith. I would describe the holiness that the law points to is the fruit of faith. The law instructs us is how to get to that holiness or what that holiness looks like. And then the spirit enables us to have that fruit which after all it's the fruit of the spirit that the spirit provides the ability for us to have that kind of fruit. That's a very good, but that's, that is very closely related to this third use of the law. That's right. Okay. There's a lot more we could say about the law. I just wanted to bring you into that, that level of the discussion because I think if you have that threefold understanding, then you can appreciate your Old Testament more for one thing. I mean, there now becomes motive for rereading the book of Leviticus. Okay. Because the book of Leviticus is actually giving us moral instruction. Now, that's not to say that it means that you, you know, now need to avoid shellfish. Okay. But you, you have to understand what the internal moral instruction that is going on in that legislation. God's people were called to be a separate people that maintained a level of purity that is not found in the people around them. And, and it, that instructs us to that regard. There's a lot more complexities here and I'll leave it to some of my Old Testament colleagues to talk about some of those. But that's, that's just a start. And it certainly helps us see the different uses of the law in the New Testament because, again, Paul didn't leave aside the law even though he says that it's our pedagogue. He then comes back to it and, and instructs us that we shall not murder, we shall not commit adultery, et cetera, et cetera, and that we should love our neighbor. And he's picking up on the third use of the law there if you would. All right. Just to quickly go through these last bits. Old Testament liturgy is picked up in New Testament praise. So in Romans 11, Paul finishes this amazing discussion of the divine plan of God that is so intricate and complex through Romans 9 through 11. That at the end of it, he has to say, oh, the depth and the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God, verse 33. How insurmountable are his judgments and unfathomable his ways. He's just amazed at the wisdom of God. And then he cannot help, but then invoke the Psalms when he says for who is known the mind of the Lord, who became his counselor, who is given back that it might be paid back to him again. And in doing so, he is specifically quoting the Old Testament Psalter in a way to bring praise to God. So in the New Testament age, the Old Testament provides a means of liturgical praise of God that was picked up in the New Testament church. So that's another use of the law in the New Testament. Another use of the law is that of prophecy. Now here, I want to say that prophecy works in a couple of different respects. We've already looked at how prophecy is fulfilled in Matthew, but it's done so in a way that is a bit surprising out of Egypt, I've called my son, well Jesus being the true Israel. So sometimes when we approach a prophetic text that refers to Jesus or to the church, we have to think that the logic is a little bit more complex in the citation of it than you and I would have initially thought. Another example of this is in Acts 2.17 and following the first major sermon that we have reported on the lips of one of the disciples. And here, it's based on several citations of the Old Testament, three in particular. A couple of them go to display that Jesus was to be resurrected, that the Messiah was going to be resurrected. And so when David says, I'm in Acts 2, verse 25, for David says of him, I was always beholding the Lord of my presence for easy at my right hand that I may not be shaken. Therefore my heart was glad my tongue exalted, moreover my flesh also will abide in hope, because thou wilt not abandon my soul to Hades nor allow their holy one to see decay. And thou hast made known to me the ways of life thou wilt make me full of gladness with thy presence. That's the new American standard. It likes the thousand eyes. If you want to turn those to use, that's just fine with me. But the point is that David said, my soul will not be abandoned to Hades. Well Peter quickly says, brothers, I may confidently say to you regarding the patriarch David that his tomb is with us to this day. You know, his skeletons rotten in a grave. So this Psalm can't be applied to him in a full way. Now what's going on there in terms of its internal logic, this was not deemed typically to be a messianic prediction. But Peter sees it as a kind of prophetic text because it is a Psalm of David and who is the Messiah? The Messiah is great David's greater son. And so what David saw only in a kind of shadowy way is exemplified in the resurrection of Christ whose soul is not abandoned to Hades and whose body is not undergoing decay. And so you see this kind of prophetic use of Scripture. But again it's not this kind of well plug and play. This is a messianic prediction therefore Jesus. This is about David but it can't be about David. So it has to be about the Messiah and therefore it's about Jesus. So you have to go through a few intervening steps before you come to our Lord. So this is the prophetic use of Scripture and we could go a lot more. I mean this is amazing the way that Joel is used at the beginning of the book of Acts but I think for a sake of time I won't go into that. So the prophetic use of Scripture but often in a way that's not how we deem prophecy to work. I mean don't you I still have this for my kind of evangelical upbringing. I deem prophecy to be okay it's going to describe X, Y and Z and it's going to refer to this guy. And you just know that it's got this little checklist in you of being and is there. Often prophecy works in a much more sophisticated way in the mind of God. One illustration that was given to me by one of my teachers, Villain van Gameren who is a fantastic biblical theologian wrote a book called interpreting a prophetic word. He's also written one of the fine book describing the story of the Old and New Testament called the Progressive Redemption. He's Dutch. You can tell by Van Gameren which means as you might imagine that he loves flowers. I mean Dutch flower is just goes. So he likes to describe the unfolding of the prophetic story as a rose. He has a wonderful garden even in Chicago he has a wonderful garden and that's a trick especially given the weather up there. So he's got this beautiful garden is back here and he would plant roses upon rose. But if you put the bud in the ground and slowly the flower comes up, you know it's going to be a rose because you know that's what you planted. But you don't know if it's going to suddenly go to the right or to the left or this leaf is going to go here. You might not even be sure of the color of the rose. And certainly when it forms, one of the things that makes a flower so beautiful is that you look at it and there is such sophistication to its beauty. There's a predictableness to it. You can recognize that's a rose but the way that it continues to unfold is not wholly predictable. That's what makes a flower so beautiful. He uses that picture of Old Testament prophecy. You know it's speaking of the Messiah. But you don't know exactly until after the fact the beauty of the glory of what that Messiah looks like. And that's his illustration of Old Testament prophecy. And I think there's a profound insight there in terms of how Old Testament prophecy worked. With somebody who applied this psalm to the Messiah and said okay he's going to be resurrected, he's going to come back to his people and he's going to proclaim to them that they're going to need to stay on the earth for thousands of years proclaiming his glory until he finally returns. No. But from the back end of things we look back on it and we see the glory of that promise, now in his fulfillment. And that's kind of how I think prophecy works in a quite a way. There is also allegory in terms of the New Testament in one place. There is an allegorical use of the term Sarah and Haggar representing two different kinds of approaches to God. And this is found in Galatians chapter 4. Now can I say that we have to acknowledge two things. One, well three things actually. First, there were some Jewish people that engaged in an allegorical use. It's an allegorical interpretation of the first century. Philo did this all the time. So it was an interpretive method that was prevalent in Paul's day, we're looking at Galatians. Paul is extremely restrained in his use of allegory and only uses it in this one place. And doing so he is probably meeting his opponents in the very kind of argumentation that they themselves might have employed. Therefore, point three, we need to be very careful in assuming that we can approach the Old Testament in allegorical fashion today. I'm going to acknowledge that in one place the New Testament uses the Old Testament in an allegorical way. That is it takes people and instead of them representing literal people, they suddenly become these huge images of things that in the story you had no notion that they were going to image. Law versus grace for Sarah and Haggar. I got them reversed but there's that. And so it's done but it's restrained and we need to be very restrained and probably skeptical of that kind of usage in our own exegesis. Some of you will immediately track with what I'm saying. Some of you are kind of like, well, I don't know but I wanted to speak to that in any case. Finally, typology. Typology is a sophisticated way of seeing the relationship between the Old and the New Testament in some respects. If we look at Matthew 12, verse 40, Jesus says to the people around him, an evil and adulterous generation craves for a sign and yet no sign shall be given to it but the sign of Jonah the Prophet. For just as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the sea monster, so shall the Son of Man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth now. What's going on there? Well, there is the story of Jonah in the book of Jonah. It has a literal reference. It literally refers to a man in a well and a whale. There might be something beyond that in terms of its redemptive import and that it images that even a prophet of God may be called to a time of being effectively if you would captivated by death itself. Before he is released in God's redemptive plan, something like that. So, captivation of a prophet. Jesus doesn't apply the literal reference but he applies the type, a logical meaning of it to himself. And that's how typology works. Now, when I illustrate that about typology, note several things. First, I am not changing the literal reference of the original Old Testament story. What is the book of Jonah about? Well, it still involves a guy in a whale. And I am not saying that Jonah is Jesus. I would not say that. What I am saying is that this shows one of the redemptive ways that God works with his prophets and that's what's applicable to Jesus. That's how Old Testament works. Now, one can look at the Old Testament law and the sacrifices in this regard as it's done in the book of Hebrews. So, the book of Hebrews describes the day of atonement and Jesus is the fulfillment of that day. The literal reference of the day of atonement was a guy in a temple presenting himself as God required, presenting a sacrifice. That was literally what the Old Testament was talking about in such. The author of Hebrews describes this though as a mere shadow of the heavenly reality which is the heavenly temple and sacrifice. And it is that which Jesus accomplishes. So, I would be very careful, for instance, about saying Jesus is the day of atonement in the Old Testament. The day of atonement has a little reference. Jesus is the day of atonement only in so far as it accomplishes most fully what this and God's redemptive plan entails. And that's how typology works and it's used multiple times in the New Testament. Now, the careful thing about that is I'm reticent to read then Jesus back into the Old Testament but I see the Old Testament as setting up patterns of thinking for the people of God so that when Jesus comes he fulfills those patterns of thinking in a way that blows all of our socks off.

Finally, I've ended then the New Testament uses of the Old Testament. Are there any questions about any of these? Yes, exactly. What I'm trying to say is that when we look at typology we see the Old Testament is setting up patterns of thinking. How does God work in the world? And then the New Testament becomes the fulfillment of that because it takes all of those to a completely different level with Jesus. But then that does not permit us to go back to the story of Jonah and read as he suggested everything about Jesus into the life of Jonah. So his throwing into the water being thrown into the water was like Jesus being crucified. His time in the whales like the time that Jesus is quote-unquote in Hades. I mean some people have done this with it. When he spit out, well that's like the resurrection and then he goes off and proclaims, well, you know, there's points where suddenly you start saying, okay, there's discontinuous aspects here aren't there? I mean, Jonah got hop and mad when then if a repented. Does Jesus do that? No. You know, so there's just so much discontinuity. All that Jesus is doing is he's saying sometimes the prophet is called to a period of captivation. I will undergo a similar captivation of my body, but then I will be resurrected. I mean, that's kind of the internal logic that's going on here. And we then dare not apply more of Jonah's life to Jesus because Jesus didn't sanction that. Nor do we apply more of Jesus's life to Jonah's. The last section here on our handout, Matthew 27 verse 46, and about the ninth hour as Jesus is suffering on the cross. He's been suffering on the cross for at least three hours by that point because in 1st 45 now from the 6th hour, darkness fell upon the land until the ninth hour and about the ninth hour, Jesus cries out with a loud voice saying, that is, interpreted into Greek and now into English. My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Why have you forsaken me? What is going on when Jesus does that? Well, on the one hand, we can say that this is a cry of despair in the midst of suffering. On another hand, some people have found in this a kind of spiritual separation of the second person of the Trinity from the first person of the Trinity. That's possible, and I'll let the theologians debate all that. But there's, I mean, it's not overt that that's what's going on in the surface here. I tell you a third possibility, aside from just the nature of despair and the possibility that it involves some sort of relational separation, there is what I think clearly going on here is if you would turn at the same time now, maybe hold your finger and Matthew and turn back to Psalm 22, I'm going to wish here that frankly that I hadn't brought my new American standard, which is a great translation, but it insists on thy and thou. And that always trips me up when I read, but Psalm 22, how does Psalm 22 begin? My God, my God, why has you forsaken me? Why hast thou forsaken me? It's right here. Why have you forsaken me? Far from my deliverance are the words of my groaning, oh my God, I cry by day but thou does not answer, and by night but I have no rest yet thou art holy. O thou who art and thrown upon the praises of Israel and thee are Father's trust that they trusted and thou didst deliver them, to thee they cried out and they were delivered in thee they trusted and were not disappointed, but I am a worm, and not a reproach of men and despised by men. All who see me sneer at me, they separate with the lip, they wag the head saying, commit yourself to the Lord, let him deliver you, let him deliver him, let him rescue him because he delights in him. The whole thing is about Jesus, isn't it, in a sense? I mean, it all describes different aspects of what happened in terms of Jesus, and not far down from this, you get verse 16, for dogs have surrounded me, a band of evil doers has encompassed me, they pierced my hands and my feet. I can count all my bones, they look, they stare at me, they divide my garments, they divide my garments among me, you've heard that before in the gospel, right, among them, and for my clothing they cast lots. When Jesus quotes Psalm 22 from the cross, a psalm that is written by whom, what is the superscriptions say at the beginning of Psalm 22? A psalm of David, great David's greater son is suspended on a cross, and all of this is being fulfilled in him in that moment. And he is providing an interpretive matrix for his followers to understand who he is, and that the son of man, the Messiah, the son of David had to suffer in such a way. And in the midst of all of this, there is this constant refrain that I will tell thy name to the brethren, and verse 24, for he is not despised, nor abhorred the affliction of his afflicted, neither has he hidden his face from him, but when he cried to him for help, he heard. And so you get this hope as well in the midst of Psalm 22 that it will not end in death, and so is the case with Jesus. Jesus is making a new testament use of the Old Testament there, and he is instructing his followers in how to frame his death as a Messiah in light of the cross. Now let me just say, at this stage, as far as I can tell in 1st century Judaism, and it's an area that I've spent some time studying, no Jewish expectation of the Messiah had him going to a means of death, let alone to the cross-inclusive fiction. What was needed for his disciples was a way of understanding this as messianic fulfillment in a way that nobody else in his day would have understood it. And so one of the last things he does for his disciples on the cross is give them a way of understanding what's going on. Now that is not to say that that's the only place in the Old Testament where the suffering and the death of the Messiah is mentioned. And of course Isaiah 53 actually starting in chapter 52 provides an even fuller expression of the kinds of suffering that the afflicted one will do for our sakes, he was afflicted for our sakes, for our stripes he was healed. That also is very much understood as referring to the Messiah from the standpoint of Christians looking back on the cross and is repeatedly used in the New Testament in that regard. So you have these various Old Testament images that can refer to the death of Jesus, one of the themes in our class is the death of Jesus. And then the last one is Deuteronomy 21 which we covered a few sessions ago, remember cursed of God is the one hung on a tree, cursed by God is how Paul understands it in Galatians 3 and understands that the curse that Jesus bore while suspended to that tree which is the cross is the very curse of our sins that he takes upon himself. So there's three major texts from the Old Testament that then provide interpretive matrices for understanding who Jesus is. I did that very quickly but I hope that if you ponder that some more you can see just how important these texts are. So I would encourage you to go back and read through Psalm 22 and read through the servant song that begins in Isaiah 52 and through Isaiah 53 and see the aspects of the suffering of the Messiah who is the true servant of God and also that the hope of life and we would say resurrection that's found in those locations as well. Any questions about that? What I would say is, I mean this is in keeping with what is said about the prophets, the Peter says about the prophets that they're born along by the Holy Spirit. And there's a sense in which they see what's going to happen but they don't see it clearly. There's a fog and they can make out images because those images have been revealed by God but the fullest and clearest understanding of those is not given to them in some respects. However and therefore I agree with you that this happens throughout the Old Testament. The one qualification I put in that is a caution again that we need to be careful not to say that we can see that through that fog more clearly unless it's specifically revealed to us in the New Testament itself. So this is why I say I'm restrained in this idea of typology to the types that the New Testament authors themselves mention because they see them clearly and they do so in a revealed fashion. I might be willing to speculate about other texts and what they mean but I'm going to put it in the category of speculation because I don't have the divine light of revelation to clearly tell me that that's a type. And in that regard some of the languages picked up from Ezekiel 28 and some of the New Testament writings about Satan and so I might be willing to go there. One last thing before we finish up here we have a few more minutes. I'm going to leave aside our talk about the Old Testament. We've got an author right talking to an audience in a cultural framework, drawing explicitly on the Old Testament and drawing explicitly on Jesus. So we're going to talk about Jesus for a few minutes here and then well into next time.

But as soon as we do so we have to say that for the last 200 years of scholarship there has been the question of what do we know about the historical Jesus. The question has been asked and I don't think it's inherently a wrong question, do the gospels present an accurate portrayal of Jesus. Certainly we would all recognize that the gospels do not present a full blown picture of Jesus. We only get certain slices of a few years of Jesus's life. And so people have long wanted to know more about Jesus and go behind the gospels in that regard. Another aspect of the gospels is that they present four parallel narratives but in doing so they bring up instances that are in one gospel but are not in the other. So if you were to try and lay out a chronology of Jesus's life as it historically happened which is something that naturally we want to do. So the question is how would you move those pieces around so they all fit together in a natural chronology. In both of those respects this idea for looking at who is the historical Jesus has some reason and rationality to it and is not inherently wrong. But this quest for the historical Jesus has been combined with a high level of skepticism as to the degree to which we can actually get to know who Jesus historically was. And this is centered around a skepticism about the gospels. So for example, you and I live in the 21st century. We are in a light and group of people. Just think of the advances that have happened in science in the last 400-500 years. So that we at now are at this forefront of knowing so much scientifically about our world. We know for instance that all things in this world happen via some form of cause and effect. And that means that things don't just happen out of the blue as if there's no explanatory cause but one expects a series of natural events leading up to natural events. In other words, you and I don't expect to see, let me just put it this crackly, you and I do not expect to see miracles on a daily basis. If you get sick, you take an aspirin, you go to the doctor, you take an antibiotic, you don't suddenly expect bang, I'm going to be healed. Now there might be some who are going, well no, I expect God to heal me and I do too, okay? I do too. But certainly describing the society that is around us, science has such explanatory force that miracles cannot happen. Therefore in a scientific world when one approaches and the science has been around for several centuries, so even 200 years ago when people were in the heyday they thought of science in their life, and science was explaining so much about the nature that is around them, they approached the gospels and Jesus walks on water. That doesn't happen physically. There is no natural physical cause that lets him walk on water unless, and this has been suggested by some commentators, including William Barclay, his famous commentator. There was really a sand bar under his feet that people didn't see. Now there's a natural explanation for a phenomena. But if you look at the gospels, it's full of miracles, and we just don't believe in those anymore. Secondly, if you look at the gospels, there are times when they again present different things, different stories of Jesus' life, but sometimes these stories seem somewhat at odds with one another. So for instance, in the three synoptic oscillals, Matthew, Mark, and Luke, Jesus cleanses a temple. At the end of his ministry, it makes the Pharisees and others so hop and mad that they seek to put him to death. They were looking before that, but they were looking all the more afterwards. I hear a phone. Anyway, it's for me. Well, in the Matthew, Mark, and Luke, it's towards the end of Jesus' ministry. In the beginning of the gospel of John, it's one of the first things the guy does. It's cleansed the temple. And then he goes to Jerusalem several times after that, and there's no cleansing later. So people will point out there are tensions between the chronology and the gospels, so somebody, they will say, I'm not saying this, but somebody got it wrong. Therefore, you cannot trust the gospels as accurate historical accounts, they will say. So how do you go about determining what is historical and what is not historical in the gospels in order to understand who the historical Jesus is? That's the Jesus seminar, some of you may have heard about. And basically, every year now, for the last several years, right before Easter, it's the front page of time and newsweek, talking about who is Jesus. And unless you understand the reason people talk in those terms, and unless you have an articulate response instead of, well, I believe miracles, I think the gospels are right, you cannot speak to this culture in this society, unless you're able to articulate a response. So have a good weekend, we'll talk about it next Wednesday.