<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bantu Bantu Bulanan

Christianity & Liberalism

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Lecture 35, Christianity and Liberalism, that is the title of a famous book that I want to speak about in a few minutes written by J. Gresham Machen, professor of New Testament at Princeton Seminary in the early 20th century, and also the prayer is from Dr. Machen, let us pray. Almighty God, our Heavenly Father, We give the thanks for the wonder of thy grace and the gift of Christ, our Lord and Savior. How can we ever find words which shall not seem vain as we think of his love for us? How can we without shame try to give the thanks for the grace of Christ our Savior who died for us, the jest for the unjust? And how can we think without shame of the ill way in which we have required the for thy love? But we rejoice in the knowledge that when thy Holy Spirit we have been united to Christ through faith, we are his forever. We pray thee, that thus we may be kept safe by one stronger than we are, and we pray with all our souls, for those who have not found Christ a Savior, that they may be led through the mist of era and doubt into the clear shining of the light of faith, that when they have sought other saviors, and their souls are still restless, they may, through Christ, find their rest in thee. And all that we ask is in the name of Christ, Jesus, our Lord and Savior, amen. In the last lecture, it was a kind of a doleful refrain that kept coming through, and I expect you noticed it, as again and again I said, in surveying the history, particularly of the reform faith, but in some small manner of Christianity in various countries of the world, by focusing in that lecture, especially on the history of Presbyterians and reform people in those countries, the refrain that kept coming through was something like this in the 19th century, and in the early 20th century, these churches fell away from historic Christianity into a kind of liberalism. Why did that happen? A lot of answers I'm sure could be given to that question. But I want to emphasize one in this lecture today, and that is the importance of ideas, the importance of ideas. In the fall of 1912, Dr. Machen gave Princeton seminaries opening address on the topic of Christianity and culture, and these are some words that he spoke to the students and the faculty and the education. He said false ideas are the greatest obstacles to the reception of the gospel. We may preach with all the fervor of a reformer, and yet only succeed in winning a straggler here and there. If we permit the whole collective thought of the nation or of the world to be controlled by ideas, which by the resisteless force of logic, prevent Christianity from being regarded as anything more than a harmless delusion. Under such circumstances, what God desires us to do is to destroy the obstacle at its root. Many would have the seminaries combat era by attacking yet as it is taught by its popular exponents. Instead of that, seminaries confuse their students with a lot of German names unknown outside the walls of the universities. That method of procedure is based simply upon a profound belief in the pervasiveness of ideas. What is today a matter of academic speculation begins tomorrow to move armies pulled down empires. So at Princeton, they did study the German theologians and they did try to keep up with the latest critical thought that was coming from Germany and from other places because of the importance of ideas and the importance of being able to answer false ideas. So we think about liberalism and its rise in the 19th and 20th centuries. I'd like to do that by speaking briefly about five influential books full of ideas that will impact culture in the Western world significantly. Five books which indeed did begin to move armies and pull down empires. Of course this movement, theological liberalism did not begin with these five books. The roots of theological liberalism can certainly be traced back at least as far as the Enlightenment and in some ways all the way back to the Renaissance and even earlier. But these five books were very significant in moving many people away from historic Christianity into a new way of looking at the Bible and at God and at the church. First the book called On Religion published in 1799 by Friedrich Schlimacher. The German Schlimacher is sometimes called the father of modern theology. He was brought up among the Moravians at an evangelical piotistic beginning. But at university he was very much influenced by the thinking of the Enlightenment and accepted a rational critical view of the Scriptures and it was also influenced by romanticism with its great stress on the importance of subjective understanding and feeling. Schlimacher wrote his famous book on religion, speeches to its cultured despisers 1799 in order to find some way in which he could make Christianity seem revelant again to people who had long since given up on it. Cultured thinking rational people in the university world who despise Christianity. And you see the problem that Schlimacher was up against is the problem that we are up against today as we try to think of how to present the gospel to modern secular humanist or how to present Christianity to postmodern people. Schlimacher was trying to find a way to present Christian faith to enlightenment people, to modern people. His solution was this Christianity he said is not ideas, it's not creed, it's not propositions, it's not really a book like the Bible. It's not in knowledge and neither is it an ethics, it's not simply being good, but Christianity religion is located in religious consciousness or in the feelings, not in the head, not in outward conduct, but the heart and core of Christianity is what one feels. Deep within his or her own being, Schlimacher put it this way, the consciousness of being absolutely dependent or which is the same thing of being in relation to God. You know, somewhere, somehow a person has a feeling of dependence, not being autonomous and that means being in relation to God and that is the heart and seat and core of religion. You can find something similar to this in 19th century revivalistic piety which in a song asked the question, you asked me how I know he lives, the answer in that song is he lives within my heart. It's not a wrong answer but something else has to be said too. Before that and after that and with that and with Schlimacher there is the moving of religion from the area of history and confessions and even propositional revelation in the Bible to this inner subjective feeling. That's going to have tremendous impact, that idea of religion as subjective what I feel inside me, tremendous impact as we go through the 19th century. The next book that I'd like to mention of these five influential books is a famous one, Origin of Species which appeared in 1859. The work of the English scientist, botanist Charles Darwin, who developed the modern theory of evolution. He was not the first person to think of this but the modern theory of evolution with its operational principle of natural selection comes from Darwin. In time that book will make a tremendous impact on thinking people as they're called, since it still does, some Orthodox Christians immediately responded very negatively to Darwin's book. For instance, Charles Hodg at Princeton Seminary, who just a few years later wrote a book called What Is Darwinism and answered it very simply by saying Darwinism is atheism. But not all Orthodox Christians responded that way, even Hodg's son A. A. Hodg and the Princeton professor B. B. Warfield were much more cautious in their treatment of evolution. They did insist of course that there be a personal creator and that that creator be working out everything in creation according to his own design. But within those parameters there were some Orthodox Christians who were able to take a weight and see attitude as far as evolution was concerned. But many people, Orthodox Christians as well as other kinds of Christians, bought Darwinism, bookline and sinker we might say, not only as an understanding of the physical world but as a kind of principle for everything. Everything moves upward into a higher and more profound level of existence. So many people began to find in Darwinism an explanation for almost everything, place that God had previously held in people's minds. The third book is called Essays and Reviews and even though that book is probably certainly not very well known compared to Darwin's origin of species came out the next year, 1860, just a year after Darwin's book. Essays and Reviews at the time appeared to be a much more serious challenge to Orthodox Christianity than Darwin did. It's a book with a rather harmless sounding title Essays and Reviews but it was a liberal manifesto by seven clergyman of the Church of England who actually had taken German higher criticism, German higher critical views of the Bible and expressed those views in English. Which meant that these Essays said basically the Bible is an ordinary book, just like any other book. It has many good things in it, has some not-so-good things in it, has some downright bad things in it and people should read the Bible as they read in the other book. Well, certainly the Church of England by 1860 is not a liberal church and 11,000 clergymen signed a protest against this book written by seven ministers in the Church of England, these 11,000 clergymen declared their belief in the inspiration of the Scriptures and in the doctrine of eternal punishment which was denied in this book. And the book itself was condemned in 1864 but those ideas don't really go away. It's just the first of many books that will be written undermining authority of the Scriptures and sooner or later those books would take their toll. The fourth book, written by a German, German theologian named Albrecht Richel, the title of the book is the Christian doctrine of justification and reconciliation, which sounds like a good title but when you really get into reading what Richel has to say, there's not much there of orthodox understanding of justification or reconciliation. Because Richel says, as Schlimacher had said, Christianity is not doctrine, but then he disagreed with Schlimacher when he said Christianity is not feelings either, Christianity is ethics. It's how one lives, it's what one does, particularly in society. Maybe thing else is underpinnings and not essential to ethical moral conduct. Richel's book was very influential, particularly in America, kind of a practical-minded country. We were supposed to be, at least at that time, and Americans took up Richel's ideas with a vengeance and out of that comes what we call the social gospel. The real gospel is not this gospel of personal individual salvation but redeeming society through ethics, through morality, through good works. The slogan for all of this is the fatherhood of God and the brotherhood of man. That becomes one of the great themes that could be heard from the major pulpits of this country and other countries in the early 20th century. Somebody has summarized it this way. The liberal preaching of this time can be summed up with the son-of-slet me suggest that you try to be good. That's not very powerful message, but it was a message that was repeated over and over again. The social gospel did some good things and much had to be done and still has to be done in Christianizing society, but the social gospel was not the gospel, not all the gospel. The social gospel was, we might say, the implications of the gospel, but in the hands and in the minds and voices of the preachers of the social gospel like Walter Russian Bush, that was all their lives. Richel's theology of ethics came through loud and clear. And then the last of these five books that I want to talk about, it's also by a German theologian, Adolf Harnack. The book is called What is Christianity in its English translation that appeared in 1900. Harnack was a professor at the University of Berlin in the winter of 1899, 1900. He gave lectures on the essence of Christianity to students at the university, at 600 students that listened to him, to give these lectures and finally translated into English the lectures were published as a book called What is Christianity. Harnack tries to discover what is truly essential in Christianity. One of the themes throughout all of this is Christianity has added so much that really is not Christianity, so we need to get back to the essence or the kernel. And so Harnack strips off all the husk, almost the first thing to go or the creeds. And then please the ask the organization and then monastic aestheticism to find that one essential kernel or that essential element of Christianity and he comes to not surprisingly Christ. Jesus Christ, the founder of Christianity as he is described in the synoptics, right away Harnack drops out the gospel of John, too much theology and all sorts of things in John that are extraneous. But in the synoptics Matthew, Mark and Luke there is the picture of Christ which is the heart of the Christian faith. But as Harnack studied the synoptics he realized that there was a great deal there, too, that he could not allow to remain. There were miracles and angels and demons and all sorts of apocalyptic elements, so all of that had to be stripped out. So eventually a kind of core gospel from the synoptics and what he ends up with is the personality of Jesus and his teaching. If you just let you hear it in the words of Harnack, this is the real heart of Christianity. His words, Jesus' words, breathe, peace, joy and certainty. He lived in the continual consciousness of God's presence. His eyes rested kindly from the whole world. He ennobled it by his presence and he recognized everywhere the hand of the living God. Archbishop William Temple once remarked that one of the greatest mysteries in church history is why anybody would have taken the trouble to crucify the Christ of liberal Protestantism. But those were five books and those five books exerted great influence and still do. But liberalism would seem poised, I would say, in 1900 to sweep everything before it. It was going to suffer a very serious setback, theological liberalism. And we call that setback World War I. Perhaps this does tell us something about the providence of God and allowing even very evil things to accomplish something good. Because in World War I, you see with all of this moving toward a kind of evolutionary, optimistic humanism, the last thing you would expect would be that in Western culture, even in the very heart of Western culture, in Germany, there would emerge all that happened in World War I. Liberalism in this context then appeared weak and ineffective in the face of real evil. It appeared superficial. The war to end all wars did not end all wars but it did in much of evolutionary optimistic humanism, at least for a time in Western Europe. And in the Protestant world. But I think the problem with liberalism was that it not only failed to provide real answers as Tillic points out. Tillic was certainly a product of this. He talks about walking along the rows of dying men after the Battle of Champagne in World War I and he said much of my German classical philosophy broke down. That means it's theology because that's all that he had broke down as he could not put this tragedy within the scope of what he had been taught. But not only the failure to produce real answers but also the failure to produce real Christians. Now don't say that in a triumphalistic manner as though evangelicals are always producing real Christians and nobody else is. We've often failed to produce real Christians too. But liberalism produced people who were nominally Christian, Christian by cultural definitions so that you can have a critic like Frederick Nietzsche saying that he can't be a Christian. He rejects it all and moves into a death of God philosophy because he said I just don't see much in the Christians that I see. Their songs would have to be better songs and they would have to look more redeemed or need to believe in their redeemer. The Christians that he is looking at are not evangelical Christians but liberal Christians that I have described in the evolution of Christianity through the 19th century. That whole movement of liberal theology I think is best summed up by H. Richard Niebuhr. I can't quote Niebuhr without at least mentioning that Niebuhr was a Missourian born very close to St. Louis as was his famous brother, Reinhold Niebuhr. They were both educated at Eden Seminary and we're very critical of the old liberalism without fully espousing conservative theology. But Richard Niebuhr's critique of the old liberalism is a classic one that you undoubtedly know. The liberalism taught that a God without wrath brought men without sin into a kingdom without judgment through the administrations of a Christ without a cross. Well, I can't really add to that or I certainly can't improve on it so we'll let that be the last word on liberalism. I'm a man who was a liberal and later is identified more in the category of the theology of crisis that I'll talk about in a moment. And we'll move on to orthodoxy. It's not that liberalism was first and orthodoxy was next. Orthodoxy was always there from the very beginning and liberalism developed from the Enlightenment through the 19th century. But the question I want to ask is what is orthodoxy doing during this time and orthodoxy was struggling mightily to stay the tide of liberalism. There is a book chapter in volume two of my Princeton history that I call a mighty battle and that was the fight at Princeton over these issues. But we could take that title and apply it to the entire period in history. There was indeed a mighty battle. We sum up that mighty battle by referring briefly to two sermons in 1922 in America which will set the issues before us in a very graphic way. The first was called Shall the Fundamentalist When, for each by Harry Emerson-Postick. He was a Baptist but for seven years was guest minister at the First Presbyterian Church in New York City. It says something about the Presbyterians as well as about the Baptist. And in this famous sermon Shall the Fundamentalist When, Postick ridicule the so-called Fundamentals, the five Fundamentals. In Herendstead Scripture, Virgin birth of Christ, Miracles of Christ, the blood atonement and the bodily resurrection. There are elements of Christianity that have long been believed to be the very essence of the faith. At least you can't jettison these without jettison Christianity but Postick says you can. Postick was one of many liberals at this time who felt that doctrine really was not important. Let me show you a cartoon here of a drawing of a church and there's a sign outside the church saying beware of dogma. Well, that's Postick's church, not that church building at a very beautiful church because he went to Riverside Church in New York City which was built for him after Presbyterian Church finally did remove him from the pool. From the first Presbyterian Church in New York City. But the liberals had no love for dogma or doctrine. The sermon by Postick was answered in another sermon by Clarence Edward McCartney called Shall Unbelief When. McCartney was a Princeton train pastor at the Archstreet Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia and a very good friend of Gresham H. and that brings us to the famous book Christianity and liberalism written the next year, 1923 by Dr. M. H. who had been New Testament professor at Princeton since 1906. M. H. in New liberalism first hand. This is not a conservative writing about something he doesn't know anything about. He went to Germany, he studied with Wilhelm Hermann who had studied with Harnack and actually as Machen studied with Hermann at Marburg, he was captivated by liberal teaching. He had come from a conservative evangelical home in Baltimore with roots in the Southern Presbyterian Church but he was swept off his feet by the piety of this liberal German theologian and almost moved away from his Orthodox beliefs into liberalism. It was his mother's prayers back home, kept him on track in his practice of getting back to his room and taking out the Gospel of Mark and reading it through after he had listened to Harnack lecture, trying to get his bearings again. So he knew liberalism and in the book Christianity and liberalism the title you see is very important because it sets forth Machen's thesis. That is it's not fundamentalism and liberalism it's Christianity and liberalism. Machen said there are two religions here liberalism is not a variety of Christianity it's something different it may be something noble maybe something that does some good things. It teaches some great ideas but it's not Christianity it should be called something else it's a distinct religion entirely different from historic Christianity. I really think Machen's Christianity liberalism is one of the truly great books of the 20th century and it's the book that we should read as we approach the end of the 20th century because it's still relevant in so many ways. I've given the outline of the book in the syllabus and some pertinent quotations from Machen on the topics that he covers. As modernism liberalism and orthodoxy clashed and as that battle was going on something new appeared in Switzerland and we sometimes call it neo-orthodoxy. Carl Bart and Amel Bruner were teaching preaching Christian faith but as people listen to what they said they heard something new but it wasn't liberalism they heard something old too but it wasn't orthodoxy. I want to talk about Bart just in the next few minutes Bruner is important too but as the century moves on and as we move into the next century the great important name and theology for this century will probably be Carl Bart. He was trained in the liberal tradition in fact he was trained with the same teacher that so captivated Machen will help Perman. But Bart having bought into all of the liberal theology faced a crisis early on in his ministry became a pastor first in 1909 serving first in Geneva. And as a pastor of a church he faced a problem that all pastors face and that is what am I going to preach on Sunday morning. What am I going to say to these people? Well as Bart tried to preach he discovered that all his critical knowledge of the Bible was not something that he could preach no message came through and in the crisis of trying to discover how to preach Bart did something that seemed to a lot of people quite unusual. He started to preach the Bible. He wrote a commentary on the book of Romans and that helped to Ori and him toward preaching the Bible. That commentary which came out in 1918 shocked the theological world because here was a man who seemingly was taking seriously the Bible once again and it was not a fundamentalist or conservative. But a number of the Swiss reformed church. Bart later wrote as he looked back over this event in his life he wrote this as I looked back at my pathway. I looked like a man who groping his way in a dark some church tower unwittingly took hold of a rope that was in fact a rope for a church bell. And then to his own shock he heard the bells resounding over him and bar beyond him. People began to hear what Bart had to say because of what had happened to Bart as a young pastor in Switzerland rediscovering the Bible. What was this shocking message that so alarmed and captivated European theologians? The Dutch theologian G.C. Berkauer put it this way. This is what Bart began to preach. The majesty, the holiness and the sovereignty of God set over against all human pretensions to greatness, over against all theification of man or of anything in the created world. In short, it spoke of the infinite qualitative difference between God and man. Their echoes of Kirchegor there he might detect but basically is a message of God's sovereignty let God be God. Some years later Bart became a professor of theology that was in 1921 and he faced another question here. How do you teach theology to seminary students? What do you teach? By this time he was convinced that his old classical liberal German education was not what should be taught. And amazingly Bart returned to the old reform orthodoxy. He found a book, Heinrich Heppi's book, when reform orthodoxy in which Heppi had brought together brief quotations from 40 or 50 of the old orthodox, Beza and turret and the Lutherans and the Dutch and the whole list. And under theological topics like election and providence and God would be these short snippets of orthodox theology. And this is what Bart said about that volume, said he found that volume of Heppi. It was out of date, dusty, unattractive, almost like a table of logarithms, dreary to read, still an eccentric on almost every page I open. And if you study Heppi you'll have some sympathy for those comments from Bart. Informing content, pretty adequately corresponding to what I, like so many others, had described to myself decades ago as the old orthodoxy, written that off. Well Bart said, I had the grace not to be so slack, I read, I studied, I reflected and found that I was rewarded with the discovery that here at last I was in the atmosphere in which the road by way of the reformers to Holy Scripture was a more sensible and natural one to tread than the atmosphere now only too familiar to me. Of the theological literature determined by Schlimarker and ritual. So Bart has gone back to the Bible, going back to the Protestant Orthodox tradition, and directed many theologians and many people back to the Scripture and toward the great tradition of the church, especially toward the tradition of the Reformation and post-Reformation. Protestant theology and so back toward an understanding of the utter transcendence of God and his grace in the incarnation and in redemption simply stated Bart's theology was God is God. But what looked like a new orthodoxy, a neo-orthodoxy, to many people, some people looked like a new modernism because Bart doesn't go completely back. To the Orthodox tradition, nor to the Scriptures, or a Newious Vantil wrote famous book early on about Bart called the new modernist, was it one of Bart's favorite books, but Vantil felt that he discovered in Bart not neo-orthodoxy, but neo-modernism. What do we understand, Bart? When I was studying at Calonist Seminary in the 1960s, my professors told me that Bart was a dangerous liberal. When I went to do doctoral studies at Princeton in the 1970s, my professors told me that Bart was a dangerous conservative. In fact, he was almost a fundamentalist. Well, I was confused. Let me try to say very briefly how I think we ought to approach the study of Bart. There is great value in studying Bart. He is a great theologian, and he can add much to our understanding of the Christian tradition and challenge us in many ways. Bruce McCormick, who is now professor of theology at Princeton, he did part of his endim work at Covenant Seminary. He has written the most important book on Bart to come out in recent years, Karl Bart's critically realistic dialectical theology, name of Bruce's book, published by Oxford University Press 1995. Well, even the title will indicate it's not going to be easy to understand Bart because it takes three words to modify the noun theology. But what Bart really does in theology is to use what we call a dialectical method. He uses opposing ideas to try to find truth in the tensions that those ideas present, which means that Bart will always be saying what appears to be contradictory. For instance, God's revelation is both failed and unveiled at the same time. Now, I know that my time is up, but bear with me a few more minutes because I don't want to leave the impression that I'm urging us all to become Bartians in this class or on the video, which many people will be seeing elsewhere. So just three quick points. There are some serious problems in Bart, one the nature of the Bible. Bart spoke against the liberals when he said, God has indeed spoken supernaturally in his word. The Bible is the word of God. God has spoken in this book. God has spoken to us directly and supernaturally, not merely indirectly through historically conditioned cultural movements so far so good, but then against the conservatives, like people at Princeton Seminary, Hodgen Warfield and the others. Bart said scripture is veiled in human language. Well, we could accept that, but not the corollary, so that we cannot say Bart said that this book, these propositions are directly the word of God and so are in error and authoritative as they stand. The Bartian doesn't really say, listen to the word of God as the Bible is written. The Bartian says, listen for the word of God. Somewhere in all of this humanists, God through the Spirit will bring a word to you, but it cannot be acquainted with that word, which stands written in the book. The second evangelical concern about Bart is his understanding of history. Did the things the Bible says happen really happen in time, space, history? Bart was lecturing on one occasion to some students in Amsterdam and he was lecturing on Genesis and the Dutch students asked him, what's there really a snake in the garden? And Bart's answer was, it's not important whether there was a snake or not. What is important is what the snake said? Well, Bart escapes the question of history there. As he did when Carl Henry, editor of Christianity today, asked him a question after one of his lectures at Princeton University, if a person could be present with a tape recorder or a video camera at the resurrection of Christ, what would he have seen? And Bart's reply was to say, sarcastically, did you say that you represented Christianity today? It sounds more like Christianity yesterday. It doesn't deal with the historical question. That, of course, is unsatisfying to conservatives. It's why Francis Schaefer had to talk about true truth and it was also unsatisfying to real liberals. It's why Paul Tillich said we have to ask the question of the historical meaning of the biblical writing. Was there a snake in the garden? Schaefer would say, yes, Tillich would say, no, Bart would say, it's not important. And then finally, the issue of universalism. Bart's view of election is such that it's hard to separate that view from some kind of universalism. Christ is the elect person and we are elect in Christ, that is, all mankind is elect in Christ. God has chosen for us and all are chosen in Him. That has to mean either absolute universalism, which Bart refused to directly affirm or a kind of hesitant admission that some may opt out of this election. It syndicates, I think, really how far Bart has wandered himself from listening to the word of God. The grass withers, flower fades, but the word of God stands for ever.