<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bantu Bantu Bulanan

Emphases in the Gospels: Why do We Have Four?

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Can I pray for us?

I think the proper Christian response is amen.

Let's pray. Father, we do thank you for a beautiful day such as this. A reminder of your beauty, of the beauty of your creation. We're thankful for the way that you love us and have lavished a love on us that is so high and so deep, so wide and so long that we truly cannot fathom. Even though Paul desires in Ephesians that his people get to know that love, but we recognize the depths of the riches of that love beyond pondering. We're thankful that we live on this side of the cross and of the empty tomb and that we can see your love all the more richer for the gift of your son. We would desire that he be honored in this hour that we have together and that all things be done unto his glory and his name we pray. Amen. Okay, I'm going to take us back. Boy, it seems like it's been ages since we've been there. I guess it's just been a week, right? But with the campus day and such, that was a good time. I hope you guys were able to participate in the campus day activities. I'm going to do something a little different here. I want two bold volunteers. Okay, thank you, sir. That's great. This is your dolly, right? That one is second-fold volunteer. Yeah, why don't you come up here? That'd probably be best. Yeah, come on out here. Okay, thank you so much. When you're in the army, you know never to volunteer for something that you don't even know what it is. Here's what I'm going to ask you to do, and this is on the fly and it's extremely unfair of me. But give me a counting. You guys can decide among yourself who goes first. But give me, he goes first. That's already been decided. Just tell me the life of Jesus. And I'm going to put some things on the board as you're talking. Okay, go ahead. Life of Jesus. Okay, it's a good start. Very good, he's born. 12 in the temple. Very good, frantic parents. Where's my son? Let's try it. Prox. Okay. It is 30. Good. Yeah. Choosing disciples. Good. Okay. Wine. I got the wine out. All right. Cool. Here's your time. I don't think I'm going to put that one up. That's how you know. No, no, no, no. You got to go the whole the end, all the way. You got the attitudes. You don't have to get everything. I'm not, this isn't a test. It isn't a test. Hey, and you can't help. This isn't, this isn't a test. Okay. Miracles and ministry in Galilee. Good. Okay. Not liked. Well, so we go like, not like. Okay. Good. Okay, we got the cross. Good. Yeah. Okay. Cross and death. Good. You really died. Yeah. Good. Okay, so rose. Good time of year, Easter. That's it. That's good. That fossil screen pulls you through. That's great. Okay. Right. Okay. Okay. Very good. That was well done. Thank you. Okay. Volunteer one. Volunteer two. Could you recount from, yeah. You can do it. Oh, she'll do great. You did great to you. Good. Thank you. All right. I want you to start. All right. It's born specifically in Bethlehem. Good. Okay. ordinary folks. Okay. We got 12 in the temple. Okay. Bad ties. Okay. Teach. Good. Four miracles. Four miracles. Good. Ruckus Cross. God's plan. and paid penalty. Good? Yeah, good, you've listened to? Well, anyway. Okay, resurrection? Visited a disciples? Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. I'll just put community. Okay. Sense spirit. Okay. Great commission. Very good. Yeah, thank you. Okay, well done. Now they are gone. Thank you very much. I really appreciate this. That was a very bold of both of you and well done in both counts. Let me just talk about this for just a half a second and let's pretend that what we had in these two very bold fellows is our gospels. Two different people who are writing a perspective about who Jesus is. All right. By the way, is there anything in any of this that we would disagree with? Everything looks just great to me, honestly. I didn't find anything along the way that I thought was odd or unusual. In fact, I found it to be very good. And especially when you're kind of right on the spot just to be able to do all that. That's great. Now, I want to approach this from the kind of the perspective of the redaction critic for a moment. These were gospels now that were written 2,000 years ago. And they were written by people who are no longer alive. So we can't check with these two guys, gals. Sorry. I use guys in kind of the Chicago sense. All right. So that's right. Thank you. Meaning everybody. All right. These two wonderful folks. And so we can't double check with them what they meant. So we've got stuff up here and we need to kind of tease out what's going on. And we're interested in particular in kind of the theology of it. Now, the redaction critic is particularly interested in the aspects that are distinct in the two columns. All right. And especially in this case, we would benefit by being able to say that this gospel came first and your gospel came second, which meant that you were looking on this. And so anything that's different here, well, this has got to be part of your distinct theology. Okay. So as I look at this, I start off and I notice that from the very beginning, whereas Mr. Dolby just had born, here we have born in Bethlehem to ordinary folks. So now we're going to develop our theology of writer two. Let's just identify these as writer one and writer two. The theology of two involves the situatedness of Jesus in the ordinary life of his people. Does that sound good? Sounds scholarly, doesn't it? And so that's the distinct theological contribution. In fact, we can actually say if we were to go to really push this, that gospel two was bothered by the lack of ordinaryness in gospel one. And that this wasn't just a distinct theological contribution, but this was a correction to gospel one. All right. And then we would also want to stop for a second and take a look at Bethlehem. But what is the theology of Bethlehem in gospel two, as opposed to gospel one? I'm not quite sure. We don't have enough material, but that's never stopped scholars before. So we're going to kind of play with that and see what we can get out of this. Now here, this was ministry. My recollection was that I didn't write down everything, but she was a little vague on when exactly he did his ministry. So there's something about the 30s, probably that gospel one is very interested in. Perhaps because it's the Jewish coming of age, there's actually a rabbinic sense that he's now can be a full-fledged rabbi. So obviously gospel one is extremely interested in the Jewish nature of Jesus and the rabbinic character of him and how he can rightly teach. Here we have him choosing disciples. So obviously discipleship is a particular interest in gospel one, whereas gospel two chose intentionally to ignore that aspect. We have the highlighting of a particular miracle in the wedding at Kena, so we can try and identify why the wedding at Kena miracle actually stood out to the author of gospel one, whereas it's much more vague just that he performed miracles in two. Here we have a specific mentionance of the attitudes, but kind of a more generic teaching idea. And when it comes to the theology of the cross, here we see that gospel one just simply focuses on the mere fact of the death of Jesus as if there was no great theological import other than just his death. Perhaps that would make the resurrection, the ascension, and the sending of the Holy Spirit more important for that gospel author. Whereas if you come to this one right here, there's a very significant theology of the cross, right? It's not just that he died after a ruckus, but that there's God's plan that there's a penalty paid and that there's the term of redemption that was in there as well. And here the resurrection accounts a little bit more vivid because we've got a visiting of the disciples. What do you think? Does that make sense to you? Making a lot of assumptions? Yeah, good. Yes, there's a lot we don't know about the two. Now let's say that let's also admit that this procedure, as it's given on the board here, is a little unfair to the reduction critic in the sense that let's just postulate for a second that gospel one is Mark and gospel two as say Matthew. Well we don't just have a few kind of bullet points in Mark and Matthew. We have a much longer 16 chapter work here and 28 chapters here. And so there's a lot more material to work with. And so it's a little bit easier to really actually engage in comparison and contrast. But this does seem a little unfair to the authors at the same time. They would have done a little bit more work with the audience's ideas as well. That's right, that's where it's unfair as well. Any other comments? Yeah, I think it'd be an overstatement to say the point is very well made, which is basically that I was kind of pitting the two against one another. And however, I don't think it would be right to say that the reduction critic would say that the church was fighting against one another. But there would be points where gospel two is reading gospel one and they just think that's not right. And so it's not like they would have a duke it out. Their whole factions, according to the reduction critic, but there would be areas of disagreement that you would inherently postulate just because things are changed from one to the other. What else do you think? Very good point. Actually, if I can, I break it down into two points. I'm focusing on dissimilarity as opposed to dissimilarity. And then the second point is that where they're dissimilar, I'm sorry, you said basically this like the the other guy's not interested. That's right. It's like here ordinary folks, this person's not interested in ordinary folks. I just kind of assume that in the process. Yeah. That second point is extremely well made because I do I am starting to make assumptions just because it's not here. There's not part of their theological concepts or anything like that. Which we don't have enough material to know if they don't believe. We just have enough material to know what they do believe, right? And then secondly, if I can come back to what I separated off as the first point, this is very significant. I want you guys to hear this in a big way. You notice if you go down the list, I mean initially undoubtedly your impression was, well they basically agree, don't they? And so by highlighting the dissimilarities, which are fairly slight in the two lists, I've ignored the fact that over 90% of what's on the board is agreement, right? And that therefore the theological agendas of one and two probably are very closely the same, right? See that's what's going on there. In fact, can I suggest a possibility for, I'm getting into your brain here for a second, but maybe you can confirm this or deny it for me. You felt that you needed largely to repeat which was over here because I mean it was well stated to begin with, but you felt that also your job as number two since number one was already in the board was to add a little bit of extra detail that you know to be true just for the sake of adding detail and maybe some things that were perhaps missed that you know were accidentally omitted the first time. Am I getting into your brain? Yeah, just need to add a little bit, just so it's not exactly the same, right? So couldn't there be more mundane motives for a longer gospel that's copying off of a first gospel? And mundane and I don't mean to say that there weren't, you know, there wasn't any interest in theological perspective there, it's just, I mean if you've already got 16 chapters of Mark under the theory of Mark and priority that Mark comes first, why just repeat those 16 chapters? You're going to add something. So, and it's also likely that you're not going to subtract very much. So, you know, that might explain things right there. What I'm doing is getting into the mind of the redaction critic and then also critiquing it at the same time. When we ended the last time, I think we ended really mostly focusing on form criticism, but I said a few things about redaction criticism. Redaction criticism assumes source and form criticism in many ways. So the way that the redaction critic is thinking is there is Jesus and there are certain traditions to come out of him, maybe even groups of traditions. Let's group the traditions and we'll group one tradition as A and one tradition as X and X goes through community Y which changes it slightly, whereas maybe X could also make it into community B, but that's going to be slightly different than community Y and you get to the end and you're going to have C and you're going to have Z and these are the final forms of the text. And by the way, there's also the assumption that there's additional material not coming from Jesus that's just coming from the community so we could say D here comes in there and I don't know I'm getting lost in my letters Q comes in here and that what we're trying to do is redaction critics. The form critic and the tradition critic is their goal was to go back and trace all this and try to figure out what goes back to Jesus and try and figure out what goes back to different communities along the way. The redaction critic isn't as interested in that. The redaction critic is interested in C and Z and what the distinct theological contribution is of D and Z or C and Z. Sorry. And the way what they have to work with is the source critical stuff so they're going to say that gospel one or in this case say mark came first say that was gospel X here and that was changed in this community and it was taken up in this community and the result is that you get Matthew and Luke but they have other things going on as well and so you're trying to determine what is the distinct nature of Matthew's community versus Luke's community. That's redaction criticism effectively and in some ways I've engaged in this here. Now the other aspect of redaction criticism and I think a very apt critique of it is what you're really interested in is the theology of Z and Z and that means what you're interested in is the stuff that is distinctly C as opposed to B or distinctly Z as opposed to Y. Therefore there is a focus on what are known as the redactional seams. What's interesting what's most interesting because what's going to most give you the theology of C versus the theology of Z is the way the redaction critic is thinking is not the source material they use because after all they were basically just copying that. It's the stuff that they use to connect the material together. So if you assume for instance that the teaching material and the sermon on the mount which saw grouped together and then is otherwise much of the same material appears in a long teaching ministry starting in Luke chapter 9 I think and so on on his trip to Jerusalem. So the same material appears in two different contexts. Well what you're interested in is not the material that's the same but the distinct contexts in which is put. So if Matthew links one saying of Jesus with another saying of Jesus even by three or four words you're most interested in those three or four words that are Matthew because that's going to tell you what his theology is. Now along the lines of what we've talked about here what kind of things are you thinking about then? Coming out of those pictures. How would you critique this?

Not seeing the force for the trees. They're focusing on these few details instead of the big picture yeah good point. Couldn't there be just stylistic things going on that make for even distinct word choices etc. between Gospels? Couldn't it just be stylistic instead of there being these huge theological moments? Yeah. Can I say in addition to some of the comments that came out of our discussion here? A couple other critiques one. Redaction critics are indebted to the source and form critics. So our critiques of source and form criticism would also impinge on redaction criticism so that's one point. The second thing is is this force for the trees thing is extremely important because what happens is you get less and less material that is distinctly Matthew because even the sayings that are only in Matthew and not in Luke and Mark assuming almost that Matthew knew Luke and Mark right but even the sayings are somewhat irrelevant if the sayings are the material that came before Matthew. What you're really interested is just the way he linked it all together the seams if you would and that means that of say 28 chapters of Matthew I'm just going to guesstimate here but the number of verses that are distinctly Matthew then could probably at most fill maybe two chapters maybe one chapter. So you've gone from 28 chapters that give you kind of the theology of Matthew if you want to speak of it even in those terms to two chapters which means you have a lot less to work with which means you tend to make too much of the details right that's what was going on here when I made too much of ordinary folks you know that was just an extra details she chose to throw in but if I'm ignoring all the material that's the same between them then ordinary folks suddenly takes on this huge import and I'm going to construct a whole theology of the ordinary folks in gospel too right so those are some of the potential problems now let me say some of the potential benefits okay quite apart from from all of the tradition diagrams and everything I think it is the case that Matthew makes a distinct theological contribution as does Mark and as does Luke it is not to say that they're in conflict but rather again that diamond analogy everybody's looking at the diamond from a different perspective and so they have their own perspective and techniques that we can we can use to tease out what those distinct contributions are that that can be beneficial as long as we don't misuse them and abuse them so for instance if we were correct this and say we're not just interested in the scenes but we're interested in everything that was included so the theology of gospel to here isn't just ordinary folks and a few other distinct things it's everything that's on the board and we didn't can compare the infacies here with the infacies here I think there's something that is potentially positive about it if you're cautious and you do it in the right spirit of respect of the author and especially the divine authorship of scripture as well all right so I'm not saying we just threw out the baby with the bathwater but I am saying that we need to be careful understand to understand that some of the assumptions that are going on here are certainly extreme and possibly wholly erroneous at times let me show you some books that would indicate that one of the two of the most famous early kind of books in this genre are it's a group one done by Bornecombe Bart and Held and it's a tradition and interpretation in Matthew and you can go through almost anything in this book and in a lot of this stuff will stick out

and then another book that's along those lines is this book by Hans Conzelman called Theology of Saint Luke and I think I highlighted I think you can even hear it right the theology of Saint Luke what is the distinct theology of Luke now I'm you know that I have some sympathies with that but I also if you hear somebody say the theology of Luke you should suddenly you know your attendance should go up and you should say how are they going about determining what the theology of Luke is so let me read you some selections from this this is the significance of John the Baptist according to Luke it's not the significance of John the Baptist it's the significance of John the Baptist according to Luke so you can hear the kind of the terminology that's being used in the pre-Lukean tradition John is understood from the standpoint of the dawn of the new eschatological age he is more than a prophet he is a forerunner he is Elijah here Mark and Matthew used traditions which Luke himself has preserved for us so it is all the more striking that Luke's own pronouncements point in another direction it is true that he does not set out his views coherently in other words we're going to have to tease out a lot of this stuff but he indicates it whenever he speaks of John by what he'll miss and by what he adds I mean you you hear this is the methodology just kind of right in front of us right there in the tradition John the Baptist stands on the dividing line between the old and the new epic what's the tradition this is the pre-Lukean tradition presumably Mark that Luke is then editing and then he goes on Luke I'm skipping it into the next chapter Luke uses the existing material but transforms it in a characteristic way nowhere in his writings is a figure from the past brought into new into direct connection with the future eschatological events so Luke John's not brought into connection with eschatological events on the contrary existing interpretations are rejected Luke is now rejecting the tradition namely Mark instead of being directly linked with the eschatological events the figure is given a definite place in a continuous story of salvation the end of which is not yet in sight John no longer marks the arrival of a new eon but the division between two epics in the one continuous story and then he goes on okay now what he's going to conclude from that from doing that in several different locations is Luke's eschatology is wholly different from Mark and Matthew Mark and Matthew have two epics pre-Jesus Jesus Luke has a continuous eschatology that comes from and out of the Old Testament and in a much smoother way through Jesus and that's going to be his conclusion when he gets to the end of that okay so you hear how the red action critic is thinking I'll give you one last chance to ask any questions or any thoughts on all that John oh yeah yeah Jesus disappears in many ways because you're not trying to get at what Jesus taught notice at no point in that in that whole point that I read now granted it's just you know it was a page and a half from two hundred pages but at no point are you trying to come back to hear that's pot that's impossible to get to so we're no longer even interested in who Jesus was we're wholly interested in Matthew and Luke and Mark and keeping yourself employed well that's kind of cynical but if not there's some truth in it yeah it's not necessarily the question was was the assumption there that whatever is brief or more concise is the first and the answer is not necessarily so for here remember he's glad for Luke to omit stuff that's in Mark and Matthew and so there Mark comes first presumably and Luke is omitting stuff so it's a lot more complex basically they would they would again rely on the source critics who have argued usually they go with the Mark and priority that Mark came first and that the broader arguments there that Mark is is more concise Matthew and Luke are longer so they're expanding on Mark but that's not to say that in every pericopy in every little passage that the more concise is the original that you come to a broader conclusion that Mark comes first that you have Q that's involved remember that and then M and L those distinct sources coming in and they can expand or they can abbreviate the sources does that respond to your question well yeah my opinion I mean in a sense what we've done in terms of of saying what's good and what's the critique I would affirm all that's been said in the class if you want my opinion in a short kind of summary form it would be something like the idea of finding distinct theological infacies in the different authors is not necessarily bad at the same time these people go beyond calling them infacies they call them distinct theologies as if the theology of Luke can be pitted against the theology of Mark and Matthew so there's a presupposition in a terminological distinction I would make a more specific critique that I would make is that by focusing on just the redactional scenes you lose the sense of what they have in common and they have more in common than what is distinctly there and then even when you focus on the redactional scenes you're usually assuming source theories and you're assuming a particular theological motive in every little addition or omission from what you think the source was and then these things may be more stylistic and you need to view them in a much bigger picture. Yes that's right I would agree the method is inherently interested more in the differences than in the unity that's right can I say that I have a lot of sympathy with the idea of that analogy that you you have an accident you got four different people talking about the accident all at once I do think that when we come to the Gospels that's a good starting point but we need to be a little bit more sophisticated in thinking through how they came to actually pin their Gospels so Luke remember the prologue to Luke indicates that he knows of many people who came before who basically wrote these things down he also knows of the eyewitnesses in the tradition that they pass down so it's not like he's at the accident viewing the accident but it's more like he knows the eyewitnesses he knows the written accounts and after careful investigation he's able to put it together so it's like he's at it's like he's interviewing people who are at the accident I mean he might be a little bit better way to do it with Luke John might have been at the accident Matthew might have been at the accident but even Matthew being at the accident I would hold out the possibility that Mark came first and Matthew uses Mark as a basis for recollection of what happened at the accident and brings in other material as well so you know I think we have to be a little bit more careful in our analogy there but the the point is very well made that everybody's looking at the accident and they're wanting to describe the accident they're not wanting to be you know distinct from one another just to different that's right yeah you're emphasizing the reality of these individuals and you're just interested in the individuals you're not interested in what really happened in the process yeah that's that's true frankly some reduction critics are not can't aren't wholly guilty of that but that's because some reduction critics will go on to eventually talk about Jesus but but that is a good point I should also say that it's not strictly postmodern reduction criticism kind of came at that juncture and the transition from modernism into postmodernism now in reality those of you study postmodernism will realize that there's a lot of connections with modernity in postmodernism and that transition from one to the other is a lot less kind of absolute than we recognize but yeah it's that if you want something that's a little bit more towards postmodern actually then we'll move to the next methodology on your on your outline there namely narrative criticism all of these critiques that we've been talking about here have are are not uniquely ours I mean they've occurred to many other people before us including some very capable capable scholars and especially the critique that said you're only focusing on the distinctions God's plan paid penalty redeemed not explicitly mentioned here part of his theology and then not part of this theology you know that's the you focus so much on the distinctions that you lose the big picture and and secondly there's a imagine trying to take this into a pulpit okay you know what let's let's just try this you know let me I'm just going to turn randomly to to passage and I'm not honestly prepared to do this whole way but let's let's give it a shot the sermon for today is on mark chapter 1 verses 9 through 13 and it came about in those days that Jesus came from Nazareth you know I read through the text and I start saying as we look at Mark we realize that there's some distinct features to Mark when you compare him to Matthew and Luke and we realize that when he uses the phrase and it came back in those days as opposed to but which we find I'm not sure if that's actually the case but but that we find in Matthew and Luke that we we need to meditate on why he said and so the first point in my sermon is about and you know you know it's just it's not going to work right it doesn't there's a sense in which it doesn't preach and so that reality alone has called for people to say I need something I can take into my pulpit okay so there's that as well the other thing that's that's gone on in all of this is the read it is the realization that people are going to fight forever about the historical Jesus now part of the reason for that is the presuppositions you know we talked about the presuppositions going into the historical Jesus debate we talked about that a few weeks ago they're gonna they're gonna be at odds constantly about what happened here in the tradition and what we really want to just know is why was it that Matthew's trying to tell us or Mark's trying to tell us so a new approach is let's ignore all of this and in ignoring all of this we're not even going to be able to say much about the relationship between C and Z because the relationship between C and Z somehow comes back here to a hypothetical X so our goal is not going to be to compare and contrast C and Z we're not just interested in the seams we're interested in the whole gospel so let's just read the gospel from cover to cover Matthew and just read Matthew not compare and contrast with Mark and Luke but just read Matthew all right this is known as narrative criticism and the idea is that you have a narrator he tells you a story the narrator creates the whole world in which he wants you to interact in a narrative fashion okay and so you can as if it was just kind of put everything else out to the side as if you knew nothing else and just read Matthew chapter 1 verse 1 to 28 20 I think is the end and and everything in between and then try and draw connections between different parts of Matthew okay now it's important to notice that in that context we're speaking of a narrator who is telling a story we are not about saving the authenticity of the story that is not our goal our goal is to approach this as any other work of literature Moby Dick, Shakespeare's play Julius Caesar you know and just understand the work of literature as a work of literature apart from historical reference and just kind of read it from point A to point Z right and that's effectively narrative criticism if you want an example of that I've kind of brought a bunch of books that were in my Luke shelf here here's a book called Reading Luke a literary and theological commentary on the third gospel you got the word reading Luke you're just reading him like a narrative and then a literary and theological commentary we're interested in him as a literary figure what is he right I mean we would just study it like any other work of literature okay now obviously I mean that's a lot on 24 chapters in Luke it's probably more as much as you would produce on Moby Dick which is much longer so the amount of detail of interest in the narrative is perhaps discontinuous with other great works of ancient literature but it's that's what you're doing okay and that's narrative criticism I don't know I didn't pull out a passage here Luke 952 through 56 and 101 through 24 not only present the theology of world mission they also offer guidelines to govern missionary behavior on the one hand both the Luke 9 passage and and the Luke 10 passage contain a note of rejection following the theme of universality two different responses to this rejection or mention do you hear the word rejection that's a technical term in literary studies for crisis there's a crisis going on there so you got rejection I mentioned one in the Samaritan episode James and John ask Jesus about the possibility of calling down fire from heaven now in a literary context James and John are just figures in the text we're not talking about the historical James and John it's just James in the text John in the text Jesus in the text they're just different literary figures so James and John the two characters ask the character Jesus about the possibility of calling down fire from heaven on those who rejected him reminiscent of an Elijah episode in second Kings 110 so he's willing to least refer back to some Old Testament reference Jesus the character rejects any retaliation against his rejectors here is one guideline for dealing with rejection it is in line with early Christian instruction about disciples response to offending non-Christians two in the section of the mission of the 70 or 72 the response to rejection is very much that of nine five so he's going to go back and compare things that are going on elsewhere in the gospel so he's can compare and contrast what's going on the literary motifs that are elsewhere in the gospel and that's how you go about doing narrative criticism okay now I'm interested in what you think about that you see benefits do you see drawbacks what do you see well no no you say it's a focus on the story itself without looking for meaning of content no you are looking for meaning and content but you're looking for the meaning that the author of this story is trying to convey and the content that the author of this story is trying to convey you're not going to take it back to Jesus you're just interested in Luke what is Luke trying to say in his narrative it loses the historical connectedness which means it loses the redeeming power that got Jesus would have now at the same time let me just play with it she said slightly you said that it seems that

Jesus becomes just kind of a moral figure teaching about morality now you would go much farther beyond that you would say that in Luke the character Jesus dies on a cross and Luke the character Jesus is raised again and in Luke the character Jesus is a sense and so Luke has a theology there and his theology involves the death of Jesus even the attaining and ramifications of the death of Jesus the resurrection of Jesus the ascension of Jesus his power that comes from all that all of that is in Luke what you cannot do is say that that all goes back to Jesus because you're not making historical pronouncements as to any of that happened or not it's still just within this narrative framework yes very well stated the objective truth of Jesus is suppressed for simply the subjective thing of what Luke thought that's exactly right yeah and you see how this I mean part of the motive for that is this kind of frustration that if I want to say anything about Jesus himself then I have to engage in historical Jesus scholarship and all the presuppositions there and all of that so let's just ignore all that and not even care about it and just talk about Jesus as a character in Luke now well yeah I'll stop there I haven't further comment had there but go ahead yeah this seems to be in discontinuity with how else we do history is that your point yeah I mean we want to know something about what actually happened here in a sense we're kind of throwing up our hands and saying we can't know that so let's just study what Luke says yeah it's not that his history is accurate or anything like that we can't pronounce on that but there's a there's a different truth I mean the on a one way of approaching this on a more liberal perspective would be to say there is truth here but it's not historical truth as to whether events happened there's a truth that speaks to our souls that might be how they would go yeah the question is is there are they interested in historical context like when he wrote it and all of that and and how it would have resonated in his day the answer varies the early practitioner of the narrative critical approach simply said all of that is irrelevant because a narrator provides you with the world as you need to know it you don't need to know anything out of the when you read Moby Dick you don't need to know about what life was really like for Melville that that would be the point they would make I don't I don't agree with that point but that's what they would say you don't need to know what the historical context of Shakespeare's day is you just read the story and he provides you everything you need to know now I don't agree with that and I have to say also that many of the later narrative critics began incorporating ways of speaking of the society so that you speak of Luke in context you're still just interested of Luke you can't go back to Jesus but you can say how Luke would have sounded in the first century to a first century audience so there have been some narrative critics that have brought that more in and I think that's a helpful corrective to the approach frankly question are they at all concerned about the inspirational least better than the word well I mean this gets at a point that I was going to make actually somewhat separately this this approach does not assume a particular theological viewpoint in at least some sense a a a very liberal let's say I mean again these categories are funky but let's just say somebody who who has no doesn't believe that Jesus's death is atoning for their sin let's just say that okay can approach and use this method and get quite a lot out of the gospel in terms of what Lucas trying to say but for them they're not then going to draw the broader implications that Luke is correct it's just this is what Luke is saying on the other hand there's a number of evangelicals who have used this method as well and they want to say Luke is saying you know Jesus died it was atoning sacrifice was raised again ascended all of that is what Luke is trying to convey and then they would perhaps overtly or maybe outside of their actual publication of that say and by the way Luke was right okay but they're in a scholarly context let me let me paint this picture for you you're you're a person of evangelical convictions in a secular university trying to get your PhD okay you want to write about the gospels if you use the reduction critical approach you're going to be constrained by the seams and all of the source critical stuff and and it's you're going to pit the gospels against one another you don't want to do that if you want to go back to the historical Jesus suddenly you're going to have to engage in some of the scholarly presuppositions about historical Jesus including the criteria of dissimilarity and all that stuff you don't feel that's a level playing field therefore you're going to lose if you go back to Jesus in that context but you do you really are interested in what Luke is saying and what Matthew is saying so just read it as an narrative okay don't try and speak about going back to Jesus because as soon as you do your doctoral supervisor is going to nail you he's going to say you can't talk about Jesus without engaging in a full blown historical Jesus analysis of that little passage with all the presuppositions and all the problems a full source critical approach tracing the traditions backing up to do all of that so don't do it don't talk about who Jesus really was and you're you're like okay I can do that I can play that game I can just talk about what Luke is trying to say and then deep down I can say that what Luke is trying to say is true but I can't say that in my dissertation and that's that's a context now and there's a number of very fine scholars that have gotten their PhD doing that so is there any problem with that well I want to say yes because these these gospels are about history remember remember the title of this class New Testament it's not just New Testament theology it's New Testament history and theology so Luke is about real history and we want to affirm that I do have to say and I understand that my evangelical colleagues who are trying to speak to the broader academic community who realize that to try and go back to Jesus is going to invite so many questions that it's dangerous that they are still doing something good and just produce talking about Luke and doing the narrative of Luke but there's something dangerous about it because suddenly the gospel becomes a historical it becomes loose from history and and that is extremely dangerous because frankly I mean just put it in very brush terms if Jesus did not rise from the dead our faith is useless it just is I don't care what Luke thought I don't care what Matthew thought if Jesus is still his bones are still rotting in a grave we should just go home so we want to be able to say more than that and there's the danger that the narrative theological approach doesn't let us do that and then I I can't say tying in a little bit more to what you were saying your question Nathan there is a tendency and most narrative approaches to to not speak too much about even the historical context of Luke and not do too much of that so I would want to do more I'd want to engage the narrative more both on a historical level in terms of rooting it in history and then also in and on a historical level of saying that this is true history so I'd want to do both of those things all right now what I've just done is I have given you I think in redaction criticism and narrative criticism these two critical approaches are the closest to what I actually do want to do in this class I've done quite a lot of narrative criticism with you guys in this class and you just didn't realize it so on the first day of class or early in class when I when I pointed out that there's worship in Matthew 2 and there's worship in Matthew 28 and this shows that there's a major important theological emphasis in Matthew that has to do with worship well what's going on in the back of my mind is this is something that is not emphasized as much in Mark and Luke it's not that it isn't there it's not emphasized as much Matthew uses the word and so there's a little redactional critical tinge to what I just said there and I also was drawing a narrative connection between Matthew 2 and Matthew 28 and that was doing narrative criticism there so I was saying just as treating this as a work of literature you see the connection between the two and so I want to say there's fruit to all of that but I would also say that the match I really showed up and they wanted to worship Jesus and when Jesus appeared to the disciples in Galilee the first thing they did was fall down on their knees and worship and that happened historically and that was really what we're not it's just Matthew chooses to bring that out to invite his reader to respond accordingly to Jesus will you worship Jesus that's one of the things that Matthew is really trying to produce in that moment right well let me say that if you pull any commentary off of the shelf in the library that's been written in the last 20 years it's it's aware of all of these approaches and they use them to their varying degrees and if you pull an older commentary 50 years ago then they weren't even aware of narrative criticism and they were largely stuck with source form and reduction criticism you know so this is just the reality of the books that you have in a library and even the most popular commentaries think in these terms and that's not necessarily bad what I would invite you to do is then not to reject that literature but to read it from a critical viewpoint so that you're saying when I'm reading this commentary is their methodology getting in the way of scripture or is it assisting in the understanding of scripture and in the same commentary within the same paragraph actually you can have both going on the methodology can get in the way but it also can produce some very helpful results and so I would invite you to read the literature but to read it critically and understand what's going on and not just you know be overwhelmed by the presuppositions all right a last thing with regard to the dating of the gospels as I mentioned actually while he was changing the tape a late dating of the gospels is required for many of these approaches especially for form criticism so a common second century date is very often done sometimes as late as even the mid second century so a hundred years after Jesus but also dates as late as the late first century now there's some problems with that one is that we have a text it's a very fragmentary text but a text of the gospel of John from 135 AD so from the beginning of the second century the text does not come from you know where John actually wrote and such so there was a wide distribution of the gospel of John at the early part of the second century so the gospel of John at least must predate that all right so we have some grounds for assuming that at least that gospel comes before more over there is extensive use of the gospels and the gospel traditions in the early church fathers and widespread use well and in the second century and even is in the later part of the first century so that shows that the gospels must predate at least their traditions but I would actually argue that the gospels themselves must predate the late the not the post apostolic writings of the late first century in the second century now there is much discussion about individual gospels whether they are pre-80-70 or post-80-70 why does 80-70 matter what's what happened 70? Folger is good if you if you if you one of those things that if you leave this class and you can't remember 70 yet and you know I'll just you know I don't know I'll be despondent all right so 70 so the gospels the dating of the gospels is often done as to whether they anticipate or they know about the destruction of the temple all right so there's a lot of discussion about that now I I don't want to go into the individual issues on Matthew, Mark and Luke and also John if you want to investigate this further you guys own I hope Carson, Mue and Morris introduction to the New Testament right and you can go to their chapter on Matthew or Mark or Luke and they'll go through a lot of detail about dating the tradition of Matthew and dating the tradition of Mark and Luke, etc. Okay now a broader point and I would suggest that you can take this into consideration how does the book of Acts end? Anybody know Paul's in prison he's just leaving he's just there in Rome in prison there's an expectation really I think that he's going to be released because they don't have a good case against him but he has to go through all the hoops to be released but he's in prison he's still ministering in prison, etc. Why would Acts end that way? I mean that is an odd way to end. If Paul was freed from prison as church tradition indicates fairly universally then why not mention his release from prison? I mean it doesn't seem to serve a purpose to leave him in a Roman house arrest in a Roman jail effect, a Roman house arrest. You'd want to mention it if he was released. If he was executed then that might also serve your purpose because after all one of the recurring themes in Luke is people bartered for the Christian religion and that persecution that Paul goes through and the death of Stephen etc. So he might very well have wanted to talk about that and certainly his readership would have known of Paul's execution, it had he been executed already. Therefore it is possible that the book of Acts is written while Paul is still in prison. I think that to be very likely in any way. If that's the case then Paul's in prison roughly 58 to 60 AD somewhere in there. Okay and that would indicate that the book of Acts is written say six let's just say ballpark 80 60. The book of Acts is a sequel to the gospel of Luke. That means that the gospel of Luke must be written before 80 60. If the gospel of Luke let's just again make a hypothetical possibility that the gospel of Luke uses Mark, Mark in priority or even if you were to say Matthew in priority and Luke uses Matthew. Then you have a case for at least one of the other two synoptic gospels also being before 80 60 and then the gospels are within 30 years of the life of Jesus. Same generation from the apostolic authors all of that and that's a very short

argument that would need to be fleshed out in much more detail and would then need to be supplemented by the details for each of the individual gospels that you have in Carson Moon Morris but I would suggest that is a possibility. If that's a possibility then you just simply do not have the time for all these communities to have so changed the traditions that they've been manipulated beyond recognition.

And therefore I would critique some of these gospel things on that part. If you would flip the page on your notes let me just simply note something here and I think I won't take the time to explain this in any great detail because we're going to have to move on next time. But there's some distinct theological themes mentioned by RT France. That is the article by RT France that is in Lads theology of the New Testament. It's an article you've actually read. And these are some of the theological themes that he indicates are going on in the three different gospels. And again I would largely affirm all of this because I think this provides a helpful summary of some of the distinct contributions that each of the gospels makes. And I would also note that France is careful in his article to acknowledge that these are just distinct as in light of the unity elsewhere in land. In other words he's saying this isn't everything you would want to say about Matthew or about Mark or about Luke. This is just what you would say is distinct. There's a lot more unity going on and he's assuming that you've read the rest of Lads to get that unity. And I would say that's also in a favor of that. And I would also note that he's not just recounting what scholars have done but he evaluates them. So he's not just kind of imbibing at the fount of redaction criticism and saying let's do this uncritically. So all of that is pro. I have some critiques of that as well.

France in ways that he doesn't fully acknowledge is dependent on scholarly studies and does not produce as a result a balanced theology of Matthew. In other words he's so dependent in some ways on the work of redaction critics that he is by default, though he doesn't intend to do this, only emphasizing the redactional scenes that connect the gospels or the redactional scenes. So he is not sufficiently emphasizing the areas of unity that are also part of the distinct theology of Matthew. I would also critique this article that he raises these distinctives to the level of theological points as if these are theological points to be made. And he does so almost at times to the point of raising a disagreement between them. So he'll say that the Christology in Matthew is higher than that of Mark and Luke. He has a more overt emphasis on the deity of Christ, Matthew does. And I want to say that's a little too strong RT. You're going a little overboard here because these might be infacies, but to say that they're distinctives and that they can be pitted against one another is somewhat dangerous. We've already engaged in that discussion here. And finally, nearly every distinctive is demonstrably present in all is just emphasized in one. So Jesus certainly fulfills the law in Matthew, but that's not to say that he doesn't fulfill it in Mark and Luke. They just don't use the word fulfill. Jesus is in many ways like the new Moses in Matthew, but there's mosaic elements to Jesus' ministry in Mark and Luke. Luke is interested in the Holy Spirit, but the Holy Spirit isn't lacking in Matthew and Mark. Luke does show a great deal of interest in Gentile mission, but so does Mark and Mark does so in spades. So even though these are infacies, it's saying that maybe this is heightened in these different gospels, but we can't say that they're missing in each. So there's some pro and con kind of on that RT France article that you read. And then the less I do think that this is a helpful kind of starting place to look at those columns and see that there are some some special infacies in each. Okay. Next week on Wednesday, I want to briefly talk through some issues in Mark and Luke, and then we'll talk about Axe a bit and by the end of the week, I hope to be in the gospel of John.