<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bantu Bantu Bulanan

"I am Not Ashamed of the Gospel": Paul and His Gospel; Toward a Theology:

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

All right. Let me open us in prayer and then we have an ambitious day here ahead of us. We'll see how far we can get. Father, it has been a joy to be with these students and I am excited about their desire to serve you that has brought them here to the seminary, that has brought them to a desire to study your word and to study it passionately for its implications in their lives and in the lives of the people to whom they minister. And I pray as they open the word of God over the next many years that that passion and that excitement would remain and that the inspired word of God through the working of your Holy Spirit and the lives of these students would avail to their knowledge of Christ and of God to their love of Christ and of God and to their love of their people. I pray that you would bless their ministries, whatever the ministerial calling that they have, be it lay or vocational. And I pray that you would use them mightily to bring your glory into this world and it's in the name of Jesus our Savior that we pray. Amen. Here's what I want to do. I have a conclusion that I want to do the class that was just distributed. I want to do that when Patrick has to change the tape. So up to this we're going to do Paul for the next 50 minutes, which obviously is short shrift on Paul. But there's a few kind of key principles that I want you to bear in mind when you approach the Apostle Paul and that's really what I'm after here. You have quite a lot on Paul in your readings. I mean Lad likes Paul, doesn't he? So he has a nice long section on Paul. There's no way I could touch covering as many of the theological themes certainly not in the depth that he covers. So I'm going to let Lad cover most of that. And you also have some readings obviously on Paul's life that were found in FF Bruce's book on New Testament history. And you have a short reading on the pastoral epistles, I believe, and Carson and Morris arguing for the authenticity of the pastoral epistles. And all of that I'm assuming that you've read. So what I want to do is highlight just kind of a few things I want you to bear in mind when you approach Paul. The first thing is I want to give you a bit of a background in terms of some of the issues in contemporary scholarship because when, like I pointed out before in this class, when you go to read a book in our library on the Apostle Paul, there's 200 years at least of discussion of interpretation of Paul that lies behind the book, even if it's a very just kind of commonly-friendly book that's written by somebody with some academic credentials. And as with the Gospels, there are a number of questions that are asked, you know, critical techniques, et cetera. With Paul, there are some as well, but they're quite different in some respects than with regard to the Gospels. So let's highlight those for a second. The first thing, and I believe I've mentioned this before, has to do with the legacy of the tubing in school, and especially Ferdinand Christian Bauer. You remember his name from the very beginning of our time together, beginning of the semester. When I mentioned that this was a very important moment in New Testament studies when Ferdinand Christian Bauer came across, and suggested a different way of synthesizing the history of the New Testament. I ultimately want to say that it's a highly defective way, but I don't want to put the cart before the horse. Basically, what Bauer did is he looked especially at the book of Galatians, and you'll remember that in the book of Galatians, Paul is trying to oppose kind of the circumcision party. The party who are often called Judaizers, and what they want to do is to ask that the Gentiles who have come to Christ undergo circumcision. Paul is against this because in his mind, that means that we're asking the Gentiles to take on the whole weight of the law, and the danger there is that the works of the law become a substitute for faith in Christ, such that you seek your salvation based on what you do in particular, you're keeping of the law. You remember that that's kind of the essence of what Galatians is about in many ways. Along the way, in the book of Galatians, Paul mentions some history, some kind of background history, to show that his gospel is a true gospel, is the true gospel. What that means in part is that he says that he was even willing to oppose Peter to his face when Peter withdrew from eating with the Gentiles because of people from the circumcision party. Now using that as the kind of guiding heuristic for the history of New Testament interpretation, Ferdinand Christian Bauer said that on the one hand you had Paul who represented Gentile Christianity, and on the other hand you had Peter who represented Jewish Christianity, and then later in the church there was a synthesis. So Peter versus Paul, if you would. Now, as I think I briefly described this at the beginning of the semester, you remember that this is predicated on a philosophical outlook that was prevalent in 19th century Germany, namely that of hagelianism. And without going into all the the Murk and Meyer of hagel is very complex philosophical philosopher to try and understand. On a very sketchy basis, hagel had the concept that has later been described as thesis antithesis synthesis. Those of you who have ever studied Karl Marx will recognize that kind of progression that Marx drew from hagel and then applied to the sphere of economics. But many people were very taken with this approach. And what would happen is you'd have thesis antithesis synthesis, the synthesis itself would become a thesis effectively. And there would be another antithesis and then a synthesis. And this is how the history of human thought has progressed over time. And it also has to do with the very ways that we think because our categories are determined this way, if you would. So he was looking for this if you would. In other words, this is a philosophically laden approach to approaching the New Testament. He needed a thesis, he needed an antithesis, and he needed a synthesis, and he found it if you would. So in some ways he was guided more by his philosophy than by the materials themselves. Some of the problems with this and I'm very interested that you know what some of the problems are. Some of the problems have to do with just where do you fit then the rest of the New Testament in this. So for instance, in the book of Acts, in Acts chapter 15, the council in Jerusalem, the council is there to determine whether Gentiles need to be circumcised. And you know what the decision of the council is? They do not. Acts 15 very early on just after Paul's first missionary journey. So very early on in the book of Acts, the decision is made. And who steps up to defend the Gentiles not needing to be circumcised will certainly Paul. But you know who else? Peter. And also James eventually. James, ultimately the brother of Jesus, makes the final call, if you would, by kind of drawing a conclusion what the sentiment of the church was. So at least in Acts 15, Peter is not Jewish Christianity versus Gentile Christianity. So what do you do with the book of Acts? Our, his answer is, oh that's part of the synthesis. That's part of the second century synthesis. In other words, the book of Acts is written long after the facts and is of dubious historical value and its principal theological aim is to create a synthesis between the opposing Gentile and Jewish Christian parties. So that's what, where he would put that. Well, okay, let's try a different book then. First Peter or second Peter? Second Peter, 316, my goodness. I mean, what does it say about Paul? Let's, let's, let's, I'm encoded for you here for a second. Second Peter, 316, starting in verse 15. And regard the patience of our Lord to be salvation. Just as also our beloved, this is Peter, second Peter, our beloved brother Paul according to the wisdom given him wrote to you, as also in all his letters, speaking in them of these things in which are some things hard to understand which the untaught and unstable distort, as they do also the rest of scriptures to their own destruction. Peter is saying there, Paul's the beloved brother. You need to listen to him. Yes, his books are hard to read, but the only problems with them come from people distorting his books. The books themselves are great. In fact, they belong with the rest of scripture. So Peter likes Paul. Well, if you're Ferdinand Christian, Bauer, then where do you put second Peter down here in the synthesis? It also has to be written in the second century. Well, there are other books in the Pauline corpus that speak quite highly in some respects of the law. And if the, the need for work. So for instance, Ephesians 289, for by grace, you've been saved through faith and it's not according to yourselves as the gift of God, right? And then there's the issue in 210 that we are Christ's workmanship created in Christ Jesus unto good works that we might walk in them. So there's this positive view of works there. It's not the vehicle of salvation, but it's a necessary corollary of salvation. Well, what do you do with Ephesians then? You got to put it out here in the synthesis. So increasingly, there's less of Paul that's actually written by Paul. None of first Peter and second Peter are written by Peter and acts as in the second century. So you got to date everything very late in order for this kind of opposition to work. In particular, Bauer held that there are only four authentic Pauline letters, only four letters that are actually written by Paul. And those letters are Romans, first and second Corinthians, and Galatians. And you should know what those are, all right? Those are known as the helped brief of the chief letters. Those are the ones that are authentically Pauline. Paul actually sat down and did them himself. Everything else is somebody later. So do you see any problems with Ferdinand Christian Bauer's synthesis? I see a few. One is it's very theory laden working more off of a philosophical presupposition than what you actually find in the text itself. Secondly, it only accepts a part of the letters that are written by Paul as truly Pauline, in part because the other letters don't fit his synthesis. And next, it requires a late date for pretty much the rest of the New Testament, especially the Book of Acts, and certainly the Petri and Correspondence, first and second Peter. So those are at least some of the issues with this. In point of fact, the Book of Galatians, although Paul represents him opposing Peter to his face, he never then talks about the resolution of that. And so depending on when you date the Book of Galatians, very likely a high degree of resolution is expected. And the Book of Galatians itself says that Peter used to eat with the Gentiles, but it was out of concern for the circumcision party that Peter separated from the Gentiles, meaning that Peter doesn't seem to have kind of a personal problem with Gentile Christianity, but he's doing it out of a sensitivity to some of his Jewish colleagues that do have problems with it. In some ways, Peter is trying to mediate between two different positions, but Paul is saying, in that mediation, Peter, you are doing something that is incredibly dangerous. So I would argue that the Book of Galatians itself doesn't really pit Paul against Peter, except only temporarily. So there's the issue of the Ferdinand Christian Bauer thesis. Now, some of the ramifications for this, basically, they're ramifications for pretty much everything other than the gospels, because if you follow this, then suddenly you're dating very late, most of the rest of the New Testament. So the ramifications go outside of just the Pauline corpus, but they have to do with acts and everything else. Within the Pauline corpus, there is this sense, and it's still in Pauline studies today, everybody will agree that Galatians, Romans, 1st, 2nd, Corinthians, that's Paul. Everybody will definitely agree that. Most people will also add other books, such as Philippians, 1st and 2nd Thessalonians, Philemon. These are also agreed, even by the most critical of scholars today. Most of those are also accepted as truly Pauline. So people have added to Bauer's halped briefah, but this remains the core, and the question is always, do these other letters cohere with the core? So when it comes to dating Pauline letters, there are a few issues that come up again and again. One has to do with stylistic affinity to the known Pauline letters. Another has to do with theological vocabulary, and the degree to which that coheres with the known Pauline letters, and what we mean, by the way, by the known Pauline letters, are these four, especially. So to the degree to which a book such as Ephesians has stylistic similarities and theological vocabulary that overlaps with this, people argue, well, that's authentically Pauline. To the degree that it varies from that, then they'll say, well, maybe it's not Pauline. Well, there's some problems with this. One is that we know, from the way that, say, for instance, Paul will come in and say, notice that I'm signing this letter, basically I'm paraphrasing with my own hand. That he's using scribes in the process of writing, and depending on the degree to which he felt confident in a scribe, scribes could have a broader range of techniques that they could bring into bear. In other words, he might give him the gist of what they want to say, but individual word choice could vary slightly from scribe to scribe, because the scribe could put in their own concepts at times. Or their own ways of wording the concept. So you can see how trying to maintain a kind of stylistic homogeneity between all the letters is kind of working against the very process of writing that we know Paul likely employed. Secondly, let me just ask you guys a question. You guys occasionally write letters, maybe emails. It's more an email generation now. But, you know, if you ever sit down and handwrite a letter, do you write letters now like you did 20 years ago? Use the same vocab. Do you use the same kind of grammatical forms always? Do you sign your letters the same way? All of that. After 20 years, could there not be some change? Well, when you give the notion that Paul's letters could be written over a 15 to 20 year period, we might expect some stylistic variation. Given that some of his letters, such as Philemon and First and Second Timothy and Titus, are written to individuals, whereas most of his letters are written to churches, we would expect some stylistic variation. So stylistic variation is a problem. Moreover, to do real stylistic study, you need a very large sample. You need a large sample of very secure material so that you know that, for instance, based on these 600,000 to a million words, that this is the standard vocabulary and stylistic devices that are used by that author. And then, if you have another large work of several thousand words, you can compare that to the main database, because all of this is basically probability and statistics, and you need large samples to do any good probabilistic work. We don't have a big enough sample for Paul to securely say, this is his style and he didn't do anything other than that. You can say, this is his style and he generally follows this, but to say that he cannot vary from it, we would need a much larger sample. So there's problems with stylistic issues. When it comes to theological vocabulary, some of the words that we consider to be, you know, Paul's theology, the core of his theology. You realize that Paul uses those differently in his letters? Here's an example. The word flesh, the Greek word is sarks, flesh and Paul. Sometimes, it means the physical body that we have. Other places, it means the sinful flesh, the sinful nature. Now, generally, theologians, because of Paul's theological use of it to mean the sinful nature, like a flesh and Paul as an entirely negative concept, but in point of fact, if you study the Pauline literature, you'll realize that very often flesh is a neutral concept referring just literally to our bodily substance. And sometimes, in letters such as Colossians, for instance, you have both uses simultaneous, basically the first half of the book of Colossians, physical body substance, second half of the book of Colossians, sinful nature. So, to say that every term that we typically associate with Paul's theology is a technical theological term is also problematic. And some of the terms that are most associated with Paul, such as justification, show up very often, for instance, in the book of Romans, but are almost entirely missing from, say, a book like Second Corinthians. Within the very same halped briefah, if you would. So what I'm trying to say, basically, is that the kind of criteria that are often tried to apply to say that, oh, this isn't Paul, and this is not, have significant problems with them. The criteria themselves have significant problems. Now, if you want further details on that, the Carson-Mumoros article on the pastoral epistles, the key issue in Paul really is the pastoral epistles, because it has the greatest degree of stylistic variation from, say, the halped briefah. I would argue that's because he's writing a personal letter to a friend, and he's writing much later in his ministry than some of these other letters. But if you read through the Carson-Mumoros article with some of those things I just mentioned in mind, you'll see why they're discussing what they're discussing in terms of authorship issues. So here's this. Now, one of the problems, theologically, then, that is an implication of this, is the core of Paul's theology is still almost invariably found in these four books. Which means that when you get into the book, a book such as Ephesians, or certainly the pastoral epistles, if you read a book, go to library downstairs and get a book that's a major scholarly work on Paul-line theology, go to the index, the scripture index, and see what percentages of which books of the Paul-line corpus are quoted. And you'll see it's those four books primarily, which means that some of the stuff that Paul talks about in some of his later letters is almost entirely excluded from the discussion. And this is very problematic at times. So, for instance, when Paul talks about poverty and wealth in the pastoral epistles which he does, he's very harsh at times on richness. Being rich and wealth, that's not typically found elsewhere in the other Paul-line letters. It's a theme we certainly know from the gospels, especially Luke. It's a theme we know from the book of James, and so it's a concern that we find in the early church. Not a concern we normally associate with Paul. Well, why not? Well, it's because we've focused on this set of letters to the exclusion of some of the rest of Paul. So, there are effectively theological implications in my vocation from this Bauer concept, and you should know that. And I would suggest that there needs to be fundamentally a corrective in some of the approaches that have been made over the years to Paul-line theology because we've focused on the wrong things. One last little story. This is kind of a cute little illustration. There's a New Testament scholar named Harold Honer, who works in Dallas, and a few years ago he came up with the idea of using these very same criteria to argue against the authenticity of the book of Galatians. And you'll find distinct theological vocabulary in Galatians. There's also distinct structural elements in the book of Galatians. There's no thanksgiving, usually after the introduction, Paul and Apostles Gentiles, etc. The next thing that comes up is I get thanks to my God, and then he goes on, he gives long thanksgiving. There's no thanksgiving in the book of Galatians. There's a very strong tenor against the church in Galatians that you don't find in many of the other things, and there's stylistic variations as well in some of the ways that he writes Galatians. And so, he argued against Galatians as being authentically Paul-line. Now his point was, he's evangelical, he wasn't really trying to say Galatians isn't written by Paul. But he was trying to say that if you use the very same kind of criteria that are used against, say, first Timothy, you apply it to Galatians, you end up with, there is nothing written by Paul. Because there's such a range of stylistic variation in theological vocabulary variation between the different Paul and books. And I think the point should be very well taken. What we need to do is to broaden our scope and simply allow Paul to be Paul in all of his, the diversity of his letters. That's going to tie into something I want to say later about the diversity of Paul's letters because we need to understand that Paul was not a systematic theologian trying to write out and try out a coherent systematic theology. Certainly he thought in theological terms. But primarily he wrote to crisis situations in the church and he addressed each crisis as it came along. And that means that the letters are much more to use a technical word occasional. That means that Galatians is written to a particular occasion in the church. Romans to a particular set of issues that he thought needed to be addressed in Romans and same with the first and second Corinthians and such. Which accounts for the diversity that you have in Paul because there's a diverse set of situations going on in these different churches. I'm going to stop there. Are there any questions about any of that? Do you want to agree this Paul or any other process that I want to quote in the Gospels? What to agree is he quote the Gospels. We can't know for sure because when he quotes Jesus it says if he's quoting his Lord we don't know if he's quoting it from the Gospels per se. But there are certainly passages where he's citing Jesus that then cohere well with the Gospels. So for instance his account of the Lord's Supperco hears very well with Luke's account of the Lord's Supper and such. So there's overlaps significant overlaps. And is that account that when he quotes that account? Is it in one of this? Is it in the top three person in one of these doubt? This is a much later call. It's in first Corinthians. Okay so it just seems to me that there are parallels that that's a good way to take the Gospels to. If they want to say this is often in Paul and we know Paul existed at a certain time then it just seems to me that's a good way to take the Gospels. It's an interesting point. Connected to that there was something in the readings that said perhaps that Luke was described Paul used for some of that particular overlaps. What do you say to that? I think that's very possible. We again we don't know for sure because he doesn't always name his scribes. There's a few places where he seems to like at the end of the book of Romans but it's very possible that Luke would have been one of the people he would have used there. Oh and by the way in that regard one of the reasons that Luke is associated with Paul is there's point I meant to mention this when we talked about the book of Acts. There's parts in the book of Acts where instead of describing the events as they did this, they did this, they did this, all of a sudden he switches to the first person plural and says we did this. And these are known as the we passages in Acts because he uses the word we, not we as in little, the we little passages in Acts but the we passages as when he includes himself. So Luke I think we have every reason to believe was in the Paul line train. He was one of the people who followed Paul. That has to do with point I. The legacy of the tubing in school and some of the questions with regard to the authenticity of Paul's letters. Second. The legacy of the historical Jesus quest and 19th century German liberalism. Basically what you need to know is this. That 19th century German liberalism and by that I'm using a term that technically has been given for years. I don't mean liberalism in a pejorative sense there. I'm just saying that's the the term that's given to this movement. But 19th century German liberalism and then eventually American liberalism as well in that period typically drew a distinction between Jesus and Paul. And the idea was that Jesus taught about the kingdom. Yes, he was interested in poverty. He was interested in the brotherhood of mankind. I mean that the three main phrases for 19th century German liberalism are the fatherhood of God, the brotherhood of man and the infinite value of the human soul. Those were the main theological points that came out of German liberalism. You'll know no major mention of sin. Certainly no mention of dealing with sin. It's just we're all basically good people. God's our father. We need to act as brothers of one another because we're all worth something. Well obviously that's not Paul because Paul likes sin. He talks about it a lot. And certainly there was the awareness among the more sophisticated people within liberalism that the church had principally discussed Christianity in different terms. The holiness of God, the sinfulness of man created in God's image and the death of Jesus and his resurrection to produce atonement for our sin. There might be other propositions you want to throw in there, but you'll notice that those three propositions are very different than the liberal propositions. You'll also note that those propositions can be easily defended in Paul. So the idea was that Paul took the Jesus movement in a different direction from the way that Jesus actually went. And so Paul becomes, and this is the term that they actually used, the founder of Christianity. And that's not a good thing because Christianity is different from what the historical Jesus taught. So the historical Jesus quest was going after what Jesus taught and what they were after was he taught about the brotherhood of man. Paul stood in the way, so you spoke of Paul as a founder of Christianity who ultimately obscured what Jesus was trying to teach. So if you want to see a good representation of this, Adolf von Harnack's book, What Is Christianity? From that period, it discards Paul very quickly on these very bases. Now there are people teaching today in universities that basically argue the same thing. You have a very nice book by Wynnum to argue against that. And he writes about, the name of the book is Paul, what is it? Something, Paul, founder of Christianity or follower of Christ, something like that. And his point is, Paul followed Christ instead of founded this new religion. But you need to know that that's also an assumption that many people have an approach Paul. A new movement in the last 30, 40 years is the new perspective on Paul, moving to point three. And this requires quite a lot of development, but I'm just going to give you a short take on the new perspective on Paul. The new perspective on Paul really starts with a new perspective on Judaism. The view of Ed Sanders, EP Sanders is that scholarship, New Testament scholarship has typically disparaged ancient Judaism. It has done so by saying that Judaism in the first century was largely a legalistic religion. The idea is that if you keep the law, you get to go into the world to come. And he argues that if you go back to the Jewish sources that are from, especially the Palestinian vicinity, that are pertinent to studying the first century, that you don't have this kind of legalism in ancient Judaism. Instead, you have what he calls covenantal nomism. This is on your handout. But this has two aspects to it. First is that covenant is a relationship created effectively by grace, where God chooses his people Israel. And the idea is that if you were to correctly synthesize the functioning of Jewish religion in the first century, if you ask a Jewish person why do you anticipate going into the world to come, he would say, first of all, well, I was born into the covenant that God established with his people. And ultimately, it's God's work there. Now, to stay in the covenant, I have followed the law. So there's a difference between getting into the covenant and staying in. So you get in the being born into the covenant or being accepted as a Gentile prostalite. You stay in by keeping the law. And this is known as covenantal nomism. Now, Sanders take on this, then, is that this is fundamentally a gracious view. It's not a legalistic view, it's a gracious view. Our salvation is not fundamentally predicated as Jewish people, we would say, in first century. On us keeping the law, it's fundamentally we're in the covenant. And that's something God did with his people. Now, Sanders' point was if this is how Judaism is properly understood in the first century, then you come to Christianity and Paul couldn't be fundamentally on about opposing the legalism of his Jewish youth. He must have been on about something else. Because this isn't legalism, according to Sanders. Now, that's basically what is being taught with regard to the new perspective on Paul. And everyone would agree with that who's following the new perspective, that perspective on Judaism. They might add a few more details, but that's basically the idea. The outworkings of this are that there's three different kind of major approaches that assume this view of Judaism and then talk about Paul. The first is Sanders. And Sanders basically, I mean, I'm going to have to oversimplify here, I just for a sake of time, but Sanders basically says, what was Paul's problem with the Jewish people? His problem was that they weren't Christians. They didn't accept the Messiah. And so because they missed the Messiah, that's their issue. And that's what Paul's really kind of on about. The next viewpoint is that of Jimmy Dunn, James DG Dunn here, and Jewish identity markers. Dunn, I think, is much more nuanced when he approaches Paul and he says, okay, I agree with you Sanders about Judaism. It's much more gracious than we've ever allowed before. So Paul couldn't have been on about legalism and Judaism, but he does talk repeatedly about the works of the law and how these are not salvific. So what are the works of the law? Well, for Dunn, they're the items in the law that separate Jew from Gentile, circumcision, food laws, and keeping them a Sabbath, being the principal issues, especially circumcision. These constituted Jewish identity markers. How did you know if you were Jewish in the ancient world? Well, you were circumcised, you didn't eat the same foods that the Gentiles ate, and you kept the Sabbath. And so Paul's on about that, that's Dunn's view. And so what was Paul about, he was trying to say, no, the Gentiles should be accepted without having to keep the Jewish identity markers. The last perspective is that of NT Wright who has a much more kind of evangelical pledge to it, and I tell you what, it's just too complex to go into the right at this stage, so I'm just not going to talk about it. I'm thinking, we've got to do other things here with this time. But it's important that you know Dunn and Sanders. Now, problems in my mind with this. You will not find covenantal nomism, that terminology, certainly in ancient Judaism. And point of fact, ancient Jewish people did not write systematic theology. It's not how they thought. And so, when Sanders draws out covenant nomism, he can't go to a systematic theology that says, okay, covenant comes first, and then you've got to stay in by keeping the law. What you find he is, some texts in ancient Judaism to talk about the covenant as the gracious work of God, and then some texts I would argue a lot of texts to talk about the need to keep the law. And he says, what's the logical order to put these in? And he would say it's this. But the problem is, you won't find ancient Jewish authors talking about that logical order. And so, in short, I want to question whether this synthesis is a wholly accurate understanding of what was going on in ancient Judaism. There was a tendency to seeing the need to keep the law as a requirement for entering into the world to come. And as even in, say, Protestant, certainly non-Protestant churches today, if you talk repeatedly, repeatedly about how it's important that you obey these rules and these rules, keep the Ten Commandments, et cetera, again and again and again and again. And you only rarely talk about grace. What is it that your people get? Keep in the law. How am I saved? I keep the law. And I want to at least hold out the possibility that something analogous to that was going on in Judaism in the first century. I'm oversimplifying greatly. I'd have to support that. I'm playing on teaching a whole class on this next research class with THM students next year. But I think that Sanders is oversimplified to a point of danger and lack of clarity. Secondly, Paul doesn't seem to be, he is concerned about these Jewish identity markers. I would agree with that with Dunn. But it seems like he's concerned more than that. He's not just concerned that you don't have to keep the identity markers. He's fundamentally concerned that the law is not what saves. The law cannot save. This seems to be part and parcel of the whole argument of Galatians and Romans. And certainly, the point is made very clearly in the book of Ephesians, for by grace you have been saved, you know, that whole passage I just quoted earlier. And so therefore the law cannot save. So he's talking more than just circumcision food laws. He's saying the law cannot save. Now the practical concern is Gentiles don't have to be circumcised. But the broader concern is salvation comes by faith. And I think we need to emphasize that when we approach Paul. Now, I have two quickly, but still importantly, you know, covered that. Theological themes in Paul. Here's what I want you to write under the theological themes in Paul point B. You ready? C. Lad. Okay. Because Lad has well over 100 pages on this. And I think he does an excellent job of drawing off the theological themes in Paul. So there's that. Now, I want to talk about the book of Galatians and the book of Romans especially. There's an issue to the dating of Galatians. I'm going to hit a few kind of key points here. Galatians is a lightning of Pauline scholarship because everybody does accept it as Paul. And because it was very much a part of the Bauer synthesis, Galatians remains kind of very front and center in Pauline studies. And it should. It's a very important book. I would say that we need to bring in more of Paul than just Galatians, but there's at least that. One of the issues has to do with the dating and location of Galatians. If you looked at a map of Asia Minor, there's an issue as to whether, let's see, I'm horrible at drawing maps, but let's say here's Greece, there's the Peloponnese. You can see why I'm a cartographer here, right? And then you come across and here's Asia Minor and then you're into Palestine, et cetera. Well, the issue is whether Galatia is, there's a northern part of Galatia and a southern part of Galatia. Now if you remember Paul's first missionary journey, there's also Lil Island here in Cyprus. Paul goes here up into southern Galatia, comes back out and returns home. That's the first missionary journey of the Apostle Paul. He doesn't make it up into northern Galatia in that journey. One of the issues on dating the book of Galatians is, which part of Galatia was it written to? The northern Galatians are the southern Galatians. And another ramification of that has to do with the degree to which Galatians corresponds to the Book of Acts chapter 15. Acts 15, you know, I mention it now multiple times, the Jerusalem Council, where there is ultimately an agreement about circumcision and Gentiles don't have to be circumcised. Yet in the Book of Galatians, Paul is on about Gentiles not having to be circumcised. And he doesn't simply mention as you would think would be possible, hey we decided this back in Jerusalem. So on that basis, many evangelical scholars especially would date the Book of Galatians to the time in or after his first missionary journey before the Jerusalem Council. So he's writing Galatians before Acts 15. In which case he must be written to the southern Galatians. In other words, it must be Paul's first book before he writes anything else because he hasn't visited church elsewhere. Corinth, Ephesus, Philippi, he's not ever been there. So it's his first book. Whereas if you hold a northern Galatian point of view, then you inevitably are saying that the Book was written to the Galatians, the northern Galatians church after the Jerusalem Council. Now again, I'm simplifying somewhat. You could still hold that he was writing to the southern Galatians later in his ministry. But usually if somebody mentions the southern Galatian theory, what they are saying is it was written to this group of churches here before Acts 15. And then that provides a means of synthesizing Acts 15 with Galatians. Galatians, Paul has to get really harsh on the issue of circumcision because it's not yet been decided officially by the church. Then it's decided officially by the church. And although it crops up again in Paul's ministry, it doesn't crop up with the same fervor in his other letters. So one possibility is to date and locate Galatians in South Galatia prior to his ministry to the other churches and prior to the Acts Council. The last thing, I'm going to leave the question of the prevailing purpose of Galatians and just move to Romans for half a second because I want to illustrate, I'm just cruising here. I want to illustrate basically one thing by looking at Romans. And that is the danger of asking the question, what is the purpose of the book? It's a dangerous question because of the word the and because the singular nature of the word purpose, what is the purpose of the book? There have been a lot of debates over the last hundred years about the purpose of the book of Romans. And basically over the last hundred years, this is the shift that has gone on. Chapters one through five, as you see on your hand out there, are principally about salvation, especially justification. And so coming out of the Protestant Reformation, what is Romans about? Justification by faith alone. So what's the key section of the book of Romans? Chapters one through five. Well, as we move into the 20th century, people started saying, well, you know, he didn't stop with chapter five. So clearly he was on about something else. So some people suggested, well, he was concerned really about them understanding justification by faith alone, but then living out a life that is brings glory to Christ, especially by dying to sin and being a slave of Christ, in chapter six, especially six through eight. So what is what is a Romans about? I think I say Galatians and Romans. Anyway, I mean Romans, if I ever say Galatians, no, I mean Romans, all right? Romans six through eight. Well, still that stops short. I mean, there's a whole not that we're only halfway through the book of Romans then. Some people, especially coming out of the discussion of Judaism, which arose in part because of the Holocaust, have said, no, you know, what really matters is chapters nine through eleven because Paul is trying to wrestle through. Why is it that not all of Israel will be saved? Why is it that, well, he says all Israel will be saved? But why is it that not every individual within Israel seems to be following the law, following Christ? Why is it that Jewish people are flocking to Christ? Chapters nine through eleven. That's what he's concerned about. Finally, some people have most recently argued, well, no, what he's really interested in is the end of the book, where he's talking about relationships between Jew and Gentile, and he's trying to bring this kind of sense of unity of Jew and Gentile in the church. One last option is that in what he's really after is a ticket to Spain, because if you know the end of the book of Romans, what he's after what he's talking about is, you know, hear my plans, I want to go into Spain, please receive me and send me on. So what's the purpose of the book of Romans? Is he really, is there a ticket to Spain? Is he really interested in Jew and Gentile relationships? Or is it primarily justification by faith? You want a suggestion, it's not new with me, but it's fairly radical. Maybe he's interested in all of that. And by trying to ask the question is what is the purpose, we have unduly constrained the various purposes that he may have in writing the book. So be careful when you ask that question, and be much more inductive to let Paul tell you what his purposes are in terms of what he covers. Now, if you turn to the last page of your handout, this page is very important to me, which means it should be very important to you, because you should know this page like the back of your hand. Because what I have basically argued up to now is there is a diversity within Paul, and the diversity comes because each letter is written to a particular issue or set of issues that are going on in the church to whom he is writing. So it's very important that when you read the book of Ephesians, or let's say Philippians, that you understand why he's writing the book as a whole before you try and interpret each and every passage in the book. Therefore, I want you to know the diversity of occasions, the things that are called forth the books, and therefore the diversity of purposes for which these are written. And I can guarantee you that there are at least three or four multiple choice questions on the test, just to show you how much I care about this, from this list. And they will say something like, you know, which a letter of Paul bears some cautions against a dangerous hybrid religious philosophy but largely contains general encouragement and Christian living. And you say cautions, you know, and that will be your answer. Because I want you to understand the diversity of the letters that are possible. Suddenly, people are getting excited, they feel that the end is approaching. The end is near, all right? We got two things that I want to do in the last few minutes. One is eventually, I need you guys to fill out some course evaluations, so we'll get to that. But before we get there, I want to try and bring this course together in about five or six minutes. We've covered a whole range of topics. And again, as I mentioned the very first day of class, I'm assuming you guys have read the New Testament before many, many times, so that you know in general the contents of the New Testament. If you don't, this is the wrong class. This class is not about it. It's not a content course. Really what I'm trying to do is frame the ways that we approach Scripture. And especially I want you to approach Scripture, certainly interested in individual interpretations of passages. And with some confidence that you can do that, even in light of your pre-understanding, remember some of the hermeneutical issues that we talked about. But I also want to help you frame Scripture in two major ways in terms of the history that we find in Scripture and in terms of the theology that we find in Scripture. So I've repeated here some of the course objectives, and you can see that these were some of the purposes and goals that I had here. I want to end with two concluding questions. Why is it important to study the New Testament through the lens of history? Well, first of all, because it purports to discuss history, the book of Acts talks about the history of the church. The Gospels talk about the history of Jesus the Messiah. Paul talks to particular historical circumstances. When he's writing the people in Corinth, he's interested in the issues in Corinth, and they're historical issues, and so we need to see that he's writing to historical events. Another reason, aside from the fact that they purport to be historical books, is that if the history is untrue, then our faith is useless. That's Paul's argument in 1 Corinthians 15 with regard to the resurrection. If the resurrection is not a true historical event, then we're wasting our time in this room. So we need to understand it as representing real history. Another reason that you need to understand the New Testament through the lens of history is that it then allows us to interpret scripture correctly. So you'll remember my diagram, author, body, and the background in which they wrote, and the Old Testament that they drew on, and the teachings of Jesus that they drew on explicitly, and how all of this is under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, and of course we then apply this to us today in our own cultural framework. So we need first of all to understand the New Testament historically in terms of the questions that were being framed in the time of Paul and Jesus, et cetera, itself. Paul addresses the issue of circumcision. It's because it was a real issue in the first century. When Paul in the book of Ephesians, at the very end, talks about relationships between fathers and husbands and wives, fathers and children, slaves and masters, there's a reason that those three things are all in place. Because in the ancient Eukas, in the ancient house, you had fathers and fathers and children, and you had slaves in the house. And so we need to understand all of that in terms of its first century reference, because for us slavery was a horrible, socio-economic thing that had to do with the marketplace, but in the ancient world it was a widely accepted way of conducting your household. And so you need to understand Ephesians from that land and judge it in those bases and understand what he's saying on those bases. When he talks about in the beginning of the book of Ephesians, the predestination of God, the predestining hand of God, we need to understand that when he brings up predestination he's bringing it up in a context where remember the Pharisees, the Sadducees, and the Essenes all disagreed on this issue. So it was a live issue within Judaism, it was a live issue within Greco-Roman context because the Stoics disagreed with the Epicureans on this. And when we understand it in that frame, then we're trying to see what Paul is saying in his first century context about predestination instead of immediately applied to the 21st century. So one other reason we need to understand the New Testament through the lens of history is that it helps us interpret it correctly. So there's some rationale for seeing through the lens of history. First of all they are historical books and they report to report history. Secondly, if that history is false, then our faith is useless. Third, in order to interpret them correctly, we need to understand the historical situations that they themselves are addressing before we apply it to our particular cultural context today. So at least three reasons for that. Next question. Why is it important to engage in the activity of New Testament theology? Because in seeing the diversity of infacies in the different authors, we can expand our horizons theologically. And because in seeing the synthesis and the unity that's in the New Testament, we can understand what the church fundamentally needs to care about in terms of its theology. So the diversity of infacies adds to our sense of theology, the New Testament, and then we can synthesize it and come back to a kind of a sense of the core of New Testament of theology. And then there's a third reason, which is if we inductively approach the New Testament and ask what are the theological purposes going on here? Then we recognize that there might be areas that our own theology is lacking. I made this point several weeks ago when I talked about the resurrection and how in most systematic theology, western systematic theology, that the resurrection of Jesus gets just a handful of pages. And yet it was obviously much more important than that in the New Testament itself. And if we inductively approach it instead of taking our systematic theology and always approach the New Testament as proof texts for the theology we already have, if we go to the New Testament itself and allow the theology that it presents to bubble to the surface, we will find our own systematic theology confirmed, but also I hope expanded. And that's what I would suggest is another help to doing New Testament theology. So at least three reasons. The diversity helps us test more our theology. The synthesis helps us develop a core. And by inductively approaching the New Testament point three, we can again test our own systematic synthesis that we've been working with for hundreds of years. Now as a approach to that, the very end of this lecture was basically to say that if you look at the cross in New Testament writers you'll see a diversity of infacies. So you'll see some works will emphasize the justification as Paul does that comes from the cross. If you approach the gospels themselves they'll talk of the cross and Jesus's blood poured out to create a covenant. So it's a much more covenantal discussion right there. If you look at John, the gospel of John, one of the things that comes out of the gospel of John is that Jesus's glory is when he's lifted up, his very suffering on the cross is glory to Jesus and through that he draws all men to himself. So you see these kind of different infacies that go on obviously they all cohere very well but they're different infacies. If you approach the book of Hebrews you see that Jesus becomes a high priest who presents himself as an offering. Well that's another picture of looking at the cross. And of course you guys have studied first Peter and some of the diversity there. However, while we can see distinct infacies we can also see synthesis across the variety of New Testament authors that we can synthesize at the end. And I give you four propositions there that Jesus's death produces salvation and that's given a variety of pictures throughout the New Testament whether it be the priest presenting himself as an offering and Hebrews or justification as in Paul etc. It has self-effic importance. It provides an example to us. Again I'm reading through your first Peter papers and most of you have very well seen in first Peter that the cross of Jesus provides us an example in suffering so that we as Christians are willing to endure suffering. Well therefore the cross has exemplary force to us. And you see that as well in Jesus when he talks about in Mark 1045 this sense that Christians should not exalt themselves over others but should be humble because even the son of man did not come to serve to be served but to serve. So his death focuses as an example for others. Jesus's death is inseparable from his resurrection and it's also inseparable from his person. He is the son of God who comes to die. He is God incarnate who comes to die and that's why his death is particularly important. So what I'm trying to illustrate there although it's done very briefly is there's a diversity and yet there's a synthetic unity to the New Testament in terms of theology. And that's what we should expect when we study the New Testament from a theological viewpoint. That was quick but there's some sense of kind of where I wanted us to go. That you see you need to view the New Testament through the lens of history that you also need to understand the New Testament as theological and the distinct infacies within the different authors and yet the ultimate synthesis that comes throughout it. And if you if you've got that that's basically what I really wanted you to get out of the course.