Father, we thank you for this time we have together. And as we think about the influence of your word and your spirit and your people upon society, now we pray for your wisdom and for your understanding. We ask that in Jesus' name, Amen. We have been looking at what shape a regarded as various examples of accommodation. And the one we spent our time on last session was on what we called slipping morality. And then I think we had a helpful discussion about two kinds of problems, the one where where we regard the present culture as our authority in moral issues. And the other in Ancita Rebeta's question where we regard the traditional culture as being equivalent to biblical teaching and become subject to the authority of traditional culture rather than the authority of scripture itself. But today I want to move on to the next point, which I think is point number 12. We'll make this our last one. This is getting rather too long here in these number of points. But point number 12 is what I've called the devaluation of reformation influence and Christian influence in general on the culture. That is really the denial that Christians have had any serious impact on the law, the moral
values, the institutions of Western culture. On page 384 of that's of volume 4 and shape is complete works, Christian view of the church
in the great evangelical disaster, shape deals with this issue. He's speaking about the influence of the reformation on European and Western society in general and then the influence of the reformation heritage on the founding of the United States
and in other ways on the political and social structures of various Western European and American and so on cultures. And Shaper writes this, there are those with any evangelical circles today who would under the guise of scholarship, but little all of this, an act as though the Christian consensus was always in a total model. Just how far this can be taken may be shown by the example of one Christian historian who carries the model all the way back to the reformation itself. He writes, Shaper's confusion rests on his inability to see Protestantism as the religious form of Renaissance humanism. To be short Protestant said that their consciences were informed by the Bible, on which authority alone rested, solar scripturia, yet we all know of Protestant inability to agree on what the Bible said or even on what kind of a book it is. In his triumphalism Shaper cannot see the ironic and tragic in the Protestant movement because he refuses to see it as an aspect of the humanist movement itself. In his various works Shaper repeatedly invokes the reformation as the answer to the problem of humanism, when in reality it is part of the problem. Now Shaper then goes on to comment on this issue, but it's obvious from if you read how should
we then left for example or see the films or if you read Shaper's Christian manifesto, he was very profoundly convinced that Protestant Christianity had had an enormous impact on the life of Western Europe and on the life of the United States and on the development of its political and cultural institutions. How Shaper gives this one example here of the devaluation of this notion, but that is that kind of devaluation or attack on the notion of any kind of Christian influence on Western culture is one that one will find repeatedly. I remember reading a review of how should we then live series written by Jack Rogers from Fuller Seminary in which he attacked this idea very very strongly that the reformation had had this kind of profound impact on Western society that Shaper suggested. But it's a criticism that you'll find very often made. Now it's important, it becomes particularly important in the discussion at the moment that's
going on in the United States about the political structures and the moral values of this culture.
But I want to just make some points here about what Shaper was saying. But first of all, Shaper was not arguing that there was a golden age either after the reformation in Western Europe in say Switzerland or Holland or Scotland or England or Germany. He was not arguing that there was a golden age, nor was he arguing that there was a golden age at the time of the American Revolution, the Declaration of Independence, etc. When Shaper writes about the reformation or speaks about the reformation, he readily acknowledges mistakes that the reform is made. For example, of their tying state and shirt to closely together of Luther's attitude to the peasants revolt where he encouraged the nobles to smite, stab, and slay the peasants and also of their failure to take up the challenge of missions beyond Europe. And you could find other points as well where Shaper points out some of the inadequacies of the reformation. So Shaper wasn't arguing that there was some a perfectly Christian past or that where Christians have influenced society, that everything they did was good or that they really created a culture which one could call completely Christian. So that's the first point. The second was, is this, that Shaper was not arguing either but all people or even the great majority of people were at one time real Christians, either in Western Europe after reformation or in the United States and its founding. Rather, what he was arguing was that there was at one time a consensus of opinion in say Switzerland or Holland or England or the United States at its founding a consensus of opinion which was shaped by a biblical world view. And I want to make several points here that are fundamental to that biblical world view which affect the nature of a society. One would be that there is indeed a God in heaven, a God who exists to whom we are answerable. Secondly, that we live in a created universe, a world made by the divine being with an order to it and structure which can be examined and understood. Thirdly, that there is a moral order in this universe, a moral order which finds its source in God, and good stands over against evil. There is what Shaper would call antithesis, that is, that truth stood over against falsehood. And again, this notion of antithesis found its source in God. Fifthly, that there is a morally accountable human race, but there were absolute distinctions between good and bad behavior,
a morally accountable humanity with distinctions between good and bad behavior, and between innocence and guilt, that there was such a thing as objective guilt before God.
Seven or six, sorry, six, that all human beings stand on level ground before God made by him in his likeness. And seven, that people or human beings are sinners and need restraints on their sin. Though those seven points and one could add others to them, but those are fundamental, those were the consensus of opinion in Western Europe after reformation and in North America at its founding as a nation. It's not that everyone was Christians, that's not the point. But the great, the vast majority of people held these views.
Now, holding those views and holding them not as religious truth over here, in the way that people might do today, but holding them as the truth about what is and who we are, had a very profound effect upon the kind of societies which developed. And let me make several points here. What did these give? This consensus of opinion give. It gave several things which are tremendous blessing to the human race. The first is the notion of a rule of law. That is that there is a law given by God which rules all human beings and every human society. That is very important because much of the human race has been ruled by the notion of might as right. But whoever is in power is the law. Wherever biblical Christianity has had any influence on a culture, it has given this gift that there is a rule of law which comes from God himself which stands over all people. A second consequence of this is therefore accountability, the accountability of those who govern. That is they stand under the law too, just like the peasant, the peasant and the prince, the peasant and the president, the ordinary man and woman in the street and those in Congress stand equally under the law. They are accountable to God, they are accountable to the law. Indeed that they are accountable to the governed as well. Thirdly the notion of truth that there is truth which can be found which ought to govern a society and its people and every discipline
that because this is a created universe it can be examined and understood. That is again that truth can be found. This is God's world, we can study it and examine it. In other words this is the foundation for science. We might say and science hasn't developed in all cultures because many cultures do not have a notion of an objectively existing created order which has a rational structure to it which man can understand but where Christianity has shaped the consensus there is that confidence that truth can be found that there is a world that can be examined and understood. This Christian consensus or Judeo-Christian consensus has within it a democratic impulse that is if all people are significant before God and stand on a level plain before him then all people ought to have some say in their government as I said before those who govern are accountable not only to the law but they are accountable to those who govern them. I mean they are rather accountable to those who are governed. So there is a democratic impulse within a biblical understanding of the human person. Well I got to number five. Okay, five. Another consequence of this view is the notion of restraint on those in power because there is the recognition that everybody is sinful there is also the recognition that power corrupts people and therefore there have to be restraints on human authorities that only God's authority is absolute all human authority is derived accountable to him accountable to the people and because of the sinful tendency of the heart power will corrupt people and then must therefore be checks and balances separation of powers restraints on those in power however we want to express it and then sixth again the notion of objective guilt of human responsibility that people are accountable for what they do before God before the society before one another and there is objective guilt which can be punished which ought to be punished.
Now there are many other things one could say as well but these are some of the fundamental gifts one might say of a Judeo-Christian worldview to a culture and this is really what Shaefer is arguing that there was after reformation there was in northern Europe in northern America at the time of its founding a consensus of opinion shaped by a biblical worldview which deeply affected the institutions and understanding of the society thirdly this is coming to back to the things with main points here first he wasn't arguing there was a golden age secondly he wasn't arguing that all people were Christians thirdly Shaefer was not arguing either but all the fenders of the USA of its constitution of its declaration were personal Christians he knew very well that some of them were deists and rationalists but even though they were deists and rationalists some of them not all of them because some were Christians they were indeed shaped in their thinking too by a Christian worldview
when you look back at people like Thomas Jefferson for example it is important if you say this man was a deist or this man was a rationalist it is important not to that regard him as a 20th century rationalist a 20th century rationalist in 1990 doesn't believe that there is truth to be found doesn't believe there is a moral law in the universe does not believe in sin Jefferson was not a 20th century man he was not a Christian but he wasn't a 20th century man his understanding too of the world was shaped by a Christian worldview and profoundly believed that there was truth to be found that there is a moral law in the universe that there is sin which needs restraint etc in addition as there to their own thinking being shaped by a Christian worldview these men recognize the consensus around them that it was Judeo-Christian and appealed to it and as Oz made this point over and over again in his lectures this past weekend they understood that this republic would only flourish and endure with it with a religious underpinning with the underpinning of that Judeo-Christian worldview and morality now that's important because when you look at somebody like Jefferson and you say this person was a a deist or this person was a rationalist don't understand them in a 20th century context point number four it was the loss of this consensus the Judeo-Christian consensus that made shape was so concerned for the future of this nation and the future of Western Europe he pointed out over and over again that what remains now in our culture is the notion of freedom but just of what he called merely freedom or bear freedom freedom without any definition of what it means freedom without a sense of moral obligation or moral accountability to God and one's fellow human beings but now we have the pursuit of freedom for its own sake shape a felt if you've seen how should we then live you'll see how he makes this point very strongly in episodes 9 and 10 that it is this belief or pursuit of merely freedom which he regarded as the hammer blow which will destroy this culture at freedom without responsibility freedom without a sense of moral obligation
is totally destructive to a culture what it creates is a society which has to have more and more government to control it and we see that all around us because you have to replace people's sense of obligation people's sense of responsibility to God to one another to the society with more and more rules and laws and more and more government officials in every controlling every sphere of life and the more just excessive freedom you get the more power has to be given to those in authority
Germany in 19 the night early 1930s creates gives us a very instructive example of a society which had become extremely decadent which pursued freedom without any kind of form and the reaction to that was Hitler a man is seen as one who would provide that structure which was missing within a society so shafa was very afraid about the future on the basis of the loss of consensus now he wasn't a pessimist because he believed that there was a sufficient we might say interest in the economic sense a sufficient incest interest rather a sufficient interest from the Julia Christian consensus of the past to appeal to in people and to work on as a basis on which to call people back to that consensus and to the gifts that it gave that brings me to point number five why is this important why is it important why was shafa so concerned about the denial by Christians of any positive influence from the Reformation or of any positive influence of Christians at any point in our past on the development of this culture why did he think it mattered I think there are several reasons here as I thought about this one is that it undercuts the need for Christian involvement today if you suggest that Christians in the past have had no influence it seems to devalue the importance of Christians seeking to have some influence today if we may help more of the consensus they had no influence what chance do we have and one might say more fundamentally secondly it appears to deny this you appears that deny that God has been active in history at least in the lives of nations since the New Testament era it appears to suggest that even when there were many Christians that God was not able to enable them to be any impact any salt and light in the society in which they lived so it seems to remove God from the arena of society thirdly
such of you appears to accept a sacred secular division that the concern of Christians is only for some narrow sacred realm rather than that we have a calling to influence the culture in which we live wherever we live at any moment in history and related to that fourthly it appears to suggest that there is different truth in different areas again that Christian truth is something which only affects the individual as a person rather than something which affects the lives of nations social structures political structures economies law etc when should note incidentally that a great many non-Christian historians don't hesitate to acknowledge that Christianity had a huge impact on the development of this particular culture I always remember reading a book a fascinating book by Jeremy Rifkin who was one of the radicals in the 60s it's called the emerging order God in the age of scarcity so written a book written in the 70s in which he though he is not a Christian he looked back at the history of the United States and saw that at every point of crisis in this society there had been an evangelical revival which had been the impetus for the radical transformations that came about to really shape this culture and he was looking at evangelical Christianity today as the only source of hope for providing a basis for dealing with environmental problems the problem of the environment in which we live because Christianity has within it fundamentally a notion of human beings as God's stewards stewards of this creation rather than simply as exploiters of the world in which we live and again this is a non-Christian writing but you would find in many many different contexts the acknowledgement of Christian influence on the development of this particular culture or the culture of Western Europe but does anyone have any questions here at all I've got through quite a bit of material there and there's some very important points in all this but this is one of the areas where where Schaeffer is thinking is particularly under attack at the moment yeah one he was not arguing there was a golden age those ones you mean yes one Schaeffer was not arguing that there was some Christian golden age either at their affirmation or at some point in America's past he was ready to acknowledge the mistakes that were made the lack of consistency at all sorts of points secondly he was not arguing that all people were Christians individually are you born again but that there was a consensus for opinion which was shaped by biblical world view and then all the points under that thirdly he wasn't arguing that all the founders of this nation were individually Christians he recognized some were deists and rationalists but would have said they were shaped by the Christian world view they went 20th century rationalists fourthly the loss of this consensus this Christian consensus or Judeo-Christian consensus was what made him very concerned for the future of this nation and of Western Europe incidentally souls in it's in makes exactly the same point if you read his Harvard address from several years ago now I've had copies of that if you're interested I handed out one of my classes last semester he makes exactly the same point about about the understanding of freedom and the loss of a sense of obligation in our culture and he argues very strongly that that sense of obligation before God this is souls in it's in now is what shaped the whole development of of Western democracies and fifthly why why is this important this whole whole notion that that Shaefer where Shaefer suggests that Christians that indeed influence the development yeah thank
the questions is there indeed enough of a consensus to stop the society breaking down that's a very difficult question to answer but I would say there's enough of a consensus to appeal to people still if you consider Oz's lectures this weekend and the work he did on the William Spock Charter he attempted there to contact Protestants Roman Catholics Jews Muslims humanists people right across the board religiously to come to the defense of the religious liberty clause and the way he did that work if you look at the William Spock Charter it carries with it the notion of respect for other people and the sense of obligation to other people as well as to oneself he's just this week he's actually had a non-Christian college dealing with this issue and it is a very serious problem you've probably read articles in the press about what's called the sensitivity issue on college campuses how people on the left have presented people prevented people on the right from speaking they say what you're saying if you're from the right is offensive to minorities it's offensive to women it's offensive to this group it's offensive to that group therefore you're not allowed to say anything and this is created a real problem and a couple of universities here in the states who recognize that they have lost the freedom of speech because of this because of this such a concern for sensitivity that then you end up nobody's end up able to end up saying anything controversial at all but it it is it is a kind of tyranny actually which prevents anybody saying anything not that people shouldn't be sensitive of course they should and you know when you look at some of the some of the we won't mention any names but you look at some of the adverts in the political race a few weeks back and some of them were absolutely shameful in terms of appearing unashamedly to racist tendencies in people when it came up to the election so sensitivity is important yes but sensitivity must not be used to deny the freedom of speech and ours was invited by a couple of college presidents and that's where he is this week giving lectures on this issue and the president one of the colleges wrote to every member of the faculty administration the whole student body and personally invited them encouraged them very strongly to come and hear him because he recognizes that something very profound is happening once you lose freedom of speech in a culture and to and hopefully that will be enough of a consensus there to appeal to if you can help people to see what they're doing and have precious the notion of both freedom of religious expression is and freedom of and freedom of speech in a society you know I think there is still something there to appeal to but it's getting less and less that is the problem that's why very carefully use the expression that you could say if you like you've got capital the capital would be those judo question notions of who God is who we are the reality of sin the existence of truth of good and evil etc etc that's the capital the interest if you like is is the points that that gives there is a rule of law or that you need checks and balances you need restraints on those in power those are the interest which comes from the capital of a Christian consensus now I think we would have to say where probably the majority of the people are concerned or perhaps the majority I mean it's difficult to know figures that the capital has gone
what you're left with is the interest most people if you push them would say they still believe in a rule of law though actually there's a real tension and we talked about this in Christian responsibility in society if you talk to the average American men and women you will get double answers here you get ambiguous answers if you ask them about this they would probably give a mixture of answers depending on what question you ask them if you ask them certain questions they might say or what is basic in our society is the freedom of the individual to choose that is that law comes from the individual person if you ask them different kinds of questions they might say well it's really a question of democracy and by democracy they would understand what the majority think so we ought to have a referendum on it we ought to it ought to be on our ballots what are the majority the people think what is the consensus do they think the homosexuality is right or do they think it's wrong do they think this is right or do they think that is wrong and so you would get people appealing both to both to the freedom of the individual and to the majority opinion as their basis for law but if you ask them other questions if you push them a little bit you would find most Americans would still say that a rule of law is necessary that there really are objective moral standards and legal standards which ought to govern everybody from the president down to to the person on the street I would say we are in a situation where these two views the one which is based on the human person as the source of law the other as God is the source of law even at the level of interest are never might at the level of capital are in real conflict with each other but I think most people if you help them to see what that leads to will opt for this even without a basis for it the same of in other areas it would be more obvious if you started talking about restraints on power because power corrupts because people are sinful if you worded it rightly you would get everybody to agree with you almost immediately while people might say in theory that people are really basically good that there is no real problem of evil when you started talking about those in power everybody recognizes so clearly that power corrupts people and that there are all sorts of of greedy tendencies in some in members of our government you would get them to acknowledge with no problem at all that they need to be restraints on those in power so again there is something to appeal to but your question is a very important one because what we we really have to realize is that not only is the capital going in more and more people but in lots and lots of people some of the interest is going to or it's been cut off from its source and the work that we have to do as Christians is severalfold one is appealing to people about these gifts which have come from a Judeo-Christian world view helping people to see their importance the second is rebuilding the foundation at the level of persuasion of really teaching people in our society what is true and pointing out that this is where this is where these come from that it is some that Judeo-Christian world view that these notions arise that's a very good question the question is well where what was Oz's position in particular on the Williamsburg Charter well he was the director of it basically I've forgotten what his title was but he is the person who worked full time with others on its production a maneuver it's really something that he gave three years of his life too now you've raised some very important questions one of the things they were trying to do and they are developing educational programs which are being taken up by many different states one of them is to get people to recognize and to get it to be recognized in the public school curriculum that Christianity did indeed have a profound influence on the development of this culture because that is something that has been denied there are many textbooks which have been written for school children which have left Christianity out completely it was partly because some of the publishers and I was pointed this out we're afraid of being taken to court by the American Civil Liberties Union or other groups who don't have much interest in defending the influence of Christianity on this society but there was a patch of of several decades where Christianity wasn't mentioned at all in terms of the development of the institutions of the moral values of the legal structure of this society and one of the effects of the Williamsburg Charter work is to get that reverse to get people to acknowledge that this was indeed a historical reality regardless of what they think about Christianity that this was a historical reality the second element is this does the does the fact that the Williamsburg Charter or Osprey example or these school curriculums speak about different religions does this mean relativism does this mean the denial that there is truth or what and Osprey to that would be know that it's not a question of relativism at all it's just simply a question of acknowledging that we live in a pluralist society he gave the example you would go to you can go to some schools where there will be he gave Los Angeles as an example where there may be 90 different religious positions represented in the student body and evangelical Christianity may be a minority of those do we really believe in the separation of church and state do we think that on those children in the public school system they should all be taught Christianity not just that Christianity influenced the development of this culture or should there be a recognition that in the student body and in the population as a whole there are indeed different religious positions and that it's not the school's business to teach the Christian faith or the Islamic faith or humanism or Buddhism or Judaism or whatever else Osprey made one illustration he said you take a fundamentalist for example from Louisiana who may be protesting a bad public education in the fact that his children are not being taught Christianity in the public schools if he moved to Utah his tune will change very rapidly because he doesn't want his children taught Mormonism in the public schools he will suddenly recognize that the separation of church and state and the removal of religion from the curriculum in terms of a religious perspective being taught as the truth which will have to reflect the attitude of let's say in that case the majority of the parents in the area and if their majority of them are Mormon what do you do for the evangelical child who's there why should they be or what's important is to listen to to Jewish people as well they don't want a Christian position taught in the public schools they would argue this is the response of the pet the responsibility of parents to teach their children Christianity or Judaism or Mormonism or whatever now that issue doesn't touch the question of what is true the question is simply is it the place of the public schools to be teaching in a pluralist society which we have to acknowledge as pluralist a particular conviction about who God is who Christ is who we are what our dilemma is and what the resolution to that is and I would say from the British situation one of the reasons for the great strength of American Christianity is the fact that that has not been seen to be the responsibility of the schools because in England where I come from where the church is a tiny minority where we had an established church we had and still have compulsory religious education in every state school but it is it is worse than useless it had the effect of inoculating all the children against Christianity that was one of its consequences the reason for that it was simply this that the most of the people who taught it were not personally Christians consequently what they taught had absolutely no conviction I remember all the way through school I regarded as I well I'm an I grew up in a non-Christian family I regarded as the most boring lesson of the week everybody did we hated having to take it we all resented it and it had the effect of us making us want never to think about the Bible or anything to do with Christianity it was profoundly unhelpful oh we may lament the fact that we're no longer living in a situation where Christianity is the consensus for the great majority of people and we may lament that we ought to lament that but we need to come to terms with the fact that we are actually living in a pluralist society and acknowledging that is not the same as relativism being tolerant of other people's convictions is not the same as saying that they are true so I must recognize for example that there are people on my street ad in Bolwin who are Jewish people there are people who are Roman Catholics there are people who are humanists there are people who are into the new age there are people with all sorts of different convictions there are probably people who are Muslims should I not tolerate the fact that they are there or their convictions of course I must and I think there is something very fundamental here in terms of the nature of biblical Christianity itself where God Himself respects human significance and God Himself does not force people to be believers he reasons with them he seeks to persuade us and to convince us of what is true and that is our challenge and it is a real challenge before us living in a pluralist society but I think the last thing we want I would say in America is Christianity being taught in your public school system again sometimes you would have Christians who were teaching it and I remember one Christian who taught religion when I was in school in England and his classes were different from the else's but he was one among about 30 that I had during my years in school and only one that that really made any sense I know I could see really had some convictions about what he was teaching but what has happened in England today is that the religious instruction has been forced to come to terms with the pluralistic nature of British society and what is taught now is comparative religion but nothing is true and again that one doesn't want that either it's best to take it completely out of the public school situation and say it's the responsibility of parents to raise their children to know what is true to love God and to serve him and it's the responsibility of Christians to seek to persuade other people, children and adults in the society that Christianity is true but it isn't the responsibility of the schools but I know it's a very touchy issue here and it's a very difficult one but I would certainly say from the British perspective don't hark to the answer that what we need is publicly legislated Christianity in the school system it won't help it will actually make the task evangelism much more difficult because people become hardened that's that certainly been the effect in Britain and you always have to to kind of take that into account when you're talking to somebody here is somebody who has a perception of Christianity shaped by what they heard in school and somehow I've got to get through that and behind that and get back to the issue of what is true that I'm not talking about something religious I'm talking about truth I'm not talking about something which is imposed on people against their will I'm talking about something which which by its truthfulness by its power by the beauty of its life demands attention but there are a lot there I mean there's some very big questions