<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bantu Bantu Bulanan

Living Before God in All Life

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Now, we were speaking in our last class about the need to keep a unity of thought. And this is clearly one of the central emphases of all of shapeist ministry. One might term it an insistence on living before God in all of life, rather than having this kind of split view of reality. That insistence on living before God in all of life obviously affected him on a personal level, the way Libre was set up, the way as a ministry was based on prayer and dependence on God. And it also affected the way he tried to think about every issue which arose. And today, what I want to do is to look at what he had to say about the issue of the environment, that ecology, about pollution. He wrote his little book, Pollution and the Death of Man in 1970, quite a long time before most Christians even began to think about the issue. In fact, before there was a great deal of thinking about it in the general culture. And this I think was simply just an illustration of his desire to really live under the word of God in every area of understanding. The way Libre was structured, people were free to raise any question at all, nothing was off limits. And so people could come, for example, and raise questions about the environment and the Christians' attitude to the environment and not expect to be dismissed out of hand. I would say even today with this issue of the environment, the response of most Christians is still to simply dismiss the issue because it's raised by people on the left wing politically or people who are liberal in their understanding. And today, in particular, it's dismissed by many Christians because the people who raise it are, quote, new age people very often. I know a pastor, for example, who got an enormous trouble because he was a member of the Sierra Club and Greenpeace. And these were both environmental organizations, and of course many of their members are touched by new age ideas. But he got into enormous stress, created tremendous difficulty in his congregation, which is a fairly open congregation as congregations go, simply because of this. And I think we really need to learn a lesson from Schaeffer at this point because it isn't enough to ask who else is saying this, therefore I won't think about it, or to condemn something by association, but to rather try to examine the issue itself and ask what does Scripture have to say about it, which is what he attempted to do with this issue of the environment, to ask what does Scripture say because Scripture speaks to every area of life. What was interesting, I think, when one reads pollution in the death of man, is that Schaeffer recognized already then in 1970, before the term new age had become popular, or before again most Christians were aware that there was a growing influence of Eastern thought. And some of the people who were trying to resolve the problems of the environment were appealing to pantheism as the resolution to the problem, and criticizing Christianity as the cause of the problem. For example, he, the two people he writes about in particular in the book, one is Lin White, the other is Richard Means, and both of them really see Orthodox Christianity as the reason for the destruction done to nature, done to the earth. They feel that it is the biblical teaching that man has dominion over nature which gives rise to the destruction of the environment. One of them, for example, writes, this is Lin White in the appendix, because Schaeffer quoted his hol article in the appendix, a pollution in the death of man, he writes this, in antiquity, every tree, every spring, every stream, every hill, had its own genius loci, its guardian spirit. These spirits were accessible to men, but were very unlike men, sent toars, fawns, and mermaids, show their ambivalence. Before one cut a tree, mind, demands, and or damned a brook, it was important to placate the spirit in charge of that particular situation to keep it placated. By destroying pagan animism, Christianity made it possible to exploit nature in a mood of indifference to the feelings of natural objects. White suggests that all pagan religion has at its heart a kind of unity of man with nature and invests nature with a kind of spiritual reality and power, and that this set a limit on the exploitation of nature. Christianity in denancing that pagan animism, he said, really opened the door to the destruction of the environment. There are all kinds of things when one could say in response to that, but I think one of the things that one needs to recognize, and it isn't usually recognized by people who put forward this point of view, because it's often put forward, is that that kind of animism actually prevents any kind of development at all. I think I've spoken to you before about a friend of mine who works in Kenya, and he is working among people who will never do anything differently, because they are terrified of offending the spirits of the trees, of the grand, of the water, of their ancestors, and so on. They are banned in total subjection, if you like, to nature. They have no understanding at all of the possibility of dominion over nature in any sense, or the improvement of the human condition. But this notion that Christianity is the source of our environmental problems is a very widespread one, and when Schaefer picked on this, or pointed this out, in 1970, it was before that criticism was being very widely made, but now you will find it made everywhere, if you read New Age literature, for example, that criticism is made over and over again. You remember I mentioned in a different context the other week in apologetics, some friends of mine who went to a conference on the environment at Middlebury College, at which the Dalai Lama, among other people, was speaking, and the Christian representative there turned out to be a feminist deconstructionist, theologian, and where everybody else, the Muslim, the Dalai Lama, the Hindu, and so on, disclaimed any responsibility for the environmental crisis, and suggested some ways forward, the feminist deconstruct, the Christian representative, a simply claimed responsibility, and said it was precisely because Christianity had proclaimed a God who was transcendent over nature, that the door had been open to the destruction of the environment by human beings. Christianity then went on to say that in order to have any kind of answer to the environmental problems, Christianity needed to change its metaphors, and notice she said metaphors, not its truth, because she doesn't believe that, but even that traditional understanding of God was true in any sense, but it was an unhelpful metaphor, and now she suggested we need to find some new metaphors for God and our relationship with God, which will enable us to have a constructive, rather than destructive, relationship, to nature. But you will find, as I said earlier, in much new age literature, the accusation that Christianity is really the cause of the problems in the environment, and that only accepting some form of pantheism, some form of complete identification of humanity with nature, will there be any kind of answer to this problem at all, only by accepting that identity of nature and the human race? Now, I think there are several responses one can make to that in which Schaefer makes in the course of his book. The one is that, if you declare that everything is one, you have no basis at all to make any distinction finally between human beings and nature. Clearly, you lose the possibility of being able to regard human beings as distinct in any way. It's interesting that people have consciously moved in that direction. If you read anything by Peter Singer, who is the major thinker behind the animal liberation movement, he accuses Christians and others who affirm the uniqueness of the human race of speciesism. That's the new word of the animal liberation movement. We're no longer guilty simply of class distinctions or of racism or of chauvinism or whatever, but now we are guilty of speciesism if we speak of the superiority or the uniqueness of the human race in any kind of way. This leads him to the view quite naturally that healthy dogs and pigs have more value than handicapped children, and that handicapped children should simply be disposed of as we would dispose of a handicapped pig or dog. It also leads him to the view that we shouldn't be bothered about famine problems, let's say an Ethiopia elsewhere, because there's plenty of human beings. We should be devoting our energies to saving snails or whales or anything else which may be in danger of extinction, but the human race certainly isn't. So we shouldn't really concern ourselves with problems of famine or anything like that. So if you adopt a pantheistic view, that is that there is a fundamental unity between the human race and nature. You're left without being able to make any basis for finally distinguishing people from nature or giving them any more respect. The second problem of a pantheistic approach to nature as if this were the answer to environmental problems is to recognize that on a pantheistic view, there is no basis for speaking about abnormality in nature. There is no notion of a historical fall which has changed nature. Nature as it is now is expressive of God. It may sound pleasant to say that nature is perfectly good and fine, and this leads in fact to all kinds of romanticism in some writings. I remember reading essays for example. I think it was an essay in National Geographic several years ago which suggested that there was not one single case in history of wolves or any other animals like that ever attacking human beings, that this was just a load of stories. The same essay suggested that there was no historical evidence either that there had ever been any human cannibalism. You can end up with a kind of extraordinary lack of realism about the problems that are in nature and the cruelty there is in nature, a sort of romanticism about nature itself. But there's a much more fundamental problem and that is nature as it is if it is identified with God has to be seen as normal, as divine in everything that it does. Take for example the possibility of an earthquake which is very much in the news right here in St. Louis at the present time with Ivan Browning's prediction of an earthquake over these few days. How can I fight an earthquake? Why should I resist an earthquake? Why should I consider an earthquake as something to be feared? If in fact nature is divine is God expressed both in human beings in trees, in animals, in plants, in the sky and in the functions of nature. Can I regard an earthquake in any way as wrong? Death whether the death of the individual or the destruction of massive parts of the environment, let's say by an earthquake or the reordering of them would simply be an expression of divinity in nature. That is the issue of course that Albert Camus wrestles with in the book The Plague. How can one fight against the plague? If in fact everything that is is simply an expression of God, of the will of God, the plague itself becomes the way God is expressing himself at this moment in time. Pantheism gives one no basis whatsoever to declare that anything that takes place in nature is wrong whether it's forest fires, earthquakes, tidal waves, tornadoes or whatever. It's very interesting at the very end of Shirley McLean's book Add on a limb she actually expresses this she is in an aeroplane, she's flying along in the aeroplanes being buffeted by a tremendous storm and she says at first she was terrified but then she thought well what if it does crash? I am part of the storm the storm and I are one I will just carry on in another form ultimately fundamentally the storm and I are not distinct in any way I don't need therefore to fear the storm if I die if the plane crashes a nature will just carry on I will carry on simply in a different form another aspect of nature now I don't think Shirley McLean then works that through to think what that would mean in practice but that notion of recognizing everything that is as normal is an inevitable consequence of any kind of pantheistic thinking. So we don't want to have any questions here before we move on no questions, no problems? Yeah, we're better. A fall. Would we have had earthquakes and tornadoes if there wasn't a fall? That's a difficult question to answer certainly the scripture teaches us that that the whole of nature has changed because of the fall that's very clear if you think of Paul statement in Romans 8 he says that the whole creation is subjected to vanity now because of human sin what exactly that means I think it is difficult to say I don't think it's appropriate as some creationists have done to suggest that the death of animals is a consequence of the fall I think that necessarily follows at all because the word death in scripture is used primarily and fundamentally of human beings and it speaks first about first of all it's primary meaning is our alienation from God which a part of which has its consequence in physical death for us so the physical death of human beings is certainly a consequence of the fall but the heart of death biblically is separation from God and that's why the scripture speaks about the second death which isn't another form of physical dying it is of permanent alienation from God I think it's inappropriate to take what death means for human beings and then say that the death of anything else in nature is necessarily a consequence of the fall clearly trees and plants die as a part of their natural cycle they drop their leaves in the fall and your flower is die and drop their seeds I don't think anybody would regard that as unnatural or abnormal and nor do I see that it's necessary to regard the death of animals as abnormal or unnatural they were not created for an eternal relationship with God as human beings were human beings are physical spiritual creatures created for eternity for eternally knowing and loving and enjoying God animals are not created for the same kind of relationship with God to read into Genesis 3 the death of animals as a consequence of a fall is going far beyond the evidence that is there but with regard to earthquakes and tornadoes and things I would say yes we have to say that something which is that destructive which clearly would have destroyed people and their environment must be a consequence of the fall nature itself has been damaged clearly now I can't spell out what that means exactly because scripture doesn't but I think if I don't think it's possible to imagine for example the kind of earthquake which took place in San Francisco recently or took place here in St. Louis in the early 1800s when the river flowed backwards for two or three days I mean it's an enormous earthquake if we had one like that now everybody here would be every building would be destroyed totally and hundreds of thousands of people would die one clearly cannot imagine something like that having that kind of effect on humanity taking place before the fall but I think we have to be careful not to go beyond the data that scripture gives us in terms of saying what those consequences are because we don't know what nature would be like unfolded because we've never seen it now what we do know is what Isaiah looks forward at the creation of the new heavens and the new earth that there will no longer be any heritable destruction that humanity will be completely safe on the earth I mean that is what he looks forward to I think we have to say that everything in terms of the relationship of animals with one another has changed you get animals that kill just with pleasure I don't regard the death of animals as a consequence of the fall but certainly the violence that there is in nature now what Schaefer calls nature red and tooth and claw in pollution the death of man I think we have to see as a consequence of the fall and yes Lewis is very interesting on this if you read his book out of the silent planet where he he has a nature which has power and force in it and even death among animals but in an unfold and context I think one of the other problems that one gets in within within the sort of movement towards either pagan animism or pantheism is a kind of romanticism about the past I've read several articles for example which describe how Native Americans American Indians had a completely harmonious relationship with nature here on the North American continent and that it was only as people came from Europe with a Christian understanding of nature that such damage was wreaked on the environment here it is suggested that Indians lived for thousands of years in total harmony with nature here and it was only when when the Europeans came that animal species began to be destroyed like the buffalo and the passenger pigeon for example of course there's no way one would want to defend the destruction of passenger pigeons or buffaloes however there is no doubt that native Americans had previously destroyed many many species there are vast pits of animal bones which became extinct very long ago which are marked with human weapons spear cuts and so on it just simply is romantic and naive to suggest that any human beings have ever lived in total harmony with nature because human beings themselves are sinful and that is expressed in man's relationship with nature just as it is in our relationship with one another now let's go on to look at a what scripture has to say in fact a bad our relationship with nature this is really summarizing some of the points that Shae for makes but really pulling them together putting them in some sort of orderly form and adding a few points that that he doesn't make explicitly but which are really implicit in his argument first let's think about God's relationship to nature vividly God's relationship to nature now I want to make several points here first of all God is clearly spoken out as the creator of everything of the heavens and earth of everything in them

and that everything which exists declares that it has indeed been created you can think of the words of Psalm 19 or Romans 1 verse 20 but scripture uniformly speaks of the world the whole world everything in nature is created by the word of God God boarded into being by speaking it into being secondly God sustains everything in its existence we don't live in a clockwork universe which simply runs by itself Christ upholds the universe by the word of his power without God's constant sustaining things would fall apart he orders them and upholds them what are called the laws of nature simply descriptions of the way God himself upholds created reality thirdly God declares that his creation is good you can think of the repeated words of Genesis 1 and this is true before humanity is created in other words nature creation has its own value independently of human beings God delights in nature for its own sake it hasn't got value simply because it is useful to us it has value in and of itself as part of God's creation God delights in his creation and cares for it and you can think of repeated statements in the Psalms Psalm 104 and in the New Testament where Jesus speaks about how God cares for sparrows and for the lilies of the field 4th there is now a curse a judgment on the earth on nature because of human sin that judgment takes two forms biblical there is a general judgment so that the whole of creation is under a curse is subjected to vanity as Paul expresses it in Romans 8 20 through 22 because of the original sin but there are also explicit ongoing particular judgments of God which affect nature because of human sin you can think for example of the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah which turn that whole area into a salty flame on which almost nothing can grow or live or the flood would be another example 5thly God has made a covenant between himself and all of created reality when you read the account of the covenant in Genesis 9 12 through 17 it is very important to notice that it's not only a covenant between God and Noah and his descendants the text repeatedly states that God has made a covenant between himself and all of life the whole of creation every creature that lives in the sea on the earth and flies in the air that God has made his covenant with all of nature not just with the human race a covenant that he will never again destroy it during this age and the rainbow then is the sign of that this then is still God's world after the fall he still cares for it he has a covenant with it sickly are we sick now okay six there will be a restoration one day of nature of creation we look forward to a day when the curse will be removed from nature the work of Christ the redemption of Christ applies not only to humanity but to our environment to nature itself and that's very important to notice because if God has such a concern for nature around us in terms of caring for it making a covenant with it and promising its ultimate redemption that should say something to us too about the way we should care for nature our redemption now or to work itself out in the way we treat nature just as it should work itself out in the way we treat one another let's turn secondly to our relationship to nature

our human relationship to nature point one we have been called to have dominion over nature we are given mastery over nature Genesis 1 27 28 and the words that are used there in Genesis 1 are very strong words to rule and subdue a very strong words and Psalm 8 verses 3 through 8 expresses the same point that God has set us over everything on this earth that he has indeed made everything subject to us Psalm 8 verses 3 through 8 yet secondly it is important to remember that this is God's earth that we have no absolute ownership it is not ours our dominion is to be expressed under God

there is a quite extraordinary statement in Leviticus 25 23 where the Israelites are told that they are to regard themselves as aliens as aliens and tenants on the land because it is God's land not theirs ultimately God is the real owner of the earth we are simply tenants and even aliens in comparison with him that's very important because it means we don't have an absolute ownership thirdly we also are creatures Genesis 9 again 12 through 17 brings that out so strongly God makes a covenant with all of reality with humanity and with the rest of life Schaefer uses the expression from a song by the doors speaking about nature as our fair sister and that is quite appropriate biblically you remember he draws uses his little picture which we've referred to before of the infinite personal God but on the side of God's infinity there is an absolute chasm between God and man animals and plants on the side of personality

the chasm comes not between God and man and everything else but between man and everything else because we are like God we are persons like him now this is very important because it gives us a basis both for the affirming human distinctiveness human uniqueness from creation we are made in the image of God animals and plants are not but it also tells us that we are creatures like the rest of reality and therefore it is appropriate for us to respect the rest of creation as fellow creatures creatures with whom God has also made his covenant that brings me to point number four while Genesis 1 uses these very strong words for dominion Genesis 2 15 uses quite different words to describe our relationship to nature the two Hebrew words there are ebbed which is to serve that is that we are servants of nature of creation and Shema which means to care for or preserve to protect to keep so while yes we are given a dominion over nature that dominion is as stewards who are called to preserve nature to serve it not to destroy it or to abuse it but to keep it and pass it on the better for our keeping not the worse for our keeping

fifth just I haven't got five haven't I yeah I haven't got my numbers written down here that's why I have to keep asking you fifth the earth is damaged by our sin as I mentioned before there is a direct relationship not only between original sin and the curse but continuing sin and the judgment of God a couple of remarkable passages from the prophets let me read to you Hosea chapter 4 verses 1 through 3 listen to this here the word of the Lord you Israelites because the Lord has a charge to bring against you who live in the land there is no faithfulness no love no acknowledgement of God in the land there is only cursing lying and murder stealing an adultery they break all bans and bloodshed follows bloodshed because of this the land mourns and all who live in it waste away the beasts of the field and the birds of the air and the fish of the sea are dying Isaiah 24 makes exactly the same point Isaiah 24 verses 4 and 5 the earth dries up and withers the world languishes and withers the earth is defiled by its people they have disobeyed the laws violated the statutes and broken the everlasting covenant therefore a curse consumes the earth it goes on to say the new wine dries up and the vine withers now the point of these passages is that there is an ongoing relationship between human sin and the destruction of the environment the more sinful a culture the more its environment will be destroyed sickly there is the command that we are not to worship nature idolatry the worship of nature is rejected everywhere in scripture in the ten commandments Deuteronomy 4 15 through 19 in Romans 1 21 onwards the pantheism and worship of nature which is so much a part unfortunately of some of the environmental movement today is clearly forbidden by God but also will not produce what it wants to because it is fundamentally sinful at its heart and will only bring destruction not only in relationship with God but in every other way ultimately

7 God provides for us for our food and yet also for all the creatures when we see God's care for us each day and we thank him for providing our daily bread we need also to remember that the same Lord is providing for and caring for everything else and it's interesting how often the Psalms tie these together some 104 10 through 15 some 145 14 through 18 where both of them tie together God's care for all the rest of created reality and his care for us again it's underlying underlining the unity that we have with nature in that proper sense of the word 8 we are encouraged to develop the earth by scripture not simply to keep it as it is when God gives the Israelites the land of Palestine Deuteronomy 8 7 through 9 he tells them that as well as having fields that they can plant and trees that they can they can take the fruit of also he has made it in such a way that they can dig copper and iron from its hills the Bible certainly is in favor of the development of the environment but again it has to be development with respect and then finally there is this emphasis in scripture on a particular care for created things Proverbs 12 10 sums it up and says a righteous man cares for his animals and the mosaic law is very interesting because it has all sorts of provisions which demonstrate God's command to us to consider the needs of the creatures around us for example in the sabbatical year the people are told not only that the poor and the stranger can gather food from the fields but so that the wild animals may too Exodus 23 10 through 12 God demands that the land itself be given rest every seventh year and when the Israelites fail to do that because of their greed he gives the land an enforced rest for 70 years by taking the people out of the land and that in fact is stated in the law of Moses Leviticus 25 verse 4 and 26 34 to 35 God tells them that if you don't give the land its rest I will take you from it that it may have an enforced rest or you can think of the commandment Deuteronomy 25 verse 4 don't muzzle the ox when it's treading out the grain in other words we have to be concerned for the animals and not just for profit or Deuteronomy 22 verses 6 and 7 a remarkable passage where it says if you take the eggs or the young from a nest don't take the mother bird as well why and God says so that you will live long in the land the Lord is your God has given you if you abuse your environment in other words God will take the land away from you and shorten your life on it but fundamentally there what the Israelites were to see in their whole notion of the ownership of land in Israel was that the individual did not own the land it was ultimately God's land but it was also the land for future generations so that stewardship is the biblical model the faithful Israelite had to keep that land and pass it on to the next generation that was his responsibility he was a steward rather than an absolute owner there is no biblical basis for the exploitation of or the destruction the unthinking destruction of the environment certainly dominion certainly development and development will transform a landscape but it has to be done in the context of stewardship and in the context of respect of the creation because it is God's creation any questions that's a very good question the question is is the church or rather we don't see the church doing anything or very little in line with this teaching but while we may not blame the Bible for environmental destruction the church certainly hasn't them much to stop it I think that's that's certainly true there have been very few books written by Christians on this subject and even now I mean there are a couple of good ones there's a book called Bent World by Ron Ellsden and there are a couple of others but there has been not much attention I know a few Christians who were working in this area I have a friend who works in Portugal for example and an Englishman where they have started a work there which is is concerned for the preservation of the environment there are a few questions here and there I know a few who have gone into the science of ecology precisely because they see a calling as believers to do something in this area and I would say it is a proper criticism to make of the church at the present time again I think a lot of it is a reaction because quite a few of the people involved in the environmental movement influenced by new age ideas many Christians immediately run in the other direction instead of saying what's right here now we should be challenged by this so you've got that kind of knee jerk reaction as soon as you see somebody whose whose ideas you don't agree with instead of thinking about what they're saying you just simply run away which is a very serious problem in terms of the churches response on many issues you had the same response a few years ago where whenever anybody would raise the issue of social justice in any context or poverty or racism people would immediately say you're a Marxist simply because you were talking about those issues I remember a friend of mine when I was here as a student at seminary and he was a pastor of a church of a few miles out in one of the distant suburbs here and he preached a sermon from 1 John 4 on the need to love one another and some of the members of his congregation afterwards came and said that's a liberal sermon which is ridiculous and it's the same kind of knee jerk response because somebody you don't like and who's really wrong has said these things therefore you can't say them yourself and this is just foolish of course I think there's a more fundamental problem though where the church is concerned and that is that we have an inherited a view of the environment from the end of the 18th century onwards where the earth is simply seen as something to be used by human beings where any sense of stewardship under God has completely been lost I think the Saint is is true we were talking about this with regard capitalism the same is true with regard to capitalism itself since the end of the 18th century where it's been set free from any sense of obligation to God and obligation to one's neighbors which any kind of economic enterprise has to be carried on with where the Christian is concerned that our bottom line is never profit it is obedience to God and righteousness according to his commandments and careful ones neighbor and just as capitalism in general has been set free from any sense of obligation to God or one's neighbor and regarded simply as something which is my chance to make what I can for myself in the same way our use of our environment has been set free from any sense of obligation to God and to our environment but simply it's something there for our benefit for our use it is our it is our servant to be dominated and abused by us so I think that's certainly true that the that the church has not been has not sufficiently distanced itself from or challenged a lot of what has happened under industrialization and modernization which has so often meant such a radical abuse of the environment and we certainly need to wake up there because we are called always to be faithful to God's word I mean I don't think I have ever heard anybody except shape a preacher sermon or give a lecture on this subject I know there are Christians who do I've never heard one apart from apart apart from he who did this I think it's a tremendous challenge to us to to really submit ourselves to Scripture because if we we draw our our division of the other day you know what we say in effect is yes the Bible has authority but then down in the lower story we put the treatment of nature and the two never touch each other and we really have to be committed to bringing our understanding of everything in subjection to the word of God there is an enormous amount of material in Scripture actually on the subject if you just go and look I mean I just quoted a dozen passages to you but on these two bits of paper I've got here on God's relationship to nature and our relationship to nature I've got about 50 passages in Scripture and there are far more than that you know which you can just find in five minutes if you sit down and and try and look to see what it says and then pull the material together into some kind of a orderly form