<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bantu Bantu Bulanan

Modern Missions; Latin America

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

As we meet in this morning, we ask for your presence and for your help. Do guide us and lead us. We pray in Jesus name. Amen. All right. We are moving today into topic number 20, which is Modern Missions 1. Topic 22 is Modern Missions 2. And I'll explain that division here in just a minute. One chart that is taken from Patrick Johnstone's book that I showed you last time, the church is bigger than you think. It is a helpful chart of looking at major mission movements over the last 2000 years. You can see within the early church in various directions, the Celtic church to Western and Central Europe, the so-called Nestorian church and its labors in Asia, the Orthodox church moving into Central Europe and Russia, the Catholic church in Northern Europe. And then it's when we get to around 1400s and 1500s. We see the Western missionary movement into the Americas and Asia, similarly the Russian Orthodox church, the Siberian Alaska, the Moravians and Protestant evangelical. And I'm going to argue that it's helpful to see that whole phase as a continuous phase that we should call the modern missions movement. Actually in two phases, beginning with the first one of the Roman Catholics in Spain, in Portugal, in particular going to the Americas and Asia and then the evangelicals in Protestants going later. So I helpful chart and you'll know it. You see the globally evangelical movement really in our day catching on and that could inch back further a lot of what's been happening on a global scale has happened unbeknownst to many of us. In terms of cross-cultural missionary efforts as we've talked about in Africa and elsewhere. Another set of maps which gives a bit of perspective on the modern missions movement. You see Roman Catholic missions from 1500 to 1800, the dark area in southern Europe shows what was traditionally Catholic and then with the expansion of Spain into the Americas and the Philippines and influence of Roman Catholic missionaries spreading around Africa into various parts of Asia under Portuguese protection and then later French protection, you see growth in inroads. It's hard to see the little marks around the coast of Africa. They are indeed little similarly in India and then fairly widespread influence into China as Jesuit missionaries have significant influence in pockets there. When you look at 1792, why is the date 1792 chosen here? What happened in 1792? Yes. William Carey published this significant work in inquiry into the means Christians have used to convert the heathen. And that, anyway, sets in motion the Protestant modern missions movement in the 1790s. But the dark period in northern Europe, the dark area in northern Europe showing the Protestants were prominent 1600 and then as the British Empire and Dutch creating influence spreads into the North American colonies and the Caribbean. Some parts of Northern Latin America, Southern Africa, Australia, you see pockets of Protestant gains during the 17th and 18th. Another chart here of some Protestant Roman Catholic missionaries, names, many of these household names in the history of Christian missions, De las Casas, the Dominican Spaniard who eventually wakes up to the atrocities that the colonial authorities are committing against the Native Americans in Spanish America and starts to write and otherwise protest those abuses. France's Xavier sees significant numbers of baptisms in India. What comes to be known then is say long current day Sri Lanka in the East Indies and then comes to Japan in 1549 dies as he's longing to get into China in 1552 and their Xavier churches worldwide including at St. Louis University, if you go to downtown St. Louis. But one of the most widely known and beloved Roman Catholic missionaries in all of mission history is skipping to Mathieu Ricci in China, one of those influential Italian Jesuits who seem to have the capacity and willingness to adapt to the particular situation. They're nobly in India, they're the same sort of thing. They're nobly adjusted to Brahman ways of doing things. Mathieu Ricci adjusted himself to the literary in China and he helped set in motion what comes to be known as the Chinese Rights Controversy that is what should the Christian church do about venerating or worshipping and the word you choose obviously is important, the ancestors. And Mathieu Ricci takes the posture that it's simply a civic duty, it's not a religious act and it's only right for Christians to honor the ancestors by going through the particular rights that the Chinese literary observe. And the Catholic church under that sort of advice and leadership in China advocates that position but there's controversy back and forth and it depends on who are the superior generals within the Jesuits, who has influence in Rome, etc., etc. And finally, when some conservative French jans andists gain particular influence in the 1700s in Rome, the Vatican brings down the ruling that Christians may not observe those rights and when the Vatican's messenger conveys that message to the church in China and the late 1700s as you can imagine, the Chinese Emperor is not terribly pleased about that. And so the Catholic church is therefore outlawed and a period of relative flourishing peace is ended. And that remains to be a controversy amongst many Christians in the world about what to do about the ancestors. But Mathieu Ricci is one who took a more liberal position if you will, a generous position to what the context should say. Those are just a few of the prominent Roman Catholic missionaries in the modern missions movement. Now let me make the try to persuade you of why I think it's important to see what happens with the early Catholic missions, early modern times, starting about 500 years ago, who I think it's important to see that as part of the modern missions movement. In some ways it can be a semantic distinction, that's certainly not anything I want to die for, or be arrogant about. Or even argue for in terms of a semantic distinction is to when the modern missions movement begins. Most of the literature that you will encounter talks about the modern missions movement really beginning with Kerry in the 1790s. And that's one way to look at it. But it seems to me there are at least a couple of reasons for seeing the modern missions movement as a continuous movement starting 500 years ago. And these are the two reasons that seem to me to be helpful for seeing in that way. One, it's a movement that moves from the west outward. And is that happens under Spanish and Portuguese protection and especially with the Spanish as a Spanish propagate the faith in their newfound colonies in the Americas and the Philippines. That is out of the west as Dutch and English traders begin to go out about terminus with that. And then once we get to the 1790s when you have Protestant missionaries as missionaries and you have Moravians going out earlier. But when you have British missionaries and German missionaries and American missionaries going out to that's real. That's from the west as well. And it's a continuous movement from the west to the non-Western world. And that's a continuum I would suggest to you. And to see it as a continuum helps to explain how much of the non-Western world as a whole speaking in generalities wrestles with some of the same sorts of problems of contextualization having received the Christian faith through various nations, Western nations over the course of the past 500 years. That to me is one strong reason to see it as a continuum. Second, many of the issues similar to what I just mentioned with the right controversy that the Roman Catholic missionaries face in their ministries, in their areas, whether it be in the Americas, East Asia, wherever it might be. Many of the issues they face are the same ones that the Protestant missionaries face during the last two centuries. How do you adapt to the local setting or unwittingly you see abuse, importation of culture, imperial gains, Christianity being associated with imperialism. Some of the same sorts of issues that are the dynamic beginning in say around 1500 are still being encountered once you're in the 19th and 20th century. Therefore to see it as a continuum strikes me as helpful. Now there are differences and therefore to call them phase one and phase two also strikes me as helpful because the second phase as a Protestant phase, for example, stresses the translation of the Bible into the vernacular tongues. And that's a critical difference. Catholic missionaries are not doing that really until after Vatican II in the 1960s. And so that's one major difference that we see. All right. And thinking then briefly, and we are just going to think briefly about this what I want to call phase one of the modern mission's movement, you know the notion really that's decided it's a decision between some papal bull, some papal bulls. And the Catholic and Portuguese crown crowns that as far as Spain and Portugal are concerned and as far as the Vatican is concerned, the non-European world is divided up into two parts. I mean, it's all non-European non-Christian heathen, but the non the heathen non-Christian world is half Spain's half portals. And I don't have my world map up today because of my technical problems, but when you look at a world map and you just see the scope of that mentality that the crowns of Spain and Portugal had, you see how a kind word of adventure some that was. Yes, not in terms of what the papal bull said in terms of actual control that comes about, absolutely. Spain has the resources to conquer much of Central and South American move on to the Philippines and Portugal is only able to establish a few trading posts around African India. But as far as the papacy was concerned, as far as the crowns were concerned is they set out in their respective divisions, this half is Spain's, this half is portals. And it's only makes sense then, so when Christopher Columbus and others come on behalf, they plant the flag, claim this on behalf of the cross and of the Roman bishop and that's just the way it works. It's not a totally uniform picture to where you have all the same views of people going people like De las Casas who are missionaries object to what they see happening and with some of the colonial rule. You have many of the Jesuits in Asia who have to be very careful with respect to what political and trading authorities have to say and Jesuits who are working in China and in Japan and other parts of Asia, they slowly get intertwined with some of the silver trade and some of the silk trade partly to support themselves financially. Missionaries who teach English in various settings today use that sort of a trade as well to help support themselves financially. But missionaries are wanting to be specifically religious in their work and aspirations, but they have to be careful about being intertwined and many of them see the dangers and object to how political authorities want to impose their will without really understanding the situation. So it's a mixed bag of especially talk about the Spanish scene, contested doors who are going to conquer and rule and missionaries and of course different landowners who come into the scene as well, especially as far as the Spanish are concerned. It's helpful as well to recall that once we are in the late 1600s and 1700s as Verkyle mentions in your readings and I've listed here his pages 176 to 178. You have the Meravian missionaries who play important roles in formulating what missions is all about, who help to raise awareness amongst other Protestants eventually about the importance of all peoples around the world coming to hear the gospel. And of course it's count Zinsendorf in the early 1700s who sets up his community at Hurnhut and many missionaries that are trained and sent out some missionaries sell themselves as slaves to go along to the America's to minister. There are all sorts of creative ways that Meravian missionaries go out. Piotis missionaries associated go with early on and we'll see a chart of this effect with the Danish how they mission as Pai Lutheran Piotis missionaries early on to India early before carry in the formal beginning of phase two of the modern mission's movement begins. And so what's happening with these early Piotis and Meravian missionaries is very, very important with their stress and zeal on the salvation of individuals. But when you think about what the mission strategy is of phase one of the modern mission's movement of what the Roman Catholic missionaries are about and what really some of the early Protestant reformist geologists are about. And there aren't very many but when you look at what the missy logical view is it's basically to plant the church to see the church take root and begun with all of its structures all of its hierarchy as an organization in these new lands. That's what missions is all about and you've read about that in your readings as I mentioned with for Kyle. Any questions about phase one I'm wanting to move ahead a little bit just to catch us up a bit. Yes, with the Spanish colonialism in the Americas and the Philippines is the missionaries goal to start the church in particular. Yes, of course, they see that as part of a wider Christian civilization being brought into these lands that need all of the benefits of the zenith of rural civilization which is Spain. So all of the structures of government of commerce of the ecclesiastical orders they are all to be brought to bear but as the missionaries they in particular have a focus on serving the Pope and the Jesuits you know the Jesuits have a particular allegiance directly to the papacy. And that sometimes serves them when they need to act independently of colonial authorities when some of them fight on behalf of indigenous peoples for example but it's part of the whole complex but their particular focus is on establishing the church. Let's move in we're not going to spend a great deal amount of time here either on to the next topic topic 21 which is Latin America. And I would like to show you a couple of websites but I can't do technical difficulties but I'll just tell you what they were as introductory material these websites were taken from some articles in Christianity today speaking of some contemporary developments within Latin American Christianity. One was about increased cooperation between penicostles and evangelicals in Latin America likely you will know and from your readings in New Nyes this will have been confirmed for you that much of the significant growth in Latin American Christianity or the past decades. Has been amongst penicostle groups varieties of penicostle groups and I heard one mission leader put it this way. You'll also know about in association with the development of liberation theology in Latin America in the 1970s and following many Roman Catholic ecclesiastical leaders have latched on to liberation theology and sought to be more affiliated with the poor and suffering masses in Latin America and the developing base communities of these poor people but as one mission leader put it while the Catholic church may have opted for the poor the poor have opted for the penicostles. Generally speaking but this one article that I am unable to show you speaks of attempts at cooperation between penicostle groups and evangelicals realizing that they really cannot ignore each other and that they both are sizeable enough and growing to the extent and share enough to need to cooperate. Another article that I was going to show you speaks of how evangelicals in Latin America have grown to the point now to where many of them are more comfortable with consciously expressing being Latin Americans. This article speaks of how for many Latin American Christians many of the forms of worship and church structure, church practice, church lifestyle having come through Western missionaries and in particular North American missionaries has influenced them to the point to where they've had a struggle at being Latin American and being Christian at the same time. But with enough time having passed and having achieved enough growth and confidence many of them now are incorporating Latin American styles of music and worship etc. One demin dissertation that is being written now for covenant seminaries of pastor here in the states who grew up in Cuba then Venezuela and in recent years has gone to Mexico to do worship seminars he's writing a dissertation evaluating how some of these churches have taken what he's given in these seminars and used those principles and contextualize them. And what he is discovered in his research is that different church leaders have different attitudes towards using one traditional Mexican music and secondly contemporary Christian music of the American variety. Contemporary Christian music with the American style is quite popular among many young people some church leaders say we definitely need to use it some are saying no need to stick with the traditional hymns that's what's holding right in what the missionaries taught us. Few church leaders presently so he's discovering within this is within the presidential church in Mexico are ready quite yet to incorporate much traditional Mexican music it has too many evil associations for them. Some are willing to go that route but that is a present struggle so this one dissertation is discovering now I have some people who have roots and experience in Latin America here and you can ask for comment on that and I'll ask for some of your further questions and comments as well that yes so comments out of Mexico namely that yes there are struggles with worship but in your experience you didn't see really anyone attempting to incorporate quote unquote traditional Mexican music and again just just as I mentioned just a few people were in the name of kind of making worship like a fiesta and make it feel more at home. Some people willing to do that and then the further comment that much of what you saw was in line with what the readings were saying and that is is that many evangelicals there have a problem with living compartmentalism. Living compartmentalized life with the religious sector of life and the rest of life and just to piggyback on that just a bit from other people that I have read Latin American theologians and a couple of names the provian Samuel Escobar Renee Padilla's an Argentine Baptist both of these men have written a number of articles and books even in English but they have been among those a wide chorus of evangelicals in Latin America. Who have said what liberation theology was trying to articulate in the 1970s wasn't all the way off the mark in that much of what they were reacting against was a piotistic compartmentalized over spiritualized Christianity that had been imported into Latin America from North America. And so they have been ones who have really helped to push the rest of the evangelical church to have social concerns total life concerns as a part of the total theological agenda and matters of the Christian gospel necessarily. I'm looking to my friend over here to for any questions or remarks in reaction to what we've covered so far or as we move into the topic in general. Where we are with Latin America so what would you share with the you we've done this before once but would you remind the rest of the class your own experience with Latin America so I'm going to repeat that for the sake of the type briefly just that. You went back in 1978 there for 20 years and when you first went in like 70s, Protestants evangelicals, Pentecostals and all they were all lumped together in terms of terminology and understanding they would tend to be marginalized not terribly significant but over the course of the past 20 years there's been significant growth amongst Protestants evangelicals, Pentecostals and now there's respect there's influence and continuing growth amongst those groups. Thank you and I'm going to welcome any further comments. I want to read something that you did not get to read the readings that you had out of New Nies from this book. Crisis and hope in Latin America co-authored by Emilio New Nies and William Taylor. William Taylor is editor of another book I have you perusing. You're reading a couple of essays by Samuel Escobar in connection with the assignment and that's on reserve for you in the library but this is from the forward by Samuel Escobar. It may sound as a typical Latin American exaggeration is stated the future of Christianity is at stake in what happens in America today but he says when we pay attention to figures we may have to conclude that there's no exaggeration in that statement. That the future of Christianity really is at stake depending on what happens in Latin America almost half of the Catholics of all the world live in Latin America. I heard someone in passing or somehow mentioned the other day that somehow there was rumors or something like that that maybe the next Pope could be Latin American. Can you imagine what that would be? Well if you think about the numbers and you think about the papacy's desire to make sure the Latin America remains Catholic what not that would be interesting step. Consequently the Catholic hierarchies consider the region as a reservoir of human and material resources for their missionary work in the future. Another side comment on this I think this came up in your readings as well in fact I'm sure it did Latin America especially 100 years ago was somewhat of an anomaly for the Protestant missionary force because was a Christianizer was a not Christianized. At the 1910 and missionary conference for example due to the long standing Catholic presence there it was basically considered to be Christianized in comparison to Africa in Asia. Now some of those views have changed in light of especially North American missionary activity in the 20th century perhaps but at the same time Latin America again in comparison to and the Philippines fits in the same category. It has been viewed differently missiologically than many parts of Africa in Asia by Western Christian agencies and churches. On the other hand on the heels of speaking of Roman Catholicism Latin America happens to be the continent or popular forms of Protestantism grow faster than anywhere else and they grow at the expense of the Catholic church. During the most recent decades more people have left Catholicism in order to become Protestant than at the time of the reformation in the 16th century. That's truly interesting to think about isn't it? The reformation in Europe is so terribly significant for our very identities those of us here but you think about what's happening in Latin America and the sheer numbers of people there. So claimed here greater. Brazil with his population of over 140 million is considered the largest Catholic nation in the world but the Catholic percentage of the population went down from 92.8% in 1970 to 88.4% in 1980 and decline has continued. In fact the 22 million Protestants of Brazil might well be now a religious majority in comparison with the number of Catholics who actually practice their religion. I don't have this text on that and I don't have with me some of the graphs and stats I've been given about the numbers of Brazilian missionaries going out within Brazil to new people groups and indeed around the world was just speaking yesterday with gentleman on our campus who is currently ministering in Mozambique former Portuguese colony and he is interested for example in recruiting Brazilian missionaries to come minister in Mozambique. Mission to the world has sought to see Brazilian missionaries go minister in Portugal and other similar sorts of places in the world. So the significant growth of Protestant Christianity in your readings you did just the part on the spiritual dimensions about the Catholic church and the evangelicals those of you who will be taking the elected course will be reading what the book sets forth as a contemporary panorama and it synopses of history. I've just included those outlines for you in the syllabus to know when you look at Latin America you have to remember the tremendous variety of peoples and nations and histories there religious heritage. And again we for convenience sake we we speak in lump terms of Asia Africa Latin America etc but there's just a tremendous variety of peoples in Latin America then the geography mountains forests beaches etc and I'm sure in Argentina you will have seen a variety of geography that most of us who have been there would not be able to imagine. Varieties of races the huge population explosion many places the ever changing and interesting political scenarios in countries the religious scenarios the Catholics the Catholic mix the varieties of new religious movement springing off of Catholicism and in the varieties of Protestantism and Pentecostalism etc and the rich cultures of music and dance and craft etc. And then when you look at history the way they talk of history here is pre in post 1492 we have to remember that this is helpful for looking history but we have to remind ourselves that this part of the world has significant strands of history prior to 1492 if we're going to really think in a multipolar world historical sort of away. Side note to this if you if you like history the funniest book ever written is one written by a couple of Brits in the 1930s entitled 1066 and all that if you know that book it is just the funniest if you like history and if you know British history in particular you will just be crying out of laughter and reading that book. Someone graciously gave me a copy recently and I read it earlier and even though I don't know British history as well as I should I could get some of the humor in that and for example they talk about just in the remind me of what I was just talking about in light of when it speaks of India it begins the chapter by noting in a tongue in chic way Indian history begins in the 1700s when they start fighting wars for the British. And if we're not careful you know we can think of those sorts of ways including about Latin America but with the coming of the Spaniards obviously things change with all of the conquest and the colonization that takes place your readings pointed out to you and if some of you remember Neil Hageman coming to campus last year he stressed this in his lectures on Latin America it's not all Roman Catholic missionary activity in Latin America. In the mid 16th century in the 1500s you have various Protestants coming in association with Dutch and British attempts at establishing trading process and that's important to remember that Protestant history goes back to the mid 16th century and some of those attempts failed and some succeeded just a bit but French Huguenots for example went there. And Nunez mentions that in what she read as I recall but the various revolutions and independence gain in the early 19th century the new republics form there for the development that occurs in the late 19th or 20th century and then the instability that many nations have experienced in Latin America and then when you look at all the various spiritual dimensions of which you've read tremendous activity tremendous vitality and just worldwide significance for what's happening with respect to the Christian faith in Latin America and again this should be a help to us in realizing where the mission field is. It's the whole world and the Christians in Latin America are about working out their salvation and fear and trembling just as we are in this part of the world wherever else and they are involved in sending out missionaries in a cross cultural way whether it be within their countries or outside their political entities as well. I would welcome any further comments on the readings or this brief overview from those of you who have experienced in Latin America that you think would be helpful to us. Anything you would like to add so the huge testimony to the huge crusades and important evangelists that have arisen in that setting in Louis Plough is a name that's perhaps more familiar to people worldwide and English speaking circles as well of widespread permanent evangelist. Alright let's move in to modern missions too and by this again I'm meaning what is occurring really since the 1790s in particular. Phase two of the modern missions movement or the Western missionary movement might be one other way to look at it. A couple of maps that you have in your syllabus. Protestants in 1865 you see areas in based on a map we saw earlier in 1792 in Northern and Northwestern Europe in the North American colonies pockets of South American Australia. You have Protestants with a significant presence by 1792 but over the course of the next 70 years you see Protestant advances across what is now the United States in southern Africa with the English and the Dutch activity there in the Indian subcontinent and further into Australia in association with colonial expansion. Side note to North America some people have noted that when you get right down to evaluating what has been called the great century in Christian missions namely the 19th century perhaps the single most significant occurrence of Christian advance in the 19th century is the spread across the North American continent of the Christian church. In connection with the growth of the United States of America then when you look at night by 1910 you see further growth into Eastern Europe and in parts of Central Asia further into China Australia pockets of South America and again this will be association largely with British missionary expansion and some other European countries becoming involved as well. In colonial expansion throughout the world when you look at some prominent Protestant missionaries there will be some familiar names from any of you John Elliott coming to England to the North American Indians in New England a congregational missionary with the Society of Provocation of the Gospel in New England Thomas Bray similarly this as an Anglican. Zigenborg one of those early German Lutherans who goes to India in the early 1700s with the Danish holly mission the Danish holly mission excuse me David Brainerd the young zealot who dies in his zeal of giving himself no rest in his concern that Native Americans actually come to hear the gospel. Christian Friedrich Swartz is another one of those Lutheran scientists to go to India in the 1700s with the Danish holly mission and then there's William Kerry and you know the story of his being a shoe cobbler and he comes as he's hearing about the adventures of Captain Cook and the Pacific and becoming more aware of the needs of war people around the world he becomes concerned and he becomes convinced that Christians need to do something about that. And there's the anecdotal story that as someone has noted if it isn't actually true it ought to be true when he's in a meeting of ministers and Kerry says there's something that we have to do about this and the old minister says young man if God wants us to do something I'm he'll do it himself sit down and be quiet. And that shows some of the ethos and thinking that was the prominent thinking for Protestants that the early apostles had had fulfilled the great commission and what do we need to do about that. But William Kerry spearheads and he writes his inquiry into the means that should be used to the Christian should be all about what they do and and Kerry of course goes to India and turns out to be a tremendous linguist educator and rightfully seen to be the pivotal seminal figure that he was. Henry Martin is another Englishman and he is an Anglican who goes to India and then Persia Robert Morrison another Anglican this time with the London Missionary Society and that's really give the Baptist Missionary Society associated with the independence you have the London Missionary Society which helps send many others out including Anglicans and you have the Church Missionary Society which is specifically associated with the Anglicans out of India. The first American missionary to go out is Adam and Judson as he goes out and settles in Burma now Myanmar and you know the story how he really helps to found the American Board of Commissioners for the Foreign Missions which is associated with congregationalists in England in route on ship he gets convinced of Baptist teaching becomes a Baptist and the folks back home are really happy about that. But Baptist are very happy about that and you'll see all sorts of Judson colleges around this country named after Adam and Judson. Robert Mothett Alexander Duff the great missionary scholar out of Scotland who went from the Church of Scotland to India and thankfully Samuel Crowther listed here. That young boy taking out of the Niger region is a slave relocated by the British in Sierra Leone and Samuel Crowther leaves the cross cultural missionary effort several of them into a present day Nigeria. Yes he is when you turn the page continued here he comes glad you asked that was not a setup. David Livingstone of course and his travels into the interior of Africa when you get to about the 1850s and we'll see a chart of this effect in a minute you start to see different missionaries start to move into interior areas much of that is simply because it becomes more feasible to do so practically. If you try to go inland at all prior to that you're going to die of disease or get killed one of the other but so Livingstone really is a trailblazer in that sense. John Patton very important Scottish missionaries in the South Pacific and there are all sorts of heroic stories of missionaries from Britain and from France and from the United States in the Pacific Islands in the 1800s. Leading to the widespread growth of the gospel toward you have whole populations coming to Christianity got the Pacific Islands in John and many stories of of martyrs and cannibals eating missionaries and those fire the imagination further of what it means to be a missionary in the Pacific. We've run across John Nevious already who really implements in Korea the three self formula churches needing to be self governing self propagating self supporting and that those ideas were unannunciated articulated earlier by Henry Van in England and Ruth of Sanderson in America and then Hudson Taylor who found the China inland mission and in connection with Taylor you have the Guinness family who in various places in Africa and otherwise support the founding of what come to be known as faith missions. This is where faith missions really begin and where people again start to go inland faith missions being to where you don't have a church structure to support you financially you don't go around asking for money to support you you believe God and you go. And you trust God to provide and you'll know the story of Hudson Taylor as well how he is he he seeks to become Chinese other missionaries just cannot understand this really eccentric figure and he rubs in the wrong way but his autobiography embography is about him and he becomes one of those heroic missionary figures who is just captures. Many of the imaginations due to the haggiography written about him Mary Sleser is another important missionary who in West Africa moves inland again in in President Nigeria and she is a name that in Nigerian history stands out amongst the most prominent and she against the advice of many chooses to move inland saying that I'm not a threat. People are going to consider me dangerous and is able to blaze many trails CT stud that interesting figure famous cricket here and leaves it all and goes to join the China mission then goes in the event sets up his own mission eventually in Africa the heart of Africa mission and Albert swipes are the again the famous medical doctor working in in French equatorial Africa. From Germany so just a list of some of the names we look at these more extensively in the history of a world mission elective class. I couldn't see this mentioning another missionary into West Africa this is not meant to be an extensive list to list everyone and just fix out some of those that are prominent yes I'm sure that when they compile this list they just had to select a few that people would be particularly familiar with. As you read for Kyle in about the development of mission theory I want to stress from that from for Kyle the importance of mission theory is developed by various missionologists. Gustav Barnack in Germany a very similar missions thinker and researcher as far as ducks missiologists certainly boving in our reform tradition is extremely important and as I noted earlier when mentioning his book. The science of missions many of us cut our theological teeth on boving on Rick Kramer listen on vocals page 41 very important worldwide figure an influential especially in the 1930s and 1940s when the worldwide Christian movement is starting to wrestle significantly with non Christian religions etc. Kramer takes a relatively conservative Bartian but on the scale on which he's operating conservative posture for the uniqueness of the Christian religion amongst other Christian religions and many people have trouble accepting that sort of a position. Page 51 of recall hook and dick another important Dutch missiologist and as he's writing in the 1960s he's taking a rather radical stand that the church as we know it needs to disappear and allow for the modern secular age to come forward in the church will find itself as it loses itself in a midst of all the interesting thinking going on in the 1960s. Angus missiologist I'll tell you what I'm going to stop here and we'll pick back up because we have a guest that I want to bring up but I'll just show you and we'll come back to it next time in closing about here a chart that touches on some of the missionaries we just considered. This is my Ralph winner and looking at the what he calls the three eras of the modern missionary movement you should have this in your syllabus but we talked about the inland missions that really start in the mid 19th century and this chart talks about how when you look at what was happening from the 1790s for the next 100 years basically missionaries are going to the coastlands then in the mid 19th century you see people start going to the inland and then beginning in the 1930s with Donald McGill. In the 1930s with Donald McGabbard and Cam Towns and we'll talk more about them you see people start to crystallize the notion of unreach peoples and that's the stage and that's the final stage of missions that were in so this analysis tells us we'll come back to this. I just wanted to refer to it now briefly because it systematizes a bit some of the missionaries we were considering earlier. All right we have a guest I'm going to ask him to come up for them to come up depending on how they're going to do it and it's a treat for us to have Mark and Marty Mylon who are NTW missionaries in France and we are friends from going through different NTW things together and remained in touch and they are back in the stage for home ministry assignment. Martin St. Louis for a missions conference a good shepherd Presbyterian church and they've been gracious enough to come by and share with us a bit here in class. Nelson asked me to speak a bit about missions in France and Europe really you know we know other missionaries in Europe I know more have more experience about missions in France could start when Marty and I arrived in 1994 we started in Paris with the language school and as soon as we were up and running and able to speak to people and understand some of the responses in French I went around and I asked as many people as I could what advice they'd have for me a new missionary or new injuries were missionaries so much a new pastor because in France they have a tradition of pastors the reformation from Calvin was started and then really declined through the words of religion but still in French society and culture the kind of can understand what a pastor is so I asked what advice would you have for me a new pastor just starting a ministry in France I got as you can imagine all sorts of responses and suggestions and I asked the missionaries pastors and business people lay people believers non believers I was at a wedding not long after we were in France about a year after we arrived and asked a business man that was seated next to me at the reception all three and I asked all three what advice would you have any he said two things that always stuck with me he explained his own background his experience with the church was raised in a Jesuit school and learned a French phrase illa boufé du purfé I don't know if any of you didn't speak any French but he's stuffed with with with priests he's he's added up to here with them that explain why and and why he left the church himself and he said that when he was a young boy he was positive towards the church and and the village priest he would come around and visit them in their home and and he would always this kind of folkloric the kind of the chubby parish pastor who was a priest who would come and and he'd always arrive at 11 o'clock or 12 o'clock and it would forcibly be invited to stay for lunch and just he spent that time with people and to to this fellow honkry that's the distant past the religion church has become a business it's become an industry it's become anything but but just a kind of personal and so he said that is is the one reason that he's distance himself from the church and the other was that the church is now involved in politics and social activities and education and everything everything but the spiritual and it was kind of surprised really ironic for me to be hearing this from a fellow who is on his friends our common friends would would would describe him as a hardened cynic businessman a materialistic but what he missed in the church what he didn't find in the church was a spiritual and the circumstances of the sweating and the reception were that our friends our common friends were having the wedding in a neighboring village not their own village because their local village priest is communist and our friends Michelle was the president of the chamber of commerce so you can imagine that he didn't really get along with the communist priest which goes to show that just when when the church was was no longer offering what what people wanted in personal spiritual and as Marty and I arrived in principle well we can do that we can spend time with people at wedding receptions and cafes and restaurants in our home in their homes and spiritual that we do have a message of reconciliation to offer sometimes I am tempted and people want to hear about the politics and economics and they want to talk about the death penalty they want to talk about American things and it's tempting to go that route because we would have lots to say about that but we don't want to take positions that would offend people on those issues and that would limit the hearing that we have with people regarding the gospel and reconciliation and that kernel of the gospel of practicing reconciliation having the truth of the gospel yeah we need to be orthodox we're reformed we understand the culture the world those things are essential but then also we need to do that in a way that is personal and spiritual in a way that is really relevant and I think in Europe at least what I've seen in France it's and we've learned in seminary the inspiration the authority of scripture but it's the relevancy of the gospel the relevancy of scripture is the Bible something that I can use in my relationship with my family with my wife my children those are the things that we have found to be really useful in our ministry and my weakness is I have trouble seeing the big picture and there are other people that do that kind of thinking in the think tanks and addressing the biggest issues in culture so far we have just a personal ministry with some neighbors with some friends some friends of friends and those are the points that people really have wanted to know they we haven't gotten so much into there are some people that ask those kind of questions I'm glad for my seminary experience I don't know if I forget if Nelson had said that I graduated from covenant seminary about 10 years ago so at that point there was just one missions class and what I did that served me I think in my experience here at seminary was that took as many missions courses well just one missions course but I took as many church planning courses as I could because that's really what what we were headed for church planning such courses with Phil Douglas and did as much as I could with that practically to understand the principles and have them clear enough to me so that I could apply those principles in a different context culturally and sort out the difference between what is cultural and what is is this universal principles the next thing I would like to say in that is that regarding our mission work in France it's really yeah it is the church as as Nelson said but the church isn't really marketable in France it's not as one one fellow told me one missionary told me don't come to France don't come to Paris and expect people to line up to come to your Bible studies and your small groups in church real the French is kind of shrug and we're there we're all excited that we have all these people behind us praying for us and we're prepared and sent out to be missionaries and the French are just going to so what they're not really interested in coming to church but they are really interested in sitting down over a cup of coffee and talking and speaking and people will say all kinds of things and in that sense I would say ministry in Europe well presumably ministry in Paris is like ministry in the States it's personal people have needs when when they you know they know how much you care well they don't care what you know those kind of things really are true that it's that personal loving not churchy church is not real it's just they don't have a cultural repair they don't have the cultural context to put church into asking somebody to church like I grew up in Northeastern Maryland I just didn't know many Muslims I didn't know any Jews so the idea of going to a Jewish satir meal was just kind of I didn't I had no idea you name it I'm not a Jewish I had no idea you know even if I would have heard about one I wouldn't have gone because it didn't mean anything that wasn't like I grew up in a nominal Christian really not understanding the gospel so I just those activities I didn't have that cultural insight and I I think many of us perceive that as antagonism or aggressiveness from the French but as I've been there for these last what we've had seven years now that we've been involved with ministry in France I can understand from their point of view their suspicions towards organized religion they they would go back to the crusades the wars are religion the all kinds of events that have happened that fortify and explain their position of being suspicious of organized religion they would go back to September 11th and the how how religious extremism can can cause all sorts of problems so they want to be prudent they want to be cautious but at the same time they really do have spiritual needs and spiritual interests and we see our job as meeting meeting those as we can and getting in touch with them and then really having something that we would would be able to offer them the reconciliation of Jesus Christ so I don't know do we need to stop there or I could just okay yes excuse me is there any kind of renewal in the church yes there are some churches we know that the vineyard movement sends some people over and that was kind of messy I was just one church I know of in the south of Paris there is the Toronto blessings there's just a big movement in the Catholic church it can mean all kinds of things I had a pen pal when I was in high school and went and visited with her father and she told me that her son that my pen pal's husband his son and all was charismatic oh great I get you know I have to meet him and find out it well turned out he plays a guitar in church that's the nature of his charismatic expression so I you know I it means all kinds of different things oh that's something else that I didn't understand really until going to pray the charismatic or the Catholic church sometimes as Protestants were kind of embarrassed because we're all divided up into all these different movements and it's hard to explain well the Catholic church is seems to me from the outside I just don't get it either it's just as eclectic that we have a friend is oh yeah she's Catholic she disagrees with the Pope she never goes to confession you know she she just likes this church that church you know she takes this and that and well then she says she's kind of like well so things I guess it's the other thing in ministry in France probably in Europe you have to get underneath the surface to really find out what things mean I think we jump so quickly once we have labels that we think we understand or even a translation that we think we understand and doesn't necessarily mean what we think it means right okay the the question was kind of the traditional French perspective particularly on on the church and and the gospel prepared to the African and I thought today was here longkins and the on the French Caribbean islands the on key on TA that are in France from what I've seen is I really haven't seen any church is growing in France amongst the called Fonset de Souche the root French the European French there are some churches that grow a little bit here and there they're particularly two charismatic churches and in Paris that have had tremendous growth we'll see how long lasting that is but in terms of reproducible growth it's it's really uniquely as far as I can see you uniquely amongst minority groups for different reasons they're they're uprooted they're not at home and they come to France and then they're more open to things but even even in the Caribbean islands it's that's where about 1700 churches in the Caribbean islands and that's just a huge it's about five times more per capita in those islands and there are in France in France in the continent but the Holy Spirit is working amongst many from from Africa that are in France the all the churches we go to the ones that are growing they're they're growing amongst Africans and non continental French and that's that's one of the puzzles that we have in in ministry in France I imagine it's like that elsewhere in Europe do we work with those that the the Spirit seems to be working in and bringing to us one Lutheran pastor who told me well you know the French people there God has rejected them and because they've rejected God and the people are going to hell he told me when I came to France we'll just go back to America and have a ministry of encouragement of teaching God's blessing and preaching God's blessing don't stay in France where where the message of the gospel it's going to be true to the gospel in France he told me it's preaching God's rejection of people that are rejected him so of course I don't believe that's what the gospel is the Jesus Christ has taken all that condemnation and so we can really offer the piece of God that Christ has earned but it's not universally understood that way the question is do we have some contact with the gypsies in France probably the most contact we have with them is when we see them outside our home or they come and knock on our door sometimes to to sell something the we've heard I just you know things figures that you read half of the gypsies in France have been converted to the gospel they have huge 60,000 people get together on airfields and have revival meetings and camp meetings I don't know but there certainly is still not integration of them into the the rest of the church the rest of the church the Protestant church or reform church