Here at lecture 32 beside the Bonnie Briar Bush, 19th century Scotland, you might wonder where I'd come up with some of these titles, and this one is easy because of a very famous book that I read over and over again, called, Beside the Bonnie Briar Bush. It is a book by Dr. John Watson, whose pen name is Ian McLaren, and it's a collection of stories, fictional accounts of church life in a glen place that Dr. Watson calls Drum Talkty in Scotland, stories set in the 19th century about the churches and the people in that little glen in Scotland. Years ago, Dr. John Sanderson recommended this book to me and I read it from time to time just to renew my joy in reading about Scotland, Presbyterian churches, in a time in Scotland, when those churches were very much part of the culture. Those stories in Beside the Bonnie Briar Bush might well be illustrated by John Laura Thomas painting, the Changs in the National Gallery of Scotland in Edinburgh, it's called The Ordination of the Elders, and it shows the service of ordination for elders in one of the Scottish curts, painted him 1891. The Briar Bush, beside the Bonnie Briar Bush, the Briar Bush, of course, is the Fistle Scottish symbol since the early 16th century and became not only a symbol of the land of Scotland, but it became a symbol of the Presbyterian Church. The Fistle is a pretty tough plant, you might know, farmers find that out when they struggle with Fistles. But a beautiful plant too, that is able to not only survive, but often flourish in very difficult places, so it's not an inappropriate symbol for the Presbyterian Church, and because it is a Presbyterian symbol, it's also become a Covenant Seminary symbol. We have the Fistle in our seal of the Seminary, along with clergy tartan and numerous other Scottish devices, because of the close connection between the history of the Church in Scotland and the Seminary that comes somewhat from Scottish heritage. So we begin this lecture on 19th century Scotland. I want to use a prayer from one of the great Scottish pastors and theologians and hymnwriters, Horatius Bonar. We'll pray these words of Horatius Bonar as we begin today. Let's pray. Fill thou my life, O Lord, my God, in every part with praise. That my whole being may proclaim thy being and thy waves, praise in the common things of life its goings out and in, praise in each duty and each deed, however small and mean. Fill every part of me with praise. Let all my being speak of thee and of thy love, O Lord, poor though I be in weak, so that no part of day or night from sacredness be free, but all my life in every step be fellowship with thee, amen. Episcopacy was reimposed in Scotland in 1660 with the restoration of the stewards that brought, of course, great suffering to Presbyterian people who oppose the settlement of prelocution in the city or the Episcopal Church on the land of Scotland. That suffering came to an end in 1688 and 1689 with the glorious revolution of William and Mary, which brought an end to the steward reign and introduced a new day into the life of the people of England and Scotland, the settlement of 1690 restored Presbyterianism to become, once again, the faith of the Scottish Church, the Scottish people. That was 130 years after the first settlement of Presbyterianism in 1560 during the days of John Knox from 1560 to 1690 was, as we know now, a tumultuous period in Scottish history and certainly in Scottish Presbyterian history. At the settlement of 1690, the Anglican Church was established in England and the Presbyterian Church established in Scotland. From that point down to the present, the Anglican Church is the Church of England, even though non-conformist were tolerated in England and the Presbyterian Church, the Church of Scotland. Since 1600 in three, Scotland and England were under one ruler. The union of the parliaments would not take place until 177 and now 300 years later, Scotland is to have its own parliament, once again, as the new labour government is working for the establishment of a Scottish parliament. But in the period of the settlement of 1690, it was one ruler, but two state religions, depending on what part of the British Isles we were in, actually north of the border, the king or the queen, no matter that he or she was the supreme governor of the Church of England, would become a Presbyterian simply by crossing over the line there. And the king and the queen worshiped then in the Kirk in Scotland. There's a story about Queen Victoria, one occasion when she was in the north at the castle at Melmorrow. She went as she did ordinarily to the little Kirk at Kratty near the castle and there she took the Lord's Supper. Those days, quaintly, the clerk in the church would list the people that received communion on a given Sunday, not by name, but by profession. And so on this day, when the Queen was there and received the Lord's Supper, the clerk wrote in his book, Shefford's 12, Servant's 12, Queen's 1. Well, that illustrates something of the unusual nature of the settlement of Anglicanism in the south and Presbyterianism in the north. When the Presbyterian church was re-established, as the Church of Scotland in 1690, there were two groups that remained outside of that settlement. One was the Scottish Episcopalians. There were people who were Episcopalian, particularly in the preceding years of Stuart Rain. And many of those Episcopalians now switched over to Presbyterianism, but some did not. Some remained. Episcopalian, the Scottish Episcopal Church was legally recognized in 1712, but that church was not popular in Scotland, as you can imagine, and became even less popular because the Episcopalians and the few Roman Catholics who were still around supported the Jacobite cause. The king over the sea, the stewards, as over against the new rule, and that created repression and persecution experienced by Scottish Episcopalians. But the other group that stayed out of the settlement was the Presbyterian group. Some small number of Presbyterians, we call them the Coveninners, who felt that the settlement of William and Mary was defective. It wasn't Presbyterian enough. It did not acknowledge the Covenettes. The Covenettes were discreetly dropped. And so these Presbyterians, the Coveninners, objected to the settlement and did not become part of the state church. They met for a while in groups called Societies, until they were finally able to constitute themselves into a denomination, which is called the Reform Presbyterian Church, that happened in 1743. The Reform Presbyterian Church all the way down to the present, in very tiny groups in Scotland and in our own, and a little bit larger group in the United States, called the Reform Presbyterian Church of North America. Those people still go by the name of the Coveninners. But most Scottish people became members of the Church of Scotland, Presbyterian Church of Scotland, the State Church. And I would like to look through that history of the State Church very briefly with you and just touch on some highlights, some important names, and some important events that mark the history of the Church of Scotland during the 18th and 19th centuries.
One of the wonderful ministers of that church was a professor of divinity at St Andrews University, his name was Thomas Halle Burton. And I list his name and include him in this brief survey because I would like to encourage you sometime to read Halle Burton. You get a very wonderful, warm, evangelical reform faith that comes through in Halle Burton's writings and also heart-searching and intensely practical sermons. To my mind, he's one of the great figures of the late 17th and early 18th centuries in the history of the Church of Scotland. But Halle Burton, unfortunately, doesn't represent what happened to the Church. If he was just an example of a lot of people, a lot of ministers and attitudes like that in the Church of Scotland, but a kind of dead, reformed orthodoxy began to settle in over this Church, which had fought so long for its spiritual independence and had such a glorious and wonderful history. Churches can lose their traditions quickly and the Church of Scotland did. Before long, we have people who were accurate and orthodox, but very hard, cold in their faith, something I just heard about from Alexander White, the free church minister of Scotland who talked about sanctification by vinegar. Some people are sanctified by vinegar. They are accurate and orthodox, but not very sweet and not very wholesome in their spiritual lives and in their ministries and something like that was taking place in the Church of Scotland at this time. Hearts of the ministers were closed to the message of free grace despite their orthodoxy and closed to the lost in all nations as they resisted the missionary movement, such as the English Baptist and resisted the urgent plea of William Kerry for the Church to become active in the evangelization of the laws throughout the world. It's not long before we have in the Scottish Church what is called the Marrow Controversy. There was a Presbyterian in Scotland, the actuararter Presbyterian, who began to ask candidates coming before the Presbyterian Presbyterian for wicensure and ordination. This question, this was the only Presbyterian Scotland that asked this question, but the candidates coming to the actuararter Presbyterian had to answer the question. Do you subscribe to the following? I believe that it is not sound and orthodox to teach that we must forsake sin in order to come to Christ. I wonder how you would have answered that if you were facing the fathers and brothers of the arterarter Presbyterian. One man stammered and stuttered and could not bring himself to subscribe to that statement and he was denied licensure by the Presbyterian and the General Assembly then had to act, which it did, to condemn the statement as a statement that was false and unsound. Now the statement is a rather complex one and I don't blame people for being confused when they look at it and try to decide whether it's right or wrong, but despite the awkwardness of the language, what the brothers in the Presbyterian actuararter were attempting to do was to preserve the free grace of the gospel. People don't have to clean up their lives, they don't have to qualify for it, they don't have to do anything but come to Christ and in the coming to Christ, Christ brings his own benefits including faith and repentance and so the heart of the Presbyterian was in the right place, but the Church of Scotland rejected that message of free grace and a struggle continued under the leadership of a very famous man named Thomas Boston. Certainly one of the great ministers in the history of the Church of Scotland, ministerate Etrick down near the English border in what is known as the Scottish borders. Thomas Boston was pastor and Thomas Boston fought against the mood of the General Assembly which was in some subtle ways introducing some kind of human preparation or righteousness or qualification for the receiving of the gospel of Jesus Christ. Boston's most famous work which perhaps you know is human nature in its fourfold state. For a hundred years, Boston's fourfold state was a book that was read in Scotland next to the Bible and became tremendously influential in Scottish history and made its way over to this country where Jonathan Edwards read it with great appreciation and many others read it as well. Thomas Boston had a small group of people who followed him called the Marrow men. They had that unusual name because they read and recommended and printed and did everything they could to set forth throughout Scotland the message of an old book which they had discovered written almost a hundred years earlier called the Marrow of modern divinity. So the Marrow men Thomas Boston stood for the free message of the gospel in a day when the understanding of pure and complete grace, efficacious grace as a wonderful gift of God without works. That's anyone should boast was being obscured and lost in Scottish history. Rather pleased to know that one of those Marrow men was the man named John Cahoon as people for now skeleton in Scotland who was minister at Lee and wrote a number of books defending Thomas Boston and the Marrow. There were two great issues at stake here. One was, is anything required before we come to Christ or is coming to Christ the only thing that we need to do? Well the Marrow men said nothing is required but coming to Christ but that begins a lifelong life of activity, faith and repentance and service to the Lord. Nothing is required but simply coming. And the other great issue is can we tell lost people that can we go out and preach the gospel to everybody or do we have to worry about who is the elect and how we should shape and frame this message so that we don't preach it to the wrong people? Well the Marrow men said preach it to everybody, preach the gospel to everyone and that is what the Bible requires us to do and that is what we should do. We should tell everyone that if that person, whoever that person is believes on the Lord Jesus Christ comes to Christ, that person will find eternal life. Well it's clear by this time that the moderates are in control of the Church of Scotland because the Marrow was condemned and the Marrow men were despised as troublemakers in the church. You can read the long quotation from one of Robert Lewis Stevens and short stories which describes the condition in the Church of Scotland at that time. If you can understand the Scottish dialect that's printed there in the syllabus, it's not too hard but read that for a statement from the famous Scottish novelist about this period of history. Describe the moderate ascendancy in the Church of Scotland is described by Stevenson celebrated by the great Scottish poet Robert Burns. It's really sad to think of the life of Robert Burns particularly for a Scott because so much of what Robert Burns wrote is beautiful and of real value in describing human emotions and scenery and much of what makes up life in Scotland but Robert Burns was not a very religious man, certainly not an evangelical Presbyterian. He became a tool and a victim of the moderate ministers in the parish of Aeshaire where he lived. Burns once wrote to a friend these words which tell us pretty much where he stood theologically my creed is pretty nearly expressed by the words Lord Grant that we may lead a good life for a good life makes a good end at least it helps so you don't get a great deal of serious thought in Robert Burns about theological issues he tends more to make fun of the strict Presbyterians and celebrate the triumph of the moderates. There's another man in Scotland John Witherspoon who becomes famous in this country too because he became the first president of Princeton College or not the first president of one of the early presidents of Princeton College in New Jersey and an American patriot. Witherspoon criticized the moderates, he grew up in Scotland during the reign of the moderates. He said that moderate preaching is like a winner's day, it's brief and dark and cold. Well there were two great problems in the church by this time it was really not so much theological orthodoxy because people still claim to believe the Westminster confession so the church had not yet fallen to liberalism but the two problems were dead orthodoxy or he talked about and another problem that we refer to is patronage. That's a Scottish practice in which the land owners were able to have the final say concerning the settlement of a minister. You know in the Presbyterian system the church calls the minister and the Presbyterian approves that call but in Scotland there was this other level. Many of these churches were built on lands that the lords on sometimes they own the churches church buildings and everybody in that area was a servant of that particular lad so that patronage meant that he had the final say if he did not like the minister the church had called church could not call that minister. Well that of course undercuts Presbyterianism at a very vital place so that the congregation is thwarted in its decision to call the minister of the gospel and that problem a patronage along with the problem of dead orthodoxy led to two secession from the church of Scotland not too far apart so we come to the people who called themselves the seceders or they have the covenanters now we're getting the seceders. The first secession took place in 1733 and was led by a man named Ebenezer Erskine very much part of the marrow movement and Erskine and his friends left the church of Scotland because of the two issues that I've talked about doctrinal orthodoxy being held in a cold and formal way but also the problem of patronage. Erskine said what difference does a piece of land made between man and man in the affairs of Christ kingdom well I should the lord have any more say who comes to the church than the servant in the church and so that group of people a small group left the church of Scotland and became what was called the associate presbyterian associate reform presbyterian church today maintains that word which is an honored word in ARP history. Now we have three churches three presbyterian churches in Scotland the covenanters the church of Scotland and the associate presbyterian problems remain in the church of Scotland despite some touch of revival that came in 1742 through the preaching of George Whitfield and the famous Cambusling revival that I've talked about already which interestingly enough came to the church of Scotland not to the small seceding group it wanted to hold Whitfield for themselves Whitfield said I'll preach everywhere even if the Pope of Rome would give me his full that I would preach there so revival came not to the seciders so much as to the church of Scotland but despite the revival there were still problems and soon another church developed you might wonder why this second church did not join the first seciter church but presbyterians in their particularly scots don't do it that easily so another church led by Thomas Gillespie really seceding basically over the same issues created the relief presbytery in 1761 now you take a quick look at other denominations in Scotland before we go back to the church of Scotland and continue the story of that church I've mentioned already the Scottish Episcopal church that church was finally organized in 1766 and then began to grow and flourish even Scottish Episcopalians are high church or not anything like the broad church of the low church in England but high church very much in contrast to the presbyterianism of Scotland and then congregation list and Baptist came into the Scottish picture by the end of the 18th century well the brothers James and Robert Hall they began to preach they were not ministers they were layman but they felt that God was calling them to preach they wanted to be missionaries but hindered in that and so they set out on preaching missions particularly in the highlands and in the islands of Scotland where many people still had not heard the true gospel all these years after the Reformation church of Scotland opposed all of this the whole day mission and viewed these two brothers as unqualified preachers for all they had not gone to seminary and been licensed and ordained properly they were just preaching and church of Scotland did not take kindly to that tried to restrict the ministry of the hall names and these men who remained evangelical Calvinists then became Baptist and through their work both the congregational churches and the Baptist churches began to appear in Scotland not in large numbers but there are Scottish Baptist and congregationalists today that trace their history back to the ministry of James and Robert Hall Day we'll think of a hall names again later because Robert Hall Dayn shows up in Geneva in Switzerland has a great deal to do with the second Swiss Reformation that takes place in the 19th century I should mention to the growth of the Roman Catholic Church in Scotland after the Reformation Catholics were scattered and few in number there were some highlands in the hebrides that remained Catholic in some pockets of Catholics up in the highlands but not many Catholics until the 19th century when there was a great immigration of Irish people to Glasgow and these people were Catholics and so the Catholic church began to grow greatly in Glasgow and in the cities of Scotland and today perhaps the Roman Catholic Church is the strongest church in the land of John Knox well back to the Church of Scotland and renewal and division there was still some spiritual life in the old state church despite all of the problems that I've talked about and the successions that had taken place Alexander Dough became the church's first missionary went to India 1829 and missions began to be then part of the life of the Scottish Church Robert Murray McShane was a minister of the Church of Scotland who emphasized missions abroad and godliness at home in his short life as minister of Saint Peter's in the town of Dundee McShane he died when he was only 30 had a tremendous impact on Church of Scotland as well as religious life in Scotland the memoir of McShane by Andrew Bonar friend and fellow minister he's certainly one of the great books of Scottish Church history Robert Murray McShane had the practice of praying on Saturday before his services in Saint Peter's in Dundee on Sunday and those were lengthy times of prayer once a friend asked him do you never omit those do you never get so busy that you just skip that Saturday time of private prayer and McShane's answer was what would my people do if I don't pray he was concerned not only to preach on Sunday but to pray a long time on Saturday for people of his church the year that Robert Murray McShane died 1843 that year was an important year in Scottish Presbyterian history because there was a major division in the church of Scotland in 1843 the climax of what is called the 10 years conflict this is called the disruption of 1843 use words like the seciders and the disruption to describe the breaks in the history of the Church of Scotland the two succeeding groups were relatively small but the disruption church was large over 400 ministers and 400 elders at least one third of the Church of Scotland left the established church in protest against a loose erasianism which at its cold heart had no love for the old gospel and now we have another church the fifth Presbyterian Church in Scotland called the free Church of Scotland the first moderator of that free Church was Thomas Chalmers he had been in the state church in fact he was already ordained a minister in the state church before he was converted he was converted reading Pascal's ponsace and reading William Wilberforce's real Christianity it's always interesting to me to see the impact that these great books make through church history and we've studied Pascal's ponsace and Wilberforce's real Christianity and now those two books are the ones that God uses to bring Thomas Chalmers to himself Chalmers wrote then I am now most thoroughly convinced that on the system of do this and live there is no peace it is believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and that shall be saved there are other leaders in that new church the free Church of Scotland William Cunningham was a great friend of Charles Hodges and Cunningham was the professor of church history and theologian at the free church college in Edinburgh author of the two volume historical theology which is still a very valuable set of books joining with Chalmers and Cunningham was a very interesting man called John Duncan his friends called him Rabbi Duncan he was not a Jew but he had been a missionary to the Jews in Budapest and he taught Old Testament at the college it was a very interesting man because he liked to talk about all sorts of things and his students remembered the things that he said in fact there's a new book published by batter truth trust called Justa Talker sayings of Rabbi John Duncan so many quotable things from John Duncan like this every sin will be adequately punished blessed be God not every center of John Duncan was able to take some great thoughts and put them in short statements of a sentence or two and he's a wonderful person to study to get some very crisp and nice quotations for your sermons somebody said John Duncan was the only man I ever knew who appeared to believe and to love every word of God without preferring one above another that's a wonderful testimony to John Duncan we started a class with a prayer from Horatius Bonar who is called Scotland's chief singer one of the greatest of the come writers of Scotland I love his hymns including I heard the voice of Jesus say not what these hands have done and go labor on spin and be spin well it appeared then with the establishment of the free church of Scotland that finally there was a strong evangelical Bible believing missionary-minded church in Scotland but before many years there was trouble in the new church we come to the trial the ecclesiastical trial of William Robertson Smith he was a member of the free church of Scotland teaching in one of the free church colleges but he was very much attracted to the higher criticism coming from Germany there's an old saying that theology is created in Germany corrected in Scotland and corrupted in America think the Scots must have made that up or I'm sure they did but in in this case the theology was created in Germany but it was not corrected in Scotland it was consumed in Scotland by William Robertson Smith his article on the Bible in the 1875 edition of the encyclopedia Britannica alerted people to the fact that teaching at a free church college in Scotland was a man who really held to the higher critical views coming out of Germany and for about five years there was great turmoil in the church along ecclesiastical trial that people followed with a great deal of interest reading every word spoken by people on both sides of the issue actually the culmination of that trial was the expulsion of Robertson Smith from his teaching post in the church but despite what seemed to be a victory for the conservatives the decision that case there was a growing willingness on the part of people in the free church to accept the higher critical views in 1883 the moderator who was Horatius Bonar that year warned the church that fellowship between faith and unbelief must sooner or later be fatal to the former sounds like something I heard from Richard John Newhouse which he calls Newhouse's law where orthodoxy is optional orthodoxy will sooner or later be prescribed well by this time we have a number of Scottish Presbyterian churches various church unions among the half dozen or more Presbyterian churches culminated in 1929 in the union of the Church of Scotland and the United Free Church now I'm not going to try to describe all of that it is most complex that United Free Church was formed in 1900 with the union of the Free Church of 1843 and the United Presbyterian Church which was a church that originated in 1847 from those Sissita groups that I talked about earlier which experienced of a wilderness series of unions and sissums so if you're interested in trying to work this out get a chart and you might be able to follow it but the upshot of it all was that most of the Scottish Presbyterians come back together in 1929 in the Church of Scotland in a way everything ends up where it began but let me say before we close where there is an evangelical witness in the Church of Scotland or in Scotland today among Presbyterians I think we could look in two places there is a continuing free church there were people go back to the 1843 disruption who refused to go into the various mergers and maintain a separate existence today as the free church of Scotland they were called because there were not all that many of them they were called by the Scots the We Freeze but the We Freeze continue with a free church college in Edinburgh right next to new college on the mile and churches particularly in the highlands and out on the islands it's my privilege last summer to be on the island of Lewis and to go to the free church that's torn away these churches conduct their services in Gallic as well as in English in fact they have two churches that meet simultaneously in two different buildings one church but two congregations the English and the Gallic I wanted to go to the Gallic to hear the Psalms singing in Gallic but my host and host is that you really ought to go to the English church so you'll know what's going on so I did attend service there the free church people use only the Psalms they don't use instruments in their service but they sing very well long Presbyterian sermons very orderly services back when you go into a free church there's no music playing and nobody is talking absolute silence and people fill out the fuse not just sitting all over the place but you fill it up in a very orderly manner the service in in storm away that little town in the outer Hebrides had 800 people there Sunday morning in the English service I don't know how many were over in the Gallic service and our host and host is my son was with me we're staying with members of the church invited us to come back for the Sunday evening service which we did and we found the same 800 people back again which surprised me but they said well we go to church twice and same people back for the evening service in fact I heard that that little church denomination early big church building way up in the almost the remotest part of the British Isles has the largest Sunday evening church attendance of any church in the British Isles there's no church in London that can produce 800 people Sunday night well the free church is still there and is an honorable group of people they do struggle with a lot of things struggle to break out of their cultural isolation and I think most gods view the free churches really not going to be a very vital factor in the church life in the in the land but we can pray that God will bless these people give them unity which they need and peace and a missionary vision and a heart for the Lord they have the they have the worship and the doctrine they can only get the fire to go with it they can move out of their isolation into a much more prominent role in the life of Scotland but the other place you can look for evangelicals today in the church of Scotland or in the Presbyterian scene in Scotland is within the church of Scotland the church of Scotland has not had a strong evangelical movement like the Church of England but there is the beginnings the hopeful beginnings of an evangelical movement within the church of Scotland due to the work of men like William Still in Aberdeen and Eric Alexander who was pastor at St. George's Tron in Glasgow sing clear Ferguson who until recently taught at Westminster Seminary but is now returning to Glasgow to be pastor of that same church Rutherford House in Edinburgh church of Scotland study center the Scottish Bulletin of Evangelical Theology edited by David Wright who is senior lecturer in ecclesiastical history at the University of Edinburgh so some good things are happening and we can trust that God will return strong reform witness to the land of John Knox seeing that we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses let us run with perseverance the race that is marked out for us well I knew if I got started on Scotland I would take the whole time so