<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bantu Bantu Bulanan

Respect for Human Life, II

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

As we begin that class, I'd like to read the first question and answer from the Heidelberg Catechism. Question is, what is your only comfort in life and in death that I am not my own but belong body and soul in life and in death to my faithful Savior Jesus Christ? He has fully paid for all my sins with his precious blood and has set me free from the tyranny of the devil. He also watches over me in such a way that not a hair can fall from my head without the will of my father in heaven. In fact, all things must work together for my salvation because I belong to him, Christ by his Holy Spirit assures me of eternal life and makes me wholeheartedly willing and ready from now on to live for him. Lord we thank You for the great comfort that the gospel brings to us. The gospel of life and salvation. And we pray that we may live in the light of this truth, that we may have the same respect for physical life that You do, and that we may have the same motivation to spread Your gospel that motivated the reformers who wrote this wonderful Catechism. Be with us in our generation we pray to uphold Your Word. We ask for Jesus' sake. Amen. The issue that we have left under respect for human life. This is a point E, the fifth point, is human embryo research. This was in the news this last week as the Senate held hearings on federal funding for human embryo stem cell research. And I'll explain a little bit about what that means. The current law in the handout that I gave you last time on the reverse side of significant events in a new life is the current law on federal funding of human embryo research. So you can read that there. None of the funds that made available in this act may be used for the creation of a human embryo or embryos for research purposes. And research in which a human embryo or embryo is destroyed, discarded or knowingly subject to risk or injury or death greater than that allowed for research on fetuses in utero is forbidden. And notice the how they define human embryo or embryos, any organism, and not protected as a human subject and so forth, that is derived by fertilization, pathogenesis, cloning, or any other means from one or more human gametes that's the sperm and egg or human diploid cells that's the union of the sperm and egg cell. Now on the last page of this handout is on stem cell research into human embryo, a Christian analysis, under point two, how are scientists able to obtain these cells that they give two means by which they were obtained. The Wisconsin team obtained its cells from surplus embryos donated by fertility clinics. We have frozen embryos accumulating at the rate of 10,000 a year that are not wanted by those who can deceive them. And so the last time I checked it's been three or four years. We have 50,000 of these that are simply being maintained in frozen form. And so these were donated by the clinics and for research. The other research team at Johns Hopkins derived their stem cells from a boarded fetal tissue. There is now a third means by which human stem cells are derived that you might want to just append a note there. Michael West, who is the head of a company called Advanced Cell Research, has cloned human embryos, removing the genetic material from cows, eggs, and inserting human cell tissue. And so that's the third area that is from which of these stem cells are derived. And human embryos now have been created by cloning. That's just last month in Great Britain there was a recommendation from the agency that is responsible for essence in these things to allow that, allow cloning as a source of embryos for stem cell research in Britain. So this is where the current issue is. And there are all sorts of advantages that come from stem cells that have a great potential, very moving testimony, very emotional testimony by Christopher Reed. The idea that you can replace a spinal cord as well as treat Parkinson's disease and a number of these things, so is the great potential good that could be done from embryo stem cell research. Now in the way in which this is reported, typically you get a dismissive phrase that this is all affected by abortion politics, and if we didn't have abortion politics and there wouldn't be any question about this research going forward, well I say thank God for abortion politics, let me explain what I mean by that, there are at least some people who are holding the line trying to hold the line in terms of federal funding that would further institutionalize abortion in this country. It's been going on for some years since the 70s, since the Roe v. Wade, there has been the one area where pro life movement has been able to hold the line is on federal funding of abortion or federal funding of research that involves abortion. The idea is that Roe v. Wade established the right of a woman to choose abortion, but that's different from approval of abortion, which would be if we get into federal funding that goes beyond tolerance to sanction and beginning in the 70s there was a strong movement to resist. Even with the abortion on demand, taking that as a face value as the right to choose abortion, right to choose abortion doesn't mean that the state may not express its non-complicity in abortion by refusing federal funding. It's just the one edge of the whole, the one fingernail hole that has been in effect for the last year. It begins with fetal tissue research, there is a distinction between fetal tissue research and live fetal research, research on human beings in the room from implantation to birth has been denied federal funding since 1975, even if that fetus is going to be abortion aborted, you cannot experiment on that. So federal funding of live fetal research is permitted only if the experiment is therapeutic for that particular child, you know, the experimental surgery of Spina Bifida and so forth, that is therapeutic for that particular child, or somehow necessary for gathering information poses no risk to the child, now that's still on the books that you may not experiment on a fetus in the room, even though it's scheduled for abortion, even though a woman has a legal right to choose abortion, the living fetus is still treated as a subject with human dignity. That's the value of having that law denying federal funding, of course, in private clinics that are not federal funding that may be gone, but at least it doesn't have public support through taxation and fetal tissue research, on the other hand, involves the use of tissue following the death of a fetus, and those have been going on without, in the early part of the century, without much success, but and use of such tissue from spontaneous abortions or miscarriage, or from indirect abortion, or not the issue, the issues, whether we should allow such research in terms of federal funding, of tissue research using induced abortion,

fetuses from induced abortion, now there's an interesting development here, I want just to share with you, in 1988, the Bush administration banned the federal funding of fetal tissue research using aborted fetuses for transplant. That was by administrative order. That ban was rescinded by President Clinton, January 22, 1993. That was his first act on assuming office. It was in your face to the pro-life movement because they were gathered there on the anniversary of Roe v. Wade to protest abortion, and he did that. Now, by administrative fiat, he removed that ban. Now, what gets glossed over is that later in that year, it was actually June 10, 1993 that the president signed into a bill passed by Congress that permitted fetal tissue research

on aborted fetuses. It would pass overwhelmingly. It's the National Institutes of Health Reauthorization Act. The Senate 96-4, the House of Representatives, is 283-13. It's not just President Clinton. You're strong, congressional support of this, and as one person who was sympathetic to this move has said, the irresistible pull of progress in the end trumps moral concerns. I fear that's true. I fear that's true, but we should recognize there was overwhelming support of that in Congress, and the argument shifted this way. Of course, we may not do evil that good may come, but the argument was, can't we at least bring good out of evil? Granted that abortion is evil, can't we at least do some good with this fetal tissue that otherwise would be incinerated. The act included a number of safeguards that helped gain congressional support. Doctors performing the abortion must certify that the women specifically consented to the abortion before being asked to donate fetal tissue. Decision has to be made and didn't you ask, and also banned the purchase from standard abortion procedures. She had to certify that she doesn't know who the recipient is, and so they were these safeguards, including it made it a felony to purchase or sell the tissue for profit, but it did allow reasonable charges to be paid to companies that extract and transfer the tissue to researchers. Now, a pro-life activist at the time said, I'll quote one, how long before we have an unregulated fetus industry in which the organs of unborn babies are bought and sold as commonly as pints of blood, and the answer that is about five years. This was the story that broke the last fall. It was a good report in World of Magazine in October last year of the sale of fetal tissue for transplant, fetal body parts with price tags attached, brain, foot, whatever you want. It's a grotesque industry and was featured on one of the evening news programs, and congressional hearings were held, but as so often happens, the pro-research of forces

attacked the witness. They attacked the whistleblower and attacked his motivation, and nothing came of it. There's all this big noise that body parts from aborted babies are being sold

for profit, and that's a felony, but no one is really interested in pursuing that to go to the trouble of finding out how it's done, but there is a symbiotic problem. There's a relationship between researchers and abortion clinics in which it's to the advantage of abortion clinics to have these folks on site where they can have access to the body parts, and it's clear that the law is being circumvented. It's just one of those areas where all parties claim no one is buying or selling fetal tissue. One of those areas where people were shocked, even those who had supported the idea of abortion were shocked by buying

and selling fetal tissue. Spokesperson from Planned Parenthood said it was inappropriate. That's not a strong moral critique, but the subject was changed in the House hearings, and so a moral dilemma is obscured. There's a very great hardness of heart on this issue, so

that any question of that. What it would take to enforce the law shows how we ought not to so easily be distracted by safeguards. We have to ask, are the safeguards enforceable?

Is there the will to enforce the safeguards, and it was predicted at the time by a stoop pro-life activist that it would be not likely? Now, the progress overcame the scruples, the embryonic stem cell research is at the same place in the debate. I think that it's very

courageous for people to oppose this on principal grounds, but it is a living human embryo. Those who argue the other side, I won't take time to go into the details of the stem cell research. You've got the two-page analysis there, but those are on the other side, Michael West of

advanced cell technology, for example, is quoted in Nature Medicine, asked the question this way. It does a blastocyst, that's the one cell embryo that begins developing, as I go

that develops to a blastocyst over a few days, does a blastocyst warrant the same right and reverence as that accorded a living soul, a parent, a child or a partner who might die, because we fail to move the moral line. I think that my response to that would be, we don't draw the moral line. If we move the moral line, it can be moved anywhere. Indeed, as Arthur Kaplan,

University of Pennsylvania said before the committee, we don't live in a world of moral absolutes. Well, what that means is, if there are no moral absolutes, then nothing is forbidden. We

used to say, if God is dead, everything is permitted, well, you can state it the other way too, if we don't live in a world of moral absolutes, then nothing is forbidden. It's not, is the moral line something that is under our control, or is the moral line something that we discover. The other question is, there's a great resistance to the idea that an embryo

is a living human being. It begs the question. If you put it in terms that term, does a blastocyst have the same rights as a person whose life we might say, then, of course, you feel the pull of that argument. The question is, what is the status of the blastocyst? Is that a living human being? If you watch the news, you saw that exchange between Senator Figaro and that exchange between Senator Figaro's name from Pennsylvania. Yeah, specter, Arlen Specter, and the opponent of Stim cell research, who raised the issue of experimentation of human beings and Nazi Germany, and Senator said, Senator Specter said, but those were living human beings, and the answer came right back. This is a living human embryo. This is a living human being. I think that there's a line from Paul Ramsey. You might want to take this down, not to be tested on, but because I think that it's so much to the point. This goes back several years when cloning first was on the horizon as a theoretical possibility. He said this, the good things that men do, the good things that men do, can be made complete only by the things they refuse to do. I guess a great line. The good things that men do can only be made, can be made complete only by the things they refuse to do. There are some moral lines. Not for us to move the moral line in terms of the good consequences that we can get out of. You know, consequentialism is a principle for tyrants, and its tyrants over embryos and fetuses as well as a born human beings. If you draw the line, then nothing is forbidden. The good things that men do, can be made complete only by the things they refuse to do. Is it abortion politics? Well, I don't dismiss that. It's trying to hold on to the dignity of the human being from its beginning, the life of every human being begins at conception. Now, there are alternatives that are ways to embryo stem cell research that have the same results. In Nature magazine, in February, there's a feature article on stem cell research with both the ethical issues and the scientific issues drawn up. Adult, there's more possibility or as much possibility from using adult stem cells as they are from embryonic stem cells, and in the case of a particular adult, there's no rejection possible in terms of cells from his own body. So we really need to not think that we're shut into all these horrors of nobody will be able to help. It's moving the research in other direction, putting federal funding into adult stem cell research. I think it's a significant issue. You might say that with open abortion, with abortion-owned demand, how can we allow abortion-owned demand? Is there any point in trying to hold on to the dignity of the embryo and not to using human embryos for research purposes? I think that there is great deal of interest in that. Well, I think that I have a problem with it. I think that it's forbidden knowledge. If it ought not to have been gained, it ought not to be used. I feel the pull in the other direction, and I'm not suffering from Parkinson's disease, but I think that those who have it and refuse to involve themselves in a borty fetal tissue are it now? It would be stem cells or that. The embryonic stem cells are from a five to seven-day embryo. That's due blastocyst stage, normally before implantation and a natural childbirth. There is also primordial germ cells that are taken from a six-week embryo, so experimentation is going on up to six weeks. The germ cells are the sperm and egg, and research on human beings without their consent. Yes, especially disturbing is the consequentialist ethic that the end justifies the means. All of this progress, all of this good that can be done, overcomes any scruples, and you feel the pull of that. I mean, that's so much. But if God has forbidden it, then there are other ways to approach doing good in these same areas. Well, not to make it dependent upon this research. How murky it becomes in future times, because it's hard to separate out in the future what has come from where. So we may face some hard questions later on. Yes, sir. It is troubling. I'm not sure what to do with it. Once it's there, I think that once it's there and is common knowledge, the source of it was evil, but knowledge is knowledge. And I'm not sure what to think about that. So it's a good question. I think to resist participating in it while it's still in its experimental stage to encourage it being done, at some point the question may become loot. How can you separate out what went into research? That may be impossible to do. And so I don't really have a firm position on that. I think that really we're talking about federal funding. This is going on in private companies. And why should we bother to hold the line? The argument is this would be controlled if it's under federal funding. Well, that's a private companies are going to go on to develop what they will for profit motives anyway. So I don't know that making the federal government a competitor is going to have that kind of control. And it really involves in my judgment it involves the society in complicity with what is morally repugnant. I don't think that folks who believe that the life of every human being begins a conception and should be treated with dignity and respect from that event. And should be forced to support, to further entrench that as a social issue. Well, I wanted to say something about that because that's the cutting edge of where nascent human life is now. My topic was respect for nascent human life. That's the rationale for keeping abreast of where we're going as a society with experimentation on human beings for now at the embryonic stage. If we can move the line then we can move the line further along. Is the line ours to move and what is the status of that living being in the womb or now in vitro. And we need to move on to what is the sixth major heading which I'm going to call respect for the natural end of human life. Respect for the natural end of human life and I'm underscoring natural there on the basis of the biblical passages such as Psalm 90 verse 10. Days of his years of three score in ten if they be eighty years it's with sorrow and so forth. Not many people at present live past a hundred. Now there's another area of research developing that promises open ended aging. We need to look at that too. Keep up with the bioethics website that I shared with you that address for these developments. There is an article already on analyzing that aspect of this. Ecclesiastes 32 is another one of those texts. In the fallen world there's a time to be born and a time to die and I think that we may paraphrase that. There's a time to resist death and there's a time to cease resisting. And what is that time is a matter of discernment. So it's respect for the natural end of human life knowing when to resist death and knowing when it's time to cease resisting. PCA report. I won't go into them here. List five biblical principles in it's the heroic measures report. I just want to list them and don't try to take these down there in there in the handout so that you can get them. First is God is sovereign over human life. You would expect us to begin there as Presbyterians but it's an important point. Interact with it. Second physical death is a relative evil. It's spiritual death that's the absolute evil. Physical death is a relative evil. We may give up our lives for the sake of the gospel for example. Third life is to be lived to its full extent to the glory of God. We use Philippians there where Paul even the Passie Quarge says to depart and be with Christ is far better yet lives on full to the full in terms of his calling before God. Number four life is not to be abandoned on account of suffering. Our text there is Jesus word to Peter at the end of the gospel of John. Peter wants to know what about John. When you're old Jesus says to Peter you'll be somebody else will dress you and take you where you don't want to go and you follow me and he's talking about the kind of death Peter would die. Now what people fear is not so much pain as loss of control. That comes out again and again in these studies. Pain we know can be controlled. People do not fear pain so much as they fear being dependent on somebody else. Nobody wants other people to change their diapers at the end of life. Now that is what people don't like. So they have that loss of autonomy. I don't want to be dependent especially in this country we have that strong independence that works against us. Well we don't want to suffer in being a burden on anybody. And Jesus says follow me. He determines how we may glorify God through our death and being recipients of the service of others as well as the willing giving of it in terms of our ministry here is part of God's plan, part of God's purpose in a fallen world. Then the fifth point is imminent death is to be met with realism and readiness. We use the patriarchs there. They're ages from us from technology but the recognition that death is near and with final ministry to family and so forth is appropriate. Francis Schaeffer is our model there in the last stages of Schaeffer's life. He made that tour to promote the film, how should we then live and the Mayo Clinic said to Edith we're not going to he's going to have to come in and have more radical stuff and in the hospital. And Schaeffer said let me go home. It's time for me to die. Don't intervene and so he for went the equipment that would have maintained him for a few more days in order to be at home in the circle of his family and friends ministering and being ministered to that is a legitimate decision. It's time for me to die and to recognize when that time comes and that life is not just mere length of days that we must extend as long as we possibly can using whatever technology means is available. We need a definition of euthanasia. I have a number of preliminary things before that you can get those biblical principles from the PCA report but I'm using a definition of euthanasia that was put out by the U.S. Roman Catholic bishops in 1996 take this down please euthanasia an action or omission an action or omission which of itself or by intention causes death in order to relieve suffering. Euthanasia comes from the Greek good death it means it means easy death relatively painless death. It's mercy killing is what it really means but the bishops are including in their definition an act of omission is morally culpable so it's not simply mercy killing but it's neglect supposedly out of mercy that would also fall under that definition. An action or omission which of itself or by intention causes death in order to relieve suffering so that's at least the ostensible reason. Now I think that we need to remember the larger catechism questions 135 and 136 on the 6th commandment. Larger catechism treats it in terms of sins of comission and sins of omission. 6th commandment is violated by sins of comission you've heard these before all taking away the life of ourselves or of others except in the case of public justice rigorously control capital punishment lawful war just in both cause and conduct as we expanded on that or necessary defense that is imminent threat to innocent life. All taking away of our life of ourselves or others except under those limited conditions and sins of omission which they define as neglecting or withdrawing the lawful and necessary means of preservation of life. Very carefully crafted phrase and highly relevant to this moment in our thinking through of the ethical issues neglecting or withdrawing the lawful and necessary means of preservation of life. It's a good phrase all taking away that's the sin of comission but also neglecting or withdrawing the lawful and necessary means of preservation of life that is the sin of omission. Now when we come to terminal decision making that is when death is imminent there are I think we should distinguish three categories of decision. I think we should distinguish between killing and neglect both of those are morally wrong sin of comission killing the sin of omission as the larger cataclysm defines it neglect. I think that there is a third category of non intervention in the dying process that ought not to be confused with neglect which is morally culpable omission. We need three categories of distinction between killing an act of comission neglect which is a sin of omission and a morally right decision not to intervene in the dying process. Putting to death is killing the phrase allowing to die is not specific enough to make this distinction allowing to die could mean culpable neglect but allowing to die could mean non intervention in the dying process as futile. I'll talk about the criteria for non intervention later but it's a great advantage to the proponents of euthanasia to blur these distinctions and to talk about killing as active euthanasia and to bracket these as tacit euthanasia. And so when it comes you know so that non intervention morally just a morally appropriate non intervention gets blurred in with culpable neglect and the argument goes since you approved non intervention passive euthanasia why don't you approve active euthanasia. There's a very great rhetorical issue involved in how these terms are used so be on guard and try to sort that out. I think we need three categories and the term passive euthanasia tends to blur that distinction and to create by applying it to non intervention to create a favorable attitude toward euthanasia. Well that's my concern anyway. Take it and see what you do with it. I have I'm going to treat this under three major headings and the first heading is neo natal neglect. This refers to newborns the neglect of handicap newborns is what this is talking about. And there's a case on record that I think is worth remembering worth recalling the case of baby dough. This was a case that goes back to 1982 Bloomington Indiana child born with down syndrome and a deformed esophagus was allowed to die of starvation and dehydration was allowed to die of neglect. The esophagus could have been corrected by routine surgery had it not been for the down syndrome it would have been corrected but the parents decided against treatment they did not want a retarded child. And so baby dough was allowed to die only because she was a down syndrome baby now what turned out at that time. That this is not that uncommon. We're not talking about babies that are born dying in which heroic measures are futile an anticellic baby a baby is born without a brain is going to die a few days a baby with only a brain stem is not going to live. And so you make that child comfortable there are those who we have a case in Florida baby Teresa which folks wanted her to be killed in order to provide organs for transplants she's going to die anyway. So why not salvage these organs if we wait for her to die they'll deteriorate and won't be available for transplant and the consequentialist ethic was was used in that case or to hell the line it would not allow her to be killed for body parts. But we're talking about lives that can be saved and would be saved were there no handicap down syndrome spina bifida but we learned at the time that it it's common in the United States to with whole routine surgery and medical click care from infants with down syndrome for the explicit purpose of hatesening death that's a form of omission that is euthanasia by omission. And it turned out that this was more common than we really noted there was even a quality of life formula that was applied to infants to whether decide to treat them or not based on the idea of little or no hope for achieving meaningful humanhood. And down syndrome is is the classic case although you know there's a very down it's clear the down syndrome babies grow up to be adults with a great interaction blessing to their families that those who have had them. Now in the in the coverage of of the it was a program of neonatal and neglect at Yale management option they called it in the coverage of the Yale management option the Yale medical school management option. Newsweek use the term vegetables in describing certain hand handicap newborns who were allowed to die just vegetables I mean that you know that wasn't there their intention but that's what they that's how they characterize them. Well this producer response from Sandra diamond I just read you her her response I'll wager my entire root system and as much fertilizer is would take to fill Yale University that you have never received a letter from a vegetable before this one but as much as I resent the term I must confess that I fit the description of a vegetable is defined in the article. Due to severe brain damage incurred at birth I'm unable to dress myself toilet myself or write my secretary is typing this letter many thousands of dollars had to be spent on my rehabilitation and education in order for me to reach my present professional status as a counseling psychologist my parents were also told 35 years ago that there was little or no hope of achieving meaningful humanhood for their daughter she was afflicted with cerebral palsy. Have I reached humanhood compare with doctors Duff and Campbell I believe I have surpassed it instead of changing the laws to make it legal to weed out us vegetables let us change the laws so that we may receive quality medical care education and freedom to live as full and productive lives as our potential allow now that's a great letter. And you admire her spirit and the to put our you know to put put our investment as a society to put our money in there money is a factor in these things especially with down syndrome in 1995 American college of OBGYN recommended down syndrome screening for all pregnant women. Now there's no no cure for down syndrome maybe they will get a genetic maybe they'll find the gene like they've done the first breakthrough just current this week for genetic screening in terms of the immune deficiency they finally found that in two kids have been set free from the bubble but that's the only one so far. And what it means usually is a death sentence for the down syndrome fetus now any of centasis is a thousand dollars down syndrome baby in the first year of life is a hundred thousand dollars when you can see how HMO is regard this no we've got a problem we don't have to think about you know what we do with healthcare well following the publicity of the baby do case president Reagan ordered the secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services to apply section 504 of the rehabilitation act of 1973 to handicap infants the act prohibits discrimination against the handicap under any program receiving federal aid well I got to test it in the courts second circuit court decided against the administration and a judgment not to perform certain surgery they're quoting from the descent judgment not to perform certain surgery because a person is black is not a bona fide medical judgment so to a decision not to correct a life threatening digestive problem because an infant has down syndrome is not a bona fide medical judgment. So Congress then amended the child abuse prevention and treatment act to make explicit that withholding a medically indicated treatment from disabled infants with life threatening conditions is included in the definition of child abuse and neglect this is the way to get it you know there's all this uproar about child abuse which I think you know I'm not not depreciating that. But this is a form of child abuse this is a form of child abuse I really bring this out because of the opposition that that move received from Peter Singer now at Princeton University he opposed bringing newborns under the handicap under the child abuse of prevention and treatment act he wrote this at the time. Society cannot coherently hold that it is all right to kill a fetus a week before birth but as soon as the baby is born everything must be done to keep it alive well that's true that is incoherent that is incoherent although we don't exactly say it's all right to kill a fetus we say that a woman may make that choice but I think you know practically we are saying it's all right. So Singer solution since we cannot coherently hold that it's all right to kill a fetus a week before birth as soon as the baby is born to do everything to keep it alive the solution is to abandon the idea that all human life is of equal worth. The reasoning behind that is that the equal worth of human life is is sectarian that's a Christian conviction that you're imposing upon the society at large you see other thing moves you know separation of church and state I mean you get all the big big guns in on an issue like this and claim that it's a sectarian view. Well that view has been influenced by Christian he the question is whether it's right but it is true that the equal worth of human beings is Judeo Christian tradition the question is whether not whether it's sectarian but whether it's true whether that is the way human lives ought to ought to be taught. I used to some neonatal neglect issue because of the singer now going beyond what he said then at the time it was to allow them to die but actually wouldn't it be more merciful to kill them painlessly kill them but you know to let them just starve to death that does it. It seems to be merciful if wouldn't an act of wouldn't it be more merciful just to kill them well you know if if if you agree that they can be neglected to death then if if you know how much difference is there between an act of a sin of omission and a sin of commission. It's the same murderous assault on innocent human life but I would hope that we would rethink neglect you know and that we would rethink abortion what is the difference one week before birth and and a week after birth you know the infant is breathing on his own but is that the key significant event when the baby takes air into its lungs oxygen has been doing all that other stuff via the blood of the mother what what is it that makes the difference there but but in terms of the way in which as I've mentioned before in terms of the way of which the human being is not regarded as a person in the womb. It's the same after birth as before if we define human beings in terms of functioning personhood rather than then we then we lose protection for innocent infant life as well as life in the womb. Yes I say but you get your own show touch by an angel I don't watch it but you know touch by an angel has an evangelical Christian involved and she's the right and the producer and and that that show doesn't appeal to me I don't know why but it's it's there as an alternative thing and it's it has had some programs you know we create an alternative culture. We shouldn't just we you know it's a world in life we need we need folks in every sphere of the culture doing the right thing you know you got my threefold model for social transformation and it's personally really please for example also structural form I'm talking about not just political reform but cultural reform we we need we need folks. We're doing their thing yes sir the most controversial question in that area is giving food is assisted nutrition and hydration a medical intervention and I've given you for factual information may have to delay this till next time but for factual information do dying patients really need IV fluids is written by a nurse who has the technical information what actually goes on in the dying process that we need but I'm sympathetic to your question because when I served on the heroic measures committee of the PCA I went in with a different view but there were ruling elders on that committee who were medical doctors and they had the facts and sometimes it's counterfeit to try to feed a dying person the body shuts down and it can't metabolize and you're hurting them by trying to force feed them and the same is true with with hydration so that and there's a reason there's a reason to turn off machines and that's why I say we need three categories of decision making and non intervention is the third so we're coming to that I feel you're concerned because I've been through that's the problem the most in this area the most thing that I've been most asked in terms of practical question I mean people in our circles are not contemplating a system suicide I think that's a social issue but they do want to know whether it's a sin of omission whether this is whether the larger cataclysms withholding the necessary means of the preservation of life means turning off that respirator I mean isn't air in this I mean isn't oxygen in this and now that's a good question my second main heading is position assisted suicide the article that I have given to you for a handout from the Hastings Center Report last summer promoting autonomy or medicalizing suicide I think is very good analysis from a cultural trend that affects this question let me just highlight a couple of things and then you can work through this on the on the second page was just page 31 in terms of the article and the down at the bottom of that middle column they say in contestably she says in contestably from a certain perspective position assisted suicide is a dramatic expression of autonomy empowerment self determination the life the contemporary debate about death and dying has shifted focus from medical norms to individual rights choices and desires a shift from outer codes to inner individuals okay then at the last paragraph in that column the right hand column yet there's a paradox underlying position assisted suicide it's conceived of as an intimate existential act indeed a response to modern medicine but at the same time it is a request for the complicity of physicians and society this is not just an individual choice this is asking for complicity of the medical profession and society so that in contemporary west society the decision to take death in one's own hands is just construed as an act that is not simply personal private and solitary but contrary to social norms and expectations from a societal perspective the individual who commits or attempts suicide is in this sense an outsider what seems unusual in the debate about aid and dying is the request for public endorsement and legitimization of the act of suicide is the cultural trend for autonomy has overridden the right of society has overridden social norms so we're in a total individualistic frame of mind whose life isn't anyway but it's my life well that's society has an interest in the life of all of its citizens and you can read through the rest of that in terms of that so I think that first of all what we think about suicide is the key issue the civil law does not make suicide a crime in this country and that's also true in great Britain the suicide act of 1961 in Britain you can do this all at once here it goes state by state 1961 decriminalized suicide but at the same time it made aiding or abetting the suicide another of another a crime punishable by up to up to 14 years let me just give you some figures on where we are in terms of the state's and assisted suicide by the way to remove criminalism to decriminalize suicide does not was not approval of suicide was only recognition that it only penalizes the family and because most suicides are associated with depression it's a criminal approach to what's a medical or psychological problem so it was not appropriate area of the civil law to try to criminalize it but assisted suicide 35 states explicitly criminalize assisted suicide the latest of those is Michigan trying to get Dr. Kavorkin in 1999 they finally passed the assisted suicide law 9 states criminalize it through common law not an explicit statute but common law so 35 plus 9 then there in the rest of the states there's only one that explicitly permits the position assisted suicide that's Oregon since 1997 so you've got ambiguity in about five states one state with explicitly permission and if you follow the following Oregon reports it's distressing the safe guards just don't work what what you get is doctor shopping this is reported in that comes out of Oregon a woman really her daughter took her mother to get permission for physician assisted suicide but went first to a psychiatrist and he wouldn't get permission he felt the wasn't so clear to him that that's really what her mother wanted so she shot for another doctor and it went this time to a psychologist and after he didn't at first feel that that was the that warranted assisted suicide either but it ended up a someone in his office made the final decision and got that or just give me a second here I'll give you a reference for the where I got that this is from the weekly standard November 8th of last year final final decision was left to an ethicist administrator and he interviewed Cheney who told him she wanted the pills not because she was in irremediable pain but because she feared not being able to attend to her personal hygiene and he gave the okay for assisted killing you know this this puts once you once you have this in the law you create a permission for it you even create an expectation for it in a culture where people don't want to be a burden on somebody else here's a law it's safe and legal you know there we shouldn't think that this is enhancing patient autonomy this is putting pressure on folks to to take that option once you have the option in law you create a situation which it becomes an expectation now Derek Humphreys the hemlock society had the final exit book writes in his more recent book Freedom to Die he asked the question this is there in fact a duty to die a responsibility within the family unit that should remain voluntary but expected nevertheless I just let that sink into your ears voluntary but expected nevertheless well how voluntary is it you don't want to be a burden you know you the same cards don't work I think that there is I think that it is inevitable that you I think that assisted suicide is the first step in an inevitable process toward voluntary euthanasia I think it's inevitable for this reason that if you can see that a person has the right to physician assisted death then it actually makes more sense to it's more humane to let the physician do the injection if you're relying on pills you can spill the pills you can vomit them up it takes a time it is stressful when all concerned it's inevitable once you accept physician accepted suicide in fact I think it's a stopgap measure because voluntary euthanasia would not pass the referendum but it is inevitable it's an inevitable nest next step and it happened in the Netherlands but it is it is it is inherent in creating the problem it's actually more pro life to have voluntary euthanasia because you've got to take those pills before you get too sick to take them yourself why not wait until I lapse into a coma and then have the doctor inject me I've expressed my wish I can't argue against that if you've argued for physicians the physician assisted suicide so I think it's all all the more reason for us to to to oppose it and I'll have to say something more about that next time and not not get it confused with my the third area which is non treatment of when it's right to reject refused medical intervention well thank you for your attention we'll come back to this topic