<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bantu Bantu Bulanan

The Regulative Principle of Worship

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Father, we thank You for Your faithful love to us in Christ, for Your bringing us from death to life, from the kingdom of darkness into the kingdom of Your Son, for justifying us for adopting us into Your family, for pledging by the blood of Christ Himself that You will one day make us like Him. And we pray, Father, that You would give us hearts that love you, that desire to be faithful to You, to Your Word, submissive to Your Spirit's work in us, and through us. And we pray now that as we look at this specific understanding of what it means to worship the way You desire for us to worship You, that You would give us wisdom and insight, that we would be careful not to step beyond what You have said, but not to be overly restrictive, beyond what You have said either. So we look to You now and seek Your blessing in Jesus' name. Amen. Okay, regular to principle of worship, the RPW, as we sometimes reference it.

I think one of the first things I want to say is that I believe that inherently all Christians everywhere who love Jesus and His Word want to worship God the way God wants to be worshiped. I mean, it's sort of part of being belonging to Christ and wanting to honor Him with our lives.

For me to say as a husband, you know, I really love God, but I don't care what He says about how I'm supposed to treat that. I'm going to do it my way. I mean, I'd be in serious danger to talk about fire coming out and consuming. Might happen if I said that in that. Or to say, you know, I really enjoy spending all of my non-working hours at the casino out there in St. Charles. And, you know, so, you know, borrow to the limit all my credit cards and all that sort of thing. You know, I don't care what God says. You know, I still tie. And that's what really matters. So I can gamble away the rest. You know, I'm married, not three children, and yadda yadda yadda. Well, that's a... Christians don't talk like that or live like that, or at least if we do, we should repent of it and be called out on it. So there's sense in which you don't really care what God says about how He wants to be worshiped. I really like being served communion by people dressed as clouds, mining the Lord's suffer. That happens.

So I guess what I'm saying is that it's part of being a Christian. It's not part of being a Presbyterian to want to worship God the only, to want to worship God the way He wants to be worshiped. Okay. This desire is not... Let's not presume that unless you're committed to the regular principle of worship. You don't care what God thinks about worship. That's very unfair to people beyond the circles that some of us live in. And yet I think the desire to worship God the way He wants to be worshiped is the core of out of which this idea of the regular principle of worship. Gross and develops. The concept of regulating worship has been around for quite a while. The term or the phrase regular principle of worship was actually not used until the 20th century is best as we can discover. So we sometimes talk about the RPW like if we were having a able to have a discussion or an email interaction with one of the Westminster Fathers, you know, they know exactly what we're talking about. You know, remember when you were writing about the RPW? RPW? Oh, he means chapter 21 of the Confession. Oh yeah, I remember now. Yeah, okay. And it's usage in the Presbyterian tradition is from the Westminster Confession 21-1 as we've looked at before. The acceptable way of worshiping the true God is instituted by Himself and so limited by His own revealed will that He may not be worshiped according to the imaginations and devices of men or the suggestions of Satan under any visible representation or any other way not prescribed in the Holy Scripture. Now, to me, the key word in that section of chapter 21 is the word prescribed. What is the meaning of prescribed? Is it only what is commanded is allowed? In other words, to do anything in worship, there must be a direct biblical command or prescription or warrant saying, this is what you must do. Or is it possible that we derive what God wants from direct commands biblical principles and biblical examples? I've mentioned before that if it's the first, we have a hard time coming up with an offering as an element of worship. If it's the second, we're okay because we have apostolic example. If it's only the first, it's a little tough to come up with the first day of the week is the day we're down corporate worship. But if it's the second, we can see from apostolic example and trying to understand what John is saying in Revelation 1 about the Lord's day to be pretty even strong on saying, this is what God wants us to worship on the first day.

There are other relevant confessional statements that I think need to be brought to the discussion of the regular principle of worship. One of them is found in the Westminster Confession of chapter 1, section 6, and I often say, which comes first in the Westminster Confession? It's going to be a tough test question. Chapter 1 or chapter 21? Obviously, chapter 1 comes first. What's to be set in the context of what? I think chapter 21 should be understood, particularly since it's talking about what God is prescribing in His Word, what the confession is already taught in chapter 1 about the nature of the Word of God and what we can learn and understand from it should inform our understanding of 21.1. So let's look at what? 1.6 says. It's a great statement. The whole Council of God concerning all things necessary for His own glory, man's salvation, faith and life, pretty comprehensive there, is either expressly set down in scripture or by good and necessary consequence may be deduced from scripture. Some of the things about how long a sermon should be, or how many sermons we should have, or whatever is by good and necessary consequence derived from scripture rather than finding a direct passage. unto which nothing at any time is to be added whether by new revelations of the Spirit or traditions of men. Nevertheless, we acknowledge the inward illumination of the Spirit of God to be necessary for the saving understanding of such things as are we viewed in the Word. And that there are some circumstances concerning the worship of God and government of the church, common to human actions and societies which are to be ordered by the light of nature and Christian prudence. According to the general rules of the Word, which are always to be observed, that's a bit of a mouthful, but I think very helpful. What a good statement of faith or doctrinal standard like the Westminster standards does for us is it does sort of set the parameters of the room that we're to live in as we use that analogy we've talked about already. And this first chapter is doing that in terms of our understanding of scripture which is the vehicle God uses to set the parameters of all kinds of rooms in the Christian life. And here that's what the writers, the Westminster fathers are doing and with some application even to the worship of God explicitly stated in the statement.

There are some circumstances concerning the worship of God, common to human actions and societies which are to be ordered by the light of nature and Christian prudence. According to the general rules of the Word which are always to be observed, that's arguing, I believe, for biblical principle, applies to some of the figuring out what we do in worship. What's required and where we have some liberty of application and practice. Now the question is what is included in circumstances? What is the meaning of the word prescribed in 21-1 and what's the meaning of the word circumstances in 1-6? If we could have complete agreement on that, those two words we'd have complete agreement well a lot more agreement than we do right now on the narrow or broader understanding of the regular principle of worship. And where we stand on that should be informed by, I believe, most informed by scripture with the guide of this confession.

So how does 1-6 relate to 21-1? I think 1-6 allows 21-1 to breathe a little bit, particularly in areas where the Bible doesn't tell us what we're to do. Are we to come forward to receive the elements of the bread and the cup in the Lord's Supper? Or should we remain seated? Or should we get in a big circle around the perimeter of the worship space? Well, I haven't found any passages scripture that reference that. So what does that mean? Well, if we have to have the Bible tell us something before we can do it then I guess we can't have communion because we don't know whether we're to sit or come forward or stand in a circle around the room. Well certainly that would be contrary to what the Bible wants because as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes seems to be saying he wants us to eat the bread and drink the cup but he's it doesn't tell us specifically how to do that logistically. So what the manner of administering the elements of the Lord's Supper fall under circumstances where you would use what? The general rules of the word and the light of nature and Christian prudence. So for instance

if you have a congregation of people many of whom are not able physically to get up and walk and come forward or even get to the outer perimeter of the room you may decide that sort of Christian prudence and the light of nature namely how well people can walk would mean that you should probably serve the congregation in their seats even though you may be personally convinced that it could be more meaningful and significant to do it in some other way or in other circumstances you might do it differently. Some people have argued a very narrow definition of both prescribed and circumstances to say that circumstances only has to do with the appointed hour for gathering for corporate public worship and the arrangement of furniture in the worship space. It's a circumstance whether you sit on the floor, stand, sit in chairs, pews or indoors outdoors kind of the place and time of worship that's all it's talking about there. Well I happen to think that it's more than that. Some people argue that it's only Psalms it's without instruments you know they argue for let's just assume that it's kind of that minimalist perspective that we looked at last time from the English Puritans. You still have to decide which Psalms you're going to say and how many and what passage you're going to preach from and for how long and how many preachers are going to preach today. Does the Bible say one preacher only? Well I was preaching in covenant church the one preacher of the day there were others present but not preaching others far better than me present and not preaching which is another whole question in itself should you always yield to the best preacher and who decides who the best preacher is. Anyway that's another it's another course to probably answer that either but come closer than this course. While I was doing that a covenant three of the assistant pastors at Chesterfield were taking a turn at preaching in the same service so Chesterfield had three three three many service. Well covenant had one so that's you know that's that fall under general circumstances as the Bible addressed that specifically. If it if it doesn't say how long the sermon should be does that mean I can't preach no I still preach and I figure out what seems best for this people on this day in terms of where I am in the scripture and how I present it and you know whether or not the Bible doesn't say that you should preach from a pulpit so does that mean we shouldn't have pulpit

or whether or not you have a pulpit fit under circumstances of worship where there's room to figure that out in a place a local church specific kind of way. Another passage that Dr. RJ Gore has introduced to the discussion is in his in his latest in his new book covenant to worship reconsidering the regulative that the Puritan RPW. He references chapter 20 verse 2 God alone is Lord of the conscience and hath left it free from the doctrines and commandments of men which are in any way anything contrary to his word or beside it if matters of faith or worship. What he argues is that this seems to give room for what I would call varying applications of the regulative principle of worship the binding of the conscience is not something that's intended and you have this sort of strange dynamic going on as they the Puritans more than anyone else are saying to the Church of England don't bind our consciences but do they turn to others and say without intending to bind the consciences of others by saying you can't do this you can't do this you can't do this so they sort of bound the consciences of others around this minimal place because the Bible doesn't explicitly say so when I think the Bible does generally say so and gives room for specific expansion and application you know David expanding the musical instrumentation and vocalist in worship with the temple was a huge step forward from Moses as we saw in our biblical survey earlier but I think David felt he was on good solid ground and consistent with the principle that had been revealed and had room and liberty to do that we don't have recording that I can find of a dust say at the Lord you should now have 4,000 in the Levites it's sort of like it seemed good to us in the worship of God to strengthen the worship of God with Psalm and worship by having people devoting themselves to music at the temple day and night and providing the instruments to David and even creatively making new instruments so it never meant maybe for potentially to be used in the worship of God just because the Bible didn't mandate it didn't inhibit or prevent David consistent with what God has said and just look at all the Psalms that even the David wrote about praising God with this instrument and that instrument and so on and so forth that are there so I'm in favor of a variety of multiple valid applications of the regular principle of worship that focus more on the biblical elements that the Bible mandates and less on the particular implementation and application and arranging of those elements in a given time and place

and I think that in the long stream coming from Calvin to the present even in reformed represbyterian circles I think that's most consistent with our heritage and not out of accord with 21 1 and 1 6 now some people think you can't make such a statement like I did but you restate that statement again if I can at least we have it on video you said focus more on the biblically mandated elements of worship of prayer and scripture reading and preaching and singing Psalms and spiritual songs and observing the sacraments and so on collecting of offerings and and give lots of room for the the way the manner which those get expressed and the arranging of those in order of worship that's more place specific time and place specific that's not out of accord and my understanding of rpw and as I try to point out in what the statement about the directory of worship earlier I don't think it's out of accord with what they told parliament about their own directory of worship that it wouldn't wouldn't be pressing too much and opportunity for new things to come I mean I think I think it's consistent even with these guys here's what I think was going on now again it's speculation I'm living you know 350 years plus past the the writing of the confession but I think and frame and gore both say this and others I think they wrote a document

particularly if you bring the directory of the Westminster directorate worship into the discussion

that gave more room for future generations than they themselves were practicing

and as Dr. Calhoun pointed out one day at a faculty meeting in this very room

when we were discussing this particular issue

the the Scottish covenanters of the the Scottish Presbyterians who were mainly observers of the Westminster assembly their practice of the celebration of the Lord suffer was to set tables with chairs around them in the front of the worship space and have people come out of their rows and be seated at table and be served around the table and then go back to their rows till everybody came up and was seated at a table and then served and went back which is sort of taking this fellowship meal idea from the butcher was emphasizing that influence on Calvin that then had influence on Knox which had influence on the Scottish Presbyterians there's some movie I can't remember the name of it that was set in like Northern Scott on somewhere probably movie 15 years ago which showed early on in the movie I just this sort of all connected up for me when I saw people in a church service it had table set in the front okay it's kind of a Scottish Presbyterian church in a community so now the west the English Puritans at the Westminster assembly felt that the elements of the Lord suffer should be served to people where they're seated in rows and that the the men from Scotland said does that mean that if we're going to adhere faithfully to what comes out of the Westminster assembly we can't celebrate the Lord suffer the way we have to and say oh no it would be okay we'll we'll accommodate to you in the way that you practice things now I mean it seems sort of funny to us that there that that would be of such significance because that we don't have a lot of debate over man or of at least in discussions I can and maybe it's out there maybe internal to some churches but that sort of shows that the latitude and the willingness even at the time to let these Scottish brothers and sisters implement some of the practices a little bit differently than the Puritan English Puritans do so I think that's instructive and maybe helpful instructive in that even there we see flexibility yeah flexibility at the time they're writing this supposedly very narrow understanding and prescribing and circumstances and recognizing that this is not something that is prescribed in the detail that we are you know that to me the key to understanding so much of this and and I I have quite a bit in this is a repeating theme in my dissertation that we dare not confuse biblical principle with the application of a biblical principle for instance

let's suppose that I decide the best way for the congregation to pray the Lord's Prayer is to sing the Lord's Prayer right what's the biblical principle that relates to either the praying with words only or praying with music the Lord's Prayer and worship service what's the biblical principle that relates to that when you pray pray like this okay it's the the element is prayer

and I guess I would say that under the under this heading of prayer the Lord's Prayer is a legitimate actual prayer to pray and a model of ways we should pray all right I decide to sing it that's my application of praying this biblical prayer we're gonna sing it and I think this is so wonderful and so impacting and so faithful to the Bible then I'm gonna say you are not praying the Lord's Prayer properly in your terms unless you sing it what have I done I've turned an application of a biblical principle of prayer in a particular kind of it into the biblical principle itself take what do I put my children in public school Christian school or do I homeschool okay let's suppose I decide to put them in the Christian school and trips home schooling and Eric's public school and Bobby's not gonna sent his to school period or homeschool just gonna defy everything um so we'll leave him out of the discussion that's a different issue okay and and I say to Eric and am I the Christian school then okay I say to trip and Eric the only right way to educate our children is put them in a Christian school so you're not being faithful to God and you're not being faithful to God I've turned a biblical principle of nurturing and educating our children in the Lord I've turned an application a legitimate application into the principle itself you know do it my way and we do this I think a lot of people do this with worship they found a worship expression that is is exciting it's has a sense of being faithful to God it rings true with the worshipers gathered in this time in this place in this level church people's lives are being impacted and changed by the gospel in this worship service and they long to have other people experience the same blessings that they are and some of these people may have come out of other kinds of worship experiences where that wasn't happening and so they sort of are suspicious of anything other than how they do it as being legitimate before God and getting back into the people I mean sort of see how people get there and we can turn lots of good biblical applications of things in worship into new laws for people to have to abide by and I guess that's what I'm that's what I'm most passionately against and when I'm around people who when it comes to style of worship are strict traditionalists I tend to nudge them in affirming what where they are in the principles behind it and say this isn't the only legitimate way that the principles that you hold dear that you're applying in this way have to be done by everybody else and are you paying attention to the demographic realities and generational dynamics and socioeconomic ethnic aspects that there are people's whose voice in song and worship is being pushed down or off to the side potentially because you're so convinced that you're one right way of doing it must be true of every time in place and people in class and so on now when I go to church isn't I've got some of these two where they're committed to all contain up with you will never find a hymnal in this church and we got rid of all of them and organs no way we won't even duplicate the sound of an organ on our keem work that's how anti organ we are well and I'm in those settings I I try to affirm what's right about what they're doing and then sort of nudge them towards you know the world's bigger than where you live sort of thing and maybe challenge the attitude that is a whole lot like the attitude over here okay interesting thing and my goal is not some perfect formula of blended worship I personally don't like the word blended because it seems to be I don't know but just it's sort of like it tends to be what we have to have oh this would be a great hymn to use here but we already have two hymns we have to do it a scripture song here in the service to keep the formula blended or people might think we're going to traditional this Sunday well you know if it's if it's all ancient hymns that really serve the gospel story and purposes of this worship service and they do it the best let's do them okay in some way it may be that that the rewrite of those hymns or contemporary hymns may serve what we're doing better and and we're not you know I had a woman one time in a church that I served we did a mighty fortresses our God with not just a piano but with the full band and we did it in a Tommy Walker arrangement that have been done at Promise Keepers okay which has after the second and third stanza this little interlude thing says oh mighty fortress and mighty fortresses our God and then it goes into stanza three traditional words traditional tune so we had guitars and drums and other things going with it maybe a trumpet as well well the woman met me at the door after the service and Mark I did not appreciate the fact that you brought something contemporary into my part of the service

see she had in her mind that the early part of the service would be only the piano with traditional hymns and then later in the service she would tolerate and put up with you know the more contemporary stuff see that's that's the problem that a blended mindset can get into well I'm agreeing to some changes in his church as long as it doesn't go past this percentage or you don't mess with a hymn by arranging in a way that feels contemporary see I'm saying so I think that's uh that's problematic okay broader understand yeah truth I was intrigued by you said that's a problem with blended I mean what do you think's more deeply we've been happy with that woman's view of community in that moment I think she felt that she had already stretched a long way to allow and be okay with people in the church needing to have some things that are different than what she needs and the she had you know I'm glad you asked for because I really think she was working hard and trying to prefer others in love but we across the line in messing with the mighty fortress because she just looked forward to doing that with the piano only in the traditional way without the little syncopation and some of this stuff in between and what do I do as a pastor in that situation well I try to explain to her and then I go to our worship team and say we probably shouldn't do that for a while because you know some people are struggling with you know they would be better with a completely retuning of a mighty fortress this is probably not a wise idea anyway because that is one hymn that I mean I've heard people try it and not don't do that but that's one you know that kind of fits you know come now found of every blessing for example that you know a rewrite of that is is it lends itself to so many different kinds of arrangements done with organ and blood vessels it can be done you know with the little syncopation it can be you know but a mighty fortress in this woman's mind which is just favored him that is done this way you know it it's sort of in a part of the service that she had sort of figured out this part I know I'm going to be able to fully enter into and enjoy and then I'm going to ask the Lord to give me heroic forbearance like the reggae kid quote to live with this other stuff when these other instruments join in and these other songs so we were asking her to exercise in her mind heroic forbearance only for this part of the service but now in her part of the service you've got a you know stretch and I have empathy toward that okay and it wasn't necessary to have to do a mighty fortress that way and so I'm not sure we ever did mighty fortress again that way in the last two years I was there which is part of my wanting to prefer others in love as well though I didn't agree with her that that was her part of the service okay and I think that we need to I think we need need to be willing to draw on any and all kinds of resources ancient and present that serve the gospel purposes at any point in the service and so blended to say this half and this half or this many hands as many songs I think limits our repertoire of what can be used to accomplish gospel centered worship in any given Sunday I want to expand the repertoire how do you think this incubation improved on that hymn? Well I think for some people who may not like a mighty fortresses our god and view it as part of just kind of the old traditional church sort of thing and and for them we're saying this great hymn can be brought forward with a different kind of expression that may connect better and maybe my grandchildren will only know it in that version and some old guy like me will say well could we sing it the old way I mean I remember when James Ward's new tune to Rock of Ages came out people loved it and I love it so do

but you know I'd get people who would say oh we ever ever ever ever again going to do the old rock of Ages too I'd like to do that once in a while too because that meant a lot to them in their growing computers which was one of the two or three hymns always done our little house on the prairie when the church hymns were heard as well bringing in the sheaves Rock of Ages. What is a better term to use you might suggest other than blended which would better capture the focus of what you're talking about? I often end up using blended because I haven't found a good alternative but then I defined blended to mean the best of blended meaning always being open to using a vast array of ancient prayers and hymns and readings and new ones or whatever then you give a point to say you know what serves best what we're trying to do at this point in the service at this time. It still has sensitivity to the congregants that are there. What I would do when we were introducing new whether it was like an indelible grazed tune or a new scripture song or something like that in a worship service when we were introducing I would deliberately go out of my way to try to find a hymn that I knew that the older people who would be wondering about this and least enjoying this new hymn. I would try to find a hymn that I knew most of the people who would have struggle with this would love. Not just to use a hymn that they would love but here's the additional criteria that also fit in with what I was trying to accomplish in that service and if I couldn't find one I wouldn't just do it as a sort of well. Let's just throw one out to the old folks. But what is there from their most loved repertoire that will accomplish and maybe I was going I want to introduce this new and maybe I was going to do another contemporary one but this one does just as well as this contemporary one so in this service with these people as we learn to do what even the Westminster assembly guys told parliament they wanted to do about you know that great line of the be studious to please others rather than ourselves that's a biblical principle that applies to planning and leading portions as well. So I want to love the whole congregation well and hope that in the process they come to love each other's stuff that they most prefer. One of the things we would do in the church enrichment, the music director Mindy Deckard would meet with one of the thirteen weeks under school time periods would meet with the teenagers and they would study the content of songs as they learned to sing them that Mindy and I agreed should the adjective the churches repertoire singing in the coming year okay new songs either new tunes for old hands or just new songs and we would pick eight or ten and they would work on them over that time period and then we would have this Sunday evening teen choir event where they would teach the congregation the songs and as if we learned them or already knew them we were welcome to join in it wasn't all it wasn't a performance concert thing and different ones of the teens would take their turn in introducing the next song I remember we did a rock Kevin Twitt's tune to arise my solo rockist when one of the eighth graders talked up and and sit up and talked about what Christ as our surety means there's language that most of the adults in may sing it and like the the him aren't sure what's the how is Christ our surety what does that here's this eighth waiter talking about what it means and what it means to him now a lot of times the people in the congregation who are most against this new stuff are the parents of those teenagers okay or the grandparents and it's pretty hard for them to be against seeing their teenage children or grandchildren get up and talk about the beauty and the wonder of Christ as our surety and what that means for my life in terms of being in him and then seeing this lively version of arise my solo rise that you may or may not like how could you be against your children grandchildren being enthusiastic about their walk with the Lord and that's what I often will do when I go to places and somebody say well some adults will say you know I really think we should add to our musical repertoire and worship some of the songs that the younger generation will like but how are we going to do that I mean our organist doesn't know how to play that stuff and how do we how do we teach it to the congregation I say you know probably if you went to your youth group right now talk to your youth director fall into your repaid or whatever here she may be and said could you could you talk with the youth about maybe picking two of their favorite songs that they sing when they get together as a youth group that they think that that the rest of the congregation is most likely to enjoy don't pick the two that'll most defend pick the two that are most likely to be loved and sort of practice them and maybe let let a couple of the elders come in here you know or whatever and and maybe at some Sunday night service or maybe a special music at a Sunday morning service maybe we could have the teams with maybe don't try the drums just yet but maybe with guitars okay and keyboard or something do a special music of something that maybe someday our congregation could add to the repertoire and sing I mean a lot of churches that once they're convinced that maybe there's something we could do they already have the resources and the people are doing it often with great musical excellence among some of the youth or college age in their congregation that could be gradually and easily incorporated into the life of the church and what we basically did in Richmond when we we didn't really change the repertoire as much as added instruments and some of the teams where the people played the instruments and that 10 instrumental ensemble of instruments and I found something amazing happened that I didn't change my sermons we didn't really change the service we just added some instruments and let teams be up front playing them all of a sudden when I was preaching most of the teenagers in church were paying attention in ways they haven't before why because we had engaged them and used their gifts to serve the body in bringing glory under the God it was just an amazing thing which I think that wasn't the reason for doing it but we started to see the fruit of or or go the other way I'm saying I mean there were people in the church who came from you know independent fundamental Bible churches or whatever from the past that had songs and the himnals that they loved that wouldn't make any addition of the trendy animal because of the theology okay that they said you know what we have these great loved hymns that we wish we could sing more of and I actually would say to people could you write down your 10 favorite loved hymns that we never do a Christ of Respiratory Church and I can't promise that we'll ever do all of them or how soon we'll get to any of them but if I know what you love as I'm planning worship services then I can have this in front of me and look at it from time to time and realize gee I got three or four people have this song on their list that isn't in the Trinity hymnal that we could insert in the bulletin and sing some something when it ties in well with this servant or this focus in the worship service it wasn't too late it tells them that you love them and care about them but you do in a way that isn't necessarily compromising did legal theology or what you're planning to do in any given ocean service and there's a lot of things you can do to engage people and include them and let them be be a part of things that then wins their confidence and trust that bears fruit in other ways in the life of the church so worship is one place where we really can show one another we love each other well by accepting some of the things that aren't our first preference anyway we're moving yeah you have time I can wait let me get yeah let me go through this for now catch it later at the top of 19 broader understanding regular principle of worship a few quotes will move pretty quickly through this martin boots are in strasbourg nothing should be introduced or performed in the churches of christ for which no probable reason can be given from the word of god that's not exactly the same as a regular principle of worship but I think he's after the same thing but he's saying we're pretty sure this is consistent with what the word of god would direct us to be do more I think in that application area or a hodge comments on 21 one of the confession they god in his word is prescribed for us how we may worship him acceptably and that it is an offense to him and ascend in us either to neglect to worship and serve him in the way prescribed or to attempt to serve him in any way not prescribed now you notice what's different about that he inserted a positive formulation in that the last part is pretty much right there with the last phrase of the confession but he inserted it is a sin to neglect to worship and serve him in the way prescribed that's a positive statement of let's do all that he's prescribed and nothing that he hasn't prescribed usually it's formulated nothing he hasn't prescribed so hodge is added that positive if I'd read that and ask you what's the tone of this statement you might not have said negative this quickly frame you've read some we've talked about the broader application and understanding gore we've talked about he broadens the understanding of circumstance to put it into the audio for like in Romans 14 weaker stronger brother things or things that indifference that we made we decide kind of in the context of local church whether or not we should have the drone set or sing in the garden for example okay which seems to be kind of an over romanticized you know I've come to the actual garden he walks with me he talks with me you know that old him yeah um I think the theology is pretty suspect even though I think it's after a nice idea I have a you know that that's one that gets on the list of the old folks okay then I'm not comfortable using an worship service that's why one more than their one favorite one so I can pick some of the others whose theology is a little better and I don't know how many people out there and you know access land I may have upset by that last comment but um and any great I think that you know there's here's a circumstance where I was willing to sing that song uh every week on Wednesday I would go to the look one of the local nursing homes and because I can play the piano and sight read him I would leave some singing and then give a devotional and then the best part for all of them was I walked around and actually you know shook their hand and talked with them I want to want you to some of this kind of stuff you know and I let them pick anything in the him know that's there that they want to do and if somebody picks a him that I probably in Sunday morning would not pick for the worship service we go ahead and sing the first dance out because of what just out of love for in ministry to to what's favorite to them now if they were singing him that denied that Jesus is God or you know wanted to pray to mother earth or something like that you know I would still draw my lines even at the nursing home along the way at the end of gorge book he talks about worship these are sort of some positive things he says that worship should be should be simple orderly free glorifying edifying Catholic culturally sensitive balance in Christ center and I commend that last section of his book especially if you wanted to look at some of that now here's something I want I talked off camera to some of you at the break the other day about as the governor was Steve Schlissel that I talked about he was the one who said the strictness of the regular regulation of the sacrificial system now seems to be put on the theology and doctrine of the person of work of Christ okay that's how that like Galatians one six if anybody preaches another gospel in the world we preach to you an angel of heaven or even if we come back let them be eternally condemned or Schlissel also talks about in his paper everything I needed to learn about worship I didn't learn from the regular principle of worship so you can sort of see the attitude in there as well which I have some problem with but he talked about what he calls the informed principle of worship now as you say at the outset is that his practice of worship looks very much like well even strict regulates a list okay but he calls it the informed principle of worship the IPW okay if the Bible commands it what do we do well we do it if the Bible forbids it what do we do

we don't do it okay now there's nothing distinctively Presbyterian about those two statements all Christians everywhere should agree that if the Bible commands something we should do it the Bible forbids something we shouldn't do it okay here's where the problem comes where you decide your view of worship if the Bible neither commands nor forbids what do we do I would just say depends she is that somewhere around here let's see oh good right all right you're right it depends now what would the historic strict articulation of the regular principle of worship say to this last one don't do it don't do it okay and the Lutheran principle of worship would say if it's neither command or forbidden it's okay to do it within

kind of the general principles of the rest of scripture okay now I think that if it's neither commanded nor forbidden I think we have to be very careful and make sure we are operating within general principles of scripture but I think in the and most of this is in the realm of application it's sort of back to how many preachers how long of a sermon how many scripture readings do you have okay the scripture doesn't okay the scripture neither commands nor forbids the wearing of a robe to preach should we do it the argument of the English Puritans was no the Bible doesn't command it therefore we can't do it you're beyond scripture this is the way the the the God regulates worship if he hasn't said it in the Bible that we dare not do it let's say I think at the end of the day to say no to this last one here um it becomes pretty unworkable in the planning and practice of worship because there's so many things that we have to decide where to do that I think is where where the reason I can say it depends is because I put a lot of these things if if we're not talking about the actual elements of worship but the manner of expressing them and the way of arranging them then I think this last one actually falls under chapter one six of circumstances where it says the general rules christian prudence light of nature always the general rules of scripture apply in that regard now let's go back to the clown serving communion okay I've been present at a retreat where that was the plan and there's sort of this mimeing of the meaning of the Lord's supper that was acted out then they came around and you know I don't I blocked most of it out of my mind because I didn't enter into it um I sort of sat in a place where they you know couldn't get to me because I felt there was some violation of some biblical principle going on I mean it was well meaning it was well intended but why would I forbid the serving of communion by clowns people dressed as clowns acts from the meaning of what's going on because everyone's paying attention to the person dressed like a clown yeah yeah certainly but but you're beginning to argue from from general principles that would apply and you look carefully how did Jesus institute this and what is the significance of unless it's in their clowns who are using Coca-Cola and Dorito chips as the elements let's just add that to the mix okay well there the Bible if I was in some far away place and there was nothing anything like wine or grape juice or bread available would I consider possibly using something other than that well yeah maybe but that's not what we're talking about right now okay um officer like this is a neat cool thing wouldn't it be cool if and that's sort of be careful when you hear wouldn't it be cool if we could do this in worship it may be trying to bring something in that that that shouldn't so I think we're often functioning at this level now I think there's some things that you would we'll get in this more later in terms of like drama and art and those sorts of things where just because something can be done to the glory of God clowns miving a gospel message can be done to the glory of God okay just because it can be done to the glory of God doesn't mean it sooner must be done in a corporate public worship service may not be fitting in occasion I've been in gymnasiums where I preached from a pulpit facing this way with the basketball hoop this way and the three-point line coming right by where I was standing and I used to play basketball and I'm old enough that when I played they didn't have a three three-pointer or else my average would have gone up because most of my shots were outside a three-point line and so I could pull the basketball out from behind the pulpit and turn and jump shoot a three-pointer and make it to the glory of God and say I now on institute as a regular element in all biblically sound worship services the preacher making a three-pointer before he preaches now what will be wrong with that I think that's fine everybody here agrees I say I convinced you way too much now yeah exactly even the best three-point shooter is only 30 percent so just because something can be done to the glory of God doesn't mean it must be done in corporate public worship okay and that's my answer to a lot of things it might be cool to do and sometimes people want to introduce aspect of the arts into worship because Christians by and large and especially in our circles which is a denial of our heritage have sort of relegated to people in the arts as being sort of weird and off here and the gospel doesn't have anything to do with it it's too much like Hollywood to do anything like that and we know all a Hollywood is just completely controlled by the enemy and so on and so forth okay sex drugs rock in the role in Hollywood movies which is and while we're out we'll do a card playing and dancing and drinking smoking and whatever okay although you dance they may not know if you're playing basketball good point the dance in the garden exactly that's right that's right just don't put a basketball in my hand while I'm dancing in church okay and we turn into okay I think like in a lot of things we sometimes press the scripture to be more detailed and black and white than God has given us you know wouldn't it be nice in most married relationships if God had just determined for all eternity for every married couple that the husband takes out the trash and the wife does all the dishes or that the right way to squeeze a toothpaste to is from the bottom up with the rolling of it the sake of all the arguments or the toilet seat should always be put down we're really getting on it unsanified repertoire but God doesn't give us all the details that we need to functionally practice the worship elements and principles that are in his word and he's invited us relationally to enter into a walk with him and his word and his people that uses I think an element of creative imagination to put together these things that he has commanded that we use for worship in a way that serve gospel purposes and this leads me to my last point perfect no I last point but the time I have to fit in this timeframe of what I call a suggested solution in progress related to the regular principle of worship and it goes something like this the regular principle of worship and I understand it requires the following okay the use of commanded elements in worship and we'll talk more about what these are later I've listed them before as well I think you know the reading scripture the preaching of the word singing the songs in spiritual songs prayer the sacraments offerings I put testimonies in there too which we'll talk more about but the the use of commanded elements that's first now that's not all there is to if I started this if I started to pray before preaching and covenant last Sunday at covenant last Sunday by oh mother earth

would that be pleasing to go no oh why not I'm using a commanded element I'm praying it's not all the matters no the commanded elements have to be filled with biblical content I've heard some sermons that I don't think are glorifying to God because they were denying essential truths of the gospel so it's commanded elements filled with biblical contents there's some this is this is how we determine first and foremost um the prayers we pray the songs we sing the sermons we preach okay are they filled with biblical content now biblical content all by itself with commanded elements could be sort of put together one after another in a worship service in a way that has no sort of logical gospel progression to it if I started with a benediction and ended the service with the call to worship that that I'm using commanded elements with biblical content but it's sort of contrary to the way the progression of a service should go and so I think the third thing in addition to command using commanded elements filled with biblical content is arranged in a gospel shape or arrangement that that we're going to look at after our break in terms of what gospel centered or shaped worship is about now I would argue that we should be able to virtually evaluate any and every worship service based on these three things are they using commanded elements are they being filled with biblical content and did they take gospel shape or arrangement in the way they're ordered however they don't have to look exactly alike to accomplish this from one service to the next from one local church to the next because fourthly there are a variety of valid expressions such as the singing of the Lord's Prayer as as compared to the stating of it or the using of it to form a larger prayer you know our father who art in heaven how will be your name and then you invite people to pray prayers of honoring God's name and then you move through a 10 minute time of prayer that uses the structure of the Lord's Prayer without ever having prayed the whole prayer or sung it that's a valid expression of prayer in an worship service and then fifthly these things all take place in in the midst of circumstances or context that's unique to a local church so I see the line here I think I could go around I'm going to say this I'm going to make this as a faith statement most Sundays let's put it that way I could go around every one of the PCA churches if I could actually conceivably be at all of them on a given Sunday and say wow Twin Oaks, Kirk of the Hills, Chesterfield, New City, Grace of Peace, Old Orchard, etc. etc. covenant made use of commanded elements filled with biblical contents that were arranged in with gospel shape this week but I saw a variety of expressions of these things I had to look behind just did the bulletins all match up they all sang the same first hymn and they all had a prayer and confession here and they did okay no and they reflected the uniqueness of each local church that has its own sort of worshiping personality see the style things come down here the thing the diversity of acceptable worship the acceptable worship is here and the diversity and flexibility of expression is below that line so I think I shouldn't go to Chesterfield and say you didn't have a unison prayer of confession day you didn't worship God the way he says he should be worshiped well I that's and then you know if you are let to pass your testimony but did you notice this song we sang that was a prayer of confession I guess I missed that

or in the prayer of invocation also included in asking of God for forgiveness first day I think we should be able to show any of us in any church in the services that were involved in planning and leading we should be able to show how we're doing this these first three things with lots of flexibility in what that looks like the style of the music the instruments use whether you're wearing a coat in a tie or you're standing or kneeling or raising your hands or you have three assistant pastors preach this week or one the one senior pastor or you know you have a woman giving a testimony this week or you you have somebody you have teenagers reading portions of scripture that are selected to tie in with the sermon earlier in the service they walk up to a microphone in the middle of the congregation and and read scripture that ties in there may be a lot of different different manners of expressing these things and I think our unity is here and we have a right to sort of ask each other the hard questions about whether or not we're doing worship the way God wants here and then we give lots of room to each other down here that is as unique as any local church on the gathers to worship to me this sort of I think helps us it gets behind the expressions to the core substantive issues now when you're doing your worship services what your foot noting is showing me this up here I want you to say why and why you're doing why the things you're doing here may be very different from the other services are actually serving these things here okay talk to me about this sort of above and below the line stuff as you do those things okay we've got it's about a minute left before we need to break is any last other questions or comments but let me just say that I am finding this and things like this that are being set out there in in art and foundation of pca as people are people are sort of rallying to this and finding it unifying with room to breathe saying we're in the room we know where it is going outside the room but look at the folks over here taking the liberty that they have within this room we've agreed on to worship like this and look how it look isn't this a beautiful picture of how God works at the uni and diversity of the body of Christ or I go to Africa and I am able to say wow look at how they do this element of the offering that impacts me not to go copy it but to change the way I do it to make it more expressive of what the Bible calls us to in terms of of truth on this again but with regard to the last part on the circumstances being unique if you're saying a situation where people who come and worship are the church over time say 20 30 years and the church stays in the same neighborhood you still have basically since most churches are typically made of basically the same families generation generation your worship stays the same in style and I mean it's biblical it has the shape and the elements on that but your circumstances within have not changed but then the demographics of your neighborhood and say what used to be a rural area is now an urban area that can happen over 50 years how should churches bring in that change to reflect the demographic changes in order to draw those new people in instead of just concentrating on people who have been there for 30 or 40 years great question and I'll give a short answer and we can talk more about it later I think as you say this there's a constancy here and maybe some slight tweaking over the years it seems to me that there needs to be a constant evaluation of the circumstances unique to our local church that then informs a potential adjustment of the variety of valid expressions all the while keeping biblical elements in a gospel shape so the the changing demographics in terms and contextual relevance to this circumstance that's unique to us may mean we need to tap into more of the variety here of valid expressions while keeping this and that's very this is where the unity stays up here at these top three while you're challenging people who are very comfortable the way it's always been to consider being different for the sake of the mission of the church if we're worshipping community on a kingdom mission that begins in Jerusalem right around us then we may need to consider for missional reasons changing not the substance of worship as God requires it but the expression of it to be able to accomplish that mission better all right let's take a