I will begin every hour, kind of, right at 8 by doing a review questions. So, if you're kind of thinking, I wonder what that final exam is going to be like. I won't tell you every question on the final exam, I will give you at the beginning of the hours. But many of them, I will give you at the beginning of the hours, because it's my way of saying, what was key in that last lecture? Well, let's do some review. So, I will do the review right on the spot of 8, and we'll do that for three to five minutes. And then we'll move into the lecture time. As you're coming in for the sake of the recording that we're doing for all future generations or whatever, if you come in after 8 o'clock, you're asked to come in the side doors rather than the middle door, because that would put you right in the aisle in front of the camera as you're coming down. So, really, there's no problem coming in the side doors and just sitting on the sides as you come in. And that will be our pattern as we go. Please note that at the beginning of the lecture, it says, even as today, what the reading was for that lecture, at the end of the lecture, it will say, what the reading is for next time. It will also give you the assignment, okay, if there is one. Now, today, there is an assignment and it's not for next time. You see, it's not due until the fourth lecture. So, it kind of says, you know, what is the assignment and when's it due? And it will kind of key you as you look at the ends of lectures. And at the end of lecture three, it will actually say, remember, assignment due next time, and to key you that way. Now, the difficulty with that a little bit going between lectures is sometimes there are things you have to do between the lectures and I won't be reminding you every time. For instance, what you'll be doing as an assignment on this lecture this time is you'll be listening to at least a couple of chapel messages between now and lecture four and evaluating them for the criteria that's established there. So, if you wait until the night before to do assignment, why, that would be problematic because you'll need to kind of at the end of today's lecture, see what that is, and then be working on it prior to the fourth lecture in which that material will be turned in. If you cannot go to the chapel services, they are available on the portal and that's where you would then get the material. So, the idea is we're all looking at the same things and responding to them. We're kind of getting a criteria for looking at sermons in the class, but so that we're moving through together, we want to have some standard things we're considering. So, those are the chapel messages that we'll be evaluating looking at and then responding grouply to, grouply is not a word, but you know what I mean, okay? Let's pray and we'll begin today.
Heavenly Father, we thank you that you have given us your word that which is life and bread to your people, and you make your spirit shine upon it so that it is reflected into our hearts and our hearts made able to receive what you say. But not our hearts only, rather as we ingest all the goodness of what you have given, you make us also reflectors of your truth to others, and we would be those who shine well. Help us therefore by what we learn in this class, by what we do, to be those who are well equipped for shining your light into darkness, for the sake of those that you love and are calling to yourself. We ask not on the basis of our ability, but rather on the ability that is made available by your spirit. We lean upon you now and ask for your help and aid because apart from you, we can do nothing. Grant us therefore your spirit we pray in Jesus' name. Amen.
If you look at the beginning of your first lecture there, it gives the goal for this lesson, and it's to understand how important preaching is and then what is really important in preaching, and especially it's that last, what is really important in preaching that may actually surprise you a bit today as we move forward. If I were to ask why you're here, why you would sit in a homolytics class, why you would go to seminary, I hope you have some sense of gaining the knowledge and the skills for what God is calling you to do. And it is both sides of that, gaining the knowledge and the skills for what God is calling you to do, that is important because I think you would recognize if you're here just to gain knowledge, the scriptures themselves say the consequence of that. Knowledge puffs up. That's all it does. If there is not some release, some mechanism by which God is enabling us to share that knowledge, then it's not going to ultimately benefit us. It's actually harmed to us unless there is some way in which it is being used for God's purposes. Now, Ed Wright now is reminding me, we are circulating the attendance sheet. So as you do that, just a reminder, don't just check by the way. The government requires, if you're receiving any form of aid, that you actually have to initial, so initial with the date, and identify your being here. The idea of God saying what I desire from you is not simply your knowledge of the word, but your ability to communicate it to others. It was even that which I mentioned in the convocation the other day when the apostles prayed for others, they say, we want you to know everything that we know. But in order for that to be true, you have to active in the sharing of your faith. That you may know how wide and long and high and deep is the love of God in Christ Jesus. That's an amazing concept that really to know what God is saying, it has to be something in which you are actively involved in communicating to others. Therefore, Dr. Rayburn who taught this course for 25 years and was the founding president of Covenant Seminary would always remind us in this first lecture he would say, now there is only one king of your studies, that is the Lord Jesus Christ, but he would say, homologics is the queen. Now, what did he mean by that? He was reminding us that everything we do in the curriculum, whether it's New Testament studies, Old Testament studies, systematic church history, is feeding a purpose, and that purpose is to equip us to feed others, because it's really the means by which we ourselves are knowing and growing fully in the understanding of the grace of God that he intends for us. And so preaching is a sense elevated to the highest position, and that sounds nice until you consider the responsibility it puts on you, because once you elevate the task so high to say, this is the main thing to be done, then people who are about to do it feel very inadequate. You elevate the task, you make the servant very lacking in confidence. And what I want to do this morning somewhat is take the monkey off of your back of thinking that the responsibility for the effects of preaching all rests on you. It's just something you have to do well enough and good enough that it's going to have an effect. I want you to just recognize this in its essence. The power is not in you and it never will be. The power is in the word. It's not how well you do the task that ultimately is responsible, it is how well you communicate the word which carries the power of God. We sometimes think of the greatest 19th century reformed preacher as being Charles Haddon's virgin. I want you to think of what he said about himself. He said, I have often been surprised at the mercy of God to me poor sermons of mine that I could cry over when I get home, have nonetheless led scores to the cross. And more wonderful still words that I speak in ordinary conversation, mere chance sentences as men call them, have nevertheless been as winged arrows from God and have pierced men's hearts and laid them wounded at Jesus feet. I've often lifted up my hands in astonishment and said, how can this be? How can God bless such feeble instrumentality? The key word of course is instrumentality. We are those earthen vessels. We are the instruments. The power is in the word. And therefore the clarity with which we present the word is ultimately what preaching is about what not what you may be tempted to think, even what this course is about. What is this course about? Well, if I just get the outline right, if I can just deliver this well, then I'm going to be a great preacher. I actually know it's the clarity of the word because the word contains the power. In your readings, you read so many of the key verses by which the scriptures are relating this to us. The power of God inherent in the word comes, we know because the word of God is what created the world and the universe as we know it. God said let there be light and there was light. He spoke and it came to be the power of creation was in the word. The word of God continues to control everything around us. He sends his command earth. His word runs swiftly. He spreads the snow like wool and scatters the frost like ashes. He hurls down his ale like pebbles. He sends his word, amazing thought, isn't it? He sends his word and melts them. The word of God continues to be active in persuading other people. Let the one who has my word speak it faithfully is not my word like fire and like a hammer that breaks a rock in pieces. Now, some of you have friends that you want to come to Christ and you have family that you've prayed about for years and you wonder what it will be that will finally break them. What does God say will finally break through? It is the word that breaks a rock, a hard heart. It is faithfulness to what God Himself expresses. The word of God performs the purposes for which He designed it. As the rain and snow come down from heaven and do not return to it without watering the earth, so is my word that goes out from my mouth. It will not return to be empty but will accomplish what I desire and achieve the purpose for which I sent it. One of the amazing verses in scripture whereby the inherent power of the word is being expressed is that in Philippians, where Paul is saying, I'm in prison and while I'm in prison, I'm still rejoicing the word is going forth. Now, some people are preaching it out of false motives. Some people are preaching it out of true motives but I rejoice for both because as long as the word goes forth, it's still accomplishing God's purpose. Now, that's an amazing thought. People even misusing it for their purposes and God's still using it for his purposes. The word has this inherent power in it that takes the burden off to us to say, unless I just do it exactly right, it has no power. No, it has power beyond us. It has sufficiency unto itself which ultimately gives me a lot of confidence when I preach. There's not some magic to what I'm doing. It has the power. If that's the case, you think about the importance of why it has that power, it is actually communicating Christ himself. The divine logos, remember in the beginning, was the word and the word was with God and the word was God who is being described Christ. If he is described as the word, he is God still speaking to us in incarnate form, fleshly form, the word presented. This is what God is saying to us what Christ himself represents. Why is that important? Because we recognize by the word creation came into being, that's part of its power. Without him was not anything made that was made, this word of God. The word of God created, now a bit of a pun going on in Scripture, right? God spoke and it came to be, but the word was also the means by which Christ came into creation and created creation. He is, in fact, that word of creation. He's also the word of the new creation. Again, in your notes, James 1, verse 18 and 1 Peter 1, 23, here the pun occurring explicitly in Scripture. James says he, that is Jesus, chose to give us birth through the word of truth. And what do you think James is talking about when he says God chose to give us birth through the word of truth? Is he talking about the inscripturated word or is he talking about the incarnate word? The answer of course is it's both. He chose to give us life through the word of truth. That's the word about Jesus and the word that is Jesus. Even more explicit is Peter saying you have been born again, not a perishable seed, but imperishable, the living and enduring word of God. You've been born again by the word of God. Now again, is it the inscripturated word being referred to or is it the incarnate word being referred to that makes us born again? Again, it's a trick question. It's both. God is presenting himself to us in the words so much so that when he presents Christ to us, he says that's the word. Now it begins to be really amazing. What are the implications of that? If Christ is the word and when I speak, I am presenting the word of God when I speak who is speaking?
It's God yet speaking. A gustan said it this way when the Bible speaks, God speaks, when the Bible speaks, God speaks. So if I say what the Bible says, who is still speaking? I know it's my voice coming up, but who is still speaking? God is still speaking to his people through the human instrument that is faithful to his word so that the second he'll Vedic confession, that is the early reformers confession, sounds too bold to be true. It sounds almost heretical, but this is what it said. The preaching of the word of God is the word of God. That's a very simple statement, but think of the implication. The preaching of the word of God is the word of God. God spoke and creation came into being. He spoke and it stood fast. I speak, and if it's faithful to the word of God, he still speaks. So that Luther would say the church is God's mouth house. It's the house of God by which God is speaking to his people and into the culture. God is still speaking. Most bold was Calvin and he said it this way. God has so chosen by his spirit to anoint the tongue and the lips of his preachers. So that when they speak, the voice of Jesus resounds. No, it's just me. It's just me speaking. I ever sit around the holiday table and think, Lord, there's all my unsaved loved ones around here and you know, if just Jesus were here to talk to them, if just Jesus were here, then they'd listen.
God is so chosen to anoint the lips and tongues of his people by his spirit that when they speak his word, Jesus still speaks. Now, did everyone accept the voice of Jesus? Everyone said, oh Jesus, I'll go with him because did everybody do that? No, but those to whom God was calling to himself, those who he designed to have their hearts broken as the word will break a rock. Those persons were persuaded by the voice of Jesus which we yet possess when we speak the word of God. And it's not magic. It's not, did I use the right formula? Did I say the right words? Did I use the right tone of voice? Did I raise my hands just the right way? No, it's the commitment to the truth of God's word that yet contains the power of God's word. That gives me such confidence. You know how the writer of Hebrews will say it. The word of God is living and active. That which we speak is yet living and active, sharper than any double-edged sword. It penetrates even to the dividing of soul and spirit joints and marrow. It judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart. Here is that activity of God, yet present, yet working, living and active, as we speak the words of these pages 2,000 years old and yet presently working because the word of God is yet living and active. So Paul could say, I am not ashamed of the gospel. For it is the power, now you know more what that means. It is the power of God under salvation. The good news, the truth of God, I'm not ashamed of it because I recognize more and more it is the power of God communicated to His servants and I am one of them. Not capable of myself, but given this dynamite, given this dunamis, given this power that is inherent in itself by virtue of it being the word so that when I present it, God is yet doing amazing works of creation even through such as I. Now you think of Spurgeon. Why was he so able? Because he knew he was so insufficient. He kept getting out of the way. How could God bless one's whose efforts are so feeble as my own? How could I be an instrument in his hands? Because that's all I am. I rely entirely upon him. So his power is what is coming to the fore. There are many ways in which this is said and maybe it's best just to express it in what you know Ed and I were just talking before class of some friends from our past. But do you have friends from the past that you remember from high school days or maybe college days that you recognize were living just an entirely different lifestyle. I mean they were living in a pagan self-serving, totally lost condition. I think of it from a couple of friends of mine, a guy that I knew in high school, a friend of mine, and basically he lived for football and the weekends. And a girl that I knew who basically lived to be appreciated by men and basically her life was giving herself to others in dating. I kind of kept track of those friends through the years. And during college one of them and another after he became a parent and a child of his was diagnosed with cancer, both became Christians. And I think how did that happen? Something I said, something a preacher in a church said, how could I say here were people who were walking after idols, totally self-consumed, turned from themself to serve the living in true God. The scriptures say they turned from idolatry to serve the living in true God. How did that happen? Little puffs of air out of my mouth. Some vocalization and syllables happen. How does that happen? Is not the word of God like a hammer that breaks a rock in pieces, not by anything in me, but by the wonder of the word that is committed to us. It has such power that even when I recognize my weakness, my feebleness, my frailness, my lack of adequate instrumentality, I say thank you, Lord, for the word that takes the burden off of me, and as long as I am faithful to it, it performs your purposes. So I have a much lesser obligation than some sort of dramatic presentation to make the word of God work. My goal is simply to make the word of God clear. When I've done that, the word of God works. Now we need to talk about how that occurs. The power of God, if you think of this word and the power of God has, how is it applied? One powerful way in which it is applied is expository preaching, and this is item C in your notes. The power of the word is applied in expository preaching. Now we'll do a lot of definition as the semester moves forward, but let's first do definition of what expository preaching is, and then talk about its advantages. How is the power of the word applied in expository preaching? Well first, what expository preaching is. It's the simple. The meaning of the message, the meaning of the message is the message of the passage. The meaning of the message of the sermon is the message of the passage. So what the passage means is what the sermon is going to be about. Now what the Bible says, God says, the preaching of the word of God is the word of God. So all expository preaching is trying to do, at its essence, to say, what is the meaning of that passage? That is the meaning of the message that I will be preaching. That's what expository preaching. Now if you do that, what are the advantages? When the message of the passage is also the message of the sermon, what are the advantages? Number one, there'll be three of these. Expository preaching confronts with the truth of the word. Expository preaching confronts with the truth of the word. It is that truth that is so powerful. So if expository preaching is simply saying what the word says, making the truth plain, then we are confronting others with the truth of the word that has power, not my opinion, not the philosophies of men. I don't take a poll to find out what I should be saying. The power is in the word and expository preaching is saying I want to confront you with the truth of the word because that's where the power is. Second, advantage of expository preaching. Expository preaching confronts with the authority of the word. Expository preaching confronts with the authority of the word. You may remember in that preface to Christ's inner preaching. I said basically, if you say what is the great debate in our culture today, it is the debate not only over meaning, but authority. Does anyone have the right to tell me what to do? What's the basic answer of society? Nobody's gotten the right to tell me what to do. But God does and God has spoken. So my goal in expository preaching is to say, now I'm telling you what you must do. Not on the basis of my authority. On the basis of God's authority. I have no authority. I too am a man under authority, said the apostle. Remember? Don't listen because of what I say. Listen to the one who I speak for so that when I speak the truth of God, I can do so with boldness because my authority is not my own. I speak with the authority of the word of God. Now that's again, getting kind of the monkey off of my back, right? I've got to accomplish this. No, it's not upon me to make you believe, nor is it upon me to say, you must believe because I say it. You must believe and respond because God says it. It's his authority as well as his truth. When the meaning of the passage is the message of the sermon, I speak with God's authority. Finally, expository preaching confronts with the power of the Spirit. Expository preaching confronts with the power of the Spirit. Here's where I give you the big heads up and I say, here's one of the questions that always appears on the midterm. Always appears on the midterm. If I were to ask you, who or what alone can change the hearts of men and women? Who or what alone? Can you do it? No, you can't. The Holy Spirit working by and with the word in our hearts. Who or what alone can change the hearts of men and women eternally? The Holy Spirit working by and with the word in our hearts. That's the specific language of the Westminster Confession, the first chapter in the fifth paragraph. It's a wonderful expression of what we understand. God must accomplish through his ministers. It is not you see the Holy Spirit working apart from the word. Any number of people will say, well, the Spirit said and then gross heresy results. It's the Holy Spirit using what God uses to create the new creation and the original creation. The new creation in us, new life, new conformity to his word. It is his word that he uses, but what inspired the word is still illuminating us so that we will receive that word and understand it. The Holy Spirit working by and with the word. So what is expository preaching doing? It's making sure that the Holy Spirit has the right raw material as it were for doing that work of construction that must be done in the human heart. I'm not depending upon something other than the word to be used by the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is going to use God's word to convince and change people. So what I'm doing in expository preaching is saying here is the word so that people will be confronted with the power of the Spirit. It's this amazing thought. When I preach, I recognize I'm never the first preacher. I'm always the second preacher. The first preacher is the Spirit. He gave the word and he is working already in the hearts of those who will receive it so that when I speak, I am a servant of the work of the Spirit. I come along after. I speak in conformity with what the Spirit is doing but the Spirit is the first preacher. So I am seeking to work in such a way that the Spirit's work is made manifest in the hearts of others. Now, if I say all of that, that expository preaching is seeking to confront with the work of the Spirit. If I recognize that technical excellence is not really what preaching is about, I recognize that undercuts much of the notion of why people get an appropriation to the recourse. Aren't we supposed to be talking about excellence in preaching? Yes, the fact that the powers in the word doesn't mean that we're to be stumbling blocks to others, right? At the same time, we are to recognize that the power, the power cannot be in us or else we will actually hurt people. I want you to listen to a biographer describe Edward Irving. Now, you've never heard of Edward Irving though he was the greatest renowned preacher of his era. Listen to what the biographer of Edward Irving said. He was the preacher in London in the 19th century to which all the celebrities went and the people of government. This is what his biographer says. The effect of his preaching was to leave men dazzled and stupified rather than convinced or converted. They went home marbling at the eloquence of the orator rather than mourning over their sins and yearning for God. That's a rather stark condemnation. He's a great preacher. I mean, people just marveled at how he spoke and what did it accomplish spiritually, virtually nothing. Now, that compared to a couple of other preachers from an earlier and then a later era. Some of you have read these words already from Robert S. Rayburn, the son of Dr. Rayburn, who used to teach this course. And he wrote this to encourage us. He says, the Lord will use what little we have. But his blessing ultimately is the key to our preaching rather than our abilities. Church history furnishes us with grand illustrations of this fact. I think for example of the court preachers of Louis the 14th day. In mid 17th century France, that court was as decadent and depraved as any kingly court ever was. Yet all the while, it professed earnestly its Christianity. And for its appointed preachers, it has John Messian and Jacques Boussé. There's was some of the greatest preaching ever produced in the history of the church. It was not only some of the most eloquent and powerful oratory ever heard. It was pious, blunt, intensely earnest, unafraid, and for 17th century Catholicism, highly evangelical. This is the same John Messian, you may remember, who when appointed to preach Louis the 14th funeral sermon ascended into the high pulpit of Notre Dame, surveyed the great congregation including the crowned heads of Europe, and forever honored the office of preacher by saying to them, in the hour of death, only God is great. And what was the consequence of that bold, courageous, evangelical preaching? Nothing. The spirit did not blow on that occasion. But a few years later, in Kemposlong near Glasgow, Scotland, there was a minister named William McCullough who was so bad of preacher. He was nicknamed the ale preacher because when he got up to speak, all the men left for the pubs. His own son says of his father, he was not eloquent. He was very different from the popular orators of his time. After being licensed, it took him nine years to get his first pastorate. But it was upon this inelegant, poorly constructed, poorly delivered sermons that the spirit of God fell in 1742 and produced such a spiritual awakening in Scotland such as not been known sense. He was no messian, but it was not McCullough's gifts that were the key, but the spirit. Who alone can convert the hearts of men and women? Only the spirit working by and with the word in our hearts, not our oratory, not our eloquence. But when we present the word of God, it is the spirit who then can use us as his instruments, though we be weak, an inelegant and seemingly poor vessels, commitment to the truth of God's word is the enabling of the work of the spirit for the purposes of God's word. If you think of the effectiveness of the word, you have to say how is it made effective in the lives of people? And this may seem to undercut just a little bit what I've said. For while the power is in the word, you know that we can get in the way, can't we? How do we make sure that people are getting through to the word and that we are not getting in the way? How is the effectiveness of the word promoted by testimony? Under Roman numerals two in your notes, I want to talk to you about Aristotle's distinctions of what is included in every persuasive message. Now, if we were in med school, it's the time of the class where you recognize we're going to get some definitions going on. We get the taxonomy being explained because if you were in med school, a lot of the first year is doing what? You're simply learning the terminology, you know, what is the tibian? What's the fibula? And what's the clavicle? And hamleticians do the same thing. We are going to be looking at sermons for the next couple of years and we are going to be preaching sermons and we simply need to know some common terminology so that we can dissect as it were but also so we can heal. So we know what we're talking about as we look at the different components. And one way of thinking about that is to think of the elements that go into a message that make it persuasive historically and what are unique aspects of that when we talk about getting people in confrontation with the word of God. One way to think of it is this, every persuasive message is made up of at least three components. The first is called logos, logos historically. That is simply what's logos mean in Greek. Word, it's the words, it's the verbal content. Logos is the verbal content of the message. It includes not only the words used but the arguments used, it's craft, the logic of the message. What's the verbal content? That's part of the message, it's logos. A second major component of any persuasive message is pathos which is that, if it's not the verbal content, what is pathos? The emotive content, that's right, it's the emotive content, the passion or further or feeling with which something is expressed. Now I must tell you, it is sometimes hard, particularly for men and young men in this culture, to feel the weight of pathos because we're kind of trained in a John Wayne, Indiana Jones culture which is kind of you know stoic, you know, to really be strong, you don't express emotion. And there is, we all recognize a manipulative sort of preaching that expresses emotion just to get effect. But I want you to recognize how dangerous preaching can be that shows no passion. And if you do not receive Jesus Christ, you'll probably go to hell. And you know, let's look at the next page. What did you just say?
It was once said of Moody, he was one of the few people qualified to speak of hell because he could not do it without weeping. It grieved him so and people knew it did. There was this sense of if the message does not move you, is it doesn't seem to have any impact on you? Why would you expect to have impact on anybody else? To speak about the love of God in a way that does not move you is actually to speak untruth. To say, this isn't very important. This isn't very significant. Your manner is now contradicting your message. And it's just a standard rule of communicators. What if your manner contradicts your message? What will be believed? Your manner. So the manner needs to go with the message. One of the wonderful preachers of the 19th century was Robert Murray McShane. And some of us actually visited his church this summer. He was a wonderful preacher, sparked a revival in Scotland, died before age 30. So he's the age of many of you here. When he was known as one of the greatest preachers of the English Isles. And if you want to hear some hint of why he was so listened to, listen to his own diary. This is what he wrote on February 21st, 1836. Preached twice in Robert on the righteousness of God from Romans 116, in the morning was more engaged in preparing the head than the heart. This has frequently been my error. And I always felt the evil of it. Reform it then, O Lord. What's he saying? My sermon had become just a lecture. Just give them information. I prepared the head, but not the heart. Some weeks later on March 5th, he again wrote in his diary, preached again in Robert Heart with very much comfort, owing chiefly to my remedying the error of 21st February. Therefore the heart and the mouth were both full. In large my heart and I shall run, said David, Lord, in large my heart and I shall preach. Well it's a wonderful expression, isn't it? In large my heart when you speak to God's people, do they see your heart full? Are you able to express now? Our personalities were very greatly, right? The goal is to say things as though you deeply mean them. You will vary. Our personalities were very, but in whatever way shows the depth of your feeling. Just talk to people that way as though you care because that bears so much on the final aspect of persuasion and that is ethos. The final component of every persuasive message is ethos. Now this is, you have to write down careful. This is one of those midterm questions, all right? It is the perceived character of the speaker. What's the key adjective there? Perseve. It's not the character of the speaker. You know you say, but I know what I'm, well, how are you being perceived? It is the perceived character of the speaker. That's one of the reasons that logos and pathos are so important. What's your character perceived to be if you are disorganized? It seems that you don't care. What's perceived about you if you don't speak with passion? It is perceived that you don't care. Now you may care very much, but by inattention to logos and pathos ethos is damaged. And what everyone has known throughout the centuries if you were evaluating the importance of these things, logos, pathos, and ethos, which is the most important for persuading people? ethos. The perceived character of the speaker. You know this. Some of you, you know, you go to visit a friend on vacation and they're telling you about their wonderful preacher and you go listen to him and you go, man, how am I going to talk about this? This guy is really awful. Why do they think he's so good? Because they know him. They know his heart. They know his care. They know his compassion. They listen to character. And the character becomes part of the vehicle for hearing the word of God. That's why the Apostle would say we put no stumbling block in other people's path. It's our character that we recognize as part of the means by which people hear the word of God. If you could see it visually, this was in your book, so I won't go over this long. But if you were just to see it visually, you would recognize this. The path of the gospel is the word. So we would recognize that the word of God is going to be the thing that convinces. But somehow the listener has to get in contact with the word. So we are telling in the meaning of the word. That's the logos, the verbal content. But if we have heart-feltness that is not showing, if our manner is contradicting our message, then that becomes a barrier to people hearing the content of the word. And of course if our character does not reflect the meaning of the word, then people will say, what you do speaks so loudly, I cannot hear what you say. So character becomes part of the point as well. The listener has to go through these doors, as it were, of logos, pathos and ethos to be in confrontation with the word. Paul said it this way. And you remember this is in 1 Thessalonians 1.5. Our gospel came to you not simply in words, which is what, not simply in logos. Our gospel came to you not simply in logos, but also in power and the Holy Spirit and with deep conviction. What is that? There's the pathos. You know how we lived among you for your sake. What is that? That is ethos. And they become absolutely key if you hear both of those things. You know how we lived among you for your sake. When those who study persuasive speech say what ethos is, it's always two components. It's credibility. Do you know what you're talking about and compassion? Does the speaker appear to care about whom the listeners? If the speaker appears to care more about himself, what's my impression? What are you thinking about me? What's the reaction of listeners? It's actually to remove themselves from the speaking event. I don't want to be manipulated. If your main goal is your reputation, I actually will distrust you and not accept what you say. The very reason you see that preachers sometimes speak with boldness. What they know will hurt people is the people know what they're doing. They are putting themselves at risk for the sake of the people. Preachers who ultimately only say what people want to hear finally are never heard because people know you do not care enough about me to put yourself at risk. So when you care more about me than yourself, I will listen to you. Sometimes even when you say very hard things because you love me that much. Now again, if the goal is simply to assert my authority, that's why you have to listen to me, then I won't listen to you again. Your concerns now about you. How do people read all of these things? Ethos. It's the involvement of the life of the minister with the people. Sometimes we think, you know, I could be a great preacher if they would just give me 40 hours a week in my study. If I could just concentrate on that message, but the fact of the matter is, if there is not life upon life, word will not be heard. It is actually that wonderful balance of having sufficient study to be credible and sufficient involvement to be known to be compassionate. The pulpit is not the only place you preach. In fact, if it is the only place you preach, you will not be heard. It is involvement in life that gives foundation to what is being said in the pulpit. These things continue in many scriptural places. I think probably my favorite pastoral passage is the one that's in your notes. First, that's onions 2, 3 through 8 and 11 through 12. I'm just going to read portions and I want you to hear how the apostle is talking about the power of what is moving forward and how it does. He writes, the appeal we make does not spring from error or impure motives, nor are we trying to trick you. So, you know, I'm just looking so magic to make this scripture thing work here. That was the seven sons of Skiva. Remember, they would just use the name of Jesus as a magic spell and they thought that was going to make things happen. He says, we're not trying to trick you. On the contrary, we speak as men approved by God to be entrusted with the gospel. We are not trying to please men, but God who tests our hearts. What's he arguing for? Why should you listen to me? Right now, he's saying because you know we are trustworthy before God. Even so trustworthy that we won't try to please you, but please God instead. You know, we never use flattery, nor we put on a mass to cover up. Greed God is our witness. We were not looking for praise from men, not from you or anyone else. As apostles of Christ, we could have been a burden to you. Look at these words, but we were gentle among you, like a mother caring for her little children. Now, the NIV is being kind of gentle in our sensibilities here. The actual Greek language here is we were as gentle as a mother nursing a baby. Here's an apostle. Does he have a right to be bold? Does he have authority? But we wanted to show you our compassion. We were as gentle among you as a mother caring for her little children. We loved you so much that we were delighted to share with you not only the gospel of God, logos, but our lives as well, ethos, because you had become so dear to us. Wow, what a statement. We delighted to share not only the gospel, but our lives because we were so concerned for you. So the logos is traveling with the ethos, recognizing that becomes the way in which the gospel is heard. Look at 2 Timothy 2, 15. Study to show yourself approved unto God. Now, that's almost surprising language. Studies so that you will proclaim the word of God correctly is what we expect to hear said. But he said, no, study to show yourself approved unto God. A workman that needs not be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth. It's actually ethos now that's coming into you prior to logos. Before you're rightly dividing the word of truth, you're showing yourself approved unto God. Avoid Godless chatter, flee the evil desires of youth and pursue righteousness, faith, love and peace. Very hard next sentence for seminary students sometimes don't have anything to do with foolish and stupid arguments. I love to argue. I do. I mean, my college background was competitive speech and debate. I just love a good get in there and do it out. And I had to recognize early in my ministry, it would not serve me in the church. If you reason you got a seminary so you'll have a great debate, well, it may be fun for you. But Paul said the man of God must not strive. He must not be known as a lover of debate. I loved you so much. Yes, I would do everything I can to convince you to make you know, but he's not loving the debate. It's loving the product of truth. What is this doing in your heart? Am I actually caring enough about you to watch what's happening to you and people around us as we simply are engaging in dialogue because it's fun to cross swords. It does not serve the church. What are we doing? Defending truth or enjoying the battle? In everything, Paul says to tie to set them an example by doing what is good in your teaching, logos, show integrity, seriousness and soundness of speech that cannot be condemned. Now, at this point in the lecture, I hope you're feeling a certain tension. Because early on, I was saying, it's not all on you. The power's in the word. Now what have I spent the last 10 minutes talking about? Your obligation, your responsibility, your faithfulness. How do those two things come together? Let me try it this way. How do we reconcile the power in the word and the place of ethos? How do we reconcile the power being in the word and the place of ethos in the ordinary process of preaching effectively? I think it's this balance. God can work apart from us. Can you do that? Paul's rejoicing whether for right motives or wrong. I'm rejoicing the words going forth. God can work apart from us. But he chooses more often to work through us and in that he uses our character to confirm the truth of his word. So where does that leave us? It's here. His ability to work without us removes the burden. His ability to work without us removes the burden. I've just got to do it right or it won't work. Hear that? His ability to work without us removes the burden. His willingness to work through us grants us the blessing of knowing our labor is not in vain. His willingness to work through us grants us the blessing of knowing our labor is not in vain. So we have this burden taken off of us and still the blessing of knowing that God rewards faithfulness. If I'm not faithful, I'm not rejected. If I'm not able enough, I don't say, oh no, God can't now work. No, the burden is off of me. But I have the wonderful blessing to know that he is able to use my efforts, which I want to give him. I mean, that's true of the heart of a believer. I want to serve my God. I want to use my gifts for his purposes. And God blesses me by saying, I will use them. It is my choice to do that even though I do not need to do that. What are the implications of this ethos power then? If we recognize that God can use it powerfully even though he doesn't need to recognize this isn't in required. There are three things here, ethos implications. First, guard your heart. Guard your heart. If ethos can be so used of God, Archibald Alexander said it this way, there is no person that needs to be more in constant exercise of prayer than the theological student. In the midst of studies, his heart should be raised to God more consistently for help and direction than in any other place in society. As you're taking in all this information, all this material from the Word of God to actually know that what I am taking in will be used of God, says, I must guard my heart so I take it improperly, especially as these foundations are being laid for all future ministry in life. Whether you know it or not, you see, this ethos enables us to witness to others but actually to know the Word. So far, we've actually talked about witness the most, right? People examine who we are so they'll listen. We know holiness of life is necessary, commonly, holiness of life is necessary most of the time for the effective communication of truth. Do you know that holiness of life is also necessary for the knowledge of the truth? That's a rather startling thought. By communing with God, I actually know more than I would know without him. I can't express to you all that I wish I could in this regard but you know it, why are there certain ministers you have to listen to? Because they seem to have special spiritual insight, they walk with God and something and you knows that. And because they walk with God, they seem to have, I'm not talking about a pipeline of you know, special revelation but their hearts are resonating in such a way that they are living in a way that makes God's truth powerful in its communication. I think of AB Earl and he was a great Baptist evangelist in the last century and when he wrote prior to the radio and TV age of what he thought would be so effective in terms of communicating the gospel to others, he ultimately recognized it was his own hearts communion with God. And so he wrote in his diary these words, this day for the sake of God's people I make a new consecration of my all to Jesus Christ. I now and forever give myself to him my soul to be washed in his blood and saved in heaven and last my whole body to be used for his glory, my mouth to speak for him at all times, my eyes to weep over lost sinners, my feet to carry me where he wants me to go. My heart to be burdened for souls, my intellect to be employed at all times for his glory. I give him my wife, my children, my property, all I have and all I ever shall be, I give that I may obey every known duty for the sake of my Savior and his message. Do you think this man knew something of the Lord? I think he knew more and more and more and more so that those who counted by the time he was done said that he was responsible for hundreds of thousands of conversions in the pre-electronic era. Amazing. He knew more by walking with God. You'll discover more and more of that, won't you? You'll see it around you, not to be judgmental of anyone, but the guys who seem sometimes so intellectually gifted and so cold and those who seem so warm toward God and what you really want to learn from them, they know something about God because of their guarded heart which gives them integrity before him. Now, now should you guard your heart, a second implication of ethos is become well acquainted with the grace your heart requires. Becoming well acquainted with the grace your heart requires is a recognition of something. Once we put so much weight upon ethos, every one of you should say, but I can't do that. I can't do that. Here's this wonderful example of AB Earl who is willing to give everything to God and we recognize the power of that, but ultimately AB Earl was preaching the gospel. And the gospel said, I am not dependent upon my work. I, in my best efforts, recognize my failures before God and therefore I am dependent upon his love and mercy in my behalf. If you are to preach grace, you must know it and knowing it means you put not only the willingness to obey before God but the constant heart of confession before him, Lord, as much as I will, I fail. Though I want to do good, I do it not. Teach me of your love, teach me of your mercy because when you then experience it, when it's not your ethos, that's the power of the word, but your recognition of God's conforming your character to himself by his grace and despite your character, then your heart for God enlarges. The grace of God begins to motivate you and you become one not only whose characters observe by God's people but whose compassion is felt by God's people. You know the grace of God. Character when pursued leads you to a sense of failure and failure rightly responded to teaches you much of the grace of God which makes you desire to be all the more conformed to his image. It's interesting isn't how that works? That when I pursue character for his sake, I know the need of his grace and when I experience his grace, I so much more long for more of his character. It's my blessing to follow it then. We got our hearts, we become well acquainted with the grace that's in our hearts and then the last ethos of implication, ethos implication is this. Believe in the grace that says, you can be a great preacher. Believe in the grace that says, you can be a great preacher. Dr. Rayburn, when he would teach this class, always at this portion of the lecture, would say to us, you will have different levels of skill. Some of you are just naturally gifted palpateers and some of you are not but if your heart loves the word of God and the people of God, the words that you say even if they barely can crawl over the lip of the pulpit will be heard by God's people because what they are listening for is somebody who understands the grace of God more than anything else, more than eloquence, more than great argument, more than great argument, what people listen for is. Do you understand the truth of God's words so much that you can communicate the gospel to me? Why did I sit down? Why did I come into this place as a church to you just so I would get more information just so that you could tell me it's hard to raise kids today? I knew that before I sat down. Why did I sit down? Don't you have a word of God for me? Isn't there some healing that you can provide? When you know the grace of God, God can greatly use you and believing in that grace is ultimately what makes you a great preacher. More than any other thing is understanding the work that he has done in your behalf. Do you remember how Paul said it to Timothy? There he was, a young man fearing he wouldn't be able to minister at Ephesus. Paul said, don't let anyone look down on you because you are young, but set an example for the believers in speech, in life, in love, in faith, in purity, always ethos. Until I come, devote yourself to the public reading of Scripture to preaching and to teaching. Do not neglect your gift which was given to you through prophetic message when the body of elders laid their hands on you. Be diligent in these matters. Give yourself holy to them so that everyone can observe your progress. Now think of that. You put yourself on the line before people so they can observe you as they hear what you're teaching. Be diligent in these matters. What's your life and your doctrine closely, persevere in them because if you do, you will save both yourself and your hearers. Watch your life, but also what you teach because you're teaching what saves people. Teach that, and when you do, it will not only be nourishment to your soul, but to many others as well. I want you to believe it deeply. God can greatly use you, not because of your gifts, primarily, but because of your heart. Set on him, you can lead others to his healing and to salvation forever. Tell me we have 10 minutes and that's my desire here to see if you have questions and give you opportunity. Do you see that there is an assignment for next time? Look over that just for a little bit and tell me if you have questions about it. You're to listen and chapel and then write a one page comparison of two sermons. Divide the page into thirds, divide a third to comparing how the speakers establish and use, logos, pathos and ethos. So it's just beginning to listen. Listen, you can turn this into a very dry dissection. You know, you can have roast preacher for lunch every day, you know, and that's not what we're talking about. Are you trying to learn so that you can feed God's people, not be critical, actually say, what am I learning about how this person is by ethos giving me confidence, or is there something being said that's actually putting me off that I just trust this person now? So I even reckon, I don't want to go there, not to be mean or harsh, I'm learning something, or is this person saying something that draws me in? How is pathos being expressed? What's the difference between saying something authentically moving and something that seems kind of manipulative? What makes me feel one way or another is I listen to other people. And logos, could I follow it? Did it make sense? Did the argument hold? Was it logical? So begin to just divide third of a page, look at two speakers, only one page all I'm looking for, and look at logos, pathos, ethos and two separate chapel speakers. I think there's only two that will happen before you have this assignment do at the fourth lecture. So it'll do at the fourth lecture, which I think is a week from Friday. You're comparing both on the one page. So you're comparing both regarding logos, both comparing pathos, and both comparing ethos. So a third to each component on the page. Yes, sir. Can you use the sermon from the convocation? Yes, you may. Use the sermon from the convocation. If you have enough kind of recollection of that, you can move backwards, if you want, as well as forward. Questions about the lecture itself. Do you feel the tension that I mentioned to you? God's saying I can work without you, but I choose to work with you, and if I will work with you, I need your heart as well as your words. But of course, now we say, but my heart isn't pure enough, that's right. But remember, God is sufficient still. So it takes the burden off of us, even if it gives us the delight of knowing I can be used of God. Questions? I would just tell you straight out, it always appears on the midterm. Who are what alone can change the hearts of men and women eternally? The Holy Spirit working what? Buy and with the word in our hearts. Buy and with the word. You know it will come. Anything else? Yes, sir. The perceived character, that's tough isn't it. The perceived character of the speaker. Yes. The question regarding is, it's just hard to say the perceived character of the speaker because we all know that we can be misperceived. And that's why we have to say just the reality is perception becomes the reality. And if people are perceiving me in a way that I do not intend, I have to recognize that and deal with it. It's in your readings and will come up again. But, you know, Dr. Sanderson, when he taught here, used to say that the way that you test any candidate for preaching what you should do, anybody read this yet, you'll get to it. He said, you know, play softball with them. And when they were, when they were safe at second base on a close play, call them out. See what happens, you know, the great pastoral test, you know. But what he's saying is, what people perceive about the individual largely will determine how they will receive what he's saying. Phillips Brooks, famous statement, what truth is, or preaching is truth poured through what? Do you remember? Personality, preaching is truth poured through personality. Now, lots of different personalities. But if I think you're a liar, will I listen to you? If I think you don't care about me, will I listen to you? It's actually, I think, just for what it's worth, I mean, one of the weaknesses of my background, and I think many young men in my setting, when you come from families where you were taught to be stoic, not to show emotion, then, then kind of reaching into the pulpit setting in which you were saying, if I act like this doesn't matter, then I'm perceived as not caring. I care greatly. But my manner is something trained from my youth that I have to, in some ways, war against in order to adequate communicate what God is saying. Now, again, different personalities, right? Some people, if they just kind of almost lift an eyebrow, you see, wow, he really means that, you know, just give it, but other people almost have to be quite demonstrative, because they're demonstrative all the time. So to act, they really mean something is going to take more. And we'll talk a lot more as we go through things. How we express things so that we're not miscommunicating what we're trying to say, because there are simple things at times that we do that miscommunicate and we don't recognize what they are. For now, recognize character just oozes out of you in ways we don't even know, right? You have a conversation with someone, you've met them for about five minutes, and just their choice of words, the way they hold their bodies, you know, you're making all kinds of judgments about them just like that. What scares us is speech communicators say that people typically make those judgments in the first 30 seconds of whether or not even you care about them and are willing and whether they are willing to listen to you. Now, we're not with people 30 seconds, and we're pastors, we're with them for years and years, and recognizing that our perceived character really weighs in their minds whether we are worth listening to is important and deadly if I don't believe in the grace of God, because they will always perceive my weaknesses louder than my strengths. So I need to know greatly, God has forgiven me, that's what gets me back up here again. He makes me his own despite my weaknesses. I didn't take that monkey off your back, did I? perceived character is going to be a tough one, it's always going to be there, and yet it has to be in our minds as we evaluate giving ourselves for other people, not just working in my comfort zone, right? I'm comfortable with this. Well, how are you being perceived? That has to be taken into account, too. Yes. How did you find out how I was being perceived? People will talk to you about what they're unhappy with. One of the things that you'll do, not this semester, but in future ones, is you'll watch a videotape of yourself, it's torture, you know, you have to look at yourself, you know, while you're preaching, and you know, sometimes when you're preaching, you know, your heart is racing, and you're just feeling, wow, I'm just so demonstrative, and you look at yourself on the tape and you're going, and I believe that this is the most important thing, and you're kind of, you know, you're there, and you felt being so animated, but you look at yourself on tape, and sometimes it's quite different. You will get some feedback from your peers this semester, because we'll do those devotionals, in which you'll present something, and people will give you an evaluation. John Stott and many preachers just put themselves under the discipline of meeting with people weekly, just to give them feedback on their messages. I mean, they just so much recognize I can be the worst perceiver of myself, that they, you know, you have to have a pretty thick skin and a pretty sure ego, you know, to do that, but actually say, what do you think? And then begin to trust God enough, how do I say, and understand people enough to properly filter what they're saying, because certain people will come at you no matter what, and you have to say, well, there's a certain legitimacy to what you're saying, but I have to remember who you are, and other people, of course, will never say anything unless it's very wrong, and if they say something, you really have to listen. But that's some of that pastoral prudence coming forward, right? What do I need to listen to? What do I actually before God have to turn a deaf ear to? All those become part of the resources. But we'll read more about how you gain in your knowledge of yourself. Keith? Yes. What's the difference between becoming credible for the sake of perceived understanding versus then just becoming manipulative and not authentic? And at that point, you have to say, I have to ultimately do certain things so much that it becomes authentic to me. Those who will get down to it a little bit later, but for instance, if you just say, you know, I'm just not a demonstrative character, you know, it's just not my nature, so I just don't want to gesture when I talk. Well, ultimately, I said, you know what you need to do? Not just I will tell you, but many is what, you need to over-gesture in practice. You know, just gesture all the time when you're talking so that finally when you're speaking, it is natural to you. So you do enough of what is outside your comfort zone so that it actually becomes comfortable to you and natural to you. Now, I'm not talking becoming a different person, but we just must recognize it. Well, you know, I'm just a soft spoken person, so I will talk softly when I preach. So well, that doesn't work. You know, you're going to have to raise your voice and if you consistently raise your voice, it becomes natural to you. And then it's not something you put on, it just becomes natural. So practice regular interaction with people and learning what's putting them off can deal with some of that. More to come, though, it's a good question. How do we deal with what's necessary without becoming inauthentic? We are going to try to say more and more being natural for who you are is the most powerful thing you can do. But it's not natural to do certain things and we'll actually find out standing in front of people actually creates unnatural things. In conversation, the people who say, I just don't want to gesture. Say, if I were to look at you in any conversation, you would gesture. Everybody does. But when you stand in front of people suddenly your arms have weights on them. And we stop, you know, or we start gesturing with our shoulders. And we say, actually, that's not natural, you know, so the goal is to stay natural and we'll talk about more how to do that. So a lot of this authenticity is a very good question and we'll come forward. See you next time.