<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Darovat Darovat měsíčně

Justification & Christian Freedom

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Okay, we made it through one of the two volumes of Calvin's Institute. Long section on justification, I'm sure that was a tribe, your perseverance. And I included in the sum of his Calvin's outline in 3, 11 to 19, just to kind of present a little bit of a roadmap through those chapters. Calvin spends considerable time on this doctrine, and tends to repeat himself somewhat. We didn't read every single chapter, but we read most of that section, 3, 11 to 15, chapter 17 and chapter 19. And what I want to do this morning is to talk about Calvin's doctrine of justification, not really following the order that Calvin uses through these chapters, but summing up his thoughts, and there is some repetition there. And first, let's look to the Lord in prayer with again a prayer from John Calvin. Almighty God, you set before our eyes the many evils by which we have provoked your anger against us, and yet you give us the hope of pardon if we repent. Let us a teachable spirit that with the coming meekness we may pay attention to your warnings, but not so as to despair of the mercy offered us, but seek it to your son as he has once for all made peace with you by shedding his blood. So cleanse us also by your spirit, from all our pollutions until at last we stand spotless before you in that day when Christ shall appear for the salvation of all his people. Amen. Remember, we review for a moment that in book 3, Calvin is talking about the way in which we receive the grace of Christ, what benefits come to us from it, and what effects follow began with the chapter on the Holy Spirit, who is the bond between Christ and us, the Spirit is the way, and the principal work of the Spirit is faith. And then Calvin says, I must choose between two points that equally demand attention at this place and my treatment in the institutes. One is justification and the other is sanctification. And then surprisingly, Calvin chooses to put sanctification first for reasons that we looked at probably because of Roman Catholic objections to the doctrine of justification by faith alone. Calvin wants to emphasize the importance of the necessity of the certainty of good works in the justified person before he comes as such to the doctrine of justification. He explained that back in 3, 3, 1, when he said our immediate transition will be from faith to repentance or sanctification. For when this topic is rightly understood, it will better appear how man is justified by faith alone. So having spent time on repentance, the race of repentance, sanctification, the Christian life, Calvin now comes to ask the question, what produced this kind of life? How can it be that a person can live this way? And the answer is, God alone can do the work which enables a person to become a Christian and live the Christian life and God does it by justifying us by faith alone. So we come finally to justification in Calvin. And certainly the length of the treatment shows something of Calvin's concern to emphasize this doctrine. He doesn't want us to think that because he's postponed it a bit, it's not central, it's not urgent, it's not foundational. In fact, Calvin calls it, you recall in 3, 11, 1, the main hinge on which religion turns. You could translate that, the main thing about religion, that Calvin's image is an interesting one. The main hinge on which religion turns, that's 3, 11, 1, says the same thing in 3, 14, 11. The principal hinge on which our controversy with the papus turns, you might wonder why Calvin is using that particular metaphor. And I think the answer, that is Luther used that in his bondage of the will, written against Erasmus on the freedom of the will. Luther said, you, speaking to Erasmus, saw what was the grand hinge upon which the whole turn. And therefore you attacked the vital part at once and Luther goes on to say, I thank you for that, because you have really focused on the main topic, rather than indulgence as purgatory, the corruptions and the Catholic church, which are minor topics Luther says compared to this main topic, which is how a person is saved. So Calvin picks up on that language and uses it in the institutes. Some have wanted to see Calvin's treatment of justification as somewhat second-handed, and maybe not really vital to his own construction of his theological system. In fact, Alistair McGrath makes that point, but it seems to me it's quite mistaken. I think what we have here is Calvin stressing this doctrine in a very unambiguous way. Certainly in one sense, the second-handed, he's inherited it mostly from Luther, but that doesn't have to mean that it's secondary, just because Luther has come first with it. Calvin comes along and emphasizes it just as much as Luther does. In fact, T. H. L. Parker in his book on Calvin, an introduction to his thought, said, justification is something Calvin has been working up to all through the institutes. And I think that much closer to an accurate assessment of the place of this doctrine in Calvin, then Alistair McGrath's comment. So we have significant treatment to nine chapters, more space given to justification by faith in the first three books and any other topic, except for the doctrine of the Christian life. Actually, if you look at all four books and just think of space, it's not the most determinative factor in assessing the importance of what is being treated, but it certainly is significant. The doctrine of the church gets more pages than any other doctrine, but the doctrine of justification is significantly treated. In fact, Calvin seems to feel, he says in 314-6, that maybe he's overdoing it in terms of going back over these points again and again. Calvin says, the thought repeatedly returns to my mind if there is a danger of my being unjust to God's mercy, when I labor with such great concern to assert it as if it were doubtful or obscure. So he doesn't want us to think because he's emphasizing it, saying the same thing over and over again, repeating himself that he's trying to make a point that is somehow not certain. Calvin's attention to the doctrine and his repetition is not because the doctrine is uncertain, but because it's so important. And because it was so controversial, Calvin is going to treat doctrines that are controversial, much more than he will treat doctrines that in the 16th century were not controversial. So we don't get huge amount of attention to the doctrine of the Trinity, not because that was not considered essential, but because everybody was accepting that, almost everybody. But this doctrine of justification is one that was controversial, and so Calvin spends a considerable time with it. Okay, that's the importance of the doctrine. I'm now to talk about the relation of justification by faith to sanctification. Calvin sees both as the gifts of God, sanctification, and justification. Justification frees us from the necessity of obeying the law for salvation. It doesn't free us from the necessity of obeying the law, but it frees us from the necessity of obeying the law for salvation, which we can't do anyway. So it's our only hope. And then sanctification, regeneration, units of life enables us to obey the law as justified people. So these two topics are very closely linked in Calvin's thought. They're both gifts of God, gifts of the gospel. They can't be separated. Justification is the source of sanctification. Without justification, one has neither a foundation on which to establish your salvation, nor one on which to build piety toward God. He's been talking about piety toward God for quite a few chapters, but in 3111, when he comes to begin his discussion of justification, he says, now we've come to the foundation of all that. Without this foundation, there's no way that we could build piety toward God, or there's no basis on which we can establish our salvation. So two different things can't be separated, can't really have justification without sanctification. You can't have sanctification without justification. But at the same time, Calvin is very concerned that they could not and should not be confused or confound it. You can talk about justification, you can talk about sanctification, should not separate them, and we've seen in the very way that he tries to handle these two, how he doesn't want to, in any sense, separate the two. But at the same time, it's essential not to confuse them. And Calvin felt that the heresies of his day were caused by a confusion of sanctification with justification. He has two targets here, two opponents. One is a Lutheran, theologian by the name of Acyander, and the other is the Roman Catholic theologians. He opposes them both. And he thinks they both make the same mistake in the long run, although they come at it from quite different angles. Let's take Acyander first. Calvin doesn't have much respect for Acyander. He attacks him on a number of occasions. And Acyander was not a great theologian. In fact, we would probably not even know much about Acyander if Calvin had not spent so much time attacking Acyander. The Lutherans did, for the most part, care for Acyander either. So, when Calvin attacks Acyander, he's not attacking Lutheranism. He's attacking a Lutheran theologian who had some heretical views, according to Calvin, and, according to most of the Lutherans. What Calvin describes as Acyander's doctrine is some strange monster of essential righteousness. That is his discussion of Acyander, the introduction to it. And what so upsets Calvin about Acyander is that Acyander believed in justification, but he rejected the undiluted imputation concept. In other words, Acyander said, a person cannot be justified just because God, besides that person is justified. Without some kind of change happening within that person. God cannot regard as just those who are not just. If God simply says about the center, he's justified. That's improper and impossible. There has to be something that happens within the center that enables God to speak of that center as justified. Calvin said that some strange monster of essential righteousness, because Acyander felt that we become just, not because God says we're just, but by the fact of Christ indwelling in us. So justification is not just a forensic act, it's not a declaration. It's the actual coming of Christ to indwell within us. And so we're made righteous by the infusion of Christ, the essence of Christ within us, and God can look upon us then as justified, because we really are now to some extent righteous and just people. Luther would not have agreed with that, and certainly Calvin doesn't either. Calvin says, we who are not righteous in ourselves are reckoned as such in Christ. To him, justification is not that we are indwelt by Christ, and so are justified on that basis, but we're not righteous in ourselves, but we are reckoned as righteous in Christ. I think Calvin's objection to Acyander is that he mixes sanctification and justification. Certainly the indwelling of Christ is an important doctrine for Calvin, but our union with Christ which produces the righteousness which we experience as Christians is sanctification is not justification. So Acyander's view is justification by sanctification, whereas Calvin's view is justification by faith alone, and then sanctification as the result of our justification. So our righteousness Calvin insists is always in terms of our justification, our righteousness is always outside ourselves. Something God does for us imputes to us, gives us credit for it, reckons us as righteous, but we're not righteous, although we've become righteous then as a result of the justification which is given to us. That's outside of anything that we do or anything that happens within us. The same thing as Luther talks about when he talks about alien righteousness. Righteousness that we have which justifies us is always alien, belongs to somebody else, it's not ours, and of course it is the righteousness of Christ which is imputed to us. So one of the targets of Calvin is Acyander, and then the other target and far more significant target is the whole Roman Catholic sacramental system built up during the Middle Ages in which the Roman Catholic doctrine of justification was one that mixed. God's grace with human works is another form of justification by sanctification. So even though Acyander and Roman Catholics are quite different in their approach to this doctrine, it ends up Calvin thinks the same place. When he's talking about the Catholics, he says this, they interpret the grace of God not as the imputation of free righteousness, Calvin's view, the imputation of free righteousness, but as the spirit helping in the pursuit of holiness. So grace of God is there, but justification is not God's simply declaring the center justified on the basis of the work of Christ, but God applying the work of Christ to the center, enabling them the center to begin to do his or her part in the work of salvation.

Calvin throughout these chapters is concerned to show that he is following St. Augustine in many things, those things, and we're going to come to the doctrine of election, which we will quite soon now. Calvin is greatly concerned to show that he is following Augustine in that doctrine as well, but in this treatment of the Catholic view of justification, Calvin says, or when Augustine says anything clearly, Lombard obscures it. Lombard is Peter Lombard, the author of the sentences, called the master of the sentences, he's probably, he is the premier Catholic medieval theologian, prior to Thomas Grinus. Lombard's sentences would be the standard Catholic systematic theology of the Middle Ages, and what Lombard does is largely look for sources, quote, church fathers and earlier medieval theologians, and create the theology on the basis of what others have said, but Augustine is often quoted in Lombard. But Calvin says when Augustine says anything clearly, Lombard obscures it, and if there was anything slightly contaminated in Augustine, Calvin finds a occasional little problem in Augustine, Lombard totally corrupts it. So Lombard is not his favorite theologian by any means, and Lombard and the others that stand for Roman Catholic theology are subjects, then, to Calvin's attack here. Could you real quickly go over the differences between Calvin and Augustine on this? Well, let me put it in two ways, just briefly. Augustine will talk about salvation by grace alone, and that's the whole theme of his anti-pollegium writings, it's not by works, it's by God's grace. But the reformation formula of justification by grace through faith is not present in Augustine, but through faith aspect is not present in Augustine as it is in Luther.

Luther says I agree with Augustine, it's by grace alone, but we need to say by faith alone too, and there's much more emphasis than in the reformation and in Calvin on faith alone. There's a big discussion about that, but I don't see a huge problem there, you know, when you say by grace alone, and the reformers said by faith alone, they simply mean you can't add anything to God's grace, that's what faith alone means. But that emphasis is not found in Augustine as it is in Calvin. The other issue, the other point of difference, and there are some tiny points of difference too on small matters of interpretation, but the other major point is that Calvin clearly, as we'll see, goes to a double predestination, and it's debated as to whether Augustine does or not. Could you call a Augustine a single predestinarian in Calvin, a double predestinarian? And what does Augustine say about reprobation, what does Calvin say about reprobation? So I'd say on those two points you have the major differences. The Catholic view of justification that Calvin is dealing with is one where someone that is infused with righteousness by grace. How does that differ from Augustine's view? Calvin, how does the Catholic view different from Augustine's view? If Augustine says grace alone, then the Catholics say grace alone, meaning infusion, rather than infusion. Okay, Augustine's view is grace alone, apart from works. The Catholic view is semi-Augustinian? Yes, grace, but works have to be added. However, works come. You can talk about works as the result of infusion of Christ's righteousness or the enablement of the spirit or the obedience of the Christian. But justification ultimately depends on some human works, whereas for Augustine justification doesn't depend on human works, but on God's grace alone. If we have time, at the end of the lecture, we'll look at the Catholic system of salvation versus Calvin's system of salvation. And you'll see with that it's outlined in the syllabus at the end of this lecture that a person gets to heaven, that person gets there, both because of reward and human accomplishment. Whereas in Calvin's understanding of heaven is just as much a gift as justification is. We get to heaven because of God's grace, not because of our efforts. Of course, that raises the issue, which the Catholics would very quickly. Well, does it not matter what we do? And I think we have to go back to the fact that Calvin has already spent considerable time emphasizing the necessity of the Christian life as the product of justification before he even comes to justification as the basis for Christian life. OK, let's look at his definitions. Calvin's definitions, usually he gives us a definition. He likes definitions, likes to be clear, set forth his thought, a brief phrase or sentence or paragraph, but he gives us three definitions at least of justification. They're not contradictory, but each one is slightly different. Three, eleven, two, it's the acceptance with which God receives us into his favor as righteous. Acceptance is the big word there. Receives us into his favor as righteous as though we were righteous. It consists in the remission of sins and the imputation of Christ's righteousness, forgiven we receive the righteousness of Christ. Three, eleven, three to justify means nothing else than to acquit a guilt, him who was accused as if his innocence were confirmed. In 317-8 we define justification as follows. The sinner received into communion with Christ is reckoned by God, to God is reconciled to God by his grace, while cleansed by Christ's blood, he obtains forgiveness of sins, and clothed with Christ's righteousness as if it were his own. He stands confident before the heavenly judgment see. When we look at those definitions, I think two ideas I keep coming through. One is the idea of imputed righteousness, believers are righteous, not in themselves, but through the righteousness of Christ. It's not imparted righteousness, like we find in us the ender, but it's imputed righteousness. Righteousness of Christ is reckoned as ours. Three, eleven, twenty-three you see that our righteousness is not in us, but in Christ. So as we talk about justification, we have to talk about righteousness, but it's not ours. It's in Christ. One of Calvin's illustrations here is Jacob in his brother's clothing, and he comes before the father, and the father recognizes him as someone that he is not. It's kind of a convoluted illustration. You might not really think of using it, because of all the background of that illustration, and I'm not sure I would want to use it in a sermon either, but Calvin's point is clear. Jacob stands there, and the father says you are Esau, and we stand there, and somebody else is clothing, and the father says, I see you as righteous. So imputed righteousness is essential, and then forgiveness of sins. So it's not only that God sees us as righteous because we're clothed in the righteousness of Christ, but God sees us as being forgiven of our sins. Three eleven, twenty-one, the righteousness of faith is reconciliation with God, which consists in the forgiveness of sins. Sins forgiven, and the righteousness of Christ imputed to us. Now it's not really two different things, because forgiveness of sins is based on the righteousness of Christ imputed to us, but it's two ways to look at what transpires in justification. Sins forgiven, and we stand clothed in the righteousness of Christ. See, I suppose we could think of sins forgiven, and then we could stand there in ourselves, but that would be a pretty pitiful situation because we're still sinners, despite the fact that we've been justified. So our sins, the guilt of our sins are forgiven, the guilt is forgiven, and we stand in the presence of God, clothed in the righteousness of Christ. When Calvin is writing about the cannons of Trent, the council of Trent was going on through good portion of Calvin's lifetime as a reformer in Geneva, so he's aware of these rules that are being drawn up by the Roman Catholics in Trent in Italy, and Calvin was also writing about what Trent was doing. What Trent was producing in order to answer Trent's doctrines and Trent's attacks on Protestant doctrine. In Calvin says this about Trent, the venerable fathers, kind of interesting, there he uses a rather pleasant description. His enemies, he doesn't always do that, but the venerable fathers, he calls them, maybe that's irony or sarcasm, but nonetheless it sounds better than those scoundrels or those dogs or something else which Calvin often says about his enemies, theological enemies. The venerable fathers will not allow justifying faith to be defined as the confidence with which we embrace the mercy of God as forgiving sin for Christ's sake. When you think about these two ideas, imputed righteousness, imputation and forgiveness of sins, as I say two ways of looking at the same thing, they're not contradictory, they are complimentary. Sometimes people seem to be uneasy with the idea of imputation, that's forensic, that's legal, that's the kind of intellectualism, and forgiveness is something that's warm and personal and start talking about adoption, things like that. But I don't think we should see it that way, certainly, imputation for Calvin was not some kind of abstraction and forgiveness, the real justification, but part from imputation, forgiveness would have been unintelligible to Calvin because God doesn't and really can't just forgive because he wants to forgive. He has to have a way to forgive, a basis on which to forgive, and unless the righteousness of Christ can somehow be reckoned to my account, then what other faces is there for the forgiveness of my sins. God just can't say you're forgiven because God's holiness and justice would have to be satisfied in some way for God to be God. So imputation is not an abstraction, it's not some kind of cold intellectualism. I think we can embrace imputation as warmly as we can embrace forgiveness.

Okay, let's look at the results of the doctrine of justification by faith. Remember this third book, Calvin, is talking about the way in which we receive the grace of Christ, the benefits that come to us from it, we've just been talking about those benefits, imputation, righteousness of Christ, imputed to us and forgiveness of sins, and what effects follow. Some effects will follow, and I think Calvin means by that things will be present in our lives, be seen in our lives, the effects of justification, as well as the effects of repentance, which we looked at earlier. Practical application of that in the golden booklet of the Christian life, self-denial bearing across meditation on heaven, uses of this present life, those are all effects which show up in our lives as a result of God's work of repentance or regeneration or sanctification. And when we come to justification, there are effects as well. This is not merely a kind of legal exercise, doesn't have any practical implications, but justification has practical implications as well as sanctification. And two, mainly one, justification by faith alone, serves God's honor. This enables us to honor God, this doctrine, enables us to honor God in the way we think and in the way we live so that His glory stands undiminished. Three, thirteen, two, man cannot without sacrilege claim for himself even a crumb of righteousness. For just so much is plucked and taken away from the glory of God's righteousness. In other words, when you talk about salvation, if you even take a little bit away just a crumb of righteousness that you claim for yourself, then you've diminished by that much the glory of God's righteousness. When I think about the Roman Catholic medieval system, I usually call that percentage theology, as I do in the Church history classes, because what it means, and Catholic theologians differed on exactly how this would work, but what it means is that God does His part and you do Your part. And God, let's say, does 90% and you do 10% percentage theology. And God, if He does His part and you don't do Your part, you're not going to be saved. Or let's say God does 99% and you do 1%, it's still percentage theology. And Calvin says, it doesn't matter how small the percentage is that you do if there is anything, they are a crumb of righteousness. Then by that night, it's going to diminish the glory of God's righteousness. So the doctrine of justification by faith alone is the only teaching that can fully honor God and His glory stands undemannished. It was at the St. Louis Zoo some years ago and looking at some kind of strange breed of cattle. I don't remember what these things were called, but they could tell they were some kind of breed of cattle but different and big. And while I was standing there looking at these things, a little two little boys came running by and they wanted to see what they did at the zoo and they took one look at this thing. And one little boy said to the other one, come on, they ate nothing but a big cow. And it didn't look kind of like a big cow, but it was an unusual big cow. But the reason I thought of that is, you know, whatever you call a system in which there is some percentage of human effort required for salvation, it ain't nothing but salvation by works. So justification by faith alone serves God's honor. His glory stands undemannished. We cannot take credit for our salvation even a little part of our salvation and at the same time give all the glory to God. You see the prayer, thank you Lord for helping me to become a Christian. It's not the same thing as thank you Lord for saving me. And that's the prayer we would pray if we were true to Calvin's teaching and I think true to the Bible. The other effect which follows is that this doctrine gives us peace of conscience and you can't really imagine how lacking that was in the 16th century unless you've studied quite a bit of the writings of the people of that time. There's no assurance, no confidence, nobody ever knew where they stood. Unless they receive some kind of direct revelation from God saying, you are a Christian, you're saved. And that did not happen very often, even according to Catholic sources. Salvation is a gift of God and because it's a gift of God, then there is the basis for confidence, assurance. Calvin says we profit nothing in discussing righteousness unless we establish a righteousness so steadfast that it can support our soul in the judgment of God. You see if we stand before God now or ultimately at the judgment, what's going to give us confidence? The fact that we did some things, well I expect that not strong enough, certainly people in the 16th century found it lacking. We'll always doubt then the validity of our works or the strength of our works. And if salvation is a work, even partially a work, even to a very small degree of work that is required of us, how can I know that I've done that work? And I know that I've measured up, you know, that was Luther's problem in the monastery where he went into the monastery in order to do more than he could do as an ordinary Christian. And then in the monastery, he did more than he was required to do as a monk so that he said if ever a monk could get to heaven by his munkery, it was me. Because whatever was required by the order, Luther did more. And he was supposed to confess. And yet so he did confess. But even at the very first step of confession which is contrition, confession is not going to be valid unless there's contrition. That is to feel genuinely sorry for your sins. 16th century person could not confess sins that he wasn't sorry for. But Luther stumbled even at that point because how could he know that he was really contrite? How much contrition was required? And he struggled with that. And then he confessed and he confessed until he wore his confessor out. And you might remember the story, the man said, we'll go and do something really bad and confess it because Luther would confess every little trivial thing and then would leave and come back and knock on the door and say I've forgotten something. I was a thought that I had, there was something that he had forgotten because Luther was trying to make the system work, you see. And he was certainly zealous in attempting to cover all of the bases but he never could have any confidence because he didn't know if he had done enough. But if salvation is a gift, a gift from God, then you don't have to worry about that because we know that God has done enough. We can stand confident in his presence. I don't have to earn it, don't have to deserve it, just receive it. And I know that God's gift is then enough. Okay, we're ready to go on to Christian freedom. This is a very interesting chapter 319 and this material in 319 was already present in 1536. Some of this Calvin tags from Luther, some from Malanthin. Malanthin has similar material in his Los Angeles communists of 1521. But as always, Calvin adds his own particular slant on things. And this material has moved around some through the various editions of the institutes. But in 1559, it's placed at the end of his treatment of justification as what he calls an appendage of justification. What does he mean by that? Well, I think Calvin means by that now that we've understood justification, we have to talk about Christian freedom because this is going to protect us against falling back into works righteousness in some way. It's going to keep us from legalism and doubt. One writer has said this and I think it's really so true how many words about Calvin's legalism would have remained unspoken if this chapter had been read more often. Calvin has criticized for anything he's probably going to be criticized. Well, for burning Servitas, having part in that, at least approving of it. But also for legalism. And sometimes you wonder if people who make those claims have read the institutes, they certainly have not read 319. So, let's look at what Calvin says here. Legalism doesn't understand the power of justification. Now, here's a point that I've made already, but make it again, both repentance or regeneration or sanctification or whatever synonym you want to use there. And justification have implications for how a person lives. The fact that we are accounted just before God is no less significant for practical life than the fact that we're united to Christ in mortification and vivification. So, the fact that we're united to Christ in mortification and vivification leads Calvin says to the life of the Christian and he gives us those chapters at the end of his treatment of sanctification on how a Christian lives. And the fact that we are reckoned righteous with the righteousness of Christ imputed to us in our sins forgiven. That has practical implications to for how a Christian lives. Calvin sets that forth in 319 on Christian freedom. So, you might say 319 is there to answer this question. What difference does this doctrine make in the nature of the Christian life? And Calvin tells us that it makes a difference in three great ways. First is, we're free from the law. There's no place for the law, 319 to. But of course, you have to understand what Calvin means by that. And I think you do, by this time, having read all these hundreds of pages in the institutes, it means we're free from the law as a means of salvation. We're free from salvation by works. And so, we're not, quote, disturbed and troubled over forgiveness of sins. That's a wonderful freedom. We know we have been forgiven. Our confidence is sure. We can forget the righteousness of the law and we can look to the grace of God. Now, his first point here is classic reformation teaching of salvation by grace alone. As we've been saying for all these pages, and now he says Christian freedom is freedom from falling back into any kind of old works righteousness, where it depends on us and not on God's grace. This, of course, is not a denial of the third use of the law for the Christian. But the third use of the law doesn't deny first use of the law. First use of the law says, I'm a center. I can't keep the law. I'm doomed unless God does something for me. The third use of the law says, I will keep the law. I must keep the law because it's God's holy intention for my life. So this is not a denial of the third use. Calvin says the law does not stop teaching and exhorting and urging believers to good. Even though before God's judgment seat, it has no place in their consciences, 319-2. We stand before the judgment seat. The law just doesn't come in. We don't even think about it. We can forget it. But that doesn't mean in terms of our Christian living, we can forget the law. That's the first use of Christian freedom. The second use is somewhat related. We are free now to freely obey God. We have the freedom of children to freely obey God's will. It's not the necessity now of a servant who knows he's not going to measure up and is going to fall short and be condemned. But it's the freedom of children to happily, freely obey the Lord. It's not a requirement for sonship. It's the result of sonship. It's not that I must obey the law so that God will love me. But I want to obey the law. I will obey the law. Because God loves me. So that God will love me. It's because God loves me. Calvin says, what a wonderful freedom that is because now we can bring our works, small imperfect rude to God. And we can know that this is not going to be measured by the rigor of the laws demands. Now these works we do keeping the law. I'd say it's down here on this level the law is way up there. What a goal there is between what the law requires and what even the best of us ever accomplishes. But we don't have to come into God's presence then with terror thinking God is requiring that. And we're only producing this. And so we're in big trouble.

Because we come in the presence of a gracious father this morning is go over the hospital for treatment and one of the doctors that I see has on the wall of his office. Very nice office. Portant looking medical books there but he has some incredibly poor pictures that he has all over this office. And they're done in crayon. And who knows what they stand for maybe a tree maybe a bird but doesn't look like a tree and doesn't look like a bird. But he's got these proudly plastered on the wall of his office. And the reason of course is because his children did them the bottom you can see with love to daddy something like that on all of these works of art. So you might say pretty poor stuff but treasure displayed accepted. Sure that doctor did not criticize his children because they were not Rembrandt's but he accepted the pictures because of what they stood for. And so in a sense you know we're like that we come into God's presence with our imperfect efforts and our pretty juvenile drawings and God accepts what we bring doesn't find fault with it. Well that's the second freedom that's an incredible freedom. And then the third freedom is freedom in the indifferent things the idea for a Greek word that we use for that Calvin uses that word occasionally but not much. But the idea is certainly present here in Calvin. He says as we live the Christian life there are many things which are indifferent. Not specifically covered by the law. And the Christian is free in all those things. There's no there's no legalism in Calvin here despite what people think. We cannot make the church cannot make nobody can make an eleventh commandment ten commandments God's law is God's law and we should not add to the law. The different expressions of Christianity of course have done a lot of this but we sometimes call fundamentalism tends to add to the law. You shall not go to movies you shall not dance you shall not play cards you shall not what else drink alcoholic beverages. And I grew up in that tradition and there's some very good things about it but all those laws were there all those restrictions were there and we were made to feel that this was part of the law of God. Just like the ten commandments but Calvin says things that the Bible doesn't cover are indifferent and the Christian is free in regard to all those things guided by two principles. So he's not just telling us just go out and do what you want to now in these areas. You're free in these areas don't add to the law. You're free but there are two principles that you ought to keep in mind. The first is moderation. Calvin says this we think about the indifferent things we should avoid both aestheticism and indulgence. On the one hand, asceticism entrapes the conscience in a long and inextricable maze. You can get really trapped in this by being too strict. Remember his illustration here people think maybe they should not drink good wine so they drink kind of mediocre wine. And then they think they should not even drink mediocre wine so they drink poor wine and then they think they should not drink wine at all so they drink water and they think they should not drink clean water so they drink dirty water. I mean it gets kind of an argument reductial out absurdum. And Calvin says don't go that way, don't get caught in that kind of rigid, narrow outlook on life. Recognize that God has given us good gifts and we should use those gifts for the purpose for which he gave them to us. And you might notice how this begins to overlap something that we have read in the life of the Christian. So both Christian freedom coming out of justification and appendage to justification and the life of the Christian flowing out of repentance can return to the same ideas. So avoid asceticism and on the other hand avoid indulgence. So slippery path here, narrow path and we can go off on the too strict side and we can go off on the too loose side. But we should live not luxuriate. Scallion's word for us. Now maybe a seminary students you think you're in good shape here because probably not many of you are luxuriating. We should live but not luxuriate. Here's how Calvin puts it in 399, surely ivory and gold and riches. Those things good or bad. He says they're good creations of God. They're permitted indeed appointed for men's use by God's providence. And we've never been forbidden to laugh or to be filled or to join new possessions to old or ancestral ones or to delight in musical harmony or to drink wine. True indeed. But where there is plenty to wallow in the lights, to gorge oneself, to intoxicate mind and heart with present pleasures and be always panting after new ones, such are very far removed from a lawful use of God's gifts. Gifts are there. We can use them as God intended us avoiding asceticism and avoiding indulgence. And then the other principle which should guide us in our Christian freedom is compassion. Christian freedom consists as much in abstaining as in using. It seems to me that's a very important part of what Calvin wants to get across to us. That's 31910 Christian freedom consists as much in abstaining as in using.

In other words, I exercise my Christian freedom when I am free to use these gifts that God has given to us in these indifferent areas, which is much of life. But I'm still using my Christian freedom when I don't use these gifts. Then I'd say you can use your Christian freedom in drinking wine and you can use your Christian freedom in not drinking wine.

Now, why would we want to abstain? We must not abuse our Christian freedom, but use it only if it helps the edification of our neighbor. So here's another principle that is brought in. We're free, yes, in indifferent things. But we should always be aware of who's with us, our neighbor, other people. And that idea is advanced then with two further ideas. And in the syllabus it says we must distinguish between the ignorance of our weak brothers and the rigor of the Pharisees. So you start thinking about neighbor, you've got two categories. You've got weak brothers and you have Pharisees. And where you have a weak brother and you must know the difference between a weak brother and a Pharisee, Calvin says, where you have a weak brother, then you don't use your Christian freedom because that person would be called a stumble. Where you have a Pharisee, you don't have to abstain. He gave you Calvin's illustration here. Paul circumcised had Timothy circumcised, but he did not have Titus circumcised. So there seems to be some kind of inconsistency there where he would insist on the circumcision of one of his associates, not that not on the other. He said, Calvin says that Paul had Timothy circumcised because Paul restricted his freedom, Paul would not have had Timothy circumcised, no longer requirement in the Christian era. But Paul restricts his freedom because it was fruitful to do so. There were people that would have been hurt, offended, would not have understood it. And so Paul thinks it's right to take into consideration the weaker brother. But Paul asserted his freedom in the right of Titus because of the unjust demands of false apostles. See, one issue concerned weaker brothers, the other issue concerned Pharisees, and here were Jews saying circumcision is required for keeping the law in for salvation. Paul says, no, it's not Titus is not going to be circumcised. So the rigor of the Pharisees is something that should not cause us to forsake our Christian freedom in order to satisfy Pharisees or hypocrites or whatever term you want to put there. But there are weaker brothers too, and may God give us the wisdom to discern when we're dealing with weaker brothers and when we're dealing with Pharisees. And Calvin's last point here, under compassion, as he discusses the indifferent things, is that, remember, trying to avoid giving offense to people, be sure you don't offend God. We must not offend God in trying to avoid offending our neighbour. There are sometimes when we can go too far, and we don't want to offend our neighbour, and we end up offending God. Calvin's illustration here is the mass. To Calvin, it was wrong for a person who had embraced the Protestant teaching to continue to go to the mass and participate in the mass. Some people were doing it. Calvin called them Nicodemites, like Nicodemus, secretly doing it going by night as Nicodemus did. They were doing it because they said, we don't want to offend neighbours, and we don't want to be too harsh here. And after all, people must first be fed with milk before they can grow to the place where they need meat. So here are these Protestant, secret Protestants going to the mass, and people saying, yes, that's right, and that's good because you have to have milk before you have meat. Calvin's answer is milk is not poison, and him the mass was poison, and so don't be too gentle with people when there's an issue like this involved where you're going to offend God. Well, I did not get to the Roman Catholic system of salvation compared with Calvin's doctrine of justification by faith alone, but you can look at the outline there, and see the Roman Catholic system of faith and works, and then Calvin's order of justification with the various references in the institutes. Next time, we have a very wonderful section, Calvin on prayer, along chapter, but just one chapter, chapter 20. So let's read that with care and discernment, and we'll talk about prayer next time.