<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Darovat Darovat měsíčně

The Inerrancy of Scripture

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

Okay, let's start. So here's the thing. We say, okay, people say, well, this claims to be the word of God. It is the word of God. I believe it's the word of God. But might there be some mistakes in it? Might there be some little errors in it? And that's the question of the inerrancy of scripture. This word inerrancy has been a major, major focus of debate over the last 30 years, among evangelical scholars. Particularly in the 1960s and 1970s, perhaps into the 1980s, it was quite a large debate. It was made to be a very explosive debate by a book by a man who was the editor of Christianity today named Harold Lenzell. He wrote a book called The Battle for the Bible and had a bright red cover on it and it was an alarm. And what he did was he went through various seminaries and various denominations and said to people, well, you may not know it, but the professors at your seminaries, when they get students in their classes, they teach them that there are some mistakes in the Bible and they can't trust at all. But it doesn't matter because they're just little mistakes. But he said they're denying inerrancy. And so that's the question. In 1948, I believe, there was a group of conservative Bible scholars who met together and formed something called the evangelical theological society. There were maybe a dozen of them who started it. Now it's up to over 3,500 members. But for many years, the only thing you had to believe to be a member was inerrancy. And they decided this would separate them from the liberal people who didn't believe the Bible who were teaching in other seminaries. And so the statement of faith for the ETS, the evangelical theological society, all it said was the Bible alone and the Bible in its entirety is the word of God written. And therefore, inerrant, in the autographs, autographs. What's that mean? We'll talk about that. It means the original copies. It's inerrant in the original copy. And so if you believe that, you could join the ETS. And if you didn't believe it, you were out. And that really served as a good gatekeeper for a number of years. Eventually, we had some people who didn't believe in the Trinity that joined. And so we added a statement called a statement about the Trinity as well. But that's all that the statement has now, even today. And a few years ago, we had the dispute to try to force some people out of membership of the ETS. And it was whether they believed in inerrancy or not. That was the question. When, over the course of, I don't know how many years of teaching, 28, 28, 28, 29 years, when I've interviewed, I don't know, dozens and dozens of people have been part of an interview committee to teach at a seminary. Or in some cases, I've been on a search committee for an associate pastor or something like that in a search committee. One of the questions I'll always ask is, do you believe in the inerrancy of scripture? Do you believe it's totally truthful in all it affirms? Because it tends to be a dividing line that sorts out people's attitude toward the Bible. So what I want to do this week, and it'll go on into next week, is define more clearly what inerrancy means. We might kind of sit back and dream up some views of anerrancy. We might think, well, if the Bible is perfect, it doesn't have any spelling mistakes. You might say that. Or it doesn't have any strange grammar in it or anything. We might just say that. Or you might say, like the Muslims say, like about the Quran. It can't even be translated. It's so perfect. If you really want to understand it, you have to learn Arabic and read it in Arabic. But in fact, that isn't what we say when we're talking about inerrancy. I'll talk about anerrancy. I'm going to tell you in a few minutes. But I'll get to the bottom line right now. We're talking about the truthfulness of all that it says, that whatever it affirms is truthful. So let's go on and talk about that in more detail. Are there any errors in the Bible? The meaning of anerrancy. The anerrancy of scripture means that scripture in the original manuscripts does not affirm anything that is contrary to fact. We'll get to this talk about the original manuscripts in a few minutes. Contrary to fact, it doesn't affirm anything that is contrary to fact. That is when it affirms something, then that is true. Now, where's Tom? Tom sent me an interesting note. This last week said, well, doesn't it quote some false things? Yes, it does. It quotes some statements of kings who made some mistakes. Or another example, did you know the Bible says there is no God? Psalm 141. The fool says in his heart, there is no God. Well, the Bible doesn't really say there is no God. It says those words, but when you see it in the context, what it affirms is that the fool says that. So it quotes some false statements of people, but then it shows you that those are false. So that's not what we mean. We mean when it affirms something, it doesn't affirm anything that is contrary to fact. Okay, Psalm 126. The words of the Lord are pure words. We talked about this last time. Like silver refined in a furnace on the ground purified seven times. These words are perfect. And the way the Lord wanted them, there is no impurity in them. Every word of God proves true. Proverbs 30 verse 5. Numbers 2319, God is not a man that he should lie or son of men that he should change his mind. And so these words, and we could go back to last week, there are other verses that affirm the truthfulness of the Bible. This definition does not mean, does not mean that the Bible tells us every fact there is to know about any one subject, but it affirms that what it does say about any subject is true. Now people will say to me, well, this is not a science textbook. Yeah, you know, I figured that out. I didn't really read it to learn high school biology. It's not a science textbook. Okay. But does it say anything about science? Does it say anything about creation? Does it say anything about weather? Does it say anything about astronomy? Well, there are some examples. For instance, it talks about some constellations, Amos 5.8. He who made the Pleiades and Orion. Those are constellations in the stars and turns deep darkness into into the morning and darkens the day and tonight calls for the waters of the sea and pours them out on the surface of the earth, not in Arizona, but other places. The Lord is his name. It says that God does that. He controls the weather. You have to believe that he controls the weather. It doesn't tell you everything about weather, but it says that God controls it. It doesn't tell you everything about the stars, but it says God made them. He made the Pleiades and Orion put those constellations in place. And here, Hebrews 11-3, by faith, we understand that the universe was created by the Word of God so that what is seen was not made out of things that are visible. That is, God just didn't take pre-existing matter and form it and shape it. He actually created out of nothing. So the universe was created by the Word of God. Now that doesn't tell you everything about the date of creation and how it came about and the time it took and all that, but it says that God made it. So I think we have to affirm that. The universe hasn't existed forever. So when it does talk about a subject, it has to speak truthfully. The Bible can be in errant and still speak in the ordinary language of everyday speech. Now this is important. The authors of the Bible are ordinary people whose lives God touched. David is a shepherd out in the fields. Amos was a herdsman. Matthew was a tax collector. So just a number of different Peter was a fisherman. These are ordinary people. And God doesn't override their manner of speech, their personalities. He uses their own personalities and speaks through them. And so that means that we have ordinary language of everyday speech. The Bible can speak of the sun rising and the rain falling because from the perspective of the speaker, this is exactly what happens. So people can take a verse like James 1-11 for the sun rises with its scorching heat and withers the grass. Now this is talking about Arizona. It's flower falls and it's beauty perishing. So also the rich man fade away in the midst of his pursuits. The sun rises and they'll say, oh wow, how hopeless. It's talking about the sun rising. It's just got this ancient view of the universe that it's a flat earth and the sun comes up and it goes down and it comes up and it goes down. They'll say, well this is just, this doesn't understand modern astronomy that the sun really doesn't rise the earth rotates. See, and then the earth rotates and you can see the sun from different parts of the world. Well my answer to that is this is not trying to speak from some abstract fixed point out in the universe. I mean as if there were such a place and where would you stand? I don't know. What it's doing is it is saying as I as I watch from the perspective of the speaker, the sun rises. In fact that's true. It's coming which way is east? You just stand here and again we can talk about sunrise. That's ordinary language. It's not trying to say that the earth doesn't rotate or does rotate. It's just saying from the perspective of human beings the sun rises and that's a true statement. That's ordinary language however. I never did get a white board. What did we? Do I have a marker board here? No. Some maybe next week we'll get it. I don't know. I don't know. I won't draw any pictures this week. Okay. In errancy has to do with truthfulness not with the degree of precision with which events are reported. Here's another question. I could say to you, here we go. Man, that was instant. Okay. I could say to you I live seven miles from Scottsdale Bible Church. Okay. Good. Thanks Bob. I think that's great. Is that a true statement? I live seven miles from Scottsdale Bible Church. Actually I'll tell you it is well I looked it up on map quest last night and it says I live seven point one six miles from Scottsdale Bible Church. Now the question is is this still true? At about I could say about six miles but I thought of adding about but then I thought no I'm going to make it harder for you. I was typing this in. Is this a true statement? I live seven miles from Scottsdale Bible Church. You think it's true? Okay. Here's the standard. The standard is it should be true according to the degree of accuracy implied by the speaker and understood by the hearer. Okay. And if I tell you I live seven miles from Scottsdale Bible Church in ordinary conversation the degree of accuracy expected is what I'm going to say you expect about about seven miles and that's true. No. However, if I'm trying to decide whether my kids go to school A or school B and they've got to live within seven miles of the school district then what's going to happen is some official from the school district is going to get one of these fifth wheels out that actually they pull behind and it measures to the hundredth of the mile or some and they and they then they've got decided they measure from my front sidewalk or my front door or what and they've got all these rules and then they're going to get and then they'll find out I'm seven point one six miles sorry my kids can't go to school A they've got to go to school B. So there in that case the degree of accuracy implied when they say seven point one six is more precise and then you have to be truthful according to the degree of accuracy implied by the speaker and understood by the hearers. But even seven point one six isn't approximation isn't it. I suppose if you had some CIA GPS satellite spy satellite you could put a laser beam down to my front door and a laser beam down to the front door of the administration building of Scottsdale Bible Church and you could go seven point one six four two three miles. But even that's around number around it off number isn't it because it could be even more precise to do the front part of the door or the back part of the door and to what moment you so all those measurements are approximations and and so that comes back to the point in air and sea. Bible can be an errand and still speak in the ordinary language of everyday speech all right. It's still but it has to be truthful and if I said I live nine miles from Scottsdale Bible Church I don't think that would be true. I'd be mistaken and if I said 16 miles that would be really really wrong. Okay. Then the Bible can be an errand and still include loose or free quotations. I'm trying to just think of a conversation I had coffee this. Oh okay a few minutes ago I asked if you had the handouts from last week. Is that true? But if Trent played back the tape recorder he might say oh when you didn't say handouts you said do you have the outlines from last week. So am I lying when I say a few minutes ago I asked if you had the handouts from last week. I don't think so because I'm not actually putting it in our custom of quotation marks and saying it's the actual words. I'm reporting what we call an English indirect speech that is I said that or I asked if you had the handouts and so it was a truthful statement even though it didn't use the exact words am I making sense. And then the meaning of it was not changed in any way any any material way any significant way and that's what we have many times in the gospels where you have different gospels reporting the sayings of Jesus and they are in what we call a loose or free quotation in the ancient world they didn't have the custom that we have they didn't have the custom that we have. They didn't have the custom that we have of putting like this Wayne asked do you have the outlines from last week and when we put quote marks around it way we use English today that tells the reader that I'm reporting the very words. And if I leave anything out I'm going to put dot dot dot to show that some things left out and when I'm quoting a scholarly article I have to be sure that I quote exactly the words and not leave out a word or not change a word I can't just give a summary and that's if I put these quote marks but those quote marks that's kind of what you would call a convention an English language convention kind of a world everybody agrees on today. That has not always been so and in the ancient manuscripts the Greek and Hebrew manuscripts they don't have anything like that they don't have that convention whereby they when they were quoting speech they often summarized or gave what we would call a report of indirect speech which would be Wayne inquired whether you had the handouts. Yeah, whether you had the handouts from last week that would be a probably it wouldn't be the exact words but it would be the same for us and so in the ancient world probably because they didn't have tape recorders I don't know but they didn't have they didn't have the convention of quoting exactly and so the accuracy required was we can have loose or free quotations as long as they're truthful as long as they don't change the meaning of what is said all right. Questions about that you know Mike it does cover a lot of what is in the synoptic gospels Matthew Mark and Luke where the wording is a little bit different and it looks like it's exactly the same story now what I'm going to do next week is take two or three of the very hardest ones of those where Jesus said take sandals don't take sandals take a staff don't take a staff. Or what day did he curse the fig tree and what day did the disciples see it those are really tough ones and I'm not going to hide those from you I'm going to say these are the hardest ones I know to resolve and we're going to look at them and see. But in many cases yes it's pretty simple you can see that either it's it's just different words mean the same essentially same synonyms or it is just Matthew quotes part of what Jesus says and Mark quotes a different part and Luke quotes a different part. And they can you can fit them all together so that's that's another way you can have. There isn't anything that they just have a little word hot that introduces he said that and it's like we would say an interact quote so their standard of precision that they expected was not word for word in quotes of speeches that's I guess that's what I'm saying. Oh I see. But I think it's all great microphone yeah repeat the question you might be saying maybe we've created a problem by putting things in quote marks or or red letters but I don't think we have a choice because if I do indirect speech in English when asked if you have the hand out but if I do directs you can tell the form of the words but when asked do you have the handouts then you have to put it in quotes in English because it's. Well you have heard that it was said but I say to you when you get Jesus saying I if you're part of that indirect speech Jesus said that he said to them so you'd have to change the form of it but when it takes the eye form you kind of have to put it in quotes in English or you wouldn't make sense of it so I think we have to do that we have to put it in quotes but I just want us to hold those quote marks a little bit loosely in terms of who can have looser free quotations okay now but you can't do that and say in one gospel Jesus said take sandals and the other gospel said don't take sandals that's not a synonym that's the exact opposite so there's no there's a problem okay so that's where the problem comes up not in the where the exact words all right now there's the see how that's what I was worrying and that's what I was wondering about okay what's forgetting Clyde yeah Clyde saying well then the pair of phrase but I will be justified now does this you see what I'm saying about looser free quotations does that come into conflict with what I said about every word and Jesus quoting the very words of the Old Testament and there are several places where it just depends the argument depends on one word and I think I mentioned in Matthew 22 when he says the Lord said to my Lord he's basing an argument on one letter of the Hebrew text and so what I'm saying here is this applies to quotations of human speech where people are talking about what somebody said but once it gets written down in the Bible then every word is right every letter of every word is right once it's written down then it's God's words and we have to say every bit is true okay come to oh look at this oh okay go just saying you'd be confusing if you handed out more than one thing but as long as the outline is if there were more than one thing in the word I said could apply to different things then they'd be confusing but I give a safe example okay well that's that that that thing right here I think we have to do that because of what we find in the Gospels where the wording just varies a little bit but I don't but I want to say that's consistent with truthfulness in reporting it's sort of the standard of accuracy we would expect when we say he said that that kind of thing number four it is consistent with inerrancy to have unusual or uncommon grammatical constructions in the Bible oh boy now what's that this is not a very good example have the oh okay here's my example we ain't asked do you have the outlines from last week and I misspelled outlines I forgot to eat I forgot the question mark too okay good all right no is that still a truthful report of what I said even though I misspelled outlines Bob Bob you're going to accept it in court I think it would stand up still but isn't that an error how can it be inerrant and have a different spelling of a word it's it's human error but if it's God's words how can it have okay here's the thing it's conveying truth and even if you misspelled something it's still true it's completely true all right that's that's the question now in our day and age when we have computers and we have dictionaries and everything there's kind of a standard spelling for for most words right but in the ancient world there were some dictionaries very few people had them just a few people took to writing them and then got a few copies but there weren't zero ox machines there weren't printing presses there weren't facts machines and all that and sort of the way words were spelled varied from place to place in fact if you go back a hundred years in American history you can find Abraham Lincoln spelling words differently okay but he was a man of his word he spoke truthfully and so correct spelling is kind of just a convention that we've grown up with now and it doesn't have to do with truthfulness it has to do it just trying to spell everything correctly so everybody can understand it and so you get in the Bible what we call our different spellings of some words I wouldn't even call them wrong spellings because maybe these some areas spell the word one way in some way like in England they spell color C-O-L-O-U-R and here we spell it C-O-L-O-R and so you can have different regional spellings of words and things and that doesn't affect truthfulness and you get call he starts a sentence and then he breaks it off and he goes on to another sentence if you see that sometimes in Ephesians let me just find that Ephesians Ephesians 3-1 Ephesians 3-1 for this reason I Paul a prisoner for Christ Jesus on behalf of Eugeniles and I have a big dash right there for this reason I Paul there's the subject where is the verb it goes on assuming that you have heard of the stewardship of God's grace that was given to me for you how the mystery is made known to me by revelation as I have written briefly oh wait a minute for this reason I Paul a prisoner for Christ Jesus on behalf of Eugeniles and he doesn't finish the sentence he gets to another thought is that an error in the Bible I don't know if your versions all translate that way but that's pretty literally what he does he starts out with I as the subject and it doesn't give a verb because it's a broken sentence now that's not an error it's just it's just Paul it shows that he's saying I Paul and I think it's saying I'm writing this and then he doesn't even finish the sentence he knows you get the thought I'm writing this to you and then he goes on and talks about something else so there are unusual or uncommon grammatical constructions and there are things like oh here's one Jack who are you going to give that book to your son in law now any English professors or English teachers in here there was a grammatical error in that Jack who are you going to give that book to I'm there it should be whom to whom are you going to give that book but oh my goodness not one percent of the population speaks that way anymore but in a way I mean you could say oh that's kind of technically an error but it it really isn't it doesn't it doesn't make a lot of difference and in fact can people have poor grammar speak truthfully so you think of a you know a murder trial in a small town in northern Minnesota and then the defense attorney brings in this backwardsman who has a witness and and the witness says no I seem Jack that morning and he was having coffee with me and and he didn't he done nothing wrong well that's ungrammatical I seem Jack but not you Jack but the whole town knows the old herding out in the backwards he's never lied in his life and the jury believes him even though he has bad grammar all right so again the issue is truthfulness and in some cases say in the book of revelation in in in Greek you have a gender for nouns masculine feminine neuter and you're supposed to put a masculine adjective with a masculine noun and a feminine adjective with a feminine noun it's that way in French it's that way in Spanish it's that way in a lot of languages but in the book of revelation sometimes you've got a masculine adjective with a feminine noun or you've got a noun that's usually masculine that's treated as feminine or feminine as masculine just grammatical categories I don't know why maybe John was writing in a hurry it's just there but it's true and am I is that so I'm saying all the things that an erincy doesn't mean it means that the statements are true even though you can have unusual grammar unusual spelling that kind of thing all right yep yep good good good good okay okay all right go into saying there are some verses I can read over and over again and I don't get the meaning okay incidentally go into that happened to me last week too so what does that mean Lord okay so there are verses like that and Peter said there are some things in Paul's epistles hard to understand so now was that true in the ancient well yeah apparently there were some things that were harder to understand now sometimes they had more information Paul says do you not know when I was with you I told you this and they kind of knew what he was talking about so sometimes they had more information what we try to do is get as close as we can to a native speaker understanding of the language and as much of the background of the life situation as we can but to some extent there were they had to think about it for a few minutes too in fact I was I was just writing something that's going to be on this focus on the family the booklet the other day and and when David's time to die drew near he did such and such and he's such and such and then it said so David slept with his fathers and was buried in Jerusalem now when you read that David slept with his fathers it takes you a minute to think what does that mean and was buried in Jerusalem so what does it mean he slept with his fathers it means he died okay what's going on with what I would call paraphrase or dynamic equivalent translations they say that's too hard for you to figure out so the new living translation for instance says so David died and was buried in Jerusalem that's easy no problem the problem is the Hebrew word means sleep slept and the Hebrew word means fathers so why not translate those words and I bring that back to Guimther's question I think the first readers when they read that so David slept with his fathers and was buried they had to think for a minute to know what women slept with his fathers and then they think oh yeah that means he died but it really means more than he died slept with his fathers there's something else hinted at there it's hinting at life after death because he slept when you sleep what happens you wake up again so slept with his fathers has a hint of resurrection so there's kind of a fuller meaning there with his fathers is there any more meaning to that yeah yeah okay imitating their faith maybe and what else Abraham Isaac Jacob okay doesn't it hint that maybe he's with them see and so is there's a hint of fellowship in after death so David slept with his fathers is a pretty rich and full expression even though the first readers might have to think about it for a minute so there are things like that too where we have to think about it oh she's asleep yeah yeah okay okay good so Jesus spoke that way so it ties in with other places where okay so yes but anyway where am I? okay so we're talking about what an emergency was and yes there are times I had a little note to myself in my ipad when don't try to cover so much allow a little more interaction with class and so that's what I'm doing this morning incidentally okay just try it all right now here are some current challenges to because I figure if I don't get through the outline you'll come back next week maybe okay some current challenges to an air and see now what I'm going to do here is I have a list of six objections that people make people that don't believe in an air and see some of these people and look I'm not I'm not I'm not so much talking about liberals that don't believe the Bible at all I'm talking about Christians evangelical Christians to say I think this is the word of God but it's not an errand there are some little mistakes in it and a number of the born again evangelical believers who are in the academic world in England all in this category some some my friends some some professors at different places and the dispute over this I don't want to criticize friends here but because we have an extension of Fuller Seminary here in Phoenix but the dispute historically honestly focused at Fuller Seminary in the 1960s and 1970s and so I'm just going to try to record that accurately to you and there was a question of whether you have to believe in in air and see to be part of an evangelical church or an evangelical community well here is one objection number one people say well I believe the Bible is without error in all things having to a faith and practice practice means how you live your life don't murder don't commit adultery don't lie don't seal that's practice okay ethics so the Bible is only authority for faith and practice this view would hold that the purpose of scripture is to teach us in areas that concern faith and practice only so it's possible that the scripture makes false statements in other areas such as historical or scientific facts and this was this was the view of a number of professors at Fuller and I went there for one year 1971 1970 to 71 and they took in air and see out of the statement of faith in that year because they just they were faculty members that just weren't comfortable with that statement and one of the objections and it wasn't just at Fuller there were some people at other evangelical institutions but one of their statements was well hey look why do God give the Bible he gave it to us for faith and practice we know what we to believe we're to believe in the deity of Christ or believe in Christ for salvation through faith alone we're to believe in the Trinity we're to believe in the second coming we're to believe this things about faith and practice you know the morals in the Bible we don't need to believe that we don't need to believe that so all some of the people and number them and tell our eem 200,000 men on foot 10,000 men of Judah oh what if there were 20,000 men of Judah so what how's that gonna affect your life you see I just took that random it it's just for faith and practice and maybe our scientific or historical facts that might be wrong but that's not the purpose of the Bible we can find those out ourselves sometimes that's referred to as belief in the infallibility of scripture it won't lead you astray it's infallible now how would I answer that my response is the Bible doesn't make any restriction on the kinds of subjects to which it speaks truthfully and you know what here I was I was how old was I I was 19 years old no no no that was first I was 22 23 years old first year student at fuller and I was being told in my class that it doesn't matter if Gamalio made some mistakes and what he reported to the Sanhedrin he got some error or no it doesn't matter if Luke in Acts 5 got some the order of Judas and Judas wrong the point is there doesn't matter if the mustard seed is really the smallest of seeds the main point is the kingdom of God is going to grow and so there are some and it doesn't matter if John's gospel and the Baptist really didn't say behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world early in Jesus' ministry he couldn't know that because at least he said it at some point so I mean that's the or at least the statement is true that Jesus is Lamb of God and I was troubled by that and I was troubled by teachers saying to me well the Bible isn't given to that for that purpose to teach us science and to teach us history and to teach us astronomy and to teach us geography it's given to teach us faith okay and so I went through and I started to look what does the New Testament itself say about the kinds of things the New Testament will trust back in the Old Testament and so here 2 Timothy 3 16 it says all scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching reproof it isn't just some of it it isn't just the scripture having to do with faith and practice it's all of it Psalm 12 6 the words of the Lord are pure words it isn't just some of the words it's all the words of the Lord are pure there isn't any historical or scientific or astronomical or geographical or biological impurity in them they're all pure Psalm 119 verse 96 I've seen a limit to all perfection that I think that means that by that human perfection everything that human beings build breaks eventually but your commandment is exceedingly broad that is it's not limited it's perfect unlimited perfection every word of God proves true about every subject it doesn't say just some subjects just faith and practice and fact the New Testament has other places where people say they're trusting every bit of the Old Testament so Paul says this I confess to you I worship the God of our fathers believing everything everything believing everything laid down by the law and written in the prophets Paul didn't just believe some parts of the Old Testament he believed all of it Romans 154 whatever was written in former days was written down for our instruction that through the endurance and the encouragement of the scriptures we might have hope so it's whatever was written in the scriptures was written down for our instruction 1 Corinthians 10 11 I thought this was really interesting Paul said the people sat down to eat and drink and rose up to dance and that's not one of your major events in the history of salvation in the whole Bible that's not like David coming to Jerusalem it's not Abraham sacrificing guys the people sat down to eat and drink and rose up to dance and then Paul says these things happen to them as an example but they were written down for our instruction on whom the end of the ages have come so he's saying these things happen and that that word in Greek means they occur the people did sit down to eat and drink and they did rise up to dance and he just he then he takes a lesson from that just goes back into the Old Testament takes a lesson and then Hebrews 11 my goodness you get many many detailed events that are affirmed as though they happened Hebrews 11 Hebrews 11 what happened able offered to go out of more acceptable sacrifice them came verse 4 unique was taken up so he should not see death verse 5 Abraham obeyed verse 8 when he's called to go out to a place verse 11 Sarah received power to conceive verse 17 Abraham offered up Isaac verse 20 Isaac invoked future blessings on Jacob and Esau 22 Joseph at the end of his life made mention of the Exodus of the Israelites and gave directions concerning his bones I mean that's kind of a small detail isn't it now take my bones and bury them back in the land of Israel that's a detail and the book of Hebrews says by faith we know it was true and there are other things the walls of Jericho and other things so I don't think that you get any indication that the New Testament authors look back and say where you can only trust the faith and practice parts but you don't have to trust all the historical details so and then the other problem with this faith and practice objection is it mistakes the major purpose of Scripture for the total purpose of Scripture the major purpose of Scripture is to teach us about faith and practice that's true that's the main point but that's not all it also teaches us that God made Pleiades and Orion that's not one of the major points in the Bible but it's there and God decided to say it so I'm obligated to believe it because he said it okay just take an example here you're out of the class and you see a friend out on the sidewalk and they say what was just what what did what went talk about this mind and you say he talked about an air and see well then the person said oh good I'm glad because I thought he was taught I thought somebody said he talked about how far his house was from Scottsdale Bible Church and so if he talked about an air and see I'm sure he didn't talk about how far his house was from Scottsdale Bible Church what those what you're here is doing is is taking a summary and using it to contradict something that's being summarized and that's not right he said oh no he did talk about how far his house was from Scottsdale Bible Church but it was an illustration and so here the summary is faith and practice yeah that's a good summary of the Bible but there are other details in it we have to believe those two all right that's objection one faith and practice we're not going to get through all these but we'll do see we do a couple more objection two the term an air and see is a poor term I get this in England all the time oh I don't like the word an air and see two scientific two precise it's not in the Bible in air and see is two precise a term it did not notes a kind of absolute scientific precision that we do not want to claim for scripture and the term isn't used in the Bible my response to that is you know what scholars who have used the term have used the term in air and see have defined it clearly for over 100 years you can go back and see it in BB Warfield in the late 19th century and they have always allowed for the limitations they're attached to speech and ordinary language that's those things I talked you about before so people have defined it they haven't said it's it's like laboratory precision with laser beam or a very high caliber measurement it's just ordinary language and truthful and two we often use non-biblical terms to summarize a biblical teaching people say well the word an air and see where's that in the Bible I said well it's not in the Bible well then why do you use it well it's a good summary word because it talks about truthfulness the word trinity is not in the Bible but I believe in the trinity the word incarnation that Jesus became man that's not in the Bible but it's a good word to summarize the teaching of the Bible and so the term an air and see is the standard widely used term in the discussion regarding biblical authority and it's not helpful to try to eliminate the term from the discussion at this point note the international council on biblical and air and see and the Chicago Stateman on biblical and air and see in 1978 this was an organization that was formed to promote in air and see and they put an air and see in their title and they wrote a statement in 1978 that I'm gonna go over with you next week or the week after whenever and it was kind of a longer definition of an air and see and in 1978 they put it out about 250 260 people I was a second year professor at that point and I was in the conference I didn't have a major part in it but I was there and it's kind of been a useful summary ever since then and so I don't think we're gonna get rid of the word. Number three, how are we doing on time? 916 and the first Sunday I was supposed to get out 915 but otherwise I can go to 920 flats where I'm gonna try to do there let's do this for another few minutes and then we'll just have to stop and you will all bring your outlines back next week okay

now people will take my definition of an air and see or the Chicago Stateman on an air and see in this say or the Phoenix Seminary Stateman on an air and see I think maybe Scott's a Bible church statement and they'll say well you say it's an air and then the original manuscript where are those? show me one, show me the first copy of Romans the Paul wrote, show me the first copy of Isaiah that Isaiah wrote or first copy where are those and I say well we don't have any haha well what a stupid doctrine you're holding you say the original manuscripts are inherent but they're all missing not very convenient so that's what this that's this objection

we have no inherent manuscripts therefore talk about an air and Bible is misleading answer well first explain an air and see has always been claimed only for the original manuscripts what's called the autograph auto means self and this is word related to a grapho Greek word to write so it's self-write, autograph that's the book of Genesis that Moses himself wrote okay and an autograph we say today is something where a person wrote his own name now we just reconvene it to name today but here in this sense it means the autographs mean all the original manuscripts response I agree we don't have the original manuscripts I don't know why I don't know why God didn't preserve them somehow they were just lost and maybe it's good that they were lost because where would you put them? nivatican? no we wouldn't want to do that in the Billy Graham Center in Wheaton now probably not there ten quarters of the national association of evangelicals in Washington these how about the national archives knowing that's get all well I don't know where and people might kind of travel and make pilgrimages and start to worship them or something I don't think we want to do that so I don't know why but Godness wisdom didn't allow us to keep all the original manuscripts but does that matter? for far over 99% of the words of the Bible we know what the original manuscripts said therefore we can affirm the inerrancy of the words in the manuscripts to the extent that they are the same as the originals now I want to give you an example of that let's take the United States Constitution for an example now there was the original the original copy of the Constitution and then immediately people made copies of it and then what happened? they made copies of copies right? and then they made copies of those copies no no I hope this never happens but what would happen? do you know where the original copy is? is it in the national archives building in Washington DC? next to the mall in Washington DC what would we do if a terrorist bomb blew up the national archives and we didn't have the Constitution anymore the original copy what would we do? you would have copies you would get this copy and this copy and this copy and this copy and this copy and you look at them and if they all agree you say well I don't have the original but my goodness I know what the original said because the copies all agree and that's the same way with the Bible we don't have original manuscripts but we have many many copies and for the New Testament the ancient Greek manuscripts there are over 5,000 whole or part manuscripts and you go around and you look and there's some in the British Museum there's some in Ann Arbor, Michigan and the University of Michigan Museum there's some of the University of Illinois there's some in Leningrad there's some in Paris, France and there's some in the Vatican and there are museums all over the world and you go right into the British Museum or the British Library and you can look and there's a very very early manuscript of the New Testament and so you look at them and there are people who are specialists and that they compare them all and they say 99% of the time they all agree and with these are the words but does it worry you about that one tenth of one percent where they don't agree? see that's the problem first how can you find out where they don't agree? how can you find out? look at Romans 8.1 that's not bad we got a good example just let me uh... oh yeah, just a second I'm sorry it's Romans 5.1 that was the example I was looking for Romans 5.1 therefore since we have been justified by faith we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ is there a footnote? we have peace with God is anybody have a footnote in your Bible? what does it say? okay some ancient manuscripts read let us have okay and the difference in Greek between we have and let us have is echo man versus echo man echo man versus echo man it's just one letter we have let us have what do you do? you go to London and one manuscript says let us have you go to Paris and another manuscript says we have what do you do? what was the original? what you do is you look at the age of the manuscripts and you look at how many copies of each kind and what would be more likely in terms of copyus make air and you decide and then you put a footnote to let the readers know honestly that there are some differences does it make a whole lot of difference? it doesn't change any point of doctrine if I'm preaching on it I'd probably take a minute and say we're not quite sure whether Paul wrote let us have if you wrote let us have here's what it means if you wrote we have but it's the same it's that kind of thing a lot of times there's a difference between we and us which is a little you know we have or let us have but no point of doctrine is affected okay and I just think that the editors are playing fair with us in fact I was probably putting some of those footnotes in and that's just the state of affairs that's just way could God have absolutely supervised all the millions of people in the world who ever wanted to write down a copy of the Bible so they would force their hand never to make a mistake I suppose but it isn't the way God works you work through ordinary people preserving manuscripts so that now does that trouble you? oh my I'm at 9.25 I just hate to there's a huge difference however if we affirm that the mistakes in there are mistakes in the copies and there are there are the mistakes of human beings but if there are mistakes in the originals these would be mistakes of God and that's why I think it's important to say the original was without error and for 99 probably 99.9% of the Bible you know what the original said and for the rest we don't miss any point of doctrine on the difference okay and we know where the differences are you can trust it it's truthful it's God's words it's without error no where are we? I think this is going to take me two more Sundays I want to finish up some objections and I want to look at some hard cases and I want to look at that Chicago statement so next Sunday we'll continue on in Aaron C and I've tied it for 25-30 years I've been looking with people who said hey there's an error here there's an error there and I looked at them and I've never found one why I'd say yeah that's really an error but you have to talk sometimes study them and look at them and I want to do some of those with you so to be next Sunday and then let's see it's 7,16 the 23rd I will not be here without a guest teacher because I'm speaking to the Camelback Bible Church men's retreat Tim Savage spoke for us there's a kind of exchange here and then the 30th we're going to Raleigh, North Carolina it is being ordained as pastor of Christ our comfort, Presbyterian Church so it will be going for two Sundays and then back in November and we're finished but next Sunday we'll finish up objections to an Aaron C let's pray Lord God, we give you thanks thank you for your word how wonderful that you've brought about that it's preserved so faithfully for us and we can trust it Lord, we're just honest with what is here pray that this would not hinder anyone's faith but actually increase confidence in the word of God which we have we have nothing to hide Lord as Paul says by the open statement of the truth we would commend ourselves to everyone's conscience in the sight of God so go with us this week and especially pray for Jim Lord and that how open heart surgery to be near him and protect him in Jesus' name, Amen