<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Darovat Darovat měsíčně

Worship & Music 1

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Okay. We're now in lecture 17. Yes. We're going to be looking at music today and we're going to start by talking about the relationship between pastors and musicians. Most churches of any size from small to large have somebody who is a key music person, whether it's volunteer, accompanist or paid position part time or full time person on staff. And so because music, as we'll see later this morning, is such a key element of a worship service, it's important and because music carries content, it's very important that I believe that the pastor and the musician will be well coordinated in approaching the service, planning the service, being able to carry out the service, not having to stop in the middle of the service and say, do you want me to start playing this at this point or whatever, so that it can be, have that gospel progression to it without distraction as we go. So with that introduction, let me pray and then we'll talk a bit. Father, we thank you for this day and the opportunity to have worship together for, as access students here at the seminary this week in July of 2006. And we pray now that as we continue to look together at the different components and elements of worship, that your Holy Spirit would lead us and teach us and instruct us, change us. Not only in our views, but where that needs to happen, but also in our practice of worship and our capacity to be faithful under servants of Christ and serving and shepherding your people, for we ask it in Jesus name. Amen. Happy to have Claudia Wuten with us today. She and her husband are here at the seminary just finished their first year. He Rob is doing his MDiv and Claudia is doing her M-A-T-S, like most of you out there in video land. And Claudia, why don't you tell us a little bit about what you did before you came to covenant seminary? I got my degree in music at VCU in 94 and taught for a little while and then in 98 was part of a church plant in Norfolk, Virginia and ended up leading worship there until we came here in 2005. So led worship there for seven years, did worship and arts. So a combination of leading the musicians and arranging the music as well as working on the aesthetics of the bulletins and flyers and anything else that went into the worship service. And what was your, how did you work with the pastor there? My pastor was Jack Cowell who graduated here in 1998. And he and I were really a team as far as public worship went. He and I met once a month to plan the worship for that month. He and I talked about all of the components of the liturgy not just the music but talked about what we would want to use for scripture for the call to worship and writing the confessions together. And he helped me choose the music as well as I did. We really worked on gospel-centered content-driven worship services and then I would implement them with the team on Sunday morning.

I asked Claudia as they were moving here shortly before they moved here. She would serve in the student services office in helping with the chapel program particularly. One of the things we've tried to do a covenant seminary is to make the chapel worship services be actual worship services and not just another opportunity to hear a professor speak or give a lecture.

We have several very gifted students musically but to have somebody who's coordinating the efforts of finding those people, building teams with those people, rehearsing with those people, getting them to commit to various chapel services. We didn't really have that as well coordinated as I'd hoped for and so that's sort of the assignment that I gave Claudia to try to move forward in that area of helping us with chapel here at the seminary. So we've worked together over the last year planning two chapel services a week and I've benefited very much from her seven years with Jack. Jack Howell and just and my own experience of working with different music people over the years and pastor and so on. So I think we've seen how kind of the potential for how we approach things and the resources we draw on is sort of partly the fruit of those other places we've been now applied in the seminary context. Why don't you talk a little bit about why it's important for the pastor and musician to spend time communicating well and being on the same page with things and some of the maybe some of the dangers if they're not. Well one of the things that I think is important for pastors to remember is that your worship whoever is coordinating your worship is implementing your vision and the vision of the session and so it's imperative that whoever is upfront on Sunday morning is drawn into the vision and that really happens in fellowship with pastor and musician and discipling of the musician by the pastor not only in the vision but also in spiritual growth and leadership skills and growing in their gifts. I think part of just the real benefit to me is been my spiritual growth under pastors who have poured their lives into me as somebody who was leading an aspect of you know for a church plant public worship is very important and so it was an honor for me to have pastors really love on me and care for me and grow me and my gifts and my understanding of theology and the word enough that I would want to come here and get a degree. I think when I see pastors and musicians who either the musician pastor lays out the formula for worship and they give them three blanks and the musician has to come up with the three songs to fill in the blank on their own. I see a real breakdown in partnership and breakdown and loyalty and really a vision breakdown because when the musician is approached by people in the congregation they cannot express the vision to the congregants and likewise the pastor can express why the music has been chosen. After the sermon the music is going to be the most criticized thing in a church and so it's important that a pastor take that responsibility seriously and not just allow a musician for their own sake. Again it's been my growth that the pastor has taken the time to meet with me but also I think it's been the benefit of the churches that I've been a part of enough here. I think one of the things that I found to be important is that pastors need to grow in their understanding and appreciation of music and the role that it has in worship like we looked at previously Calvin understood that music has power to stir the heart in worship of God and because it has such power it can't just be sort of a raw power out there on its own. It needs to serve the gospel purposes as we've talked about and I think that musicians can help disciple and train pastors in music appreciation and understanding why a song in a service that may have great words that serve what's going on at that place in the service musically it may not fit or work or the congregation maybe that song would be better for special music because it's too difficult for a congregation to learn or this may have association with other kinds of things that in this context wouldn't work very well so helping a pastor be gain understanding and insight as to how music works in worship and what are realistic expectations I think can be very important and then as Claudius mentioned on the other side sometimes you have musicians who think well what I bring to the table is just my musical gift don't bother me with that theology stuff the more pastors learn about music without trying to usurp the role of the musician and the more the musician learns more about theology without trying to usurp the role of the pastor than the more overlap and interconnectedness and being able to work together in planning takes place and I think there's air on both sides of that in the church but one of the things that I find myself wanting to urge you all and particularly most of the the students I have in the worship classes here are going to be pastors is to care for and love and appreciate and learn from and encourage your music people I know from years and pastoral ministry probably the most difficult time was Sunday afternoon and Monday morning in terms of feeling like I didn't do all I could have done I could have preached that sermon a lot better and all it takes is one or two people to tell you that on the way past you or to ignore you and hug the wall as they walk by and not even give you eye contact and you wonder what's going on with that it had to have been me we're very I'm very self-critical in those situations and and I think musicians also I mean they put themselves out there and the importance of a word of encouragement one of the things I've I've tried to do everywhere I've gone even I find myself at like wedding receptions where somebody's just playing background music I've tried to make it a point to go up and express appreciation to the musician that's often sort of they're missed if they're not there but they're not noticed sometimes when they are there and just to try to give an encouraging word as you would appreciate leading other aspects of worship so I think that's I was just going to say part of that is also the importance of the pastoral relationship with me is that when I'm feeling really vulnerable it's my fellow staff that I would need to hear from and I appreciate congregants are very nice or sometimes quiet but it's that really trusted ear you know that that mark is going to really tell me how worship was and how it pulled off and I need that criticism and I trust him but that's because we've met together and we have a relationship and we've established rapport and commitment to one another so what what do you what's been your experience when there's been disagreement between you and the pastor or conflict over what to do or what not to do how do you handle that well one of the things that I run into a little bit as far as worship goes is the amount of subjectiveness in worship and and and that has led to many conflicts with the pastor because he might like a song that I don't like like my friend Mark really likes and songs that I don't like and and I have a high what I call the cheese factor and so some songs I just don't want to do in my postmodern artistic subjectiveness but I realize that I have to bend to that but I find that those conflicts tend to tend to be more about my own personal preference or personal preferences of the pastor and sort of not broadening our scope to the needs of the congregation or the themes or the really positive aspects of certain music but I will say one of the things that I have really appreciated from the pastors that I've worked with is just the ability to dig in and do conflict real conflict and not sort of you know really argue it out which I like you know let's if we want to talk about a song I'm I'm just not going to go into the rug really sell me on why this song is good enough to do in public worship 20 years after it was written and you tell me why it's still why you think it's bad now right right okay right okay we had this little I don't think I'll name the songs yeah given all the people who may the wide variety of people but we have this president's welcome reception that has a little worship time related to it and I've been here I'm now in my eighth year and the two songs that were always done in that I just continue to do and one was a him and one was a chorus okay and Claudia comes last year never having been to one of these before and looks at the chorus when it says are you kidding why would we do that now 20 years after it was written you know it's one of those classic choruses which I do happen to like and think it has with stood the test of time okay and the thing I appreciate about it appreciated about Claudia is she said I think for incoming students that really wouldn't connect as well as some other songs might and you really want to set this as sort of your initial experience of the students in terms of what you're trying to do in chapel I said well and and so she came up with an alternative which I think I will name which is before the throne of God above which is a wonderful song that is an old hymn that has a great tune that the combination of doing that song and be thou my vision I think it's okay to name the other song which is there's one we're not naming really improved and all I was doing was carrying over somewhat uncritically what had come before and so here's a fresh set of eyes of an incoming student herself who is willing to challenge knowing that I'm not going to you know fire her that day for challenging me on that or something that really has helped to improve so I think there's that it's for the goal not of getting your way but of making something more honoring to God and edifying to the congregation in that yeah and in that regard I was just going to say I think one of the ways that we protect each other is when we work together we keep it from being coming a cult of personality so people cannot blame me for the music because my pastor and I have worked on it together or this session has said this is what we want we want you to do and in that way I'm protected and I really appreciate that in that story Mark can attest that I did say that I did say if you ultimately want to do that song I will do it so I made my opinion known with the caveat that you still I still value your opinion as the authority and so if you want to do it we'll sing it but I appreciate that you had this change okay let's see what do we maybe not doing here okay aren't we

what is helpful to a musician from a pastor about the sermon and what the vision for the services that helps you and how far in advance is it helpful to get that well that's a loaded question but I'll start by saying as a musician it's it was first of all really helpful for me to read Brian Chappell's book Christ Center of Reaching if you have not read that my pastor had me read that right from the start which really helped me to understand when he gave me something that said F-C-F I knew what that meant the fallen condition focus of the passage and so he would give me the F-C-F's and the proposition and the points in a blurb and from that we would start working on the whole service and the text as well we also we were usually did sermon series from books so I knew the passages well in advance and then as much as I would like to say that he got me the the information about his sermons well in advance that just I never found that that really happens so usually that day at the meeting we get it and and just start kind of brainstorming together and it's just kind of a big fun collaborative moment I think even because I'm busy even if he got him to me earlier I'm not sure I would have looked at him but part of the fun is just coming to the moment and seeing what we're going to do I did always read the scripture ahead of time because I knew where we were going because it was just logically throughout the scripture we the class will already know a little bit about how we planned for today's worship service which is perfect the fallen condition focus the proposition the three points and then of course this pastor didn't give you any more than that until yesterday afternoon before the Friday morning service but we did put every I had gave them an assignment to come up with sort of some prayers some songs whatever having had this and then we kind of pooled our resources and put them all up in the board and then collaborated together how to structure the brief service for this morning but I think the other thing that I used to do for pastors which I would suggest is help my pastor remember testimonies and baptisms and other vows or oaths that we had going on I kept the calendar for that so that he didn't have to worry about so when we came in that morning I would say we've got a baptism next week we have a testimony a missions moment we need to do an announcement about the women's retreat so that all became again part of the liturgy and the overall flow of the worship was was well thought out before Sunday one of the things that has come up in some discussions among pastors and worship leaders recently is that the dynamic we're talking about between pastor and musician there's really a third party in most churches call the session or the elders and that sometimes this struggles not necessarily between the pastor and the musician but it's between the pastor and the elders who aren't necessarily agreeing and there may be back door pressure on the musician to try to get at the pastor and can you speak to the importance of really all three of those entities having at least some communication and being in unity yeah and and again I mean that's part of being Presbyterian but one story in my past was the pastor and I had been working closely on a new we were developing my new contract okay and the salary and all of the the information about that and he and I came to a place of of agreement and he wanted me to come to the meeting with the session about the budget well we had come up with one figure and he's not talking and the lead this one man on the session starts to speak up and he comes in with a figure that is way below and said this is what we've decided on as a session and I burst into tears looked at this pastor and said I can't tell you how the trade I feel right now by you why aren't you saying anything and I think right in that moment I realized I have to have a relationship with these men you cannot it's it's very difficult for me I want to submit to them and to know them and to know their vision and I want them to know me and to care for me and that can't happen only through the gateway of the pastor and so after that we started quarterly I met with the session to just debrief worship how was public worship going how was I doing in my job what do they think about me how was I feeling how was my relationship with the pastor all of that just laid out on the table every three months which I think really ultimately benefited because then it became again in a church plant vision is so important and it became not just Jack and I doing the vision gatekeeping but the session better knew what we were trying to do in worship and so I just felt like it you know as much as we can become less of a cult of personality and more of real Presbyterians please that's going to ask how you worked in regards to that how were you told on it I was 30 hours a week what would be some advice that you always recommend on how to how to come up with salaries salaries and solutions because it seems like a problem in our many churches where we can afford a full time person and so I would wonder what's the best way to go about that process I mean repeat the question since you have the mic that usually gets them okay the question is how do you figure out what to pay especially if it's part time what sort of principles or whatever would guide and that's the process of arriving at that well for for the several times that I've done it unfortunately what's so great about for pastors is you have salary ranges that are that are publicized and so when a church calls a pastor they know what the normative ranges for their church size their location with worship it isn't there and so this was also a learning experience for my pastor he had me call other churches and gather all the information and put together what I thought was a fair package I would not suggest that I think it's better if you do that as a as a session and really but I think it requires the research you know in Virginia where I was doing worship for 30 hours a week and I'd started off at 10 in each year built and built and built and built and built and built hours and also the job sort of started to extend to women's things other things like that but one worship director in Virginia was making $65,000 a year and one was making five and so really you just it and so at that point as the worship person I said here's for my family's sake where I feel like we need here's what we need and here's what I think is really fair and and I felt like it wasn't a negotiating deal it was just here's the bare minimum that my family can afford we love this church we love this plant we've been part of it from the beginning we're not trying to milk you for something and so ultimately after the big conflict they came up way up or what I haven't asked for but which was a real you know it was a nice gesture we I think there are a lot of a lot of variables for some what happens in the church that I passed her there was the person doing was paid like a very small amount to be in a company and then this job started growing okay choir director forming an ensemble of musicians to play weekly work you know doing all kinds of things that kept growing the job to where the point was almost 20 hours a week and she was still being paid pretty much you know the $50 month sort of thing and and she was glad to do and love to be kind of grew into something that if she if her husband got a job somewhere else and they move the church would have this big hole in terms of a gifted person doing this work 20 hours a week and nothing in the budget to pay anybody to do her to find somebody to do it and so I think I don't know you you can all figure out your own sort of rule of thumb but it seems to me that every committed member of a local church if you're talking three to five hours a week and something they really love doing and want to do it probably isn't necessarily something that you would put them on the church staff and pay them for okay but once it begins to go definitely above that five hours it requires a certain skill set that is needs training and gifting and that sort of thing and it begins to pour to that I think you really need to to build that into things and and you have to call around figure out what people are doing some people are doing usually in my experience in the smaller part time things it's way under compensated and even appreciated and valued and part of the vision as you would grow so I think that is and again there's people work hard and love working hard that really don't mind volunteering in one sense and then you know somebody over here may get maybe doing some other job in the life of the church that they they're considering them and paying them it doesn't even compare to this and then you can have lots of it's really hard to deal with disappointments where you know you really are doing something that is worthy of more but you don't want to complain you don't know who your advocate is you know you bump up against the sessions who are talking about tight budget and cut backs and yet they want this program to expand so it's a we we have to be careful where we presume on people where it moves from legitimate volunteering into really stuff that's right and I think and as a rule of thumb in our church we always said you know is this person doing above and beyond because it will come up not just with your worship but are you paying your guitarist and how often are they playing and we we try to do an average of how many hours are are lay people we're doing to see is this person really doing above and beyond what God has called them to do in the church and likewise as the worship and art director I realized I wasn't getting paid for every hour that I was doing stuff for the church because again I'm still a church member and part of that requires that the Lord has asked me to serve the church it's not just a vocation so what I would always ask is this person doing something that's above and beyond the normal and then if so can we cut back first of all like are we not allowing other people to serve because this person is serving too much or is this person the sound tech is a good example of this sound is very complicated and if you have somebody that's really good and knows what they're doing it may be worth paying a sound person to every week run your sound board so you don't have a different volunteer every week because sound is if the people can't hear what's happening then nothing's happening so sound is really important also I was going to mention what Mark said about the different gradients of what what this job could look like there are some people who are doing a company some a choir director some people have chief musicians which they're not arranging music they're not conducting choirs they're it's the lowest level of kind of doing worship director they're in charge of the musician they're a skilled musician who maybe doesn't want to work for the church as far as theology vision that kind of thing some people who have chief musicians also have a worship director so under them there are some churches that have multiple people in the worship department one is a worship director a coordinator who does the liturgy planning the overseeing the arranging the teams the leading the the shepherding the gifting the discipling then under them a chief musician who practically helps lead the Sunday mornings and so those would do be different kinds of pay scales and then that on you know I guess also people who ordained pastors who also do worship in arts kind of different yeah there's a wide there's a wide range in this area compared to some other areas too okay anybody else have any questions what were some ways by you you do the session well besides just the meeting with them and that with a session one quarterly also one couple in particular we had a very small session it was my pastor the assistant pastor a guy who's a friend of ours and this one older man and he was part of that that earlier meeting I was talking about we ended up getting to a place where we really needed like mature wisdom advice and my husband and I went to them sort of just as congregants so there was a place where I had to get to know the session as a congregant and not just as a worker and they really became our parents I mean they are the ones who funded my CD and helped us do a budget and are supporting us to be here I mean that really that relationship really changed mainly because not just at the staff level but really just what it looks like for a shepherd to shepherd and for me to be willing to be shepherded by the session I think that's when that relationship started to change when I really went to them willing to be shepherded anything else you wanted to say well thank you for joining us for playing this morning you're welcome and I look forward to ongoing working together with you including the redemptive conflict that inevitably will arise let me to speak to that briefly I think that there are people you have conflict with that it never gets resolved and there's always tension you're always walking on eggshells what I mean by redemptive conflict is that you there is a love and acceptance and a trust and a desire to have the tension gone and a willingness to kind of go through and push through and realize you can have conflict and still get along and and because you're serving a vision that's bigger than both of you and I think that that's that's important not just in this relationship but as you work with other staff particularly with elders with deacons with your wife and kids you know it's sort of a principle of facing things honestly in the light of the gospel and saying Lord we all need to be shaped to be more like Christ and where am I missing it and how is this conflict wanting me to look at something in my own life not just make him or her not not cause this tension in my life but let's kind of push through especially if you keep bumping I mean love covers them all to the sins but if you have to keep covering it and it keeps getting bigger then you need to find a way to address it gently and lovingly and break through on something I think it's always a good opportunity for repentance and growth and and as we talk about you know our conflict together that that is what's happened I feel like we come to the table willing to repent or willing to say what is the Lord trying to teach me or grow me and as Daniel understands don't waste your pain good point I think for us the thing that we were we talked a lot about vision and what we wanted to do at chapel and how that fit sort of her understanding as well and then we began to talk about a level of implementing things and found that we were on very similar pages and so that's that looms large and the little things like this choice of song and stuff like that you know because we know we share a vision and we really we want the incoming students to be engaged and to have that first experience of something sung in chapel be something we draw them in I mean being on the same page of that and saying okay how can we get there rather than this is my song I want you know that that that really becomes when you put it in that larger context sometimes the things we fight for are not really that pretty petty actually one more thing I just thought of in some of the churches where I have friends who are in really tough relationships with their pastors as pastors I would encourage pastors to lead in repentance because you have to understand for the the pastor sort of seems like the untouchable authority and it's the musician who is just growing in bitterness in silence it wrongly but feels that they've lost their voice with this pastor and they've lost the voice in the vision they've lost a voice in implementation they've even lost a voice of fellowship and love so of all of us coming to the table and saying I'm willing to be wrong helps for everybody to to have a voice and to be heard and to grow in more love for each other we're on page 28 in the outline worship and music and

one of the things that Luther and Calvin particularly felt strongly about is that music would be used of God to help reform the church the restoring of song to the people singing the word of God singing words entered Christ centered hymns and there's a quote from World Magazine years ago by George Grant who's one of the pastors at Christ Community Church who was sitting right where Eric is sitting yesterday when his wife Karen gave her a capstone presentation in here as part of the M.A. by access so press on anyway George's quote which I love says ours is a singing faith at every turn on every occasion and in every age the Christian church has been marked by a prolific love of music wherever the gospel has been preached it has simultaneously been sung wherever the praises of our God have been expressed in words they have simultaneously been expressed in melodies as a result some of the most glorious music ever produced has been the fruit of faithful worship according to Martin Luther next to the word of God the noble art of music is the greatest treasure in this world i think that sums up well the the value the importance um the phenomenon of music sort of accompanying the movement of the gospel in the history of the church in that way usually when there's revival and reformation there's an outpouring of new musical expressions of saw for worship music is ultimately a gift a creation gift from God part of his command to be fruitful in multiplying fill the earth and subdue it and rule over it includes all kinds of development discovery innovative putting together of resources that God has made in ways that can be harnessed to glorify God and be a blessing to people and that was his intention for music it's interesting that music was developed in the line of came in uh genesis chapter four verse 20 says Ada gave birth to jable he was the father of those who live intense and raised livestock his brother's name was jubal he was the father of all who play the harp and flute zilla also had a son tubal king who forced all kinds of tools out of bronze and iron now what the scripture is showing us here is that the mandate to be fruitful in multiplying fill the earth and subdue it and rule over it the development of the creation is taking place in spite of the fact that the people in line of came are developing the creation of giftedness and resources in a way that wasn't necessarily to the glory of God um it is just sort of an interesting dynamic there um but they're noted in sort of raising a flocks musicians and tool makers there's sort of three large categories here that sort of summarize ways that that the cultural mandate despite rebellion and sin is nonetheless being fulfilled in these areas musical gifts are to be offered to God in both corporate worship and all of life um and as i said earlier different kinds of music fit different settings and contexts of life um and they're not all the same you know the take me out to the ballgame something you've stretched happy birthday to eric um let's sing happy birthday to eric did you all know it was his birthday today 46 72 72 actually it's not his birthday and he's only 32 wow what a mature 32 when you agree you know i think barely do some work on this thing or at least entertain it is not the number of these December 4 we're not i just made that up some guy did that to me at a summer camp my birthdays in march and he said i want everybody know today and march trying to hide it from us it's his birthday let's all stand up and sing happy birthday to mark i mean what do you do there's 150 kids singing happy birthday to you and you can stop them well i'll tell you this is so a rabbit trail down the track and it really has nothing to do but it has we as a music this this guy playing this practical joke on me um happened when i was newly married and 24 years old and how many children yet years later this man was teaching english literature at Geneva College of Pennsylvania and my daughter was in his class and so i had her stand up in class and announce that it was dr. kio patrick's birthday and had the class join in song singing happy birthday till when it wasn't his birthday 30 years later or 25 or whatever it was and he got it i mean he remembered he said i deserve that yeah really waiting for the opportunity or moment that's right music is as i talked about before a heightened expression of the spoken word the quote from frame there music is closely related to the spoken word human speech has a kind of natural music about it rhythm timber and pitch play important roles in verbal communication and not only in tonal languages in one sense then all languages musical when we enhance the natural music with well-crafted melodies harmonies and instruments our words often take on a new kind of vitality you know my analogy is telling Beth that i love her if i say Beth i love you what kind of respond you know if i say Beth i love you okay but then if i say Beth you know kind of go into music and write a love song to her okay it's gonna be hopefully it'll be special to her even if it's corny although there is this one song that i heard about Albert and the tea I want to brass how does that date me a few years ago he had a song this little piano book that i had called i'm in love with an angel so i started saying that to Beth and she has really hated the song so if i say that to her i get the opposite reaction anyway there's something about music being able to carry an expression in a way that more fully engages the power of music we talked about that quote from Calvin the Psalms could incite us to raise our hearts to God to move us with such order that we exalt through praises the glory of his name and truly we know through experience that song has great force and vigor to move and inflame hearts to invoke and praise God with the more lively and arc of zeal one of the books you had to read by Larry Roth let us sing he says that music has the power to create and intensify emotions to engage the memory the only song i ever wrote my entire life was driving a long trip with two of my children from Pennsylvania to Missouri and or Indiana and i was trying to teach them to memorize Galatians 5, 22 about the fruit of the spirit love joy peace patience kindness goodness faithfulness gentleness and self-control so i created this simple little tune that helped them to memorize i mean it's not song worthy to even be sung but it accomplished the mile's flying by while learning this scripture verse that was committed to memory because music had a way of engaging the memory that i find a lot of times you may find this too Bobby and working with with older people who have some form of dementia or Alzheimer's or whatever they can sometimes even remember their name but in a worship time if you're singing a hymn well loved him from years ago all of a sudden they'll break into song and sing all four stances of a song and after it's over they still don't remember their name so there's something about music touching us deeply emotionally with our memory it activates the imagination it contrasts the soul a lot of times in hospital rooms with with people that are in a coma to just sing to them read scripture then pray with them to not just assume that there's nothing going on there and sometimes song is what can break through to people again in some of those challenging times it's important to harness the power of music to the glory of god in the gospel not just who are feeling good about what a great song that was and so there's a difference between being moved by music just sort of as a goal in itself which would tend toward emotionalism my goal is to go to worship so I can have certain feelings okay as compared to it moving us toward god and his word a movement of a spirit that uses music as a means toward a greater goal rather than being an end in itself and so I think that's that's an important thing that we have to keep in mind as well and the excellence of music does carry the message more powerfully I don't think excellence is the ultimate goal it's it's an important means toward the ultimate goal of the glory of god and excellence has a measure of subjectivity to it and is valued differently in different settings or understood even to be excellence if you've never heard a French horn being played in somebody plays that you might initially think that's sort of a strange sounding instrument but if you learn what it takes to play the French horn and hear it done in a way that you know with other instruments and song and song is done beautifully then you've come to appreciate the excellence that is there to serve something greater um this uh acapella men's chorus that I sing in called ambassadors of harmony at our Christmas show last year at the two hill center here at the University of Missouri St. Louis and St. Louis we did five shows um and Saturday afternoon and Saturday evening were two of them and we we have this song go tell it on the mountain it's just a great arrangement of that spiritual with a hundred and fifty men singing four part harmony and a quartet comes out partway through sings and then we join with them um but when you're singing acapella excellence is partly defined by maintaining the pitch and not going flat which normalize what happens when you sing acapella and the energy of the song is carried by the excellence of the singing so in the afternoon show we flattered go tell it on the mountain by almost a half step and people sort of politely responded you know they they were expressing appreciation and the evening show we sharp did by about a quarter of a step and that's actually a good thing you know me an acapella choral singing like that and the energy with which it I mean same word same notes but with greater excellence of musician show and the response of the people in the songs it just stood up and cheered in response to the communication of the the message got across better because of the now were they saying you know we're out here with our our pitch meters trying to figure out you know if they flattered on if they do we're not going to respond no it just happens so the carrying of the power of the music with the excellence of of the musicianship is something it's there and so to strive for that is important the level to which you can accomplish that is going to vary from place to place based on who your musicians are and how good they are you know there may be well this this may be a time to tell a great musical story that I found in a book when I was working on my dissertation that a man who was a missionary to Alaska planning a church there he ended up gathering a lot of people together who came to his church because he was willing to to care for sort of the downcast on the outcast and and so on and there was you know one of their Sunday school teachers was a former prostitute and piano player was a former former alcoholic blind man and there was just a lot of down and outers who had been rescued from devastation as we looked at in sound 30 this morning by the grace of god who were now engaged in sharing the gospel and living out their lives in the glory of god well there was this family that they discovered who had a daughter who who had some sort of disease where she was wheelchair bound and she couldn't speak except to make some grunts and grunts and so she had one of these little chalkboard things hung around her neck that she would write on to try to you know communicate to people and so this pastor and his family would pick her her family had pretty much didn't want to have much of anything to do with her because of her condition and just gave her very minimal care physically but the pastor and his wife and family would pick her up and bring her to the evening worship service each Sunday and she just loved that and responded to the gospel and though she couldn't do much for herself she loved being there and was engaged in worship to the degree that she couldn't be well one Sunday night in the period of time where the pastor said was anybody have a testimony to share or a song they'd like to sing she raised her hand and when he said is anybody have a song they want to sing and what she was able to communicate is that she wanted to sing sing a solo she wanted to sing amazing grace and so the pastor not quite knowing how this was going to come up turn to the blind pianist and said you know brother can you play amazing grace for our sister here who wants to sing it so he played amazing grace and with grunts and groans as best she could to the to the sound of amazing grace she sang a solo of amazing grace I think you know just I mean talk about worshiping and spirit and truth to the glory of God and the power of even music in that moment to convey the message in a way that that transcended almost any other way to do it even though it wasn't from a raw musicianship and excellence you couldn't even understand the words you were singing let alone the notes being anywhere near the pitch it didn't matter whatsoever it was the heart of love for God that was being expressed in that musical expression in that way so you may not be a Philharmonic you know orchestra in your church or the some great you know Brooklyn tabernacle choir whatever the case may be but to have people sing from the heart with as much musical excellence as they're capable of and willing to work toward improving it is really the most you can ask for and God will take that and use that in great ways the other story I heard one time was a chaplain in a in a state park for a summer would never know who was going to come to the worship service and he given Sunday and he was not musically trained himself but he would prepare the devotional and then sort of see is anybody here who can play the piano and one one Sunday he the only volunteer he got was someone who said well I can't play very well but I can pluck out the melody line on the piano for the congregation to sing and so he said come on up and use your gift to aid us in our worship of God so they say you found it out to the service that there was a concertinist who was an attendants who was unwilling to volunteer to use his gifts so there was greater excellence in the room by far but it's not just being excellent it's having the willing heart to serve which is other person I knew they weren't very good but they could do something as far as I knew they could do the most of anybody in their room in that regard so just a few thoughts on excellence is important in the way that it powerfully carries the message but it's not the whole thing in our worship there's an article in the in the journal of the Evangelical Society I've listed there Jets if you're interested in this it's in our library and you can make a a copy of it to take with you where Gavin and Steve Guffrey makes a case

that music itself as music by God's design has a role to play in our sanctification and he does sort of a historical study of music and Augustine's view of it and some of that in the article and then he does some exegesis of the Ephesians 5 passage to make this point and I find it fascinating I'm not sure I completely understand it or agree with it but I think he's making a valid point that is worthy of consideration in Ephesians 5 verses 19 and 20 we read speak to one another with Psalms hymns and spiritual Psalms sing and make music in your heart to the Lord always giving thanks to God the Father for everything in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ now part of what he's saying here is that certainly the content is the songs the hymns and the spiritual songs but he's say speak to one another with Psalms and spiritual songs sing and make music in your heart to the Lord there's something about taking those words and making music in your heart with them that has an impact in the shaping and forming of you to be more like what you're singing about and it's in the context of being in a sense an outgrowth of the answer to drunkenness in verse 18 to not get drunk on wine which leads to debauchery instead be filled with the spirit speaking to one another songs hymns and spiritual songs and singing and making music in your heart so part of the you know how in in the many of Paul's letters it's the put off of this aspect of this info nature and put on this aspect of being in Christ and filled with the spirit so if you look at the context what is this relationship between drunkenness and the rest of the passage well certainly it's don't be drunk be filled with the spirit but what is one of the ways and means of being filled with the spirit that God has given us it's the singing of Psalms in the spiritual song there's a certain forming of us that very you know when I'm I know a pastor who spoke to a youth retreat that I was at one time and he said what he's called has to go to the hospital emergency room not knowing what he's going to face he would sing this little song it was philmy Jesus philmy now he's sort of a crying out to be filled with just a simple little chorus thing that he would sing on the way to the hospital and he said that he found that God used that singing of that song making music in his heart reminding him of his dependence upon God and his need to be an instrument of God as he went into an unknown crisis situation as part of what God used to make him what he wanted him to be and so when we think about that if this is true even to a small degree think about the importance of the songs we select for the congregation to sing in corporate public portion and to encourage them in understanding that sort of shaping sanctifying dimension of them what the music itself does in connection with word never separated from the word but this guy gothries almost giving a quasi sacramental means of grace dimension to the music of singing songs in itself in that way the quote I have your music makes its own distinctive contribution to Christian life in worship whatever support may off music may offer words however it may highlight reinforce or enhance the text music itself the music of music is used in the sanctifying work of the Holy Spirit only high view of the role of music in worship and consistent with some of what Calvin was saying this is something God wants us to do in worship we're not doing it we need to be doing it because of its power to stir our hearts to love God I mean in a sense gothries standing in a Calvinistic tradition and in terms of what Calvin said about that again swingly and I would say what Calvin said about that maybe against some others later in the history of even Presbyterianism that diminished the role of music in what part he possibly disagreeing with gothries statement well I guess the part that makes me pause a little bit is if I go to this idea of the music as music he's almost saying he's not saying disconnected from the words and they're inseparably related but I think you're trying to make his point of the power and use and sanctifying work of music he almost separate at times and the article tends to almost separated from the content I don't think he means to do that and it just it's one of those things where even I can't find anything wrong with this and if it's true it's a tremendous thing and it reinforces a whole lot of things that I can believe it's almost like it's too good to be true and so I wonder well maybe some actually do to look at that and understand that differently and I want to make sure we have content with music yeah right which I think he would complete thing right with but he's sort of isolating the music of music out here which you then I think have to reconnect with the context of worship I mean but the music in the heart and the songs in the spiritual songs are inseparably linked in the passage and in the Colossians one kind of cross reference that we've looked at before in three 16 let the word of Christ dwell in you richly as you teach and watch one another with all wisdom and as you sing songs in the spiritual songs with gratitude in your hearts there's a you know it's the this this is a mate this Colossians three passage starting at 15 has it's the piece of Christ ruling in your hearts it's the word of Christ dwelling in your richly it's gratitude in your hearts you know there's that it's piece word song in the heart combination they come together really it's it's a I agree with him that it's a it's a means that God uses to powerfully shape us when serving the purposes of gospel center worship and filled with Christ center and biblical content but I would agree with you because this is what you're saying that the truth is that center like the content has to be a primacy over yes expression yeah and I guess that's right maybe I don't I don't want to accuse him of sort of that it doesn't but by separating out right also alongside of that the very vehicle through which that content is going it's sort of like you separate things to analyze them and sometimes people then take that and wait them separated so that's the rejoining with yeah I don't think what you're saying I'm just saying that either I just think I'm prone to worship music yeah so I'm trying to resist that yeah I'm trying to think through how can I be careful well I think it actually helps to say that the purpose of music is to sanctify us not just to make us feel good about enjoying and make an idol of music so the emphasis on it it having a role as a tool and a means that God uses toward a greater goal just like that's the purpose the goal of worship is not the sermon the goal of worship is greater Christ likeness and glory to God which the sermon is a vital part that's used toward that goal but the sermon is a means it's a means of grace okay toward the goal of greater Christ likeness so using the sacraments prayers the reading of scripture but see what that does to us then is worship planters and worship leaders is we haven't accomplished what the purposes of worship are by just selecting things and doing things and saying we've we've honored the regular principle because we haven't gotten to the right or left God wants to worship so as well forgetting that it's it these are means of grace toward Christ likeness and the glory of God and so to be thinking is what preparing sermons or a pastoral prayer or you know that the prayer that Paul gave at the end today and the worship service wanted it was obvious that he did he was placing himself both into the the message of the service out of Psalm 30 and the people who are there who are getting ready to go back home there was sort of a thinking through of how this prayer could be a means that God would use in the sanctifying and commissioning as we had talked about yesterday of those who've been together this week as they go back home so it it wasn't you know it isn't you know I stick in my thumb and pull out a plum and saying what a good prayer am I okay it's um entering into the word the music the the worship the culminating point in the servant of death I thought that was I was as I was sitting there it's it's hard when you teach worship to not analyze what's going on in the worship service in a way that may not be fully entering in so while trying to fully enter into Paul's prayer and analyze it at the same time as the professor at the class um you know I found myself thinking you know a lot of times this kind of prayer is earlier in the service but it really fits here today with where it being the last day we're together the last morning of devotions um and and that that commissioning side of the worship service often gets short-changed in most services I go to sort of the a quick benediction at the end not maybe a lot of sort of sending out one of the things I try to do at the end of the Lord's supper is to have a scripture passage of exhortation now I often will use Ephesians 5 I think it is to be beginning yeah um I'll say something like from verse 32 of chapter 4 be kind and compassionate to one another forgiving each other just as in Christ God forgive urging people toward one another in forgiveness as we've now received it or uh be imitators of God therefore having come to his table and been renewed in the grace of the covenant now go and be imitators of God as dearly loved children and live a life of love just as Christ loved us and gave Himself up for us as a frequent offering and sacrifice to God there's that taking forward into their lives as we send them out to live a life of worship in every area dimension of their lives the other six days of the week that that needs to sort of uh carry forward and out and into into life