<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Donér Donér månedligt

Discussion: Edmund Clowney's "The Church"

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Teach us tonight we ask about the church and how it should function Lord help us to love you and love your church. Maybe not be detractors Lord but edifiers in our own fellowships. Give us a broad view of the body of Christ and a concern for other Christians and different communion's Father. We do ask you to improve our own churchmanship Father, our zeal in your service, our effectiveness in your service. We commit ourselves to you. Teach us we ask through Jesus Christ, our Lord, amen. Our goal tonight is to finish up the doctrine of the church and then next time to move to a study of the means of grace. Three tasks tonight to go over the cloudy quiz, to talk about the government of the church and then the women and the church. I want to say right away too that we welcome our students taking the course by videotape. We welcome them tonight. Let's talk about the book. What do you think about it? Are you glad you read it? First of all, why? I hear a mixed response. Did you learn about the church? I hear a lot of yeses.

One student has expressed that appreciation for many good thoughts in this book but also difficulty in following the flow of the argument and following the thought. There's some choppiness there. Last time we talked about how the book was cut way down and it was too long and I guess it's daughter, Dr. Clowney's daughter edited it for him and one student is saying that that shows and this hindered the readability. I bet on the positive side had you read a good book on the church lately. I'll tell you something, there are not many and this book filled a real gap in my own assignments. Dr. Jones, I'll give you a little inside scoop here, was contemplating writing a book on the church. He's got excellent notes, minor largely, pilfered from his but he has excellent notes and was seriously thinking about writing a book on the doctrine of the church to fill the need. He's no longer thinking of that although he does acknowledge that problem in the flow. I don't disagree at times it was a little choppy. Other comments? Yes, sir. Appreciation was expressed for Dr. Clowney's fairness in dealing with others, even with those who he disagrees, Roman Catholic theology by and large for example and also for his balanced treatment of women's role in the church in that particular chapter. Let's do our quiz and hopefully this will be a learning experience in itself. True or false according to Edmund Clowney, that's not according to you or me, that's our objectivity factor. Number one, missionary concern was a leading factor in the development of the ecumenical movement. True page 17, it's simply an historical fact that that is how things developed. Believers began to get together to share their burden for the lost and the missionary task of the church around the world and out of that came ecumenism which has some good and yet today is the World Council of Churches for example, it's so dominated by radical realities that most conservators are very much ill at ease, even in supporting it. And there's been such a move away from a missionary zeal that now the focus is on dialoguing with the world's religions. But that is true. Number one is true page 17. Number two for a fresh look at the biblical doctrine of the church. A full Trinitarian approach serves best, true page 29. I agree, that's why in our own notes we talked about the church as the people of God, the Father, the body of Christ, and the temple of the Holy Spirit. It does seem to lend itself to a Trinitarian approach. Number three when Jesus said, you are Peter and on this rock I will build my church. The rock referred to Peter's confession, not Peter himself. According to Dr. Clowney, false page 40. According to Martin Luther and John Calvin, it would be true. I would agree with Dr. Clowney that this was one place where the reformers were overreacting to the Roman claims. If you do say that it was a word play and it was playing with Peter's name and calling him, we would say something like Rocky today or Stoney. You know, you're not, you're, I'm going to call you Rocky. I gave him a new name and on this rock I'll build my church. It does not lend any weight to the Roman claims about Peter being a pope. Okay, that's not Dr. Clowney's point. But I do think the reformers engaged in some defensive exercises at this point. And I would agree with Dr. Clowney, although there is disagreement here among Bible-believing Christians. But certainly I'll be clear. Peter did not claim to be any pope and he is not the pope. First, Peter 5, 1 rather gives his attitude. He was a fellow elder and a servant of Christ. Yes, sir. It's a good comment. I think you just put your finger on. A student has expressed some difficulty in understanding Dr. Clowney's statements there in a few paragraphs in which he discusses question three, the information from which we drew question three about Peter and his person and then in his and the confession that he made. Dr. Clowney emphasized the inseparability of Peter's person and his confession. I think that's a good way to do it. That is if Jesus was talking about Peter as an individual, it was not Peter apart from his fellow apostles and it was not Peter in himself and some kind of an office apart from his ministry of the proclamation of the word. But exactly Peter as the God ordained or leader of the early churches. No doubt the book of acts focuses around the ministries of two outstanding leaders gifted by God. Peter and then Paul, Peter was the original man used by God in a mighty way. God tamed him and used his zeal and leadership gifts and boldness and so forth in preaching especially also in healing and so forth but that was that supported the preaching ministry and the preaching was just blessed by God. I mean just incredibly and thousands were converted day after day and so forth. So I think that's the sense. He doesn't want to support Roman claims mainly he's being positive. Rather than a defensive exegesis he's trying to be positive and study the text and say yes the reformers had something when they said it was Peter's confession but they didn't need to separate that from his person. In fact it's Peter the confessor, Peter the preacher who is in view in Jesus' statement. I would agree with his understanding for the work of the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament is limited to empowering select individuals for special service. Of course this one is true. Just joking. Most of you are used to my tricks by now. Just see if you're awake. Paul's page 54. Some teach that. It's a long history but see if I get this straight. The early dispensational writers would have answered this one false. Then for a long period and the most popular writers said true today there's a tendency back in the other direction within the dispensational tradition so there's been some movement there back and forth. Yes he empowered select individuals for special purposes and service. No question but we can't limit his work to that and Dr. Clowney along with other reformed theologians would say that ever since the fall people were dead in their trespasses and sins and if they were to be saved they needed to be given new life by God. He refuses to accept and I agree a different salvation in the Old Testament and in new. There are differences in terms of the object of faith and the understanding of people who the saints in looking forward to Christ's coming as opposed to looking back to his coming as we do now. We see things much more clearly but still if people were spiritually dead then we have to ask the question first of all did God save Old Testament believers. Surely we have to say yes on the strength of passages such as Romans 4 and Galatians 3 and 4 and Hebrews 6 and 11 and if we say yes then we have to ask did he save them in a different way than he saved them now the answer has to be no all event of all Christians as far as I know agree on this point that no one is saved apart from the atonement of Jesus Christ either looked forward to in prospect or looked back toward in retrospect and likewise now the tendency is to go along these lines as well and say even so the spirit the Holy Spirit had to apply that saving work of Christ to come to the Old Testament saints as well. If they were spiritually dead and I don't see how we can deny that although that is more plainly taught in the New Testament than in the Old and if they were saved which New Testament certainly teaches that they were then I don't see how they could have been saved apart from the election of God the Father and the saving work of Christ in the future and then the application of that salvation by the Holy Spirit we are not claiming these things are as plainly taught in the Old Testament as they are in the New there are hints of them in the Old the revelation of the Bible is progressive but especially from a New Testament perspective I would agree with Dr. Clowney that although the Holy Spirit was involved and sometimes this stands out in the narrative he was involved empowering individuals to think of the judges for example in a book of judges like Samson to do great works of service we cannot limit his work to those aspects but instead we need to ascribe to him other aspects of the working of salvation unless the people weren't saved or what seems like a theological monstrosity to us they were saved but saved some other way apart from the work of Christ was it a work salvation for them no dispensational interpreters ever said that they said some things that sounded like that and their opponents fastened it to their credited to them but it's not really fair to accuse Darby or others of that but then if they were saved by the work of Christ was it without the Holy Spirit did they make themselves alive spiritually or did they remain dead spiritually and and what they saved why they were spiritually dead that doesn't work where the works that Joseph and David and other Old Testament heroes that they performed were those works deeds of the flesh or were they the fruit of the Holy Spirit I think if you think about it for a while you can again confess a great difference in clarity between the testaments and in the working of salvation but even as God has always been the Holy Trinity and that is much more plainly revealed in the New than in the Old even so the one salvation has been always been planned and accomplished and applied by that same Trinity throughout the pages of the Bible yes sir about the spiritual creation okay even apart from matters of salvation someone has said what about the spirits work in creation and also in providence as well there's evidence in the Psalms that the Holy Spirit is involved in God's good work of sustaining his creation especially and also directing it toward his ends try it on for size if that challenges you don't accept anything just because I said it and clowns says it by and large on picking books that I think are correct so the testimony of two witnesses doesn't prove it here you've got to be convinced from the Bible but the alternatives to number four to saying true to that the alternatives to saying false to it are just again it's into great problems it seems to me number five two qualities define the spirit's purposes as he founds the church he is the spirit of truth and the spirit of life true page 58 but that was good perhaps we should add spirit of love there's an awful lot about fellowship in the book of Acts and sharing and so forth but that's a quibble this is what he says and it's true he the spirit gives new life and he does work through the apostles preaching first of all and then he leads them to put into writing certain aspects of that preaching directed toward individual churches and individuals and some of their needs in writing the New Testament and all of that in fulfillment of John chapters 14 through 16 number six in discussing the work of the Holy Spirit we cannot sharply separate natural gifts from spiritual gifts true page 66 this seems wise to me is it a way to get around denying the supernatural not at all it is a way of saying the most important thing is if we get busy forgot and the Lord has given us natural endowments and he sanctifies them in his service praise to the Lord it's not even so important our ability to distinguish those things but it all comes from God feel free to ask questions as we move along or I'll ask I'll give time at the end as well yes do one believers have natural gifts shortly they can have great natural gifts they can be off the charts intellectually or artistically or terms of win some this or yes first comment is can we look at on say people is having natural gifts yes second one is then do we just kind of fold them over into the church if they kind of know the Lord and give the you know the most closely corresponding spiritual gift unnecessarily that's his point we don't need to do that but we can be sure that believers have every believer has at least one gift it may be it may augment their personality and be something that never did or were before they may discover an at this for teaching or ministry in some particular area but usually God doesn't cancel out their whole personality there can be great changes in that way but I would say that's unusual usually there's a blossoming there's a flowering of natural gifts and endowments and we might quickly add to as the Lord's people we still can have problems and even big problems so we're not using even our natural gifts to the best way that we can many times let alone our spiritual ones as well seven the sure sign of Christ's true church is found in its unbroken line of succession from Peter I'm not going to try to pull your chain anymore tonight false page 73 you wouldn't even have batted an eyelash if I said true on that one no it's found in its fidelity to the gospel that Peter and the other apostles taught that is the apostolicity it means faithfulness to the apostles message not an unbroken line of succession from Peter eight while no church is perfect in its teaching we must distinguish between churches that are defective in doctrine which I guess would be all churches and those that are apostate having renounced the apostolic pattern of sound teaching true page 82 don't we need to make a distinction like this I believe so the New Testament itself warns of great apostasy in the last days I don't know if I mentioned this before but some years ago in teaching the doctrine of scripture I was struck by the fact that in the two great in the contexts of the two great passages that teach the inspiration of the Bible second Timothy three and second Peter one the preceding and following context and second Timothy three and the following one and second Peter one deal with apostasy in the last days I think that's not accidental I think the Lord by implication is saying he forthrightly says there's going to be such apostasy great turning away from the truth of the word of God but I think the implication is that the Bible is given to us as the antidote to that it is God's remedy for that spiritual poison now it is humbling it's humbling but the truth to admit that none of our churches are perfect in teaching okay that's that's a tough one but I think that is the case in that way we should be always reforming always trying to evaluate our teaching by the word of God but we need to distinguish between orthodox churches that have some defects and they have defects not just in teaching but morally and every other way you can think of between that and between churches that are have departed from the apostolic pattern of sound teaching it could be hard in individual cases to label churches as having done such some others it may not be hard I remember a professed Christian congregation calling for the union not only of all who call themselves Christians around the world regardless of what they believe but the just outward embracing of theological pluralism with the religions of the world and anything less than that was called imperialism and so forth just an outright pluralism of accepting every religion and whatever beliefs they have that certainly is wild it is tricky to to pronounce the nomination this apostate especially where there are pockets of truth within them and even more than pockets and the history of American Christianity has witnessed a couple of times now I'm thinking of the Lutherans Missouri Synod and the Southern Baptists a direction a move in a liberal direction and then a writing of that a turning of the compass back to north as it were I don't think in this case the Southern Baptists the full fallout has occurred it looks to me like it's possible the moderates may realign themselves and form their own group or pull out or whatever but it does look like the group the church has a hole has turned back to its historic conservative and Baptist affirmations in that I rejoice 9 Christ is incarnate in the cosmic process false page 95 he fills the universe he created it and he sustains it that is not how he is incarnate he is incarnate in becoming a human being living a sinless life dying for our sins rising again returning to the father and so forth so we don't downplay the uniqueness of his incarnation by talking in these actually it's evolutionary theory applied to Christian theology it is false page 95 10 sectarianism and racism deny the Catholicity of the church true page 97 I know another point we can praise him on see if you agree with me he is a practical theologian is he not that is he knows historical theology the church he works carefully with the Bible for the most part but he has his his finger on the pole so what's going on and he speaks to different application doesn't he maybe you'd want it to be stronger there but I appreciated his practical emphasis number 11 10 was true page 97 11 the marks of the church include true preaching of the word proper observance of the sacraments and faithful exercise of church discipline true page 101 some of this is review and too simple that's good that means you're learning and that's exciting to me to see that happen number 11 is true page 101 number 12 church membership is unbiblical and unnecessary false pages 103 to 104 you find that section edifying I've known a few good people who in the name of why would call a biblicism a fidelity to the Bible that I don't know they take themselves too seriously and they work with the Bible in kind of a wooden fashion and they don't do theology they just believe the Bible if you know what I'm saying they don't admit the human enterprise in studying the Bible and the fact that we're using our minds and putting things together and so forth and if the Bible doesn't tell us every detail but that we think to try to understand the the implications and so forth behind the scriptures who have indeed rejected membership in the church that seems to me to be a serious mistake I would agree with him on number 12 that is false pages 103 and 104 the early the information we have in the epistles concerning church discipline implies something very much like church membership how can you put people out if there's not some notion of being in it may have taken a different form than ours but still there's that notion of belonging because people if they go far enough are then disenfranchised and put out well they were in is a way you could be in that is the biblical foundation for what we call church membership maybe you were surprised on this one I wasn't sure what he would say about paraturch organizations and I can tell you this people who have enough thought and interest in the church to spend years of research and they write a book on the church are likely to say paraturch organizations are bad at least to largely cast them in a negative light okay they are to be criticized but I was frankly pleasantly surprised by 13 the church ought to label paraturch organizations illegitimate false page 107 there are problems I understand that there are problems sometimes serious problems and I have taught students who have worked faithfully in paraturch organizations and known the Lord's blessing on their ministries and have not regarded all as wasted who came to seminary because of abuses and problems in order to get more training to do a better job and to work with the church I rejoice that church staffs are hiring paraturch types in the areas of discipleship and evangelism have you noticed that tendency some very effective people uh there are definitely problems but it would be too strong to label these things illegitimate per se yes sir where I have to confess ignorance here maybe somebody can help me while I'm summarizing the question for our friends taking a class by video take your question is these those particular groups you sure on that one your memory is better than mine at this point question is why the Missouri Senate Lutherans and Southern Baptist was the word reject why they're not crazy about the paraturch organizations maybe shun is too strong uh wow I speak as a Presbyterian here who's pretty ignorant but from my own bias perspective of conservative Lutheranism okay they're pretty tight and closed and you need to go to a Lutheran seminary to be ordained for a Lutheran ministry and so forth so there's their own structures in that way I respect them on that I would have some disagreements concerning the unity of the church uh is it true Southern Baptist no want to say anything is anybody no official policy of this Southern Baptist convention one student one pastor's wife has said it has not been her experience

okay the Baptist principal of the autonomy of local churches uh would seem to indicate that local churches could support or not support support paraturch organizations it may be a thrust in a big denomination like that to work through their denomination agencies and so forth and there are what is it called Baptist student unions on college campuses and why can't Southern Baptist support that kind of work and they maybe they might consider sometimes others other campus ministries rivals although I wouldn't be surprised that they work together in seeing unsafe people say and so I don't you can point to me to a paragraph point me to a paragraph I'll look at it I'm not sure if that's quite correct comment okay another person has shared from his own recent paraturch ministry that these particular churches have their own works and they support them but he found no hostility toward his own different the paraturch group it'd be good to maybe probe that a little more but I need to get the exact page to do so 14 the New Testament gives us an order of service complete with detailed directions for conducting worship false page 126 I wasn't by saying true I hope he was gesting I have been with different groups that have thought this was the case in my own spiritual pilgrimage which has been a happy one which I will not recount for you now uh but uh it looks to me like that's a mistake to say that our particular order of services commanded by the Lord because the implication is then if the rest of the people aren't worshiping according to the Bible uh that seems to me to be not deliberately but in the end kind of prideful uh we are simply not given an order of service uh there have been some studies of early Christian worship which which is related to the 1st century synagogue worship uh I would say that's helpful to study those things but that we're not bound to those forms there are certain essential elements of worship as Dr. Clowney points out and uh in terms of Christ's mission around the world why can't those elements be applied in particular cultures in different ways under godly leadership sensitivity to the Holy Spirit uh and that I don't see where every service has to be the same perhaps the Lord in wisdom didn't give us a divinely commanded order of worship for that very purpose 15th in the USA in the last 25 years the pendulum of the church has swung away from indoctrination in the direction of the loss of ordered instruction in the word of god true page 147 do you agree is there a problem I think so I think so there are lots of different reasons why one thing is competition with mass media that has gotten flashier and flashier and more powerful in that way and people find it dull sit through a Sunday school monologue Sunday school classroom whatever within our serious problems here and we need to devote ourselves to doing a better job of teaching on the other hand some movements like Bible study fellowship and so forth have moved in to fill the void again they're not without the problems but uh I suppose the existence of those types of ministries demonstrates the point that there's a real need number 16 the identity of the church is necessary for the mission of the church true page 162 I agree with him so strongly and that's why we began talking about what the church is nature of the church out of each of the church marks of the church and so forth and then moves talking about the ministries of the church and that type of the thing and today it's a government and so forth this is a kind of a fundamental order that being is prior to doing modern philosophy has not followed that order and modern theology which chases after modern philosophy has done the same and evangelicalism has not been unaffected by that we tend to downplay being it's an mistake and we need to know what in the world the church is before we develop programs as to what the church or to do we need more time spent in preaching and teaching has anybody in the last five years had taught or sat in an adult science school class where the topic was the doctrine of the church anybody that's tremendous the last ten years anybody else I'm not surprised and we wonder why people don't understand the church why they hop around why the lack of commitment to the church lots of factors there a part of the problem however at least is a lack of teaching even concerning what the church is and ought to do 17 for the church to turn from evangelism to multi-culturalism and radical feminism is to turn to another gospel true page 165 you have commented on Dr. Clowne's fairness I'm glad that in the midst of being fair and compassionate was the word one of you used he in the other hand doesn't pull his punches when it comes time to knock somebody out and here's a case where he surely shouldn't compromise and he doesn't he stands his ground

18 the Bible never condemns any cultural practices false page 181 it's got some pretty hard things to say about idolatry for example okay and if incest or other sins are a part of a culture's framework they have to go when the gospel comes in I thought he showed some sensitivity in discussing some aspects that were pretty neutral others that could be very positively used in the propagation of the gospel and life in the church but he needed again to draw a line in the sand and say there are cultural practices that the Bible condemns as sinful so the negative of that would be false 18 is false page 181 19 believers in every country should form exclusively Christian political parties that seek to exercise power in the name of Christ false page 193 I should have saved my pull your chain one for that one maybe it would arise you a little bit false 193 he sees it as a misunderstanding of the mission of the church I agree with him on that 20 because of the authority Christ gave to them church leaders are free to invent doctrines and practices ha ha ha ha without script your authority why of course not page false 202 hey some of you were praying for relatives of some of you who are trapped in cults and that's exactly what happened either you laugh or you cry it's good to remind ourselves of that it indeed is good 20 is false 202 21 and 22 are false and true respectively women ought to function as elders in the church false 229 as deacons true to 31 he is part of the present hearing church in America which which excludes women from both offices so he would be in favor of changing part of the PCAs understanding of things and allowing not only allowing but maybe I don't want to speak for him but he's in favor of having women deacons I don't know how strong he is I can say this I think maybe I'm not quite as strong as he is but I would not oppose it and I certainly agree with him that we ought to not only have a negative theology of women if all we say about any group of people is no is not as negative Bible doesn't only do that it has a couple prohibitions in this area I respect them I don't think we're free to change them but we need also to say what the Lord says in a positive way we're going to try to do that later on tonight ourselves but so he says elders no deacons yes he grounds it not in personal opinion but in his understanding of the scriptures 21 is false page 229 22 is true page 231 yes question that there's some problem here 232 234 how does it refute it which which one you're thinking about here regards Phoebe as a deaconess so number 22 is true 21 is false to 29 he is not in favor of women as either teaching or ruling elders he's in favor of women teaching and serving the Lord and they can't exercise authority in different spheres in the church but not as the official leaders or official preachers of the congregation is his own conclusion by the way if you disagree with that we'll still love you around here but we will you know lovingly disagree with you you have the right to disagree with us we're not trying to be contentious but we are bound to what we understand the Bible teaches you still have a problem Phoebe is a deaconess he thinks is that clear some would some would just see her as a servant and not have not holding that office even though it's the same word for Deacon show me that one comment is made that someone thought Dr. Clowney was saying that only was Phoebe a deaconess and charged with some important ministries but that she was over on congregation I don't believe so he would be carnivating himself show me that maybe you can find it in the break where we would certainly respectfully consider what you say I don't believe he's carnivating himself he could be a little unclear at points that's that's unfortunately what all writers are eventually yes the question is would he exclude women from the role of pastor teacher yes they could be so gifted but they couldn't use that gift as the pastor teacher of the congregation they could do pastoral ministries they can teach but not as the authoritative teacher of scripture and doctrine in the church or as the rulers of the church calls variously elders bishops pastors 23 we are not to look for apostolic signs today true page 244 some of you might take issue with him on that did you not find his spirit though good even where he disagrees sometimes with the he has to disagree with people sometimes people have different views on things I did find him having a consistently good spirit yes okay yes that doesn't make sense let me summarize this for our students taking the course by extension and then make a few comments on it's probably a difference of the way you look at it and the way dr clowny does I don't find him inconsistent 244 first full paragraph on the top the cessation of the apostolic signs does not mean the cessation of the gifts of the spirit the saints still possess the graces that were supernaturally heightened in miraculous gifts I think the key here is the word apostolic that is he would not agree that there any more apostles having that authority to write scripture to preach direct revelation from god and so forth he is showing some openness to gods continuing to do the supernatural and so forth but I think the key is apostolic signs and he would see that as limited to the founding of the Christian church I would agree with him that apostle is something really de jellously guard as a first century phenomenon I understand the Bible itself uses apostle in a secondary sense perhaps we could use it in that sense but I would think just because of confusion it's unwise to do so on the other hand god is god and he does still do supernatural the supernatural so I see a certain openness in him to appreciate there but a guarding the whole notion of apostolicity in the primary sense of the word apostleship and apostle 24 we should understand the gift of tongues as a supernatural speaking of languages true according to dr clowny page two four six he has made me I get me some food for thought that was not my conclusion before I read his book I'm an expert on this but he has given me things I've got to think about some more now there's more to that viewpoint than I previously thought of in any case in terms of clownies book 24 is true two four six and 25 is false weighing Grudem's view of the gift of prophecy today is correct false page two six eight comments your questions for a few minutes sounds to me like you're profited yes sir false two six eight he takes strong issue with Grudem who was his former student and weighing Grudem weighing Grudem of Trinity Evangelical Divinity School has produced a fine big systematic theology text and he dedicates it to different people who greatly influenced him pastors and others and one of the people has been clowny that's really a nice gesture I think yes sir yes yes it doesn't make sense this is the hard one to summarize concerning question 24 and what the speaking in tongues is a comment is that there's a divine interpretation maybe emphasis should be on the interpretation and the hearing because of what happened at Pentecost that does seem unique though in terms of the I don't know how to say it united nations affect without the headphones of all different languages I mean if the Lord was doing some amazing special thing there are we to see that same multi-language phenomenon in all the other references and acts and so forth I don't think so but you might say that's because they were only people of one language so I don't know how to answer there's certainly debate and not all would agree with Grudem concerning 24 okay yes and they didn't speak English that's amazing we shared that a student's brother was it or brother-in-law brother-in-law had done some preaching in an African country and had preached in English and the people had heard him in their own language I'm not sure what we call that but if he's preaching the true gospel and they're hearing the true gospel I would call it occasion for praising the Lord we need to take a break we can come back and talk a little bit more about the book if you'd like let's take a 10 minute break