<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Spenden Monatlich spenden

Discussion: Hoekema's "The Bible & the Future"

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Bless our class time tonight make it profitable in your sight and for us we pray and We'll commit ourselves to you thanking you through Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior. Amen Got to work cut out for us point number one is the hookam a quiz as a whole are you glad you read the book? I Think it's one of the finest books that I assign I Have found some good books over the years We've been greatly blessed by the Lord with very helpful books. This is one of the best. I Use hookamas three books creating God's image saved by grace and the Bible in the future. I have no doubt although three all three are very good This is his best book true or false according to St. Anthony, that's right not according to you or me number one Old Testament believers looked for the new heavens and the new earth true page 11 2 in the New Testament we find the realization that the great eschatological event predicted in the Old Testament was Still future false page 15 rather that it has happened The great event has happened there is still more to come but the great event is the coming of the Redeemer 3 The New Testament believer was not conscious of living in the last days False page 17 think a first John 2 it is the last time we know that because many Antichrists have already appeared for the blessings of the present age Are the guarantee of greater blessings to come true page 20 of course understood there is four believers If somebody put false Because you thought of unbelievers and I was trying to be tricky anybody do that Did I I did not add the word for believers that I that's my intention, but it hasn't gotten done yet But by the way concerning that you are not allowed to look at any past final examinations I do recycle questions being a person of limited creativity I don't make brand new finals up every time so you are not allowed to look at past finals That is considered cheating. So don't please Five the Christian understanding of history is optimistic true page 38 That is related to the Christian understanding of God and Has of his plan six in the teaching of Jesus and Paul the Kingdom of God is both present and future true page 51 number six is true And you find that on hukama page 51 seven The Holy Spirit is the connecting link between the present body and the resurrection body true page 67 we want to talk about Resurrection bodies At least say some things we don't understand completely the new earth and hour situation on it But we can say some things we can make some progress along those lines eight Seven was true page 67 Eight it is impossible to understand New Testament eschatology apart from the tension between the already and the not yet true page 68 a lot of these We reinforced in lecture and that's good that lecture and reading fits together that fit together that way nine Eight was true page 68 nine the deepest meaning of death is cessation of existence False page 82 its separation from God false page 82 10 the highest end of human beings is continued existence after death false page 90 90 it is life in fellowship with God all Human beings continue to exist after death although many of them We'll wish that annihilationism were true Because it would represent relief from punishment understand That would not be the worst imaginable fate. It would represent Relief from the punishment of God and in an evangelical Christian annihilation is scheme Since annihilationism is stuck on the end of a Christian eschatology You have resurrection of the dead Appearance at the last judgment and then terrible punishment is emphasized Why not immediate annihilation? They're trying to take into account the Bible's teachings on degrees of punishment Okay, so and in light of that terrible punishment being exterminated would constitute I argue Reliefs from punishment Relief from it it would not constitute a worst punishment Although annihilation is to insist there's nothing possibly worse than to not exist I disagree It is much worse to exist forever In conscious torment That is why the death doctor for example has clientele Okay to live in torment in this life is a terrible thing and I don't make I don't minimize that And that way people view death as relief From punishment in from suffering in this life uh Number 10 is false page 11 the Bible's central message about the future of human beings Is the immortality of the soul false page 91 it is the resurrection of the dead

I agree And we'll be back to that topic tonight 12 there is no intermediate state false page 108 By the way the definition of the intermediate state is Missouri in between Kansas and Illinois terrible I used to use Pennsylvania, but I've shifted locale here Although you know I still look at that weather map occasionally from the perspective of Philadelphia Well, you know, it's incurable I guess I was there for so many years my whole life until six years ago. I mean, I'll just crack me up uh 13 appealing to the concept of prophetic foreshortening In eschatology is to be rejected as contrived hermeneutics false 114 and 119 are places where hukama appeals to it Some have objected to his treatment of certain matters With which they take issue with him and said and it's fair Why couldn't he apply the principle to this matter? Well, it's due to other considerations in his own thought But he is right I think we could demonstrate from the way the New Testament uses the old that at least at times the Bible presents fulfillment in terms of prophetic foreshortening which opens the door to our understanding as yet Unfulfilled prophecies in the same way. So it's not contrived. It seems to be biblical at least in principle As to when to invoke it and when not that's trickier But it is I would say an example of the Bible's own hermeneutic 14 Paul did not figure on a centuries-long continuing development of the present world order True page 123. Does this mean hukama thinks there are errors in the Bible? No No, it doesn't he's just trying to get inside of Paul's mind This could be accurate. I could see somebody concluding otherwise but We don't have to think that the biblical writers were omniscient The God who spoke through them was but they certainly had minds Just as every other human being since the fall filled with truth and error So our claim is not that they had no error in their minds It is that they wrote no error and not even in their whole lives But they wrote no error when God led them to make their contribution to holy writ That's all we're claiming If you could have talked to Mrs. Paul she would have told you he wasn't infallible at home We say there was no Mrs. Paul. Well maybe not but I wonder who made those fish sticks then oh a terrible terrible 15 tell me how 15 reads in yours

I can't hear you. Oh, I have corrected this one the signs of the times pertain exclusively to Christ's second coming Great the answer is false page 130 at one time this one read the signs of the times pertain Exclusively to the end time and that was ambiguous you see people said the end time means the time in between the Cummings of Christ That's what you told us so we got it straight in that now the signs of the times pertain exclusively to Christ's second coming it's false of course page 130 16 Romans 1126 and so all Israel will be saved Refers to a great conversion of Jews in the last days According to hukama false He accepts his third view which is the total number of Jews between the advance 140 141 check that out carefully Remember it's according to hukama and not according to you or me 17 the Roman general Titus Was a type of the antichrist who is to come true page 156 according to hukama This answers somebody's question from last time. Could we speak of New Testament types? Well according to at least one expert on biblical prophecy hukama we should so speak 18 a study of the New Testament words used for the second coming Provides a good argument for a two-stage second coming false page 165. I might say false 165 That part of the progress of dispensationism from Unmodified to modified or progressive dispensationism has been this very point They have given up the words being technical terms for either the rapture or the second coming to earth By and large you probably would find some pastors who still would hold on to that but The people at the seminaries the teachers have given it up The great majority have that that for sure 19 Christ second coming is to be invisible false 171

19 false 171 20 Our millennialists Hold that the world eventually is to be Christianized false 175 it is post millennialists 21 the pre millennial interpretation of revelation 20 is a theological anomaly true page 186 according to hukama You may indeed take issue with him on that one And you are at liberty to do so 22 According to dispensational eschatology there will be the restoration of animal sacrifices during the millennium true page 191 This seems impossible for hukama based upon the epistle to the Hebrews. I agree I have to agree 23 too often our millennial theologians have failed to keep the new earth in mind When interpreting Old Testament prophecy true page 205 and 206 It is nice to see The reformed admitting that there's a progressive reform theology that is It's easy to throw sticks and stones at the dispensation list and say well. I'm glad they're correcting their errors Well, you know, you point the finger the thumb comes back to you well Have reformed theologians made any progress or everything been perfect since the time of Calvin The answer is every theological system develops Even believing ones do and hopefully they perfect That is they they reject errors here is it i would consider a genuine advance a genuine point of progress bringing the different traditions closer together by the way This satisfies some of the pre-millennial yearning for a fulfillment of God's promises on the earth. I would think I appreciate 23 being answered in as true by hukama 205 206 24 dispensational teaching about the parenthesis church is not supported by scripture true page 214 This likewise has been abandoned by some progressive dispensationalists you say well then what is dispensationalism anymore? It's a very good question on the very cutting edge of it those who are just pushing The envelope I cannot answer the question. I was astounded to hear the the Prime mover in the progressive dispensational camp Craig blazing give a lecture at the last annual ETS meeting The room was just had to open to a three rooms 100 people maybe more it was incredible the interest And when he was all done Somebody asked him a question that was right on the tip of my tongue Doctor blazing What then provides continuity in the different epics in the different Generations of dispensational teaching his answer was unbelievable He said, you know, what is the distinguishing mark of dispensation? He said something like Taking the Bible seriously and seeking to build one theology on the Bible That's no distinctive that is one of the Protestant principles And that's just being a Bible believing Christian If that is so then I think dispensationalism just died It has no more. I mean that's that's no distinctive whatsoever That was remarkable to me others would disagree But that's where the very leading edge of it is going. I don't know where it's going to end up I applaud their willingness to reform their theology based upon the Bible. I applaud it. It's wonderful I don't think all will go to those exact conclusions and maybe that's not his final conclusion either 25 the binding of Satan described in Revelation 20 refers to the devil's inability to prevent the spread of the gospel in the current age True to 28 to 29 all students of prophecy are not persuaded by this interpretation 26 the words they came to life and reign with Christ a thousand years Revelation 24 refer to a literal physical resurrection from the dead false 233 they refer to the souls of believers Living and reigning with Christ in heaven The souls of deceased believers living and reigning with Christ in heaven Likewise To pre-millennial interpreters this looks like the Achilles heel of the omelennial exposition of Revelation 20 It's it does seem to mean no matter what view one adopts problems remain And I would think this is one of the prime areas in which Christians ought to study emphasize what's clear take positions beyond that But then not go hunting Uh with the their fellow believers being the targets really I think we ought to be gracious and continue studying Not make these some of these things the test of fellowship 27 the resurrection of believers and unbelievers will occur together true page 240 true page 240 28 the resurrection is body is immaterial and non physical true of course Just seeing if you're listening I like to see those mouths open up false page 250 So what does it mean spiritual body first Corinthians 15 We will talk about that in a minute Resurrection body is immaterial and non physical false Or as the teenagers say not page 250 29 I usually give you one zinger I was trying to figure out the best place to do it that may not have been it 29 the outstanding purpose of the final judgment Will be to meet out rewards and punishments false 254 false page 254 the outstanding purpose that's one of the subsidiary purposes the outstanding one has to do with God To display God's sovereignty and glory And I would suggest even more than that will be back there tonight again as well 30 The work of judging will be Christ's final exaltation and highest triumph true page 256 in the middle right Will be set on the throne Error will be put on the scaffold And wrongs will be righted And here The Savior who was judged think of it by a human judge And condemned by mankind think of it the injustice of that one Will himself be the judge of all the earth He will be exalted in that day number 30 is true 256 In the middle in fact 31 Believer sins will be revealed in the judgment as forgiven True 259 32 Annihilationism is compatible with biblical doctrine and I will not make a joke out of this one false 266 and following his treatment is Good I would say it's not great, but I say that after devoting myself to studying that those issues for a couple of years In terms of his of all the things he covers it's an outstanding book And it's a great place to start on any of the topics he covers You could go beyond that, but it's a great place to start His footnotes are a place Are pointers in the direction of how to go beyond it 32 is false page 266 and following 33 the doctrine of hell should add urgency to our evangelism amen true 273 33 is true 273 34 going to heaven Is the final destiny of believers false page 274 it is being resurrected Having one's soul and body reunited if one has passed away And living with God on the new earth forever and ever it is not The intermediate state existence as disembodied spirits 35 Abraham looked forward to the new earth True page 278. I don't deny it, but I would add adverbs like dimly and from afar I don't see how you can deny it. He who says it says almost that kind of language He looked forward to that city, you know whose builder and maker was God So he had and he had some kind of a hope like that and yet it was an Old Testament View that since God was God there was more to Abraham's blessing than Canaan That his chief reward as God told him early on was God himself 36 the new earth will be totally other than this present one False page 28 zero that matter is debated And I will sketch out the debate later tonight. Okay, we don't have a we don't have time for every little question You might want to ask from the book, but first of all questions concerning the quiz Wow, yes Okay If you answered 34 true Okay, here's the thing The understanding of heaven here is intermediate state heaven if you took that to mean new heaven And that's why you put true. I leave you on your honor You have it. So give yourself credit now seriously give yourself credit Understand if you flat out missed it didn't think of that well you don't get credit But I want to be fair Believe me it is hard to make perfectly on it. It is I'll say it better. It is impossible to make Perfectly unambiguous true and false questions May I comfort you with these comforting words May it be so on the whole semester's work that for everyone you knew and got wrong because of my ambiguous questions There's an equal number of those that you really didn't know but got right because of my ambiguous questions May it be so and I want to say thank you for Not you filled out your evaluations Thank you for your patients It would be better if I gave you essays all the time, okay? I can't grade all those essays and just can't Uh, remind me to say something about make up a final exam in the content in that regard. Yes Yes, so but here's the thing It's not a last day's thing It's the bringing to salvation throughout history of the total number of the elect from among the Jews What you read says Interpretation three is distinct from interpretation two which understands Israel to mean spiritual Israel Jew and Gentile believers Number three means that Israel means Israel ethnically But it what makes this when false is not that it is in the last days Understood as the last last days and not the sum total of the elect Jews or believing Jews in between the Cummings It gets complicated after a while. Yes, sir Okay early on in the book He talked about from the from the vantage point of the Old Testament, okay? Things in the New Testament are fulfilled already and some are still to be fulfilled not yet Well, where would the New Testament put the weight of emphasis there Decidedly he says on the fulfillment motif that is since the Savior has come the great Predictions have been fulfilled and in their fulfillment There and the words of Jesus himself There's a pointing to a greater fulfillment But that's the sense Okay, it's not saying if there's nothing else to be fulfilled But the great event was the coming of the Redeemer Hey, man, he has come Yes, the kingdom of God has come Now it's it is here in spiritual form it came in the person of the king and It's final outworking will be spiritual slash physical And that awaits resurrection of the dead but the owner reason that's a surety Is that God has invaded human history in the person of his son So it's a matter of perspective. It is an important point. Yes sir 256 in the middle isn't it a quotation? It's a quotation Yes, the question is number 30 and I pointed number 30 the work of judging will be Christ the final exultation and highest triumph The student says I agree with the first part but the second part highest triumph seems awful strong We ought to reserve that language for his resurrection from the dead The only reason that number 30 is true is because hukama says so quoting the middle of 256 the work of judging more over will be Christ's final exultation and highest triumph I understand what you're saying But according to hukama it certainly is true He would say that's the result of his own resurrection and conquest of death. You could argue either ways either way I wasn't trying this Split hairs as Unfortunately you thought I was and I can I can't understand how you'd ever think I would do that other questions on the quiz Then licking your wounds. I hope you did well This was a big book a lot of work. I appreciate your work. I'll tell you what 36 questions give me Give me a number right over 35 which means I just gave you one So however many let's say you miss three Don't subtract three from 36 subtract three from 30 That's wrong that's wrong Give me a 36 Oh boy Give me a 35 right there and up on top give me 36 minus the number of your errors That'll give you a point right any mathematicians in the group So if you missed one here we go if you missed one 36 minus one is 35

And your grade is 35 over 35 100 even though you missed one get it however many you missed subtract from 36 And then put that over the denominator of 35 In other words, I'm giving you a freebie It's the least I can do

No, I'll thanks for more questions about the book. I would ask this. Please don't split hairs Please ask Things that others might be asking. Go ahead try it stuff Okay, a question is It was prompted by number 12 on the test Uh talk about the intermediate state. These are the purgatory and make distinctions and so forth specifics understand Did you read my final chapter for tonight? In hell on trial Because I do address the question about purgatory there in some detail can that didn't we read didn't you read the last chapter to conclusion? Uh Did you read the have a chance to read that yourself? Because I tried to address uh purgatory in that final chapter It was one of three nagging questions three persistent questions that I was asked uh the Martin Luther when he posted his thesis did not reject purgatory Okay, but as he It's a long story as he was led in public debate and forced into putting scripture over a council of the church and then as he began to then Do more and more reforming work studying the scriptures and evaluating Roman Catholic teaching on the basing on the script basis of the scriptures He came to reject the so-called third place in between heaven and hell which is purgatory Which is much more than a mere intermediate state It is a place according to Roman Catholic theology where sins are purged That is only absolute saints go immediately at death to heaven almost everybody goes to this Part place of purging And uh it is little known but Vatican II did not strike purgatory from the books. Maybe they deemphasized it Many Roman Catholics today don't believe in purgatory, but they're not being very faithful Catholics They really don't have the option to pick and choose uh concerning what they believe The difference the reformer said no that is a false hope It is the meaning to the atonement of Christ and it gives a false hope God wants us to have assurance of heaven Understood as the intermediate state in this life So Maybe out that'll suffice for a nutshell thumb nail sketch Other big questions from the book

I'm going to put on this one and just summarize it for the benefit of our students are taking the course by videotape uh a student expressed appreciation for hukuma's presentation of the progressive parallelism and revelation and mentioned that Hukuma said it's not without its problems The meaning is in making all that in interpreting all the details of revelation in that light I refer you to some of the substantial commentaries on revelation This question is really beyond our scope. Let me ask you to hand in Your quizzes with the number correct The number wrong subtracted from 36 Given overtop of 35 You in case you're mixed up at the top of the paper put down how many wrong that'll help us For some of you mighty mathematicians