<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Deng Nhial Deng Nhial

Listening to Exvangelicals

September 9, 2021
0:000:00

Anne Friedman was the main art dealer for a gallery in New York City called Notelers and she had a woman walk in one day with a very believable understandable story about how her father or ex-husband I can't remember exactly all the details but had acquired all these these artworks throughout his life and now he was dead and so she was wanting to sell them off and Anne who was one of the nationwide experts in art began auctioning off these pieces of art for millions of dollars and as she did that over a period of years evidence began to come in as they were fake and Anne insisted they were real and more evidence came in and her friends in the art world started talking to her and she doubled down I'm right these are real they are genuine until the evidence became irrefutable and she ended up losing her job and the art the gallery which is one more older respected ones in New York had to close and and there's a movie about it called Made You Look and in it they quote this book called the Confidence Game and the writer of the Confidence Game says this if you really believed a con he really believed it as the evidence comes in against you you are more likely to double down it's psychologically easier to to maintain your perception of the world rather than to take the new evidence that no longer matches it it is psychologically easier to double down and insist on something that the evidence says is wrong then it is to change what you've already believed and and put your reputation on that that's a scary thing it would be easier I wish you know the the psychologist said just said that and and strange and weird and different and she has a mental illness but we don't have to worry about that but instead she said no we all have that tendency we all have this tendency to assume that we are right about things that we believe for a long time I use that to open up because this week this month we're talking about why people have left the church and we're kind of been zeroing in on this week is the week that we're going to listen to not not necessarily speak to I'll do a little bit of that but but primarily listen to the claims of those who called themselves X van jellic people who are leaving now this is a group that's in the millions by now people who have grown up in evangelical churches and left and most of the articles that are written about them don't take them seriously call them you know irresponsible children who are just rebelling or they just want to go off and have sex and so they want to abandon the church and I want to listen to what one of them says she is a chaplain her name is Caitlin Stout and she wrote a friend asked the other day what percentage of people I went to youth group with who deconstructed and what percentage remained evangelical and I thought about it I realized that for the most part it was the kids who took their faith the most seriously who eventually walked away those of us who tearfully promised that we would follow Jesus anywhere eventually followed him out the door we learned exactly what it meant to work out our faith with fear and trembling they told us to read the Bible and take it seriously and then they mocked us for becoming social justice warriors the people who took it seriously I'm not talking about the celebrities people who are getting you know millions of likes on Facebook and making tons of money from publicly denouncing their faith there's a lot of them too but I think that has more to do is just the price of fame but I'm talking about the people who grew up in the church who loved it and were hurt by it and who have left I think we need to listen to them and I think today is the day to do that to open up ourselves to the possibility that maybe our positions and our traditions and our attitudes think that we hold dear are unnecessary extra biblical and unhealthy and so before we kind of dive into those critiques and try to respond I want us to read two passages of scripture together one is are the words of Jesus okay you can listen to him right and the other one the fascinating account of the Apostle Paul who is a new Apostle on the block unheard of who confronted the Apostle Peter after 15 years of Peter being the leading disciple the pillar of the church the Apostle Paul confronted him let's stand and read these words together first from Mark chapter 7 and the Pharisees in the scribes asked him that's Jesus why do your disciples not walk according to the tradition of the elders but eat with defiled hands and he said to them well did Isaiah prophesied you hypocrites as it is written this people honors me with their lips but their heart is far from me in vain do they worship me teaching as doctrine the commandments of men you leave the commandment of God and hold to the tradition of men then Galatians from the Apostle Paul Seifus's Peter's other name is the name that Paul used but when Seifus came to Antioch I opposed him to his face because he stood condemned for before certain men came from James he was eating with the Gentiles but when they came he drew back and separated himself fearing the circumcision party and the rest of the Jews acted hypocritically right along with him so that even Barmas was led astray by their hypocrisy when I saw that their conduct was not in step with the truth of the gospel I said to Seifus before them all if you though a Jew live like a Gentile and not like a Jew how can you force the Gentiles to live like Jews we are cells are Jews by birth not Gentile centers yet we know that a person is not justified by the works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ so we also have believed in Christ Jesus in order to be justified by faith in Christ and not by works of the law because by works of the law no one will be justified that's why the reading of God's word all men are like grass and all of his glory like all of our glory like the flowers in the field the grass withers the flowers fall but not guys were God's word stands forever you may be seated you teach as doctrines of God the command the traditions of men Peter you're not walking in line with the gospel that's a fascinating review isn't it he doesn't say you sin we love this defense right show me in the Bible where it says I can't eat with the Jews show me in the Bible where it says I have to eat with Gentiles I'm gonna stop you right there buddy what you're doing is not in line with the gospel you're not walking in step with the gospel it's a higher calling it's a higher calling what what you're doing people says is it's you're betraying the truth of Jesus by your actions the truth of Jesus is that we are all centers gathered together is one body loved in him justified in him nobody's more justified than anybody else you're not ahead of the Gentile centers we're all together we are new creations in Christ but by by rejecting this one party by refusing to be associated with them you're communicating to them that they're less than you that's not in line with the gospel you know that in the X-Fan Jalicles I think you know don't I'm not one obviously and I'm not encouraging you to be one and I've talked to them last week you can go back and listen to it on tape if you still have one of those but I do think they're saying some things we need to listen to we don't need to double down on our cons we don't need to double down on the things that that we've always assumed were true we need to listen to them and ask ourselves are we living in line with the gospel our standard is not that we should keep doing what we've always done our standard is the gospel is our our our actions reflecting the truth of it so let's just kind of go through I've been polling people I've been reading X-Fan Jalicles and I don't want to ask ourselves that this question where are they right what do we need to we how do we need to repent and the first thing that is always at the top of everybody's list when you ask why did you leave the church in one way or another they answer is the people there weren't nice to me now that comes out in different terms in different ways sometimes it's simple things like they didn't speak to me they basically did what Peter's doing here they made it clear that I didn't really belong there but in some way or other they demonstrated hypocrisy you know what hypocrisy is right hypocrisy is acting it's wearing a huge mask it comes from the days of Greek theater when they didn't have you know audio equipment sound equipment and so to communicate who were the good guys and who are the bad guys they were these enormous masks so you can see from the balcony who the bad guys were who the good guys were and and from that we get this word hypocrite wearing a mask and we need to ask ourselves a question are we hypocrites are we acting like something we're not answers yes some agree I think you want me to be a little bit don't you I mean you know let's just let's just be honest we're gonna talk here okay it's gonna get uncomfortable what's gonna get better do you really want the truth about me you know the truth about me I got sores in my mouth and they bother me and it really hurts my back is hurting you know the truth about me for the last two years I've been struggling with the depressions made me want to quit my job every week you know the truth about me I've gained 20 pounds because I've been dealing with my depression by peanut butter you want to know the truth about me every time I think I'm getting better something else seems to happen and make you feel like I'm hanging on that right then for us sometimes I'm tired of being sad you want to know the rest of the truth about me I believe that Jesus Christ was raised from the dead and I believe in hope is real even when I don't feel it and I believe in joy and in peace and in forgiveness and in love both of those things are true about me and yes when I walk into this church I choose to project the second one because I think that's what you need and the truth of matter is I'm not everything that I want to be but I'm becoming it the Holy Spirit is in me and he is making me better I believe that and I can trust him for that and yes that the typical road is to cover up and pretend and get angry with anybody who would be an outlier who might possibly make it obvious that I'm not really what I am I don't think that's hypocrisy though I think it is just struggling with my son and I think I'm getting better now I'm not denying there are true hypocrites in the church and and if you're not familiar with this body that we called believers you need to know that Jesus told us there would always be two kinds of people right there together and that you wouldn't even be able to tell the difference between them until they were old and begin to mature and produce fruit and so yes there are people who are in the church because it is a powerful place to be and it makes you feel good to think God is on your side and everything about them is fake and wrong and we just don't know who they are until the fruit begins to reveal itself but that's not who we are that's not who we are so yes I'm sorry if sometimes when you have gotten too close to me I'm sorry if the truth has come out and you get the porcupine clues I wish it weren't real and along for the day when those cools were gone I'm sorry sorry for those I've hurt I really am can't apologize if you won't tell me but I'm sorry that's the first thing and main thing the primary thing that comes up from people who've left the church you know second thing that you hear a lot is is to talk about celebrity pastors and and how they they fall and when they commit sins that were so much more likely to believe them than we are to believe those who are pointing to their sin and and we're likely to call the people who are who are pointing out the failures of these men and women we're likely to call them slanderers and gossips and we want to hush them up and and keep these celebrities on a pedestal and we completely ignore their sins of pride and vanity and greed and until it becomes something sexual that we can't cover up we we worship them basically and then once they do their sins do become public we we wash them away until like they never happens and that's true yeah we do that that's always been true it was true King David you remember what Nathan said to King David when he came and confirmed him over his sin he said you have given occasion for the Gentiles to blaspheme me and we should have learned from there but we haven't and we always want champions to kind of project that life that we wish we had and we need to stop having celebrities he's not here so I can talk about him you know I have a son is a great singer and he's very charismatic and he would be a great worship leader one day probably be a great worship leader now but I'm not letting him on this stage because I know what being on the stage does to you it's not safe if you're popular for being a Christian it's pretty easy for your fame to go way further than your spiritual gravitas is prepared for and we need to stop having celebrities and they hurt people it really do you we're sorry next these are gonna get harder as they go on and probably the number one issue with those who are being public beyond just the things that personally happened to them Christianity today kind of put this under the broad topic of the things we do to women true we've made by and large evangelical community has created an image of what the ideal woman looks like and she is married by the time she's 22 and she has four kids by the time she's 30 and she stays home and dedicates every minute to those kids and she loves it and she meets her husband's sexual needs however he wants them to be met and she loves it is that you and and in doing that and projecting that image what we have done is we have hurt we badly hurt people who've been are single people who don't have children are unable to have children and people who get terribly depressed and sad when they're at home all day with their kids and they don't they're having the life that they thought was going to make them so happy and it's not now some of you had that life and you make you happy and I am delighted for that I'm very thankful for that but it's not the biblical image of the ideal woman it's not the the probably 31 woman works just job women done the women throughout the Bible have jobs and some of them are single and some of them are married and some of them have children and some of them don't and some of them are more sexually active or sexually whatever then their husband and some of them aren't and some of them don't like it at all and some of them have been hurt sexually in their past and it's difficult and all these people have been made these sweet sisters in Christ have been made to feel less than less than what they were they ought to feel they've been made to feel imperfect and Christ some have been ostracized by further divorces when they're divorcing people who needed to be divorced we have created treated them with shame made them feel ashamed and like failures and we've implied by our actions and this is this is a hard one it's undeniable that the Bible had roles and they're different from any women we can't deny that those roles I believe are linked into are locked into rooted in the Trinity whether son is 100% equal with the father and you are not a Christian if you deny that he is not in any way subordinate he's not a voluntarily subordinate himself but he's not in any way less than he's not in any way and instead of linking our what the Bible says about the the headship of men in the house in the family and in the church and in that voluntary submission we have locked it into creation somehow so that we believe we project whether you believe it or not we have projected that women were not as we're not equal when I was intelligent when I was emotionally mature we're not something yeah and we were wrong and we need to repent of that period I'm sorry I'm learning somebody who achieved the stature of four foot eight by the end of junior high I know how it feels to be made subordinate and to be dismissed as someone who went to Vanderbilt University with airbrush t-shirts and a red neck accents I never have lost I know how it feels to be dismissed and I know that some of you sisters have felt that on an infinitely higher degree and I'm sorry closely linked to that is we talked about this a little bit last week is a purity culture that absolutely 100% dealt with all kinds of sexualist sin with shame and guilt and a shame and guilt that has overwhelmed people they they receive the heaping dose of it as teenagers and they have never been able to fully get out from under that so that even as adults their intimate lives are crippled by the shame and guilt and we kind of made you know sexual sin into the one sin the unforgivable sin we should have done that it was hard we were scared I was youth minister and I did this one out so many things I'm kind of apologizing for as a representative of the greater evangelical church but I flat did this one and to everybody who was one of my former students I'm sorry I was scared it's not good to pastor people out of fear and if I made you feel ashamed or made you feel like you were a bad person because of the desires for intimacy that you have I am sorry next one that comes up in testimony after testimony of why people have left the evangelical church is that they feel like evangelicals have confused political power and cultural influence with the calling of Christ and because again because white men are basically the most powerful people in culture we've kind of been more worried about maintaining that position of power than we are about elevating the weak and the poor and the outcast and the marginalized and so you see accusations that are the wall you see these kind of accusations a lot you know evangelicals care more about their politicians than they do about the poor and you care more about winning elections than you do about feeding the homeless that was hard because there's some truth to it but let me tell you why I think it's true it's just easier to win an election it's easier it's easier to feel like you're really doing something to change the culture when you're winning an election what's hard is elevating the poor it's hard it was tried you know we found it hard and we just kind of gravitate toward what's easier that was wrong we shouldn't and we shouldn't care about what's going on the headlines nearly as much as we care about the that invisible grace that goes into to tell people that you are important and to tell them that Jesus Christ has died for you and and you have hope in the resurrection he's raised for you and you are new life that's that's that's where we ought to be and we know that but it's difficult I mean we had I had a guy come live with me a few years ago one person you know he he was out of prison and he showed up with all the tattoos and we I mean we just threw ourselves in the helping him and it took everything that I had you know and and Glenn senior will come by the house every morning at 730 to drive into work because his work was all the way in a wasa and gas was $4 gallon and and and go back out and pick him up every day and and just group a family after family after family and the church had to join in for one person and you know it failed pretty much he ended up going back to jail going back to his former life going back to jail and I think I actually think the Lord's recently is blessing him now and elevating him now but it was just so difficult for one person it's hard very closely related that's the issue of racism and the event of church is often condemned for not caring about it or not doing anything about it and while it is absolutely true that we have failed to discipline and excommunicate people in our midst for the racism which we should I don't know single case where it's happened but we should because it is definitely living a life that is out of line with the gospel but for the I don't think that by any stretch is the majority of of believers in the church I think most of us just kind of feel overwhelmed by that problem you know I think everyone else we if we could flip a switch and erase 300 years of racial evil we would flip it more overwhelmed by the problem and it's it's difficult it's difficult to address a school system that's been broken absolutely broken 50 years ago by the way we tried to deal with the segregation and if I could flip a switch and fix that I would but maybe we don't talk about it enough it's true another big issue that comes up is the treatment of people who are sexually dysfunctional or non-normative and it's true that people who struggle with their gender or with their sexuality make most the typical evangelical very uncomfortable and we talked about this last week our tendency to treat them as enemies and that's wrong and for victims of sexual abuse I just I would definitely say as a young minister I didn't deal with that well I just didn't know what to do now it's called flat footed and ignorant in my innocence and naivete victim-shaming I don't think I went that far but some naiv I'm sorry and again I've hurt you I'm desperately sorry and I think there's you know the the question as we listen to the accusations of ex-vanjalicals and frankly have to nod our heads and go you know that one's a hundred percent right or ninety percent right or sixty-three percent wherever you're going to it I think there's different you know there's different ways we have to respond and one way to respond is to write them off as silly and young people who are just rebelling and I don't think that's fair or wise I don't think that's I think that's what Peter could have done with Paul I'm the head of apostle I don't listen to you I don't think he did and I think for us who admit that I we're at least wrong on some of these things that what we have to do is do exactly what James tells us to do we weep and we mourn and we humble ourselves in the sight of the Lord and we trust him to lift us off and we're not going to defend ourselves we're not going to double down on on the ways that we've acted and the things that we've said and things we didn't say when we should have we're just going to say Father forgive us forgive us our deaths as we forgive our daughters and we're gonna ask people to forgive us and we're going to thank them for showing us the sins that we did not see and we're going to trust Christ in him we are new creations and the old is gone and we can be better than this and we're going to be better than this because the Holy Spirit is real and he is not abandoning his church and we're going to trust that and we're going to be willing to lay that stuff down and be made new and we're going to be willing to die to all that power and be made new so that we can humbly come alongside instead of ruling from the top and now to my ex-vanjellical brothers and sisters I just say this at some point you have to stop defining yourself by what you're not you're not evangelical okay we get it and we're not saying come back to the church and hurt you I wouldn't say that but I am saying please come be part of Christ church somewhere and show us how to do it better we're willing to listen and the invitation is for all don't you don't want to live this life of bitterness and anger and die in that rage you don't want to let your anger ruin you I'm asking you humble yourself and you'll be exalted there's a different way there's a different way than just getting angry and feeding that anger every day the way of forgiveness is hard and I'm not again I don't want you to endanger yourself by going back to abusive places but we're here on our knees asking the Lord forgive us and we would like for you to come be with us and to be beside us please pray with me Father in heaven we all need to lay our self righteousness down this heart but what you're making us into is so much more beautiful than what we've been we pray that you would make us new father we long for the day when we are one thing we're not two different things fighting it out to see who's going to show his face today but we are one thing we are the very image of your glorified son and we pray that you would we would believe you when you say the way to the way to that is the way down it's the humbling yourselves in the side of the Lord and trusting you to exalt us if father we want to do that would you enable us to do that would you receive us we pray in Jesus name amen have a seat and talk a little bit and then we'll be done so you know what that's over all right we're going to do it again it won't be as good next time y'all know this first sermon is always the best you get the fresh one they get the leftovers all right I only have a few questions today love you too all right in light of your comment about the hardness of serving the poor what is the way forward for R.O.P.C. to press into these challenges how are we seeking to combat our tendency to gravitate toward what is easy I mean part of it's just we're gonna keep stumbling forward together and messing up and doing it wrong and we're gonna keep trying we're gonna keep trying we do rely on people who know what they're doing and so to the two ministries that we support probably most aggressively of any of our ministries and any of our missions actually the three I just thought another one one is City of Hope which is a ministry to the homeless here in town and it's just need based honestly I think I go back and forth about it but ultimately I think they're being biblical they're not necessarily they don't put qualifications on getting their help you need something we'll give it to you I think that's the way Jesus would have us to do it and I love that ministry another one is crossover crossover community impact which is a ministry that's really dedicated itself to one particular community in North Tulsa and elevating it with us and in some ways they're shining example both of great ministry to the poor and of how hard it is I mean several the most gifted people I know including two families from our church that I missed desperately are just dedicated their entire life to it it's a great ministry I'm very thankful for it and then ministering to the poor in an international sense through compassionate international which is a good time to remind you that compassion Sunday is only three weeks away and and we are well you are welcome to come help and lead with that if you want to come up with something new I won't say no all right as gospel believing Christians how then do we live in a world where the church appears to be divided and confused about what doctors hold on to for example many mainstream Christian churches believe different things about gender sexuality the role of women etc I can't control what other people do we're going to we are going to do what we think the Bible commands us to do and we're going to do it as hard as we can as good as we can and we might be wrong you know make it to heaven and look around it's just filled with liberal of his companions and I think bang it and it may not be you know we may not get to heaven at all and be nothing but other denominations that we weren't gonna go but we're going we're going I just don't mean that I don't mean that callously and I want to listen to what other people are saying and evaluate it against the Bible and against history and against our particular denominations brand but at the end of the day I can't be paralyzed or obsessed about what other people think or do and that goes both for other churches and for people outside the church the Apostle Paul said it very well imagine that I was dumping saying first Corinthians 5 he said what if I what if I had to do with unbelievers this is not my concern and and that's not necessarily fair one-for-one transition to other you know churches but kind of is I just can't I can't assess about what other churches are doing I just have to do it I believe the Lord's calling we have to be we believe the Lord is calling ourselves to do just like this sermon right I mean it's not like I have any position to apologize for the entirety of American evangelicalism I don't think I have that I don't think that you know every church in the country is gonna look at this sermon and go yeah but he said you know we just have to do what we do and that's the way to mental health by the way you personally been vulnerable on us this one I need somebody to read these for me thank you I'm a practical person would like to know from you the elders perspective what we as R O P C church community need to acknowledge confess and change of anything and how can we overcome it together improve on living out the gospel to the outside community I think everything that I you know brought up is is worthy of a consideration on those things and and we are trying to figure it out it's hard we all have our own stuff right and so I mean that whole list I wasn't kind of trying to do that just as my personal diary I mean I think you know the women's roles something where we're pushing towards with a new kind of not new but an enhanced vision of the women's care team and trying to do ministry well there and supporting the the ministries to the poor that we've already talked about and those are just things we need to be serious about and do so how do we approach those who double down with criticism exposed you know I'm sorry I read the question well how do you recommend we approach our brothers and sisters who double down with these kinds of criticisms posed by ex-van jellicles to defend themselves rather than listening I think if the last two years it's convinced me of anything is that you can't convince anybody else of anything and honestly I just kind of quit trying completely quit trying I think if somebody you know who's like number one rule of ministry for me is I don't answer any questions not being asked and so for me to kind of go and publicly go I'm gonna change everyone's mind today you know give me Facebook you're all dumb yeah that doesn't work and so don't do that and please don't do that if you're a known member of our church but you know someone comes to me and says you know do you think these ex-van jellicles having good points or if someone comes to me and says you know help me with such a job talk your ear off but if you're if they're just kind of you know spouting forth their wisdom on the golf course I just let them maybe that's cowardice I don't know I'm not good at confrontation I usually wait until it's way too late and then blow up and everybody's really happy I did for those who are deeply hurting and hiding what can church do what can hurtings people do I think we make ourselves vulnerable I try to do that we make ourselves into as receptive of a place as possible we don't victim shame we don't tell them less you know you need to get over that by now and and and we as a church you know have ministries available we we have a ministry called Plumline that we support we send a lot of people to I will say this if you're hurting take responsibility for your mental health don't just assume that you're gonna get better one day sometimes that works I guess but and for me I needed somebody to talk through my life with someone with a wisdom who could actually not just go that sounds bad but actually talk back and give me some steps and I want to encourage you to find out as well and we will help you and if it's something beyond what we think Plumline can do we will be glad to recommend resources and help pay for those as well last one how do we keep from falling into despair the great question how do we keep from falling into despair about all the church failings at least in action and moving forward in hope and that's that's the reason why we come together to worship every week to remind ourselves we do not worship a dead God but a living God who is alive in the church and who has promised us that ultimately he's gonna make all things right and his kingdom is going to come and we we we would never believe that on our own if you think that you can separate yourself from everybody else in the world who believes in the resurrection and maintain your faith in the resurrection I'm just gonna tell you you won't you need to be surrounded by people who also believe it and that's a great segue it's a next week we're gonna start a series on Revelation looking at the different pictures of Jesus in that book which I hope will be very hopeful for us all please stand for