<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Deng Nhial Deng Nhial

Review of a Review

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Father, we thank you for your truth. We thank you that you have revealed yourself to us in your Word and spoken to us. We thank you too for the way you reveal yourself in creation, that you haven't left the human race without a witness, but everywhere there is testimony to yourself. We pray Father, as we think about these things and how to speak to people, that you will teach us in Jesus' name. We have got, I think, to point number four in my summary of the point Shaffer makes here, in this little article, a review of a review. I was discussing how the unbeliever is caught in tension. That brings us to point number five, but as we think about the tension, Shaffer makes the point that God is constantly confronting the unbeliever with this tension, with this inconsistency. The unbeliever has developed his system, his worldview, his set of beliefs about himself, about the world, about his life. And all the time, he is confronted by God with the actual world that God has made. Remember my two circles, which the person is living in between. And perhaps I'll draw them again in a moment or two. But he's constantly confronted with God's testimony of himself. You can think of Paul's statement in Romans chapter one, verse 18, where Paul says that ever since the creation of the world, the eternal power and divine nature of God have been clearly seen in what has been made, and that men are suppressing the truth and unrighteousness. And I've heard Shaffer appealing to this passage over and over again, using the image that God is constantly confronting the unbeliever with evidence from the universe, from his own nature, and the unbeliever is constantly pushing it down, he's suppressing it, he's holding it down in his heart. So there is this, he's constantly being driven by the evidence to become aware of the inconsistency, to become aware of the tension, but he's pushing that down in unrighteousness. That was Shaffer understood, those words of Paul there in Romans one, or you can think of Paul's statement in Acts 1727, in the Sermon on Mars Hill, where Paul says to the people there on the Ariopagus, that God is not far from every one of us, in him we live and move and have our being, so that every unbeliever is constantly surrounded by the testimony of God, all the time, and Paul again in Acts 1417, says the same thing in the situation where he's trying to stop the people sacrificing to himself and to Barnabas, he says God has not left himself without a testimony, without a witness, but he provides for us and so on. So that this is Shaffer's fifth point then, God is constantly confronting the unbeliever with the tension, with what Shaffer calls the illogicality in his own life. If you look at page 9, the third page of this little review, you'll see at the top there, what Shaffer says this, he says many look at the beauty of the moon at night and do not want your medication, they're looking at, they see the splendor of creation, and they don't want what their own view leads them to, which is that the world is ultimately meaningless or rational, they fall in love and they don't want it to end in blackness, they experience the reality of love in their own life, which is a part of the world that God has made, and they don't want it to end in just nothingness, which on their view of reality it will, they'll die and there won't be any more love, the human race will finish and there won't be any more love for anybody, it will all be gone, it will have all been worthless in the end. Or they fear to die, they face death and in their world view, that's what should naturally come to a human being who's just a developed animal, but they fear death and they feel they ought not to die, there's something in them which tells them that man wasn't made to die, and so Shaffer uses these three illustrations of the way God himself is constantly confronting the unbeliever with the tension, with the illogicality between his own understanding and the way things are in the world that God has made, let me draw that image for you again, again I apologize for my drawing, but we have our unbeliever really caught between two worlds, we may say that if you like he's turned his face this way into his own world which he has developed, but all the time he's actually living in the world that God has made, he's really caught between those two worlds and God himself is constantly witnessing to him of that tension and he says here God can and does use these illogical things in unsaved men to bring some of them to salvation, now later on Shaffer stopped using the word illogical there, he tended to use the word inconsistent more rather than illogical, but at this early stage he's using the word illogical to speak about this tension, so that's the fifth point, that brings us to point number six, if God uses these means to save his elect, so may we use them and pray that God will use these things and we'll use our appealing to them in our preaching and in our apologetics, in fact Shaffer says that we can use whatever is appropriate for the person, now this is important again because he's saying that the person you're talking to is more important than the system of apologetics that you develop because each person you meet is in a different situation, so you look there again on page nine, on the last page of this little review, he says to the extent that the individual is illogical this is halfway down the first column, we have a point of contact, therefore to a certain type we preach of sin and point out him that by his own sin he's been brought down to the gutter, to some we give Dr. Majin's book the Virgin Birth, to some we at the alter fulfilled prophecy, to some we use the classical arguments, to some we use the philosophical approach, we show them the alternatives whether it's the man in the gutter or the philosopher philosophically minded, unbeliever, we use what point of contact we can get, if they flee from the nearer contacts into the distant we pursue them there, in either case it is Christ or death, it is Christ or Diana, Christ or modernism, Christ or irrationalism, Christ or suicide, so it goes the last step back to which we press them is into the blackness of irrationality and if they're already there we ask them why they haven't committed suicide, now what is he saying here? His point is that yes, but if in fact the person in their inconsistency is living more or closer to God's world over this side even though in some ways their thinking may be shaped by the thinking of the age in which they live, if they're living closer to God's world we may be able to simply use straightforward evidences to appeal to them, we may be able to, here he gives the example of Majin's book the Virgin Birth, we may be able to show how the New Testament clearly teaches the Virgin Birth and give the evidences for the truth of the Virgin Birth, we may appeal to fulfilled prophecy, now later on Schaeffer would come to point out that this was really what Paul was doing, if you think of Paul in the book of Acts, when he's talking to Jewish unbelievers, when he goes to the synagogues he doesn't talk about the nature of the universe, he assumes already that they're living partially in God's world because they believe in the God of the Old Testament, they believe that the Old Testament is God's world, they expect a Messiah, so in fact he appeals to fulfilled prophecy, he shows them that Jesus was the Messiah, he's appealing to evidences, now he's not talking about evidences here in quite the way but it's sometimes understood in terms of evidentialism as a way of approach, he's thinking of it within this context of the man being caught between two worlds, every unbeliever is really caught in between two worlds but the closer a person is to the world which God has actually made, he will already have some ideas which make him more open to a very direct approach, you see how he Schaeffer uses the language here, if they flee from the nearer contacts we pursue them to the Father, he's talking about the nearer as the person you can use here and talk about the virgin birth or fulfilled prophecy, the person who's accepted a totally non-Christian world view, a humanistic world view is not open at all to hearing about fulfilled prophecy or to the fact that Jesus is the Messiah, now you see when Paul is with the Gentiles he doesn't talk about Jesus as being the Messiah, they wouldn't have understood the idea even, he talks about something different, he talks about who God is, the nature of the world, the nature of the human person, he starts with the issues that the person is dealing with more over here, we pursue him to where he is, so the person who is most consistent is the one who's most over in another world view, I'm sure my diagram isn't very helpful here but I hope it's at least communicating something, I have to think of something really really good, I need somebody artistic to do something for me, here, so we will use whatever is appropriate in communicating to somebody, depending on where they are, how close, to or how far away from a biblical position, what we have to work to do is to find a point of contact, to find a point of contact, now the point of contact again will be the area where the person is inconsistent or where there is attention in his own heart, like the example he gives above, if the person is valuing human love, even though there's no room for love in his world view, that will be the point of contact, if he's valuing rationality, even though there's no room for rationality in his world view, we will make that the point of contact, let me give an illustration from V. Shell's discussions with the Hindu man who was coming in, if I hear was a man who clearly valued his own dignity as a human person, who clearly thought that there was a fundamental difference between good and evil, now V. Shell appealed to both of those issues in discussing with him, because those were the clear point of tension because in Hinduism, in absolute monism, there is no room for the value of the individual, and yet here's this person with tremendous dignity, with a great deal of intelligence, and obviously delightful personality, who values himself as a person, so you appeal to that, you show him, there's your point of contact, he is valuing something which only has meaning within a biblical understanding, so you start from there and you show him the conclusion of his own position, again my images are so hopeless here, if you like, he's standing in the middle, he's valuing his personality, let's say, but in his worldview, let's say he's a Hindu with an absolutely monist view, like this man was, that is everything is ultimately one, what you do is you push him right over here, so he sees where his own worldview leads, but it leaves him with no value whatsoever for his personality, so you're showing him the conclusion of his own position, you're pushing him to the logical conclusion, that's what Schaefer called it later, like he says here, the last step back to which we press them is into the blackness of irrationality, and if they're already there we ask them why they haven't committed suicide, that that may sound terrible, to speak that way, he's not saying it harshly, he's not saying it harshly at all, he's just trying to help us to see what we need to do, it's exactly what Isaiah does when he's talking to the people who worship idols, he pushes them to see the folly of their own position, if they really think through what it means, it's exactly what Paul is doing in Acts 17, he's showing them how foolish it is to worship the things they do, rather than the true God, so you're doing several things, you're pushing him to the conclusion here, you're showing them him the conclusion of what his own worldview is, at the same time you're showing him that the things that he values, that point of tension, that point of contact, can only make meaning within a Christian understanding, you're taking the thing that is valuable to him and you're showing him that it only makes sense here, like Isaiah and Isaiah 40 through 48, he tells them really, you're so much greater than an idol, you made them yourself, how can you bow down and worship them, a man can only have real dignity because he's made by God, not by worshiping something which he's made, himself, so you're showing him the conclusion of his own position and you're at the same time showing him the glory of the gospel, because you'll never meet anybody who is completely consistent, there's always a point of contact, there's always a point of contact, as he says here again, if the unsaved man were completely logical and so had no point of common contact we could not reach him for he would have taken his life and so be out of our reach, so anybody who's still alive you can still communicate with them, precisely because they're still holding onto life and life is God's gift and the extent that they're holding onto life, to that extent you have a point of contact with every human being, if we're thinking about the issue, the point that Shaeff was making was this that if we like Bertrand Russell say that there is no God, you can take his book for example why I'm not a Christian, which he sets forward his arguments against Christianity, he acknowledges there himself that if there is no God then my individual life will end in the grave and the whole human race is going to disappear completely when the earth is destroyed, when the solar system ends, no there is no future for the individual, there is no future for the race and he goes on to say that that means that there is no value ultimately ultimately to morality, to any kind of human achievement, to intelligence, to creativity, to anything we can build and he actually says it's only on that foundation of despair that the soul's habitation can henceforth be safely built, only on the foundation of unyielding despair, recognizing that your moral choices have no value at all. Now he's acknowledged there that if he were consistent he should recognize that there is finally no difference between good and evil, it really doesn't make any difference in the end. Avishal made the same point when he was talking about Hinduism in the Bhagavad Gita, it's very very clear in the discussion between Lord Krishna and Ayuna but Krishna is acknowledging that in the end there is no difference between good actions and bad actions, it makes no difference in the end, that's what amorality is, that you have no basis for morality. However as you look at at the life of somebody like Bertrand Russell, you see two things, you see first that he was a moral person in the sense that he wasn't amoral, he continued to make moral judgments right up until he was at past 90 when he died, he was out there marching against the bomb and against American intervention in Vietnam and everything else, he was always making moral judgments, this is wicked, he's got no basis for that whatsoever when he said in the end it really doesn't matter but we can be thankful that he does, if people were completely consistent universe would be in a polling place but God hasn't left himself without a witness and human beings do have the law of God engraved on their hearts and thankfully they're not completely given over to evil to thinking that it really doesn't matter what we do. So he wasn't a moral, he was a moral person in that sense Bertrand Russell was very good at making pronouncements about morality in general and the immorality of nations and his cause was man with a capital M but what he lost sight of was the importance of individual morality and he would talk all the time about the human race and the importance of doing things with the were righteous for the cause, really furthering the cause of humanity but in the process his own life was an absolute scandal in terms of the way he treated his wife who was very faithful to him, who loved him very dearly and then when he was in the United States furthering the cause of man of humanity he was staying in the home of a professor at one of the universities here in New England and he seduced the man's younger daughter and for him you know it didn't matter because the cause was all mattered so there was certainly immorality but there wasn't immorality in an individual in him or really in very few other people you occasionally find people who are almost totally immoral the marquee de Sard would be a good example the father of what's called sadism he had the view but because man is stronger he can do whatever he likes to women physically and sexually and he lived it out quite consistently and it was interesting this man who spoken our class yesterday in Christian responsibility in society said it was the marquee de Sard's mother in law who had him put in prison in the pastee in 1798 1789 rather because he treated his wife her daughter so appallingly badly you know he really lived out what he believed that you could treat women exactly how you wanted to he said simply because I'm stronger I can do what I like he was really a naturalist in that sense you know that we are and man is just an animal who sprung up from nature and in nature there is the survival of the fittest of the strongest I'm strongest so I can do the woman whatever I want to do then he lived that out in practice and the French Revolution was an expression of that of the strong destroying the weak at every point and that was an amoral revolution it's a good example of amorality you know it had no moral basis or foundation at all that brings me to the next point and that is this point number seven we are not consistent either that's the last point that Schaeffer makes in this little paper he says incidentally and it's really after he's finished he says incidentally I think it is worthwhile also to call attention to the fact that after we are converted we do not hold the Christian worldview consistently either many people are Christians with very little of a full Christian worldview and none of us will be completely consistent until we're fully glorified now this is really important to have that humility about yourself changes the way in which you speak to people and if you wanted to give a heading for this article or for this whole section or for shape as apologetics we could call it compassionate presuppositionism compassionate presuppositionism we must not imagine and this is really what he's saying that the unbeliever is in total darkness and that the believer is in total light that we've got darkness here it's not as simple as that of course in one sense it is when a person becomes a Christian they're translated from the kingdom of darkness into the kingdom of God's beloved son we are fully acceptable to God we are covered by the blood of Christ so that we are perfectly received by him we have peace with God so once once we can say we are walking in the light fully in one sense but in another sense we're not fully in the light and we all know that very well it's like Paul says now I see through a glass darkly and then I shall see face to face God knows me perfectly well but I don't know him perfectly well that's that is the reality in which we all find ourselves actually any particular individual is on a road heading out of darkness into light any Christian is on a road heading out of darkness into light we haven't fully arrived yet we all make many mistakes in our thinking as the New Testament acknowledges none of us are perfect men either in what we do or in what we think now that's tremendously important for the way we treat other Christians as well so we don't think well I have perfect doctrinal system at every point and others are are completely wrong we acknowledge that that we make mistakes in our thinking now why this is important in apologetics is because it enables me to speak with humility to the unbeliever I am speaking as fellow sinner to fellow sinner as fellow seeker to fellow seeker because while I have found God in one sense rather God has found me I'm still seeking him I'm still seeking to know him better so I'm speaking as fellow sinner to fellow sinner as fellow seeker to fellow seeker and I must speak with compassion to a person who is living intention compassion because he's lost and because he's caught in the tension compassionately pointing out to him the end of the road down which he's going you very carefully and very gently point out to somebody where he's going that if he were consistent he would have no alternative but suicide you're not interested in arguments you're not interested in making points in beating somebody over the head to make them realize what a fool they are for holding this position you are compassionately showing them where this would lead them if they took it consistently at the same time we're compassionately showing them the truth which gives light so when mustn't imagine that what you're doing is if we had a rather illustration up here from before that you're pushing a person hard into his own worldview and saying this is what it means don't you realize where it's taking you it's leading you to death irrationality meaningless absurdity armorality a hopeless universe and that's all you're doing and then when you've got in there and you've left him feeling totally worthless then you come along with a nice word of comfort and say actually there's an answer here that's not what shape is talking about at the same time as you're showing him where this leads consistently you're also showing him that there's an answer to it you're showing him where the darkness is you're pushing him back this way but at the same time as you're doing that you're showing him where the light takes you you're showing him what the light will give the book of Ecclesiastes which we're studying in apologetics at the moment is a wonderful example of this because the major theme of the book of Ecclesiastes is of the total vanity of human existence but it's not unrelived gloom every chapter or so in the book of Ecclesiastes there is another theme which appears just briefly here and there showing that there's an answer to the problem it's never spelled out in detail it's not spelled out in its clearest form till the very last verse but after death there will be a judgment of God when everything that is done and thought and said will be brought to light and that's the end of the matter now he doesn't take to the very end of the book what the solution is the problem that he's raised and then he doesn't spell it out in any detail but all the time through the book he is giving hints that there is an answer to the problem of meaninglessness with which he has begun that that would be an exhilaration of what I'm talking about so you don't just push somebody to absurdity because they might very well commit suicide at the same time that you're showing them as an answer here because you don't want the person end up in absurdity you want them to end up in light so you're showing them the light at the same time so with compassion you point out the end of the road with compassion you show the truth which gives light with compassion you have compassion because you've been found by by compassion yourself that is the heart of the gospel Christ is compassion he is compassionate and I have been found by compassion by the compassion of God and therefore I speak with compassion to others and compassion because I have inconsistencies myself because I I still have tensions confusions I don't live the Christian life perfectly and I mustn't pretend that I do I don't have everything clear and I mustn't pretend that I have everything clear I have some wonderful answers which God has given me which I can share and hopefully there should be some consistency in my life so that he can see there's a difference in in what I'm doing in the way I'm living but I'm not in the position of having everything and this man has nothing you know God has everything and we are both looking towards God who gives who gives truth who's given me some and now I humbly and compassionately want to share it with somebody else let me give you an illustration of my own father when I went back to live in England my father was in his 70s he was 74 and he was very ill and he had been a really a very radical socialist a Marxist for most his life for the previous 40 or 50 years ever since just after the First World War like many other young British men he was made both totally cynical about the prevailing order by the First World War which was such a totally useless and worthless and unnecessary war and so many people's lives were just so appallingly destroyed by bad by bad leadership both from the government and from the generals and he saw almost everybody he knew killed you know he was in the trenches in Belgium and France and he could never talk about it even 50 years later without crying I mean it was just one of those things that was just so completely overwhelming to him and after the war in reaction to to everything that he he'd been brought up in he he he turned in the direction of Marxism as having the answer so he was he was you could say humanist he didn't believe in God he didn't think God was necessary was just man here but the particular direction he'd gone for answers was Marxism in terms of its economic solutions its societal solutions now when I came back from the States when my wife and I came back from the States to live near them and that's why we why when they're graduated from here we went back to England to live near them because of their their their need that's none of my family were Christians at all and I had spent very little time with them since being converted just a week here and there before coming over here what I tried to do was to find a point of contact using the language that Schaeff was using here now in his situation the point of contact was this he and my mother were both very moral people if you like they they assume that the second half of the Ten Commandments is self evidently true like many other people in our society though increasingly less I may add but they assume that the second half the Ten Commandments you shouldn't murder you shouldn't steal you shouldn't commit adultery you shouldn't bear false witness you shouldn't cover to your neighbor's wife or his property but these were self evidently right that all decent human beings regarded these as an necessarily true and that was the way they lived and they were extremely good people as people go they were not better in some ways humanly speaking than many Christians that I know I mean they were really compassionate people I remember as a little boy going to taking every Christmas to an old man who lived alone in the village a basket of food my parents were very poor basket of food with a chicken with a Christmas pudding made by my mother with mince pies were all kinds of things so that he could he could have some kind of Christmas and they were always doing things like that really being kind to people so the point of tension really was their morality which was very precious to them and which they regarded as self evidently right and they were both tremendously distressed by the moral breakdown in our society because even back then when I went back to England in 1971 all of Western society as it is increasingly today was evidently morally bankrupt and moral standards of every kind whether in the area of section morality of honesty in the workplace or in any in any other area we're decaying now sometimes people were trying to deny that and say well people are always the same well of course people are always sinful but there really are differences in moments of history just one illustration when I was a little boy I used to wonder all over the countryside in the area of England where I grew up by myself weekends and in the holiday invocations without my parents having any fear at all about me wondering around now I've lived for the last 18 years in England just a few miles from where I grew up working in the tree there and I was talking to my mother about this just last year you know we have never let our children I have three boys wonder around the countryside by themselves and she agreed with me she wouldn't have considered doing it today you know things have really changed children are not safe in our society wondering around alone they were 35 years ago but they simply aren't now now that is one illustration of what is happening in our society now for my parents that was a tremendous concern and I used that as the as the point of contact now I tried to show them very gently and they were open to discussing it's because of the rejection of God people have begun to live more and more consistently to the fact that there is no God like Dostoevsky said if God is dead everything is permitted now everything is permitted and that's what's happening in our society everything is indeed permitted and Sartre quotes that over and over again Jean Paul Sartre if God is dead indeed everything is permitted and man is completely alone to do whatever he wants to do and whatever he will do and it really doesn't matter make any difference what you do it doesn't matter in the end and I tried to show this to them very gently you know of course with your own parents with your own father you don't say dad you're a fool you've got it all wrong you know all your life you believe these lies and if you only have the intelligence to see you know this is just ridiculous you don't speak like that to anybody and especially to your own parents you don't my father is a very proud man so very gently I started showing him this moral decay that you see in the society is the logical conclusion beginning to work itself out of the worldview that you have adopted that was a hard thing to say but you say it very gently and at the same time I was saying the kind of morals that you so rightly treasure can only be held can only have any real meaning on a Christian foundation because there is a God who has a moral character who's holy and righteous and just and his character provides the foundation for melody in the universe this is a moral universe in which we live and good is really good and evil is really evil and it will always be no matter what people think and that's why you treasure morality because you've been made in God's image and it really is right you have this law written on your heart so at the same time you're saying this is where this leads it leads to darkness it leads to death it leads to the decay of the individual and of the culture and at the other time at the same time you're saying and this is the answer to this problem now that was really a means on which we could communicate and he became a Christian you know and that was the point of real contact of him saying yes yes I see I see but you don't do it all at once we had discussions every day over a period of three or four months then he became a Christian eventually about six weeks before he died actually with Dr. Schaefer personally when he was visiting us and he died of cancer and he became believer just six weeks before the end but it was this point of contact which really opened the door now I've done the same thing with many many other people but it's a question of getting to know the person that's why Schaefer says if you have an hour with somebody you spend 50 minutes asking questions and 10 minutes given the answer what he meant by that was you in order to communicate you really got to find out who they are so you begin to find out where that point of tension is where there is a hole in the armor if you like where there is a point where they're still living in the world that God made and still valuing what is true and right and good and just and it's from that point you say you start communicating the Christian message do ordinary people the ordinary man in the street the man out in a rural community the ordinary men and women have questions like this can one approach them in this kind of way and I would say absolutely yes it's not a matter of using intellectual language or talking about philosophy or anything else my father that school at the age of 16 and went and joined up in the first world he had no formal education he was quite a widely read person but he certainly didn't mean philosophy or anything like that he actually read mostly travel books about other cultures and so on but he wasn't an intellectual at all now I think it's got nothing to do with being intellectual actually but that is where I think we have such a confusion about apologetics apologetics come to be thought as something which is for intellectual people and I don't think it is at all I think you can say these things to children to small children it's just a matter of using the right words you know when the shapers first went to Europe they went to do a children's work they were talking about the world that God has made the truth to little children they produced that series of studies on the book of Genesis and on the book of Luke everybody can know and you can take the most profound aspects of the local truth and communicate them really simply to people using illustration of I have a conversation which is ongoing with with my barber the lady at Baldwin who cuts my hair and it's really on this same issue she raised it one day when I was there having my hair cut and she raised the issue of that this was last earlier this year sometime when a girl was brutally raped and murdered just out here in West County you probably all remember the illustration and said why are there so many things like that happening there is a there is a there's a good opportunity to say something so we started to have a discussion she's not intellectual at all but she's concerned about what's happening in our society about moral breakdown so I began to explore very gently in the limited amount of time you have an a barber shop what is happening and first of all I got her to open up a bit more just to find out where she was thinking and she was talking about her own husband watches pornographic films and how to stressing this is to her it just gave me the opportunity to talk about general moral breakdown but it really has a practical effect in people's lives you can't just keep watching pornography and it not affect you these images these ideas really do change the way people think about about women about men and ultimately they change their behavior you know people really are profoundly affected by ideas and by images their imaginations and their minds are really touched and that began to be a point of contact to talk about well you know what is happening in our society why because people have turned away from God in his commandments and think that they can make up their own ideas of how people should live that can be said very simply it doesn't have to be said in an intellectual way and there is no solution to this problem except for people turning back to God and having a really solid source of knowing what is right and what is wrong and in fact I would say that most rural people are open to this particular argument because they're generally more conservative in their morals and they're really appalled by what's happening in our cities and in our culture as a whole and I would suggest that not only in terms of talking to the individual but you can preach on these things and that we all ought to be preaching on them regularly because it's precisely to point like this where God's word really touches our world today so we are communicating the truth that we are talking about a God who truly exists who has a moral character whose moral character provides the basis for distinguishing between good and evil and for moral behavior in the human world and that what we see in our society is the ruin of the society which is which has turned away from that insisted that man can manage the measure of all things for himself you can say those things really simply what I've been challenging the apologetics class to do is to to try and think about how you would communicate that particular idea to children of eight and nine years old I think you can communicate it very simply