<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Anneta Anneta regulaarselt

The Church in the Netherlands

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Lecture 17, God's free mercy, the church in the Netherlands. We've been looking for several times at developments in the 17th century in England and Scotland. And now we go to the Netherlands, the most significant Protestant church on the continent to study the history of that church during the 17th century. The Heidelberg Catechism is one of the three forms of unity that Dutch churches use with the Belgium confession and the cannons of the Synod of Dort that we're going to study today. And I'd like to, for our prayer time, read two of the questions from the Heidelberg Catechism, which is a very lovely, wonderful catechism that we should be familiar with. Heidelberg question 116, why is prayer necessary for Christians? The answer that is given there is because it is the chief part of the gratitude which God requires of us. And because God will give His grace and Holy Spirit only to those who sincerely beseech Him in prayer without ceasing and who thank Him for these gifts. And then question 118, ask what has God commanded us to ask of Him? And the answer is all things necessary for soul and body which Christ the Lord has included in the prayer which He Himself taught us. Let's join together now in praying the Lord's prayer. Let us pray. Our Father, who art in heaven, hallowed be thy name, thy kingdom come, thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven. Give us this day our daily bread and forgive us our deaths as we also have forgiven our debtors. And lead us not into temptation but deliver us from evil, for thine is the kingdom and the power and the glory forever. Amen. I want to start today with a picture of a flower that's a tulip famous and beautiful flower. We think probably tulip originated in the Near East or in North Africa. But in the 16th century it was imported into Europe and in the 17th century it became a craze in Holland where extravagant prices were paid for bulbs of rare color. From there the tulip has spread around the world. Today it's beloved by a culturalist and a Calvinist everywhere. I expect you to know why I'm starting this lecture with a picture of a tulip. The Senate of Dorit met in the Netherlands for about six months, the latter part of 1618 and the first part of 1619 and certainly the Senate of Dorit is one of the defining episodes in reformed church history. The background of the Senate is the clash that took place between two groups of Dutch Christians, one group called the Remonstrants and the other group the counter-remonstrants. To understand who the Remonstrants were we need to talk for a bit about Jacob Arminius. Arminius from the Netherlands originally went to Geneva where he studied with Beza and became a strict Calvinist as we would expect. He remained on the Calvinist side of things for some time but at one point in his career he was asked to write against a theologian or a man who was questioning some of the teaching of Calvinist. Arminius sat out to do that and as sometimes happens in that sort of exercise he discovered that as he tried to answer these anti-Calvinist arguments he became less and less convinced of the accuracy of his own belief. Arminius shifted in his faith from Calvinism to what in time is known as Arminianism. He was appointed professor of theology at the University of Leiden in 1600 and III and there he soon clashed with a very strict Calvinist colleague, man whose name was Francisco Morris. Arminius died in 1600 and IX but that was just the beginning of the dispute because the followers of Arminius and there were a number by this time in the Netherlands. Put forth a document called the remonstrance. They felt that their views needed to be better understood and accepted in the Netherlands and so the remonstrance was produced in 1600 and 10 even though Arminius had died there were others there who could set forth his views as they did in this document. What the remonstrance teaches can be summarized in five points. The election of individuals when that is in view in the Bible is based the remonstrance said not on God's choice but on God's foreknowledge. Although often election doesn't relate to individuals at all according to this document. Secondly, Christ died for everyone. Thirdly, laws people certainly need God's grace. This document is not a Pelagian document. Grace is needed for people to believe. That point for this grace is resistible. It is up to the individual as to whether he or she will believe or not. Had point number five stated that the theologians who drew up this document could not quite make up their mind about perseverance. They thought that they needed to study that further. The main point in all of this is that God does not choose anyone in the sense that the Calvinists were teaching the doctrine of election but God makes it possible for everyone to choose him. Well, this was not an isolated phenomenon in the Netherlands. It's part of a Europe-wide encroachment on the theology of the Reformation by the rationalism of the Renaissance. But certainly the clash in the Netherlands is the classic example of a Calvinist versus non-Calvinist interpretation of soteriology connected with the theological issue where many other social and political concerns almost never is a theological debate purely about theology only. And the theological debate in the Netherlands became caught off in the explosiveness of 17th century Dutch politics, tensions grew and threatened to bring the United provinces to civil war. In those days, cartoons still not with political matters but with theological matters because that was really what concerned most people. And cartoons had very sharp points back then as they do today in this picture. 17th century Dutch cartoon, we see a man on the left with a large hat and his name is Sound Head. He's a Calvinist as his head screwed on right. The one on the right who is a Roman Catholic monk with a shaved head is called Round Head. And the one in the middle who is looking both ways is the Armenian because he's trying to draw something from one side and something else from the other side and he is given the name of Rattle Head. Well, that's not very nice but people did not prize niceness much in this period as far as theological debate was concerned. It was important for the church in the Netherlands and for the country to settle this debate because it was not just a tempest in a teapot. It was something that threatened to undo the government and create chaos in society. The fact that the Dutch were able to settle this debate in the Synod of Dort I think must have contributed to the progress of the Netherlands as one of the great nations of exploration and colonization in the 17th century with Dutch ships going all over the world and Dutch people settling from New Amsterdam in this country to Indonesia, in Asia and many other places as well. But I won't talk about the political social issues. You can read that short statement from Carl Bange's book called Arminius which I think summarizes nicely the issues on both sides. But I will come to the theological debate which is our main concern of course today. A Synod was called by the nationalist and anti-Catholic Prince Maris of Orange to meet at Dortrek near Rotterdam in November 1618. It was a ecumenical reform Synod. By ecumenical there I don't mean that people came from different churches, Lutherans and Anglicans and Catholics of course were not there but it was ecumenical in the sense that this was not only a Dutch Synod but that reform theologians came from England and Scotland from the Palatinit in Germany which was the main reform area. The German-speaking world from German-speaking Switzerland and from Geneva delegates were invited from France but I think they were not able to come because of persecution of the Huguenots in France at this time. This was a truly international Synod. The only truly international Synod that the reform churches held. There were 84 members. All of them were Calvinists. The Armenians were not present except as defendants and after several weeks of skirmishing they were expelled altogether. So this is not a Synod that's going to even handedly debate the issues. This is a Calvinist Synod framing an answer to the Remonstrance of the Armenians. There was a consensus, a unanimous consensus on the major issues debated at Dorte. There were some minor differences expressed on issues such as infrah and supra-lapsarianism. The canons were stated in such a way that people holding two different views on the order of the decrees were satisfied with the general way in which an issue like that was dealt with. Out of the discussion and the debate comes the famous five heads of doctrine. I've listed those in the syllabus, the five heads of doctrine which cars bond with the five points of the Remonstrance. Those five heads rearrange slightly with point number or head number three. Man is corrupt, place first. Rearranging that order produces the famous five points of Calvinism that we remember with the word tulip. Total depravity, unconditional election, limited atonement, irresistible grace and perseverance of the saints. Overall thrust of the canons and that word simply means the rules set down by the delegates said Dorte. The overall thrust is this. It is God who saves us by fulfilling his plan. It is Christ who saves us by his effective purchase of us on Calvary. It is the Holy Spirit who saves us by instilling faith in us so that we will believe. Or to summarize it all, we could simply say God saves sinners. It is what the canons of Dorte is all about. Often these five heads particularly as rearranged and put in the order of tulip are called the five points of Calvinism. I don't think that really is the best way to describe these five points. It is better to see these five points as the Calvinist response to the five points of the Remonstrance. And of course, if you think of this as the five points of Calvinism, Calvinism is much more than these five points. I don't think we should think of summarizing Calvinism in just five points. These five points do deal with the issue of Soteriology in Calvinism in a helpful way. But Calvinism is much larger than the five points of Calvinism. Tulip is a nice easy way to remember the five points. But there is some debate I think for good reason as to whether these particular words are the best words to use in describing what Calvinism really stands for. For instance, total depravity could probably better be stated radical depravity. I won't go through that whole list and try to defend the changes, but I will be teaching Calvin's institutes next fall. And we can look into that in some detail if you're interested. Something else though to stay about door to I'd like to stress this because you can hear that when you get into scholastic reform theology like this, you're getting into dry, dead orthodoxy. And it is amazing to read these documents and to realize how much they are misunderstood and misrepresented. This is not really a dead dry document. The quotation in the syllabus from the first canon section 13 dispels that right away. The doctrine of election door says leads to humility. It leads to worship and it leads to godly living. Those were concerns that the theologians that met at door head, not just to win a theological battle, but to teach something which they believe the Bible taught which would result in humility worship. And godly living. The conclusion of the canons is also a very fine statement as to how to teach and preach the doctrine of election, the resistible grace and the other doctrines related found in the teachings of door. The senate at door did some other things. The main focus of the work in that six month period was to create the canons that I had been talking about. But the rest of the work of door was divided into two parts. The pro act work and the post act work. That really means what was done before they got to the main business and then what was done after they finished the main business. The pro act work was done before the Armenians arrived and you can read the summary there of what was included there. Door to prove the new translation, a new Dutch translation of the Bible, organized catechetical instruction and established the plan for the preparation of ministers in the church. The post act work after they had completed the work on the canons established a definitive text of the Belgium confession or the Dutch confession as it's sometimes called one of the three points or forms of unity in the Dutch churches with Heidelberg and the canons of door. Also the church set guidelines for Sunday observance somewhere between I think the stricter puritan policy and the more moderate continental policy. The Netherlands located between England and Switzerland geographically and on this point the Dutch church seems to be somewhere between the stricter puritan position and the more relaxed continental position on the seven and a new church order. Presbyterian, although that word is generally not used I think in the Dutch churches reform church order is the same thing as Presbyterian church order in Scotland. The Dutch reform churches were Presbyterian from the beginning but this new order was an attempt to free the church from a rastian control that was always a problem in the Netherlands. The France or the government had a fairly heavy hand in controlling the affairs of the church perhaps not as extreme as the stewards in Scotland and England but more control than many Dutch reform Protestants proved of. Well that's one great thing that took place in the Netherlands in the 17th century but I want to come to two other points as we think of Dutch Christian history in the 17th century we really need to talk about three things. Senator Dord very, very important on anybody's list certainly in a reform discussion of church history near the top of the important events that take place in post-reformation period. But something else happens in the churches in the Netherlands during this time called the second reformation or the newer or more precise reformation. We've already come across a similar expression in studying the history of the church in Scotland the second reformation and there was also a second reformation in the 17th and early 18th centuries in the Netherlands. Let me sketch for a moment the situation in the Dutch churches in the 17th century. The reform church was close to being an established church it had a preferred status although other churches were allowed to meet. The result was that with this close connection between church and state the reform churches began to grow very rapidly and with that as we see so often in church history a kind of nominalism comes in to the church. And the problem I was mentioning a moment ago state interference in church matters was a problem so the reformation in the Netherlands as in Scotland in England was believed by many to be incomplete the church needed to be reformed more in the sense of renewed revival was needed. And what happens in the second reformation I think is not a theological correction it was not a refudiation or even a weakening of Calvinism but a development or practical application of the reformation particularly the teachings of Calvin. There were many connections contacts between Holland and English Puritans and Scottish Presbyterians in fact the Puritans and the Presbyterians looked upon the Netherlands as a special sanctuary of the Lord and when things got too hot in England or Scotland the place to go was the Netherlands. As early as 1600 and 10 Amsterdam was home to at least 10 English Puritan churches with many English speaking Christians of Puritan and Presbyterian conviction living in Amsterdam just three years before this as you know a group of those English Puritan Christians who had come originally from England some years before got in a little ship to make another trip and this time sailed in the Mayflower across the Atlantic to Plymouth the colony that first settled Plymouth in New England came from England but by way of the Netherlands. It's interesting too to study church architecture and to realize that the typical Puritan building what we think of as a typical New England church draws much of its inspiration from reformed church architecture on a dorm simplicity of church architecture in the Netherlands. So Christians in these three countries were in close contact and they helped each other and supported each other in some wonderful ways. There were some differences however church polity was not so much an issue in Holland as it was in Scotland because in Holland it had already been settled in the reformed or Presbyterian direction. The problem was the Arastian control of the church in Scotland it was settled too but the stewards kept trying to unseple it and in England with the Puritans there were different points of view mainly between Presbyterians and Congregationalists as we'll see when we come to the Westminster Confession of Faith. Another difference is that the Scottish Presbyterians and the English Puritans write books of theology that generally practical theology and even the theologians like John Owen do not write full systematic theologies but the Dutch do. They love systematic theology and some of the great post-reformation scholars of reformed orthodoxy are Dutch professors and pastors many of these men as we'll see when we come to study reformed orthodoxy were both pastors and professors the same time and somehow still had time to write great tomes of systematic theology in Latin much of which has not even been translated down to the present. Two representative leaders and I could mention many of the second reprimation in the Netherlands or William Ames and Gisbertus Poetius William Ames was a transplanted Englishman, disciple of the early Puritan William Perkins who was exiled to the Netherlands because of his very forced old criticism of the Church of England in the year 1600 and 10 he taught at the University of Froniker he was a delegate to the Senate of Dort and he wrote a book, very famous book which you'll want to add to the outline called a narrow of theology was written in the year 1623. It's a book of systematic theology but with William Ames you get the best of scientific theology and the best of practical theology. There's a chapter for instance in the narrow of theology on contentment that's in a systematic theology so you're not only on a chapter on the Trinity and on the Atonement and on the Incarnation and other things that you might expect to find but a whole chapter on contentment in a book on systematic theology. We'll see you later perhaps that this book became the first textbook at the New Harvard College when it was established in New England. The other man is Gisbertus Boetius who was a Dutch scholar and pastor much influenced by the Englishman William Ames who spent good many years in the Netherlands. Boetius was a delegate to Dort as a young minister and then became professor at the University of Utrecht. There are three things I could say about Boetius and I'll say one of them here mentioned all three but the others will come up a little later on. He was a scholastic theologian. He was a man of great piety, a leader in what is called the precisionist movement in the Netherlands. You can pretty much say that's the equivalent to Puritanism in England and that movement will have great influence on the very important German pietyist movement that we will study later. So a theologian, a man who works to bring piety and spiritual life into the church and then the third point a leader in missions. This is quite unusual because the Protestant churches at this stage in the history of Protestantism have not yet become fully aware and alert to the importance of worldwide missions but Gisbertus Boetius is already writing on theology of missions back in the 17th century. Well like Puritanism in England the second Reformation in the Netherlands was a movement that God owned and God blessed was a revival in the churches. And even though it's been criticized as Puritanism has I think by and large what happened in this movement was something of great significance in reviving and renewing the Dutch churches. One cannot speak about the religious history of 17th century Holland without talking about the Senate of Dort and the second Dutch Reformation but neither could you really speak about 17th century Dutch history without talking about an artist. Man of course whose name is Rembrandt don't have to tell you that. He was a boy of 12 when the Senate of Dort met and he died a few years before Boetius died so he lived through this period of Dort and the second Dutch Reformation. As Bach would later come to dominate Protestant church music so Rembrandt is the greatest Protestant artist. He was born in Leiden into a reformed family which doesn't surprise us because most people in the Netherlands were reformed at this time. We know that he was taught the Bible by his mother doesn't surprise us either because many people are taught the Bible by their mothers. I certainly was and I expect some of you were too. It's interesting and really a blessing to me to look at the pictures of Rembrandt and see how often he paints his mother especially when she was very very old. He paints her, he draws her as an old woman wrinkles in her face but there's still something about Rembrandt's painting of his mother that shows his love for her and so often she has a big Bible in her hands. So I expect that's Rembrandt's way of saying my mother taught me the Bible. There were tensions that developed between Rembrandt and the reformed church. We wish we really knew more about his connection with the reformed church and with Calvinism. We know he grew up in that context but later he was estranged from the church because of a common law marriage that he contracted with a woman after the death of his first wife. He apparently lived with this woman faithfully but because of some technical legal matters he was not able to have an official state and church marriage. That caused the church to put him under discipline and Rembrandt seems to have broken connections then with the reformed church. Some people think that he moved into the Minonite community. Minonites were very strong in the Netherlands and undoubtedly he did have contact with the Minonites, had contact with the Jews. He loved to go into the Jewish part of Amsterdam and talk to the Jews and get to know them and watch them because when he painted pictures illustrating the New Testament he painted Jews. Other artists did not do that but Rembrandt's way of painting was to try to be as accurate as he possibly could and he wanted to study the Jewish community in order to be inspired to paint in a way that would reflect the Jewish culture more accurately. So we can't say all that much about his theology and about his church connection but I think Rembrandt was a true believer. He gives his testimony in his art. No one ever has painted the poor, the sick, the cripple, the destitute, the way Rembrandt painted them, scores the pictures of beggars, blind people and many, many sketches of these people. I think Rembrandt was doing that not just because he wanted to paint vagabonds and people in sickness and suffering but it was a kind of testimony. In fact on one occasion one of his self portraits is Rembrandt himself as a beggar. He probably never really was a beggar but he paints himself as a beggar so he looks like the beggars of Amsterdam. And he did that because he wanted to set forth something of his understanding of human need and suffering not only in a physical way but spiritual need and spiritual help that must come from God if we are ever going to have what we need in this life. Francis Schaefer in his book How Should We Didn't Live wrote Rembrandt had flaws in his life like all people do but he was a true Christian. He believed in the death of Christ for him personally and not only did he often paint beggars which is a kind of picture of human need but he painted the cross crucifixion. And one of the most significant paintings of Rembrandt on the crucifixion is a painting with the men straining to raise the cross. Jesus already crucified, nailed to the cross and these men are straining to put the cross in the big hole. They are crucifying Jesus and one of them is Rembrandt paints himself into that picture as a blue beret on in that picture but it's clearly a self portrait of this man and thus he stated for all the world to see that it was his sins that had sent Christ to the cross. Not only is his art his testimony but it's also his preaching and his teaching. Francois Moriac the modern French Catholic novelist wrote it seems to me that Rembrandt has given the most faithful representation of the Bible stories. He was a painter of the Bible 850 paintings and drawings of the Bible and in Rembrandt's pictures of the Bible his scenes from the Bible I think we have both exegesis and exposition and I'm preaching on passage from the New Testament from the gospels particularly. I'm always concerned to know if Rembrandt painted that scene because by not only studying the text of the Bible and the words in the Bible but by looking at one of his drawings I can begin to understand more fully what that text is all about. So we summarize Dr. 17th century history in these three ways, the center of the door, the second reformation and Rembrandt. Let me close this lecture with the concluding words of the canons of the center of the door which beautifully summarize all three of these points. May Jesus Christ, the son of God, who seated at the father's right hand gave gifts to men sanctify us in the truth, bring to the truth those who air and endure the faithful ministers of his word with the spirit of wisdom and discretion that all their discoveries may tend to the glory of God. And the edification of those who hear them a men, well it's really a shame to talk about Rembrandt and not show you a lot of pictures but I knew you couldn't see them anyway but I have them here. There are many, many collections of his pictures. I have a couple of them but I'm not sure the editors are the days but go to borders and look in the art section and you will have probably half dozen to choose from. Something else yes David? Well the question is David is asking is when Prince Maurice called the Synod, doesn't that imply a kind of a rastian action yes it does just like Westminster. So in both of these cases where church centered is called is called by governing officials the prince in the Netherlands the parliament in England and there's a kind of restlessness in both cases and attempt to be somewhat free from that control but in either cases it completely successful. So it was an arastian centered called not by the churches but by the prince but the prince had some strong vested interest in this because his kingdom was suffering unless he could get some consensus on this matter. Okay question is what was the situation in the Netherlands in the 17th century in terms of religious freedom more there than anywhere I know about until Rhode Island and even Rhode Island is perhaps not much better than the Netherlands. There was the preferred status in the reformed churches but Jews were there, men andites were there, Presbyterians and Puritans were there. It wasn't a completely pluralistic and open system because there was the state church connection but there was certainly a great deal more freedom than anywhere else. The pilgrims I think probably did and do express their concern that their children are growing up in the Netherlands speaking Dutch and they want to save the English for them so they take them to New England where they can start all over again with an English colony but it was not that they were unhappy with the hospitality they received in the Netherlands. We have a Dutch citizen here perhaps a corps would like to stand up and say something. Stand up and say something in Dutch for us. Tell us about yourself in a sentence or two in Dutch so we can hear what it sounds like. Is anybody understand that? Anybody else speak Dutch? Okay translate for us. And the corps is going this summer to Amsterdam. He is our first PMI summer intern. It's going to Amsterdam to help in a church there. Tell everybody about that. Maybe you should come up here so you can hear you. Well I'm going to Amsterdam this summer to work in a church. It's a self-pastor in the Netherlands who planted a church in 1993. He's a graduate from Westminster and I think the church has at the moment about 70 to 100 members and I hope to help him out there. That's what I'm going to do. You need to raise some funds for this. Thanks for the food. I need to raise some funds for that. The message is clear I guess already. Okay thank you corps. I'll be praying for him. This is a wonderful opportunity. They will have this summer to serve in Amsterdam and if you know if you have church connections connections with missions committees and that sort of thing invite him to come and speak. He wants to go by the middle of May. Let's pray that God would make that happen. Have a wonderful spring break.