<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Lahjoita Lahjoita kuukausittain

New Modernism & the Bible

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Father, we want to thank you for this day for the beauty of it. We thank you for the reminder we had in the lecture we just heard about the wonder of your creation, that everything you've made demonstrates to us so gloriously your power, your divine nature, your ability in designing such a marvellous universe. We thank you too, Father, that you have spoken to us in your word, that you haven't left us alone, just drifting around in silence and confusion, but that you've spoken so that we may know who you are and who we are, and what you've done for our salvation and to bring resolution and reconciliation into our lives. Now we pray, Father, that in what we study together in this hour, that you will help us to understand the preciousness of your word and the truth you've spoken to us in Jesus' name are men. Our topic for today is Schafer's paper, The New Modernism, Neoworthodoxy and the Bible. This was a paper which he gave in 1950 at the Second Plenary Council of the International Council of Christian Churches meeting in Geneva in Switzerland. At this point he'd been living in Switzerland for between one and two years and he's had more time to reflect about the new theology. What he does really is to take some of the ideas we saw in the last article we looked at about Carl Bart and Bartian Theology and to develop them more. I think one of the fascinating things about this lecture, or about this lecture he gave, this article that then came from it, is the way we see in it, many seed thoughts which became much more fully developed in his later teaching and writing. In fact we could really call this the intellectual climate of the new theology. What he tries to do in this lecture is to summarize some of the points from the surrounding culture from the philosophical thought of the culture and the social thought which he sees as the background behind the development of the new modernism of new orthodoxy. In fact later on in the late 50s and in the early 60s in many places he was to give a series of lectures called the intellectual climate of the new theology. He developed in much greater detail than here and of course those lectures were part of what was behind his books escape from reason and the God who is there published at the end of the 60s. But here he's beginning to develop some of these thoughts for the first time but it isn't right he suggests to see the orthodox theology just as a theology which sort of arose in the mind of the theologian, the feeling that he needed to have something to say or in the minds of a group of theologians but rather the theology, the thinking of the new modernists of the new orthodox theologians has to be seen and can only be understood if one sees it against the context of the intellectual climate of the early part of the 20th century. Now what he starts off with really in this article in this lecture is describing his own experience and the experience of many other people like him. And that is like himself many other people grew up in liberal churches in older liberal churches which no longer taught the supernatural Christianity the Bible which didn't teach that Jesus is God that he's died for us sins but taught a very watered damn kind of message about human relationships about universal fatherhood of God and the universal brotherhood of men. And Schaefer says in his own life as he grew up going to a liberal church this had no message which compelled him or interested him at all. It didn't strike him as being something which was intellectually attractive or religiously forceful in any way like many other people he drifted from liberalism into a position of nationalism either saying that we really can't know God at all or that we just simply do know nothing about him and there is not even worth knowing anything about him. Just a state of uncertainty and agnosticism and he suggests that many many people like himself drifted from liberalism into that kind of state of agnosticism and from that state of agnosticism of uncertainty like himself many people had come to know Christ when they heard Christ clearly proclaimed for the first time when they came across the Christ who is proclaimed in the Scripture. And he suggests that it's against that background of the failure of liberalism to proclaim a gospel which really touched people and drew people and compelled people's interest we have to see the development of the new theology which he calls transcendental theology. The idea here was that transcendental theology rather than speaking like the liberal theologian from simply within the perspective of human beings developing a theology from man that the transcendental theology proclaims that there is indeed a word which comes from outside the human situation which speaks to men to give men the word of God so it's a transcendent word. It has a strong authority coming from outside man so that man can escape from agnosticism he doesn't have to be driven into a position of uncertainty with no answers to his needs so there was fundamentally a need against the background of liberalism for a new theology for a theology which had a word an authoritative word to the human condition. Now basically Schaeffer says that as we look at the intellectual climate of the 20th century the intellectual climate behind the new theology what we fundamentally see in the intellectual climate of the 20th century is a denial of the absoluteness of truth, a denial of the absoluteness of truth. But when we look at 20th century thinking in one field after another there is a rejection of the idea that truth can be known and that truth stands in absolute opposition to falsehood and he sets this out in various ways looking at some of the thinkers some of the ideas that have shaped the way people think in the 20th century. He starts first of all with the approach to logic of some 20th century thinkers. He suggests that many 20th century thinkers have stepped out of logic but if we look at the whole history of Western philosophy going right back to the Greeks but an idea that was always common was that there is truth here and opposed to it is falsehood. But there is fundamentally if you like an antithesis this was an idea that Schaeffer developed in much greater detail later on but A is opposed to non A he would say later on as many philosophers have put it. The truth and falsehood are in absolute opposition to each other and nothing can ever change that. He suggests that in 20th century philosophy there has been a radical change, a revolution in philosophical thinking. But instead of thinking about truth and falsehood there is now the philosophy of pragmatism associated in particular with the name of Dewey and in pragmatism there is essentially the idea that it's not a question of what we know that is true as opposed to what is false but rather the truth. Truth is found in what is useful what is valuable to the thinker to the philosopher to the scientist and once you say that you've completely rejected the idea that there is truth here and falsehood there. Truth may be here, if it's useful it may be here, if it's useful the opposite of what truth was once seen to be. Once one says that the truth is the useful the true is what is meaningful for me. The whole notion that some things are true and the opposite of them is false has completely disappeared because truth is defined in terms of its value to the individual, to the person that Dewey would have tried to defend this some total relativism by saying it's actually only the scientist or the philosopher who can really say that this is what is useful and therefore it's true. I tried to say it's not just the man in the street saying this is useful to me therefore it's true but it is the trained scientist, the trained thinker who is able to say this is what is useful therefore it's true but fundamentally there is a denial of antithesis that truth and falsehood are in opposition to each other. That whole notion is disappearing we're considering what truth is on completely other grounds. Truth of course then is no longer absolute. Truth is what is useful, what is meaningful, what has value. So that is one area where our approach to truth has changed or approach to understanding reality in the 20th century culture or intellectual thinking. The second he mentions is the logic of Hegel, the logic of Hegel, the philosopher Hegel. Basically what Hegel says and Schafer refers to his dialectical thinking is that truth is being discovered in history in the process of history that we see at one stage in history what we might call a thesis. But then a reaction to that develops an antithesis, its opposite, opposed to the thesis. But then as history moves forward the thesis and the antithesis come together to form a synthesis so history is progressing it's moving upwards. That synthesis in turn becomes a new thesis generates its own antithesis and then moves onward. Now for Hegel that was Hegel's key if you like for understanding history. Again this appears to deny that truth and falsehood are opposed to it. Truth is something which is in the process of becoming, of being realized as history unfolds itself. Now it would be a second part of the intellectual climate we might say of the new theology. The third issue that Schafer mentions is some of the changes that have taken place in modern science. He points out that in science up to the end of the 19th century there had been a confidence that human beings could totally understand the universe with the power of human reason. And that as some scientists turned away from God they saw reason simply as a tool for a complete understanding, a complete comprehension of physical reality. But then he points out that as modern science has developed in the 20th century the old rationalistic approach to physical reality has had to give way to a rather different understanding. And he mentions several things here. He mentions how physicists have had to come to terms with light being both waves and particles, ideas which appear to be in antithesis to each other, which appear to be opposed to each other, which appear to be paradoxical. We have to say our complementary but we have to say both are true so that in the area of science instead of talking about antithesis or paradox we have to talk about complementarity to complementary truths. He mentions as well Einstein's theory of relativity that is that the motion of objects is relative to each other. If you think for example of throwing a, if you standing on the ground and you throw a baseball ball at a wall at 15 miles an hour, but then if you are on a moving platform that is moving at 5 miles an hour towards the wall the baseball goes at 20 miles an hour. Or if you have two cars that are traveling towards each other at 100 miles an hour there's speed relative to each other is 200 miles an hour. That was part of Einstein's theory of relativity. By some thinkers that was understood to mean that everything in the universe becomes relative. That because velocity is relative to the observer that then other aspects of our understanding of reality become relative as well and was applied to then are thinking about everything that everything is relative to the position of the observer, that not just velocity of a ball being thrown at me or of a car coming towards me being dependent on how fast I am moving. But that our understanding of everything is relative to the observer. Now we may say that's an inappropriate use of the theory of relativity, but in many people's minds the theory of relativity appeared to take away the certainty of being able to know anything with any objectivity rather it depends upon the subject. He mentions as well Heisenberg's uncertainty principle that there are elements of uncertainty in the basic structure of reality. But if we look at the atomic structure of things we cannot predict absolutely what the various particles in the sub-automic structure are going to do. We can only predict with a level of probability what any individual particle will do. We have no absolute certainty. Now Schaefer doesn't develop any of these points in detail here, although he would develop them much later. He simply points out for this background that what is happening in science in the 20th century really from the time of Einstein onwards. I guess it was 1905, 1906 something like that. He first made public his theory of relativity, his special theory of relativity in 1916, his general theory. Schaefer doesn't talk about these in detail. He just points out that they have changed the way that what science has done, that science in its different approach recognizing that it doesn't have certain knowledge about everything, that there is an element of relativity in its knowledge. An element of uncertainty that in some areas it's dealing with probability rather than an absolutely determinable reality that this has changed the way people begin to think. It has encouraged an attitude of relativity towards all knowledge that what we understand is relative to the observer, to the person, to the subject. Fourthly he looks at the social sciences, just very briefly. And of course this was an area in particular which he would develop much more fully later. He says that what is happening in the social sciences is that as they treat human beings just like objects, things to be studied. But the sociologist for example will do a statistical survey and he will say 60% of the people do this. And from that is, from that description of what is, what people do, the sociologist will then create an ought. But if 60% of the people think premarital sex for example is right and that's what they practice, then it is right. Of course he was to develop this idea of sociological law or sociological morality in much more detail later on. He just mentions it very briefly here. But again this is a part of the background of the new theology that there is a relativism in other words in ethics and law in our culture.

And then fifthly finally here he mentions the arts just very briefly in a short paragraph that in the arts, in the modern arts particularly in painting and in music, there is a message of the uncertainty and the unrelatedness of all things that the arts in particular reflect where the general culture is at, that it has an uncertainty about what is seen with the eye, that its message begins to become very subjective. So it's hard for me to look at a painting and say for example with that one on the wall what is that painting intended to be, my response to it has to be entirely subjective. I don't think any of us would probably agree if we were to say that is what that particular painting is. And the same thing would be true with many examples of modern art that one saw. The response to them is subjective because one is uncertain what the artist was trying to portray and also a lack of relatedness in modern art. And again he doesn't develop this. The next time we can look at the first article he wrote on art and to see what he has to say in more detail there. So he gives these five examples in relationship to logic and tithesis of pragmatism, first of all hegaly and dialectic secondly science and relativity, the social sciences and statistical surveys of people's behavior to determine morals and law and find the arts. And he suggests that these are the background that this intellectual background is the context in which the new theology is to be understood. The one shouldn't look at the new theology and just see well here are some theologians who have invented out of their own heads a new theology for the 20th century. The theology has to be understood against this background of where the general culture is that it is simply in fact a reflection of that culture. Now he goes on then in the article to ask what will this produce as theology as neo-orthodoxy as the new modernism takes into its bloodstream so to speak this intellectual climate what effect will this produce for its approach to Christian faith to theology. And he makes a series of points here again he doesn't set them down in number and I've tried to just extract them from the article. The first thing it produces is to say that his Christianity can be true religiously even if one might say it's historically false. The Garden of Eden for example describes for us man as a sinner though it is not necessary to regard it as being a historical account of how man became a sinner. It simply describes the human condition so it may have no historical content but it is religiously true or that we may say we are uncertain about the historical events of Jesus' life of the Jesus of history but that doesn't matter for what we may think about the Christ of faith. So that this first consequence of the new theologies reflecting on its culture is that a thing can be if you like false and true at the same time history and faith do not necessarily have to accord to be able to hold on to Christian doctrine. So we could say the first opposition which is produced is one of history versus faith. The second thing we find is that theology may be full of contradictions. And he says in particular as you look at Barthian and Nehobartian theology it appears to rejoice in contradictions and in paradoxes. The more contradictions the more paradoxes there are the better.

But it's sometimes difficult to die down and say this is exactly what this theologian means. If you look for example at the discussion that Buzzwell and Schaeffer are wanted to have this had with Karl Barth he appears to contradict himself in the discussion when he's talking about the doctrine of the Trinity and the person of Christ for example. And he doesn't seem to mind that at all. It's the same when you read some of Barth's writing. It's very difficult to pin it down and say this is what he's saying rather than that. And it becomes extremely difficult to understand. In other words the new theology does not require, does not require of itself that it be logically meaningful. Paradox doesn't matter to it because theology isn't a completely different area from rationality, from logic. So he may say that the second opposition that the new theology allows is one of logic over against faith. Again the idea taken from science but really a misapplication of it that you can have complementary truths which appear to be in opposition to each other. They may appear to be logically false but they will be true anyway. Now I think that's simply a misunderstanding of science because whenever science faces something like that it just means it doesn't have a big enough picture of the particular thing to understand why it is the way it is. And that there is a higher resolution let's say to a problem like the problem of light being waves and particles. But what appears to be a paradox of contradiction isn't so when we have more knowledge. But new orthodox theology rejoices in paradoxes and contradictions and sees no necessity whatsoever to have logic and faith standing together. The third area which he mentions is that the new theology as it reflects on and is shaped by the intellectual climate says that it's impossible for us ever to possess truth. The theologian and he quotes I think it is Bruno and the article says truth might possess us but we can never possess truth. Now that sounds a wonderful statement and one might say there's a question, there's a sense in which that is true that Christ is the truth that he possesses me far more completely than I possess him. Or we might put it another way if we're thinking about ideas and say that we don't know, we don't understand God or any aspect of his revelation perfectly or completely. So we don't possess it in that sense of having a total grasp on it. That's nearly really not quite what the new orthodox theologian meant by that statement. What he was dismissing really was the possibility of having certain knowledge at all. And shape of later on was to make the distinction between having truth but not having exhaustive truth which he doesn't make at this point but it became one of his favorite statements later on that because God has spoken to us as possible for us to have true understanding even though it's not exhaustive understanding. Propositional statements in Scripture as he was to call them later which are really true though they are not exhaustive. One of the things that this meant in the orthodox thinking was that apologetics were dismissed altogether in Carbide's teaching for example. It is seen almost as sacrilegious to seek to reason about God or to argue about God or to seek to persuade people that Christianity is true. Rationality and faith I seem to have nothing to do with each other. I cannot reason with somebody. There is simply the response of faith, the leap of faith and the expression of shape was to use later. He speaks about this here they are not in those terms that the individual is called simply to respond without necessarily being given any reason whatsoever on which to respond. So there is no rationality where faith is concerned so he may say that reason and faith are set over against each other. There are no reasons as to why we should believe we are simply compelled to believe by our own encounter with God and with his word. So truth cannot be possessed, apologetics are dismissed, one cannot rationally discuss God or the evidences for his existence there is simply the response of faith. One of the fascinating things I think in all this is how all these ideas have become a part of so much evangelical Christianity today. Without people even being aware of it. That's perhaps something we could talk about on another occasion. I think as most people in our culture think of Christianity as religion rather than truth and even most people in our churches think about Christianity as religion rather than truth. It's just an indication of how deeply affected by these ideas people are in our churches without being aware of it and everybody would want to deny that they are near Orthodox. Or that they are near modernist but in fact this is very deeply a part of what Christianity in this culture has become. Fourthly he says this produces the denial of biblical authority. The Bible is said to contain the word of God rather than being the word of God. It becomes very difficult in the Orthodox thinking to identify a particular passage of Scripture with the word of God. The word of God is when I encounter God in reading Scripture. The word of God cannot be identified with the text itself. It's rather with what happens as I read Scripture but it's almost as if I was struck by lightning. Shavey uses this expression here. A crisis takes place as I hear the word preached or as I read the word in Scripture and then I encounter the word of God. He carefully points out and this was to become a much bigger theme in his writing later on that the essential word here is the word existential. From page 8 in the right hand column he quotes a theologian H.T. Carr or Carr, halfway down that right hand column page 8. The crisis at the moment is evidenced by the transition from an older traditional authority in terms of an erincy and verbal infallibility to the current existential view that the word of God has somehow written and yet apart from the words of the Bible. And Shavey comments this last quotation is especially important because the term existential is that which the pure subjectivists in art and music also apply to themselves. He recognizes that that word existential is used in philosophy. It's used in art and music to for the artists and philosophers to describe their own thinking. That it's not what is objectively true that matters. It is my existential response this moment in time that matters. Now he points out that with this view of Scripture no matter how wonderful it may be made to sound, often people will say well we're not interested in worshipping the Bible. That's a kind of bibliology and idolatry of the Bible. It's not the text that matters to us. It's the message which comes to us from God through the text, which is another way of saying the same kind of thing. And that can sound very wonderful of course what we're all interested in is the message that God is communicating to us but it's very carefully denying that the text as it is written is actually the authoritative word of God. What this inevitably leads to is a subjective approach to Scripture and to authority. He quotes Bruner for example and says basically what you end up with is a position which says what becomes authoritative is what feels to me to be in accord with the Spirit of Christ. That would be one determiner of what has authority but as I read Scripture and I am struck that some part of Scripture is in accord with the Spirit of Christ then that is the word of God to me. And of course this is a totally subjective position. And again you'll see how that has crept today increasingly in evangelical thinking. Think of much of what's read about the whole discussion of men and women in the family and in the church have come to this position. That's exactly the words almost of Paul Jewett in his book Man is male and female when he writes that basically the teaching of Paul on the structure and authority is not in accord with the Spirit of Christ. Those are almost as exact words and therefore we dismiss it we see at this point that Paul was not in tune with the Spirit of Christ. Now of course that's a completely subjective interpretation. It's dependent on either on my own individual response to decide what is the Spirit of Christ or it's dependent upon where our culture stands at the moment and that's usually what it's dependent on. If our culture says any view of structure in marriage or in the church is something which is not possibly right then the 20th century Christian will read Scripture and say this is not in accord with the Spirit of Christ. What he's actually saying is it's out of tune with the Spirit of the Age but that has nothing to do with understanding the authority of Scripture. It's a completely subjective, relativistic approach to Scripture and he points out as well, Schaeffer points out as well, how in the end the neo-orthodox theologian is bound to accept current thinking as also being God's word. And he quotes some Niebuhr at the bottom of page 8 on the top of column, column 9, where Niebuhr says that secular idealism speaks the word of God on occasion. Secular idealism speaks the word of God on occasion. Once you deny the biblical text as having authority, you are driven necessarily into a subjective position and allowing the culture to have insights which you're going to regard as God's word today. So this is the 4th point. It sets the subjective over against the objective instead of an objective word from God which is open to all and to which almost submit we have a subjective word of God where we have to determine which Scripture, if any, speaks God's word to us today. And of course our thinking will be very much shaped by our culture. The 5th point he makes is that the new theology against the background of the culture inevitably becomes relativistic but ecumenism will necessarily overlook theological differences. The 1st you've said truth cannot be known or the truth appears like Hagel in the process of history's development. You're no longer in a position where you have to say this theological position is true and that theological position is false. It becomes possible to synthesize all theological positions. And he says this is exactly what you see in the World Council of Churches in the ecumenical movement. The truth becomes unimportant. But unity bringing people together is seen as more important than truth. So this would be the next opposition that unity stands over against truth, that would be the 5th opposition which he suggests you get in neo-orthodox theology. The 6th point he makes is this that in practice any kind of neo-orthodox theology or new modernism is almost bound to become centered upon political involvement and action. Rather than the gospel which is proclaimed in the New Testament. But once you have abandoned the biblical gospel and the Bible as God's word but you are driven towards seeing some particular purpose here and now in the transformation of society as being the primary calling of the Christian. And in this context he points out that inevitably two people who are shaped by these ideas will lose their perspective, their political thinking will become relative as well. He points out how Carl Bart was equally critical of the Soviet Union and the United States. There is a loss of perspective that instead of looking at the appalling brutalities of Stalin's regime in which Solzhenitsen says 60 million people were killed and saying here is a form of government, a dealing with society which is a polingly totalitarian which is unbelievably wicked and the United States for all of its faults and for all of its weaknesses has a better political and social system that what you inevitably find is a loss of perspective. So that the Soviet Union and the United States are seen as basically being equally bad or equally good whichever way you want to look at it. And he suggests that what one more find in most people in neo-orthodoxy is an inevitable drift to the left because the left feels that it can create human programs to solve the problems of society to create a new utopia. So this is the secretary he suggests that there is a loss, there will be a loss of perspective in terms of political and social thinking. The seventh result which he sees of the influence of the climate on the new theology is that it will be driven to a confusion morally, it will be driven to moral confusion. For the neo-orthodox theologian instead of being able to speak a clear word from God which says let's say adultery is wrong, homosexual practices against the commandment of God, abortion is wrong or whatever it may happen to be. But once the neo-modernism has forsaken the Bible as an authoritative word all it will do is add to the moral confusion of society. So that has most certainly happened in the last 40 years since Shaffer wrote this paper, many of the churches, particularly those on the liberal side, have not helped at all in the moral confusion of our culture. They have simply increased it, I myself met hundreds and hundreds of young people who said that their pastors have been totally unhelpful to them when they've been facing moral dilemmas and moral challenges in their own life because they've had no sure where to give them. There is simply relativism, so this would be a seventh point that there is the rejection of absolute, moral absolutes in the favor of relativism morally as the new theology is influenced by the culture of the 20th century. And finally number eight, the eighth point that Shaffer makes here as he thinks about the new theology is that it will have no final grant to stand on in dismissing the subjectivism of old modernism. One of Bart's own major contributions was to look at the liberal theology of the 19th century and dismiss it as being completely subjective. I think it was he who made the famous statement that the 19th century liberal theologians looked down the well of history at Jesus and they saw their own faces looking back up from the bottom. Basically they all remodeled Jesus in their own image. And if you go to any theological books or any used bookstore and you pick up the lives of Jesus in the 19th century, he reflects simply the political and social commitments of the individual who wrote the book. The Jesus they found in the New Testament with the Jesus they wanted to find, the Jesus who reflected their own priorities. And Bart makes a tremendously powerful criticism of 19th century liberalism in its quest for the historical Jesus at that point that it became totally subjective in its approach to Scripture and its approach to the person of Christ. But Shafers has basically the new modernism has gone down exactly the same path even though it appears to reject that subjectivism by saying that there is a transcendent word from God. In the end it is equally subjective but it may stand in the pulpit and thunder this is the voice of God but the voice of God is just a babble of different voices depending upon the individual theologian who is speaking. And of course that's what we found in the next few years there was another quest of the historical Jesus and there were a whole new series of theologies which vary quite radically from each other as we look at the different voices of neo-orthodox theology. Because each of them each of them has a different encounter with the word each of them presents a different voice of God thundering to the church. So he says even though it rejects subjectivism the rejects subjectivism of the old liberalism it ends up basically in the same position because it has no objective authority. It may claim to have an objective authority but in the end it is subjective because it depends upon the individual recognizing God speaking to him rather than being able to say this is the word of God written in Scripture. So this is his final criticism that having been shaped by the intellectual climate of the 20th century neo-orthodoxy descends into subjectivism. He finishes with his article with a plea to the Christian, the evangelical Christian to have a consistency in thinking and a consistency in living to have a worldview which is conformed to God's revelation in Scripture, otherwise not conformed to the intellectual climate of the 20th century but conformed to God's revelation of Himself in Scripture. He challenges us to develop a Christian mind and to have a consistency of living as well but it's not enough for us just to say no to neo-orthodoxy but we have to give ourselves in sacrifice for other people including those called in neo-orthodox theology that we must commit ourselves to the unreserved giving of ourselves to other people. He met himself many young people in Europe and I would say there is an increasing number of them in our society here in the United States as well at the present time, it's come here a little bit later than it came to Europe. Who are not simply in the position of saying I have a dogmatic commitment to atheism, I am sure that there is no God and I am sure that the universe is simply a material universe and this is how it arose by evolution and this is where it's going and this is what it means in my life. He is suggesting that he had met many people who were beyond that stage and who feel that knowledge of anything or belief in anything is impossible but everything we know is uncertain. Well, if you've read any existentialist literature, what he's describing is young people who are deeply influenced by the existentialist position which starts off with not a series of positive statements, I believe in man, I believe in freedom, I believe in science like humanism which are fundamentally optimistic statements and we haven't got God and now we have man instead, we don't have a word from God. Therefore we have morals developed from man, we're not created by a divine determiner, we are completely free so you don't have that kind of optimistic belief in a universe without God. What you have really is existentialism which goes one step further and says if there isn't God then we have nothing left to believe in and we don't even know if we know anything at all so that one is in a position of complete uncertainty, one becomes uncertain. One becomes uncertain whether one can know anything at all. Now, I don't think that it's necessary to have read existentialist literature to come to that position. That was the position I came to myself as a non-Christian at university before I had read a great deal of existentialist literature or anything like that. It's simply part of the air we breathe in this culture that we are in a situation where there is just simply a lack of certainty, a feeling that knowledge, true knowledge about who we are and why we're here is really impossible, that one just simply doesn't know anything and therefore you're unsure about everything. You're not making positive statements, there's no God, I'm man, I'm free, that's fine, that's wonderful because that's fundamentally a very optimistic view or it appears to be a reality in the older humanism. But one is in a position of just being uncertain, I think a great deal of the more extreme forms of modern popular music have to be understood that way. If you look at punk just as one illustration, that you don't have really a positive belief in anything, you just simply have a series of negative statements of outrage, of despair, of distress, of uncertainty. About our life, and I think that is becoming an increasingly greater part of the culture in which we live. I think one of the reasons why so many young people and not just young people are open to taking cocaine, for example, and this is an enormous problem my boys at school yesterday had a talk on cocaine, where the doctor who works with drug addict said that he believes that it's the greatest single problem that the United States has faced in the several hundred years of its history and it's begun to become very much greater. He said there were several hundred thousand babies last year that were born here as cocaine addicts, his mothers have been taking cocaine and he was talking about the tremendous problems of it in terms of coming off cocaine. And the total lack of interest in anything that it produces once you've taken cocaine and become addicted to it. And I feel as you look at a phenomenon like that, just simply telling people not to take drugs doesn't do anything, telling them how dangerous drugs are, really does nothing because we're in a situation where people no longer have anything to believe in or any reason why they should do anything. You really are a drift as he says in a black sea on a black sea in a black night. Now that's really the heart of what existentialism says. And what existentialism really tried to say was not we are teaching a philosophy for people to follow, what it was really saying was we are simply articulating where people are at in a world which has said God doesn't exist. That's not an optimistic world, it's a desperate world. And so the existentialist writers like Sartre and Kamu did not feel that they were trying to lead people in the direction of existentialism. They simply felt they were articulating where the society already was in a state of uncertainty and certainly that's where I was without reading those things. And for any of you who have ever been in a situation like that, it really is desperate. You do feel like you're on a black sea in a black night. You know, nothing seems worth doing. There is nothing that you can get up the energy to feel strongly enough about to pursue. You are just left with a feeling of alienation, alienation from your fellow human beings, alienation from one's studies at university, from one's teachers, just alienation from life itself. And just a complete uncertainty about who one is or whether one has any value at all. And it's a very desperate feeling. He uses this expression here. To them, the world is a mass of flying unrelated particles and they feel upon the necessity of running away and standing still at the same time. I think he summed up perfectly. And the reason why he says it in these stark terms is because he met a lot of young people who spoke this way. But again, that's exactly how I felt. You know, I would find myself sometimes, you know, on the street, just feeling like running away, but running away from what? You know, from the people around me. They didn't know me. They weren't people to run away from. But you just, you just get a desperate sense that you've got to run somewhere, but there isn't any way to run. You know, because you've got nothing to run to. And in a way, you don't know what you're running from. You, you are, you're running from life itself really. But as he says, you're standing still at the same time because you know you've got nowhere to go. And I think he is simply articulating here what was true of many young people he met in Europe. And in Europe, this was already true in the 1940s. And it's now become an increasingly, an increasingly major part of our culture everywhere in the West. And I would say it's true in Eastern Europe as well. I'm just in Western Europe. Because the whole foundation of our civilization has been a view of a universe in which God exists, which God has created into which God acts. And where there are moral foundations, therefore we are, we are created to live for certain reasons, to live in a certain way, with a purpose which isn't even discussed, which was taken for granted. And this was true for people whether they were Christians individually or not, because of course, you can look at any period of history and say, you can't say those people were Christian because many of them weren't individually. But there was a structure, a meaning of purpose to people's lives, which wasn't even thought about. It was just part of the context in which people lived. In our society increasingly today for more and more people, it's already been that way for 50 years in Europe. There simply isn't that meaning or order or purpose or background. You don't have to be an intellectual. You don't have to go to university. You don't have to read existential literature to end up in that position. You simply end up there because you've got nothing else. That is where the culture is. But I think this is really important because sometimes people will read Shaefer and they'll think, well, he is writing about a tiny minority of intellectual students who've had the misfortune to study under existentialist professors at university. That simply isn't true. He's simply describing the state of desperation of our society. And it manifests itself in all sorts of forms of people trying desperately to make some meaning from their life by either drugs or alcohol or sex or just buying things or whatever it is. But a feeling of complete, really uncertainty about who we are and what we're doing here and what we're for. I would say simply a modern disease. It's a disease in the literal sense of the term. It's a dis-ease with one's existence because people don't know who they are because the whole roots of the culture have gone. Shaefer really pinpoints the cause here in the article by saying it's because people in our society are no longer believe in God. He lays the fault of the churches, of the door of the churches, that many of the churches, and this happened in a much greater way than here. So if you look at the churches in England and West Germany and France, they became dominated by Scandinavia. They became dominated by liberal teaching much earlier than here already in the 18th century. In England, much of the church was daistic in its teaching. It didn't believe in the supernatural. It was declared in the Bible. It simply believed in a creator who then left the universe to run alone and it rejected many of the supernatural elements of Christianity. Now, the effects of that on the culture were delayed by the evangelical revival under Wesleyan Whitfield in the 18th century, where just masses and masses of people turned back to genuine Christianity. But already by the middle of the 19th century, by the 1850s, liberal teaching began to become more and more dominant in the churches all over Western Europe. And it was a gospel that basically had nothing to say to people. It denied all the supernatural elements of Christianity. People were left with nothing to live for in terms of what Christianity really has to offer. Either in terms of a God who gives a meaning and purpose to our lives or salvation or any kind of moral foundation or anything else. And increasingly, people just simply stopped going to church. In England, for example, the greatest part of the Methodist church had almost ceased to exist by 1900. There were still Methodist churches, but it became over 90% liberal by the end of the 19th century. So there are vast areas of England where like when I grew up as a little boy in England in the late 40s and early 50s, where there was not just one generation but already two or three generations of people who hadn't gone to church because there was nothing to go to church for. Some people might still go at Christmas and Easter just out of habit. But already when I was small in the 1940s and 50s and this was true all over Western Europe, the great majority people didn't go to church. So today it's 5% of the people and now the number is climbing to 5% at this time. But, for example, in the village where I was working in England, one could assume that most of the children, when we were trying to reach we had a project every summer for kids in the village which 100 kids came to, that most of the children knew absolutely nothing about the Bible and that their parents knew nothing about it and that their grandparents knew nothing about it. You'd already got three generations of people who were totally ignorant. Now what does our society put in its place? It doesn't have anything to put in its place. It may offer material well-being, it may offer education, it may offer science, but those don't feel a person's heart in terms of giving them a sense of this is what life is worth living for this. You can take it, for example, in England at the moment, where there's been somewhat of an economic resurgence under Mrs. Thatcher's leadership. It was a survey in Britain last year in one of our popular Sunday newspapers, The Observer, which asked people a lot of questions like, are you better off under Mrs. Thatcher's government? And the majority of people responded, yes, we have more money, our lives are more secure now, etc. And then there are some other series of questions, are you any happier? No. Are you more selfish? Yes. And people really understand where they're at that they really don't have anything finally to live for, they don't know who they are, they're just at sea. In a universe in which there is no meaning ultimately, they're not just one generation away from biblical Christianity, they're three or four generations away from biblical Christianity, even the memory of it has disappeared completely for most people in Western Europe. So you go to France to work there, for example, and the great majority of people you meet are completely cynical people, deeply cynical. They are existentialists in the deepest possible way, they don't trust themselves, they don't trust other people, they are alienated people. At a very, very deep level they may have never read existential literature. And this is what the existentialists were trying to say if you read William Barrett or Sartre or Camus, or any of those other writers called Jasper's. In their writings, what they're trying to do is to just simply describe what has happened in our culture. They aren't the founders of a philosophy which says this is something new to believe in, follow us. They are describing the human condition. That's why they're works. The most accessible works of theirs are our plays, paintings, music, novels, short stories, which were incredibly popular because they rang a bell in people's minds. When I started reading existential literature, it was after I'd already come to that position and I read those things or I went to see films, I remember going to see for example who's afraid of Virginia Woolf and blow up. And a couple of Bergman films, the silence, I remember was one I saw. And I found them personally just totally overwhelming because they expressed where I already was that really the universe is silent, like Bergman's film, the universe is silent, that nothing one does has any meaning or in the film blow up. For example where there's a wonderful image in the film of what human life is really like, there are two people playing tennis on a tennis court if you've seen that film. It's really worth seeing because it describes what existentialism is. There are two people playing tennis on a tennis court and he's watching them and he realizes they don't have a ball. They're playing back and forth without a ball and they hit the non-ball out of the court. He's walking past, he shrugs his shoulders and he picks up the ball that isn't there and he throws it back in. It's just tremendously profound statement that life is nothing more than a meaningless game that there are rules for playing tennis, if you like, and there are rules for life. You might as well shrug your shoulders and just carry on but there's nothing really happening that wasn't even a ball there. The other theme of that film is the film was advertised as murder without guilt and love without meaning, something like that. I don't remember exactly what the posters said, but there's a murder in the film but you're never sure whether the murder really took place. You really don't know what happened, whether it happened or not. There's no guilt connected with it and in the relationships between people, between the man and the woman, there's no love, there's just sex without any meaning. I remember seeing those films and I was already in a state of feeling like my life is just completely meaningless. I'm just a drift here and when I saw those films, they had an incredible effect on me of articulating brilliantly what I hadn't been able to articulate myself about where I was. They were really devastating and I knew many people who had the same response to them, who really were, just driven even deeper into the position they were, but those films were so popular because they reflected where people are at. I would say it's the same with some of the wilder forms of modern music which are extremely bizarre. You can think of a group like the sex pistols, for example. They are reflecting what people feel. They ring a bell in people's minds. But fundamentally what's behind it, and this is what Schaefer was saying, was the church has stopped preaching Christianity. And in this article he's suggesting that the new modernism will not help because it isn't based on biblical truth, ultimately. It is just faith in an upper story as he came to call it later without any roots in history or in reality or in reason. And while it may seem to offer something, after a while it will prove to be an equal dead end and it has been. You go to churches today in Europe which teach new Orthodox theology, and they are just as empty as the old liberal churches. It gave the appearance of life for a while, but it didn't have a gospel which was going to save people. Now in the United States it all came a bit later because the evangelical church here was very much stronger when liberalism came into the church, into the theological schools and universities. There was a much greater resistance by the evangelicals to liberalism when it came and attempt to stand up and teach against it. There weren't really people in Britain, anywhere else in Western Europe, like Warfield and like Machen, for example, and others like them who stood up and said, this is what is true, there are reasons not to believe that the biblical faith is still perfectly acceptable, we can trust in God's word. There simply weren't people like that of that stature in Western Europe. And the church here remained very much stronger. But gradually the same thing has happened to many many in this culture, to those who are without any solid biblical teaching. They end up in the same position, the position of just being really uncertain about who we are as human persons. I think what is really striking about Schaeffer was that he saw these things so much earlier than many other Christians did in terms of where they were leading. I think that was simply because he had a sensitivity to individuals outside the church. He always had a tremendous and very deep commitment to evangelism. He had never been a Christian who was shut up in the church with no contacts outside. As you look back through any stage of his ministry, he was a person who was constantly having relationships with people outside, reaching out to his neighbors to the people around him. And he kept in touch with ordinary people where they were at. When he went to Europe, he discovered that the ordinary people that he was meeting there were several further stages further down the road than here in the United States. And in the position of just real hopelessness and things have just simply got worse since that time. There's a superficial prosperity in Western Europe at the present time, but it rests upon a void in terms of where people are at.