<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Lahjoita Lahjoita kuukausittain

The Spiritual Theology of Sonship

February 21, 2008
0:000:00

A little bit more formal than what we've been doing in the past here and will also be doing it in a way that will be hopefully a little more useful as well. In the sense that I'm going to try to speak about this in as fast as I possibly can. Normally what I do is sort of talk around subjects and say a little bit dear, a little bit there, dance around it, let it go, but that's not what we're going to do at this point. So what we're going to do instead is I'm going to try to give you some outline about this topic that I think will be of some significance if I can just get the computers to work. Do you have to put this on here, Frank? Okay, the question we'll just start on this and what we're going to try to do here is to talk about this, let me talk about it and then we'll discuss it afterwards, okay? Does that make sense? Let me talk first. Are there any extra things? I don't know. Are there any extra things? No, I'll wall it. I think I've ripped them off. Do you have any extras of these? This one? Is this an extra user? Yes. If you need it, go ahead and take it. Okay. If you don't need it though, I can use it. I think I've just torn my pants. Nothing's going to make that much money I have. Okay. Let's just start off by praying that we'll get right into this. You think it's working now. You're getting a newbie room? Let's try it again. You are getting a newbie room. I don't know. I don't know. Okay. One can read for. One can read for. One can read for. One can read for. One can read for. One can read for. One can read for. Okay. Okay. Welcome. Let's pray. Laura, we're here to study this aspect of spiritual theology today and what we're asking for is the ability to use wisdom and caution but at the same time to say things that will be helpful and proved beneficial in moving your people to this very important area of our faith. Also, we're asking for your blessing now. It's going to be important to have that because, how does not have a chance is getting anyone to help here. So please bless us now on that. Okay, I've entitled the lecture, the spiritual theology ofirsin and I'll be explaining that at spiritual theology just a moment because it's not one we use very frequently around here. That's for sure. spiritual, and theology don't seem to go to hand-to-hand around here very much, do they? No, thank good. But there are going to be three main topics. The first one is going to be the background of Sunship Spiritual Theology. Secondly, dimensions of Sunship Spiritual Theology and then third, an evaluation of the Sunship Spiritual Theology. And when I use this word of Sunship, I hope you understand that I'm talking about this movement that is growing in significance and popularity, especially in my own denomination of PCA, but also in others, and that it stems primarily from the work of Jack Miller and his wife and a few others, and it is closely associated often with World Harvest missions and those sorts of things, all of whom and all of which I love and adore immensely. But at the same time we need to take a look at this in a way I think that might give us a little more perspective on it than often comes, as I hear these things discussed. So let's talk first about the background of Sunship Spiritual Theology. You know, when you think about theology and how theology is normally taught, there really are at least three areas that we need to be concerned with. And one of those is the concerns of believers of relationship to their beliefs. And this we can call the consensual focus of theology, or another way to put that in more traditional terminology would mean to say that this is what we call doctrinal theology, our doctrinal theology. And then another area of life that our theology is very important is believers in relation to their performance of their faith, that is their activities, a behavioral focus, which is by and large we'll be concerned with when we talk about moral theology. There might follow me at that point. Those are the things we're used to. We normally think about these things when we think about Christianity and about doing Christian theology, the study of it in a place like this, like a seminary. But at the same time, there's a dimension of Christian faith that in our tradition, especially, is ignored in formal theological education. Now this is not ignored in other traditions, but it is by and large in our own tradition here at Reform Seminary. And that is what we can call the believer, the concern of believers in relation to profound experiences of God. I don't know how else to put that. There's no simple nomenclature to put that in, so I'm just calling it profound experiences of God. I'm assuming in other words that there's a sentence in which we're constantly experiencing God. Every moment of every day we're experiencing God, in some fashion or another, everything we're driving your cars, you're sitting in an air-conditioned room, is an experience of God. But these are more dramatic, is what I have in mind, or more profound, or light-shattering, light-changing, light-altering. And this we could call the Aspective Focus. And the word Aspect, I mean that juices actually are flowing through your body, that there are chemicals in your bloodstream, and in the fluid of your brain, that are causing certain kinds of emotional experiences. I don't mean we're thinking about having an emotional experience, I mean we are having it. I don't mean that we are thinking about God. I mean we are meeting God in a profoundly emotional or affective way. Not meeting God so much intellectually, that is thinking about it, having to change our concepts. Not so much even meeting Him in the arena of doing things for Him, like going out on the street and being moral and things like that. But instead, thinking about this direct encounter with God, much like you find in the Bible when Isaiah says in Isaiah 6, woe is me, or I am a man of life and then it's among the people of life and then this. That was an affective experience that is. That makes sense. It was a profound experience of God. It was not a simple intellectual statement or statement of fact, nor was it even Him trying just to do the right thing as a moral sin. He was expressing a profound experience of God. So these would be three areas, at least three of the main areas of the study of theology, as we think about it in traditional Christian circles. Now of course as we all know, the conceptual and behavioral have been emphasized a lot in our tradition. The affective is the one that is neglected the most in our tradition and thus the accusation of the person chosen. So let's talk first about conceptual or doctrinal theology, believers, thinking about how believers relate to their beliefs in the study of theology. If we were to think about what parts of our curriculum here at this seminary and a typical reform seminary focus on this aspect of theology, we'd have to say that theology division would be probably the first of them all. They're the ones that teach us what we're supposed to believe about God and what duty He requires of us. The biblical division does that a little bit, but we tend to scamper around dealing with introductory matters so much that we get around to telling you what you ought to believe occasionally we do. That's why they're number two and I'm also trying to be humble from some individual division. The practical division however really has relatively speaking little to do with conceptualization and has a whole lot more to do with the practice of religion. And in other words it's true that when you take a leadership course here that you're going to get ideas because you can never do anything without all the others. But at the same time you can understand the focus of the practical department is not on this conceptual doctrinal dimension of faith. These are the main concerns of a seminary education. That's why you came here because this is what you wanted. You wanted people to tell you what you should believe. So you came here not all of you. Not all of us, but a lot of them. Now there is another area that we've mentioned already the behavioral focus or the moral theology. And this of course would be those concerns that we have with relating believers to their performance of their faith, the doing of faith. The practical division here is supposed to be and I think in many respects is oriented toward this. They will ask questions like how do you do evangelism? How do you pray? How do you conduct the worship service? How do you, how do you, how do you, how do you, how do you. The skill levels are very important in the practical department. That's why it's called practice or practical because it is the doing of stuff. The build of a vision, how we talk about that a little bit maybe, especially in the arena of learning how to do Bible exercises. We teach skills or behaviors in that sense. That makes sense to you. It's a contrary to the typical or normal theology division. Now that John Train is here at RTS, things will change a little bit I suspect in this regard because John, like myself, is very concerned not simply to tell you what content of theology you should believe, but how to get there. That makes sense. Like we do in ITS. What are the tools of theology? What are the ridders of theology? What are the matters of which you are to perform theology? And that would then raise the theology division up a little bit in my estimation on this behavioral focus. But normally that's not the concern. Normally what you do is you simply learn what you're supposed to believe and so it's highly conceptual of this theology division. But the behavioral focus in the seminary certainly can be called the secondary concern of a normal reformed seminary education. That would be fair to say in your experience here. That's a reminder. They're all saying yes. These homologues courses are great because they each a little bit about how to preach, but it's pretty obvious that's not the center of our curriculum. They're intended to be counseling department the same thing that's practical, but it's not the center of our seminary doctrinal things are more central to us in sexual theology. This third aspect called by many spiritual theology where we're talking about how believers are to consider and to relate themselves to their profound experiences of God, spiritual theology, which is to produce a spirituality. Does that make sense? Spiritual theology that is to produce a spirituality with its affective focus is basically ignored at a seminary like ours. The practical division is more concerned with skills. That's what practice is for their concern, primarily skills. The biblical division we certainly don't care about how you feel. And the theology division I don't think they do much either. We make feeble attempts at this, and there are some fear attempts, but they're feeble because we haven't had a long tradition to build upon to help us in this area of the affective or the spiritual theological dimension of a seminary educational life or the development of a minister. It's nearly absent from our seminary education. I suppose some people would suggest that maybe the chapel services are designed to do that. The chapel is designed to enhance or to develop our profound experiences of God. But as you know here on this campus we only have chapel twice a week, and anytime we need to have extra time for an academic lecture the first thing it goes is the chapel hour given over to an academic lecture. And so it's quite remarkable how that's a case and also how chapel is not mandatory. It's not even considered all that important as to whether you go or not. It used to be that we would struggle with how to make that little more important on the campus, but it's difficult to do when we even as faculty are not particularly concerned with it. So chapel which is the one thing that is designed to create this affective focus, the spiritual focus, focusing on profound experiences of God is probably way down the list of where it needs to be in our seminary. And so you can see there's a result of it. The result is that you have professors in a seminary like this one who are teaching Christian men and women who are going into leadership in the church or teaching them a lot of doctrinal biology and they're teaching them a lot of behavioral or moral theology, little less the doctrinal but we've still got it. Okay? Well we are believing in certain God and what duty requires of us, that's our main concern. Then these students go out to churches and imitate what they saw in seminary which is always deadly. And they produce in their little churches an era of intellectualism and an era of legalism. Thinking this is true religion. Now after all it's what the pinnacle of Christian faith or Christian people, seminary professors, is what we thought was important, the intellectual and the moral. So it must be that that's what everyone should think is important, the intellectual and the moral. And the result of that of course is that in many of our churches we end up having an absent affective focus. It just simply is not there or it is so truncated. And you know how I often talk about that, truncated down to anger, guilt and determination. And we're guilty for our sins, we're determined to do better and we're angry at people who are not doing as well as we are. And that seems to be about the extent of our affective focus. But the absence, the sense of politeness that often comes up in our circles is genuinely the result of the educational process of the leaders of our churches. It's what you are trained to do. You are equipped to do what's on the screen right now, and very little other. So if you get out and cause this to happen, it will be because you're doing what we've taught you by example, as well as by emphasis, as well as by content in our courses, to do. If you do something other than this, it will be because you learn through hard knocks through your life, and this is why most of you are older will do better at this. If you do something other than it, it will be because you learned it from someplace other than Seminari. This is where a sunship steps in. A sunship theology in many respects is a corrective in what I call the Ocalmanist circles. Our denomination, PTA, OPC, Westminster Seminary, Reform Seminary, Coventry Seminary. The sunship movement is valued in these circles because it is a corrective to this absence of a focus on spiritual theology. We have no spiritual theology. We have no way of talking about the affective dimension of our faith. We don't even have categories to talk about how to have profound experiences of God. We don't even have the words. Much less the ability to actually instill that in people, exemplify it, lead people into it, develop it, enhance it. We don't even have words to describe it. If I get up here and talk about the Trinity, we all know what the Trinity is. We can go on and talk about other things. If I get up and talk about the order of salutes, everyone goes, yeah, I know what the order of salutes is. We can go on to other things. We can talk about and develop and work at those subjects. The problem when you come to spiritual theology is we can't even talk about it because we don't even have the words. Just the fact that we've had the search for some designation, called spiritual theology, and how uneasy and how strange that may seem to our ears illustrates the fact that we can't even talk about this easily. When you can even talk about it, how in the world can you hope to have great success in it? There's a lot that has to be done here. This, again, set the context for the Sonship Movement. Jack Miller was a professor at Westminster Seminary. Back in its heyday, the old Westminster, we would call it these days, I guess, basically the first and a half, 1.5 generation. There was some original people there, and then they were very old, but then there were people that were younger, they were there teaching as well. He saw this dead, dry orthodoxy in that seminary. I was part of that. He saw the dead, dry orthodoxy in his church. I was not in his denomination, but I was an assisted denomination that had the same problems. And he knew that something was wrong. I don't think he would have used the term spiritual theology or spirituality. But being a professor of practical theology, he was interested in giving students more than simply a set of skills, a set of preaching skills. He was interested in enhancing, can you believe this, enhancing their relationship with Christ, and actually making them aware that God is alive and working in their lives, and that there is an empowerment that can come from that, and a joy and a pleasure in life that can come from that, that can be Christ honoring, God honoring, and needs to be focused upon. Now, if, as we continue this talk, I start saying something that might not be entirely positive, you can understand that in this context, one would not expect a person to be able to come up with a spiritual theology that was perfect, when it's the first one that we have on our table. The first cave that you make is not going to be a perfect cave. The first car that you build will not be a perfect car. The idea here is not in the perfect. The idea is, is there anything valuable in it? That's why this lecture is entitled a sympathetic, what's it called? A sympathetic evaluation. A sympathetic evaluation is because at least they try to do something, rather than just telling us that what we need to do is think harder and do more. If we just think harder and do more, which is always the rhetoric that we receive from other sources, your problems in life are that you don't understand enough, and your problems in life are that you're not doing enough. And if you just do more and think more in the right ways, then you'll be happier, or you'll at least know that you're not supposed to be happy. You'll even find some satisfaction in life, or you'll become stoic and say, well, I'm never really expected to have any satisfaction in life. Miller, on the other hand, said, no, I just can't buy that. There's got to be something more to it. And as he articulated, I think what he had experienced himself in his own personal way, he did not articulate these things with a great deal of clarity, and not with a lot of attention to traditional categories, not even attempting at times, I think, to identify himself with a strand or a stream of tradition that would lead a person, or lead a group like ours, toward that same goal that he has. And rather, he just began to just do it, and just began to talk about it, a lot from his experience of these things, an articulated experience. And one of those experiences was the focus on the commentary of Lutheran Galatians. And we'll be talking about that in just a few moments. Are there any questions about this first part of what I've been saying here? The background of censorship, spiritual theology, any thoughts or issues, or do you want to say anything? Okay, good. Are there any similarities out there today, or any similarities? Are there any similarities out there that are insights into spiritual theology? In our tradition, no, it happens now. What about the other? Oh, yeah, sure. Plenty. Anglican. It's paleon, Roman Catholic. Pentecostal. You better believe that if you're in a pentecostal seminary, you'd be doing spiritual theology. Or you fail. If you're in an Episcopalian realm, and the pious is failing, Anglican is kind of an environment. You'd be in chapel every day, every single day. You'd be going to the liturgy every day. Three times a day. I have a friend that left here and went to an Anglican monastery in Michigan. And if it were like 9,000 times a day. Okay, and so, yeah. Here is a fasting, here is a prayer, all kinds of things. Following the liturgical calendar, so on and so on. So yeah, it does happen in other places. It just doesn't happen in our place. I don't know enough about the common on it. It has suspicion. But what they do is they go, they don't come to Christopheria for this, except for Peterson. You know, sort of a radical Christopheria for this thing. How about that? Is that fair to say? That's right. Okay. Can't play any more. Watch what it says. It's good. Yeah. Yeah. That's true. Yeah. I'm kind of interested. Could you say that you don't get it here? And yet, just in the years I've been here, and I was here in Lake Ignati. I mean, I see that it's a concern on part of the faculty. How close is RPS? It is a deep concern. It's a deep concern. Not only here, but at Kavanaugh, at Western Institute, at Trinity, at Knox, at Ringel, it's a very deep concern. Unfortunately, basically, we are impotent to do much of that. We don't have a theology. You find certain people like Hyper and others, and Jack Miller, who are Hyper, especially, harking back to Jonathan Edwards, and some out to John Owen and people like that. And, you know, that's wonderful, and that's good, because we need to start working on what our tradition has done on this. But these are the minority voices. And they're certainly not obvious to the faculty here what we should be doing. How bad. But the desire is there. There's no doubt about it. That would be hard to say. I would think that, in all likelihood, just from the discussions we've had in our faculty here, a lot of the concern has to do with the behavioral dimension. Why is it that our students have certain moral problems and certain behavioral issues that keep coming up? Again, again, again. Why is that the case? And the answer is, well, we don't think it's because we don't know enough, and it's not because we're not trying hard enough. It's got to be something else. And that's this character formation, we call it, okay? Or spiritual formation. But, again, the question is, okay, now what do you do? And the answer has been largely, we don't know, send him to Gary Road. The tradition of it, and you're not going to look outside of your tradition. Do you want to find it to be in your tradition? That is part of the problem here. And what Miller did, as we'll see in a moment, is he reached outside the tradition to Lutheran. Or to Luther, I should say. Okay? And, yeah, then there are others that will do similar things. I think this is a lot of what's going on in our region. We're talking about reaching into the Anglo-Catholic traditions to see how to do this. And I don't know what else we're going to do, frankly, because if you don't have a long-standing history of this, it attacks on them, even just attacks on them. Just a set of words to use. Describe things. I have to say profound experiences of God. But, well, what I really have, how would you say that in Latin? Well, I don't know. Okay. But, you know, that would be the point. We don't have it. Yeah. Yes, that's why I mentioned John Owen. That's why I mentioned John Edwards. But, yes, there are others as well. But, again, part of the problem here is that those are marginalized. Those dimensions of them, they are marginalized in our circles. And if you are really into, say, John Owen's teaching about the Holy Spirit, as soon as you start looking at that volume on the Holy Spirit, I think the reaction of most people at this seminary would be, what is really strange. And it gives us this list of 19,000 ways in which the Holy Spirit can fix people of sin. And interestingly enough, we're going to talk about this in a moment, but the mention of spiritual theology that our tradition tends to focus on is what we will call in a few moments, believe the belief side of it. The doctrinal side of it. It would be expected, right? There are a list of things that are more spiritual sounding. And that will make that a fixer. And also, behavior of some of the religious relationships that can be. It can be. Thinking God's thoughts, doing God's way, thinking, or feeling. It can be. It can be. That's why I'm just searching for words. Why not call it affective theology, be fun with me, except that we don't believe that affect is significant. So if I put more like spiritual on it, it might make it a little more important with people. I would personally agree. I don't do that. That's exactly the idea. Right, because I agree that it's all spiritual, it's all Holy spirit theology. I shouldn't agree with you more. But the problem is, again, it's an M.A. issue here. And I'm also using a more traditional word, and I use the word spiritual theology. Yes. What are the problems that you said that people were graduating here, later on the growth of heaven? Well, even while they're here. Moral problems, sectional problems, drinking too much. A lack of concern for the lost. Pickering with each other. A lack of interest in the mission of the church. I've often said here, I don't think we have a single martyr on their list of alumni from RTS. We may. I mean, I don't know. But I don't think we did. Now how a seminary can exist for 25 to 30 years and not produce one single martyr is amazing. Doesn't that just amaze you? You understand? I don't mean somebody that happened to die in an airplane on a mission trip. Okay? That's my idea of martyrdom. Am I going to die? I'm going to get big rewards for dying on an airplane on a mission trip. Now, I'm not going into martyrdom either. Okay? So I'm not doing this in some superior way, but I'm just simply saying, there's something wrong with us. If we're not producing the kind of zeal and devotion that leads people to go to their deaths for the sake of the gospel, we would never be sending from here people into the kinds of places where people went in the past knowing that they were going to die. And saying, well, I can either, you know, have these cannibals eat me or have the worms eat me when I die as an old man. I prefer the cannibals eat me. And so they went and they were all seminarians. Some of them, in fact, cowboys. So it's, you know, when we don't produce people with that kind of zeal, something's missing not only in you, but in us as faculty, and in the spirit of this place. I think that's fair to say. I mean, I love this school. I think it's the best thing since sliced bread, but at the same time, it is this is something we all need to sort of recognize and understand. We need to move forward, okay? How's that? Invicting enough? Okay. All right. As we think of spiritual theology itself, now what I'm talking now is the lower right hand corner of the chart, okay? The spiritual theology. We're inside the spiritual theology chart now. That's all of this, okay? Inside of this, there's something I think is true of all spiritual theology. And that is that they tend to have three different concerns, and they tend to deal with all three of these in one way or another. Some of them tend to emphasize more than others, but I think they all deal with these. One of those would be, again, remember that we're talking about doing these things so that we can have profound experiences of God with that intention, with that purpose, with that purpose, and an affective, a profoundly affective experience of God. Certainly, look at certain beliefs in order to have this. So in other words, you can look at something like the Trinity, for example. You can say, here's the doctrine of Trinity, lay it out three persons, one essence, and so on and so on. And you can go, and you can go, okay, beyond. Or you can talk about it and describe it in such a way that it causes doxology to flow from you, and praise, and all being awestruck and amazed at the wonder of God. You follow me? That's what I mean when I say, a belief can actually be something that leads you to this, into this spiritual theology. So you have this profound experience at your goal, and one way in which people tend to do that is by focusing on beliefs. Another way they tend to do that is through what we call traditionally aesthetics. Now, aesthetics has to do with, etymologically, the training of athletes. It has to do with disciplines. This is what the term we use, you know, Richard Foster's disciplines. Okay. The discipline thing. You with me on it. So the idea is that as we talk about Christian disciplines, this is aestheticism. Now, usually, when we think of aestheticism, we think of simple life, you know, don't own anything. Don't have a car. Don't eat anything for six months, things like that. And that is part of it. But you can see that aestheticism has, or aesthetic, has to do with the behaviors that you do, bodily things you do. Things you do with your body that have effects and can lead to these profound experiences of God. Often, jokes with you, I say, you want a religious experience, we'll try not eating for four days. Okay. Try not eating for four days, and you'll have a profound religious experience. Look out about that at all. So should it make you wonder why it is that Christians were all the centuries, all both millennia, and even in the Old Testament, did just that? That when they were preparing themselves for encounters with God, that one of the things they would do would be to fast for days. Well, you know, we're so secular, we're so scientific that we think, well, that's just manipulating the situation. No, it's not. It's just recognizing that in order to walk across the room, you've got to breathe. Well, one of the ways to have a religious experience is to observe the discipline. So observe the aesthetic. Does that make sense? So that can be another concern that you have in a spiritual theology. And then there's this third dimension, this affective dimension of the actual encounter itself. And that is not that you, it's not believing certain things in certain ways so that they can lead you to an encounter, and not doing things that can lead you to an encounter, but it's the encounter itself. And we're going to talk about that as well. Okay. So let's talk about these three things, and what sorts of things come up in these three areas. All spiritual theology, we think, believe that a Christian deal with beliefs. And they look at beliefs as avenues for profound experiences of God. Some of the questions that come up in this area are these. Which beliefs can lead us to profound experiences of God? No beliefs, do no beliefs do it, and you just not need to concern yourself with doctrines in order to have this. One is there one particular one that will give this to you, and are there a few of these that will give them to you, or are there many of them, or do, is it true that every Christian belief has the potential to lead you to profound experiences of God? If you think about them and talk about them in the right way, you know what I'm saying? Now the answer to that question will be different, depending on which group. In fact, some of the conodic traditions, conodic, what's conosis mean? The conodic meditational traditions actually say, no belief can give this to you. The only way you can have a profound experience of God is to enter yourself of ideas. It's a lot like transadental meditation, as you enter yourself with conscious thought in order to experience God. Does that make sense? Now usually in our circles, people react to that very negatively. I'm not sure it's entirely negative, frankly, but usually the response of our side is, no, you've got to feel your brain with truth and that will let you have an experience of God. Well, maybe so. But the question is, is it just one thing or many things or is it everything? What angles should we take on that? Then there's a second kind of question that often comes up in this area, and that is, what kinds of formulations of beliefs lead to profound experiences of God? Must they always be personalized? You must think of this belief in relationship to you? So for example, you think about election, and you say, election? Well, that doesn't really do a whole lot for me, but I say what? I am the elect. Now it's going to do something to me. Now it's going to make me, it's leading me to this responsiveness to God and awareness of God that I didn't have before. Well, that's one approach. Always personalize. And you can see that sometimes the experiencing God materials. You know those materials that are out there? That's what they do. You get a truth and they personalize it. And if you personalize it, that's supposed to somehow lead you to an experience of God. I've done it, didn't work. So I'm not sure I'm sure that it always has to be that way. Or is it that objectification can sometimes actually lead you to profound experiences of God? I mean, does the fact of election? Does that do something for you? Does the fact of the sovereignty of God cause you to respond in certain ways, and to have profound experiences of God? So that would be the kinds of questions that would always be asked by spiritual theologians in the realm of beliefs. Well, what does sonship say about this? Okay? What does sonship say about this? Which beliefs can lead to profound experiences of God? Primarily, sonship says the doctrine of adoption. The doctrine of adoption as taught by Paul in Galatians chapter 3 through 4.7, and 3.26 and 4.7, but especially adoption as understood, not by the reformed tradition, but understood by Luther's commentary on that material. This is, in some respect, the heart of the matter when it comes to beliefs. So sonship is devoted to understanding and enjoying and finding the wealth of truth and wonder and religious experience and countless of God that can be found by reflecting on the beliefs that are taught in Luther's commentary on Galatians chapter 3, verse 26 through chapter 4, verse 7. That's our main concern. Practically everything you hear from sonship people in their literature and the like, and I've read a lot of their literature, not all of them by any means, but almost all of it, doctrinally speaking, comes from this kind of source. Comes from this avenue. Now they may talk about other passages, but it'll be in the light of this. This will be their paradigm by which they understand other passages. To the point that I even heard somebody read Deuteronomy chapter 8, which we'll talk about later in the light of Galatians 3, and Luther's comments on it, and he was reading it, and finding in Deuteronomy 8 just the opposite, in my opinion of what Deuteronomy 8 said, just the absolute opposite, because he was reading it, because he had the word son in it. He was reading it into the light of Galatians and Luther's commentary. Then the second question is, of course, what kind of formulations of the lease lead to profound experiences of God objectified or a personalized, you remember that? Now in the sonship movement, they primarily offer the personalization. It's not that there is adoption, that makes you go, thank you Jesus. That's not what makes it happen. What makes it happen for you is that you have been adopted. You being what you are, and who you are, that you have been adopted. And it's very meaningful when you go through the process, and you hear people talking about how undeserving you are of the things that you have in Christ, and then how freely God has given you salvation, and how freely He has bestowed upon you more than just barely surviving or barely being saved, but has actually adopted you into this family in a permanent relationship, a permanent loving, benevolent kind relationship. And when you, who come usually in our circles from a very neurotic sort of background where you don't feel very good about yourself, and where you have worked very hard to perform in order to feel better for yourself, about yourself. When you hear those words, and that good news comes through, and Holy Spirit uses it to really break through and make something happen inside of you, it can lead to very dramatic encounters with God. There's no Catholic advocates. So that would be basically the way in which Sunship deals with the brief dimension of spiritual theology. Okay. Focusing primarily on Sunship and the personalization of that. What about the others' dimensions of this? Is there an aesthetic dimension to Sunship? Is there a discipline? Is are there encounters? Well, let's see. Yes, there is. And every spiritual theology and aesthetic. The questions that range along many different lines, but there are something like these, which disciplines, or regular practices, regular ritual practices, lead to profound experiences of God. Is there to not do none of them? I mean, do you just hate rituals? Do you hate doing things the same way over and over again? Or do you do that? Okay. Is there one that you have to do? Are there a few of them? Are there many of them that we're doing? Is everything you do? You want to lead you to a profound religious experience. And that's the kind of question that has to be raised. Now, if that's the case then, the second question is, what kinds of disciplines lead to profound experiences of God? For example, would prayer be one of those? Or would fasting be one of those? Or would isolation or meditation, either kinetic or planastic? Would service be one of those? You don't say what I mean by service. I mean, doing something for someone. Okay? Another duration of kind of spirituality. Sacrifice of yourself, giving your money away to the point that it hurts. Self denial. Refusing to have certain pleasures in life that you could have. Is posturing your body? Does that lead to encounters with God? Does tongues encounter leads you to encounters of God? Do pilgrimages, now that I mean physically actually walking to places, do they lead you to encounters of God? Does mission leads you to encounters with God? Does taking valve, like a Nazarete valve leads you to encounter God? Does repentance do this? Does recitation of certain truths over and over again do this to you? Can song do this to you? Can feasting do this to you? Can dance do this to you? Can lifting your hands to this to you? Can Bible reading do this to you? Well, if you're a typical neo-Calvinist, the answer is maybe number one and the last one. But certainly the last one. Reading the Bible now, that would really give you a lot of spiritual encounters with God. Okay? But the fact is, the Bible itself teaches, in my opinion, that all of these and a ton more can lead to these kinds of encounters with God. You may find, you see, that some of these things may seem a little strange to you, but actually the practice, the discipline of fasting, is an extremely valuable spiritual tool. Isolation, solitude, we would call it. Isolation is extremely important, and I know this is true of many of you in here. You haven't been alone for 12 hours for the last 10 years. And when you were, you were watching television the whole time. Am I lying? Have I misread you entirely here? We would say, wow, that's really weird. A hermit. You like to go out on the Appalachian Trail all by himself for a day or two? That's really weird. Let's be sick. You're from Alaska. You don't have any choice. You're out of your backyard, you're allowing me to. Backer fights are self-denial. I mean, when was the last time you saved up money to buy a card? Okay, you've got it all in the bank, you're not even going to have to take a loan out to get it. And you decide, we're not going to buy the card, we're going to get this money away. That's what I mean by self-denial. When was the last time you sold your second house and decided you didn't really need that peach condo anyway? And you gave the money into the service of Christ. That's what I'm talking about. Resetation, I mean, sort of a mantra thing, that you actually go over the same words, you save the same words, you go to the form of us over and over again, much like the rosary and that sort of thing. I don't like the rosary mind, I'm not Catholic, but I'm just supposing things like that. We do that in our circles. We have our own rosaries. There's a little bit of that. I don't think I know because I don't do songs right here anymore, but I tell you, if you don't dance in church, you'll also be dancing at home. I mean, religious dance. I'll just pull the curtains down, turn on any grand start dancing. Because those are the kinds of disciplines that lead people to profound religious experiences. If they won't let you do it at church, that's okay. You can live at that. You've got six other days you can do it. We need a dance class here at this school. It's practically up to go to church. And I have them at the front of the line. There's a nobody will feel embarrassed anymore when they see me try to do it. What about sonships spiritual theology? What kind of aesthetic do they have? Well, which disciplines are regular practices leads to profound experiences of God? Basically, there are very few of these for the sonship movement. I'm sure that on the individual basis, they would say there's more than what they talk about. But basically, they have very few that they really talk about. But they are all related to the doctrine of adoption. In other words, you have to do certain things, or certain practices, certain disciplines to carry through in your life. But they're all centered around the themes of the belief of adoption. They're not centered around other sorts of things. Well, what kinds of disciplines lead to these profound experiences of God? There is a regularly repeated ritual in sonship. And this is not to say that it's bad. When I have pointed this out to sonship advocates in the past, many of them are very good friends of mine. And for whom I would give my life. I put my life life in my life in the hands of several of these people on mission trips back behind their own curtains and things like that. And so these are not people that I'd disdain or I think they're superficial by any means. So to say that there's a ritual doesn't mean to say that it's bad or superficial. It's simply to say, this is what they do. They do something like this, and different ones that do it in different ways. But basically, you need to have some form of a sincere acknowledgement of your terrible sentiments. You're much worse than you think you are. It's the thing. You think you're bad? You don't have any idea how bad you are. You're so bad, that. Still in the life. And that is a very traditional Christian spirituality. May a colpa, may a colpa, maximum may a colpa. What that means? My guilt, my guilt, my great guilt. Okay? The declaration of utter desperate simpleness is not something new. Is this something that I think is even difficult for that matter? But certainly, it hasn't been traditional in circles, including our own. But this is one that we like. It fits very well with us. Okay? Then there is a... There's to be a sincere dependence, identification, and turning away from all known idolatry. Now, the idolatry is one of the crucial issues that have come up here because most of us don't know our idols. This is one of the assumptions of the movement. Is that idols are subtle, and so you don't know what they are. They can be things as terrible as the law of money, but they can also be things that have been innocuous as I want my wife to like me, or I want my husband to treat me better. That's keeping you from being happy. That's keeping you from being fulfilled. As a Christian, yes, it is. Well, that's an idolatry because all of your joy, all of your pleasure, all of your fulfillment, is to come from Jesus, and the fact that you have been adopted and have been made a son of God. That's the rhetoric. I don't agree with that talking so much, because even Adam in the garden, when he was with God, God looked at him and said, I'm not enough. You didn't quite treat him that way, that's in the evening. You said it is not good for the man to be alone. Adam should have said, I'm not alone, you're with me. What more could I want than you? Well, God said, how about you? You went, oh, okay. You got idea. Okay, number three, there's this theory. There's this theory except acceptance. There's this theory except insurance. I'm sure that we have in our worship times when she makes a minister get up and assures you of the cardinous thing. You have to hear it, you have to believe it, you have to accept it, and affirm it as being true. And then you delight in the privileges of adoption. Now, you can imagine these four steps are not always what you do to do. The people have trouble knowing how bad they are. They have trouble identifying their idols. They have difficulty being assured of salvation and delighting in their adoption. So, there are helps for this. Just like you would have in any traditional aesthetic and they are a sponsorship counsellors. Now, they're done in sort of real sort of postmodern way in virtual community by telephone conferences and telephone counseling. Have any of you gone to telephone counseling? That's a very postmodern way to do it. Way to go, everybody. Okay, soon we'll do it by webcam. No, I can't stop. Sure. There's a bunch of literature to be read, and there are a bunch of conferences to go to, where you go for a week and you pay a certain amount of money and you have this kind of concentrated experience. Now, that, don't misunderstand me, please. That is not a put down. To identify these elements is not a put down. Someone became really angry with me just recently and said, you're making this like a human thing. And really, it's the Holy Spirit. And I said, I am not making it like a human thing. I'm not saying it's not the Holy Spirit. These are the patterns of the sun-ship people themselves have identified as the ordinary ways in which Holy Spirit works in these people. What's the problem with that? So please don't take this as being a put down to identify some of these elements. Next slide. Everybody does. Good job. That's exactly what I'm trying to portray here. Everybody hear that? That's exactly what I'm trying to let you see. It's that this is not the answer to all of my problems because it's so unique and so gospel. The body of Christ has been doing this kind of thing forever. And should that surprise you? No. That should delight you and should make you ask, well, what other kinds of things like this have they done? That's what we're going. Exactly. Okay. Now let's go to the third dimension, spiritual theology. And as the actual encounters themselves, the question may be raised in this way, of all spiritual theology. Which religious aspects of company for found religious experience? Which aspect? You've heard of John Denver's religious affections, okay? Where he goes through for analyzing what's going on in the revival of New England and talks about, you know, what are the true characteristics of the emotional life of a spirit-filled person and what are the marks that distinguish that from just plain old enthusiasm and things like that? So there are efforts to try to identify these kinds of things. With none, one, few, many, all. Okay. All aspects, many aspects, a few aspects, one affect, or should spiritual theology just encounters with God not be affectual at all? The second one would be, the second big question would be, what kinds of religious aspects of company for found religious experiences of God? Are they what we would normally call, or people may call positive? Affects are a negative affect. In other words, are they free? Do they free you or do they constrain you? Do they constrain you? These aspects. Do you feel freed when you encounter God? Or do you feel constrained when you encounter God? Do you feel mild? Or are you frenzied when you encounter God? Are you delighted? Or are you fearful when you encounter God? As a Christian mind, I'm talking about real true blue, real regenerated Christians. Do you feel accepted? Or do you feel rejected when you encounter God? Do you feel secure or insecure when you encounter God? Do you follow on the same thing here? These are the kinds of questions that all spiritual theology have to deal with. Now, the tendency of every spiritual theology is to say, this set of things, yeah, that's real encounter with God. These other sets, they're from the devil. That's one of the big problems here. And as we'll see with Sonsha. Sonsha of spiritual theology says, and that there are, and there's at least one affect or a couple of aspects that are important for us, like assurance, which can come from this doctrine, focus on the doctrine of Sonsha, and going through the aesthetic of these steps. Assurance is salvation, empowerment is often a word that's used, joy is a word that's used, words like guilt, beauty, determination, fear, these are less than best for Christians. They should not have these. If you do have them, they should be simply stepping stones to something else. So what kinds of religious ethics of company profound experiences of God? The positive ones, primarily for Christian, not the negative ones. You feel free, you don't feel constrained. In other words, you worry less about whether you're doing the right thing or the wrong thing. Does that make sense to you, do you understand? That's not put down. You don't think about that so much. I mean, after all, if you're free, you're free. So you don't worry so much about whether you should have a couple of years or not. You don't worry so much about whether it costs or not. You don't worry so much about whether that happened or not. It's just not going to constrained you. You have adoption, you're accepted, so you can feel free, not constrained. Mild or frenzy. Basically, mild. I have never seen anyone in a sonship conference go bonkers, we would say. Okay. Absolutely frenzy. They will weak. There's a lot of weeping that happened. But it's usually a sort of, going from, I'm sorry to all the things I've done, I feel so good now that I feel accepted by God. So weeping happens, but not frenzy, not delirium. Delightful, not fearful. In fact, one of the things is, you don't need to fear God anymore. He'll never be angry with you again. Another year is trying. Acceptance, not rejection. Secure, not insecure. These are the kinds of experiences they think you should have. They encounter each other. Okay. Now we are on, we've done the background. We've got the mentions. Remember the beliefs, the aesthetic, the encounter, and now let's evaluate this a little bit. Along those three lines. So we're going to evaluate in terms of their focus on beliefs, their focus on aesthetics, and their focus on encounters, and the aspects that accompany the encounters. And we're going to do this first, by thinking positive things, and then do negative things. Okay. And trying to be as balanced as I can, and as fair, and as safe as I can possibly be. In terms of positives, what about this focus on adoption? Well, positively speaking, adoption is a wonderful doctrine for those who have been truly regenerated and justified. One of the difficulties, however, is that sometimes, the spiritual thing that we generate, and the 100% is not always clearly explained in the function of material. But once you assume that a person is regenerate or unjustified, then adoption is a wonderful doctrine that should be taught. It's a great thing to be a child of God. I mean, what more could you want than to be adopted into the family of God and have all the things that can come from that? Okay. Second positive thing, is adoption meets the troubling needs for acceptance by God and freedom from self-righteousness, from legalism, and performance orientation, that the things that are suffered by so many Presbyterian types. I mean, there are melodies that we have, they are these, that we don't feel accepted by God, we don't feel free before our God. We do wrestle with being self-righteous, we do wrestle with different forms of legalism, read my article on the website, and we have a performance orientation in our faith. There's no doubt, that those things are true, and the adoption of adoption can meet those troubling needs, and that people will give people some positive replacement for those neurotic endeavors. Okay. Negatively speaking, however, adoption, adoption. I really don't understand, I'll just put it this way, I don't understand what the big deal of adoption is. I don't know why that's the doctrine. Why is it sponsorship? Why is that so important? Because it could just as easily be, elect, it could just as easily be, glorify, regard self the glory people. Okay. It could just as easily be the regenerated ones, the born again ones, or the justified ones, the righteous ones. It could be all of those things, all of which are connected to adoption, but are not equal to adoption. Adoption is only one of many doctrines which forms the biblical presentation of the Christian gospel. The good news is not just adoption, but that's the way it's often presented. But this is the gospel, the doctrine of adoption. That's not true. It just simply is not true. And all of these other doctrines I'm talking about, can lead to profound experiences of God similar to those which stem from the doctrine of adoption. So if you look at Ephesians chapter 1, verses 3 to 14, for example, what you find there is Paul does talk about adoption, but he also talks about the fact that you are seated in the heavenly places right now that you've been Alexis the foundation of the world, that you have been decreed to be this way. You have been ordered by God to be this way, and that God has given you every single thing you could possibly imagine in Christ. Any one of those, or all of those, or any mixture thereof, can be believes that if you look at them and formulate them in the right way, can lead you to profound experiences of God. I personally think that one of the problems here is that we are so used to the doctrine of election that we have lost this for plenty. We use the doctrine of election to pound people over the head to make them feel like they don't understand the Bible rather than to lead us to delight and doxology. Does that make sense? And frankly, it seems to be a little bit, from my point of view, it's even more profound than adoption election best, but I don't know if that's the end of there. Number two, adoption focuses in the Bible on more, I should put it this way, adoption in the Bible focuses more on the joy of receiving and inheritance than it does the experience of acceptance. What is it that makes being the son of God so important? It is that you are joined airs with Christ. And what is it that makes that so important that you are happy now, or that you are forgiven now, or that you'll never be angry with you again, or you can have a psychological sense that I'm right with God, no, that is not the focus of any of these passages that are listed here on the screen, and it certainly isn't even the focus of Galatians 3 and 4. The focus is that the wonder of being a son of God of being adopted in the family of God is what you get out of it, and what you get out of it is the inheritance of the new world. Take a look at the passages in the scene, that is not the case. You'll be shocked to see it. And yet you don't hear that talked about very much. In the Sonship Movement, it's much more psychologized. Much more sense of I'm forgiven. It's much more sense that I can live with myself and I can be right with God. I can be appeased with God. Rather than, hey, look at me! I get everything! I get everything! You be! Praise the Lord! It's all mine! Look at the difference. I think that the primary focus of the text that are focusing on adoption of wish or not that many is what is the fact that as a child of God as a son of God, you are the heir of the promises of God. Yes, well, both. The down payment of the Holy Spirit is what you get now. It's been the passage in these passages of adoption where Paul talks about we get the down payment of Holy Spirit Ephesians after one. Okay? Which calls our hearts to cry out of a father. We're children. What causes that to happen? Is that talking about the peace we have with God out of Lisa? What is talking about is the fact that we've been given Holy Spirit already. But this is one of the problems you see. In my opinion, with the sense of movement, they don't talk about Holy Spirit enough. Because it is the Spirit of adoption that we have received. And it's the Spirit of adoption that calls it to cry out of a father. And it's because he is the down payment, the first free, the down payment of everything we're going to get one day. Yeah. Good. I don't know. Yeah, I'm not sure it's been modified. Thank you for putting blood on the softening forest roots. Yes. And the only point of adoption is that you need the benefit of calling free or smoothness to let the front of being adopted as a child. You have the full force to join air with Christ because you have that adopted. It wasn't that the only thing, because of that, you have all these other things. Yeah. That's why you can live a deeper benefit because of your adoption. Yes. But my point is this. What is the concern? Is the concern? Now, you know, your experience may be different from ours. I don't know. I don't know. Sorry. Yeah, ask the question. Think about it. And ask the question is the concern to convince people of the glory that is theirs and the wonder of that and the fantastic quality of life and experience of God that can come from that knowledge and that reality. Or is it the sense of forgiveness and acceptance? Okay. And just ask that question. Yes. That's my point. Well, we have to talk about some of that stuff. I think we're doing like this at this moment. And just ask the question, what did it mean to be adopted? Yeah. You're eating. No, not really, because they want to experience forgiveness and acceptance. My point is that in the Bible, the forgiveness and acceptance doesn't seem to be the crescendo point. Okay. The crescendo point seems to be what you get out of this. Okay. Not the experience of forgiveness. And part of the problem here is that in reformed or disillusioned, the people have argued about where adoption fits in. It's not clear at all. That's the way it should fit in. Yeah. Thanks. So, a great spin. Yeah. You take it out of the blue for a bit. Yeah. And so sometimes when you're talking about the imperative of the Bible, they encourage that and leave it. That's my next statement right here. No. That the Bible focuses more on the joy of receiving and the inheritance than the experience of acceptance and the sonship of this entails in the Bible, responsibility as well as privilege. In fact, usually, it's responsibility. If you look at Deuteronomy chapter 8, which is where the sonship thing comes from, throughout the whole Bible, Deuteronomy 8, where Israel is called the Son of God, who's got to adopt Israel, makes it hers. Makes it her again. Makes her his. The focus there is, you're my children, and I'm going to test you now to see if you're going to obey me or not. It's the test. And whether you're a true son or not, the theme of acceptance. If you look at Ephesians chapter 1 13 through 14, you discover there that sonship has to do with the fact that we are responsible to do the right things before God. Now, if you 648, the perfect as your father in heaven is perfect. Sonship has to do with moral responsibility. 1st John 310. What does 1st John 310 say? We know we are the sons of God if what? If we obey the truth. So, the sonship used as an assurance of salvation. The sonship used as a doctrine simply to convince people that they really are accepted by God and that they have nothing to worry about anymore. No. The sonship is actually used in the Bible as a motivation for further perseverance of the things and moral responsibility. And the fact that you are being tested to see if indeed you are a son. That is the more frequent theme of the New Testament and the Old Testament on sonship than what is emphasized in this. That sounds as Frank was saying, it sounds like legal. We are going back to the idea that you have got the obey Jesus to get the inheritance, but the answer is yes you do. You do. And people get so angry with me like in the prophets course, and I talk about how the prophets say, you have to obey in order to receive. Is that taken right out of this in here? And so, you know, that's the fact. The fact that the New Testament and the Old Testament do this, you have to be concerned with that. What about the aesthetics? Well, the positives, of course, are that sonship spiritual discipline is to be a normal part of the Christian experience, because it was the last of the things. Hey, there are four steps or five steps. Army steps you want to have. That's what I mean, cash for sale says you're supposed to do that. The angel can say you just need to do that. The cabin says you just need to do that. The press tree is to do it every Sunday. That's what you do. It's just what you do. And so, it's a good thing. That's not to be a little lit. That's what I say. It's a good thing. Go for it. And if you can bring this out into people's lives in a way that might be new or pedagogically significant to them, by emphasizing the thing, the sonship, taking them through the steps of the confession and all that sort of thing, then fine, that's great. That's wonderful. But realize it's just a way of doing what Christians have always done and a variety of ways. Number two, spiritual sonship, a sonship spiritual discipline is well-suited. Watch this now. For busy people. Why is it well-suited for busy people? Activist people. Activist people. Most of the same reason that spiritual breathing, I'll be right is well-suited for active busy people. Why? It needs the needs that you have. I know I was doing something. And how much time does it take? Not a lot. Okay? Nobody is asking anybody to go into the desert and live for three years. You follow me? You do that when it means something. Nobody is asking anybody to find, experiences of God by stealing their homes and living in a shack on the back of our PF campus. So that's not what's happening here. What's happening here is go through this process. You can do it with the, you know, a counseling session once a week for six weeks. You can do it. And a conference concentrated. You can do it. A little bit here. A little bit there. It's easy for people who are busy to do. Yes, they would raise concerns with me, too. So I'm going to raise it just a moment. Good point. I'm trying to be positive at this point. It's also well suited for intellectual believers. Why? It's very much focused on the cognitive. And it's very complicated. The doctrine, the doctrinal dimension of this is complex. You realize that. I mean, a lot of us in here look at it's kind of simple for you because you study these things. Adoption, regeneration, justification, authentication, grace of this, grace of that, responsibility. Yeah, right, right. All that stuff. Okay? You're kind of into it. But think of your grandmother. And try to convince your grandmother to make these subtle distinctions between adoption versus justification, versus sanctification, versus glorification. And your inheritance is forgiveness and acceptance. And God's never angry with you against her things. Those are very, very subtle and very, very complex ideas that a person has to be able to put his or her arms around and grace to some degree with some measure of understanding in order to have the experience. It's a lot different from simply reciting in John chapter 1 over and over and over and over and over and over and over again, until you have an aesthetic experience. It's a lot different. It's a lot different from emptying your mind, just emptying yourself until you have an aesthetic experience. Very highly intellectual. And as well suited them for busy people and intellectual believers who have little time for or experience in other disciplines. And I have to say that in the other way. I don't even say, by and large, our people, our kinds of people don't have any spiritual disciplines, because they're getting out maybe on Sunday morning going to church. Okay, for an hour, maybe, if they really feel like it. That's about it. And as a result of that, we just don't have much experience if only no other things are out there. Well, that's the thing that the Catholics do, isn't it? Not even need on Friday? That's what a Catholic does, isn't it? That's weird. We're free. We're Protestant. We'll leave out immediately money. Negative. A bunch of spiritual disciplines can be administered legalistically. You can be told that if you don't go through these steps, you're never going to encounter God in the way you ought to. You can be told that if you don't acknowledge that you have seriousness for found sin, and that you have all kinds of idols in your life, that you put before Jesus. If you don't just say yet that it's true, then you will never come to the full awareness of your sonship, and thus the freedom and the joy of acceptance for God. And I have one good friend who's associated with RTS who went to a conference and who basically said, you know, I'm not perfect, but I don't think my sins are all that bad. Hello, it's very bad today. He said, you know, do I love my wife like I should? No, but am I unfaithful to her? No. This is the minister. Do I serve her? Yeah, but no. I love her like you. Are you crazy? So after two or three days of this, they gave up on his same home. You know what I'm talking about. I'll tell you later. Okay? And so the reality is that not everybody's into this kind of thing. But if you're not into it, you can't get it. You follow me. And therefore, it can be seen very legalistically and treated very legalistically, without concern for differences among individuals and cultures. This thing is transported over into Mongolia, and if it's just as well suited for them, it is for us. I had a feeling that in sonship, that sonship probably will focus more on what you're going to get in the next world, and the joy and the pleasure that I can give you as you deal with Holy Spirit now, as Holy Spirit ministers to you now, when you're being persecuted. Like in mainland China, for example, or when you're running for your life because you're a Christian and he's African. That's when adoption is going to mean something a little bit different than it does for the intellectual, busy, upper-middle class white person in North America. Does that make sense to you? I mean, you and I are on a small scale of hierarchy and these were way up there. The only thing we're lacking is self-authentication. I mean, none of us are worried about what we're going to eat tonight. None of us are really all that seriously concerned that we're going to be shocked when we walk out of this house, out of this building. None of us are all that concerned, even about our social relations, maybe a few of us. But basically, we're up in that relational level, and then the self-authentication, self-actualization level. And so, what is sonship appeals to that in a particular way? It says, you can self-actualize. You can meet that need if you believe this doctrine and practice this aesthetic. You can have the encounter with God that will self-actualize you. That will actualize you. Does that make sense? No, that's not to say it's bad. Please don't take that to mean it's bad. I'm just trying to put other kinds of language on it so you can see it for what it's doing in a very positive way. Is it bad for people to self-actualize? No. Is it a good thing? Of course, that's what the book of Ecclesiasties is about. But Ecclesiasties would never have been written in a place where people were starving to death by starving man. It had to be written by someone prosperous who had time to go read the books, to go pursue the money, to go work hard, to go play hard, and find out one of that makes it either. How about that? I need Jesus. Imagine I can only self-actualize with Jesus. That's why you don't find persecuted people really worried all that much about whether God accepted them, but rather, as he's going to help me survive this so I can get lessons out there waiting for me, which is more what Paul is talking about in his statistics. Does that communicate to you? It's one of those problems that we have thinking that as North American upper middle class Christians that our problems are the problems of the world and our solutions are the solutions of the world. The second thing I would say negatively about the aesthetic is the sense of spiritual discipline can be practiced so exclusively that the wide range of physical discipline and their results can be overlooked. If you've figured you've gone through the aesthetic of such a well then you've done it. If you've done what you've got to do and you've fixed, or at least you're in the process of being convicted, you keep on doing it. But the reality is no. The history of the Church of Jesus Christ should let us know that there are tons of things that we need to be doing, in order to have the kind of profound encounters with God that we're talking about. Tons of things. Not just going through the confession of standing in the acceptance of forgiveness. Let's go now to that last slide. I'll get it up here on the screen just a moment. The very last slide that talks about our profound experiences and the friendship view of that. It's going to be something positive and something negative about that. What are the encounters like? Well, positively, the relationship has helped a number of believers and I know a lot of them. Overcomes significant affective problems such as inappropriate shame. When you feel shame over things you've done in the past, you just don't feel like you can forgive yourself or God's forgiving you. It's helped them overcome that. It's helped them overcome self-righteousness. That's a good thing to happen to you. That's wonderful. A lack of assurance of salvation. There are people who have not had assurance of salvation for decades in their lives, who go to a search of comfort, and then come out with strong assurance that they are saved and that Jesus loves them and that will love them forever. And that's lovely. I've seen people who are pronatious turn away from it. I've seen people dogmatic and have doctrinaire attitudes turn away from those things because of this. So that's a wonderful thing. Those kinds of affect alterations are very positive and something we should want people to have. Second positive thing is that censorship has drawn attention to the positive personal dimensions of the Christian faith for reformed people especially. Without some of the obstacles that are presented by the charismatic model of the Holy Spirit, I mentioned to you earlier that in the literature as well as in the practice, there's not a lot of direct attention given to Holy Spirit and the experience of Him. Now He's there in the literature. He's mentioned you can't talk about the Bible much about how the Holy Spirit is under great. But this is not a penicostal kind of spirituality where the Holy Spirit is at the center. Who is at the center of this? It would probably have to be Jesus. Maybe God the Father has the adopting one. Now we're being joined by Jesus. Holy Spirit is very much peripheral to this. This is an interesting thing because He's the one that's with us. But it's also as one of my friends in Australia said, it's safe for us to do. It's a safe way for us to get personalism back in our faith because we're so terrified by the third person of the Holy Trinity. We're so scared of what He might do, or that He might do to us what He's done to other groups. Or we've been saying all along, it really wasn't the Holy Spirit that was doing that over there in that group. So if it happens to us, well now what do we do? You follow me? And so it benefits us in that way. And I think that's the positive thing. And hopefully it'll actually lead us eventually to more attention to Holy Spirit. Negative, sonship focuses on a narrow range of aspects which maturing Christians are to desire. Negative aspects such as guilt and fear and duty, determination, anger, frustration, anxiety. These are rejected as inappropriate for the sons of God. There are things you dip into, you dip down, and you have those things, but it's not what you want to embrace. Now I don't know how we reconcile that with the fact that the martyrs in heaven right now are frustrated. And saying how long, how long, until justice comes on the earth. I don't know how you reckon with the sin, with the world that's full of sin and dying, that has all of the hearts that it has, and feel at peace when you see that. The Apostle Paul talks about peace, but he also talks about being troubled in his spirit by the things that are having incarnate. Are we not to be troubled by the things that are happening in Ethiopia? Are we not to be troubled, deeply troubled by what's happening to our brothers and sisters in England, China? Is this not supposed to just tear our hearts to pieces? Are we supposed to delight in the fact that we're accepted? Is that to be the center of our emotional experience? I don't think so. I think it's a momentary center, yes. But because the deck of life is always shifting, balance can be nothing more than momentary synchronism. So the prize one of these, or a spet of these, more than the others, is to make a big mistake in my opinion. If you've done things you should feel guilty about, you should feel guilty about it. And remember that people who were regenerated and who had Holy Spirit, many times when they came into close encounters of the third kind with God, they did not feel joy, they felt fear, they trembled. Always remember that. That is not just, oh, thank you Jesus, I'm here now with God the Father, let me sit on your lap. That's not the only experience of the leaders when they had these close encounters these profound encounters of God. Can you say that? I would say that, um... Would it go on? No, it's self-explanation primarily, yeah. I would say that. I think anger is not so good, but you especially don't want to be angry in an spiritual or religious way, or for religious reasons, or... Yeah. You're very sad. If that hierarchy needs again. Yeah, we don't, you know, it's just... Yeah, it's really sad. That's true. I believe it's true. One second thing I would say negatively is that sonship remained highly intellectualistic and is limited largely to people who have this kind of orientation. I think that's a serious negative. You know, when you go to a Pentecostal church and you wonder, what is it that attracts people to those tent meetings and all that sorts of things? I could tell you what it is. It is that they start doing it before they even start talking about it. You go up front and a Pentecostal meeting and you want to sleep in time and you're back to the Holy Spirit. What happens is the ministry, if it doesn't happen to you automatically, he'll tell you what to do. He'll say, now lean your head back. So that's saying how a little... Start saying how a little... Start saying how a little... And get people around you. Everybody starts saying how a little over and over and over again. And eventually the person in this romantic frenzy becomes tongue-tied. And they say, that's Holy Ghost. Start going. Lower the Holy Ghost. And it starts happening. And the person is lifted up into some kind of mic heaven or something. And then you do the doctrinal reflection afterwards. So whatever degree of person can do it. Well, that was the baptism of the Holy Spirit. Acts chapter 2. That kind of thing. Follow me. Now, that's not our way. Our way is work out the ordost alluded. Which our beloved John Frank said has... Is passé. And most of the people feel that way. I don't, but most do. Do you hear me disagreeing John Frank? Wow. Pass it. But the reality is, we've got to work all that out. Teach people all the wild, crazy hair, splitting doctrines before they can have any... emotional, religious, and counter- with God. I think there's some serious problem there. If you're going to administer to anybody other than people like you and me. Which we want to do. So I'm very eager to see spirituality work through different doors. I want you to see the beliefs, be one door. I want you to see the aesthetic, be another door. That's the thing that looks open your mouth. This thing howly howly howly howly howly. See, that's an aesthetic. You see that? The practice. I'm not approving of that. You understand? Yes. I'm not telling you that's a good thing to do. People can't save you saying that means I think they're good. That's not what I'm saying at all. I've done it. And I've done it because of people, but I don't think it's usually done. And then there are those things that also occur where we simply use the door. The sudden surprise experience. The sudden encounter that you did not even work towards or think about. And it just happened to you one day. You're just sitting in the room. Maybe it's your service. And suddenly something happens to you. And that then becomes the door for the other experiences of reflection and of an aesthetic and make it happen again. To make it happen again and make it happen again and to make it happen again. So, essentially, good or bad? Well, it's a lovely, wonderful thing. But in my opinion, ministers of the gospel need to be careful not to tie themselves too closely to one particular spiritual theology. They need to endorse it, love it for what it's not, and encourage people to participate. But for you, even though your parishioners, your members, they get locked in with some tractor being on one kind of spirituality. You must not be above all that. You must be a half foot out of that so that you can deal with people who are not going to buy into censorship. So, you can deal with people who are going to be this way. Deal with people that way. Deal with Republicans as well as Democrats, as well as green people. As well as the reform party. You've got to deal with them all in politics so you can't just be some Republican. You've got to deal with them all and deal with the minister to them all and the levels of spirituality also. And that's what I'm encouraging you to do. So, I hope that sets well with everybody, both those who are advocates and those who are opponents of the suspension movement because I've tried to be as positive as I can be, and yet at the same time, a little bit evaluated. So, thank you, Matt. Have a good life. And you only tapers. You know this, right? So, if you get them all to me by the end of the day, it's right. So, if you get them all to me by the end of the event time, that'll be fine. Okay? Thank you. You're welcome.