<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Tuku Tuku Vakalolo

Mysticism & the Modern Devotion

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

34, so is a great pious mysticism in the modern devotion. Here is a drawing from the middle ages of a woman at prayer. We don't know who this woman is, but she is representative of many women in the church during the middle ages. Rather looks like a modern woman in some ways because she has three rings on her fingers on this hand. But I wanted to begin with that picture because I will begin with a prayer from one of the women mystics, very famous mystic and a very famous woman. In fact, she wrote the first book written by a woman in English. Now, you might look at her name and say, well, her name is Julian, but she is a woman. Her name is Julian of Norwich in England. We will be talking about her during this lecture, but I would like to begin with a prayer from Julian of Norwich, a very short prayer as we think about souls of great quiet, mysticism and the modern devotion. That is great. God of your goodness, give me yourself. For you are sufficient for me. I cannot properly ask anything less to be worthy of you. If I were to ask less, I should always be in want. In you alone, do I at all? Amen. There were various ways in which people attempted to live out their Christian faith in the middle ages. One was the way of the scholastics doing theology, trying to understand the faith. Another was the way of the humanists that we talked about in the last lecture. Christian that with infacies that were somewhat new and somewhat different and a third way was the way of the mystics. That is what I want to talk about during this lecture, the way of the mystics. The humanists put emphasis on the classics and on rhetoric and the scholastics put emphasis on theology and learning. The mystics put emphasis on love and on virtue. That is not true that the other two groups don't have any concern about love and virtue, but these are particular themes that you find constantly emphasized in the mystics. For instance, you are going to have love and learning and knowledge is good to have both, but it is better to have love. In the Old English Book, Peer's Plowman, conscience giving advice to the monks or to the friars, give up studying logic and learn to love consciousness. That might sound like a good advice to you all at this point in this class or in your study at seminary this semester. It certainly was an emphasis that the mystics went back to again and again. It is not so much what you know is how you love and the cloud of unknowing, one of the great books of the mystics, put it this way, smite upon the thick cloud of unknowing that is God and all of that. That is a thick cloud and how are you going to get through that cloud, smite upon it with the sharp dart of longing love, not with dialectics and disputations and Greek and Hebrew and Latin and the classics but the sharp dart of longing love. So the emphasis on love is certainly central, so is the interest and emphasis on virtue. What good does it do you to know things if you don't do those things? You can find this coming out again and again in the famous book, the imitation of Christ that we'll talk about. What good does it do you to speak learnably about the trinity of lacking humility you displeased the trinity? Indeed, it is not learning that makes man holy and just but a virtuous life makes him pleasing to God. So concern, person foremost for love and for conduct, for virtue, for good living. And then emphasis in the mystics on union with God, love for Christ and denial of self, you had to choose three points to summarize the emphasis in the writings of the mystics. It would be these three union with God, love for Christ, denial of self. Not every mystic is going to put equal emphasis on each of these, there are some mystics that will be more into the union with God than others love for Christ but all of them talk about denial of self. Think the best way for us to understand the mystics is for me to describe some of these mystics for you and try to illustrate these points through the lives and work of some of the famous mystics of the Middle Ages. Let's start with Johannes Meister Eckhart, who was a German and liked so many of the mystics among Eckhart was a Dominican monk. His book is simply called The Sermons. I have that book in my library, in my seminary office and every time I come to this lecture I try to read one of the Sermons of Eckhart but I've never been able to understand any of them. I came across this statement once though that made me feel a little better because someone complained to Meister Eckhart that no one could understand his Sermons. Whereupon he said to understand my preaching, five things are needed. The hearer must have conquered strife, he must be contemplating his highest good, he must be satisfied to do God's bidding, he must be a beginner among beginners and denying himself, he must be so a master of himself as to be incapable of anger. So maybe that's why I don't understand Eckhart's Sermons but you see the answer there is not, well you need to concentrate and figure out what I'm saying. The answer is you need to be a better person to understand my Sermons. One of the statements that you'll find in Eckhart's Sermons and this is very characteristic of Eckhart and the Visits is the statement in the syllabus there, a flee to the extent that it is in God ranks above the highest angel in his own right. Thus in God all things are equal and are God himself, even the flee to the extent that that flee is in God is equal to man, to the angels and the flee, man and the angels are indeed God himself. Well that's not uncharacteristic of how the mystics sounded because they were always pushing towards some kind of union with God in which the individual would be lost in being absorbed into the greatness and wonder of God. You might say what that sounds like pantheism and that's what a lot of people said. So Eckhart was charged with Harrison, reviewed for this teaching and Eckhart admitted that he had been extreme in some of his statements and tried to modify some blood. But still there is that very strong emphasis in Eckhart on being absorbed into God so that there is no difference. Now I did come across a statement just very recently from Eckhart which I think I can understand and which seems rather profound and important to me. That's also in the syllabus. We are all meant to be mothers of God. I might seem a little shocking when you first read it but let's read the rest. What good is it to me if this eternal birth of the divine sun takes place unceasingly but does not take place within myself? And what good is it to me if Mary is full of grace if I am not also full of grace? What good is it to me for the creator to give birth to his son if I do not also give birth to him in my time in culture? This then is the fullness of time when the son of God is begotten in us. So I will keep working with Eckhart and maybe I will find more statements like that which does seem to emphasize something very central and important for us to hear. Eckhart is usually known as the person who came very close to becoming a pantheos and the church had to rebuke him for that teaching. Another mystic, it's a man named Walter Hilton. It doesn't sound like a mystic. It sounds like a modern figure who runs a hotel or something but he's a mystic and he's a medieval figure. Another monk, this time in Augustinian and English, his book is called The Ladder of Perfection. And the idea of a ladder is one that the mystics like. So many of the books of mysticism will have the idea of a ladder. Start down low and climb. As you climb you get higher and higher and many of the books of mysticism will give you steps in which you can move from the lowest level of spirituality to the highest level of spirituality. That has some problems connected with it as you can imagine. But in Walter Hilton's book there seems to be a lot of truth and a lot that can benefit us. The way he does it is this. He says you start on a lower level, level of knowledge of God by study. I want to know more about God, study the Bible, study the writings of the church fathers, study in a seminary we would say today. Although that was not what Walter Hilton had his mind. But he says this at one point in his ladder of perfection, for one who has always been ardent of the knowledge of God out of spiritual things, it can sometimes seem that he increases after a certain point relatively little in love for God. So what this mystic is saying is that you can be very ardent for the knowledge of God. But you find after a while that your love for God doesn't increase correspondingly. And he's concerned about that as he should be. And so he moves to the next level which is love for God. And that goes through various steps. First a kind of transitory love, love that comes and goes, love that increases and decreases. And we might think that's the way our love for God always is and always will be. But Walter Hilton wanted to advance to a kind of subtle love for God. It's not so transitory. It could not be shaken but would be there in all circumstances of life. And then he goes from knowledge of God up through transitory love for God and settle love for God. And then finally the top level is both knowledge and love. That's really where he wants us to be because he's not demeaning knowledge. Sometimes the mystics do but Hilton doesn't. Knowledge is important but love must keep up with the knowledge and the final analysis, the perfection that we seek is both to no God and to love God. Well let's come now to Julian of knowledge. Julian was an English Benedictine but she became what was called an anchoress. That was a person who no longer lived in community but lived alone in a cell. Julian after a time of illness in her life entered a cell that was built of joining the church in knowledge in England. And there she had a window opening into the church to receive the Eucharist and the administration of the priest and she had a window opening out into the street to receive people who would come. So she was not just shedding herself all from life. She could look one way into the church and another way into the street but she lived in that cell. The idea of an anchoress was kind of anchor for people. She became an anchor by her prayer and by her meditation and by her teaching. And I already mentioned the fact that this woman was the first woman to write a book in English and that book is called the Revelations of Divine Love. The word Revelations is important. When she was about 30 she experienced this life-threatening illness which was probably the occasion for her entering the cell as an anchoress. And during a short period of some days or perhaps weeks she received 16 Revelations. God revealed himself, spoke to her directly. She said in these 16 Revelations and she meditated on those Revelations for about 15 years. And then wrote the book Revelations of Divine Love. The two words Divine Love are important too because you might say the theme of all these Revelations is this, the Divine Love and Julian put it this way. This way I could see no sort of anger in God however long I looked. She's often quoted for that and she's famous for that. There's no anger in God. There's no wrath in God. Everything I see in God is locked. That was quite different from medieval theology which is not Cordeles Homo where God's wrath appears against sin and necessitates the coming of the God man, appease the wrath of God. Julian says there's no wrath in God there is only love. The long quotation in the syllabus has to do with her vision of the hazelnut which is probably the most famous of the Revelations. Here is the icon of Julian. You can see she has in her fingers there a little hazelnut and she looks at it in her meditation and she says what is it? And the answer comes to her it is it is all that is made and I marveled she said how it might last for me thought it might suddenly have fallen to not for littleness so small and insignificant. It seemed like it would just disappear but then she wrote and I was answered in my understanding it last it ever shall last because God loves it. God loves the hazelnut and so that's what makes it last. That's what gives it stability and significance and importance. So all things have the being by the love of God. In this little thing I saw three properties the first is that God made it second is that God loves it the third is that God keeps it. That's sort of the theme of the Revelation. God made everything God loves everything God keeps everything but what is to me verily the maker the keeper and the lover. He is my maker he is my keeper he is my lover. I cannot tell for till I am substantially won oh in E.D. to him I may never have full rest nor very bliss see the push of the desire in Julian just like in my star card to be one substantially won with God so that I can rest in bliss knowing in the world. Knowing him as the maker the keeper and the lover well just one other quotation from the book revelations and divine love and this is probably the most famous quotation all shall be well and all shall be well and all manner of thing shall be well. In the present cell of Julian in Norwich the church in Norwich was destroyed during the second world war by German bombs but it was rebuilt with the cell of Julian and there is this window with Julian hearing from Christ the words all shall be well and all shall be well and all manner of things. You might have heard that quotation and never have read the revelation divine love because that appears in one of the points of T.S. Eliot but Eliot is quoting from Julian here in the words all shall be well and all shall be well and all manner of things shall be well. The Irish missionary to India Amy Carmichael read the revelations of divine love frequently and was greatly inspired by that book particularly by the description of prayer given by Julian of Norwich which I've included there in the syllabus. Well let's move on to Catherine of Siena in Italy Catherine was a member of an order she was a Dominican tertiary the third order of the Dominican movement. There are two things that are very striking about Catherine of Siena and that is she brings together mystical rapture and active service most of the mystics are not going to be out there in the world mixing up in the world and doing things. Mystics withdrawal live quiet lives of meditation and prayer but Catherine seemed to be able to do both there are many stories about the mystical rapture Catherine claims to have experienced she referred to these times as times of abstraction times of prayer. She would not really know that she was in the world or not know what was going on around about her times of abstraction in her devotional life the central theme of her writings is Christ crucified and especially his blood. Her writings are collected in a book called a dialogue a short excerpt of which is in the syllabus as well as an excerpt from Julian of Norwich and she read Catherine Christ crucified the blood and the rapture that comes as she contemplates the sufferings of Christ until she experiences these times of abstraction but strikingly she's also very active very involved in care of the sick and the poor preaching to centers she tries to convert them. And even on a higher level she becomes a kind of mediator between the warring cities of Italy and is given credit not only for that work but she helped persuade Pope Gregory the eleventh to transfer the papacy from having gone back to Rome. It seems that her influence and her persuasiveness was the crucial factor that made him make that move but as we know that did not solve the problem on the papacy that produced the papal sism and about that time Catherine died she was only 33 years old. Sometimes said that her heart was broken because her efforts to reunite the church had not succeeded she's a very important figure she was declared a doctor of the Catholic church in 1970 fairly recently but when she was given that title Doctor of the church she joined about 30 other people not all that many people have been named to that high position in the Catholic church. Well let's move on to Johannes Howler another 14th century mystic he's also a Dominican but a German and we have in the syllabus a writing from teller called the way of prayer from his German theology it's his call and a short prayer in the syllabus may Jesus Christ the king of glory help us to make the right use of all the suffering. It comes to us and to offer to him the incense of a patient and trustful heart for his names sake a man of all the physics a teller is my favorite. It was a lot of spiritual blessing that can come from reading the sermons and conferences of John teller. He started reading teller because Luther advised people to read teller and Luther brought out several editions of the German theology with his own recommendation and introduction to teller. Luther said the German theology of teller does not float on top like foam on water it has rather been fetched out of the rock bottom of Jordan by a true Israelite. Next to the Bible and say the gust in no book is ever coming to my hands from which I have learned more of what God Christ and man and all things are. It's pretty high praise for this German Dominican from a fellow German Augustinian reformer Martin Luther. I think what really appeal to Luther in teller was his humbleness his humility his loneliness he was small nothing before God to whom all the honor belongs. So Luther who very much dislike the proud and boastful scholastics felt they had all the answers returned again and again to the quiet humble teaching of teller. The teller was not perfect and Luther in a marginal note that he affixed to one of teller's sermons struck out the word humility and put in the word faith. We are not justified by being humble justified by faith was not that teller did not perhaps come very close to saying that the Luther wanted him to say it even more explicitly justification is indeed by faith. And then we come finally to the most famous of the medieval mystics and the most famous of the books Thomas the Tempest and the imitation of Christ the imitation of Christ was the most widely read book of the Middle Ages. And the writings of Thomas the Tempest and others collected in the imitation of Christ is what's called the modern devotion the modern devotion the writings of Thomas the Tempest and others from the brothers of the common life. That was a movement that began in the Netherlands and spread to various places something like an order but a lay movement laymen and women not bowed in the same way as the monks were by bals but brothers, sisters who came together to share with each other and to practice good works particularly to set up the world. We have schools established or the teaching of children in many places by the brothers and sisters of the common life. One of these brothers was Thomas the Tempest. We really know very little about his life he had an unadventful life as brother and one of the brother houses when the plague struck down most of the members of the house. Thomas had to pitch in and do different jobs to keep things running and he became the monastery cook someone wrote him he made the kitchen a house of prayer or he knew that God was everywhere. I don't know if you read the imitation of Christ I hope you will sometime brief selection from the imitation in the syllabus but it's well worth reading at all it's not the kind of book you just picked up and read right through. It's more like reading the book of Proverbs we get short tithy statements often gilms of expression and extraordinarily fresh with something of the power and appeal of the Proverbs and other portions of scripture. I quoted just a few of those in the syllabus note the first Jesus says I am the way and the truth and the life without the way there is no going without the truth there is no knowing without the life there's no living the kind of thing you find in the imitation of Christ. I think the imitation of Christ so widely read was a book that allowed many people to understand at least something of what was in the Bible because people were not able to read the Bible for themselves. As you study the imitation of Christ the title might seem to suggest that the book is going to stress imitating Christ and trying to be like Christ and in some ways that is true but there is often a real display of grace in the imitation of Christ. It's not perfect in times that Thomas can lapse into a sacramentalism or even a works righteousness but taken as a whole the imitation is more Augustinian than semi-pologian although people have differed on an analysis of the imitation right by John Duncan. Scottish theologian said of Thomas the Empress a fine fellow but hazy and weak at times and what he meant by that was gospel doesn't always come through and I think that's true but another Scottish theologian Thomas Martin Lindsay writes despite wrong notions of the sacrament Thomas the Empress had a clear conception that God's grace was freely given and not merited by what. This man can do so you read the imitation and decide whether Duncan is right or Lindsay is right well let me come to a stunning up of mysticism kind of evaluation how do we how do we look at this medieval movement some very good things about it and some problems. One of the good things I think is stress on letting God that is an emphasis that should always be there we can't say that too much. One of the descriptions of mystical theology that comes from the middle ages came from the Chancellor of University of Paris is an illustration that I really think is very good. Because this man in writing on mystical theology says as honey requires honeycomb so devotion needs to be structured by our learn and orthodox mind as honeycomb needs to be filled so ideas of the mind must also warm the heart and lead to activity in the world. Not just about says at all you need the structure need the honeycomb need the theology need the orthodoxy also need the honey need something to fill it and not only to enlighten the mind but to warm the heart and from an enlightened mind and a warm heart we can go out to activity in the world. So all the mystics got it right some demean learning some were not very acted in the world but this statement expresses mysticism at its best it is a concern that we not only understand but that we love God and that we serve him. I think another striking characteristic of the mystics is their concern for quietness and humility. I quote here the Princeton theologian Presbyterian minister J. W. Alexander he wrote this 150 years ago but it applies to our time as well as to he is he says seems to me that in our day we take the pattern and measure of our religion too commonly from what is popular. That is from what is bustling outward and full of a plot but it may appear in another world that some of the mightiest influences have preceded from souls of great quiet those words from J. W. Alexander the words that I'd use in the title for the lecture think about that I think that is worth pondering. But there are two real problems with the mystics one is the problem of individualism this may not be true of all the mystics it certainly was not true of Catherine of Siena and it is not true in the quotation above from Joan Gerson but as the German historian Kurt Alain puts it to a certain extent the mystic lived within a glass jar from which the world was batting. And in which there was really nothing but a private conversation between God and the soul don't have a lot of development of a Christian world and life view here it's my relationship to God even the church isn't all that important. It's a very personalized individual relationship to God that the mystics pursue not all of them but mysticism generally is going to take that direction. And then there is a mysticism as there certainly was in humanism and even in scholasticism attendancy towards self righteousness toward works righteousness Richard Lovelace puts it this way the writings of the mystics are full of nervous instructions to believers trying to cross the gap between man and God. On their own foot paths well that's the old problem all over again there's a way that seems right to us and we think by doing these things we can enter into favor with God. Not all of the mystics went that way but there was the tendency for them to do so but as I've said there are glimpses of grace in the mystics in the imitation of Christ in the German theology of tower. John Newton wrote amazing grace a young sailor casually picked up a copy of the imitation of Christ not really interested in being a Christian in fact he was very much opposed to it but he carelessly read the imitation and the more he read it the more trouble he became thinking that it might indeed be true and if it was he was in trouble. So it was through the imitation Christ that the evangelical experience of John Newton was first developed. I want to clarify this lecture with a prayer from Thomas the campus and I think it's a very appropriate one because it's a prayer for all teachers and students we're all students and one sense we're all teachers here. So let me pray these words with you as we conclude grant O Lord to all teachers and students to know what is worth knowing to love what is worth loving to praise what pleases you most and to dislike what so ever is evil in your sight. Grant us with true judgment to distinguish things that differ and above all to search out and do what is well pleasing to you through Jesus Christ our Lord. No it's just a term the modern devotion is a expression that is used for the piety of the brothers of the common life and for the imitation of Christ. You can really say it equals the imitation of Christ. By the way I suggest in the syllabus that if you want to read a modern preacher who has a real love for the mystics and is an evangelical, A.W. Tozer's knowledge of the holy. He'll quote Julian of Norwich, a cloud of unknowing, teller almost all the mystics that I mentioned are coded by tozer. He was in the Christian missionary alliance pastor in Toronto for many years, a great preacher. When did it when was it applied to them? I think it the term mystic was used by these very people like John Garrison who wrote on mystical theology. So they did not they did not reject this word. They felt it was a good word and it described described it. Yes are the mystics for runners of modern day charismatic well certainly in terms of revelations ecstatic experience. I would see I could see some connections.