<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ba da Tallafi Ba da Tallafi Kowane Wata

Universal Forms of Love, IV

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

I have another prayer of Martin Franzmann to read as we begin class. This one is titled in a democracy which I think is appropriate both in light of our subject matter today and where we are in our political calendar. Let's pray together. All mighty ruler of us all, you have made us to be both Caesar and Caesar subjects. You have given us wrapped in the blessing of the free this dual and difficult duty to fulfill. Give us the meekness of wisdom to know that the good laws we make are not our laws simply to do with as we please, but have appoint them your hallowed instancy, your inviolable majesty, that when we make and honor bad laws, we are flouting you the righteous, and you will visit on us our unfaithfulness. Teach us to know that the men we have elected are your instruments with your sword in their hands. Teach us to bow before your majesty hid in such deep disguise in the name of Jesus. Amen. Now we're continuing today, a topic we began last time on the use of the moral law, and we had gotten to a section on point one was classification, two was that excursus on the Ten Commandments in Church History, and this is the topic is the secular use of the ducal log, and I want to introduce you to a German Calvinist, Johannes Althussius, as we get into this topic. He's not much remembered in our circles, although he's having something of a a resurgence, but he lived late 16th early 17th century, wrote a book that is titled Politica, first published in 1603, and then went through two or three editions and which it was expanded. It's a treatise on political science, we would call it, politics would be the way that's translated, but politics was broader than the way in which we conceive of it today. It's political science and he was a seminal baker, studied law, taught law at the Calvinist College Herborn, which had an international student body, and it was very influential in his time, but we sent lost track of him, but he provides us with a good example of how to go about life in the civil community, and it relates to particular to our topic on the secular use of the Ten Commandments. There are four points about his system of political science that I would like to make briefly. If you want more to tale about Althussius, check out the article in the Encyclopedia Philosophy. That'll give you the background and his place in the history of political science, but he's a Calvinist, he's using scripture, reason, experience in order to develop this political science. He is the 17th century equivalent of Abraham Kuiper, and there is material in there that is still very useful in building a Christian approach to society. First point is his definition of politics or political science. Politics is the science of linking human beings to each other for a social life. Politics is the science of linking human beings to each other for a social life. He suggested a term for it that he thought would be better than political. He wanted to call it symbiotics rather than politics. Well, I didn't catch on, but it shows the positive direction of his thought. He's talking about the organization of human social life. Politics is the science or as he would call it, symbiotics is the science of linking human beings to each other for a social life. That's the definition. What's the goal? Point to the end or goal of symbiotic man. Man as a social being is wholly just, comfortable, and happy symbiosis. He works that term in whatever he can, but he's talking about a life that is wholly just, comfortable, and happy, human beings living in community, the whole community. So it would lack nothing that's necessary or useful for a flourishing human life. He's talking about how can we organize society in order that human beings flourish. Third point, part of his argument for the need for political is in this life, no one is self-sufficient. If we're going to have a useful, comfortable, happy social life, then the energies and activities of many are needed to supply these things. He's arguing that as long as we are isolated individuals, we can't flourish its human beings. Human beings are social beings, and they cannot live at all well without society. Then fourth, this mutual communication between human beings living in society, this common enterprise by which human beings flourish involves three things. Goods, services, and common rights by which the needs of each and everyone are supplied and the self-sufficient and mutuality of human society are achieved and social life established and concerned. I mean, he goes on and on, but the key point is that the three things involved in the common enterprise, the common good of human beings living in community, goods, services, and common rights. And here's where the secular use of the decalogue comes in. So with respect to common rights, he puts in the preface to his third edition that the precepts of the decalogue are included in political science to the extent that they infuse a vital spirit into the social life that we teach. The precepts are the decalogue are included to the extent that they infuse a vital spirit into the social life that we teach. They carry a torch, he says. They prescribe and constitute a guiding star, a boundary for human society. Notice the positive as well as the restraining aspect of the precepts. They provide a guiding star, a boundary for human society. If anyone would take them out of politics, he would destroy it. Precepts of the decalogue are integral to the social life of human beings living in community. Notice he says the precepts of the decalogue, the principles that are there. He does distinguish the ecclesiastical from the secular. And so he divides the implications of the decalogue corresponding to the ecclesiastical communion is religion and piety which pertain to the welfare and eternal life of the soul. That's the church's job. The corresponding to the latter, the secular use of the precepts of the decalogue, corresponding to the latter is justice which concerns this life, rendering to each his due, the second table of the decalogue. So he's primarily concerned that in the social life that we recognize that there is this distribution of functions between ecclesiastical side and what he calls the secular side that which is what we would refer to the civil use of the law in society, a distinction between the first and second table of the law. But now it's to be expected that after that history of the ten commandments in the church that we went over yesterday, the formative influence of that through all of those catechisms and so forth, that the ten commandments came to have a privileged place in the ordering of society. And the Alphusius position has had many followers. I'll give you a couple of examples. There's Carl Henry who wrote in his groundbreaking book, 1947, the uneasy conscience of modern fundamentalism. Brief quote from Henry, the ten commandments disclose the only secure foundation for a society. All cultures, cut loose from these principles, have in them the busiating leaven of decay. The ten commandments are the only secure foundation for a society. And it's not just conservative evangelicals who write that way. That was Carl Henry in the uneasy conscience of modern fundamentalism. When he called for, he should that call, that clarion call, to social involvement on the part of fundamentalist Christians who had withdrawn basically from political life, withdrawn from culture. Two other books that fairly recent that take that same position, the Alphusian position, we may call it, are Walter Harrelson. If you're interested in a complete bibliography on the ten commandments, I'll give, send me an email and I can get it to you. Walter Harrelson, the ten commandments and human rights, published in 1980, the ten commandments and human rights. And the other one is Paul Lehman, the decalogue and a human future, 1995. So the recognition that the decalogue is foundation for social life and particularly the political life is widespread, particularly as it has to do with the second table of the law and the securing of human rights. We will make a brief characterization of how this works out. The first table of the law, first four commandments containing our duty toward God, calls for the recognition on the part of others are right to worship and serve God above all things. You know, if we are commanded in the first table of the law to express the love for the Lord our God with all our heart and mind and soul in these four ways, then that's a God given right that has to be respected. The second table of the law, the fifth commandment, you shall honor your father and your mother, establishes the right to exercise authority in God given social structures. What those social structures are, we'll take up after the midterm as we go through the ten commandments, but that's the principle, the right to exercise authority in God given social structures, honor your father and mother, establishes the right of parents to train their children, according to the education that is best to fit to for them. Not only to provide for them, although that's implied also, but also to bring them up for Christians in the nurtured admonition of the Lord. The sixth commandment is obviously the right to light. The seventh commandment, the right to sexual integrity, the eighth commandment, the right to, I think it's best to put this labor and its reward, you shall not steal means that there are things that I have as a consequence of my labor that are uniquely my personal property. The ninth commandment, you shall not bear false witnesses, right to one's reputation or good name, and the tenth commandment, you shall not covet, that gets to the heart, but I think that there is a right to be exempt from threats, serious threats that harm the psyche, you know, I think you can make a case for that, but certainly these five through nine have a corresponding, the command implies a corresponding right to be recognized and to be upheld in society. This is why the ten commandments have been so useful in the development of Western society because they are a handy way of expressing the what is also known by general revelation and by God's common grace. Still, the ten commandments do organize this thought in a very profound way. They've had a very profound effect on the development of American society as well as other Western societies. I'll give you an example. Several years ago, one of my sons was involved in a fender bender, it was a hit and run, and I mean he was hit in the other guy ran, and so we, as a teenager, this is his first accident on a rainy night, so he called me and I went with him to the police department where we had to report the hit and run, report, fill out a full report, everything that had happened. And it was a little do police department and there on the wall of the place where the policemen right out their reports, there was a list of numbers, went something like this, 101, premeditated murder, 102, assault with a deadly weapon, 103 and some other sort of violence, 201, forcible rape, 202, sexual assault, 203, you know, and then 301, robbery, 302, breaking in, entering, you know, what's happened? Well, you're going down, you're going down the list of the commandments and you're specifying particular crimes, the basis of which are the protection of human life and the 10 commandments obviously have had a formative influence on the way in which we organize our criminal codes. I went back to the do police department later and I showed him my card, you know, a covenant seminary. I'm writing a book on ethics, I was here on a hit and run and where the officers write out their reports, there's this code and if I could get a copy of that, it would be very helpful. I shouldn't have used the word code because they just said we don't have a code but I tried to explain, well, you know, it's these numbers that you, but they insisted that I didn't, that doesn't exist. If you know anyone in the do police department, you know, see if my memory serves me, I don't think I made that up out of my head, I think it's actually pretty standard. Now, you would think, you would think that with this history of the use of the decalogue, a particular, the second table of the law and remember there is a distinction in Althusias between how the first table is applied and who has the oversight of that and the second table of the law which is the civil government. I think it's important to recognize that. We have moved away in the Presbyterian Church in America from the excessively paternalistic view of the civil government. There was indeed original Westminster Confession of Faith in which the civil magistrate was responsible for the extrepancy of heresy that put, you know, sound doctrine in the hands of the civil government. Well, depending on whether the civil government was Catholic or Protestant, spelled persecution for Protestants or Catholics and we finally realized that that we might take another look at that in terms of how God wills his society and church to go forward in this age in which you don't root up the tears. You allow them to grow to the harvest and God will sort it out then. So the freedom of conscience had to be established and that power of the state to enforce the first table of the law reduced are the new form of the Westminster Confession that was drafted in 1788. Has it its responsibility of the civil government to protect the church? That is, as an institution that God has ordained, it must be allowed to flourish, that is, the role of government. But it uses a phrase that I think maybe we could find better language for. It calls the civil magistrate nursing fathers. That seems to me to be paternalistic to the point of being maternalistic. You know, I, is it riffle the way to think of the civil government as nurturing the church, rather than protecting the church as a separate institution? Well, we'll return to that in due course. But now that you would think that in light of our history and of this development that posting the ten commandments in public schools would not be problematic. But it is a it causes a firestorm every time this issue comes up. Last June, the House of Representatives passed what's called the Ten Commandments Defense Act. It was an amendment to the juvenile crime bill that was thought to be appropriate way. And what's behind that is we see the moral decay in our country and juveniles involved in more and more crime. This came in the wake of the particularly violent episode at Columbine High School. And in the the mood of we need to do something about the moral decay in our society, let's post the ten commandments. And the rationale was to permit display in schools and other public buildings was because these are the principles I'm quoting from the bill the principles which we as a civil society need to live by to maintain order and decency and to preserve the American family. You know, you get family values in there whenever you can. And you would think that that would not mean light of our history that that might not be be problematic. But it is questionable. And actually there is a Supreme Court case that has already dealt with this issue. It is Stone versus Graham. Stone versus Graham, this was 1980. If you're interested in looking this up on the web, 449 US 39. So that's one thing about the the internet. There's all this material that all this information is there. If you want a Supreme Court decision, you know, you can you don't have to go to a law library. You can go directly to it. You know, it's as close as your mouse. And it's not too difficult to find out where to look for it. Even I was able to do that. But Stone versus Graham had to do with a Kentucky case. What Kentucky had done was to pass a statute requiring the posting of the ten commandments on the wall of each public classroom in the state. These were not purchased through taxation. These were privately funded. Funds had been available for this to be done. And its its intention was not religious according to the way the law was drafted in Kentucky. And the ten commandments had at the bottom and fine print. The secular application of the ten commandments is clearly seen in its adoption as the fundamental legal code of Western civilization and the common law of the United States. So it was posted in public school classrooms to serve a secular purpose. And it carried that notation. I'll read it once again. The secular application, the ten commandments is clearly seen in its adoption as the fundamental legal code of Western civilization and the common law of the United States. And what happened was that the Supreme Court did not give it plenary consideration. It it summarily reversed it. It had been sent up to the Supreme Court on appeal and the Supreme Court denied the appeal. There were three justices who dissented to of whom were in the way their opinion was written felt that they should be posted. One who felt that the the the the the problem was not with the argument. He thought that the argument of the majority was was constitutional. But he felt that there ought to be a full because of the importance of this issue. There ought to be a full presentation and debate at rather than being summarily dismissed. So we already have a precedent that was said, although since it was not plenary consideration, you could argue that let's pass the law through Congress, post them in the classrooms. We know it will go to the Supreme Court, but let's see if we can get a plenary hearing for it. And there there's wide support for that among the American people. It is it is not an act of political courage particularly to be on the side of posting the 10 commandments. And given the privileged place of the 10 commandments, the impulse to acknowledge privilege position by posting them in public institutions is certainly understandable in light of the formative influence of the biblical tradition on our common law, the common heritage of Christian and Jews. And in the handout that I gave you, the ethical society doesn't have any disagreement with the principles of the second table. It affirms them. But what it objects to is the religious context in which they are presented. And I think that, you know, that's the issue that we have to have to deal with. Does religious pluralism trump our historical roots? And I think that we need to be aware of the specifically religious context of the 10 commandments. And the reason for their their desiring to post them is not just historical. I think that's more clear in the House bill that's now pending before the Senate. It's really to recover the moral fabric of our society. We post the 10 commandments. Maybe it will have some beneficial effect in terms of people adopting these are being reminded of them and not to have them. I think that I've given you two responses. The one is of the ethical society which resist the idea of posting them because of their religious context. And the other one from a reformed think tank that ejects to them because it misses the issue of what education is and education is religious and what we ought to do really is to have a different take on the public character of the education distinguishing between government sponsored education and ecclesial sponsored education. But both serving public purposes and therefore the ecclesial sponsored or private sponsored ought to have the same benefit of the public support as does the government sponsor schools. But this is one of the most contentious issues in our society. I have a different a different view of I support the idea of Christian education and I think that it is unjust that we cannot have full choice in terms of the education that people desire for their children. And I'll talk about that later. But I think that just to take the public schools, although our initial reaction is to be positively disposed toward posting the 10 commandments, how could we be against that? That just seems so right and obvious that we almost fall into supporting that without thinking what its actual impact may be. There is a different way to look at the 10 commandments in the public schools that Stone versus Graham, the majority report, did actually a firm wrote on the concerning the report. This is not a case in which the 10 commandments are integrated into the school curriculum, where the Bible may constitutionally be used in an appropriate study of history, civilization, ethics, comparative, religion or the like. I think a much better way is to take a way of that a constitutionally affirmed position. And the place to teach the 10 commandments is in either history or social science or political science or what other parts of the school curriculum because of that. For if the purpose is the formative influence of the 10 commandments and what the 10 commandments are and raising the question of the source of moral obligation, then that certainly can be done. Whereas the posting of the 10 commandments, it does seem to me that what you're doing is taking something that appeared in a particular form to God's people and making a secular use of what is a covenant with God's people. The 10 commandments include interglings, the preface or prologue. I am the Lord your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt out of the house of bondage, you shall have no other gods before me. Who is the author of the 10 commandments? Well, it's the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, it is the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. You're taking the 10 words that out of the whole Bible were spoken by God himself and then inscribed by God himself and using them for a secular purpose. I think there's a that isn't a front to people who do who are outside that to our tradition. And I think to be sensitive toward the pluralism, religious pluralism of our society, we ought to recognize that even though the commandments embody universal moral norms, I think we should say that, even though the commandments embody universal moral norms, so their society must have these principles, the context in which they are given or is particular, they were promulgated as the covenant way of life. So I think that we should distinguish between the civil use of the moral law that is known by general revelation and the secular use of the decalogue. I think that we should study the decalogue. I think that we should, instead we will show how it alums what is known by general revelation, but the moral law it known by general revelation is accessible to all, posting the decalogue, imposes special revelation on some who do not recognize its authority and establishes the divine command theory of morality. Now if you look at the handout on the Calvinan Hobbes, let's say posting the decalogue imposes special revelation on some who do not recognize its authority. And I think you can't get away from that as you just cannot separate in this form of the decalogue, the principles from its religious context. You're making a secular use of a religious document. At the same time, I want to be careful to say that the principles, the precepts of the decalogue are the foundation of a society, and they can be shown to be dead and they need to be studied that without committing us to a particular view of society. Now if you look on the Calvin side, this is a very helpful contrast written by Arthur J. Dyke, professor of social ethics at Harvard, and he's quite good in terms of his analysis. He is Christian and he does argue scripturally and he has much that's good to say, but his analysis of the contrast between Calvin and Hobbes, I think is very useful. For now, look at them on the Calvin side. Moral obligations are natural. They are expressions of our nature as social animals. Moral obligations are dependent, independent of governments. They are standards in which governments should base their policies and by which these can be judged by everyone. Third, moral obligations are God's will and the image of God in everyone. Rulers and citizens are obligated by the same moral law for moral obligations are universally known by human cognitive powers apart from any special revelation. So the moral law is universally a standard. Now that's the part that I want to focus on. I would distinguish that from the question of the source of moral obligations. That's the next question, but the fact is that there is an overlapping consensus on common morality. I would put it this way, common morality by virtue of general revelation and common grace, common morality exists without a common ethical theory to back it up. I think that there's a weakness in not giving an account of our common morality. I think that there is an apologetic opening for us to present the divine command theory of moral obligation, but we're not likely to, if we have to wait for common morality for us to have a common epistemology, we're not going to have it. And even within those who accept the divine command theory of morality, there are disagreements. In other words, you may have theoretical agreement without entire practical agreement, and you can have practical agreement without answering the theoretical questions. And my earlier comments on Jacques Martana and the UN Charter and the UNESCO Charter and the Universal Declaration of Human Lights are in that ring. I would say the common core of ethical beliefs from theological point of view, known by general revelation by God's common grace, form an overlapping consensus so that there is pre-theoretical agreement that we can build on, pre-theoretical agreement. That is before we give a theory of the ground and source of moral obligation, pre-theoretical agreement on basic moral principles, I think that there are four of these. These four general principles of common morality, reciprocity, go under others as you would have them to do unto you, which children can learn at a very early age. I understand, I don't have the documentation on this, but there was a psychologist in one of the news broadcasts this week that says research is indicated that as early as three years of age, a child can't express empathy. You know, don't hurt someone because you know what it is to be hurt. It develops that early, and by age six, there is a clear knowledge of right and wrong. The traditional age of years of discretion, the traditional age for one's first communion in the Roman Catholic system, traditional age for confirmation, in churches that have that as a sacrament, is age seven. It's at age seven that psychologists have determined that children can recognize symbolism so that they can understand the the Lord's Supper in communion and so forth. So, you know, it's very early. Now, in these early ages, common morality needs to be taught. The first principle is reciprocity, due to others as you would have them to do unto you. Second principle is consistency, and children learn this very early. It's not fair, they will say, when you don't treat each of your children alike. It's not fair. You don't have to give a reason why one child gets more attention than another child, if that's the case. You know, it's not fair. That's one of the earliest that children learn. Reciprocity, consistency, what's technically known as non-molificents. You know, don't hurt people, non-molificents, and the opposite of that is a beneficence to good people. That non-molificents would be number three, and beneficence would be number four. On those four principles, there is an overlapping consensus, so that and as children are instructed in the home, those are filled out. As they go to school, they find or should find that there is an overlapping consensus with the instruction that they get in the school. Yes, Jim. Okay. Non-molificents means, I don't know if I can not. M-A-L-I-F-I-C-E-N-C-E. Non-molificents. It is a technical term. It's not doing hurt harmful things to other people. It's the principle of do no harm, and the nephesence, these are the standard terms that go through the liturgy. Beneficence is do good to everyone. Okay, so you don't do harm, and you do do good. That's non-molificents, and if this positive beneficence. Well, that takes you along right. That's what the character education movement has that I've mentioned before, highlighted before, has introduced. If you'll take out the grid on the character education movement, I'm saying there's a better way to go about our public education. I think that even if we do have choice in terms of whether we will have the Christian education or a government education, there always be a need for a common government-controlled schools. That's going to be with us for a long time. These are the seven models of moral education that are operative now. You'll see that the character education model, which is taking the lead now, emphasizes content, emphasizes universal virtues. They are the more general ones, killing is wrong. It's only in the upper and to children, the basic moral principles need to be communicated dogmatically. Cheating is wrong. This is why the character education movement is of the 90s is so much superior to the values clarification movement of the 70s and 80s in which in order to avoid imposing morality on others, the question of whose morality you're going to impose, students would discuss and clarify their own values. A student could give a very clear account of why he cheated because that's the way to get ahead. This is that kind of a world. It's worth the risk of cheating because success is not tied to intrinsic performance. It's tied to getting ahead. And if I can get ahead by cheating, I mean, he's just adopted values from our society. What's a teacher to say? Not in my classroom, but that's imposing the teacher's morality on the classroom. So it finally fizzled. And because it was based, it was thought that we cannot agree on objective basis. Now, the cleric character education movement says, we know what morality to teach. We have a common morality. We may not be able to agree on the theoretical basis for it, but we know that respect, responsibility, trustworthiness, caring, civic responsibility, and fairness are all right. We know those. And when we get into upper grades, we can talk about the details. We know that killing human beings is wrong. The upper grades, we can talk about the morality of capital punishment. That's taking of human life. Is capital punishment fall under the general commandment of not taking human life? Or is there some special considerations that makes it right? Well, that's an application of how that works out. Is Euthanasia right? Involuntary Euthanasia, taking someone's life for their own good, putting them out of their misery, even though they haven't asked for it. Well, we can talk about, you know, that seems to be less of a borderline than voluntary Euthanasia, where a person asked to be taken out of his misery, or at least to be assisted by a physician in taking out his mystery, taking them out of his misery. Infanticide, that seems fairly clear, although some question it. Abortion, that's the most debatable issue in our society, or the most debated one, in any case, and you have to make that case. Not all one is immediately convinced that abortion is wrong. But you move from the special protection that you accord to human life as intrinsically right to the more borderline questions. But we know that human life must have special protection. Question is whether human life in the womb should have the same protection as human life outside the womb. Now, at the same time, these other models are still operative, civics model, philosophy model, and so forth, and there is still those who adopt an anti-moral education stance, that it's not the function of the school to teach morality, that this is a respect for moral autonomy and avoidance of indoctrination. That was the position behind the values clarification movement. Public schools were very much critiqued for not teaching morality, and so values clarification was a way of recovering that particular influence. The character education model, which now is on the ascendancy, is something I think we should support. I think that it has its limitations. I mentioned some in the previous talk, but it is a common morality, and it is proving successful in the younger great, which is largely where it is effective, and it opens for children who have received minimal moral education in the home. It is providing an incentive to develop their character in structured ways that are based on universal principles, that if we track them down, we could see the impact of the ten commandments and of Christianity, in particular, on Western civilization. An example, I leaked over when I was going through the Ten Commandments in Church history. I don't know if you noticed, but in the Ditta Caves, the earliest document we have, the Ditta C under an expounding, the protection of human life condemns both in fantasized and abortion. Now, it was counter-cultural to do that, but it was a Christian's word, a distinct minority. Depocrities was in a minority in the medical profession when he introduced his oath, which you had to take in order to study medicine with him, that you wouldn't perform abortion or use your medicines for euthanasia. You couldn't get this information unless you took an oath not to use it that way, which shows general revelation and common grace to a high degree of specificity as possible. Christian faith, as it spread, persuaded people of those issues. Now, in the 20th century, the late 20th century, there was an abandonment of that, but it is an apostasy from a position that was originally seen widely to be an extrapolation of the sanctity of life that was protected by the Sixth Commandment. I would say that the precepts are still there, but they are not presented in the particular context. We need not think that in order to have these principles in society, we necessarily have to post them in classrooms. Another principle of taking what belongs to someone else is wrong. Children can learn that very early. It's wrong. It's not just a clarification of some subjective value. We all think that that's wrong. There's an interesting experiment that professor at Stanford University uses when he's faced with skepticism about moral principles. Imagine he would tell them that I'm going to parachute you into a country somewhere in the world, and you have an idea of where it is. As soon as you get out of your parachute, I want you to walk up to the first person you see, take away whatever he or she is holding and run away with it. Then see what happens. With the possible exception he explains that you have landed in front of a Buddhist monk and taken away his begging bowl and that his only response is to sigh karma. You will have run squarely into the universal concept of property rights, codified in the Western world through the commandment. Don't steal. You didn't bring that commandment with you. You ran into it. If you travelers going from country to country can reasonably assume without consulting law books that most forms of theft and physical assault will be forbidden wherever they go. There may be some relativistic applications and when we get to the more complex issues such as taxation, whether taxation is confiscation of personal property or whether taxation is a legitimate government function, whether it is legitimate taxation to regard that as redistribution of wealth. Those are implications that you get to the more borderline situations that provoke a lot of discussion and thought. But the basic principles as they are embodied in the deck of log are known to human beings in a universal way. Relativism has gotten a big press but actually we don't live that way. International agreements would be worthless. Were they not based on some international understanding, transcultural understanding of what a commitment to a treaty is. Any questions that you might have in any thoughts that may be circulating in your mind? Okay. It's clear that the Supreme Court did not exclude the teaching of the Ten Commandments in social sciences and so forth. As a matter of historical fact, this is the basis of our common law and you may teach them. And I think that we should insist that part of the curriculum be the understanding of how Western law was formulated in light of these Ten principles, compare them with other cultures in terms of what standards they used in order to organize their social life. But it is clear that in the curriculum in the public schools, the Ten Commandments do have a place and the Supreme Court itself has said there's a constitutional place for it. It's when you get into the posting of the Ten Commandments as a religious document that you run into a difficulty. And even though atheists are a minority, still we have to respect the public character of our government-sponsored education and government we have learned, although government is based on a transcendent ground for moral obligation, that government should be neutral in towards the particular formations of special revelation. I think that was an important principle that was established. It took the 18th century really to get that principle straightened out. The last heretic executed in Scotland was in 1690 something. It was a man with the improbable name of Thomas Aikenhead. I don't know why that sticks with me, but he was either a pain to somebody or somebody gave him a pain, but then we moved beyond that. In public places, I think there is some difference, but I think it's a kind of an in-your-face move to post them there. Even though there's a case to be made because they have become throughout all that history, they do have the privileged place in terms of the formation of our code. They still are a religious document. The way they became a part of our code was through not imposition from above, but from development, through all these catechisms from below. I think that's still the way we should go about it, that the 10 commandments, that the decalogue as decalogue should be taught by the churches the covenant way of life, but it has its impact on society as Christians live out and implement that view in society. It seems me there's a better way of achieving our foregoalism or just society. Posting the 10 commandments, simply posting them is not the way. Besides, we have to look in terms of the purpose of the 10 commandments in Scripture is both to inform and to humble us. Run the risk of equating civic righteousness with the whole of morality by the secular use of the covenant document. At least we should be aware that we're posting the covenant in that. Your other question was oaths. To take an oath, that refers to the transcendent ground that you're taking. The reason the oath was taken that way is that's a common to take an oath by your supreme value or your ultimate reality, whatever that is for you. It's God in general, it's a religious oath, but we allow in our country for people to affirm and out of the anti-baptist tradition for those who say my word is my bond and take an absolute position against those. We allow them to affirm. We take that, take that, take them for their word on that. There is the idea of an oath was that when you can't, when they're perplexing circumstances and you're trying to decide between them, you put a person called this God is my witness, what I'm about to give is the truth and the thought was that surely that solemn either affirmation or oath with God is my witness. To call God to witness would make a person tell the truth, but we found that there's been a great erosion of that or at least if you, we've lost what the Westminster Confession has as a profound phrase, an oath is to be taken in the plain sense of the words without equivocation or mental reservation. Otherwise an oath is not an oath. If you have to play with words and people have to figure out what's in your mind, then an oath is worthless. It has to be, it has to be given. This is why we have the oath to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth. And I think we ought to add now the plain truth and not use words in equivocal ways with special meanings that nobody else has. Yes, Michael. I think that it's undeniable that biblical religion was one of the streams on which our nation was founded, but there was also the classic Republican stream, and there was an individualistic stream. The three streams are represented by Benjamin Franklin, the individualistic stream, Thomas Jefferson, the classic Republican stream, and John Witherspoon, the biblical tradition, all three signers of the Declaration of Independence. Those streams came together. So we've always had a mixed foundation, but we have assumed that we were a Protestant nation, not just a Christian nation, but a Protestant nation, with the immigration of Catholics, we began to have to realize that that's not true. And we're not even, you know, the, I think that it is not accurate to the history, but in addition to that, you have to take account of where we are now with 10% of our population who give no religion as their religion, the religious nuns, N-O-N-E-S, not in U-N-S. And that's a significant part of the population. Remember purpose of political science is to allow the whole community to live together. If you erect these barriers, religious barriers of alienation, you tear the social fabric. We need to be able to, we'll work on this again when we come to the role of the civil government, but I'm concerned that we recognize that it's the whole society that we have in mind, not a particular part of it. And the society as a whole is not in covenant with God, although it is clear that Christian principles have heavily influenced our society and should. Instead of, are you in that we should be a Christian nation, I would say we want to be a just nation. And and fulfill the preamble to the Constitution is actually quite adequate in terms of what to guide us for our our social philosophy. To establish justice, provide for the common events, promote the general welfare, and all those things or what we have, we the people of the United States say we're about. And I think that we should acknowledge that. I think that we ought not to make the 10 commandments an icon or a totem, as though just the posting of them is going to do is going to have have the major effect. And it is alienating. I'm probably in a minority in terms of objecting to prayer in the public schools, as well as the posting of the 10 commandments, but I do so on on grounds that these that we ought to maintain a distinction between government authorize religion and the recognition that there is a transcendent ground that is above the government, which is the ground sometimes of civil disobedience because these laws are human laws that may or may not reflect the will of God for society. Now there's one other topic that I'd like to say something about in this area. I've written on this in the book so it won't take us too long. But I would say it is the, but title it now, the source of moral obligation. I do think you have to answer that question at some point. We have a common morality. That's de facto. But what is the source of morality? What is the source of moral obligation? In the book I call it the ground of the moral law. And it's around one page 116. I write, if human beings or what the Bible says we are created in the image of God, no account of morality will be adequate that stops short of its ground in the nature and will of the creator. You have to give an account of moral obligation. And if we're created in the image of God, then we're not going to be able to give an adequate account without referring to the transcendent ground. And I argue that some, not at length but to some extent, we need to be aware that that of that position. And what, what our position technically is called is the divine command theory of moral obligation. That is in general ethics is referred to the divine command theory of moral obligations. That is, that all on biblical presuppositions, all morality is grounded in the character, the acts, the purposes, and the instructions of the God of Revelation. So all morality is grounded in the nature and will of God. Went into some distinctions in that earlier that some commandments derived directly from the nature of God, some derived from the way he has created human beings. And there is a way in which we can refer to natural law in that context. There's a way that God's will exists expressed in terms of the way he has made us in his image. And then there are other other commands that are obeyed in particular settings because that's God's purposes or his people at a particular time. One objection to the divine command theory goes like this. If, if morality is what God commands, then in a world created by an omnipotent demon, the opposite of what we think of morality would be morality. Now that, you know, we're not. What happens there is that people who raise that objection have the idea that your principle of morality, whatever it is, must hold for all possible universes. And so they imagine a universe created by an omnipotent demon. And if you have a divine command theory of morality, then the demonic would be moral. Well, you see, you can only think up a demonic category on the basis of the only universe there is. Then you judge this possible world that you thought up on the basis of the morality that derives from the real world that's created by a holy and loving God. We should never let folks get away with the divine command theory without specifying the nature of God as a holy and loving God. That's the only God there is. There isn't any other possible world. You know, there's only this universe and it is the creation of a holy and loving God. And therefore his commands, some of which are simply his will for us, some derive from the way he's created, others reflect his nature, are all the commands of a loving God. Therefore, they cannot be cruel or have anything that would be alien to that fundamental nature of God.