<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Muab Muab Txhua Hlis

The Emergence of Israel in Canaan

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

All right, in this section, in this session we want to take up another debating point, the debating point which I've entitled the emergence of Israel and Canaan, and you may be asking why didn't you just say the conquest of Canaan, and that's the debating point. How did it come about? What's the deal? So that's what we're going to talk about in this time. I don't know that we'll quite finish if we don't, we'll, as always, let it spill over to next time, but we'll see. The biblical picture, as you've read in the book of Joshua, is that Israel entered Canaan by a conquest, a military conquest, but this biblical picture has been challenged. The question is why? Why has it been challenged? And on your outline you see that I've listed four objections that I think are most typically raised as an objection to the, what appears to be the biblical account, what appears to be the biblical picture. The first is the historical objection, and this has to do with what is understood as the historical critical method. The method that historians are called upon to employ as they do their history work. Now you will have the privilege of reading about that in the art of biblical history, which is coming along. Now some people have asked in the past, why do you wait until later in the semester to read this? Why don't you read it up front? Because it's sort of prologomaniac. It's sort of a preparing the way and orienting you to certain issues. The reason I've chosen to do it is, I think maybe if we prime the pump a little bit, you'll go at this with somewhat more patience. It is written at a kind of a scholarly level, and this is... But Moses Selva says it's written with great literary flair, but he's a scholar, so I encourage you to be patient with it, but give it a good shot. But I'm going to quote a few things from it as we talk about these issues, and it just kind of gets you used to what you'll encounter there. Well, what about the historical critical method? I think the historical objection revolves around what I, if I can be very bold, would call simply an anti-theological bias in historical criticism as traditionally practiced. This comes right out of the Enlightenment, and so let me quote for you, a 19th century German scholar, very much under the influence of the Enlightenment, whose name was DF Strauss, who made quite an impact in biblical scholarship in a book he wrote, called Osleibin Yezu, the Life of Christ, a very groundbreaking book, and not particularly for good, but listen to what he says about how you determine what can count as historical reportage. He says this, this is on page 110, an account is not historical according to Strauss, when, and here I quote him, the narration is irreconcilable with the known and universal laws which govern the course of events. Now, according to these laws, agreeing with all just philosophical conceptions and all credible experience, the absolute cause, which is his cipher for God, the absolute cause never disturbs the chain of secondary causes by single arbitrary acts of interposition, but rather manifests itself in the production of the aggregate of finite causalities and of their reciprocal action, and you thought Meredith Klein was tough. This is Strauss, by the way, this is not my writing. I'm easy compared to this. When, therefore, we meet an account of certain phenomena or events of which it is either expressly stated or implied that they were produced immediately by God himself, divine apparitions, voices from heaven and the light, or by human beings possessed of supernatural powers, miracles, prophecies, such an account is in so far to be considered as not historical. So, he approaches the question of historicity and thus the question of the biblical account which does involve miracle, which does involve divine intervention, which does involve God as an actor in the chain of events. When he encounters that kind of thing, he says it can't be historical, and thus the biblical picture of a conquest is questioned from the outset, not on the basis of evidence per se, but rather on the basis of an a priori assumption inherited from the enlightenment. And again, just to reiterate what he said, now according to these laws, these laws being universal laws which govern the course of events, which he has some apparent window onto, now according to these laws, agreeing with all just philosophical conceptions and all credible experience, the absolute cause that is God never disturbs the chain of secondary causes by single arbitrary acts of interposition. In other words, he never intervenes. And how does he know that? Well, all just philosophical conceptions and all credible experience. Well, it's an a priori assumption, and yet it has lived on in historical, in historical, critical practice as one of the criteria of what it means for something to be historical. And so we have a great deal of confusion in dealing with the Bible because God is involved. Now much of the time he's acting behind the scenes, but sometimes he intervenes rather directly, not least in the resurrection. That's not just kind of normal course of events. And so we have a problem already with the account of the conquest. If we assume this historical objection, this anti-theological bias, some people describe it as an anti-supernatural bias, but I like anti-theological cause it really writes God out of historical process. Question. Yeah, I mean, this was all part of the enlightenment, this kind of coming of age, of freeing oneself from the tutelage of the church, and that which had sort of trained people, and the age of science is beginning to emerge. And the idea is a lot of things that we used to think were mysterious and we gave metaphysical explanations for. We're beginning to discover that we can explain them now, and the hope was that ultimately human scientific endeavor would explain everything. Yeah, well, I sympathize with what basis would we have for saying that just not being able to understand it removes it from history. Well, see because you think more biblically than you've not deeply steeped in the enlightenment. And for those who are, I think we need to be, you know, unsteeped. I think we need to pull ourselves away a little bit and say, is it the enlightenment that really should craft our worldview? Or does scripture craft our worldview? What helps us understand what reality is? And so that's part of what we get into in this book, you know, those kinds of things. So you'll get more than enough answer to your question when you get in here. Now, notice how Strauss goes on though, because it's even a little more sinister if I can call it that than this. He goes on and says, he has this notion of kind of a guilt by association. And this is what he says in another place in his book. It may be that a narrative standing alone would discover but slight indications, or perhaps might present no distinct feature of the mythus. Okay, the mythus, he says, that which is not historical, but rather myth. But it is connected with others or proceeds from the author of other works which exhibit unquestionable marks of mythical or legendary characters such marks as God's involvement in the chain of events. And consequently suspicion is reflected back from the latter on the former. Okay, this is a guilt by association. So you kind of, it's a kind of win-win situation for him that he says, well, some texts in the Bible indicate they're non-historistic because God is involved. And other texts, we know are non-historical because they're connected up with those texts where God is involved. Even if standing alone, they would be unobjectionable, they're linked. And so a guilt by association means that really, well, the end result of his book was that he regarded almost all of the life of Christ as mythical and not historical. In those days he lost his post for believing that. These days you probably receive a book of the Year Award or something for writing like that. Anyway, well, that's one objection to which we will return in just a minute when we respond a little more fully. There's also a logical objection, and we've seen this already as you're reading Joshua and Judges, you do kind of get the impression that there is some kind of logical contradiction here. Joshua seems to indicate this rapid blitzkrieg sort of taking over the land, and then we get to Judges and it seems like, well, wait a minute, we've lost a lot of ground, and it's not all that easy, and it's more complex than it seemed in Joshua, and so forth. So sometimes people say, you can't really accept the biblical picture of a conquest in Joshua because you read Judges and it contradicts Joshua. So the Bible is internally inconsistent, so why should we trust either? That's one objection. We'll come back to that one. There's also a modern, what I call a modern literary objection, and that is part of a trend in this day and age to read the Bible as literature. This is a trend I think from which we can learn a lot, which we can benefit from in many ways, but we have to be very cautious. In past decades, it was the historical, critical method that was dominant in biblical studies, and the idea there is we need to get behind the surface of the text to discover what really went on behind the scenes. You know, what the real events were from which we have this text, and so if we can divide sources, if we can somehow disassemble the text and find some pure pristine core, we can get back to what really happened and we can peel away all the layers. Well, scholars and others have kind of grown weary of that, and some have said, well, it doesn't really yield much of theological value for the church, those who are interested in the church and such. And so in recent years, there are scholarly fashion does change from time to time, and in recent decades, last couple of decades, at least, there's been more of a tendency to move back to reading the Bible as it stands. Let's read its final form, let's read it as literature. But as that has happened, many have not taken time to query or to question some of those historical critical divisions based on certain criteria that were deemed to indicate a fracture. Now they're reading the text literally, and they're saying, oh, I see how that works with that, and there's really no fracture there, but they don't go back and re-investigate those earlier conclusions. And what many do is just say, wait a minute, I'm reading the Bible as literature, I don't care about history, and there's a growing anti-historical bias among some literary readers of Scripture. And again, my argument would be that to read Scripture well from a literary perspective is to recognize all of its truth claims, including historical truth claims if that's what it's making. But there is this anti-historical bias that says, really the text is a good story, but that's all it is, it's just a good story. It's not utilitarian literature, it's pure literature, it's art for arts sake. And again, that's an assumption, an assumption really that works against the grain of the text. A fancy word for this, I love fancy words, so I'll give you one. A fancy word for this is a word autotelic. Not many people use that word, I had to dig it out of some dusty book somewhere, but autotelic means tell us or teleology has to do. With the end, the purpose or that to which something is leading. So autotelic means it's own end, art for art's sake. Some people say, well these texts are really just stories, they're to learn from them, they're to influence the way we think, but they're not really talking about events that actually happen. And that's sort of a modern literary prejudice that we need to be very careful of. And then finally there's an archaeological objection that is the one that is probably debated the most. And that is that, you know, there's just a lack of the extensive destruction in Israel at the right time, in the right places, in the right cities, that would be expected if the texts were true, if the conquest had taken place the way it is assumed to be described in the text. And people are looking for those destruction layers and such, and they're just not finding them in the right place at the right time, and that's troubling. And so these kinds of objections, either singly or in combination, have led people to say, well there really was no conquest. That's just a, you know, a biblical structure, a biblical construction, a fiction. Well, how should we respond to these? Well, first of all, relating to the historical objection, I think we need to simply recognize and reject an atheistic opiary that is involved in historical, critical method, even the historical, critical method that is employed today and sometimes even by believers. It's a real curious compartmentalization of life when you say, as a believer, I accept this, but as a historian, you know, I have to operate according to the cannons of historical inquiry that are accepted across the board and in the historical field. And you have to, but I think we have to ask one another and say, wait a minute, are you a theist? You know, do you believe in God? Well, yeah, I'm a theist. Well, what kind of God is he a God like the God described in the Bible who is a personal God? Well, yeah, I believe in a personal God. Well, did this God create the earth? Yeah, well, by what right then do you assume that he does, that he never intervenes into his own creation? And I think we need to challenge the foundations and make people sort of synthesize their worldviews. You can't have one worldview as a believer in another worldview as a practicing historian. So it's kind of a fundamental challenge. I think we need to bring against the historical critical method. There's some of that in this book and this historical objection. What about the logical objection? Well, I think we need to have our literary antenna of our literary sensitivity as we read these texts. And I think we've seen it. I think you've seen it as you've read through. That, yeah, the story, the picture that is painted by Joshua and the picture that is painted by judges, they're different pictures in some respects. The conquest is being looked at from different angles. In the one instance, it's being looked at from the angle of what God did. Joshua talks about God being true to his promises. Not a single promise, not a single promise of that which he had given to Israel failed. He gave them the land. He gave them the upper hand. They did conquer the land. They subjugated the land. Judges on the other hand turns and looks at the human component, the human response. How did they do in terms of occupying the land? It was subjugated by God's grace. How did they do in occupying it? And so two different pictures of being painted, they're not exactly the same, but they're not contradictory, they're complementary. And in fact, if you look carefully at the picture painted by Joshua, you see some of those colors and some of those lines that are then painted more boldly in the book of judges. So again, I think that logical objection really falls flat when we look carefully at them. Let me read another excerpt here for you real quickly if I can find the right place. Well, this is an example of my writing. Maybe I've read Strauss. This brings us to the next reason that many contemporary scholars have moved away from the conquest model as an explanation of Israel's emergence in Canaan. This is their sense that Joshua and Judges mutually undermine one another's historical credibility by painting conflicting pictures of the conquest. The former are hugely successful blitzkrieg in the latter a much more protracted complex affair. It is quite true, of course, that the two books present different pictures, but are they in fact contradictory? I sound like I'm saying what I just said. While the question cannot be adequately addressed in the space available here, it can later in the class. It may at least be observed that the sense of tension between the two books is greatly lessened when each is understood on its own terms and in the light of its own purposes. At the risk of over simplification, it could be said that the book of Joshua stresses God's faithfulness in giving his people the land, that is, in giving them the upper hand by not allowing any of their adversaries to withstand them, while Judges stresses the people's failure to act faithfully in occupying it. The introductory section of Judges, for example, describes how after the death of Joshua, the people of Israel gradually lost their grip on the land until, instead of having the upper hand, they found themselves living among the Canaanites, intermarrying with them and worshipping their gods. But even in the book of Joshua, amidst its stress on Joshua's success in taking the land, even the book of Joshua acknowledges that the war was a protracted affair and that there was much to be done even after the land was subdued and that the tribes of Israel sometimes failed to occupy fully their allotted territory and I give references in such. Thus Joshua can speak in the same breath of Israel having rest from all their enemies round about and yet needing still to contend with these nations that remain among you. In some it seems that the pictures presented by the books of Joshua and Judges, though different in their infacies are ultimately compatible and complementary. There is no logical contradiction between them but you will read in many books, well of course you can't trust the Bible in historical matters just think of Joshua and Judges in the different pictures they present. And it's often passed off that simply, well we need to look carefully and say this is within the pale, this is within what is acceptable in historiography. Regarding the literary objection, I think it's very important to determine the purpose of a piece. Why is this piece written? Is there an indication that the book of Joshua is really just written as a nice story to kind of help us think about life in a certain way? Is it like JRR Tolkien's trilogy, The Lord of the Rings, which does influence the way we think? Is that really what it's all about? And the way you go about discovering the purpose of a literary work is very similar to the way in which you might go about discovering the purpose for which a painting was painted and hung on the wall. Imagine with me, and again anticipating some of these things you'll encounter in this book, but imagine with me that you are looking at an oil painting of a railroad depot. It's a nicely rendered beautiful oil painting of a railroad depot, but you have no idea of the context, you're just focusing in on it. Now, the question is, is that autotelic, is that art for art's sake just a pleasing picture of a railroad depot? They are quite attractive. Or is that a historical piece? Is it referential? Is it meant to commemorate and remember a railroad depot as it once looked? Well, your blinker, you can't see the context. Well, the context is all important. If you're able then to look around you and you discover that this painting of a railroad depot is the only painting in the room, and it happens to be in a brand spanking new railroad depot, and it has a bronze plaque under it with a description and name and such, or any of these features, or the combination or even a few of them. Oh, well, as nice as this is as a piece of art, the context suggests to me that it's basically there for historical reference. It's a historical piece. It's meant to recall what the old depot looked like before they built the new one. The context tells the tale, or if you see it in an art gallery, and here's a bar next to it, and there's a landscape over here, and it's just a mixture of pleasing paintings, and you'll be unsure. You think, well, it may be a real depot, but that's really not the point. It's here with all these other works that are really art for art's sake. We're meant to appreciate them as art. So you see how context becomes the key to discovering the purpose of biblical accounts, and I would argue that the book of Joshua begins after the death of Moses, and that links us in with a prior history, and after the book of Joshua comes to the book of Judges, and that leaks us in. You know, it leads us on to the books of Sangal, and we are really in the thread of Israelite history. And so, however well told the story is, I would still say it is historical graphical in intent. Did you have a comment? Right, yeah, and in the context helps us see what the purpose is of a smaller unit. One of the principles of discourse analysis is that every smaller unit of a discourse of a text or of a communication is influenced by every higher level of communication. And all you need to do is think about everyday life. If you're just here, if you're passing by a group of friends and you hear one sentence, or a couple of words, you may grossly misinterpret what's going on there. You know, you need to go back and say, well, wait a minute, what were you talking about? You know, and you need to get the context, and as you get the context, even though you heard those few words perfectly clearly, you didn't know the purpose or the meaning or really what they were all about until you got a sense of the context. And that's the same with scripture. One of the events I talk about in here is the story of Elisha and the floating axe head, the miracle of the floating axe head. Well, that seems like pretty fabulous stuff. You know, that seems like a fable, really, that he calls an axe head made of iron or bronze or whatever to float to the surface of the water. And you think, well, that's, you know, that's why would God do that? Well, if you look at the broader context, you begin to see that it was not a trivial thing. And you begin to be encouraged by the historical graphical intent of the context to assume that what we're hearing is a historical account of a miracle that was performed, unless you can show me in the text how the influence of that context is to be discounted. Is there an indication that, okay, now we're changing, now we're adopting a different purpose. And sometimes you have that, you know, we might be reading about, reading a gospel that's telling us about the life of Christ. And then Jesus begins to tell a parable. Sometimes it will say, and he told them a parable. So we go from historical graphical discourse to the telling of a parable, which is a made up story, perhaps, to make a point. But that's signaled in the text. My argument is if there's no signal in the text, then the larger order of discourse helps us to understand and decide the purpose of the smaller unit and shift the burden of proof onto those who would want to argue that just because it's a miracle, it's not historical. Okay, we'll get into that more as we go on. One other, the archaeological objection. In relation to this archaeological objection, I want to encourage you to be good readers and I want you to be good readers in two respects. Number one, I want you to be good readers of the biblical text. In other words, really make sure that what you think it's claiming and what you expect then to find in the archaeological record is, in fact, what it is claiming. And number two, be a good reader of the archaeological artifacts because they do have to be read. They do have to be interpreted. They don't come out of the ground with labels of fixed, you know, that you can just put them right onto the museum shelf already self-explained. You have to explain them. You have to analyze them and interpret them. Again, let me read you one little short section in here that helps to explain this. Does the Bible properly understood depict a violent conquest involving great destruction of persons and property? What's the answer? Yes or no? Does the Bible depict a violent conquest involving great destruction of persons and property? I heard a yes and I heard a no and that's the right answer. It's yes and no. Yes, yes because both Joshua and Judges attest that Israel entered Canaan from outside and that this involved much loss of life to the indigenous population. But no because property damage is said, if you read the text carefully, property damage is said to have been more minimal. Specifically, the book of Joshua testifies that the populations of numerous cities were displaced under the man and totally destroyed. Maki Daliv, Nalakish, Eglon, Hebron, Debeer and so forth. But of only three cities, of only three sites, is it explicitly said that property also was utterly destroyed. Only in Jericho, I and Hotsore. The latter instance is particularly instructive for while the report of Joshua's defeat of Jabin's coalition up there at Hotsore states that Joshua, quote, Joshua took all these royal cities and their kings and put them to the sword. He totally destroyed them as Moses the servant of the Lord had commanded. It immediately adds that Israel did not burn any of the cities built on their mounds except Hotsore, which Joshua burned. Clearly then, to take a city, put it to the sword and utterly destroy it, that is to place it under the ban, implies the decimation or at least the dispossession of its population but may say nothing of property damage. The picture presented in Joshua is that destruction of property was the exception, not the rule. And indeed in chapter 24, verse 13 of Joshua, we find Israel living in cities you did not build as was prophesied and foretold in Deuteronomy chapter 6. The point of all that is archaeologists have been conservatives, evangelicals, liberals, many have been searching and searching and searching to find this massive destruction layer in all these different cities. And if you go back and read carefully, you find we have no right to be looking for that. The annihilation of a population doesn't leave anything in the archaeological record, maybe the odd bone or two but you don't find a destruction layer, a burned layer in the city. And yet that is what we have been looking for. We have been looking for. We need to read the text more carefully and so when we go to Israel and we are trying to find archaeology that correlates and the Bible doesn't need to be proved, that is not going to prove the Bible, but we do look sometimes for cross references and correlations and things that can fill out the biblical picture. We need to be sure that we have read the text carefully and thus we are looking for the right things and also then we need to be careful that we are reading the archaeological evidence that has come to light and been published very carefully. And let me commend to you an article by Bryant Wood that is entitled, Did the Israelites conquer Jericho? A new look at the archaeological evidence, this appeared in the biblical archaeology review, B-A-R, in 1990, volume 16. So really all you need to know to get this is the author's name is Wood and it's B-A-R, 1990, volume 16 and you'll see the relevant pages in the index there. What Bryant Wood does in short in two minutes, no less, what Bryant Wood does is he takes what is assumed to be the parade example. That is the example it's always mentioned as demonstrating that the Bible and archaeology do not correlate. There's a contradiction between the known facts of archaeology and what we read in the Bible, that is the destruction of Jericho. He takes that parade example and he re-investigates the interpretation of the evidence we have on that site. And what's very interesting is that whole viewpoint stems from the work of Kathleen Kenyon who published some popular books and made some articles and some popular books which led some to the conclusion that Jericho was not even existent as a city during the time when the conquest must have taken place, whether you accept an early date of the conquest or late date of the conquest, but he goes and looks at the actual official archaeology excavation results which appeared posthumously after Kathleen Kenyon had died. After this whole parade example idea had begun, he goes now as an expert in pottery, he has a PhD in the analysis of pottery and by that I don't mean he makes pots but he understands archaeological pottery. He's one of the world's experts in that, he does a very careful study, he reassesses her own excavation reports and what he comes to is very fascinating. If 50% of what he describes is actually borne out by further study, then the parade example is no longer to be paraded as an example of how the Bible and archaeology don't mesh. In fact, it could be quite the opposite, now will Bryant win the day? I don't know, but he can certainly be a benefit to those with eyes to see and ears to hear and can give us a right perspective on the force of archaeological evidence. People say well this is archaeology, it's objective evidence, well that's not true, it's objects that must be interpreted. So it's not objective evidence, it is objects, but the interpretive necessity is still there just as we must interpret the Bible, we also interpret those results. Now I could get into more of that if we had time, but I think I'll leave it at that and just commend that article to you. It's a Bimson-like treatment which means I think you would really enjoy it if you wanted to read that just for fun, you know since I'm not requiring you to read enough stuff. Before you get to this while you still feel like reading, you might want to do that. So thank you for your patience, see you in a week. Remember next week I will give you a take home kind of sample quiz that will count for something, so prepare yourselves in someone.