<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bay Bay Chak Mwa

Calvinism in the New World

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Here at lecture 19, a city of Funahill, Calvinism in the New World. Sometime ago I was talking about George Herbert, the British poet, and in one of his poems, in the series of poems called The Church Militant, George Herbert wrote these words, religion and stands on tiptoe in our land ready to pass to the American strand, and a hundred years later, when the English evangelist George Whitfield was preaching in America, he wrote in his journal on December 1st, 1739, surely the divine Herbert's prophecy is now being fulfilled. So as we come to this lecture today, we will move from the old world to the New World and see some of the events that took place in America in the settlement of this country. To begin, I would like to turn to one of the poems of Anne Bradstreet for our prayer. Anne Bradstreet was one of America's first poets, first significant poet in America. And as I have included in the syllabus, you can see examples of her poetry, including as Spring the Winter Doth Succeed, which is a very beautiful and lovely poem. It's important, I think, to see the Puritans as writers of poetry, because people do not always appreciate the artistic and aesthetic sensitivities of the Puritans, but with Anne Bradstreet and some others, we have examples of beautiful language and beautiful writing from these early American Puritans. The prayer from Anne Bradstreet that I'll use today is a very brief one, let us join together as we pray these few but meaningful words. I'll praise to him who now have turned my fears to joys, my sighs to song, my tears to smiles, my sad to glad, amen. What are the Calvinists came to America, some other people came, and I'm not going to try to lecture on all the religious traditions that were represented in the settlement of the Americas, we'll focus on Calvinism in the New World, but I should mention as we start to put this in context that long before many Calvinists arrived in the New World, Spanish Catholics came in large numbers, particularly to South America and to Central America, and to the New Mexico territories in the southwestern part of what later became the United States. These Spanish Catholics came in order to evangelize and to conquer the native peoples and to settle in those vast regions of the New World. That means that before Jamestown, the first permanent English settlement came in to be Indian the year 1600 and 7,000 of Indians in the southwest of this country were already evangelized and at least nominal believers in the New Mexico territories. So the Spanish were first. About the time larger numbers of Protestants were coming to settle the Atlantic seaboard of the new country, French Catholics were also arriving and the Colony of Quebec was begun in 1600 and 8, just one year after Jamestown in Virginia, and the French Catholics reached out in the canadas and down the Ohio River Valley and down the Mississippi River Valley, St. Louis and even further south in missionizing the Indians and attempting to set up trading posts throughout Canada and the Middle West. The motives for these various groups of people coming to the New World, of course, were complex. Generally, it's sad that they came for two reasons for goal and for God, not always in that order, but sometimes in that order. Certainly all of these religious traditions had, as one motive, the freedom to worship or to establish their own form of religion in new territories of the world and all of them spoke about missions to the native peoples, whether they always lived up to that goal or not as another matter. Often though the first goal dominated, that is the seeking of earthly goal and possessions and riches, but the second was always there as well, the spread of the various forms of Christianity to the New World, to the settlers from the Old World, as well as to the native American peoples. We'll focus in this lecture on Calvinism in the New World. There were a number of groups of Calvinists who came. The first Calvinists in the New World were not from the British Isles, as we usually think, but from France. There were 14 settlers, including two Geneva train ministers who went to a Huguenot settlement in Brazil in 1555. They attempted to reach out to the Indians in Brazil with the gospel, but unfortunately that Protestant Huguenot colony was soon abandoned because of various problems that developed in trying to establish it so that there was not a continuing Huguenot in Protestant community in the land of Brazil. Not too long after the failed mission to Brazil, Huguenots came to South Carolina in 1562 and to Florida in 1565. The Florida colony was exterminated by the Spanish who were moving up from the South and soon overran the Huguenot colony in Northern Florida. So not too much came of those early French attempts to settle in the New World, but larger numbers of French Protestants immigrated to America after the revocation of the Edict of Nantes in 1685 when Huguenots in France were once again persecuted. Many of them left their homeland to come to the New World at that time. Most of the Huguenots who settled in America joined other churches, became Anglicans or Presbyterians, although there were a few continuing Huguenot churches, and there is a Huguenot church that exists today in Charleston, South Carolina with regular services. Let's talk next about the Anglicans, who settled largely in Virginia and some of the other southern colonies, but the first settlement of Anglicans was in the colony of Virginia. Of the early settlers who came to Virginia, some of them were Puritans. They were all members of the Church of England, and we know by now in our study that there were two very distinct parts of the Church of England, the Anglican Party and the Puritan Party. Those two groups did not always get along very well and eventually took office at sides by and large during the time of the Civil War and the Commonwealth. That the settlement of Virginia, which was by Anglicans, contained a number of Puritans, the first charter for the colony of Virginia, drawn up in 1606, spoke of the project, the expedition to Virginia for the glory of the divine majesty. We know that some of those early Virginia Anglicans were Puritans in sympathy, including John Rolf, who came in 1610, an ardent student of Calvin's institutes, and a man who is famous in history because he married the legendary Pocahontas. Alexander Whitaker came in 1611, a Presbyterian, a Puritan Presbyterian, sometimes called the Presbyterian Apostle of Virginia. By Puritanism did not flourish in the colony of Virginia because in forced Anglican conformity, at least from 1642 by the stewards, although much of this was in effect before 1642, the religious situation in Virginia was comparable to the religious situation in England with the bishops and the king firmly in control and Puritan or Presbyterian dissenters being persecuted or at least not given freedom to worship in the way that they chose. Many Virginia Puritans then moved to other colonies, including Maryland, which was the only American colony to have a significant number of Roman Catholics, but perhaps for that reason was more open to settlements of different religious traditions and other Puritans moved to Pennsylvania, which under the Quaker, William Penn became the most tolerant place for religious freedom in the world at that time. The Huguenots in the South and then later in different parts of America, the Anglicans in Virginia and then the Puritans in New England. This is the most significant settlement of a Calvinist in America, and so we'll take a little longer to talk about the Puritan settlement in New England. James I tried to ignore the Puritan movement which began during his reign. Charles I was more concerned to suppress it, but soon Charles had his hands full, as you know, with the Parliament and the Civil War in England. The Stuart policies led to two events of major significance, one in the 1630s and one in the 1640s, the Great Migration of the 1630s and the Puritan Revolution of the 1640s. The Great Migration of the 1630s was an attempt to form a New England in America. Sooner or later, some of the English Puritans began to become discouraged and disillusioned with the prospects of Old England ever changing, and during the 1630s, thousands of English Puritans migrated to America in order to establish, in a new country, a new England, a new England which would be not only a life to the world, but also a witness to Old England to show what a real Christian commonwealth would look like. Let me just outline a few of the major events in the 1630s and we'll go beyond that decade in talking about the Great Migration. These are facts of history that I'm sure you've studied in other places, but it's important for us to see them here in brief outline. First the Pilgrims came, led by English separatist, the most outstanding of the English separatists was Robert Brown. Although the separatists were sometimes called the Brownists, the separatists were people in England, Puritans in England, who felt that there was no use waiting for the church to reform, and there was no use trying to establish a national church, that the most important thing they could do was to separate from the national church and create completely independent churches. That was quite in contrast to the non-separating congregationalists that were so prominent during the Westminster assembly. Small groups of these English separatists began to meet in England and one group moved from Scrubie in Nadeganshire to Holland and then fears later from Holland to Plymouth in America, 1620. Those are the so-called Pilgrim fathers and others that made that long voyage to America. Every year, the day before Thanksgiving, the Wall Street Journal includes in its editorial page the same essay coming from one of the Pilgrim fathers is the beginning of a chronicle written by Nathaniel Morton, keeper of the records of Plymouth colony, based on the account of William Bradford, who was one of the early governors of Plymouth, and it begins this way. So they left that goodly and pleasant city of Leiden in the Netherlands where they had lived, which had been their resting place for above 11 years. But they knew that they were pilgrims and strangers here below and looked not much on these things, but lifted off their eyes to heaven, their dearest country, where God hath prepared for them a city, he brews 1116, and therein quieted their spirits. It goes on in that way to express the hopes and dreams of these pilgrims who came to America. Seems to me rather significant that the Wall Street Journal continues to print that section of Morton's journal after all these years. The Mayflower Compact was created on board the ship as these pilgrims made their way to the New World, the Reformation Monument in Geneva, in the wall there, records the prayer and depicts the group on the ship bowing in prayer before the signing of the Mayflower Compact in 1620. And so with the beginning of the settlement in New England with the pilgrims, there is soon a second group coming directly from England this time, not by way of the Netherlands, but directly from England particularly as Archbishop William Laude began to put increasing pressure on the Puritans in England. There was a desire to create a model community, Christian Commonwealth in the New World to be an example to England and to all the world, John Winthrop, one of the early governors of Massachusetts Bay, wrote, we shall be as a city upon a hill, the eyes of all people are upon us. All together perhaps 30,000 maybe a few more people came in the Great Migration from England mostly from East Anglia, was not long before these Puritans as they settled in two colonies and then later in several others around Boston, what became Boston, Massachusetts, was not long before there were tensions that developed among the different Puritans who came. Most of the people who settled were God-fearing people, they were the saints, there were some strangers as they were called, people who were not professing Christians or devout Christians, but almost all of the early Puritans were Zalus Christians. But the colonies, Plymouth and Massachusetts Bay, were not colonies that were founded on the premise of religious liberty. This was not going to be a place where people of all different religions could come and worship freely, not yet. The purpose in the establishment of these colonies was not religious liberty, but freedom to worship God in the Puritan manner, which freedom these people felt they did not enjoy in England. One writer has said those who differed from the Puritan majority were encouraged to exercise their liberty to live elsewhere. And that's exactly what happened after a while, as tensions developed in the Puritan community in Massachusetts, beginning with Roger Williams. Williams was a Calvinist man of strong convictions and eventually began to express his beliefs in the Baptist conviction concerning baptism and became unwelcome then in the congregational colony of Massachusetts Bay. After some difficulty among the leadership of the colony, Roger Williams left Massachusetts Bay and went not too far away to Providence plantation where he started his own colony, later known as the State of Rhode Island. It was in March 1639 that the first Baptist church in America was founded in Providence in the State of Rhode Island. And Roger Williams has a place of honor on the Reformation wall as well in Geneva with his Puritan hat and garment and the word soul liberty engraved on the book in his hands. When there was another problem in Massachusetts Bay with Ann Hutchinson and Hutchinson Zaluson devout member of the church and the colony began to feel that the Massachusetts Bay clergy were in error in their preaching and she told them so. She felt they were preaching a covenant of works probably what she was responding to was undue emphasis on works as a sign of regeneration or election but at any rate there was a dispute between this woman and the clergy. She was charged then with antinomianism and when she began to claim that she was receiving direct revelations from God, she was excommunicated from Massachusetts Bay. It is not surprising that that happened what is surprising is that a woman would have such influence and standing in the colony that she could raise her objections to the theology that was being preached at that time. Fortunately for Ann Hutchinson there was a place to go. She went to Rhode Island. One writer has said men and women like Roger Williams and Ann Hutchinson who could not live with the Puritans of Massachusetts and who in learning to live with each other advanced the cause of religious freedom in the western world and really that is exactly what happened in Rhode Island. People of different religious convictions did not particularly like each other but they learned to put up with each other so that we have in that American colony the first place in the world where there is an experiment of religious pluralism not complete pluralism. The Quakers were not particularly welcome although gradually they were put up with as well but at least expanding some of the narrowness of the former attitude toward having only one established church and nobody else could exist in that area which had been the practice of the Protestants and of course the Catholics from the very beginning. The mainstream of New England Puritanism united around the Cambridge platform, the Senate of 1646 although the document was not published until 1649, the Cambridge platform was basically the Westminster Confession of Faith adopted as the Savoy Declaration in England had been adopted by English congregation as the Cambridge platform accepted the Westminster Confession of Faith as very holy orthodox and judicious in all matters of faith but differed on church government. There was substantial independence of each local church in New England. There were synods of ministers that met but those synods had no authority over the local church. The authority existed in the local church not in a presbytery and not in a synod and certainly not in bishops. So the New England way as it was called was established with local churches of so called visible saints people who not only had been baptized as infants but who could give evidence of their regeneration as true Christian believers in independent churches without control beyond the local church. In Puritan New England there were some very significant developments that influenced all of America and in some sense continued to influence America down to the present although not nearly in the way that this was true for several hundred years in the beginning of the history of this country. The Puritan town, Christian community, not theocratic in the sense that the clergy ruled the towns, the clergy did not govern the towns but elected officials who were strong Christians. They saw to it that the faces for the life of the Puritan towns in New England was Christian but the clergy did not control the towns of New England any more than John Calvin controlled Geneva. The Puritan family was very important. It was like a little commonwealth or a little church and much concern went into understanding how the family worked, how husband and wife related to one another properly and how they cared for and trained their children and how children respected their parents and were taught by them. The New England family, the Puritan family was the first in a series of educational institutions that culminated in the founding of Harvard College in 1638, a school that was first brought into existence for the training of clergy. The Puritan church of visible saints became a distinctive part of the New England landscape and particularly as the colonies and the Puritans were able to construct separate church buildings, the Puritan church began to dominate the New England landscape. We know what those churches looked like, white, wooden churches, graceful and beautiful. The Protestant and Puritan in their construction, there is an absence of statuary, stained glass and all distracting ornamentation although as the Puritans became more wealthy they could construct beautiful churches simple but with appropriate ornamentation as they saw it. One of the distinctive things about the Puritan New England church was the clear windows and the reason for the clear windows was not that they did not like pictures or stained glass. They simply did not want to have that in church because the windows should be clear so people could open their bibles and see them, not darkened so that they would have to have some sort of artificial light in order to read the Bible. The Bible was so important to these Puritans that individuals would have their bibles and they would be able to read and follow as the minister preached and therefore it was important to have clear glass windows. Our chapel at Covenant Seminary is not in every aspect Puritan but in the clear windows we do follow a Puritan tradition there. The central pulpit was imported or the elevation of preaching with the communion table below as the place where the elements would be served in the commemoration of the Lord's Supper. Well, the great migration took place in the 1630s during the 1640s, not as many people came from England to New England and you can see why. We've already looked at the 1640s as the time of the Puritan Commonwealth in England, the long parliament was meeting, the Civil War took place and Puritan hopes for the reform of Old England once again began to rise so that as people thought that now at last England could become the kind of church and country that God had planned for it, not as many migrated to the New World. John Cotton of Boston and Thomas Hooker of Hartford and John Davenport of New Haven were New England ministers who were invited to return to England and to attend the Westminster Assembly. They did not do so, but it's interesting to see the English Puritans including some of the New England Puritans in their list of delegates to the Assembly. The former governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, Sir Henry Vane Jr., did go back to England and played a major role in the Westminster Assembly and in the parliament. I've listed next in the syllabus four Puritan histories, which I will not talk about in any detail, but those are books of importance for the study of American religious history particularly in New England. One was by a carpenter, two were by governors of colonies, the third and the most important was by a minister, the fourth and most important was by a minister. Cotton Mather, his magnolia, Christy Americana, is still widely read and used in the study of early New England Puritanism. I might just connect at this point about Cotton Mather. He is noted as one of the clergy involved in the Salem witch trials, took place in the early 1690s and has created a kind of plot from the history of Puritanism and for most people who know anything about it shows that the Puritans were a rigid and narrow-minded sect, witches were commonly accepted. It was believed that there were witches in countries of Europe and in America, almost everybody held that this was something that really existed and was not simply imaginary. And as the witch trials preceded in Salem, as you know, 20 people were executed as a result of those witch trials, there is not much I can say to explain that or certainly don't want to excuse it, but to put the clergy in the right place and perspective, it's important to remember that it was not the clergy who instigated the panic that took place in Salem. And it was the clergy including Cotton Mather who began to see that they had to use their influence to bring this hysteria to an end. So if the Puritan clergy cannot be exonerated, they certainly should not have all the blame placed upon them for what happened in Salem in the 1690s. John T. McNeill says in his book The History and Character of Calvinism from John Cotton to Jonathan Edwards, New England Puritanism, passed through an epoch of greatness and produced a type of human being that no just an informed mind can think of without admiration. Not everybody would agree with that statement of course, but John T. McNeill is a good and competent historian and I think he has expressed it well. Let's move on to another group, came to the New World, Presbyterians and the Dutch Reform who settled in the middle colonies, the Anglicans in the South, Puritans in the North and New England and between the two in the so-called middle colonies, the Presbyterians and the Dutch Reform. There were people who were Presbyterians by conviction both in congregational New England among the Puritans and in Anglican, Virginia, but in those two areas it was almost impossible for a Presbyterian church to emerge when the other two churches were strongly established. The first Presbyterian congregation that we know anything about was organized in 1640 on Long Island and then as Scottish settlers began to come and settle along the Atlantic Seaboard and later the Scotch Irish, settled the frontier. There were many Presbyterians who came to this country and it's not long before Presbyterian churches began to spring up in many places in the middle colonies particularly. Francis McKimmy was a Scotch Irish missionary to America and it was through his influence and hard work that the first Presbyterian was organized in 1706 leading to the establishment of the first Senate, the Senate of Philadelphia in 1717. And other groups of Presbyterians came from Scotland as well as the Cedar or associate Presbyterians and reformed or cut-in-unner Presbyterians as well as independent Presbyterian churches and Presbyteris were established in America. I was preaching in Georgia last weekend, there was an elderly woman in the congregation who told me that she was an ARP. I was preaching in a PCA church in Wainsborough and this delightful lady had many stories to tell said I am, you know, ARP, do you know what ARP means? And of course I said associate reform Presbyterian and she said well it really stands for a real Presbyterian. So I learned something there. The Presbyterians in the Middle colonies and the Dutch reform in the Middle colonies as well. The Dutch reformed church was organized in New Amsterdam in 1628. That later became New York when the British took control of it. But the first Calvinistic Presbyterian church or reformed church on American soil was established by the Dutch in New Amsterdam in 1628. It was part of the classes of Amsterdam until 1792. There were Dutch settlements around New York particularly in New Jersey and along the Hudson River in New York and on Long Island so that part of the Middle colonies became the center for the Dutch church later known as the Dutch Reform Church in America and now called the Reform Church in America. Not only did Dutch reform Christians come but German reform Christians as well from the pelatinet with their beloved Heidelberg Catechism and settled in Pennsylvania mostly forming the German reform church, later called the Evangelical and Reform Church and now called the United Church of Christ because that church eventually merged with most of the New England congregation list. Well that's a very brief overview of the coming of Calvinists to America, the settling of the different colonies with people of reform convictions and something of their significance. Therefore since we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses let us so well everything that hinders and the sand that so easily entangles and let us run with perseverance, the race marked out for us. Okay we got a few minutes Phil. Yeah question is how did the Cambridge platform of the New England congregation list so quickly embrace Westminster. Well the Scots did it about the same time and I would think that the two groups in the world that were the most amenable to Westminster doctrine would be the Scottish Presbyterians and the New England congregation list the Cambridge platform was not published until 1649 the Senate first met to begin to deliberate in 1646 and so what they actually adopt is set forth in 1649. Yes, how could the congregation list have a Senate? Well they did have Senates and their Senates acted very much like Presbyterian Senates or Presbyterians except without authority. You see they could not adopt a platform and then impose it on all the churches so they recommended it and they urged it. But they were always very careful in New England not to become too much like Presbyterians. Yes, Chip. Was Anne Hutchinson right in her dispute with the Massachusetts Bay clergy. I have an impression and I haven't studied this enough to be an authority on it that her initial criticism may have been something they should have listened to. Because the Puritans could go to an extreme in attempting to base assurance on good works and I think there was the necessary correction that our assurance first of all comes through the gospel and our belief in Jesus Christ not on the evidence that we see in our lives although that's not an improper way of looking at it but in Calvin's view that was always to be secondary not first. My assurance comes because I trust Christ is my savior and then secondly because I see some evidence of that but if you put the evidence first there's always the possibility that you will be discouraged because you won't see enough evidence. And I think because that was a puritan tendency to move in that direction Anne Hutchinson's criticism probably had some merit but in disputes of theological types or of any kind people tend to move to extremes and undoubtedly Anne Hutchinson in trying to counter what she saw as an era in the preaching of the covenant of works did fall into antinomianism. And then she really lost any chance for further influence when she began to claim direct revelations as the basis for her theology. The Puritans were not going to put up with that so she had to go to Rhode Island. Yes, Tony. When did the central pulpit begin? It did not begin with the Puritans. We can find examples of this in Dutch church architecture in the Reformation era. You see when the Protestants first took over churches they took over Catholic churches and generally they tried to rearrange the church to make it more Protestant but it was not always easy to have a central pulpit because it was not always easy to tell where the center was in some of those churches. But there were various schemes that were used the pulpit was raised or seats were placed in a certain part of the church so that they faced what was then considered the center of the church. So I would say from the time of the Reformation there was a concern to elevate the preaching of the word by a central pulpit. And when people began to build new churches which of course all the churches in New England were new they could do it without any of the constraints of having inherited a building that wasn't just right. So now central pulpit and windows that were clear and an attempt to express the regulative principle of worship in architecture. It's interesting to read some of the records of these early Puritans churches. One thing that they often debated was how to design the pillow on the pulpit on which the Bible would rest. Now you don't get in the Bible any sort of direction as to whether you should have a pillow on the pulpit for the Bible to rest though. So you might say the regulative principle did not operate there but those pillows were beautifully designed with color and the best material and something that concerned the New England Puritans to do it well. If they're going to do anything like this I suppose it's very proper that they debate and work hard at whatever they're going to put the Bible alone because the Bible was very central in their thinking, in their worship and in their preaching. Another one. So strange term independent Presbyterian but there were independent Presbyterian churches and Presbyterians that did not actually go into the American Presbyterian church in 176 when it was formed. So you have really a number of different kinds of Presbyterians. You have the American Presbyterian church, 176 made up of all sorts of Presbyterians from Scotland and Wales and New England, Old England. You have the Secedor churches, you have the Covenanting churches and you have the independent churches. Most of those independent churches eventually became real Presbyterian churches in a sense by joining Presbyterians. One that did not become a member of a Presbyterian and still is not a member of a Presbyterian is the independent Presbyterian church in Savannah, Georgia which is a very historic and wonderful church and wonderful building. It will be 250 years old in several years and I'm particularly interested in that church because it has to write the history of it which I will start this summer. But it has outside engraved in the stone in the front of the church a part of the church of Scotland. Well that's not true, it never has been a part of the church of Scotland. But those Presbyterians in Georgia for some reason wanted to think of themselves as part of Scotland and not part of South Carolina or wherever the Presbyteria was going to be. Okay, I guess the time is up. Thank you.