<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bay Bay Chak Mwa

Doctrine of Sin

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

The definition of sin. Sin is any failure to conform to the moral law of God in act or attitude or nature. Right away when I say that, we're differing with people's general idea of sin when they think sin is stealing or murder or adultery or something like that, and they just focus on actions. But the Bible's definition of sin is broader than that, act, attitude or nature. With regard to act, there's a list of specific actions, of course, in the Ten Commandments, for instance, where God says, you shall not murder, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not steal, etc. But as far as attitude, even in the Ten Commandments, in that list of that fundamental summary of laws that God gave to the people of Israel, when you get to the end, after God tells them all these things, then he says, you shall not covet your neighbor's house, you shall not covet your neighbor's wife or his male servant or his female servant or his ox or his donkey or anything that is your neighbor's. Well, right there God is saying, I'm not just concerned with your actions. I'm concerned with your heart, that your heart would love me above all things and love the things that I delight in, that your heart would be pure before me as well as your actions. We read, for instance, in first Samuel that man looks on the outward appearance, but God looks on the heart. And so in the Ten Commandments and then throughout the rest of the Bible, we find that God is concerned not just with outward behavior and actions, that's important, but he's also concerned that our hearts be right and pure before him. And then also sin can do, have to do with our nature or our state, Ephesians 2, 13 talks about the fact that we were by nature children of wrath, like the rest of mankind. That means when you're sound asleep and doing nothing wrong, you're still a sinner. You're a sleeping sinner, but you're still a sinner by nature. And so sin extends that far. So we'll talk about that in a little more detail. As far as number two, since God requires purity of heart as well as actions, it follows them that the desire to steal or commit adultery would also be sin in God's sight, the desire to sin also equals sin. Matthew 5.22, Jesus also affirms this, I say to you that everyone who is angry with his brother will be liable to judgment and he's responding to those who just say, well, just God commands you shall not murder, but he says, well, wait a minute, if you're angry, you have the desire to murder your brother. And therefore you have a desire to disobey the commandment. And so that's also wrong, you'll be liable to judgment. It makes you guilty before God. And Matthew 5.28, I say to you that everyone who looks at a woman with lustful intent has already committed adultery with her in his heart. If you desire to commit adultery, that heart attitude is also breaking God's commandments. It's contrary to his moral law. And so it's not correct to do what I expect to the world does and it's thinking about God and right and wrong. The world often I think thinks that feelings and attitudes are morally neutral. Well, if you feel angry, you just feel angry. If you feel jealous, you just feel jealous. That's just the way you are. You can't change it. You can't help it. It's not your fault. It's just your feelings. They're just kind of a given. They're just kind of, that's what they are. You can't criticize people for that. That would be an attitude I think that people would assume to be true. But the Bible doesn't assume that. Psalm 19, verse 14, Let the words of my mouth and the meditation of my heart be acceptable in your sight, O Lord, my rock, and my redeeming. Galatians 5.20, look, there are some attitudes in there when Paul's lists of works of the flesh, not only idolatry and sorcery, but also enmity, that's anger, or desire to harm someone else, enmity, strife, jealousy, and fits of anger. There's some anger that's right and some that's wrong. We'd have to go into that at a different time. Anger against evil and sin is not always wrong. But there is an anger that's just trying to, just because of wrong done to us, that I think is a wrongful kind of anger. And anyway, Paul mentions this among works of the flesh, so feelings and attitudes can be sinful as well. And of course, that's a struggle, not a course for anybody who teaches in the enrichment class. Well, sure it is, it is for all of us, isn't it? And just, I mean, even this morning, I shouldn't feel this way, and I love teaching this class, don't get me wrong. But about two hours ago, I was saying, oh do I have to teach this class this morning? I shouldn't probably feel that way, but it just, I came back last night and I was tired and you ever feel that way? Okay, I'll just do it. You might even think, oh do I have to go to this class this morning? I don't know. Oh well, so we just recognize it, say, Lord forgive me, it's a privilege to change my heart, to work in my heart. And they're all sorts of attitudes of heart that can creep in and get us to lose our faith, be doubting, be fearful, be angry, be contentious, be jealous, greedy, lazy, all these proud, lustful. I mean, those things are there in our hearts, even as Christians, I think that God progressively changes our hearts over time as we are Christians and we grow and we read His word regularly and we pray, we stay in fellowship with other believers, I think God progressively changes our hearts. But we're not going to be free from those wrongful desires that are deep down in there until the day we die and go to be with the Lord or until He comes back. So we just have to recognize that and that means that talking about sin is appropriate for us throughout the Christian life, it's not a happy topic that we enjoy talking about except as it glorifies the moral holiness and purity and excellence of God whose heart is always pure and right and good. And then we're sinful by nature, I mentioned that earlier but for instance Romans 5.8, one of the key verses that you know, if you present the gospel to others, God shows His love for us and that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us, we were still sinners that as we have the status of being sinners, it was our nature. And Ephesians 2, 3, we were by nature, children of wrath, like the rest of mankind. And so we can make progress in the Christian life and we were certainly certainly forgiven sinners, we're justified before God, we're cleansed sinners and that the Holy Spirit has washed our hearts when we became believers and there's a break with the ruling love and power of sin in our lives. And so there's a difference between us and non-Christians, I'm sure there is, but we're still not completely made pure sinners during this whole life, okay. Now I'm just going to mention one other alternate definition of sin, let's go back to the definition I had here, any failure to conform to the moral law of God and act attitude or nature. So I'm saying the definition of sin is God's moral law, it's a high standard, it's God's moral perfection and we don't measure up, but the standard is there and anything that falls short of that is sin. But there's another definition of sin that sometimes people propose and that's number five here on the outline, sin is selfishness. Now fundamentally this is a definition without any reference to God, isn't it? See, it doesn't say anything about God or God's laws, it's just kind of a human centered definition. And it's kind of a, I suppose it would be a way that people could understand the doctrine of sin in a way that didn't even require them to believe the Bible or think there is a God or anything, just saying, well people are selfish. And there are some people in the history of theology, in fact a man named Augustus Strong in 1911, Baptist Theologian, where that was his definition of sin. I think he meant well by it and didn't think it was something wrong with it, but I think it's a deficient definition. First, the reason it had some persuasiveness is it's close to the truth. There's some truth in it, in that there's a lot wrong with selfishness. Philippians 233, do nothing from rivalry or conceit, but in humility count others more significant than yourselves, we're supposed to put others first. And so there is a lot of selfishness that is definitely sin. However, this isn't the way the Bible defines sin. You don't see the word selfishness in the Ten Commandments or in Paul's lists of moral rights and wrongs as a definition. And there's something else that's mistaken about this and that is honestly if we look at the Bible, there is much self-interest that is good self-interest. Jesus says, lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven. That is a kind of self-interest, where to lay up for ourselves treasure that will be ours to enjoy later on. And I think it's right for us to do that, although it is seeking something for ourselves, it's seeking it with the idea of obeying Jesus commands and it's with our heart set on heaven and set on the future. And seeking salvation, don't you do that because you don't want to go to hell? I think that's a good motive because you want to come to no God and be in fellowship with Him. Oh, that's a good motive. You want to be with Jesus forever? That's a good motive. You want your sins forgiven? That's good. I think seeking salvation is what we should do, but there's a lot of self-interest in that. It's just self-interest according to the Bible, not selfishness to steal from someone else, or selfishness contrary to the Bible. Moreover, I think there is sin that's not selfishness in the ordinary way we think of selfishness. People can be very selfless in devotion to a false religion, Buddhism, for instance. People get rid of their self-desires and become in a way very caring for others and things like that, or people could have selfless devotion to secular political or educational goals now. I just want to do good for others. I want to educate people, or I want to help change my country, and they give of themselves, and they're not, I mean, you could say they're doing it because it makes them happy in that sense. Maybe it's selfishness, but it isn't outwardly and evident that they gain from it financially or reputation-wise in many ways, things like that, and so there is, but it's still a false religion, or it could be a secular goal that's not, it's contrary to the gospel, for instance. And then this view might, if we say sin is selfishness, then how do we deal with God seeking His own glory? God does that. He creates the world for His glory. He creates us for His glory, and that's not wrong, it's right, because it's what God does and He deserves it. Finally, and this is what I started out with, to say sin is selfishness, really doesn't define sin in relation to God, it's a man-centered definition, and I think we're better off and it has implications later, we're better off if we say sin is lack of conformity to the moral law of God, and so there, our standard is not our ability, it's not how we interact with human beings, ultimately our standard is God's moral law, His perfect holiness, and that's the standard of the Bible. So the Bible has sin is lawlessness, that is, first John 3, 4, I think that means it's against God's law, that's a definition, definition of sin. Now, point B, we come to a really hard question, a really, really hard question, where did sin come from? Why is there sin in the world? If God is good and he's all powerful, how can there be sin in the world? And it's a hard question because there's mystery here, even when we probe as far as we can, and so what I want to do is say what the Bible says and what we can say about what the Bible says, and it will go on. First point, clearly, certainly, God is not to be blamed for sin. Everything the Bible says about God says He's just, He's righteous, He shouldn't be blamed for doing wrong, as if He did something that would make him worthy of blame rather than praise, worthy of hatred rather than worship. We should never think that God has done something wrong. So Deuteronomy 32, 4, the rock, speaking of God as the rock, the rock His work is perfect for all His ways are justice, the God of faithfulness, and without iniquity, just and upright is He, or in Job 34, 10, the words of Elihu, far be it from God that He should do wickedness and from the Almighty that He should do wrong. And of course, that's a theme in the book of Job, well, Job, why don't you curse God and die? That is, He was tempted to do that, to blame God, say, God, it's your fault that these things have happened and it's wrong and you are wrong, and that would have been blasphemy against God, it would have been dishonoring God, Job resisted the temptation, and the book is given to us to show even in the midst of great suffering that we should not blame God for sin or for wrong. So it would be wrong to blame God for sin, angels and human beings sinned by their willful, voluntary choice. Now, ever else we understand the other parts of the Bible's teaching on this, we have to say that the blame for sin falls on angels who sinned and became demons, or on human beings who sinned and became sinful human beings. Genesis 1825 shall not the judge of all the earth do what is just. In James 113, let no one say when he is tempted, I am being tempted by God, for God cannot be tempted with evil and he himself tempts no one, don't ever blame God for wrong that you do. So we nail that firmly in our convictions. Whatever else we think about the origin of sin, we must not blame God for sin. However else we understand the rest of the scripture, we can't abandon that. The point be, it seems consistent with scripture to say that God somehow ordained that sin would come about, but through the voluntary choices of moral creatures, about our dain that sin would come about. What do you think about it? If our names have been written before the foundation of the world, in the book of life of the lamb that was slain, well then God knew from before the foundation of the world that the lamb would be slain, that is that Jesus would die for sin. That means that he knew that there would be sin, he planned that. If Ephesians 1, 4 is right, he chose us in him before the in Christ, before the foundation of the world that we should be holy and blameless before him. In love he predestined us for adoption as sons. If God planned the work of salvation from before the foundation of the world, and I think we have to say somehow in his infinite wisdom he planned or ordained that sin would come about. But he didn't sin, he didn't do wrong, we did the wrong. And you say that's a contradiction. No, it's not a contradiction. The contradiction would be God ordained that sin would come about, and God did not ordained that sin would come about. That's a contradiction. I'm not saying that. The contradiction would be God is not to be blamed for sin, and God is to be blamed for sin. That would be a contradiction. God doesn't ask us to believe the contradiction, but a mystery is God ordained that sin would come about, but he is not to be blamed. We have to be blamed. That's the mystery, how to put those together. We do not, Vanna, as Christians, believing the Bible, we do not believe in dualism. Dualism would be good and evil, have always existed eternally in the universe, and we don't know which one is going to win. A lot of Eastern religion is that way. There's good and evil, and they're struggling, and there's the dark side of the force, and there's the good side, and you don't know which is going to win, and that's dualism. We don't believe in that. We believe that ultimately before God created anything, only God existed, and he was good. There was no belief. Ephesians 111 says in him, we have obtained inheritance, having been predestined according to the purpose of him who works all things, according to the counsel of his will. He works all things according to the counsel of his will. I think that means that God somehow ordained that sin would come about, but there's mystery here, how that can be. Some of God planned that it would happen, but Adam and Eve sinned, and Satan sinned, and then Adam and Eve sinned, and there to be blamed, and they did the wrong, and God is not to be blamed, and there's a distance there. An alternative is dualism, that evil is always existed, but I don't want to go there, because that makes it equal to God. Another alternative, and this is a respectable alternative within the evangelical world, is that evil came into the world even though God didn't want it to be, but he had to allow the opportunity for it to come into the world. That's called an Armenian view, and many people hold that. I don't myself hold that view, because I don't see the scriptural support for it, and there's evil in the world, even though God didn't want it to be, and that worries me a lot, because maybe there'd be more evil in the world that he doesn't want to be, and maybe it'll all turn out to be evil. Who knows? And maybe even in heaven, there'll be evil, even though God doesn't want it, it'll maybe creep in. That one is really unsettling as well, so I end up saying, I bow before God and say, I think He ordained that it would come about, but He's not to be blamed, and I'm not sure more how that can go together. I'll stop there for a minute before I go on to Adam and Eve's specifics in. Do you want to talk about that? Not sure we'll ever resolve it, John. Yeah. I am saying He ordained that we would have the ability to make the choice. That's part of it, but I'm saying more. I think He ordained that Adam and Eve would sin, and the Satan would sin. But He's not to be blamed, and I don't know how that works. Yeah, let me do that. Okay, John and I agree. Okay. Yeah, Patty. Does it answer the question to say free will? Does it answer the question to say free will? Well, that depends on what you mean by free. I think Adam and Eve willingly chose. But if free means God let evil, God, that evil came into the world that God didn't want, or he didn't know whether they'd choose evil or good. See, that gets more problems for him. So, yeah, Patty's just asking. And I, Patty, this is a number of people hold this view. So I'm not saying it's absolutely wrong, but that God allows these things so that angels can see how just He is. I think there's truth in that. He does allow it. But I don't want to go to the place of saying he wasn't really sure whether there was going to be sin or not. He knew what would happen. And I think in some mysterious way plan. But so that he's removed from it, and it was, it was our choice, not, not that he chose to sin. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, he's back there just free will. But okay. Yeah. Okay. When a question about angels and sin, I maybe didn't take good notes when you're discussing angels, he made angels, I think, for to do his will. How do they say? How do they fall into sin? I think in a similar way to the way Adam and Eve fell into sin, they willingly chose to go against God. I think it was pride exalting or Satan exalting himself trying to be like God being in his heart rebelling against God. How do you do that? It's ultimately unexplainable. It's not rational. It didn't make sense. But that's the character of sin. Maybe there's somebody who knows more about this than I do. But I'm just saying that's all the farther I can go. It happened. I think it was under God's sovereign control somehow. And that comforts me in the end, because I know he's going to deal with it. He's going to triumph over it. And our redeeming redeeming us from sin will result in his glory and try and think over sin. It won't get the best of him that results in his glory. So I can leave it there. It's hard though. Hi. Would you discuss the difference between God tempting us and God testing us? It's intent. Tempting is hoping we're trying to make us do wrong. God never does that. Testing is bringing us into a situation where he'll see what's in our heart. But it's always with the hope or the desire that we'll do right. Yeah, well, our attitude. God does test us. He allows hard situations to come to us to see how we'll act and brings us through some of those. But he never tempts us that is says, here, Wanda, why don't you do this that I told you not to do? This would be really good thing to do. I mean, that would be contrary to God's character. I mean, it even hurts my heart when I say, oh, God could do that. He doesn't try to persuade us to do wrong or hope that we'll do wrong. Something like that. He allows us to be tempted. Okay, cried. No, God did God create evil? Well, he didn't do evil. Isaiah 43.45 has a verse where it says God, I create evil, but when we're on the translation committee for the ESV, one of our Old Testament members, Paul House kept saying this is really going to believe people to misunderstanding. And this Hebrew word raw, R-A, R-A with a guttural sound, that that can be used of just natural disasters, hurricanes, floods and things like that. And perhaps that's more what's in view. So I would rather say he ordained that it would come about through the willing choices of moral creatures. I'm not sure what it means to say that God created evil. Creatures did evil. That I'm sure of. Well, let's go on to the sin of Adam and Eve. And look, I said that was that question is a hard question. I let it rest finally in the sovereignty of God. And I have peace in my heart about that, but it's hard. I know that. And you're free to differ with me on that. The sin of Adam and Eve, Genesis 3, 1 to 19. Now the serpent was more crafty than any other beast of the field that the Lord God had made. He said to the woman, did God actually say you shall not eat of any tree in the garden? And the woman said to the serpent, we made of the fruit of the trees of the garden. But God said you shall not eat of the fruit of the tree that is in the midst of the garden. Neither shall you touch it. Now God didn't say that, but He did say you shall not eat of it. Neither shall you touch it, lest you die. But the serpent said to the woman, you will not surely die. There's contradiction. Don't eat it lest you die. You will not surely die. He's contradicting God's word. For God knows that when you eat of it, your eyes will be opened and you will be like God, knowing good and evil. So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food and that it was a delight to the eyes and that the tree was to be desired to make one wise, it was fruit and aid and she also gave some to her husband who was with her and he ate. So there we have the first sin, right there in that paragraph. The first sin among the human race, she took of its fruit and ate. There's the first sin. There was sin of her heart and attitude just earlier in the verse and then it culminated in that action. And she also gave some to her husband who was with her and he ate. Then the eyes of both were opened and they knew that they were naked and they sewed fig leaves together and made themselves loincloths and they heard the sound of the Lord God walking in the garden in the clue of the day and the man and his wife hid themselves in the presence of the Lord God among the trees of the garden. But the Lord God called to the man and said to him, where are you? And he said, I heard the sound of you in the garden and I was afraid because I was naked and I hid myself. And he said, who told you that you were naked? Have you eaten of the tree of which I commanded you not to eat? The man said, the woman whom you gave to be with me, she gave me the fruit of the tree and I ate. And the Lord God said to the woman, what is this that you have done? And the woman said, the serpent, deceived me and I ate. How long were they in the garden before they goofed up? I don't know. Tammy thinks it's just a day. I'm going to go for a few weeks. I don't know. I mean they hadn't had any children yet. So I don't think it, but I don't know how quickly that would have happened. So we don't know. Yeah, God gave Adam the instruction and then when he wasn't made yet and then that's in chapter two and then he comes to Adam first. Yeah, that's true. I don't know. I'm not going to get into the details here. Okay, the Lord God said to the serpent, then there's the curse that comes. I'm going to skip over that just for time here. But note that the sin of Adam and Eve was foundational for future sins in several ways and this sin undermined in principle all human thought about the important issues of life. First, the sin of Adam and Eve struck at the basis for knowledge. That is true knowledge. It gave a wrong answer to how we can find out what is true. God said, if you eat, you will die. And the serpent said, you will not die. And Eve said, I doubt that God's words are true. Let me conduct an experiment to find out. Or else Eve said in her heart, she decided God's words are not true. I will not die. She probably the latter is true. Probably the latter is true. She probably believed the serpent. Instead of God's words. And in terms of determining what is true, that's the foundational error to believe human experience or observation or the testimony of other people when it contradicts the word of God, believing that something else is a better standard of truth than the word of God. That strikes at the basis for knowledge and in philosophy epistemology. It gives the wrong answer in terms of what is true in terms of epistemology. And then in terms of ethics, in terms of moral standards, the sin of Adam and Eve struck at the basis for moral standards. That is the question of what is right. God said, do not eat the fruit. And the serpent said, eat the fruit. Direct contradiction to the moral commands of God. Eat the fruit and be like God. Eve trusted her own evaluation of what would be right. She saw that it was good for food. At least seems so to her. Look good for food. Can't I make up my own mind about what's good for me? Aren't I good judge of what kind of food I should eat? It looks good for food. And it's a delight to the eye. Why it's so pleasing. How can something that feels so good when I look at it be so wrong? My feelings about what my mind tells me it looks good to my emotions. Tell me it's delightful. Oh, God made it to be so delightful. It must be good. It must be right. And so her standards of right and wrong are not God's words anymore but her own feelings and thinking about what is right and wrong. And then it's to be desired to make one wise. Well, this is going to bring a good result. So her own sense of the consequences is, hmm, I'm not going to believe God in terms of what the consequences are going to be. I'm going to believe what seems to me. It's the desire to make one wise. Wow, I'll just go ahead and eat. So epistemology is skewed by by string from God's word as the fundamental basis for truth. Ethics is skewed by deciding that my own judgments are better than God's moral standards for what is right. And then finally, Adam and Eve's sin gave a different answer to the question, who am I or in philosophy, metaphysics, what is the question of what is and what is the nature of reality in God's sight and in truth. Adam and Eve were creatures and they were to forever be subject to an obedient to their creator and their status as creatures should have determined the fact that they should not be the ultimate standard of true and right and wrong that God is the ultimate center. He's the creator. They're the creature. They should be subject to what he says. But Adam and Eve gave a different answer to who am I. They said, well, we want to be like God. We're not content with being creatures and subject to him. So this sin struck at the basis for true knowledge about all the major important issues of life.

That Eve wasn't around with God. So Adam, I'm sure, told her, so it's a great illustration of where we don't trust our husband who God has given us. As our protector, we really do get it in time. I need a microphone for Pam, you say, yeah, I'm not going to repeat it. What ages could they have been with their little kids? No, no, they were adults. They were created as adults. Yeah, yeah, created as adults. Go ahead. I just said that I piggybacking on what LeVern had said that because I had never thought about that LeVern. I thought that was a great point that God told Adam not to eat of the tree of good and evil. And so Adam surely told Eve and Eve decided not to trust her husband whom God had given her as her protector and best friend and for her to help him. She trusted the crafty, most likely beautiful Satan rather than the very one that God had given her to protect her. Jack is adding to this excellent comment. Pam, he decided not to hand in the microphone. You guys got that settled? Do you want to add something, Jack? And it didn't, the communication wasn't clear. Maybe it was, but there wasn't sin before there was sin. So I don't know, I'm not going to go into that any further. Okay, so here we come to the question then why in the world did Adam and Eve do this? It was stupid. It was dumb. Why did Adam and Eve sin? It made no sense to disobey God. I think the answer to this is it was irrational. And I think at root all sin is ultimately irrational. It didn't make sense for Satan to rebel against God and it didn't make sense for Adam and Eve to think that disobeying God would bring gain. And that's a perspective that the whole Bible has on sin. It's foolish. Psalm 141, the fool says in his heart, there is no God. The fool. How's Mr. T say that? The fool says in his heart, there is no God. They are corrupt. They do abominable deeds. Proverbs 10, 23, doing wrong is like a joke to a fool. Wisdom is a pleasure to a man of understanding. So all sin is ultimately irrational. And until we had since the last time I was here in this class, we had this tragic, tragic situation of this student shooting and killing over 30 students in Virginia at that university. And how tragic. And commentators are trying to explain this. I don't know if you saw an editorial by Peggy Noonan in the Wall Street Journal. But in the end, she said, there is irrational evil in the world. It doesn't make sense. It's futile to try to understand it. And I think Peggy Noonan hit the nail on the head. It's just outright evil. And there is evil like that in the world. It cannot be reasoned with. It cannot be educated out of its evil. It can only be dealt with by the restraint of force. So ultimately that I don't think we can explain the sin of Adam and Eve or the sin of Satan. There were some motives but they were wrong motives. They didn't make sense. They made no sense. But sin is ultimately irrational. You have questions on that. You want to talk about that? That's hard, John.

The short term seems to look good. Man cheats on a loving wife. And it's maybe a sin of lust in a short period of time. He's not thinking of a long period of what the consequences are going to be. Satan cannot promise anything for the long period of time. Well, he can promise his eternal damnation. So we're looking at a quick something to enjoy. And the quick something to enjoy goes away. And then the long term problem comes in. I mean, Eve is looking at that apple or whatever piece of fruit that was. She was not thinking long term relationship with God. I think there's a lot of insight in that, John, that a lot of the deceptiveness of sin is looking at the moment rather than the long term consequences. The long term consequences are believing that what God says is going to turn out to be true. And a lot of our obedience in the Christian life is, I don't want to do this right now, but God says to do it. And so it'll be right. And it'll turn out in the end. There is there is that in our life because of the slowness and sluggishness in our heart. Or this seems attractive for the short term, but there. Yeah, I think there is something of that. It says, in fact, Moses, when he was grown up, Hebrews 11, 24, refused to be called the son of Pharaoh's daughter, choosing rather to be mistreated with the people of God, then to enjoy the fleeting pleasures of sin. It's a deception. And the deception comes in the short term appeal of something that turns to bitterness. Yeah, then we feel bad after it. There's a lot of the problems about that as well. OK, a lot about drunkenness. Doesn't Proverbs say that sin is pleasurable for a season? I don't know where it is, but that sounds like it does to me. I don't have the verse in front of me. OK, similar idea. OK, the doctrine of inheritance. Let's see. We've got six more minutes. Maybe we'll. Let me see. Wayne, while you're thinking about that, I'll share with you a little writing that I have on my computer monitor, and that is you can choose the sin, but you cannot choose the consequences. Wow. I'm just wondering if we should. Maybe we should start on this. I'm not sure I'm going to get done with this inherited sin original sin from. Maybe we'll just take a few more minutes to talk about what we've got done so far. Now, tell me your name again. Done. Yes. Maybe because of what you just said, this is an appropriate question. What. What was the tree? What was the fruit? Was it really a tree? Was it really a fruit? It was really a desire. It was really a tree and it was really a fruit. I'm going to get on to this and we talk about the way Adam sin affected all of us. I think it's important to insist on the literal historicity of Adam and Eve as real people and real garden and real tree and real fruit. We don't know what the fruit was. The mythology was an apple. I could have been a really good apple, but a peach would have done as well, I think, a really good peak. I don't know. We don't know. But I do want to insist it was literal. What's your name? My name is Warren and I'm just sitting here and I'm thinking to myself that and I've heard this nice lady over here and heard her discussion. And I'm thinking myself that in the scripture there it said that Adam was with Eve. So I'm thinking that he's just kind of kicked back in the garden and he's enjoying his wonderful place. It's not paying attention and they're kind of going along and Eve just starts chatting like women do with the serpent. He's not saying there's anything wrong with chatting. That's great. I was trying to relate to him. But he's with the flipper and all this kind of stuff. He didn't protect her. He didn't take care of her. And ultimately it just seems to me that he just had one commandment. They couldn't even bathe that one. Well, they did have Phil the earth and subdue it, which is okay. So they had to do that. But yeah, do it to her husband who was with her right down the bottom of her sick. I don't know how much to make of that. There's nothing more you can get from the Hebrew text than the English text. Who was with her? Very simple words. Whether he was right there next door watching the conversation or whether he was 50 or 100 feet away and was with her in the garden. I don't I'm not sure. Some people make more of that saying he was standing there watching him. I just I don't know that we can go any further, but he was there somehow. And surely they both see and there's surely culpability on both of their parts. Anything else on sin? Yes. I have something. Was it Satan the first sinner? Yes. And this was human sin. This is the first human sin. But we really don't know much about Satan's sin. No, no, there are passages in Ezekiel and Isaiah that talk about that seem to talk about a great angel wanting to sit in the place of God and be like God and make his throne. Like the most high. That probably is. And then the second Peter and Jude talk a little bit about this about the angels that did not keep their proper dwelling. So there are hints at that. We don't know too much about. Again, rebelling against God's authority. John, go ahead. Remember as a child thinking about sin. And without God, I would think there really aren't any boundaries in the end. And I were just talking about this on a walk when we were talking about these shooting and how horrific that was without God. What's the boundary? Yeah. Yeah. That's another. I didn't bring this up John, but I think it's really helpful. If we don't just find sin in relation to God, we're left with a lot of the secular world today, not knowing what is right and wrong or how you define right and wrong because where do you get a standard of right and wrong? And it can all be reasoned away or rationalized away. And of course, then what happens is happening a lot of the world today, the more powerful are the people who come to rule and to have influence just by virtual force. When you don't have moral right and wrong standards, then force wins. And that's a very dreadful result for society. I hope it does not prevail ultimately, but I think we're seeing a lot of that today, particularly with Muslim aggressiveness. Now, they have their own sense of right and wrong, but there is at least in radical Islam, a triumph of a bi-grader force in terms of ruling cultures and societies and things like that. Now, they have the claim to take moral standards from the Old Testament side. There is a little different category there, but in secular university, it's not any belief in God, it just turns out to who has the most power. And people do all sorts of wrong things without God. They cast off restraint. Yup, I'm over here now. Did God cause the serpent to tempt Adam and Eve? I don't understand that the serpent, if God made the serpent to be crafty, does that mean that God intended the serpent to... I'm going to go back to... I forgot your name. Barbara. I'm going to go back to what I said. I'm looking for some language between God passively allowed it to happen and didn't know what was going to happen. I want something stronger than that, and I don't want to say that God caused it because it seems like He did it. I want to say, He ordained that it would happen. He planned or somehow guaranteed that it would happen, but the blame is always to be on the creature that did it. And you say, I can't figure that out, and I say, I can't quite figure it out either, and maybe until we get to heaven, we won't know more than that. Judas is responsible. I can't solve that today. Let's stand and sing when we walk with the Lord in the light of His Word.