<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bay Bay Chak Mwa

The Essential Nature of Man

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

Here's the question for today. What are we made of? We know we have a body. Then in addition to a body, there's a non-material part to us, a non-physical part. And really, the question is, are there two parts, a soul and a spirit inside us? Or is it just a soul with another name for it being spirit? And I'll tell you in advance what my conclusion is. My conclusion is that soul and spirit are two different words for the same thing. And I noticed that Daryl kind of already taught my lesson for me because during the last hour he was saying soul or spirit. Several times he said that during the sermon. And so I think that is his view as well. The views on this issue have some technical terms. The one word is called tricotomy. Try meaning three, tricotomy meaning, we're made of three things, body, soul and spirit. Dicotomy, die meaning two, means we're just body and soul or spirit. And then there's monism which I'll talk about in a minute. But I'll start out first by saying most people, both Christians and non-Christian sense that they also have an immaterial part. That is often would call it a soul. There's just an instinct in us that there is something that lives beyond the time we die. That we're not just a body. There's a soul within us. And the three views tricotomy, dichotomy and monism are explained in this way. Tricotomy is made of three parts, body, soul and spirit. And the people who hold to this say that man's spirit is a higher faculty. It's made alive when a person becomes a Christian. A spirit becomes alive. And on this view of tricotomy view, a spirit is the person that most directly worships and prays to God. It's the spiritual part of you, you might say. And John 424, God is spirit. And those who worship him must worship in spirit and truth. So our spirit's worship. And but they would think of that as a separate part of our being. And you can understand how people would get there because soul and spirit are different words. They're different words in Greek and they're different words in Hebrew. And so it might be that those two different words would indicate two different things. And it's kind of an instinctive view. But it's interesting for over 100 years in the academic world. I don't know of anybody who has defended tricotomy. It's interesting. Scholars can defend dichotomy and argue against monism. But I had to go back to, there's a German scholar died in 1890 named Franz Delech, an Old Testament scholar, and he held the tricotomy. But I don't think anybody since then has argued that in an academic way. It's quite interesting. Dicotomy is that the spirit is not a separate part of men, but another term for soul. And that man, that is as male and female, mankind, or us as human beings, we are made up of two parts, a body and our soul or spirit. And then there's a third view. But this third view is not a view that's held by Christians. It's kind of a secular view that is the body is all there is. That's called monism. The man is only one element. His body is the person. We have no soul. If you've gone to a class in a secular university and taken a philosophy class, you might get philosophers arguing saying, of course, there isn't any soul. How can you prove that it exists? There's no proof. It's just your chemical reactions in your brain, your nerves, and things like that, and your motions. We can explain all those in terms of just physical reactions. And so that would be a secular view. And people would say, we have no soul. We die. That's it. Well, the biblical data, what does it say? It seems before we start out on this, the emphasis in the Bible is on the overall unity of man. That is, the Bible doesn't generally speak of a person's body doing something apart from his soul, or a person's soul doing something apart from his body. Rather, the whole person does something or other. And there seems to be interaction between them. In fact, I don't think I have the verse up here, but there's a verse says, a cheerful heart is good medicine but a downcast spirit dries up the bones. That is, when we're really discouraged and down and we kind of feel it in our physical bodies, there is an interaction constantly between what's going on in our soul and what happens in our bodies. And maybe you know that if you're hit with some kind of sickness, a flu or something spiritually, you kind of often feel just, oh, I can't even, it's really hard to have energy to read my Bible or pray. And that is, there's an interaction. Interaction. And sometimes when there's just a special time of prayer and rejoicing and worship in the presence of God, your body feels renewed and refreshed as well because there's interaction between body and soul. And so the emphasis of the Bible is, we do something. Our whole person does something and it relates to both body and soul. And so one takeaway little lesson from this before we go on into the details is that the Bible is concerned that we grow in holiness and in love for God in our bodies as well as our spirits or souls. Second Corinthians 7.1, since we have these promises, brothers, let us cleanse ourselves from every defilement of body and spirit and make holiness perfect in the fear of God. Paul wants us to take care of our bodies, not defile them, not abuse them, not neglect them, but care for them to cleanse ourselves from every defilement of body and spirit. And then in our spirits, not have sinful thoughts or ideas permeating and affecting us as well. So the body and soul are both important and the Bible seems to be concerned that we look after the needs of both. Now, it seems to me, however, that as I look at the verses in the Bible, it seems that the Bible uses the words spirit and soul interchangeably. And so the biblical words translated soul, Hebrew nefesh and Greek psuké, related to our word psychology, and the word spirit, ruach and Hebrew and penuma in Greek, they're sometimes used interchangeably. For instance, just before Jesus' death, when he knew he was going to be beaten and suffer and die, he said in John 1227, now is my soul troubled. And then just the next chapter, John 13, Jesus was troubled in his spirit. It seems like John is saying the same things in his gospel just using two different words. John 1227, John 1321. Or this one, Mary says, my soul magnifies the Lord and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior, Luke 146 to 47. And there's something in Hebrew called Hebrew parallelism where Hebrew poetic speech will say something and then say it again just using different words. And sometimes there's a little change in meaning, but sometimes it's just a repetition. And so I think that's what's going on here. My soul magnifies the Lord. My spirit rejoices in God my Savior. She's kind of saying the same thing with different words. It looks like they're interchangeable. Hebrew's 1223 can talk about people in heaven, the assembly of the first born who are enrolled in heaven and to God the judge of all and to the spirits of the righteous made perfect. So people in heaven who have died and gone before they're called spirits. But Revelation 6.9, I saw under the altar the souls of those who've been slain for the word of God. They're people in heaven are called souls. And so it looks again like they're kind of different words used in the same way. And another thing, when we die, sometimes the Bible can say our spirit departs and goes to heaven. Sometimes the Bible can say our soul departs and goes to heaven. So here I, oh, who is this? In Genesis 35, let me look for a minute. This is 35-18. This is Rachel. And Rachel went into labor and as her soul was departing for she was dying, she called his name Benoni, but his father called him Benjamin. Okay, this is one of the sons, the youngest son then of Jacob being born to the wife whom he loved most. Rachel and her, it says her soul was departing for she was dying. And then first King's 1721, I'll turn to that as well, first King's 1721. Here's Elijah. And the widow of Zerafath had a son who died and Elijah came and stretched his own body on the dead child's body and cried to the Lord, O Lord, my God, let the child's life come into him again. But the Hebrew word nefesh is the word normally used for soul. And so here, the soul would come back into the person to restore life. And as they have 53-12, he poured out his soul, a nefesh to death and was numbered with the transgressors or Luke 1220 this night, your soul, your psuke, your soul is required of you because the man was going to die. So there are a number of verses that say, our soul departs when we die. But then when Psalm 31 talks about a person dying, it's a prediction of the Messiah. And the Psalmist says, into your hand I commit my spirit. And Jesus, when he was dying on the cross, quoted this in Luke 2346, said, Father, into your hand I commit my spirit. So then the Bible can talk about a person's spirit dying. Or Ecclesiastes 12.7 talking about the time of death, says, the spirit returns to God who gave it. Or John 1930 of Jesus crucifixion, he bowed his head and gave up his spirit. Some verses can say that our soul departs when we die. Some verses can say, our spirit departs when we die. But scripture nowhere says that a person's soul and spirit departed and went to heaven or reeled it up to God. And so I don't think there are two different things. I think there are just two different words for the same thing. Sandy. Not me, the God of... Okay. Now see I'm dealing with the easy verses first and Sandy jumps to the hard verse. Sorry. Okay. First desolonians 523 does mention spirit soul and body. Hold on for a few minutes because I don't want to run away from it but it is a verse that people bring up in this regard. So yeah, good. Just I'm going to delay it for a little bit. The Old Testament authors recognize that a person exists after his body dies though. Contrary to those who claim that Old Testament authors saw only the unity of man and number those verses about a person's soul returning to God or her soul was departing for she died into your hands. I commit my spirit and things like that. Of course Elijah was caught up into heaven. Enoch was not for God took him. They go into the presence of God. Okay. Now men said to be either body and soul or body and spirit. Most verses. Do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. But rather fear him who can destroy both soul and body and hell. Matthew 1028 looks like Jesus is talking about the whole person. Body and soul, soul and body, the whole person. Or 1 Corinthians 5.5. You are to deliver this man to Satan for the destruction of the flesh so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord. Flesh and spirit. Looks like flesh but in a kind of equivalent of body. Looks like that is speaking of the whole person. Either as body and soul or body and spirit. Therefore, spirit and soul or soul can refer to the person's entire immaterial existence. And so in 2 Corinthians 7 and 1, if we cleanse ourselves of body and spirit, it's cleansing all of us. Cleans ourselves from every defilement of body and spirit. It's cleansing our whole person. It isn't like there's some other leftover part that we're not cleansing. So again, body and spirit seem to be speaking of the whole person. And then here's another strong consideration. Of view held by people who hold to tricotomy would tend to say the spirit is the spiritual part of us and it's holy. It's perfect. And so we wouldn't expect that that would sin. We sin when our souls take over. And then that would be where we get sin. But there are some verses that talk about a spirit. Our spirit's sinning. So when we get this, it's contrary to the view of tricotomy. So we believe only the soul can sin. A Paul encourages cleansing from every defilement of body and spirit. So that means there can be defilement or sin in our spirits. Or the unmarried woman first Corinthian 734 is concerned how to be holy in body and spirit. Or a Psalm 78 talks about a generation whose spirit was not faithful to God. So our spirits can sin. That leads me to this conclusion. I just sat down in my Bible and I said, is there anything that the Bible says that the spirit does that the soul doesn't do? Or is there anything the Bible says the soul does that the spirit doesn't do? And I couldn't find anything. Knowing things in our spirit or soul, sinning, our spirit or some worshiping God with our spirit and soul, dying or our soul goes to heaven. All those things seem to be said of both spirit and soul. So I can't find any difference between the two. And that makes me think the two are the same. Here are some verses experiencing emotions. Now some people tricotomists would say, your emotions, that's part of your soul. Emotions, your intellect, your will, that's part of your soul and your spirit is something different. But if I look at the Bible and talks about emotions, I can find things in our spirits that experience emotions. So X17, 16, when Paul was in Athens, he was troubled by all the idols and it says, his spirit, Paul's spirit was provoked within him. Proverbs 17, 22, a crushed spirit. I think that's the one that says, dries up the bones. Proverbs 17, 22. Somebody have that. Let's see, yeah, a crushed spirit, don't cast spirit, dries up the bones. There is a feeling emotions. Or Jesus was troubled in his spirit, John 13, 21. And so emotions can be felt in our spirit too. So it isn't just that our soul feels emotions. Knowing things, Jesus, Mark 28, Mark 28, Jesus perceiving in his spirit that they question within themselves. So Jesus can know things in his spirit or Romans 8, 16, the spirit himself bears witness with our spirit so we can perceive and know things in our spirit. It's not just that the spirit or the soul feels and thinks these things, but it seems to me that these activities are done by the whole person, including the body and the brain, et cetera. So Psalm 63, oh, God, you are my God. Or honestly, I seek you, my soul thirst for you, my flesh reigns for you, it's the whole person. And again, I don't think there's anything that is done just by the soul or just by the spirit. And then, and people say, well, my spirit, that's the part that relates to God. That's the, that's the really spiritual part of us. I say, well, wait a minute. The soul relates to God, doesn't it? Psalm 25, 1, to you, O Lord, I lift up my soul. Psalm 103, 1, bless the Lord, O my soul, and all that is within me. Psalm, or Luke 146, my soul magnifies the Lord. Mark 12, 30. You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and your strength. So there seems to be no area of life that's just carried out by our spirits and not our souls or just carried out by our souls and not our spirits. I can't see any difference. Both soul and spirit are said to do all the same things. Therefore, it seems to me that the dichotomous view is best. Spirit and soul are different words for the same thing, the non-material part of our existence and we are made of body and soul or spirit. No, that's, I mean, that's my, that's the reason I get there and that's my conclusion. As I look at those verses in the Bible, no, there are going to be some questions. There's a question from Hebrews 4-12 and there's a question from 1 Thessalonians 5-23. So I'm going to come to those in just a second. But if there are other questions than those two because I've got those on some slides, John. You said in 100 years there hasn't been any arguments for tricotomy. Yep. So are there churches today that believe that? All over the place. Say the question again for the tape. You say in the scholarly or in the academic world nobody's made an argument for tricotomy in 100 years. As far as I know. Okay. And then my question is, are there churches that hold tricotomy? And hold tricotomy groups. And if so, what are they? I don't know who they are but I meet people all the time that hold tricotomy all over the place. And so why is that? I think there are two reasons. There's Hebrews 4-12 that speaks of the word of God being sharper than a two-edged sword piercing to the dividing of soul and spirit. Okay. I'll talk about that in a minute. And then there's first that's only in 5-23 that talks about your body, soul and spirit. Be kept pure and blameless. So two verses. And then it's kind of an instinct that people have. Oh, I've got this spiritual sense that's different from my emotions. Or something by feelings. There's kind of an instinct. And what else? There's just been some popular Christian literature that's written in that regard. And Watchman Knee, a Chinese Christian devotional writer, who's very helpful in many ways, talks about the spiritual man and the soulish man, things like that. So it's just kind of, it's out there in the Christian world and I keep bumping into people who say, oh, I don't know, I've read your arguments but I still think we have a soul different from our spirit. So, but I've given you my best shot for, you know, the overall teaching scripture. Okay, yeah, I forgot your name. Don, yeah. You gave an example of Mary, talking about her soul. My soul, yeah. Can you not use the word life over soul, using an English word? You know, what is the emanating force that makes this body get up in the morning or makes it, makes it dogwag his tail? You know, there's an emanating force. I've always considered that as the soul or life in the spirit is what we commute with God. Yeah, and some people, I mean, sometimes the word suke or nefish in Hebrew does mean life. It depends on the context, how it's translated. And this night your soul is required of you. Some people might say, oh, that means this night your life is required of you. But there are other cases where his soul departed or his soul returned. I don't think it's life. I think it's the person. So and my soul magnifies the Lord and my spirit rejoices in God, my savior. That doesn't mean life. That means a different part of you. Or Paul perceiving, or let's see, Paul was troubled in spirit. It doesn't mean he's troubled in his life. It means there was a spiritual part of him that was troubled. So sometimes it means one and sometimes at least the word nefish can mean life. Yeah. That's true. Or I'm over here. I'm over here. I'm over here. My question is I've always thought of tricotomy because of the spirit being a capital S. And so that makes me wonder whether the churches that think that it's a tricotomy of body, soul, and spirit, thinking of the Holy Spirit and non-Christian wouldn't have the spirit. So that's... Okay, good, Daddy. I'm glad you asked that. The Holy Spirit, people hold a tricotomy and people who hold a dichotomy. Both groups say the Holy Spirit is something else, different. The Holy Spirit is God Himself who comes to live within us. But that's different from our spirit. So it says in Romans 8, the Spirit Himself bears witness with our spirit that we are the children of God. That means the Holy Spirit comes in and we notice, spiritually, we notice that the Holy Spirit is there. And our spirit says, yes, I know that I'm a child of God. So capital S spirit means Holy Spirit. Small S spirit means my human spirit, the part that's not physical in me, okay? Mike? Yeah, when this may be somewhere you're going but is the soul a created entity by God? Yes, it means so. Does Jesus have a soul? Yes, both. There was... There was when people... And I'll get to this in about a month, but in the early church when people were trying to figure out what to believe about Jesus as God and man together, there were some people... Let's see... There were some people who said Jesus only has a human body. Not a human spirit or soul. Apollinarianism is the name of a... Heresy that was rejected in the early church. This Apollinarist said, oh, I've got it. Jesus just had a human body but didn't have a human spirit, Holy Spirit within him or his divine nature was the... But the problem is that the church said, no, we need salvation not just of our bodies, but we need salvation of our whole person. And Jesus had to be a whole human being with a genuine human soul or spirit to redeem us and represent us. So Jesus, I think, had a soul or spirit just like we do only without sin. And that's when he said, Father, into your hands, I commit my spirit. That's what's going to the Father. It's his human spirit. Amen. You know the reason that I always thought that there were three. I mean, this is just fascinating to me how they have names for all these different things and thoughts and, you know, your ways are much higher than my ways for him, for sure. But because we are a reflection of God, God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit, I always thought there were three parts of us because we were made in the image of God. And I just, I thought that but thinking it, improving it, are two different things. And I appreciate you showing us how you think this thing through. Yeah, that's a good question. Would God make us to be three parts because it reflects the Trinity? He might have, but I just don't think the verses bear that out. And I think that the way that we reflect the Trinity is by the fact that we're more people. You know, many people and we have a unity in the church, we have unity in marriage and your family and other things. Okay, Charlie. Maybe you're headed there. But are there warnings in this? Like if someone does hold the tricotomy, can you get into trouble? Or is this just kind of a technical thing that we want clarity on? Or is it dangerous? I think, well, the kind of general theory is, if we believe something that's not true in the Bible, it might skew other things a little bit. And I think what happens, actually, is that if people hold the tricotomy, then you say, well, what is the soul? They say, well, that includes your mind and your thinking. But that's not as important as your spirit. And so it can be anti-intellectual, anti-study, anti-academic. You just, all you do is you just worship and you love God, but you don't think. Now, that's a caricature. But I mean, that's, that would be the extreme. But there are some groups that would go that direction. And I encountered one time when we were in Philadelphia where a college, I was working with a college group and a college student was going to this other kind of cultist thing. And so I went with her or Margaret and I went with her to just to visit this thing. And when I tried to argue with these people or discuss on the base, the Bible said, that's solish. That's just intellectual. We have the spirit and we know what we're about. So that could be a danger. And the other thing is, if your spirit is really the highest, most important part, could make you neglect your body and say, well, that's not your spiritual part. So those would be dangerous. Okay, Leverin? In your view of dichotomy to a must and they try economists, well, how can you quench the spirit, or grieve the spirit? How does that separate out from the soul if your view is correct? Good, Leverin, that would be kind of related to this other question over here. I think that both views would say, don't quench the spirit in 1 Thessalonians 5 or grieving the Holy Spirit in Ephesians 4. They would say that that is the Holy Spirit. That's not our own personal human spirit. Don't quench the spirit. It would be, don't quench the Holy Spirit working within you. And don't grieve the Holy Spirit. Don't make the Holy Spirit within you feel so awful about your actions. Capitalists would tell you the difference. Yeah, spirit, yeah. All right, here we go. Does the Holy Spirit come and go? I'd like to think not, but we're seemingly involved with soul and body and spirit. Yeah, well, our human spirit leaves when we die. Because you go to a funeral, of course, the body is just there and the person's body, but you say that's not really the person because the spirit is gone or the soul. But the Holy Spirit within our lifetimes, once we're born again, the Holy Spirit stays within us and remains. But I think the Holy Spirit can work more or less strongly, manifest Himself more or less powerfully. We can talk about being filled with the Spirit or different people in the Bible, Peter filled with the Spirit began to do this. And so there can be a stronger work or a weaker work. But the Holy Spirit remains within us. Okay, yeah, I'd like to get this one on the tape too, because this is a good, and now I can tell a couple of stories to tell because I hear where it's going. Go ahead. People talk about a sixth sense. And I've always maintained that my sixth sense was the Holy Spirit. You spend 20 years in a trauma center. You've got to have somebody a bit stronger than my, it's just my spirit, so okay. I don't want to think that he's coming and going. Good, good. Good, art comes out all many years of practice as a physician in Wisconsin, I think.

I think, I'm just going to kind of back off to a broad answer here. I think what the secular world has vocabulary that they used to explain what Christians would call our spirit or the work of the Holy Spirit. And so sixth sense might be one of those. But in Sandy could help out here, the whole world of psychology isn't built on thinking about us as having a solar a spirit, it's built on, let's see if we can get a physical explanation for all this stuff and then all sorts of vocabulary grows up to describe what we would call spiritual terms. So what people would call a sixth sense for Christians, I think it is often the Holy Spirit guiding us in one way or another. Now we can make mistakes on that because sometimes it could be the pizza we ate last night too. But I think as we grow as a maturity as Christians, we get better at sensing the Holy Spirit's guidance. Now let me tell you two stories and because they're very recent and they, I'm just, yeah, I don't because this tape goes out on the internet, could you turn off the recording for just a second? So my encouragement to you is to grow in being sensitive to how the Holy Spirit guides us in there. And the fact that two things like that happen and look like it was just the Lord leading in the last few days, that's an encouragement to me. It's an encouragement to say, maybe this God's starting to do something exciting in our lives or in this area, Andrea? Yep. Yep. Okay, I'll just repeat it for the tape. Okay, I understand what is the heart then. I think the heart is the Bible's expression for all of our inner life and our convictions and our, just it's the broader sense. It includes what our spirit is doing and thinking and our dispositions and our convictions that it's the whole of our inward life. It's not just our mind. It includes what we think, but it's deeper than that. It's bigger, Sandy. One additional thing I would say in support of a dichotomist view is the danger of compartmentalizing our inner life that we can say, oh, well, I try to have a regular quiet time. And so it doesn't matter that I rage at my co-workers or... That's right. That's right. That's just, you know, that's just your emotion. That's just how I am. That's just how I am. I can be rude to people, but that's really, that's not important because I'm praying on a regular basis. Yeah, that's not my spiritual life. So we can easily compartmentalize our inner lives. Thanks, Sandy. Thanks, yeah, Mark. Well, that's a sense that the second or the first one have, you know, the, the second or the second or the first one. Yeah, well, the Holy Spirit shall lead us in all truth. And I think, you know, for an word of God, the Holy Spirit is going to bring Scripture to mind so that we could rightly think this secular person doesn't have the Spirit of God. Yeah. They're going to, their counsel, their sixth sense is probably going to come from the other side. And it's probably going to be more fleshly. It's, it's not going to be the way of God. That's, and I think that's the huge difference between probably the regenerative person and the person. Okay. Good, Mark. That's certainly true that the enemy can influence the spiritual side of the, of the, of the secular person. First John says, we are, let's see, we are children of God, but the whole world is in the power of the evil one. So there's that. And they're just sin. That's natural selfishness and human sin and people's life. But also, you know, when the Holy Spirit is working to draw people to himself, sometimes that's that, for a non-Christian, they're like, there can be a sensitivity to the Holy Spirit, leading or guiding someone in a certain way, too. So, okay. Good. All that's good. I'm going to go on. My conclusion is we are made of body and soul or spirit used interchangeably. Now, I'm going to be completely honest with you. When I get to the end of that, I'm not 100% sure I'm right. That is, I think it's about right, but I just wonder if there isn't some difference in usage anyway, even if there isn't a different part of us. But I haven't been able to figure out what it is in the Bible. So maybe it's just synonyms, but I wonder if there's some different emphasis but I'm not sure. Okay. Now, what are the arguments for tricotomy? Back on the other side, what would someone say? Well, there are a couple of verses in particular. Number one, first Thessalonians 5.23. May the God of peace himself sanctify you holy and may your whole spirit and soul and body be kept sound and blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ. No, that I think is a fair translation. I was in on the committee that translated it that way. When we said, when may your whole spirit and soul and body, that prejudice is it in a way that would favor dichotomy. That is, it's saying your whole person. And it's just saying, but other translations have had may your spirit and soul and body be kept holy or something like that. I'd have to look at them that may be make it look a little different. And then Hebrews 4-12, the word of God is living an act of sharper than any two-inch sword, piercing to the division of soul and of spirit of joints and of marrow. And sometimes people have said, like King James said, piercing to the division of soul and spirit, not soul and of spirit. And so it looks like you're dividing the two things, soul and spirit. And then Paul says, if I pray in a tongue my spirit prays, but my mind is unfruitful. The first Corinthians 14-14 does this mean his mind is doing something different from his spirit, indicating that they're different. The soul, including the mind is different. So that would be a verse. And then there's an argument from personal experience. People say, oh, I'm just kind of spiritually aware of things. And it seems different from my emotions or my will or my intellect. And then people say, well, isn't the spirit what makes us different from animals? And then another argument is our spirit comes alive at regeneration. And in some versions, Romans 8.10 says, if Christ is in you, though the body is dead because of sin, the spirit is alive with a lowercase S because of righteousness. Oh, there it is. Your spirits are alive, revised in a version because of righteousness. But it's not always translated that way. And more recently, the tendency I think has been, and I think more literally, the spirit is life. So that may not be the best translation. Okay, so those are the arguments. Now what would my answer be? First, that's the Lonean's 523. It's just piling up synonyms to mean the whole person. Your whole spirit and soul and body just means all of you. Like this, Matthew 2237, you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. Well, now how many things do I have? Let's see, heart, soul, mind, and then for spirit and then body. Now I've got five parts. Pentatomy, or is it? Pentacotomy. I don't know. Well, I don't think those are all different things. I think there are just lots of different words, meaning the inward part of us. Again, Don. Yeah, okay, okay, yeah. The Psalms talk about, bless the Lord, my soul, and all that is within me, bless his holy name. And the Hebrew actually literally, to can talk about our heart, our kidneys would be in the kind of place where emotions isn't, it doesn't get translated literally. They had kind of the sense that inside us, these bodily organs kind of represented emotions and feelings and things. So, I think it's just different ways of talking about all of us. The Hebrew is 412. The Word of God is living an act of piercing to the division of soul and spirit, of joints, of soul and of spirit, of joints and of marrow, and discerning the thoughts and intentions of the heart. I don't think this is meaning piercing to the dividing of soul and spirit. So, you can divide soul from spirit like it's going through and separating them out. I think it means dividing the soul, dividing the spirit, dividing the joints, dividing the marrow, that is it's just going deep inside you. And he's saying there are a lot of different things that the Word of God, the Spirit of God, goes deep inside you like a sword. I don't think he means he's dividing one from the other. So, those are the two main verses. Does that make sense? If I pray to tongue my spirit prays but my mind is unfruitful, 1 Corinthians 14, 14, I think it means Paul doesn't understand the content of what he's praying, but I don't think you need the dichotomy to do that. You could say my spirit prays that is the non-material part of me, but I don't understand, that's all. And personal experience, I do agree people should have a spiritual component in their lives. I think we should sense what we're doing inwardly in our spirits. And I just talked about that for a few minutes, but this sense is not just our spirit. It's also said to be our soul does this. My soul magnifies the Lord. Bless the Lord of my soul. Love the Lord of all your soul. And so, I think you can call it either one, but it doesn't mean there's a separate part. What makes us different from animals is not that we have a spirit, but that we worship God and relate to Him in the spiritual realm, the non-physical realm. And so, I don't think it's a separate part of us. It's just that that non-material part has abilities that an animal doesn't have, and as we can relate to God and worship Him and pray to Him. Does our spirit come alive at regeneration? I don't think that's a good way to talk about conversion. Although I've heard some gospel presentations that way. And the reason is that the Bible can sometimes talk about a non-Christian unbeliever having a spirit that does things. So, Sihun, king of Hechbun, would not let the Israelites pass by, Deuteronomy 2.30, for the Lord God, hardened his spirit and made his heart obsolete. And so, there he had a spirit that was hardened. And Daniel 5.20, Nebuchadnezzar, when his heart was lifted up, his spirit was hardened, so that he dealt proudly, it was brought down from his kingly throne. And Psalm 78.8, a stubborn and rebellious generation whose heart was not steadfast, whose spirit was not faithful to God, probably unbelievers. They didn't have faith. So, I think that non-Christians also have a spirit or soul, but it's rebellious against God. It isn't that we have one and they don't or ours is alive and there isn't. We as whole persons are a new creation in Christ. What happens at salvation is, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation, 2 Corinthians 5, 17. So, the whole of us is made new and able to relate to God. Conclusion. Although the arguments for tricotomy have some force, they are not ultimately persuasive. And I don't think there is any argument for tricotomy that can overcome all these verses about spirit and soul being used interchangeably and doing the same things, being used synonymously. So, now let's see where I am, 1045. Oh, I'm going to, I'll just go on. We have a few more minutes. I'm going to read this from an older systematic theology book, Lewis Berkoff, kind of he studied the history of Christian thought and he said, the tripartite or tricotomy, tripartite conception of man, originated in Greek philosophy, which conceived of the relation to the body of the body and the spirit of man to each other after the analogy of the relation between the material universe and God. It was thought that in Greek philosophy, just as the latter, the universe and God, could enter into communion with each other only by means of a third substance or an intermediate being. So, the former humans could enter into a mutual vital relationship only by means of a third or intermediate element, namely the soul. So, he's saying that the idea of tricotomy went back to Greek thought not to the Bible. And so, following Greek philosophy, there would be this sense in tricotomy that the material world is essentially evil and the spirit is the really good thing. And this can lead to, as I answered to Charlie O'Wallagall, it can lead to diminishing the importance of our physical bodies and the importance of the material creation, which God says is very good. Another danger with tricotomy is an anti-intellectual tendency of elevating spirit as that thing that relates most closely to God and therefore vigorous academic work and thinking and arguing and discussing can be seen as unspiritual. But, Jesus says, we are to love the Lord our God with all our mind, as well as with our heart and soul. That is, the whole person can be spiritual, it can relate to God. Paul talks about arguments and taking thoughts captive in 2nd Corinthians 10-5. And tricotomy can lead to an emphasis on spiritual discernment, apart from the truth and arguments based on the truth. So, I'm back to dichotomy and I think the advantages are, it emphasizes the overall unity of human beings, maintains the value of our body and promotes a healthful unity between body and spirit. Here's that verse I was looking for, Proverbs 17-22, a joyful heart is good medicine, but a crushed spirit dries up the bones, there's an interaction between the two. And it encourages Christian growth in the whole person. I'm kind of going through this quickly because I think I've already talked about this. But, does the Bible speak of an immaterial part of man that exists without his body? Yes.

We have a soul, I'm skipping that, I'm skipping that. Our soul goes to, oh, Gerald has preached on this. When we die, our soul goes to, our spirit goes to be with the Lord. Stephen said, Lord Jesus received my spirit when he was dying. Paul says, we'd rather be away from the body and at home with the Lord. Okay, no. Before I go to the last point of the outline, I want to see if we're all okay with this. Question's over here. Yeah, Carol. I've just had the thought, what, where does the mentally and emotionally handicapped person, is that a bodily problem? I mean, I know that it seems like it affects our spirit and their mind. I just wonder where they're at. I'm not sure. I think that. Let me just see. There are so many things that come to mind right now. Let's just talk, for instance, about someone who is born with very diminished mental capacity. Well, I think that person is still a human being and the image of God has a soul. And sometimes people with very diminished mental capacity can have us. A love for God that's very genuine and real. And surely they're going to be with the Lord in heaven and they've trusted in Jesus in a very simple way, but there's a genuine faith and their minds will be renewed and that mental capacity they didn't have will be given to them, I think, in the resurrection. So that's in general. But then there are all sorts of complex things that happen. When we take certain medicines, I know this. If I take certain medicine, my mind starts to get fuzzy and it's harder to pray. What is that? It's saying there's constant interaction between body and soul or body and spirit. And one can affect the other and all of that's kind of mysterious. I don't not sure how it works, but we can extrapolate that to a lot of other cases. So, yeah, no. Yep. I forgot your name. Rosemary. Rosemary, I know who you are. Darryl spoke this morning about our spirits and then becoming a new body. Okay. What happens to the lost person? What happens to their soul and their body? Do they get a new body when they go to hell or do we know? There's a very frightening verse that was right at the beginning of the hour. Jesus said, fear him who can destroy both body and soul in hell. And I think it, and there is in book of Revelation, the people rise to the judgment. Or the hour is coming when all in John, when all in the tombs will come forth. And we'll hear his voice and come forth and they'll stand before God at judgment. So, I think that unbelievers on the last day when Jesus comes back or at the day of final judgment, they'll be summoned to appear in their bodies before God and to be judged. But I don't think they'll get the new resurrection bodies that we will have. It's a hard thing to think about, a hard question. That was Mary. Okay, Wayne. Several years ago, and because we have some scientific folks in our class that like to ask this question, I read an article in Readers Digest where there was a scientific study where they weighed animals and humans right after death. And the animals had no loss in weight. And the humans, he said, had about a three quarter ounce loss of weight. And he attributed that to the souls. I want to, is that true or false? I don't know. I'm sorry. I had, I'd seen that too and I didn't know what to make of it. Wayne, it's true that it was in Readers Digest. But if it was in Readers Digest, it's true. I don't know. Look, we're kind of at the end here. There's one more kind of related topic. And I'm not going to, I'm just going to give you a, I'm going to talk about it here for a second without looking at the slides. There is another question. When a little baby is born or when a little baby is conceived in its mother's womb. Where does the soul come from? Does the soul come from the dad and mom? Just like the physical body does. That's called traditionism comes from the dad and mom. Or does God just create a soul afresh and give it to the body in the womb? That's called creationism. And I lean toward creationism. But I think that God, if you know you had children, there are similarities in the spiritual tendencies and things that between children and parents, at least a lot of times. So maybe this God creates a soul that's related in some ways to the dad and mom. It's a harder question than I can figure out. And I don't know if the Bible tells us a lot about it, but there's just, there's just a debate about it. And there's another view that Mormons hold and other, and Eastern religions called pre-existentianism. It means that our soul just sit up there and have and waiting for a body to be put into them. And we existed a long time before our bodies existed, and I don't believe that. And I don't think the Bible gives support to that. I think that at some point, right early in the time when our bodies come in our mothers' womb, God puts a soul there. And that's the end of that discussion. All right, Clyde gets the last question, then we're going to sing. I think he creates them, creates them individually at the... Oh no, I see, creation didn't end. That's interesting. So that's an argument for a traditionism. Well, but I mean, you and I didn't exist in our bodies either. There's something in the paper, but the parents had a role in that, so. Oh, I'm not going to get into that. We did enough for today. Let's sing because this is kind of a hymn that tells our souls to be still before God and rejoicing him. So it's related.