<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Գրանցում Ամսական Գրանցում

Worship Leadership & Participation 2

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Welcome to the continuation of leadership and participation in the worship moving toward planning a worship service lessened 14, all right, okay, good Thank you a corporate amen

We're announcing of a class title brings revival at covenant

Let's open and prayer please Father, we thank you that the Lord Jesus comes into the midst of his people delighting to call us Brothers and sisters not ashamed of us willing to join his voice with ours as we preach as we sing as we pray We thank you for the privilege we have To move in and out of corporate public worship week after week in a way that deepens our relationship with you and Impacts our day-to-day living and we pray that you would do that even in our lives as we continue to search your word and our own hearts and Understand your church and the way you have designed it and Help us to see beyond just ways we've always done things or To not be carried away with being innovative for its own sake Lord help us to be shaped and fashioned with this deep reverence for you and being an awe of you While delighting and full of joy and celebration that we can draw near to you and come right into your very presence because of Christ So guide us now as we continue through this course in Jesus name amen Okay, just a couple things about what I call the art of leading worship. I

Think Planning and leading worship is one of the most creative and artistic things that most pastors do and

That includes crafting a sermon But it's it's bigger than that and I had the Consider privilege now. It seemed like an awesome responsibility then after my first year of seminary. I was I accepted a position at a small Presbyterian church Outside of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania ghost dealers Back in the 70s when they won four Super Bowls

I say it's it's part of my heartbeat, you know City of Zion I mean Pittsburgh We were born there

Kind of be a little humor here in this so okay less than 14, right? But I I was called to be the student pastor of a church of about a hundred people Where I preached every week and planned worship service I even did the bulletin each week and the old cut a stencil around the mini Okay, um, you know, you get the blue ink all over your Whatever I just remember having ink on my hands and a few frustration a few sanctifying moments Let's put it that way in the Preparation for worship, but you know, there was a another pastor who came to moderate the session meetings and was present when we did the sacraments But virtually everything else I did more funerals in the two years there. I think it was eight Then I have since in terms of members of the congregation. I've served It's I got a lot of very hands-on practical What do I do now sort of situations there? But I think that I've come to appreciate more and more over the years as I've seen What exactly it is that God has designed corporate public worship for and how he is present and the convergence of the means of grace and the transforming of people's lives and Christ himself with us in every aspect of it The idea of the gospel shaping and gospel storyline rooted in the scripture coming into the service and going out into people's lives Now I've begun to see that this is this is a This is a creative Energizing exercise of of thinking through and planning and leading a worship service One of my answers to should we have drama in worship that we'll talk about more later is worship itself is intended to be dramatic with

The way these different means of grace come together and the sacraments themselves are part of the visible drama of redemption With the baptism of water and the eating of the bread in the cup and so in some ways The restoring to their rightful places of all of the elements of a worship service and then Weaving them together in a cohesive progressive gospel shaped way I mean that's that's like drawing a painting it's like

You know writing Music, I mean it's got an artistic side to it that transcends just kind of the logical check it off the list You know flood the numbers or we're gonna do him here here and here and here I've got a record of you know. Oh, we haven't done him number 333 for four months now And I like that one so we'll plug this in here when there has anything to do with the logical gospel flow of the service at that time or not and to do it with other people can be also Very energizing and I think part of the way God has designed His church that some of the gifts some gifts he's given to all He's given gifts to all people and some of those gifts are people who actually can have some creative resourcing input To helping you do well what where your limitations are we're gonna talk Later today about How pastors and musicians can work together Recognizing Strengths and weaknesses of each other and know ourselves and seeing that something bigger than what one or the other could do can happen when we work together In that way So it takes a lot of prayer It takes a lot of time. It takes a lot of communication with other lead worshipers the simple way out in some ways Is to just do it all yourself plan it all yourself and lead it all yourself But I think that that's Probably not being a wise steward of all the resources God has put in your congregation on both the planning side and participating in leading side of worship I Think that there's a sense in which If we want to think about worship as a dramatic unfolding of the gospel story If you are the worship leader the pastor who's overseeing it not necessarily doing everything It's it's sort of like the the drama coach Or if it's an athletic analogy you're a you're a player coach You're participating in it. Maybe the drama coach has a lead role in in the in the play, but they're also Helping others understand or or maybe in some ways another analogy might be that You're a narrator of the unfolding drama as you oversee the whole thing You sort of call or use to call people into worship and you're the rubrics these connecting words that are naming things and and and helping people through and understanding Why we come to the Lord's table what's going on while we do it without it being another lecture or um sermon but strategically placed words this idea of of Rubrics, you know, I talked about that singing of he is exalted after reading a scripture of exalting God and having people pray prayers of exaltation to say before you go into that five to eight minute time God alone is worthy of being exalted and we're going to enter into his presence in a way that we will focus on exalting the glorious name of God as We sing and read his word and pray and then That's all you say it's sort of less is more When there are times you have to give link to your explanations of things But then let it happen without saying oh, did you see how now we're praying prayers at exaltation or now we're going to send these exalted again It's sort of like it's not a Radio announcer that's over announcing an athletic event Or maybe the analogy would be a TV broadcaster of a sporting event the viewer can see what's going on and There's there's sort of an art of a good commentator of a sporting event of Saying too much or too little I mean a lot of times I think of Who's the guy from St. Louis? It doesn't want to be Yeah, Bob Cosses. I mean there I remember some Olympic moments where or the end of some grand events where There's no commentator because you can see the celebration or you know the the disappointment or whatever It's a it's one of those moments where You know after the after You know Tiger Woods winning the British open and golf in the year 2006 when this is being video recorded he You know thinking about his dad and the kind of that emotional moment You know you know you say well look there's tiger looks like he's crying now, you know whatever. It's sort of like You they set the drunk dramatic moment. You know as a viewer That this is part of the backdrop and he didn't make the cut of the US open the first major he never made the cut-out and So the stage has been set in when that moment comes that is the highly emotional moment as he's walking up to the 18th green It makes more sense to say nothing as The commentator and in the broadcast and just let the moment unfold Leading worship is like that sometimes you sometimes you have to give more of the backdrop so that people understand why we're doing what we're doing But sometimes when you're in the moment It's less is more or even not having to say anything Just let the elements unfold without announcement. I mean, I I get a little frustrated people that say it's in the hymn No, it says the title of the hymn I mean in the bulletin says the title of the hymn the page of the hymn and the preacher gets up and says we're now going to stand and sing together hymn number 100 great as I faithfulness and People start saying up and say again, it's 100 great as I faithfulness to everybody get that 100 great as I faithfulness. We're going to sing all four stanzas or something like that. It says only three to that hymn It's sort of like all right already shut up pre-tierity. No, I want to get into singing of the hymn and let the the the instrumental Prelude leading into it helped me to get ready to sing what I already know what it is and already had my hymn open to one Announcements. Okay, but three times is a little overkill In that regard. So it's kind of being sensitive to those as I say, there's there's an art to leading worship It's not just a logical checking off of a list of we did all the ingredients But it's it's thinking through and praying through and to me right now I lead worship once Once a month a chest of your press during church standing with three other singers and instrumentalists in the band and all that sort of thing and They either have an elder or me or an assistant pastor who are Part of the singing worship team that also leads the elements of worship up until the time of the sermon and There's there's not much time to say much. I know that any given Sunday. I have maybe three moments in the first 30 minutes of the service to sort of spend carefully in What I pray or a scripture illusion leading into a song or something that I may say introducing something so I It forces me to be very strategic about the words that I use Partly because I'm not in charge in one sense I'm under the oversight of the of the elders and pastors of that church and and they've got the larger rest of the service planned out and so in this first 30 minutes. I'm going to do a welcome. I'm going to give a brief prayer and maybe more like I have five minutes, but and I'm going to decide between which of the three or four songs we're singing one after another that carry some of the elements I'm going to name something or pray again or say something and so it forces me to do what I instruct the students to do all the time Which is this more is less with the rubrics the connecting words And that's one of the things when you write your worship paper. I'll be looking for those rubrics and How do you do this if I've got a page between you know inner if I've got a whole page with four paragraphs introducing a hymn I'm probably going to say that's a few too many words introducing that hymn So you just sort of have to and a lot of that the context is important and The whole it's sort of knowing what the plan is for this particular Sunday morning and Sort of like if the if the preacher Doesn't take it in it. It's a church. It doesn't have a Lord suffer every week And this is a Sunday after what's up when there's no more time a lot in for it and that's a battle you're going to have to win another time then What's going to be if you're so driven by I must have my 30 minutes to preach? Then you may rush through the Lord suffer in a way that would be less and fully edifying to the congregation And so you say okay on a Sunday that I have this Maybe I should pair back five to seven minutes for my 30 minutes sermon and let it flow into and sort of continue into The celebration of the Lord suffer or if we have a baptism In a given service now. I'd like to think that most people will be understanding of extending the service a little bit If you have some things that aren't normally there But some people where they are in their own understanding of what their Lord's day should be like aren't very understanding about extending past sort of a deadline Moment and so sometimes you have to make adjustments Or you have you thought you could deliver this sermon in 30 minutes, but You're just getting into second of three points and you're already at minute 26 I mean, that's partly why we time you in homiletics classes to it's not because we don't ever want you to take the freedom to preach longer But it's because we want you to be able to learn how to Sort of pace and say what's most important Which I mean every past rest will leave some things in the office That don't get into the sermon and sometimes you have to leave some things in the manuscript of the outline That's right there in the pulpit with you. They don't get sent And it's partly That's why the preacher has to understand even if you're only preaching and not leading anything else the rest of the dynamics in the service and Interact with it and know how you're serving the other elements of your sermon and the other elements are serving you and together You're serving the gospel purposes of the entire service So there there's an art to this and you learn it and you you You Become a student of how other people I mean, I think when you get a chance to what one of the things that Claudia is doing now trying to set the little sort of worship resource Center and student services Is she sent out to this worship reformation network? You know give us some copies of your bulletin as most to see what you do Graphically with the bulletin but also samples of lots of different worship services that you can kind of look through and learn from in that regard We're students to come to chapel regularly partly to observe how you put worship services together Pay attention to local church you're in or maybe in a church it doesn't have an evening service And you can get out and around to some other churches that they're evening services without just being a church hopper all the time So I think there are ways to kind of study and learn and observe and listen and read and and You know that sort of thing church as I pastored I had certain people that when they were away They would always bring me a bulletin from the church that they visited partly I think want me to know they actually did go to church When they were on vacation partly to say they would say you know the church we attended They did this which we found were very helpful And encouraging and you might want to consider I mean that's I would regularly encourage people to give me worship ideas While saying I'm not going to be able to incorporate all of these ideas But I'd rather have you give them to me and me decide not to use them Then to miss some gems that may be out there that have they come to your heart and mind In that regard or to encourage people if you do have a time for a testimony for example To come and talk to you if they'd like to do this Not just assume that The elders know everything's happening in everybody's life To know well this person may be the first to get attention on that so And I think the other thing is that we need to

When we're leading a worship service we need to to seek to freshly engage the congregation in this next element That's progression progressing through the service

And And part of that is just sort of the the manner and tone that you set As you lead into that or with the word you if you're going into singing a song of LeMander praying a prayer confession It's appropriate to Have the tone of your comments be sort of penitent and humble and reflective

If you're singing The doxology after you've pronounced that In Christ our sins are forgiven It's fine to say let's stand and from the depths of our hearts give Loud praise to God as we sing the doxology for what he's done for us in Christ That engages them in what could be just a routine while now we sing the doxology every week So to think through without saying You didn't sing that well. We're going to do it again and get it right this time I mean there's a there's sort of a beating of the sheep attitude that you don't want to Get into either It's not like you're at boot camp. All right

um If you're gonna do something like they might say you know I just want to congregation to know that I really didn't sing that for my heart with any conscious singing about Oh, we just sang it for my sake. Could we sing that again and really pay attention to the words sometimes One time I said I'm going to tie them with a sermon. We're singing it as well with my soul at the end. I said let's think I want you I want the piano player to play through the whole hand. I want you to sort of look at the words and meditate on and if these words express what's in your heart then sing them if not continue to meditate and ask God to make these words be you know, whatever. I mean there are times you can do things that can be challenging and exhortative not saying that you need to do it in a way that um kind of fits um at that point I think fixed forms if that's the kind of way your preferences or the churches you go to um that there should be At least if you always say the Lord's Prayer maybe occasionally sing it If you always do the apostles' creed maybe occasionally do the nice singing creed just some things that um can maybe rotate in that fill that slot We always need to have a creed here Or do the idea of the Colossians one I believe Jesus Christ is the image of the invisible God and so on so forth kind of break up the potential repetitive routine We go through it without thinking about what we're doing and saying kinds of things um And if you're in a church that changes things frequently from week to week um You don't want to have such radical change every week that people have no idea that they're more concerned about What to do next Then they are being engaged in the element of worship now. I think you can train people to Just kind of come into God's presence and be led by those who are leading and Not be too uptight about the fact that the sermons earlier this week in the service And trusting leadership has a purpose for that because they're committed to the gospel shape of the service Which sometimes may mean a sermon earlier for more response time to it after Okay, or even occasionally. I don't think it's unbiblical or wrong to have the Lord suffer prior to the summit Still do the words of institution explain what it means, but it may be that There are things flowing out of the Lord's upper that you want to do and the rest of the service to meet the gospel purposes of that particular service Now a lot of places don't afford that much Change from week to week Um, and I think you you need to have some sort of routines that people settled into that are Sort of places to hang their hats and then within that you can You can vary as you go, but there's a lot of place specific Issues that will determine that in that regard um I think your own personal presentation while leading worship is important Again, we are whole beings What I'm doing If I'm sitting if I'm going to be the preacher and Eric's leading the worship service and I'm During the singing of a hymn or During some comments that he's making leading into something if I'm scribbling on my sermon notes That's not really inviting the rest of congregation to be engaging with Eric leading the service at that point

See with your family and If you have to do that you're ready when you get there um So I think minimize distractions one time I I have this tie this red tie that I wear with the blue blazer blue suit sometimes it has kangaroos Holding tennis rackets One of those Brooks brothers ties that had kind of They had a series of them like that and the first Sunday I wore that tie Somebody met me at the door and they came up to this is what they did It's like the whole service. I like to think about what in the world is on that guy's tie Is it oh, I see what's on your tie now. So every time I've worn that thereafter Which hasn't been all that often I said oh by the way this morning during the announcement time or whatever time it's appropriate Just for those of you are wondering these are kangaroos with tennis rackets on my tie probably on of the Australian open and tennis or something like that Now please pay attention to the reading and preaching the order, you know sort of What are the distractions? You know, I mean if you've got um You should probably pass by a mirror before you go up to lead worship and preach just to make sure, you know, you don't have You know hair sticking up like like Eric does all the time sort of things You know and the yeah, I tend to get sort of shiny a shiny nose over time and it's something morning into kind of you know Do this every once in a while kind of It seems silly, but it is Important that you don't be a distraction um this whole facial What does my what comes through the most in terms of tone and emotion and attitude is largely through our face and that's sort of the way God made us um, and I can reflect joy or sadness or boredom or enthusiasm or wide range of emotions that I think my face should match what's appropriate at that point in the service um I People say if you don't have joy in your heart, it's hypocritical to smile

would it also and I agree? Would it also be hypocritical if you have joy in your heart and you don't smile

Um, we talk a lot about joy in our heart that sometimes doesn't get reflected in our face, I think um, in that regard so I think that That to try to have an integrity in the way you present yourself With Attentiveness to what's happening in the service um, I remember one as we were trying I was Trying to help the congregation understand the value of more frequent observance of the Lord suffer over a several year period of time in a church I served And what I decided to do one year kind of for that reason but also Every year around Christmas time I always get sort of frustrated With the focus on sort of the commercialization of Christmas in our culture I don't quite go the bar humbug route completely But uh, I tend to lean that way um And so I decided one Christmas I talked with the elders and they thought it was a good idea To say let's celebrate the Lord suffer every Sunday and Advent and on Christmas Eve So there's December five Five celebration of the Lord suffering December Why because what better way could there be to keep the focus on why God is send his son in the world to be born in Bethlehem than to keep the cross Representative in the in the Lord suffer in front of us and oh by the way It might give the people an idea of what to be like that weekly communion too um And so in that context as I said, I think previously in the classic that they're different aspects you can bring out. I remember one time I just I just was led in the moment to say As we're about to receive the bread in the cup after properly confessing our sins and reading the words of institution and having a right sort of reverence before God and coming to his table saying Isn't it interesting that we put here the celebration of the Lord suffer But sometimes I feel like it's really Now needs to be reverent, but I think it's okay At this moment in this service third weekend Advent For us to celebrate the Lord suffer and I'd like to encourage you at this moment to smile with me What a privilege it is to come to the Lord suffer So I call for a congregational smile. I mean, I'm sort of weird at one level But I think it it was fitting to remember We are celebrating something that very series of cost God's only son His life on the cross taking our sin upon him, but we're celebrating that on the other side of that He's risen and with us and feeding us It's a banquet table or at least the The appetizer toward it Okay, and we can be we can be joyful in the presence of Christ he's not on the cross right now. He's he's he's enjoying. He's delighting in us Let's us delight in him In that way now I My family tells me that even when I'm happy I don't often look happy Okay, then I kind of have this Scowl on my face sometimes, okay? And I sort of have to remind myself to sort of work on that now three years ago I joined a 150-man Barbershop chorus in St. Charles near St. Louis here um, and we sang a wide range of songs in the Barbershop style and there are three auditions one is You have to be able to sing your part on this Barbershop song called I'd love to live in love land with a girl like you Okay, and you sing with three other really good singers that sing the other three parts and your judge whether or not you can stay on pitch acapella and You know singing a way that blends with the other people Okay, if you pass that then you get to join us on the risers for rehearsals Okay, and then you have the second audition you have to tape yourself into you know um Recording device While the rest of the course is singing you have to be note and word perfect and blend with the rest of the singers well enough that they say you can now perform with us when we have Shows and concerts and so well I I tried out as a lead and I couldn't sustain the high notes softly long enough so I ended up qualifying to be in the course as a base Okay, but there's a third audition you have to pass and it's called presentation um, can you Say we do these mini choreography things if you're in the front line you do a lot which I will never be um, but you know we do some moving around and different things and so forth But but also the main thing is can you with your face express emotion Because when you sing correctly in acapella singing you have to have what they call tall vowels So that the shape of your mouth is usually um Vertical and not horizontal if you're smiling then your notes don't come out right or your vowel sounds don't come in unison with everybody else So you have to learn how to smile from here up Okay, um with your eyes and with your eyebrows and you know it it feels like I'm way over the top silly stupid looking And even then I'm only beginning to approximate approximate what is a proper expression of emotion um with this part of my face So anyway, I I'm pretty self-conscious about that. I'm working on and I look at some of the guys who are going You know, they're doing all these weird sort of things like I will never do that You want to sing in this course? You know um So the guy who judges us on that how do you they go out and stand and watch us while we're practicing He came up to me to break you say mark He knew I was a pastor and a professor at the seminarian's zone He said mark you're one of my dimmer lights Said and I thought in the line of work you were in This wouldn't be a problem I said well that may be true for most people who do what I do, but you have to remember I'm a Presbyterian

Now my you all appreciate that more than he did I think but he he got it enough So anyway, I've been trying to You know to incorporate this into my up front not not that I'm putting on a barber shop face Okay, but at least this sort of integrity of heart and face That I mean that that's what people see um And they I mean, you know when Zach S. Y. Preaches and he comes over here and he's looking right at Eric You know for a moment of his sermon and you know with an expression on his face it's sort of like okay If I wasn't paying attention. I better now he's drawing me in okay And that regard and sometimes you know the kind of the the twinkle in the eye and Even though people in the back row may not be able to see that there's a there's a man or a way that you carry yourself It isn't the heart of worship, but should be an expression of the heart of worship Okay, I'm not talking about gimmicks that will make people be engaged So you don't have a gospel message to give doesn't matter how involved and Wonderful. You're looking and trying to engage people these these are just then gimmicks rather than an attempt to have integrity of heart and body I guess is what I'm what I'm after them. Okay And and we're a model of things that I remembered Zachis when I had a long discussion the way back from a Presbyterian meeting in Indiana one time about the appropriateness of kneeling in worship and whether or not we should encourage that sometime in a chapel service um and what prompted the the discussion Not whether we should encourage it, but whether we ourselves should do it to model it because it was a preaching lecture series with the guy from California um, and we had to have an evening services part of that and so Because of the schedule and so Zach was leading worship and I was helping to lead music vocally and the preacher was preaching and at a time of prayer is that a prayer of confession Zach said if any of you would like to come down here where there's room to and kneel during this prayer feel free to come but Zach didn't go and I didn't go and no one else left And so we talked about maybe the way to to do that in the future is for Zach to say um During this prayer of confession Mark and I are going to go down and kneel and if any of you want to join us during that time feel free to if not that's fine too Okay, now there may still not have been anybody come But there's a big difference between the leadership actually modeling something that you're encouraging people to consider and just sort of Sort of calling it that way So just some things to think about as you look at Jack um The authority oversight and accountability for worship. I believe is lies with the elders the spiritual overseers of the church um They may delegate that authority to particular people But they shouldn't abdicate the overseeing responsibility Uh the great Presbyterian verse 1st group is 1440 all things must be done decently in an order um You hear that quoted a lot in our circles

Is a fundamental biblical principle And again, it's in this context of I think abuses in the Corinthian church of disorderly worship And that's why I'm saying well if people are going to come and And uh Give word of prophecy or tongues interpret and so on in that context at that time. It should only be two or three and You know, he's he's sort of ordering Um, what seemed to have gotten to be an out of order even the passage I read from verse 1526 Which is inviting People to participate Um after 26 Um, if anyone speaks in a tongue two or at the most three should speak one at a time someone must interpret it If there's interpret no interpret it speakers should keep quiet in the church Speak to himself two or three prophets should speak and the others should wake carefully what is said For revelation comes to one who's sitting down the first speaker should stop Um, you know, he's he's ordering What he's calling for It's interesting to me that he doesn't fall into this problem that we've discussed earlier that we often fall into if the inviting of people to participate in worship in this way like 1 Corinthians 1426 has led to disorder Then maybe we should stop inviting anybody that it's all the disorder wouldn't But no he's saying it's important to invite people to participate And the way we correct disorder is not to deny participation But to bring order to disorder and I think that's a helpful way to look at We sometimes overreact to things that aren't done right To make sure it would never be done that way again Now the situation of some people say mark I can't believe that you would invite men, women, and children to pray prayers If thanks giving openly the congregation What if somebody praise uh, an unbiblical Theologically Heretical prayer what would you do? Or what if you invite somebody to give a testimony and they say something that's just contrary to To what the Bible says Well, I think that's why we're elders Now I think there are things you can do in advance for testimonies if you're Wanting to be sure and I think it's an appropriate thing to say we like you to give a testimony. Can you maybe give us If some churches say we want you to give a testimony we want you to write it out so we can sort of see and help you Make sure it's timely and all that. I don't necessarily feel that has to be done. It could be something we've done but um I think you have In order to Encourage appropriate Edification of the congregation by people in the congregation it has attached to a risk That something could happen that would be inappropriate And in that I think out of the fear of what I would do if something inappropriate happens I've sometimes totally squelched The possibility of appropriate things Um, and I need to be enough of a leader to be bold enough You know, if Eric gets up and gives a testimony and he says Something that seems to imply that Jesus wasn't fully human um Then and I'm sure that it was just sort of the nervousness of the moment and he said something I may just you know Thank you for sharing what you did Eric and just for clarification I'm sure what Eric meant when he said this was this if it's a big enough thing Most of those things is more a matter of maybe a private conversation with Eric afterwards For sort of future reference One thing I've seen churches do I remember at Chesterfield we all got these little wristbands praying for different Unchurched youth that we're going on a week-long trip retreat Hoping and praying that they might come to know Christ and so on and Sure enough God worked and some came to know Christ and they come back to worship the next week and here's this You know 16-year-old teenage girl that's become a Christian within the last week that the youth pastor decides People have been praying for her. Let's report back by letting her tell what God has done in their life Now what's the risk of her saying something that might not be biblically sound Pretty high Okay, but what's the blessing of having people afraid for this girl knowing that she's come to Christ and she's telling us she has Wow, that's pretty high too, so what do I do Well Mark Davis who was a youth pastor at the time interviewed her He's got a mic. She's got a mic. Doesn't say here's the mic. Say what you want It's saying tell us a little bit about who you are and You know what happened in the retreat this week if she stumbles a little bit and gets nervous She can sort of ask leading questions and helper to say what he already knows she wants to say and she says something is not you know exactly Clear and I remember her saying something about one of the volunteer helpers you know was Just really paid a lot of attention to her she said in a way that some people in the congregation I thought but here's this guy leader paying a lot of attention to this teenage girl could that be a bad thing Okay, I don't remember exactly what Mark said, but But he said it you know something like isn't it a blessing to have people who are willing to volunteer with the youth group that can invest one or one time with people In the larger context of a retreat or something like that so it was it was Kind of heading off at the pass of potential direction that it may I mean she really thought this guy was cool and it was sort of that was that was part of what God probably used to bring her to himself but it been in a way that it was a little bit over the top of appropriate decorum and Sunday morning that many make people think things they shouldn't think

So you know that that interviewing that interview testimony can be a very effective way of not giving up the con To somebody that you aren't yet ready to trust but still letting what they have to say be a blessing So to think creatively about things that can happen and be willing to be bold and say things um Not to say hurtful things To people you've got to scoot up in that testimony. I can't believe you said that. I mean obviously you wouldn't do that You shouldn't do that and a lot of helping people grow is more a private conversation after After something I mean I remember a guy praying one time thanking God that he was on the president Okay, well okay Um We know what he meant. We didn't have to oh no, no, he didn't mean that you know Do I interrupt as a preacher and say that was a bad prayer he meant on the president or Let's turn to this handout on women um I guess they don't have a number on but it's in your attachment It says chapel at covenant seminary says PT 330 Christian worships summer access 06 Anyway When I first came to covenant seminary Dr. chapel asked me to work on um a policy For what women should be able to do or not do uh in a chapel service by way of leadership and It was a time in the denomination and still is in the denomination where this is a very controversial subject So as a denominational seminary we need to be uh careful and thorough and biblical and in what we do so um One of the things that we determined was that chapel at covenant seminary though it is analogous to worship services in a local church. It's not the same as that. It's a chapel service. It's not a Sunday morning corporate worship service Women in worship um What I did and pretty much the first To this took the first two years I was here. I mean I did other things I work on this policy, but um I tried to get input from Faculty we talked about in a couple of faculty meetings and and so on but Let me just kind of walk through this and then questions you have um We can uh We can talk about There are times that chapel services at covenant seminary or are more like A Wednesday night service or a Sunday school service. You know, we have the archeology chapel Which tends not to be like a Sunday morning worship service but more informational teaching time and so on but when um worship services uh Are of chapel services our worship services? We we try to To form out and and follow them like we would in a local church uh over arching biblical principles the bible speaks Primarily to human persons made in God's image More than it does to men's specific female specific I think this is important to remember there are some specifics to men or women More to husbands and wives and anything else But we're creating a God's image male and female and usually when God addresses people made this image He addresses men and women together made in his image and sometimes in our Desire to have kind of gender specific ministries in the church, which I think are appropriate I think we may be a lost sight of Most of the biblical instruction is given to image bears of God as image bears of God human persons There aren't They aren't separate species Called male and female It's gender within image bears And men and women alike are called to holiness love and Christ's likeness And the diversity of male and female is placed within the unity of human persons I mean, this is sort of a obvious thing That sometimes when we talk about male and female issues we tend to forget I think The biblical structure which I believe is there Is to serve the unity and oneness of the body of Christ So in other words The Bible does affirm gender-based structure and office in the home in the church But the purpose of those who are put in a position of leadership and authority like husbands and elders Is to serve the families and the churches So in the marked Dalby family Uh, Beth, Stephen, Kristen and Eric don't exist to keep propped up my headship That's not the purpose of headship that the whole family would keep Reminding itself every moment every day that I'm the head of the home The purpose of headship is meant to be a gift a leadership gift to serve the family And likewise with elders in the church Church doesn't exist to keep male elders feeling good about being in charge God puts male, qualified, male elders in charge to serve the church well uh, in gospel-based, shepherding ministry um Men and women are equal before God in the following ways made in God's image Fallen redeemed in Christ Ended well by the Holy Spirit Adopted as children and join airs with Christ and gifted for the benefit of the church I think We need to start there before we then Distinguish some other things that the scripture does Two important ways men are unique before God are the following The headship role in marriage is given to the husband And the office of elders given to qualified men Set apart by ordination Think the scripture bears that out now not all Bible-believing Christians completely agree with what I've just said but um I think I'm right Um and part of the reason I'm in the pca's because I believe that even though um It was a fairly long and painful journey coming out of another Presbyterian body when I was in seminary to come into the pca A lot of it had to do with this issue which I think the deeper rooted issue At that time was the authority of scripture to speak to issues like this um God's design for the church The body of Christ is to function in mutual submission to Christ the head God has given order and structure for the smooth functioning of the church The distinction between office and gifts is essential to understanding the church In other words, there are people who have gifts that can be Exercised that may not be permitted to hold an office um And we'll see some about um The leadership office of elder is restricted to men Yet women exercise gifts in partnership with men and under the authority of elders

Participation and leadership of women in worship women are not to have teaching authority in church worship Based on first Timothy 2 Women are to participate in exercise gifts in worship The first contains 11 five passage says that Essentially when women pray and prophesy They should have their heads covered and I think that's a that's a wonderful picture Of submission to the authority of those who are in the office of elder while exercising their gifts under that

um The call to silence in first Corinthians 14 that I read earlier in first Timothy 2 Does not mean absolute silence But silence in racial relationship to the speaking and ruling authority of elders If it meant absolute silence and women couldn't sing songs with the congregation and read responsive readings of the congregation pray the Lord's prayer with the congregation It's a certain kind of silence and almost nobody Says that women should be absolutely silent And Paul in in three chapters previously in 11 has said that women are to pray and prophesy with covered heads Now to say women are to be silent Did you forget what he said in chapter 11 or is it a particular kind of being silent When the authoritative judgment of these prophecies Is being determined by the elders of the of the church Women and chapel involvement at covenant seminary The primary leadership of the worship service should be conducted by those holding the office of elder or those preparing for the office of elders part of the training of pastors We basically designate we don't you know, I don't wear a hat that says worship leader when I lead worship Okay But we know who the worship leader is of a given worship service in chapel. Usually it's made but not obvious um We believe the one who it has sort of the and that's the one that in a church would have sort of the delegated authority of the session to be the overseer of that worship service and I think it should be an elder Or in the case of seminary students one training to be one Or in the local church one training to be one could be two Um, the preaching of the word should be presented by those holding the office of elder or those preparing for the office of elder as part of the training of pastors So when we have a sermon in chapel Which isn't every single chapel, but it is most of them It's given by an elder A faculty member who's a teaching elder in a PCA or a guest missionary or pastor Um, who's a teaching elder in the PCA or a senior student that's been selected by their fellow students to be one of the senior preachers One training to be an elder Since women are instructed regarding the manner of praying and prophesying in first countries levied by the command of silence Cannot mean absolute silence just covered that D female participation in the corporate unison or responsive congregational voice in prayer song in scripture reading Should be encouraged and expected So women present when we're singing a song we expect them to sing not to be silent except um Female participation in a single voice in prayer song and scripture reading Other than the reading directly related to the preaching of the word Is appropriate under the authoritative worship leadership of elders So I believe that if so I'm the worship leader um eric preaching and um Jen Sanders trips wife has been asked to lead in prayer. I think that's okay um Or to read a scripture passage or to give a testimony or to sing a solo um She's not usurping his preaching or my overseeing of worship She's exercising a gift under the oversight for the edification of the church

The reason I say other than the reading directly related to preaching the word I I wouldn't say that's an absolute mandate of scripture As much as it seems to make sense particularly in the chappelle and way that we do preaching around here Where you given you know a human that human interest account before while you're having people look up the scripture You've already started into your preaching Before you ever read the scripture passage usually And the time together of the passage being preached on authoritatively by an elder and the reading of that passage And most people's mind is so closely linked that we feel it's It's potentially unnecessarily offensive to some To have a woman read that passage Okay, because you have to realize a different people are going to come down different places of application here And so that's what we've decided to make our practice. We're not saying this is a hard and fast biblical rule for everywhere in all time Other types of single voice speaking by women or non elder men beyond song prayer and scripture reading should be limited to the giving of testimony sharing and curaging and Occasional presenting a biblical principles for godly living in an area of one's personal expertise when it meets a particular need of the covenant seminary community And how long took us to craft that sense um a while basically what we're saying is that there are people let's go to a male archaeology speaker Okay, they have he's not an elder But in the archaeology chapel he has something to offer out of his expertise uh, to the seminary community or eat of shaffer has spoken in chapel before uh, Susan Hunt who worked with women's ministries uh, Diane Langberg who's done counseling ministries um Not a lot Probably in the last three years we've maybe only had two or three women speaking chapel and some of those have sort of an interview for mattes rather than standing in front of the pulpit and speaking um, in that regard but there We have things that and in most local churches that would be something that maybe the woman would give a three-minute testimony and then lead a combined adult Sunday school class in the same day um Part of it's the chapel dynamic of This is this this is our uh All campus Sunday school class in the same way it's as our all campus uh, you know Gathering in that way now ministry lunches Sort of had begun to fill some of that role and give other other venues than the chapel service For some things we do with that The type of speaking in effabub should not be presented with the authority of the office of elder but under the authority of elder leadership um Female participation in e and effabub should be implemented with sensitivity to brothers and sisters who may apply biblical principles differently As the denominational seminary must be sensitive to those who may disagree Without stifling the participation of women and non elder men in chapel worship services and that's a That's a fine line sometimes knowing knowing what to do So conclusions women may individually pray sing and re-scripture a covenant chapel worship services under the official worship leadership Women may make announcements give testimonies present mission moments at covenant chapel worship services And on occasion women and non elder men may be asked to present biblical principles for godly living in an area One's personal expertise when it meets a particular need of the covenant similar community So long as it is clearly under the authority of the administrative leadership in the seminary with direct oversight exercise through The deans students should be neat so um That's sort of where we where we come out on that um We we probably um Guess in my seven years here we probably had women students give testimonies I don't know 10 to 15 times once or twice a year had women pray um Give sort of mission moments of times and a few women have been speakers in chapel under this sort of expertise Christine pole from asbury seminary. It's written a book called making room on hospitality. She was a shaffer lecturer and we had her Talk in a in a chapel on hospitality. It's an area of her expertise that is an important Uh, she's an important voice in that That our seminary can benefit from And so to have her come and do that she wasn't preaching Um, but she was she was giving a talk About that area that she has invested much of her life in in study and research and practice and so Including some time at library, which was a nice connection to the shape of that Okay thoughts on that questions on that

How do we? Is this a okay time ask box suddenly school The dynamics sure if you'd like How do you can help us think about other venues for teaching? Yeah, I think We did have a shaffer lecture series which you can get I think uh from the minister resource page uh of the seminary Where Dan Dorianne and some others spoke on the whole issue of women in the church And then the next year we had women in society with some other speakers um But I think that uh and dr. Dorianne's book What is it called? Women in ministry maybe Addresses some of these things um To me, I think The issue is authoritative teaching From the first to the two passage that I think is connected to the office of elder I think primarily women are not to hold the office of elder Because inherent in the office is the authoritative Is the teaching authority in the church Under that teaching authority People's gifts can be utilized and exercise for the edification of the church. I think preaching in a worship service It is so close to de facto teaching authorities stamp upon it But a woman out not to preach in the worship service Can she teach a Sunday school class with men present that's usually the way the question gets asked um I some people would say no never um And jerem actually tells a story of an experience of somebody that that he knows who uh was teaching a group of women in a In a church and one of the husbands came to pick up a little early to pick up his wife and sat in the back row and the upfront woman quit speaking because a man was present Okay, that would be sort of an extreme view on one side um Which I don't think is consistent with their local teaching um But if it was all the husbands and wives were there could the woman uh Teach Well, I think as long as it's clearly there with the stamp of approval of the elders And she has particular giftedness at teaching and Theologically sound the same way you would have any non-elder man Potentially teach. I think the standards are essentially the same Now dr. Doriani argues that If she teaches an adult Sunday school class year after year or for a certain amount of time It begins to have the stamp of inherent authority And then he would say it should be for a limited time Whereas another woman on the panel uh during that uh lecture series Said well in my church the elder their elders present and You know, it's it's not viewed that I have the authority the office of elder when I teach sort of things So there's a range of views I tend to lean Tor dr. Doriani side but not in any sort of legalistic time frame way That I think you almost have to decide in case by case sort of sort of basis um In terms of the the context of the congregation the attitude of the woman teaching the benefit of the congregation Shouldn't elder be teaching in a class instead of either a woman or a non-elder man You know, I think there's a lot of

Husband wife teams teaching is another way that that you can bring in the expertise And personal life experience of a woman When they teach it as a team

There's a difference in the authority taking a brought out in the preaching from Teaching in the Sunday school. I think preaching there's a lot of overlap between preaching and teaching And I think they are distinguishable also and I think the uh the

The element of the preaching of the word is is a vital part of Of the worship corporate worship service and I think one holding the office of elder Almost always and I guess I can envision a rare exception And sometimes those exceptions are in place, so there is no one present who is able or gifted or ordained And it may be that the only you know it's like an omission field situation only person that Has a bible and understands and is able to teach In even a worship setting may be a theologically trained Covenant seminary drive, you know with the with the masters of one kind or another in that setting And I think that that's sort of like that ordinarily A pastor should be present for the administration of Lord suffer, but I can envision times that it would be better to have the Lord suffer So it's a ordinarily it should be um an elder But at times there may be a non elder man or a woman who is the only one present who has the ability and the gifts And the knowledge to be able to teach and instruct And in those extraordinary cases I think the edification from the word would be more important than having someone who holds the office of elder But you don't make an a rule a rule from the exception You know it as an exception in that way So I can envision places in the advancing of the gospel Where it may be necessary and right and good and praise god there is somebody there who can open the word and proclaim your gospel To a people who desperately need it I'm or a man who's not an elder that's I kind of think I see women and non elder men in sort of the same category In that regard That could meet a need in the moment where there's no elder present

Okay, I think it's lunchtime