<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Tulong Tulong a Bulbulan

The Sacraments

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Well, we're coming to the end of a long road, and almost to the end of the institutes, you can take a certain amount of pride, I would think, in knowing that you've read through most of this. Not every last word has been assigned, and maybe someday you'll want to read the rest of it, but not many people actually read through all of the institutes, not many Presbyterian ministers have read through all of the institutes because I've asked them, and they say, well, I've got that on my plans to someday read through the whole of the institutes. I think people read parts of the institutes fairly frequently, but to just go through it all, or almost all of it, is unusual, and an accomplishment. So, congratulations, we'll have one last time on Thursday looking at the last chapter, Calvin's treatment of civil government, all of the book fours, you know, has to do with the church down through chapter 19, and then chapter 20, the last chapter, has to do with civil government. Quite a large section of the institutes in book four has to do with the sacraments, beginning with chapter 14, and going through chapter 19, Calvin's treatment of sacraments in general, in baptism, then the Lord's Supper, and then his reputation of the Roman Catholic Mass, and then his reputation of the five other so-called false sacraments of the Roman Catholic Church. So, today we'll look at sacraments. This is going to be pretty brief because Calvin goes into a lot of detail here, and I need to keep my remarks brief in order to get a general idea of what Calvin is dealing with in these chapters, but we'll have a go at it and see what happens. Let's pray. Words of John Calvin, grant Almighty God that as you have in various ways testified and daily also prove how dear and precious to you is humanity as we enjoy daily, so many and so remarkable, proofs of your goodness in favor, O grant that we learn to rely wholly on your goodness, so many examples of which you set before us and which you would have us continually to experience, that we may not only pass through our earthly course, but also confidently aspire to the hope of that blessed and celestial life which is laid up for us in heaven through Christ alone our Lord, amen. Calvin's teaching on the sacraments heavily shaped by Augustine, we expect that sort of thing now because almost all of Calvin is heavily shaped by Augustine, but also influenced by Buu Sir, man with whom he worked for three years in Strasbourg, influenced by Luther, and to a certain degree influenced by Zwingli, but certainly stamp with Calvin's on originality and with his own way of putting together the various ideas that he sets forth in these chapters on the sacraments. His definition, he does give several, I will use one that's found in 414-1, it's a kind of expansion, he says of Augustine's short definition that a sacrament is a visible form of an invisible grace, Calvin says that by an idea, the sacrament is a visible form of an invisible grace, but Calvin thinks that is too brief and even though it's right and good, it needs to be developed a little further, so one of his definitions is this, an outward sign by which the Lord seals on our consciences, the promises of his good will toward us in order to sustain the weakness of our faith, and we in turn attest our piety toward him in the presence of the Lord and of his angels and before men, so let's take that definition and work with it for a bit. You'll notice that in the very first synods of chapter 14, Calvin says, we have in the sacraments another aid to our faith related to the preaching of the gospel. So he links immediately the sacraments to the preaching of the gospel. The sacraments can never stand alone apart from the word. Preaching is aid to our faith and we have discussed that as one of the true marks of the church, and another aid to our faith is the sacraments and the sacraments are related to the preaching of the gospel. Calvin's definition he begins with the idea of an outward sign. Remember book four deals with the external means that God uses to invite us into the Society of Christ and to hold us therein. Book three he's discussed in great detail those internal operations of the Holy Spirit and now in book four he discusses the role of the church, the place of the sacraments, the function of the civil government as external means of blessing that God gives to us. So the sacraments, two of course, baptism in the Lord's Supper in Calvin's view are outward signs. Why does God give us these outward signs? Calvin says God gives us these outward signs because of the weakness of our faith. These signs are for our benefit to help to nourish and encourage our faith by the sacraments God provides first for our ignorance and dullness and then for our weakness. So having heard the word preached, we still need something else, we need something more not different and not separate from the word but something to nourish, encourage, strengthen aid us in accepting the promise, believing the promise and being assured by the promise that we hear in the word and the sacraments function then in that way. Calvin says that God condescends to lead us to Himself by these earthly elements. It's not that the word is weak and something else has to be added because the word is not sufficient, the word is sufficient, all sufficient, powerful but we're weak, it's not that the word is weak but Calvin says it's because we are weak, we need these aids, these external outward helps and secondly Calvin says we have these outward signs because we cannot be welded together unless we're bound in some partnership of signs or visible sacraments. So for two reasons God gives us these external aids to strengthen our faith, to encourage us, to assure us and then to bind us together as one body in Christ, baptism does that, word supper does that. So you see the two functions of the sacraments in Calvin's thought, to encourage, strengthen bless, nourish, feed us spiritually and then to cause us to be welded together in one body. Let's look a little more at what Calvin says about sacraments in general, chapter 14 is sacraments and then chapter 15 and 16 specific application of these ideas to the two sacraments of the Christian Church. The sacrament, Calvin says, is a seal of the promise, promises given to us in the word, we hear it in the preaching of the word, it's the promise of God's mercy toward us in Christ in which our faith rests and the sacrament seals that promise. It's joined to the promise as a sort of appendix, one of Calvin's many images here, you have a book and then you have an appendix and the sacrament is joined to the promise as an appendix is joined to the book. It's not going to tell us something different, it's the same message, it's the same Christ that is being presented both in the word and in the sacrament, but it is joined as a sort of appendix with the purpose of confirming and sealing the promise itself, it just underscores the promise, repeats the promise and as we both, you might say, hear the promise and then see the promise because following a gust in Calvin like to use the idea of the sacrament as a visible word, we have an oral word as we hear the sermon and we have a visible word as we see the water and as we see the bread, as we see the wine and as we participate in the sacraments as we will describe those in a few minutes. The sacrament then is secondary and supplementary, it adds nothing to the promise as such that

preach word is sufficient of itself and the sacrament can never stand by itself. Calvin really felt that the sacrament, the Lord's Supper, should always follow the preaching of the word, ideally. In fact he had hoped in Geneva to have the sacrament of the Lord's Supper celebrated

every Lord's day, but he could not have his way in this. Calvin, even in the church in Geneva, could not always dictate or determine what was going to happen because so much was controlled by the state and he had to settle for monthly communion and then later quarterly communion, but it was Calvin's thought and desire and ideal to have weekly communion. So by the strange that in reformed history, the reformed tradition, when it was free to select the

frequency of the Lord's Supper, tended to follow more of the state requirements than Calvin's own personal ideal, although Presbyterian churches are moving toward more frequent celebration of the Lord's Supper now and in the past. The church in Scotland for instance, it was customary to celebrate the Lord's Supper once a year, and that seems far cry from what Calvin had hoped

would come to pass. But the sacrament for all its importance is secondary and supplementary

it cannot stand by itself, it always must accompany the word, but it is not unimportant

because it does confirm and seal the promise, repeats the word, dramatizes the word, illustrates the word. It was the reasoning behind limiting it to once a month or a month or a year.

Jay's question has to do with why did say the Church of Scotland observe the Lord's Supper so infrequently. I think you need to remember two things once is the church, a local church in Scotland in the post-reformation period generally celebrate the Lord's Supper once a year so it was infrequent, but it was very extensive when it was celebrated. For instance, people would

start meeting early in the week and you have meetings, different services, leading up to a communion Sunday and preparatory service on Friday or Saturday. Communion Sunday would

last all day Sunday and there would be a Thanksgiving service on Monday. So it's like a whole week of services surrounding the actual celebration of the communion on Sunday. And I think with the amount of effort and time it went into that, churches tended to do it only once a year.

I should say too, though, that people in Scotland received the Lord's Supper more than once a year because these communion occasions were popular and visitors and other churches would come. So even though you would have the Lord's Supper celebrated in your own church only once a year, you could go to a dozen neighboring churches and receive the Lord's Supper during their communion occasions. I think the infrequency was a problem, but the emphasis on preparation was a good thing. We tend to be able to celebrate the Lord's Supper more frequently today, but we don't have the similar emphasis on preparation. I've heard some people express concern for weekly and second months because it would be coming to routine and common for pastors and churches that do that. What is the experience and what can pastors and elders do to retain the significance of that weekly? The question is, if we have the Lord's Supper every week, is Calvin wanted to, does it not become too routine and too common? I suppose it could, but it's almost like saying if you preach

the gospel every week, it's going to become too routine and too common. To put it in a analogy, I think we would say something, I would say something like this, the gospel is very good

news, so is the message of the sacraments. Really, good news doesn't become routine and common.

If you have, somebody is telling you, really, good news. You've inherited a million dollars. You don't get tired of hearing that. You want to hear it over and over again. Be sure it's true, be assured of it. But I think ministers and elders do have a responsibility to find ways to preach and teach and administer the sacraments that do bring fresh ideas and renewed assurance and confidence.

In the service itself, there has to be a sense of the wonder of what we're doing. In one way to avoid a kind of a routineness and dullness is just read through Calvin again. When he gets into describing the Lord's Supper, he reaches a point of almost, I think, we would say ecstasy. Then he finally says, after he has worked at it for a long, long time, still don't completely

understand it, but I'd rather experience it than understand it. So there's something wonderful

about it in Calvin's experience and in his teaching. Yes, seal of the promise sacraments of Seal of the promise, sacraments of visible words, I mentioned that already, and also means of grace. The point here is that for Calvin, the sacraments are not merely signs of grace, but means of grace. In other words, Lord's Supper and the elements in the Lord's Supper and water in baptism and baptism don't merely point to grace but or channels of grace. Instruments of grace means by which God gives unto us grace. God uses the sacraments, Calvin says, to sustain, nourish, confirm, and increase our faith. He nourishes faith spiritually through the sacraments. So as you recalve into these chapters, you get the ideas, certainly, that this is not just a sign. It's more than a sign. That means of grace, not merely a sign of grace. Calvin, on this point, is much closer to Luther than he is to Zwingli. He's concerned about Zwingli's view. He says this teaching that the sacraments are merely signs of grace weakens their force. They're not only signs and confession, but also aids to our faith. So it's not just mental, it's not just thinking something, it's receiving something, or you could say it this way, the sacraments are not just a representation, but also a presentation. It's not Calvin's words, but it's my way of kind of summing up Calvin's thought here. Sacraments are not merely a representation, representing something, but a gift themselves a receiving, not only a showing, but a giving, that's what he means by sacraments as means of grace. But, and this needs to be said too, if he is opposed to Zwingli's views, say Zwingli's memorialism in the Lord's Supper, and we'll talk about that in a few minutes, as being too much a representation, and not a presentation, too much a sign, and not enough of the reality of the gift of grace in the sacrament. He is certainly opposed, on the other hand, to the Roman Catholic view, that the sacraments in and by themselves confer grace. He's God who confers grace, he's the giver of the gift, and if he uses the sacraments, which he has promised to do, then we thank him for it, but the sacraments do not inherently possess the means to nourish and bless, strengthen the Christian, the water, even though Calvin can use the expression occasionally sacred water. He doesn't mean that the water takes on a kind of mystical power in itself, and Calvin certainly doesn't agree with the Roman Catholic view of trans-substantiation, that the elements of the Lord's Supper are trans-substantuated into the flesh and blood, body and blood of Christ, so have in themselves some kind of inherent power. Calvin says this teaching attaches to the sacraments some sort of secret powers, and the sacraments do not promote or confirm faith by themselves, so not merely signs, but not inherently capable of conferring grace by themselves. Yes. You could not make the distinction, the first distinction between a sign and a means without falling into the second problem, if you say it's not a sign, then it has to go as far as the only option that's left is that it actually confers grace. I think that is why Zwingli is concerned to be as far away from Luther as he can because he thinks Luther has gone too far toward the Catholic point of view. There is, however, quite a bit of recent work on Zwingli, that indicates that we may have misunderstood Zwingli somewhat, in other words, Zwingli may not have taught a mere memorial ism. In other words, in the Lord's sufferer, you remember the death of Christ. This new in remembrance of me, that was his text, but that to us sounds quite cerebral, and some scholars think that Zwingli's idea of memory has much more power than the way we use the word memory. I think more needs to be done on Zwingli to see if he is actually closer to Calvin than we think, but Calvin is still, even in 1559, concerned that Zwingli's view is too weak. Calvin and Bullinger do sign the consensus to gorenas, the consensus of Zurich, Bullinger is Zwingli's successor in Zurich, in which the two views, the Zwingli Bullinger view of Lord's sufferer, and the Calvinist view are brought together. The question is, did Calvin compromise there, is it a true meeting of the minds, or is it a kind of papering over the differences, but that consensus resulted in one reform faith rather than two. We have the Lutheran tradition, and we have the reformed tradition. I think if it had not been for the consensus to gorenas, we would have had three Zwingli and Calvinist and Lutheran. I'll say a little bit more about that when we come to the Lord's sufferer itself. Sacraments do not confer grace, nor do they promote or confirm faith by themselves, that there is not inherent in the elements that which can accomplish the work of nourishing us as Catholics taught. The sacraments always work in connection with the word, let the word be added to the element, and it will become a sacrament Calvinist, and always in connection with faith, receiving the sacraments in unbelief, nullifies the value of the sacraments, not the force of the sacraments, the sacraments are still powerful, but the value of the sacraments for the individual is lost if there is not faith. It is understood only by those who take word and sacraments, Calvin says, with sure faith. He has a helpful illustration of this in 1417. You might remember that as the illustration of wine poured over a vessel, but the vessel has no mouth to receive it. It's kind of a jug or a jar without an opening. You pour wine over it, still wine, but it doesn't enter. The vessel in Calvin says the same thing as true when the sacraments are received without faith, they conferred no advantage or profit without being received like faith. And the sacraments work, and this is so important for his view of the sacrament of Lord's Supper in connection with the Holy Spirit. It's the Holy Spirit, as we have seen in book three, who is the agent of our faith, and it's Christian life, and in book four, it's the Holy Spirit who uses these outward means by the Holy Spirit who blesses strengthens and aids us. The sacraments properly fulfill their office, Calvin says, only when the Spirit that inward teacher comes to them. So without the word, without faith, without the Holy Spirit, the sacraments are strong and powerful, but invalid because these three are required. For the sacraments to perform the work that God plans for them to perform. Now all of that has to do with the first part of Calvin's definition. You'll notice that he goes on to say, and we in turn attest our piety toward God. And that was an emphasis that Swingley made very strongly. I'm not sure I want to say that's the primary emphasis in Swingley, but it's certainly a strong emphasis in Swingley that the sacraments are our profession to each other and to the world that we belong to God. It's our baptism for some purpose. It's our badge, our profession, our testimony. And Calvin does include that in this definition, and from time to time mentions that. But I think Calvin's emphasis is far more on the work of the Holy Spirit in using the sacraments to nourish our faith and on our receiving the sacraments to testify to the world and to one another that we are in Christ. But that is a valid idea as well. And so Calvin does come to that in 414, 13, and elsewhere. Okay, let's look at the two sacraments now. Calvin on baptism and Calvin on Lord's Supper, two chapters on baptism. Calvin, so we would expect rejects the Roman Catholic position. That is the baptism. Washes away original sin and regenerates the person that according to Calvin and the Protestants is not the correct view of the Bible. That meant for the Roman Catholics that without baptism there was no salvation. Calvin greatly values baptism and would not for a moment countenance a person ignoring baptism. But he does say this from this sacrament as from all others, that is from the Lord's Supper as well, we obtain only as much as we receive in faith. So baptism is not ex-operato, it's not an automatic means of grace that produces salvation. If faith is not there, then nothing is there as far as we are concerned. And Calvin even goes further, he says, when we cannot receive the sacraments from the church, say hypothetically we're in such a place where there's no church, we're too distant from it, or in times of persecution we're not allowed access to the sacraments. The sacraments, if we cannot receive the sacraments from the church, the grace of God is not so bound to them, but that we may obtain it from faith by the word of the Lord. In other words, we can get the value of the sacraments, baptism, and the Lord's Supper without the sacraments if we are forbidden to have the sacraments. That can never be used as an excuse to ignore the sacraments, that Calvin doesn't tie the two together like the Roman Catholics do without baptism of salvation. Calvin would say in extreme situations, when there is no baptism available, then God's grace can be given directly through the word without the sacraments. So there's no such need in Calvinism for emergency baptisms, took place in Roman Catholic church, maybe being born, and when it seemed likely that the baby would not live more than a few minutes, then anybody could baptize, including the midwife, the Catholic tradition, because of the urgency of applying the water to the baby. If there would be regeneration, but for Calvin there was no emergency. If baptism could not be properly performed, then God is not bound to the sacrament. It might say that we are bound to the sacrament, but God is not, which means we cannot ignore it. We cannot refuse it when it is available, but God's grace is not tied to the sacraments so that it is not available in any other mode, it can be given through the word without the sacrament, if necessary. Calvin's position, over against the Roman Catholic position, is that baptism is not a means by which the inherent value of the water cleanses away sin and regenerates the person. But Calvin, again, as he has already made clear to his chapter on the sacraments, in general that we just looked at, said baptism is more than a token or mark by which we confess our religion before men. It is that, but it is more than that. It is a means of grace instituted by Christ to bestow blessing on the believers. More than a testimony, an actual means by which we receive God's blessing, God's grace, God's assurance. We are strengthened, helped, and assured by our baptism. Luther was so strong on this, and when Luther was being a sail by the devil as he was on the occasion, sometimes his last resort was simply to say, but I have been baptized. That was Luther's rejection of the temptations of the devil. Calvin doesn't say it exactly that way, but he says this in 415-3, therefore, as often as we fall away, we ought to recall the memory of our baptism, fortify our mind with it, that we may always be sure and confident of the forgiveness of our sins. I think this idea of assurance plays a big role here in Calvin's view of baptism. We, times of temptation, times of spiritual dullness, remember that we have been baptized and that gives us hope and encouragement that we can be sure and confident of the forgiveness of sins. Roman Catholic Church, of course, added penits as the second plank. It was called baptism as the first, but the assurance of baptism to be lost by sin and then penits, confession, penits are necessary in order to recover what is lost in baptism. Calvin calls that a fictitious sacrament of penits. It's not needed. We have everything we need of the promise in our baptism. We don't need penits as a kind of follow-up to baptism. Calvin, I won't do too much with these ideas, but Calvin certainly is not a donatist. He doesn't insist that baptism to be valid must be administered by a holy person, by a minister of the gospel. But if that ordained minister is not living the life that he ought to, if there's hypocrisy there or fault there in some way, that does not invalidate the baptism. That's what the donatists, you remember, back in the 4th century. You can think back to ancient and medieval church history taught, but Calvin rejects that. Augustin rejected it, first of all. It was a battle that Augustin was fighting it himself in his own time. Calvin quotes Augustin in his dispute with a donatist, whoever may baptize Christ alone presides. So we don't have to be concerned about the authenticity of the minister, the spirituality of the minister who baptizes. It's 4158, whosoever may baptize Christ alone presides or here's an illustration of the same thing. If a letter is sent, provided the handwriting and seal are sufficiently recognized, it makes no difference who or of what sort the carrier is. We get the letter, we recognize the writing, we know it's authentic and we don't have to worry too much about the postman whether he's a spiritual man or not. He's delivering the letter and the minister is applying the water but it's Christ who presides. For that reason, in Calvin, there's no second baptism. He was even willing to admit that Roman Catholic baptism was valid baptism. Calvin did not require people coming out of the Roman Catholic church into the church in Geneva to be baptized again. His view, baptism in the Trinitarian name was valid whoever administers baptism. As far as mode is concerned, Calvin really wasn't concerned about that. It could be immersion, it could be pouring, it could be sprinkling. These details are of no importance, as long as water is used, Calvin felt that that satisfied the sacrament, although Calvin did hold that the original mode in his view was immersion. The fact that he did not immerse people in Geneva was of no concern to him. The amount of water, the way in which water was administered was incidental to the sacrament. If immersion typifies certain aspects of baptism, sprinkling typifies other aspects of baptism just as validly. For Calvin, that was not an issue. Where does that video refers to? The mode. For 1519, these details are of no importance, once he has listed the different possible modes. For 1519, if you want to go further with that idea, you can also look at the commentary on Acts 8, 38. They both went down into the water, that spill up in the Ethiopian. Calvin says, here we see how the right of baptism was administered long ago. The whole body was immersed in water. It has now become the practice for the minister to sprinkle only the body or the head. The small difference in ceremony, however, ought not to lead us to divide the church or disturb it with strife. It's kind of remarkable state. When you think of the division in the church between Baptist who insists on immersion and others who have other modes, it has divided the church, but for Calvin, it should not. If mode was inconsequential for Calvin, infant baptism was not. Infant baptism was extremely important. In fact, chapter 16, which is his chapter on infant baptism, is longer than chapter 15, which is his chapter on baptism. I think length always means everything, but it does show the concern that Calvin had with infant baptism. His main scriptural basis is unity of the covenants. Calvin thinks that infant baptism protects that teaching, and rejection of infant baptism would destroy that teaching. In the end of Baptist, in order to escape the connection between circumcision and the Old Testament baptism in the New Testament, tried to make the Old Testament as carnal as they possibly could. This was a earthly covenant. This was a political covenant. It was really not a spiritual covenant. And for Calvin, as we know from our earlier study, strongly holds to the unity of the covenants. What the Old Testament teaches so does the New, but the Old Testament displays so does the New. There are sacraments in the Old Testament. We have the same sacraments in the New, and consequently circumcision is linked to baptism, and Calvin over and over again emphasizes that God established a covenant with Abraham, which included children. And there was a sacrament, a mark of that conclusion, which was circumcision. The church is the covenant community now, and children are included in this community as they were included in the Old community. Calvin cannot really conceive that the New Covenant in any way could be less full, less inclusive than the Old. If the Old Covenant promised blessing to the children, then the New Covenant would too. The Old Covenant had a place for the children, and the New Covenant would too. If the Old Covenant had a mark for the children, the New Covenant would too. I think, although Calvin doesn't say this, I think he would think this way. You know, often people will say, well, show me a place, a verse in the New Testament that commands infant baptism. And it's our divine one. We have passage and collotions that seems to link circumcision and baptism, and we have household baptisms, but there are questions about that. But I think Calvin's basic argument here is he doesn't expect a verse to say what has always been done in the plan of God should continue to be done. Because of the linkage of the Old Church and the New Church, the Old Covenant and the New Covenant, he would expect something like this that the children are not to be included. Then there would be a verse in the New Testament that would say, just as you circumcised your children, your male children in the Old Covenant. So now circumcision is changed to baptism, which is the sacrament of initiation, but don't apply it to children anymore. Children for the Old, but not for the New. But there's no indication that the Bible is moving in that direction at all, and Calvin's thought. So children are included. Of course, a child who is baptized, an infant who is baptized, hasn't repented and doesn't have faith. Baptism is into the covenant community. The parents and the church take the vows in the place of the child. And Calvin says, it doesn't mean that there is no repentance in faith, that the child is baptized into the future, repentance in faith. Calvin makes a point that the blessings of the sacrament are not always tied to the moment of the sacrament. So the full blessing of baptism is realized later in the life of the covenant child. Yes. You were making a point about baptism to be valid regardless of food ministries. In a little while ago, you had another pastor made a point that Calvin did not think it valid or appropriate for, so to say midwife to, if it was to be a Catholic church would prove that, how those two things go together. Well, let's see, baptism is valid. Well, you see Calvin in his chapters on officers and ministers of the church has argued that there are certain people who are called to preach the word in administrative sacraments, so they have to be properly called and instituted for that office. So that restricts it right there, midwives are not ordained as ministers. But once you have an ordained minister, then the baptism that he performs is valid, whatever the inner spiritual condition of his heart, if he say hypocrite, or backslidden, it doesn't affect the validity of the baptism. So Calvin does restrict it to ordained officers in the church. Reform tradition has followed him in that, but not all traditions do, of course. Is there another question? Yes. What was the practice required and it looked like it wasn't going to live the on a few days after birth? Was there not for the reasons of the Catholics who were baptized, but would they still apply this right of initiation and do the community even at for a temporary period of time? The question is, in the Reform community, would a baby that seemed to be dying, be baptized? Yes, but was it viewed as an emergency? The baby died almost immediately before the child could be brought to the church and properly baptized. It was not viewed as a disaster. God has his way of reaching people apart from the sacraments, if that is necessary. But not absolutely sure how quickly the Reform church would want to baptize the baby, but babies were baptized early. It was not like a year old, it was weeks old, or a week old, or maybe days old, so all children were baptized very, very early. But if the baby died within a few minutes or an hour or so, it could not be baptized. It was not viewed as a big problem. I heard two students in Concordia discussing this one day when I was over there in the library, and a child of one of these students was to be baptized. The student wanted to wait a week or two so his father or somebody could come but was very disturbed about the idea of waiting a week or two. In case the child might die or something happens, they were going back and forth. Should the child be baptized this Sunday without the father or next Sunday with the father? I thought, well, we don't have to worry too much about that kind of thing at least. And baptized infants as soon as we can, but there's no fear that if the baby should die in the meantime, that all is lost. I baptized my grandson last August. He was about six months old then. He had been scheduled to be baptized in April, but both he and his mother came down with chickenpox. So could not baptize in April when he was three months old. So we had to wait until August. My wife says, if we wait much longer, he'll be believers baptism. She has high regard for his intelligence. Okay, let's look at the Lord's supper now. I know this is going fast through all of this and doesn't answer all your questions about baptism, but at least perhaps gives you the lay of the land as far as Calvin's thinking is concerned. Rejection of the Roman Catholic position. I think we could extend that a bit to point B there. Calvin's position agreed with swingly that after the ascension, Christ retained a real body of flesh and blood located in heaven, but rejected his memorialism. In other words, Calvin says, yes, swingly is right. Christ's body is in one place. It's in heaven. It's not on earth. It's not in the elements. It's in heaven, but he was uncomfortable with the idea that swingly's main concern in the supper seemed to be his saying we do this, not to remember what Christ did for us. We do this in remembrance of him. But Luther had his text too. This is my body. Calvin appreciates both of those texts. We do remember the death of Christ on the cross in the supper, but we also feed upon him here and now, and not just on his spirit or his divinity, but we feed upon his body. We, Calvin, is not hesitant to say we do eat his flesh and we do drink his blood in the Lord's supper. He agreed with Luther that there is a real reception of the body and blood of Christ, just said that. You know, actually on one occasion it was that Raykinsburg, the colloquial Raykinsburg in 1541, Calvin signed the Augsburg confession, which is an amazing thing. With its very Lutheran statement of the Lord's supper, Calvin signed that. Not sure all of his thinking is able to sign the consensus dig arenas, which is on the swingly inside. He is able to sign the Augsburg confession, which is on the Lutheran side. I don't think we would view Calvin as wishy-washy. He never comes across that way or is not being able to make up his mind. But I think what this means to me is that Calvin's view of the Lord's supper is quite subtle and nuanced, and it partakes of much of what Luther says, but he never goes as far as Luther to accept the idea of the ubiquity of the body of Christ. He agrees to swingly there. If Christ's body is ubiquitous, that is, it is everywhere, then it's not a real body. Calvin wants to protect the teaching of Christology and the Council of Calcedon, that the body of Christ is a real body like our bodies. We're not ubiquitous in our bodies, neither is Christ. His body is in one place. It's in heaven, the right hand of the Father. Luther, of course, agreed with that, but to him the right hand of the Father meant everywhere. Where is the right hand of the Father? Luther would say it's everywhere. Where is the right hand of the Father? Calvin would say it's in a definite place in heaven, so the difference comes down to the location of the body of Christ. Calvin said Christ is spiritually present in the Lord's supper, but that is a rather simple way of saying something that is rather complex in Calvin. Maybe the best way for me to talk about this in just a few minutes we have left is to show you some charts that I have drawn up which illustrate the different views and we'll best understand Calvin's view as we contrast it to others. Here's the Catholic view. The Catholic view of course is Transubstantiation, you're familiar with that word, which means that what starts out is bread and wine changes into body and blood of Christ when the priest pronounces the words of the institution. This is my body, this is my blood, and no longer do you have bread and wine, but you have body and blood and when the person receives the sacrament what they receive is not bread and wine, but body and blood. It's the Catholic view, so that reason that you have a reserved sacrament because once a certain amount of bread and wine are changed into the body and blood of Christ then you can't just throw it away. The sacrament is reserved to be used later or to be carried through the streets in the festival of Corpus Christi body of Christ where people actually bow and worship the elements now transubstantiated into body and blood. Just reading last night a little booklet I picked up at a Greek Orthodox Church which actually was arguing for the safety of the common cup as the Orthodox used common cup in an age of age and other fears about transmission of diseases. This was arguing that it was quite safe and nobody has to worry about it. After all it's body and blood of Christ and that's not going to poison you. Another interesting point though that I had not thought about was this that in the Orthodox Church the priest consumes all that's left over. The common cup has been passed around and then whatever is left the priest drinks at all. This little pamphlet was arguing that our priests are quite healthy. But there is the Catholic view. We could look at Zwingli's view this way. The bread and wine remain bread and wine and what the recipient receives is bread and wine. But as the recipient is receiving the elements of Lord suffer he or she is meditating upon the death of Christ. That would be the memorialistic view, memory. This view in memory of me. Well Calvin Felpat was lacking. He rejects the Roman Catholic view as heresy. He rejects Zwingli's view as very weak. It's not that we don't do that, but Calvin thinks there is much more there than he understands Zwingli as having presented. In the consensus of Zegorina Zwingli has moved more toward Calvin. Calvin perhaps moves a bit toward Zwingli but consensus of Zegorina is not the Zwingli and not the traditional Zwingli and you or Calvin could not have signed known to it. Now here is Luther's view. Calvin has a lot of respect for Luther's view but he doesn't embrace it exactly. Luther's view is that you have bread and wine. They remain bread and wine. There is no trans-substantiation. But in with and under the bread and wine is the body and blood of Christ. That was later called cons-substantiation. That was not a term used in Luther's time. But what the recipient receives is all of this. As you eat the bread and wine with your mouth you are also taking into your mouth the body and blood of Christ. So in with and under the bread and the wine or the body and the blood. Calvin did not agree with that because that implies the ubiquity of the body of Christ. The body of Christ is wherever the Lord's Supper is being celebrated. Luther felt the body of Christ was everywhere and that the means by which we had access to the body of Christ is through the Lord's Supper. So body of Christ is present here in this room because Christ is omnipresent. Luther taught in his body as well as in his spirit but we would not have access to the body of Christ unless we're celebrating the Lord's Supper in this room. Calvin's view I've drawn like this. Christ is in heaven. The body of Christ is in heaven. Of course Christ is everywhere because he is God and God is everywhere but the body of Christ is in heaven and it's the body of Christ that we're concerned about in the Lord's Supper. Particularly the Lutherans they felt that the reform just never got around to seeing that we feed on the body of Christ. I'd say the Lutheran said something like this. Talk, talk, talk but not a body in sight. But the body if not in sight was certainly available in Calvin's theology. The body of Christ is in heaven and as the believer on earth receives the Lord's Supper that believer receives the bread and the wine but at the same time the body and blood of Christ because of the work of the Holy Spirit. That's why we call Calvin's view a view of the spiritual presence of Christ. That doesn't mean that Christ is just present in his spirit in the Supper and not in his body but that it's through the work of the Holy Spirit that we are brought into nourishing relationship with the body of Christ. And that works in two ways. The Holy Spirit lifts up our hearts, the so-soom corda, lift up your heart. It's part of the Calvinist liturgy in the Lord's Supper. Holy Spirit lifts up our hearts to unite us with Christ in his fullness including his body in heaven. So we're united to Christ, we feed on Christ, we feed on the body of Christ but the body of Christ is not on earth, it's not in the elements, it is in heaven and it's the work of the Holy Spirit to lift us up so that we are united to Christ and the Spirit not only lifts us up but at the same time spiritually brings Christ down to us. In his body and in his blood. But it's not literal movement of the body of Christ, it's the value of our being nourished by feeding upon Christ that is accomplished by this twofold work of the Holy Spirit. It's lifting up our hearts, uniting us to Christ. So you might say the problem for Luther was inaccessibility, here's the body of Christ but how can I get it? And the answer through the Lord's Supper, the body of Christ is here. For Calvin it's distance Christ is in his body not here. But the Holy Spirit is here and the Holy Spirit can unite us in this twofold action bringing us up, bringing Christ down to nourish us through the Holy Spirit. I think the Lutherans became a little agitated with the Calvinists over this idea of the work of the Holy Spirit here. But Calvin's answer would have been, but the Holy Spirit is real, this is not imaginary. The Holy Spirit is a real person, part of the triune Godhead. And the Spirit can do what no one else can do. So we can be nourished by the body of Christ even though that body is in heaven because the Spirit can eliminate the Spirit. For Calvin there is a twofold eating in the Lord's Supper with the bread and wine we eat with the mouth. But as we eat with the mouth sometimes this is called Calvin's parallelism. As we eat with the mouth we also eat with the mouth of faith the body and blood of Christ. So it's a twofold eating. You take the Lord's Supper next time. Remember you're chewing bread, you're drinking wine and you are eating Christ in his body and blood by faith through the work of the Holy Spirit. Now that's Calvin's view of the Lord's Supper. I'm not sure that always comes out in our celebration of the Lord's Supper in reformed circles or in the PCA. A lot of people tend more toward Dwingli, but Calvin's view of the Lord's Supper is what I have just described. But not necessarily, you have to say that Calvin is right and Dwingli is wrong but we certainly should understand what Calvin is talking about. And if we do use Calvin's conception of the Lord's Supper it's going to be much more emphasis on the actual eating of the body of Christ and what that means. It's rather complex view. It's easier to understand the Catholic view or the Dwinglian view or even the Lutheran view. But Calvin admits that it's complex and you know I've written all these pages in the Lord's Supper he ends up by saying that as far as I can go, I don't really understand how it works. This is what I think happens because this is what I think the Bible teaches but to explain it exactly and to understand it, I just can't. But I'd rather experience it than understand it anyway. It almost seems to be a kind of a Calvinist mysticism there but there is a proper mysticism in Calvin. The words just have to stop and we can say no more but that doesn't mean that the truth has stopped or that the validity of the sacrament has stopped. It simply means that our mental understanding ceases because we can't understand a mystery and this is a mystery. How are we in eating this bread and this wine sitting in church can actually be feeding upon the very body of Christ and be nourished by that and assured by that and strengthened by that. Okay Calvin on the sacraments I think I could do it in an hour and 15 minutes. I'm sure I left a lot of things unanswered but at least that is a roadmap through this material we'll look at civil governments next time.