<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Tulong Tulong a Bulbulan

Whom Does Our Criticism Indict?

February 21, 2008
0:000:00

Budge, or you too, will be judged. From the same way you judge others, you will be judged. And with the measure you use, it will be measured to you. Why do you look at the spec that solved us in your brother's eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye? How can you say it to your brother? Let me take the spec out of your eye, and all the time there's a plank in your own eye. You hypocrite. Just take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly, for move the spec. From your brother's eye, do not give dogs what is sacred, do not throw your pearls to pigs. If you do, and they trample them under their feet, and then turn and tear you to pieces. I don't know what to say after that. Let's return to the seventh chapter of Matthew. The sermon on the Mount is Jesus lays forth the Constitution for his kingdom. We're dealing with that main body of the sermon on the Mount in his Constitution. Where he talks about how the citizens of his kingdom will be different from the world and live different lives. Let's pray together. Our Father, Jesus, preached this message years ago. We pray that He might preach it here, but part of it this morning. I pray, Father, the dear, to pierce the heart and soul. I can't do that. These folks know it, and I know it, and you know it. But He's able to teach that way, and we pray that He will. Our Father, what a great day, not only in the life of this church, as we look forward to the ordination of McCay Castan tonight, but... Our Father, it's a great day for our sister, church, second Presbyterian. And we thank you for the pastor that you have brought to their puppet. And we pray that you would bless him and bless his family. Father, we pray that you would annoy Sandy's preaching. And he might preach with power in that church and in this community. And we pray that the Word of God, your Word, will become better known because of your power in his life. And in that puppet, our Father, we rejoice with that church this morning. And we thank you with them and for them. And now we pray that you would sweep across this congregation and bring a spiritual awakening. Our Father is messages like this that we adhere to make us aware of our own sin and our own great need. In Jesus' name, we pray.

Whom does our criticism indict? It's always aimed at someone, isn't it? Always someone feels the cut of our tongue. But God in this passage, Jesus in this passage, says that our criticism cuts us more than it does.

The government official of Florence commissioned Michael Angelo to produce the magnificent statue of David. When he was finished, Michael Angelo called the city official to come and examine his work. And the official came in and he looked at that magnificent piece of art. He stood back and Michael Angelo asked him what he thought. And the city official said, you know, I think the nose is a bit out of proportion. So Michael Angelo mounted the scaffold. The statue was 12 feet high. And he took his hammer and chisel and he formally tapped the hammer against the chisel against the statue. And the government official could hear the sound of the chisel and hammer and hear the sound of those instruments against the statue. And at the same time, Michael Angelo had some stone dust in his hand and he dropped it down to the ground. And then he stepped back and he looked at the city official and said, is that quite enough? What do you think now? And the official looked at the unchanged nose and pronounced it perfect. We smile and we say the audacity of that city official who was he to be a critic of the great Michael Angelo. And we would say his criticism says more about him than it does about Michael Angelo. And God says, amen. And so does yours. I'm sermon about criticism. Well, that doesn't sound too bad. I might stay awake and listen. I might catch a few things. It's not that big of a thing after all. Adolphery. Now, there's a major scene. People get divorced. And where we don't repent of that adultery, the church sometimes stands up and disciplines those folks. That adultery. That serious business. Stealing now, favorite people go to jail for stealing, but criticism at its worst. It's just a menial sin. It's a domesticated sin. And it's usually justified after all. I mean, who of us, when we criticize, have ever said, you know, I want to offer some unjustified, destructive criticism. Have you ever heard that? I've never heard it. Well, I want you to know that Jesus does not think that this is a menial sin. And some of the strongest words that I've ever read in Scripture from the lips of Jesus. Strong, strong words have been reserved to the subject of criticism. In fact, he is far more outspoken by criticism in Scripture and has far more to say about it than he does sexual immorality. Does that make you think that Jesus thinks this is important? You bet. And he gives in his passage five serious warnings to folks whose general trend in their talking is to criticize other folks. We're going to look at those five warnings, but before we do, I want to take about two minutes and take a very, very brief detour, but it's important. I want us to see in our detour that in his warnings about criticism, Jesus does not call us to bland naivete. Look at verse six. Do not give the dogs what is sacred, do not throw your pearls to pigs. If you do, they may trample them under their feet and then turn and tear you to pieces. Now many of us read those first five verses and we said, I've got that. I don't understand that. We came to verse six and we said, what? What would he mean? Well, it's very simple. It's not hard to understand in this context. Jesus had been said some very gay, very five, very strong warnings about criticism, about being critical and about judging. But he steps back and he said, let's balance this out. I don't mean for my people to be naive and to be bland for the world to look at my people and say, they are a bland naive people. It's what I mean for you to be a discerning folks and it uses discernment in the area. I'll be saying, don't drag my cross to a sewer. Don't throw out your precious spiritual experience, the deep things of your life and the deep things of God. Just don't throw them out, hitting one in the world. You don't give fine diamonds and pearls to dogs. You're done. He said, beat as he was saying, there's a principle of discernment here. Now a lot of us would offer criticism and we would say, oh, I'm just discerning. Yeah, sure. People, it does not take a genius. Someone would say this is a fine line. Folks, it's not even a fine line. It's a chasm between discernment and criticism and anyone that tries to make something of it and I could have spent a whole message on this and didn't want to because it's obvious. There's a difference between wise discernment for the protection of our lives and our families and the loud, persistent, talking, gossiping criticism and if I have to explain the difference, then you don't need to be here. You need a keeper. Everyone knows the difference and when you say when you are gossiping and slandering someone and when you're being critical of someone and it is and it is put under the label of discernment, let me tell you're not fooling anybody, not even yourself. God calls us to say a stand about doctrine. Tonight, when I will give the charge to McCay in this ordination service. In the charge, I'm going to say McCay, be discerning about your doctrine and be discerning for the sake of this church about the doctrine that's taught in this place. This man is going to lead Christian education here during the next decade and at his feet and his responsibility falls to teach and he's got to be sure and he's got to be discerning about literature and people. Sometimes we come under headed to criticism in this church because we've reserved the pulpit and we said, this is the place where sound is taught and we don't want to be an inch. We're going to be careful about it. That's discernment facts. There's a difference between that and personal. Criticism and we don't need to draw any of the lines. We know the difference. That's what that verse means. We've understood it. Now let's get to those five serious warnings that Jesus talks about. First, I want you to see that our criticism is the standard by which God measures us. Our criticism is the standard by which God measures us. Look at verse one, do not judge. Our YouTube will be judged. We're in the same way you judge others. You will be judged and the measure you use. It will be measured to you. The word there for measure, the Greek word for measure is the Greek word from which we get our word meter and Jesus said with the meter you use. The meter you use, I will judge you. You judge others and set up your standards, your meters, those are the meters I will use. God does not listen to our criticism. He doesn't say, well, what do you think of that? First, I need to know. He already knows, but he doesn't listen to our criticism. And he remembers that it's like a tape recorder around our neck and in eternity he doesn't need his word. He's not going to say, now here's a law here. No, he'll just turn on the tape recorder and say, remember that day you said this and you judge that person? Remember that day you said this? Well, that is the law that I'm using to judge you and you just turn on the tape recorder and the words of judgment that we will hear will be our own words. Our haunting really makes you want to be critical, doesn't it? Listen to Romans chapter 2, verse 1, just listen to it. It's huge. You therefore have no excuse, you who pass judgment on someone else for whatever point you judge the other, at whatever point you judge the other, you are condemning yourself because you who pass judgment do the same things. That's the principle here. Jesus is saying, don't you understand the things you could assign others for? You're guilty of the same things. God has a sense of humor and sometimes you can see it quite clearly and I saw it in my life a lot and I saw it a few years ago when there was an article in the paper about a man that had stopped in the convenience store. He was in a hurry, he was just running this store, gets something and run back out and he left. His car running, the door opened, the keys entered of course and he came out and his car was gone and the article was in the newspaper. And in front of my children, I said, you know that idiot deserved that his car stolen. That was dumb enough to leave their car unlocked, let alone running. And then I said, it's a wonder that he was smart enough to earn enough money to buy car. He really had to be dumb. Now probably that person is sitting here this morning, but listen to the rest of the story and I'll get over the hood. The very next week, not seven days later, I was in a hurry and I was on my way to play tennis during the lunch hour, it was noon and I was late, but I didn't have any tennis balls and a randomized merchandise to get a can of tennis balls. There used to be a door there that went straight into the sports department and it was only an outdoor. I'm like the rest of you, that doesn't mean anything to me. And so I parked there, jumped out of my car, left the car running, the door opened and just went through the outdoor to get my tennis balls. You know the rest of the story, I came out and the car was gone. And during that first moment, when I looked, I promised you I could hear my words from last week, that dumb man got exactly what it deserved. That story has a good ending. Larry Shelley, one of our deacons, was driving by service merchandise and he saw my car and he parked his van, jumped in my car, pulled it over behind his van and then went back in the corner to watch. He got a good laugh. I got a good lesson and it wasn't a lesson to lock your car. I got a good lesson in criticism. What's God saying? God was saying, John, don't you understand? When you call someone else dumb, whatever they did that makes you call them dumb. You've done the same thing. And I'm going to judge you for the same leader. I'm going to judge you by the same standard you judge that person. And it won't be hard because you do the same thing. You want to take some people. You've never criticized anybody for anything you hadn't done yourself. And you come to me afterward and you tell me to see or the criticism that you all brought someone else and you think that you hadn't done it, you come and tell me, I'll prove that you've done it. Our criticism is a standard by which God measures us. God says you better be quiet because I'm going to use those words. You'll hear them again. Secondly, criticism is a sign of self-righteousness. Look at verse 4. How can you say to your brother, let me take the speck out of your eye when all the time there's a plague in your own eye? The critic has a perception problem. Jesus says he's going to take the speck. It's the person who criticizes, it's like the person is going to take the speck of dust out of other person eyes. It's got this big, huge beams sticking out of your own eye. It's a crazy picture but Jesus meant for it to be. He meant for this to be sarcasm and his bust. He said, this is how silly this thing is. John Paul Goodado, sociologist, tested people at every level, at every age level. And he found this overriding trait. He found that young and old perceive themselves superior. In areas they admire. He said, the more most folks admire trait, the more they see that trait in themselves. That's true. The more we admire trait, the more we see it in ourselves. He said, if we admire cooperative people, we see ourselves as being among the most cooperative. If we see if we like a competitive spirit, we see ourselves as being among the most competitive. There was a similar test done with 829,000 high school seniors. 829,000 high school seniors and they were asked where they placed themselves in position of leadership. How did they rate themselves as being leaders? 70% of the high school seniors said that they were above average in leadership ability. Only 2% said they were below average in athletic ability. 60% said they were above average. 6% said they were below average. In the area of getting along with others, 60% saw themselves in the top 10%. In getting along with others, 25% saw themselves in the top 1%. How many saw themselves below average in a cooperative spirit? How many? Out of 829,000. 0%. Jesus was saying, when we criticize others, it's not that we have a perception problem with other people. You see, we always say, hey, microdiscism is true. It's just God doesn't care whether it's true or not. He may say, yes, that person does that. But God turns around and looks at us and says, do you have a perception problem? You say, no, I say that person is quite fat. He says, I'm not talking about A. You see, the first I'm talking about A. You see yourself. You don't see the beam. Look at Luke 189 through 14. It's the famous story. Luke 189 through 14 of the Pharisee. In Jesus this sermon was aimed at the Pharisee and the Pharisee goes up to the temple. The parable starts out. Jesus says, I'm telling this parable to those who are self-righteous. So the self-righteous person, what is his teeth? What is his teeth? Characteristic. He cleansizes. He walks in a church and he says, God, I'm not like that person. I really am. But I'm not like that filthy immoral public in a tax collector. Jesus says, he may be filthy anymore. But don't you see the beam in your own eye? Don't you see that you're just as filthy and just as immoral? That's what Jesus was saying. Now people, listen to this. I think it's critical. I think it's strategic understanding this. It's hard because Jesus is saying people who criticize don't know their own sin. And if you don't, we don't know our own sin. Then we don't know what the cross is all about. We don't know what salvation is all about. We don't know what Jesus is all about. Jesus is saying if we are known as being critical people, there is a very, very, very good possibility. And we're lost. They may know that they're sinful academically, but they've never experienced that ultimate conviction of sin that literally drives them to their knees in tears, agony, and tears of contrition. Let me tell you, if you've ever sat down and wept and wept and wept over your own sin, you don't criticize that sin and others.

I'm telling you, thanks. We better pay close attention to our words because if we are known in our office as critical people, if we're known in our homes as critical people, what that is saying is that we're self-righteous and we don't really understand we're sinners. And if we don't really understand we're sinners, we don't know what that cross is about. Our criticism is standard by which God measures us. Criticism is a sign of self-righteousness. And you say, this is tough. Let me tell you. It doesn't get any easier because Jesus didn't have anything good to say about critics. Thirdly, criticism is a sign of personal prejudice. Look at verse 4. How can you say to your brother, let me take the spec out of your eye when all the time there's a plank in your own eye? It was the target of this message. It was the Pharisees. And the Pharisees were going around saying, we're just helping you out. You see, that's what the guy saying. The guy with the beam in his own eye is saying, I want to help you. And Jesus was saying, it's not a matter of hell. How can you help somebody if you have this beam sticking out of your own eye? And a lot of times we say, I went off for a little constructive criticism. And we're just like the Pharisees. We're not trying to really help anybody. It's a point of personal prejudice. The point is, we couldn't say anything against that about that person if we had to. And we wouldn't. We don't like them. And the criticism is not from a point of principle. It's from a point of personal prejudice. We just put it very plain. Some facts, some facts that even go to church at Memphis, Tennessee, couldn't say anything good about black folks if they had to. Couldn't say anything good. Because it's not a matter of constructive criticism. It's a matter of personal prejudice. And we all have individuals in our lives like that. It's not a matter of criticism. It's not a matter of principles, a matter of personal prejudice. And Jesus calls it what it is. Over the 11th chapter of Matthew, the Pharisees have been critical about John the Baptist. John the Baptist had come and had been very, very strict in his personal life. And they had invited the parties and they had invited the parties to eat and drink. And he wouldn't eat with them. And he wouldn't drink with them. And he wouldn't go to their parties. And they said, you're a narrow-minded fundamentalist. And Jesus came, and he's like John the Baptist. They believe the same thing. But Jesus came. And he went to their parties and he ate with them. And he drank with them. You know what they said about Jesus? They didn't pat him on the banks. And hey, you're different, John the Baptist. We like you. You know what they said? They said, Jesus, you're a glutton and a drunkard. In Jesus, in that 11th chapter of Matthew, in verses 18 and 19 says, hey, John the Baptist and I couldn't win with you guys because you were prejudiced against us. Whatever you were going to say was going to be critical and there was nothing we could say that was good or say that was going to be good. He said, one of us did one thing. The other did just the opposite and you got both of us. You're damned if you're doing. You're damned if you're done. You ever been with somebody and you know that they're going to start talking about somebody and you know that they're going to say something about this person and they're going to say, hey, you know before they say it. You know, it's going to be bad because you know, it's not a matter of principle. You know, it's a matter of personal prejudice. There was a wife, a young wife who was married to a very critical husband, hyper critical husband. Some of you know what that's like. And she, she could never get everything right and just for an example, she would scramble his egg and he would come down the morning and say, I didn't want to scramble. I wanted to overlight. The next day you'd come down and she would have a perfect overlight egg fixed one. He said, I didn't want to overlight. I want to scramble. So one morning, she said, I've got it. And she picks one egg scramble. She picks one egg over light. She put them both on the plate. Beautifully put it before him. He was obviously displeased and she said, what's wrong? He said, you scramble the wrong egg. There's people that live like that and it's not a matter of principle. It's a matter of personal prejudice. Our criticism is a standard by which God measures us. Criticism is a sign of self-righteousness. Criticism is a sign of personal prejudice. Criticism is a sign of hypocrisy. He just comes right out and says it. Look at verse 5. He just begins, you hypocrite. How many times have you ever had anybody looking your face and just say, you're a hypocrite? Well, Jesus did. Right here. People that criticize. And he just, if you're known as a critical spirit, if you criticize most of the time, I want you to know Jesus is looking at you in the face this morning. I'm not going to tame it down. He's looking at you right in the face and saying, you're a hypocrite. Here you go. You want the definition of hypocrite is hypocrisy. The feigning of beliefs, feelings, or virtues that one does not hold or possess. You're saying, I don't care how righteous you look. I don't care. Good you look. I don't care whether you're an elder, they kind of don't care whether you're a minister. You don't care whether you're been a member of this church 50 years. I don't care whether you stand up and give your testimony. I don't care whether you're in Sunday school. I don't care where you are. What you did, that matter. You're a hypocrite. Well, we've got to go on. That's enough that he says in verse 5. He says, you see them saying anything good. He doesn't say words like this. Don't walk out here and say, Jesus can known adultery. He didn't. He just said people that were going to commit adultery were going to the same hell the people that criticized. That's all. He puts them together and he has much more to be messed from the worst of say. You know, the problem with the Pharisees was not that they were sexually immoral. The problem was that they considered themselves to be the great judges, to be the great judges of the earth and judges of all their friends and all the one wrong around. Here what Jesus says, our criticism is a standard by which God mentions us. Criticism is a sign of self-righteousness. Criticism is a sign of personal prejudice. Criticism is a sign of hypocrisy. And you say, John, this is the strongest message I've heard you preach a long time. Well, it's right there. Just go back and read this. And if you can come up with anything else, you let me know. Criticism finally is a sign of a destructive nature. Look at verse 5. You hit the first take the plank out of your own eye and then you will say clearly to remove the speck from your other brother, from your brother's eye. What was he saying? He was saying you can't. He said, only when you get it out of your eye. Can you help someone else? In other words, that thing of being critical is destructive. You know, what damage? What damage? You know, what if somebody came to you and you said, you know, I got a speck in my eye right here. Have you ever gone to a blind person and said, you know, would you get to speck out of my eye? Can you imagine what blind person would be like to in a round drive? They would do a lot of damage, wouldn't they? That's what Jesus says. Criticism does. You can't help, you just damage. We say to people, this is constructive. Jesus is a liar. It's a great story told by Helen Rosloff. She was a teacher at St. Mary's School in Mars, Minnesota, a Catholic school. She taught the third grade. Helen Rosloff had a little boy in her class. She was a young teacher when this happened very young and new teacher. And there was a little boy in her class named Mark Eckland. And Mark was one of these little guys that was so glad to be alive, so full of life. But he was also full of mischief, but very, very polite. And she'd correct him 50 times a day. And every time he would say, sister, thank you for correcting me. Always simple, just would melt her. One day, he was just kept talking and talking and talking. And she said, Mark, next time you say a word, next time you talk, I'm going to tape your mouth shut. One 10 seconds later, and the other students did light it and that Chuck said, said, Mr. Rosloff, Mark Eckland is talking again. So she goes back to her desk, gets some masking tape, goes back, we want to do this with our children, so often. One tape this way, one tape this way, and then shut him up. And she walked back to the desk and in the moment she looked up as he was doing, and he had this mischief, a little smile on his face through the tape, and he winked at her. And she just fell apart laughing. And she went back and she took the tape off, and he looked at her, and he said, thank you for correcting me teacher. Well, years later, right after that year, she was transferred to teach at St. Mary's, the ninth grade math class. So she was away from Mark Eckland for a few years, but then one day he walked into her ninth grade class, and it was that same group, and it was a great group of kids. And they were the same, just the same as they were in third, not much different. And one that was one Friday, and she just couldn't get anything done. And she was exasperating his anger with him, but she did something good. She just closed her books and she said, all right, take out two sheets of paper. And I want you to write down everyone's name in the class, and leave a space between each person's name so that you can write something about them. And she said, after you get all the name written down of every person's class, I want you to write the one or two outstanding traits that that person has. No credit system, just two or three great traits that that person has, that you admire, that you want them to know about. You got to write down every person's name and do that. And they did it. And they turned in their sheets, and she went home, and she put at the head of a piece of paper, each individual piece of paper, each individual's name. And then she wrote down, copied herself, what every student had said about that person, didn't fit the person's name down, but just wrote down what had been said about that person. And the next Monday, she handed out those sheets, and she said, there was just just powerful. She said, the students just were silently set in red, and they read, and they re-read what had been said, what their classmates had said about them. And it looked like she just, I didn't know if you thought that. She forgot all about it. Years later, she was coming back from summer vacation, her parents picked her up at their port. And they greeted her with the news that Mark Ecklin had been killed in Vietnam. His parents had called, and wanted her to come to the funeral. And she sat with the family, and of course, all of his old classmates were there. And afterwards, they went to the family farm, and they had dinner. And the students were gathered around Helen Rosla. And the parents came and said, we want to give you something. And they said, Mark had this bill folded on him when he was killed. And they opened the billfold, and they pulled out a sheet of paper. And it had obviously been folded and unfolded many, many times. It was old and worn, but she recognized it immediately, and she remembered it. And there was a list of all the good things in his students, fellow students, and said about him, he kept the list. But then something more amazing. The students individually began to pull out from billfolds and pocket bucks. That worn piece of paper, each one of them, and kept it. I want to tell you something, folks, no one keeps a list. Not your friends, or not those that you could have sized, no one keeps a list of your criticism. Because it's not helpful. And it doesn't build up, but God keeps a list of every critical word we ever say in one day. And read that list to us. One day he'll read that list.