<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Dona Dona mensilmente

Discussion: R.C. Sproul's "Chosen by God"

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

We give you our time tonight in a class Lord teach us Concerning your grace. Give us grateful hearts Renew our commitment to your great commission. We pray through Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior. Amen Please indicate your percentage of reading completed tonight on the form circulating We welcome our students taking this course by videotape Our goal tonight is to finish up the doctrine of election next time and for three Monday nights Although there is one gap there. There's one one night off as you can see from the schedule We'll be studying the doctrine of the church But why don't we first of all grade the quiz on Sproles look chosen by God is anybody here who has not taken the quiz? That's very good Let's go over the questions and use them as a springboard to Discussion let me ask you this first of all and be be frank. Are you glad you read the book? Did you find his spirit? I mean, he's obviously a man of convictions He's a fine christian man was strong convictions. Okay, that's that seems to be part of our personalities Did you find him fair?

Okay, well, maybe we'll find out why you're glad you read it as we go True or false according to Sprole that's our attempt at objectivity Your evaluation and mine are our own I'll tell you if I disagree with him as we go along Number one Arminius John Wesley CS Lewis and Billy Graham all teach a reformed view of predestination it is false pages 14 and 16 This is what one of my colleagues Dan Doriani calls an underhand pitch An easy one you can get out of the park of course even one of the if even one of those What did not teach their reformed view than it would be false as a matter of fact all four of them do not eat it so I think Spro was very fair in showing that good people disagree on this matter. Yes sir

The question is what a CS Lewis teach It's a good question what a CS Lewis teach okay he was not a doctrinal teacher But people have studied his writings to discern his theology and With mixed results, but I think it is fair to say his emphasis on the freedom of the will Because of certain problems that he saw within Christian theology would lead him to this camp It is not the same as to say you know we can study Billy Graham sermons or John Wesley sermons and writings and so forth There are many us as even formal theological work So it is not exactly the same, but I would agree with Spro that that's where CS Lewis belongs He of course is one of the most creative minds in the past in this century and did so much good for the Lord indeed Number two the idea that God for ordains whatever comes to pass is unique to Calvinism False page 26 Spro argues it's not even unique to Christianity It is unique to theism if you believe there's a God in heaven The normal thing to believe is that he controls what comes to pass he foreordains it At least in some broad sense I think that was helpful for him to point that out Three gods entering allowing excuse me three gods allowing sin to enter the world Was a good decision But the evil he allows is still evil true according to Spro 31 and 32 I don't know if I'd say it exactly that way He's trying to be uh, I don't know to get our attention Trying to be controversial a little bit Certainly if God is the Lord if he is in charge Then we have to somehow construe the fall as within his plan So he planned or ordained To permit the fall we usually say it that way The planning or ordaining idea puts God behind it and doesn't let it get loose from his control the idea of allowing or permitting doesn't Sully God's character and doesn't cause us to blame him for the fall So the fault the fault for the fall goes to our first parents Genesis 3 is plain on that and Romans 5 as well Goes to Adam especially as the head that God instituted It is dealings with the human race Uh, but still we cannot cut the fall loose completely from the sovereignty of God We may say that differently but in Spro's way of saying it number three is true 31 and 32 For Christianity has room for contradictions, but no room for mysteries false page 47. It's the other way around Christianity has room for mysteries But no room for contradictions does this sound like a cop out to you He does not intend it to be so I would agree with him And would urge that we be open to mysteries because of the Bible itself Deuteronomy 29 29 says the secret things belong to the Lord our God The things he has revealed belong to us and our children that we might do them But the thrust there is that there are some things that God simply has not revealed Uh, if that verse is true and it shouldn't and of course it is It shouldn't totally shock us if we can't figure everything out And put God under our fingernail or uh in our filing cabinet along with other facts It shouldn't surprise us that God is greater than our ability to understand him But again, I would emphasize there's a difference between the finely revealed mysteries And you and I not liking something in the Bible for example or the neo orthodox notion that truth by its very nature is paradoxical I would reject those ideas, but as we study the scriptures There appear to be three great mysteries Three great mysteries one is how God has always existed as three in one the mystery of the Trinity We can say that the threeness and the oneness of God are not in the same regard And in that way are not the contradictory But still we cannot perfectly explain how in what sense God is three and in what sense God is one another of the three mysteries The second one is That uh in the person of Christ that he is both God and man in one person the Bible teaches it We accept it but we cannot fully understand or explain His person the third one of course is the one we're touching upon here And that is the mystery of God's sovereignty alongside of genuine human Responsibility Christianity has room for mysteries because The God of Christianity the God of the universe the God of the Bible is an infinite personal being from his franchise shafers terminology He's a transcendent imminent God And because of that apparently the divine sovereignty human responsibility tension Is a reflection of the fact that God is infinite and personal in that he is infinite He is absolutely in charge in that he is personal and he made human beings over against himself and accountable to himself There is genuine human responsibility Thus the divine sovereignty human responsibility difficulty Seems to reflect a mystery within the person of God himself and his dealings with the world Number five fallen man in and of himself Does not have the moral ability to choose Christ it is true page 61 In Anthony hookamas good book created in God's image he makes an important distinction between Freedom of choice and what he calls true freedom There's a difference Freedom of choice is always part of our makeup as human beings. It is our ability to choose But hookamas says and we always have that before the fall animony if had freedom of choice After the fall people can choose and so forth After the fall and saved we have freedom of choice even in the new heavens and new earth. We'll be able to choose But That mere freedom of choice is not true freedom think about it Unsaid persons who are free to choose whether to get out of bed in the morning or not Or whether to go to the store or not there. They're not compelled to do those things They are not truly free Some of you who were saved as adults and from a non-Christian home background and remember being Quite in bondage to sin Well true freedom is not just a freedom you believe in choose true freedom is Knowing and loving and enjoying and serving God And that has been lost in the fall Our Adam and Eve were made in relationship with God and they had true freedom They forfeited true freedom and human nature after the fall is bound in transgressions and sins And if left to our own devices we would in fact not choose God These are subjects of other courses But it is good at times to tie things together. I commend to you hookamas book Created in God's image is the best single volume. I know of that summarizes the doctrines of Human beings made in God's image and then the doctrine of sin and how it has affected us It's just in case you you're thinking the ability to choose opposites is really the essence of true freedom of human freedom You think I would encourage you to think it through again because in the new heavens and new earth Although we will be able to choose We will not be able to sin We will only want to choose God and his will And that will be true freedom par excellence If you want to say we have to be able to sin And to choose sin to be free. Well then you're going to have us not free in the new heavens and new earth And there's something wrong with that. We will be most free. We'll be better off than Adam and Eve at the start because We will not be able to sin As they were obviously since they did choose sin We have the ability to choose but not the moral ability to choose Christ if left to our devices According to Romans 3 where it says there's not one who is righteous no not one There's no one who seeks for God. You say I sought for God The young person sought for God last week and in the school and believed in the Lord Yes, it is true, but when we see people seeking God we can be sure That that seeking of God is an evidence that God has been seeking them That's why we can get excited as we see somebody Take an interest in the things of God in spiritual things

Number six Augustine and Jonathan Edwards held the Calvinist view a predestination. It is true pages 61 and 62 of course. It's anachronistic to talk like that But we're using the terms reformed and Calvinist as synonymous And Arminian for the other side. Yes sir

So let me ask a question The question here is for number six that I have used the anachronism Calvinist of Augustine It is true enough by the way reform is also anachronistic There was no term reformed in Augustine's time the the right adjective is Augustinian Augustine and Edwards were Augustinians would be true. How many people stumbled over this question for that reason Because of the anachronism Okay, if you missed it for that reason if you knew that Augustine and Edwards held the Reformed Augustinian predestination view. I'll give it to you Okay, if you knew that if the terminology Calvinist if you marked it false Because that was a later term Then I'll if that's why you missed it. I'll give you credit if you knew the answer. I leave you to your conscience on that one You can understand my problem. There's not a good term to use because reformed And Calvinist and Calvinian is gaming in popularity now Those are all later terms The right one to use would be Augustinian but to say Augustin Augustin is an Augustinian Well, that's just giving it away. Yes, sir

Okay The gesture was made that we try to find some other kind of synonym for Calvinist like such as Calvinist like or something like that other comments Yes, sir That sounds like a winner to me And the winner is the suggestion For the benefit of our friends Oh taking this course via extension That number six we say Augustin and Jonathan Edwards held the view that came to be known as Calvinism with regard to predestination That is that is clear. I appreciate that. This is a prototype quiz I recycle at least questions from quizzes and I don't know if I've ever had one that didn't need Doctering after the first time so this is not unusual if I only have one problem. I will be a happy camper Spraw if I can just keep you happy campers that is And I'll give you my little Humors touch that's fine to be humors anyway At times you will know the stuff and the question will trip you up Okay, if that happens I ask you to lick your wounds And I hope that there's an equal number of times in which You get Providentially blessed shall we say oh you get lucky and you don't know what you're doing and you get it right You can have it You can have that I hope they may they balance out for you number seven sprawl favors a combination of the myth and realist theories of the fall most certainly false He rejects both of those so again if even one of them he rejected it would be false This is another one of those underhand pitches and you're just hitting him out of the park He favors false pages 80 to 84 80 to 84 88 through 90 He favors the federal or representative view I agree with him on that pages 90 and following That is the subject of another course however so we can't probe these things in detail But so we separate out the topics In christian theology among our three ma courses. We really couldn't study them all at once Are we wouldn't get anywhere you with me? We separate them out and the first one is God in his word The titles pretty much give you the subject Second second one is man Christ and redemption. This is spirit church and last things But although we divide the topic stuff like that Since christian theology co-hears it's not a perfect system We don't have everything we might want to know about everything in the Bible Since it doesn't contradict itself and it fits together When we work with any one of those doctrines we keep bumping into other ones And for the sake of completeness we at least mention and touch on Things that belong in other courses Number eight. We are all judge guilty for Adam sin because he our fair and just representative fail True page 93 This is the representative view of original sin or the federal headship view Adam was our representative God set it up that way God apparently from Romans 5 12 through 19 my understanding is God the christian religion the religion of God is such that he set it up That there would be two heads Two human beings who would be the heads of the human race first of all Adam And in Adam the human race fell the second federal head and representative is the lord Jesus Christ and through his work We are saved It is the guilt of Adam that is made over to our spiritual bank accounts. It's called alien guilt And some people don't like it Well, I would suggest if that's what Romans 5 teaches we whether we like it or not we need to accept it I know one thing is a parallel there between Adam and Christ especially in verses 18 and 19 And they say that by virtue of the sin of the one man Let me read it and not watch it so badly Just as the result of one trespass Was condemnation for all men So also the result of one act of righteousness Was justification that brings life for all men For just as through the disobedience of the one man the many were made sinners So also through the obedience of the one man the many will be made righteous Romans 5 18 and 19 I do not love alien guilt I accept the fact that God put Adam as a representative and when he fell we fell I don't love that but I accepted as teaching of God's word But I have to tell you I love what Luther called alien righteousness That is the righteousness of the Lord Jesus Christ That is put to our spiritual bank account and which saves us before a holy God Apparently we can't have the one without the other since God has Set up these two heads for the human rights Christianity apparently is a representative religion We didn't set the ground rules God did And he has treated us fairly and justly as a matter of fact He gave us more than we deserve When he gave us eternal life through the Lord Jesus Christ 9 Most non-reformed views of predestination Fail to take seriously the fact that fallen man is spiritually dead True page 114 once again Topic of our course is not the doctrine of sin But we really do need to think about that How far down the well have we fallen Are we hanging over the edge of the well with one arm out and we can pull ourselves up Are we down the well about a third of the way and able to grab a handhold and a foothold and get ourselves out Are we about halfway down my understanding of the biblical position perspective is we are at the bottom of the well And there's no handholds and there's no footholds. We are in trouble In God we need for God to throw down the rope To come down on the rope to give us a hug a rule and pull us out of that thing or we're never going to get out That is If we really consider the seriousness of sin We will magnify the grace of God and give him all the glory for saving us I would agree with Sproul a number nine true page 114 I would agree with him uh the One clear passage the best one I can think of immediately is Ephesians 2 where it indeed describes us as spiritually dead before hour regeneration By God in Christ 10 irresistible grace means that sinners come kicking and screaming against their wills into the kingdom of God true Of course just easing just seen if you're awake tonight false page 123 that that's false I usually do that once I usually get a better rise out of the people I must I must have picked an outlandish one to do it on occasionally somebody comes that way I guess you could say Saul of Tarsus did If you think of the way the Lord handed the handle dealt with the problem handled the problem of persecution in the early church I think it shows God in a sense of humor The persecution was real and some Christians even their lives were taken But he used the persecution to spread the gospel As the disciples dispersed and the Lord has a sense of humor The main antagonist the main persecutor God converted Saul and made him into the greatest Christian missionary That was one way for the Lord to handle that problem Uh, Saul would seem to be a person who came in kicking and screaming But usually that's not the way it works When the Lord gives us his grace When his Holy Spirit works Invisibly of course and unknown to us in our hearts and minds Then the gospel just makes so much sense and we kick ourselves and we say Jesus is so precious to me now I don't understand why why was I so stupid Why was I so foolish all those years wasting my time Even taking the name of Christ as a curse for example or in vain It just seems so clear to me now Well the credit for the clarity bill is to the Lord Who illuminated your mind and thinking Your adjustable grace doesn't mean that we come kicking and screaming It means that God's grace ultimately is invincible He is like the Royal Canadian Mounties of old He gets his man and he gets his woman and his grace doesn't give up on us Uh, he keeps loving us. He keeps bringing Christians into our lives He keeps grandmothers and grandfathers praying for us in the whole nine yards Uh, until he brings us to himself sometimes on death the death bed people have been saved Uh, it is amazing Number 11 only God can call a person to salvation inwardly True page 134 we cannot force a person to be saved We cannot create faith in other words We cannot be the Holy Spirit for somebody else That's why first Peter 3 I suppose because the situation is often in Situations where both spouses are unsaved and the Lord saves one I don't exactly know why but oftentimes It's the wife First Peter 3 commands wives To seek to win their unsaved husbands through their lifestyle And not by trying to nag their husbands in the kingdom of God because it doesn't work Given the male pride it drives the sinner in the other direction. It is really true only God Can call a person to salvation inwardly we can be used of God to call people to salvation outwardly But we can't control that inward business that's God's work And in the preaching of the gospel one believes and one doesn't they're all responsible to believe They're all culpable for not believing But God works sovereignly by his spirit In John 3 the spirit is likened to the wind supply on words the same Greek word means Breath wind or spirit the holy wind of God blows wherever he wills We cannot control it we need to work instead In harmony with the spirit sharing the true gospel in love and praying and looking for God to work 12 God knows from all eternity who will respond to the gospel and who will not true page 135 Very few people would deny that But that doesn't say that that is the basis of his choosing people that is another question But as far as God's knowledge goes God knows all things God knows all facts God knows all situations hypothetical and actual he knows the end from the beginning 13 Equal intimacy is the reformed view of predestination false page 142 Equal intimacy would say that God is the author of Positive election in the exact same way is the author of negative election or Reprobation and the way I said it was I used different words to teach the same thing We'll actually get to it later tonight in some more detail when we go to a systematic summary and kind of tie things together God does stand behind the fate of both those who are saved in the end and those who are lost in the end Okay, he stands behind them both, but I said he stands behind them both asymmetrically That is not precisely the same way He is proactive on the on the side of those who end up being saved because if he weren't they would be lost Over here if it is true he contemplates them all as sinners in the first place Then here he does not need to be proactive He only needs to decide to allow them to suffer the justice penalty for their sins on this side He needs to choose them To provide a redeemer to plan to send the redeemer the later on plan to send the Holy Spirit to apply the work of the redeemer There's a lot more effort in God's support in that way than there is in merely deciding for reasons Locked up in his own Infinite was the to pass by some people question or comment

The question is is equal intimacy subsumed under the supra lap serian view of God's decrees Oh my what a can of worms we open up here There are different views of God's decrees of his Of his making his plans in the divine mind before the creation of the world This is not the time they go into this in any kind of detail But some supra lap serians would favor more of an equal intimacy idea Sproul is very much against supra lap serianism I wish we had time to talk about that. Let me just say this a very helpful couple of things Bb Warfields book the plan of salvation discusses the different viewpoints supra and infra and sub lap serian viewpoints and a very helpful more recent Discussion of this which makes me question the whole discussion and put it in a different light I suspected for years that we were being overbohled to try to figure out what God was doing before creation Uh, and now I'm more sure of it although there are truths to the different viewpoints Uh, this discussion I'm thinking of is by John frame in his book the doctrine of the knowledge of God In the section of his book under logic Specifically the subsection under logical orders He shows that when theologian say the order here between these things is logical It is not a time distinction. It's not temporal but logical. He says it's very fuzzy language He shows that there are 12 or 15 different logical orders and here's the point In the order of the decrees within say supra lap serianism. There's no logical. There's no Consistent use of the of the idea of logical order. There are different logical orders from the cree one to decree two and down the line So it really really uh shows how muddy the discussion is frame instead argues that actually supra and infra lap serianism are Our teaching orders are ways of emphasizing different truths and I wouldn't oppose that Uh, to answer in a nutshell Those who hold to supra lap serianism are much more likely to argue for Equal intimacy 14 election and salvation are both Conditional false 154 to 156 the answer according to sprawl is that Only salvation is conditional Perhaps you were thrown by his statement that salvation has all kinds of conditions I can especially like that one that statement But I did like when he said the condition of salvation is faith. That's true You have to believe when the Lord Jesus Christ in order to be saved to be complete I would say it is repentance hyphen or slash faith There are two sides to the same coin the condition for salvation is turning from sin and turning to Christ uh But election according to sprawl is not conditioned on anything in the creature. I agree with him as you know so since one part of 14 is false then the whole question is false because Both election and salvation are not conditional Salvation is conditional election is unconditional according to rc And I would I do agree with him on that 15 it is easy to have a false sense of security about our salvation true page 166 Not sure if this was said perfectly either. I would say it's possible Uh, some of the churches that teach once saved always saved Make other people nervous because of the way they do it and they make me nervous too It looks like the meaning is once professed always saved Or once having prayed a prayer or once having come up front always saved it is not the truth. It is not the case Once truly saved. Yes, God keeps us But they're all is such a thing in the scriptures as false profession of faith And whereas we cannot lose our salvation We certainly can damage or even lose all together our assurance of salvation question 16 the first of all question from your comment

Okay, here's a here's first of all the question is it looks the word hour In number 15 it is easy to have a false sense of security about our salvation the word hour looks Here's to be confusing Number one, it is a direct quotation From page 166 Number two, I'm interested know to know how many people were stumbled by the word hour In other words, you thought it meant only true believer so you Missed it because of that I will have to patch that one up

He means Himself and his readers understand If you missed 15 a lot of a lot of on your honors here If you missed it for that reason If you miss it for some other reason, well, you just flat out missed it and mark it wrong take your lips But if you missed number 15 because You thought hour meant referred to only Saints Then I will give you credit 16 assurance of salvation can be increased Decreased or even lost all together for a time it is true page one 7 2 I think we need to teach that more than we do in our churches We can damage our assurance 17 we persevere in the faith let me finish these out we'll take our break And then we'll come back and I'll entertain more questions on the book 17 We persevere in the faith because God preserves us True page one seven five God's preservation is the ground the basis of our Persevering our continuing on in the faith 18 predestination is the same as fatalism Some of you may have thought so before we start studying these things, but false 191 the difference is the God who predestines is a personal God with personal attributes with the character This is not we're not really Left to the whims of fate 19 the Bible always speaks of the will of God in the same way It is incorrect to distinguish between different wills in God false of course page He distinguishes between God's sovereign efficacious will which always comes to pass His preceptive will his will in commandment which is broken every day And also God's will in disposition. I would agree with him on those points Perhaps you want to talk about them after the break number 20 Our minions and Calvinists agree that the value of Jesus atonement was great enough to cover the sins Of every human being true page 204 if even Adam and Eve were to be saved after they fell The son of God would have had to die There's no question as to the value of his saving work. Let's take a break and come back a little bit after seven to continue our class