<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Dona Dona mensilmente

The Church, I

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Well, kind of few, this morning, this must be the elect. Glad you made it, the bad weather, one more coming, and turned to book four today before we do so. Let's look to the Lord in prayer using, as we do each class of prayer from John Calvin. Let's pray. And lighten us, O God, by Your Spirit, in the understanding of Your Word, and grant us the grace to receive it in true fear and humility, that we may learn to put our trust in You, to fear and honor You by glorifying Your holy name in all our life, and to yield You the love and obedience, which faithful servants owed to their master and children to their fathers, seeing it has led you to call us to the number of Your servants and children, amen. Before we get into the beginning of book four, take a look at the outline that I have given in the syllabus. I think it's there, isn't it? Outline of book four, let me just alert you to what's coming. The title of book four, these titles are important, and you should know those, particularly if you're doing the exam, but if you're not, you should know them also. The title of book four is The External Means, or AIDS, by which God invites us into the society of Christ and holds us therein in my copy of the institutes, the page that introduces book four, says AIDS, but on page 10, 11, 11, it says The External Means, or Ames, is that still how it reads, page 11, it's not two different words, that Ames is a mistake, that's just a misprint, and I keep thinking they're going to correct that, but Ames, so change that the AIDS as it is on the preceding page. The external means, or AIDS, is how it should read. External means, or AIDS, by which God invites us into the society of Christ and holds us therein in a few minutes I'm going to kind of dissect that sentence in some detail. Calvin, as he begins a book four, is actually section two, gives his own summary statement of what is coming, the church, its government orders and powers, that would be government orders means ministry, ministers of the church, its government, its policy, its ministry, and its powers, what is the authority, what is the power of the church, then the sacraments and lastly the civil order, so in that brief phrase Calvin sums up of what is coming in book four, and this is a kind of outline of book four, first two chapters deal with the true and the false church, look at that today, and then chapter three with church officers or ministers, and chapters four through eleven church government, in chapter four, Calvin looks at the ancient church, the early church, and explores how the early church was governed, and then in five through eleven the papal church, the Roman Catholic church, we're not going to get into those chapters just referred to those briefly, those chapters do however reveal Calvin's rather considerable knowledge of church history, we know that Calvin was able in a good many fields, but generally not thought of as a church historian, but as you read those chapters in book four, five through eleven you'll see Calvin's skill in the discipline of church history, and then church discipline, that's the power of the church, chapter 12 will come to that, this chapter own vows, which is primarily a critique of Roman Catholic monasticism, and then chapters 14 through 19 on the sacraments, 14 through 17 on the true sacraments, the two sacraments that Calvin views as valid, that is baptism and the Lord's supper, and then chapters 18 and 19 on the false sacraments, Calvin's critique of the NAS, and the five other, he calls them ceremonies, Roman Catholic church had seven sacraments, as Catholic church still does, but Calvin accepted only two of those as scriptural sacraments, baptism of the Lord's supper, and then the final chapter on civil government, so that's a kind of quick look at what is coming in book four, we'll come today to Calvin's, the beginning of Calvin's treatment on the church, and let me just make some introductory remarks about this, and we'll see how this material relates to the first three books. Calvin is viewed, of course, as a reformer of the church, one of the more recent biographies of Calvin, I don't mean the most recent, but fairly recent, the book by THL Parker on Calvin, just called John Calvin a biography, and Dr. Parker said in that book, as I have been writing the book, Calvin has more and more taken on the character and stature of a doctor of the Catholic church, so Parker looking at the life of Calvin sees him as a churchman, a doctor of the Catholic church, doesn't mean Roman Catholic church, it means the universal church, we'll look at Calvin's reasons for leaving the Roman Catholic church and explore that theme a bit further, but Calvin was a reformer of the church, as you know from his biography his life story, that was not his initial goal, Calvin did not plan to be a reformer of the church, in fact he was very reluctant to be cast in that role, you remember the famous incident when he came to Geneva, it was August 1536, he was a refugee from France, decided that it was necessary for him to leave France for good reasons because his life was in danger, he wanted to go to Strasbourg to pursue a scholarly career, he'd already written a couple of books, did not make waves, particularly, but got to the street wet in this life of a scholar and apparently liked it, he thought that that was what he wanted to do, but he had to detour South because of the war that was going on between Charles V, the Holy Roman Empire, and Francis I, King of France, that made it impossible for him to go to Strasbourg directly from Paris down to Strasbourg and so he kept going south and passed through Geneva, sometimes called the divine detour because God certainly had a hand in all of that, and there he met William Farrow, William Farrow was a very fiery reformer, somebody was called in the hot gospel and he was preaching in and around Geneva, Parker in Parker's biography of Calvin, Parker says Farrow would act while angels debated, so he was a man that didn't wait, and he discovered Calvin's presence in town, this is how Calvin puts it in Calvin's own words, his preface to the Psalms commentary, which he wrote later, late in his life, it's about the only place that Calvin ever talks about himself, so we don't have a lot of personal biographical information directly from Calvin, but we do in the Psalms and the preface to the Psalms commentary in Calvin, thinking back to 1536 said that what he really desired was to continue as a kind of private scholar, in fact the more recent book that he had written, which was the first edition of the 1992, came out in 1536, the same year that Calvin appears in Geneva would be quite a sensation, and Calvin wanted to do that, to give his life to that cause of writing books and study, but he said that was my plan until Farrow detained me at Geneva, not so much by counsel and exhortation as by a dreadful curse, which I felt to be as if God had from heaven laid his mighty hand upon me to arrest me, some place else Calvin says God thrust me into the game, he was kind of on the sidelines until this happened, when Farrow discovered that Calvin was not really eager to help him and was determined to go on to Strasbourg in Calvin's words, he proceeded to utter the implication that God would curse my retirement and the tranquility of the studies which I saw it if I should withdraw and refuse to help when the necessity was so urgent, well I'm not recommending Farrow's tactics there, getting guidance for somebody else, especially in the rather strong words that he undoubtedly used, but it worked in Calvin's case in Calvin says this by this implication I was so terror struck that I gave up the journey I had undertaken Calvin, a sensitive person to have that blias coming from Farrow was more than he could handle so he stayed in Geneva and that really committed him to his life's work, although he would be expelled with Farrow in a couple of years, he would then come back three years later, but his life work was set now as a church pastor of the church, preacher, person involved in the reform of the church interestingly, he still got the right books, but the books were quite different from what he would have produced if he hadn't been able to retreat to a kind of ivory tower I think it's Parker who says that Calvin wrote the institute against the background of teething trouble babies crying in the house, not Calvin's own babies because the only child he had died almost immediately at birth is and it'll let son, but Calvin had family living with it in Geneva, sisters, brothers and others and their children, where they are crying so Calvin was not in the ivory tower but he wrote the institute says busy pastor in a kind of hectic household with all the pressures that faced him, faced pastors today and even more so we think of Calvin's life, it's astonishing how he was able to get so much done and yet he did so he became a pastor, he did go on to Strasburg and that was a very important time for Calvin, John T. McNeil in the history and character of Calvinism says that Calvin's Strasburg period was much more than an interruption of his activities in Geneva both church and school had much to teach him and he was in a mood to learn the Reformation in Strasburg was already advanced under the guidance of Martin Busser and Busser became a kind of mentor to Calvin for those three golden years as they're called Calvin's Strasburg and Calvin learned much from Busser, not so much I think theology, it already written 1536 edition of the institute but he learned how to be a pastor, how to serve a church great advance in Calvin's thinking came during this time in Christian education because there was a school there that Busser had begun and in the life and ministry and work at the church Busser was 18 years older than Calvin so he was a kind of father figure to John Calvin during this time we see as we trace Calvin's life a growing emphasis on the church both in his own experience and involvement as a pastor and also in his writing the Reform in Geneva which Calvin undertook and really was the work of his lifetime he saw that as his primary goal to reform the church to bring it into line with what he thought was the standards of the Bible it's interesting that Calvin dedicated his Titus commentary to Farrell and to Pierre Baray Baray was another reformer who was serving not far away in Lausanne and Calvin dedicated the commentary that he wrote on the book of Titus to Farrell and Baray and he says that as Titus completed the work begun by Paul so he was the successor to Farrell and Baray to complete the work that had been begun by these two reformers in the region of Geneva when Calvin attempts his work of reform in Geneva he's governed by two great ideas one of course the primary idea is the reform principle which he finds in the Scripture in other words Calvin's reformation was not innovation to him reformation was restoration he wanted to restore the church to its original integrity and he will often refer to the regulative principle not in those words that's the expression we use for it but if you look at the commentary on Hebrews 8.5 you'll see how Calvin expresses this Hebrews 8.5 says for when Moses was about to erect the tent he was instructed by God saying see that you make everything according to the pattern that was shown you on the mountain and the way Calvin interprets this and applies it is we're taught here that any mode of worship which is based on human inventions is false in contrary to God's command because God gives us instructions that everything is to be done according to his instruction it is unlawful for us to do anything different so Calvin looks at the church in Geneva and attempts to bring it into line with the Scripture he follows this idea God has told us what ought to be done in Hebrews 8.5 it applies particularly to worship but Calvin would also extend that to the order of the church the polity of the church and so on so you might say that's the primary principle that Calvin is using a secondary principle that Calvin uses and uses more than we would expect I think is tradition not only looks to see what the Scripture says he looks to see what the church has done in its history now Calvin is quite critical some of the tradition of the church but generally not on the early church he's critical of the medieval church but he believed that the church remained basically healthy both in its doctrine and in its practice for the first 500 years the consensus of the first 500 years the Calvin would speak about from time to time so Calvin is not of the mind to just wipe out everything that has transpired in 1500 years of Christian history and attempt to go back to some kind of New Testament pattern as the Anababdist and the other radicals wanted to do but he wanted to use wisely and thoughtfully the early tradition of the church some ways that may seem to bring a tension between the regular to principle and his appreciation for tradition and I'm not altogether sure how Calvin worked this out in his own mind but we have examples of Calvin's appreciation for tradition in for instance the mode of baptism will come to that later Calvin was quite sure that the mode of baptism practice in the New Testament was immersion and when he stealing with the baptism of the Ethiopian by Philip that go down into the water Calvin doesn't get nervous at that point like Presbyterians knew we generally point out that it was down in the desert so it must not have been much water and maybe they just got their feet wet something like that but Calvin says the early practice was immersion but the real significance of the mode is the application of water so it really doesn't matter how much water as long as water is used and he's quite comfortable with the idea that the early practice was immersion but the contemporary traditional practice was by a fusion which Calvin did but without too much concern that it wasn't being done exactly the way it was being done in the New Testament I suppose Calvin would reconcile the regular to principle with his acceptance of tradition there by saying the New Testament doesn't command at least in his understanding immersion it commands the use of water and so to use less water than was used originally would not be a violation of that command so we see Calvin develop his liturgy we see the same thing happening he's appreciative of traditional forms of worship and although Calvin's liturgy is not nearly so traditional as Luther's or as the book of common prayer of Kranber still he preserves much of the early style of Christian worship perhaps the most striking place where tradition comes in and you can add this I have mode of baptism and liturgy in the syllabus but in church government you also have Calvin's acceptance of tradition at least his willingness to tolerate certain developments in the early stages of church government although he did not advocate these ideas for the government of the church in Geneva but in chapter 4 of book 4 that's the condition of the ancient church and the kind of government in use before the papacy you go through that you'll see Calvin dealing with the early period by before the papacy he means before about 500 of course the Roman Catholic view is that the papacy starts with the early church but Calvin doesn't accept that there's the early church and then about 500 or so you can talk about the papal church but as Calvin investigates that early history you know it moves from a simple we would think in Calvin did two biblical polity with elders who are also called bishops that two are interchangeable and deacons two bishops archbishops patriarchs you get all of these steps in the development of church polity early on in the history of the church but rather than condemning all of that Calvin says this was connected with the maintenance of discipline so Calvin sees the hierarchy of the church developing and he explains it as connected with the maintenance of discipline and then he talks about arch deacons Calvin certainly doesn't have in his polity but neither is it found in the New Testament but he says this is a new and more exact kind of administration so he kind of sees a proper role for the arch deacons and then comes to doorkeepers acolytes and sub deacons all of those offices existed in the early church too fairly early not right at the beginning but within the first five centuries but rather than railing against that Calvin says these were steps in preparation for ministry so you can see that Calvin is concerned for basic scriptural principles but has a good bit of tolerance for different ideas that can develop in the history of the church he doesn't embody all of that within his own polity but I think his relaxed attitude there toward tradition shows a certain breadth in Calvin that we don't always subscribe to him now you come to the following chapters after chapter 4 chapters 5 through 11 what he's doing with what he calls the papal church and there he can be quite strong in his opinion with a good bit of invective added in what he considers very improper changes in a real deterioration in the life of the church Calvin's increasing emphasis on the church reformed into diva and then in his doctrine of the church or his writing in the institutes and elsewhere on the church we see the importance of the church for Calvin Calvin laid increasing stress on the church in his practice so he gives a corresponding significance to the doctrine of the church in the institutes here I think he goes far beyond Luther doesn't pay a lot of attention to the institution of the church Luther is concerned with the gospel preach the gospel and everything else will take care of itself so as far as the church was concerned Luther was willing to let the state structure the church to a large extent but Calvin's generation later gives much more attention to the doctrine of the church Calvin faced more than Luther proliferating sectarianism that is many many churches of different kinds particularly on the fringe of the reformation and he also faced a resurgent catholicism that was being strengthened by the ongoing council of Trent and the work of the Jesuits so the issue of the church what is the church what is the true church how do we describe the church how do we understand the church becomes much more central to Calvin's thinking there are two themes that I think we see as we look at Calvin's doctrine of the church not only in the institutes but in other writings as well in Calvin wrote quite a few treatises that are collected and we can read those some are on theological issues but many deal with the church it's practice it's polity and its authenticity the two themes that we need to be aware of are these the purity of the church and the unity of the church we'll look a little later at Calvin's view of the purity of the church I recommend Dr. Barker's Calvin and Ecclesiastical separation which was an article in the Presbyterian Journal 1985 for a good statement of Calvin's view of church purity and when it becomes necessary to separate from an impure church I remember a few years ago a group of us visited Princeton seminary and we were doing a two or I was giving lectures at Princeton we went to the university and to the seminary and to the cemetery have to go to both in Princeton or all three and at the seminary we were being welcomed by one of the professors there who's a friend of mine and this professor said something about the fact that sism is a sin and undoubtedly he had in mind the fact that we were PCA people not PC USA people but he said it's a sin but it's not an unforgivable sin and I suppose he thought we would feel better about it if he added that we could be forgiven of the sin of sism but it struck me as a rather strange statement for a Presbyterian to make because Calvin certainly left the church of his day and we'll come to that and see reasons for it but we should also emphasize Calvin's concern for the unity of the church in his commentary on 1 Corinthians 110 he said the most important principle of our religion is this that we should be in concord among ourselves his letter to Kranmer April 1552 this was when Edward VI said become the boy king and Calvin was concerned to bring unity within the Protestant groups he said so much does this concern me that could I be of any service I would not grudge to cross even 10 seas if need be on account of it I suppose that's a kind of daring statesman for a man who lived most of his life in landlock Switzerland to think about crossing 10 seas would be a daring feat but Calvin says I would do that I would do anything if I could bring unity to the church Calvin yearned for unity he even attended a few colloquies with Roman Catholics without a great deal of hope but at least he was there to see if there could be some sort of bringing together of the different parts of the church but he was also fearful that unity might be established on a wrong basis kind of covering over of differences rather than really commitment to the word of God I think one writing of these writings that I referred to a moment ago that you might note on this theme was writing the Calvin produced in 1549 it was his response to the Augsburg interim that was a law that had been passed in the empire Charles the Fifth wanted to bring unity to the empire and the Augsburg interim basically stated Roman Catholic doctrines but with some concessions to Protestants and Calvin could not accept that because Roman Catholic teaching on justification and other doctrines were imposed and the concessions to Protestants were in his minor but his book in 1549 was called on the true peace and unity of the reformed church you can see something of Calvin's concern there to bring unity to the church all right all of that has to do with Calvin in the church kind of background material what I want to do next in this comes before the next main point in the syllabus which is a investigation of the title is to talk a little bit about the relation between book 4 and the first three books just to see where we are in the overall development of Calvin's thought you remember that Calvin is following the Apostles Creed among other structures this is one one structural form that he has in mind I believe in God the Father treats that in book one believe in Jesus Christ treats Christ in book two I believe in Holy Spirit treats the Holy Spirit in book three because we say that I should just mention what I mentioned before is that Calvin is very trenditarian in his thought so book one is the Trinity book two is the Trinity book three is the Trinity but within the Trinity there is special emphasis on the Father in book one Christ in book two and the Holy Spirit in book three and the Apostles Creed continues I believe the Holy Catholic Church communion of saints the forgiveness of sins the resurrection of the body in the life everlasting and with holy Catholic church communion of saints forgiveness of sins we can see all of that in book four but I think we have to say that he also treats communion of saints and forgiveness of sins in book three so these themes in the Apostles Creed are treated in both book three and book four in the institutes and then the final two statements resurrection of the body in the life everlasting Calvin has already treated that in the end of book three in chapter 25 you know from our reading today Calvin makes a point of something that maybe you haven't thought about but he says there's no good reason to assert the end of book three to assert the end I end in the phrase I believe in the church that's four one two creed says I believe in God the Father Almighty maker of heaven and earth and in Jesus Christ is only son and so on I believe in the Holy Ghost and then there's a comma or a semicolon and then you have a list the Holy Catholic Church the communion of saints forgiveness of sins resurrection of the body in the life everlasting and Calvin says that we should leave the end out at least not repeat it in our thinking we believe in God the Father we believe in Jesus Christ is only son our Lord and we believe in the Holy Ghost but we don't believe in the Holy Catholic Church and he wants to make this distinction we believe in God because our mind reposes in him as truthful in our trust rest in him so we believe in God but we believe certain other truths we don't believe in them we believe in God and then we believe that there is a Holy Catholic Church that there is such a thing as communion of saints we believe that God forgives sins we believe that the body will be raised we believe that there is eternal life you see the difference between believing the truthfulness of those statements and resting your faith in a person so to make a distinction Calvin says we believe in God but we don't believe in the church we don't rest our faith in the church we rest our faith in God alone it's another way to connect the material that has gone before and the book four how I would do it book four it seems to me is not a continuation of books one to three as such so you have here one two three plus four that would be one way to see it that would be kind of a normal way to see it I think Calvin has given us book one book two book three and now we go into book four but I think rather than seeing book four as a continuation of the first three books after all we've ended book three with the final resurrection so in one sense we have finished Calvin has finished it's gotten us to heaven that's the end so rather than seeing book four as the next step you might say I would think it would be better to see book four as a gathering up of the themes that Calvin has already discussed and placing those in the concrete earthly experience of the believer so you might say that one two three equals four what we've studied so far in Calvin it leads us into book four in which all that we have learned about God the father son in the Holy Spirit will be worked out in our day by day earthly existence in the church and as citizens of the state or another way to diagram it perhaps would be this first three books point to book four and book four points back to the first three books so there are different ways you can look at the relationship between these books but something like this I think is helpful or here's another way somewhat it's not it book one talks about fallen creatures and really the first part of book two and then book two in book four give us Christ's redemption and the church's ministry of the gospel which then leads to book three which is our salvation book two is the the inward work or book three is the inward application and book four the outward helps or aids so if you look at it this way book one shows our need in the first part of book two shows our need in the first part of book two shows our need and then book two the provision that God makes for our need in Christ and in the church because it's the church that's going to minister Christ to us we hear the gospel through the church we are taught by the church and that leads us then to salvation Christ okay let's take a closer look at the title and execute that for a few minutes the external means or aids by which God invites us into the society of Christ and holds us there in the society of Christ seems to be an unusual expression I think what Calvin means by that is fellowship with Christ or to use an expression that Calvin uses more than fellowship with Christ union with Christ it's the way in which God invites us and notice those words invite us is giving an invitation he's inviting us to join with his son society of Christ as we move through book four will more and more take on also the meaning of the church but in the title I think it means union with Christ or fellowship with Christ because one of the means or aids by which this is accomplished is the church so society of Christ God invites us into the society of Christ but how does God do that and Calvin says God uses external means if you'd like to book three you would say there is the primary agent the Holy Spirit which is an internal means Holy Spirit faith, repentance and so on but book four talks about external means so not only is there the internal work of the Spirit to invite us into the society of Christ or to unite us to Christ but there are these external means by which the Spirit works Calvin says in four one one to be get and increase faith in us I really is the whole theme of book three be getting and increasing faith in us spirit works to be get and increase faith in us book three but there are external means by which the Spirit works book four and we come to those external means you have a visible earthly institution called the church you have human words spoken by human lips we call preaching or the sermon you have water called baptism bread and wine which we eat call the Lord supper so these external means are used by the Holy Spirit to invite us into fellowship with Christ or union with Christ and to keep us therein when Calvin explains this as he does in four one one he asks the question why do we need this or why does God do this why can't we just end with the final resurrection why do we need these external things and why do we need what is Calvin's answer there why do we need the church and baptism and the Lord supper and preaching why does God use these things why does he choose to work through external means does he have to do it that way well not really but we need these things because of our weakness Calvin says so it's God's graciousness to us we're shut up in the prison house of our flesh Calvin says four one one we have not yet attained angelic rank we were angels we would not need these external means but we're not so God in his wonderful providence accommodates himself that use of accommodation which we noted so often in the institutes God accommodates himself to our capacity by giving us outward helps so that we though still far off can draw near to him so we need we need to hear the sermons need to hear the word preach by preachers we needed the church and all of the church does we need to know that water has been placed upon us in baptism we need to eat the bread and drink the wine it's all for us because we're bodily creatures we're not angelic rank we're not spirits only so these external means are important and useful by which God these are means by which God invites us into the society of Christ and holds us there in Calvin means to say that these are God's means these are means of grace the church sacraments they're not devices that belong to us that we can somehow use to manipulate God it was more of the medieval idea sacramental system and if you do it right then you get grace but Calvin says these are God's means by which he gives grace to us outward helps to be get and increase faith within us and there means by which God invites us into fellowship with Christ and holds us therein or we could say as we go further in before invites us into the church and holds us therein so there's not only salvation regeneration here but perseverance as well these means God uses to bring us to faith and to keep us in faith God doesn't raise us to perfection in a moment Calvin says we know that from our early study book three of his doctrine of repentance it's a lifelong race God does not raise us to perfection in a moment but makes us grow little by little under the nurture of the church that's one four one five place of sanctification or the Christian is not the individual Christian it's not the isolated Christian that is not the context of sanctification it's the church the congregation believers in which all the blessings which God bestows upon them are mutually communicated to each other four one three Calvin adds this to in four one five although God's power is not bound to outward means he has nonetheless bound us to this ordinary matter of teaching in other words God could do without the church God could work without the church if he so chose to do it that way but we can't we're bound to the outward means God is not bound to the outward means it's his choice to give us a church and to give us baptism and to give us the Lord's supper but it's not our choice as to whether we accept those are not the Christian cannot opt out of the visible church and the outward means there's no such thing in Calvin as a kind of private Christianity the corrective of the reformers to the abuses of Roman Catholic church was not individual Christianity they were not saying the structure is evil come out of it and just relate directly to God without the abuses and evil that we find in the visible church the corrective of the reformers was a purified church they never really none of them move away from a high view of the church just as high as Roman Catholic you but a purified church and then personal appropriation of the teachings of the church not just a mechanical going through the motions is what is required okay any questions on any of that before we move on to the next point 15 minutes I could go back to finish business on election but I have the wrong notebook for that so I'll still do that at some point but let's go ahead and begin with the nature of the church then what is the true church that's an important question how can one be right with God how can I find a gracious God and what is the church those were the two burning issues I would say on the 16th century and really of any century but particularly on the 16th century is it possible for a person to say I'm no longer a Roman Catholic it still be a Christian when I reject them I ask and leave the Catholic church am I a member of the church anymore all kinds of answers were given two questions like that and here's Calvin's way of dealing with that Calvin stresses as did Augustine but contrary to most Roman Catholic teaching in the medieval period Calvin stresses that there are two churches two true churches a visible church and an invisible church now we should not think of these as two entirely separate entities without any relation to each other but they're not identical either so when we talk about the church we have to talk about the church in two ways visible and invisible the invisible church is the church as God sees it 417 all the elect from the beginning of the world we can't see that church because we can't see what is before us or what is coming after us nor can we truly see all the elect now that's the church as God sees it for us that church is an object of faith it's not an object of experience we believe that there is an invisible church pure church perfect church in which God select through all ages are gathered but the church that we know the church that we see is the visible church for us that is an object of experience and Calvin's definition of visible church 417 is the whole multitude of men he means people spread out over the earth who profess to worship one God in Christ so the visible church is the professing church everywhere we cannot identify the visible church with the elect we can't say that the visible church is the invisible church because we're not able to do that Calvin quotes a gustan mini sheep are without and mini wolves are within a gustan said their their sheep outside of the visible church and their wolves within the visible church a little puzzling to know exactly what a gustan or Calvin meant by that their sheep outside did they mean that there are elect people who are not yet justified you know there are elect people in the world certainly we're not saved yet because they haven't come to repentance in faith in Christ they will because there are elect so they are not in the visible church at least not yet or did Calvin mean something else did he mean that it's possible for a person to be so cut off from the visible church say in Roman Catholic territory where there's no Protestant church and Calvin was very much set against Protestant converts continuing to be members of Catholic churches in participating in the mass or perhaps Christians in areas controlled by the Turks in Eastern Europe where there would not be the opportunity to worship God in a church there would be true Christians elect people not yet brought to faith or people who had come to faith who for one reason or another not of their own choosing but because of circumstances found themselves outside of the visible church whatever Calvin meant whatever a gustan meant they certainly make it clear that they do not identify the visible church as the whole number of the elect there are elect sheep outside and they make it clear too that not everybody in the visible church is elect there wolves within it's easier to understand that one because that means that there are people who are visibly connected with the church who are not truly regenerate and could be described not as sheep but as wolves so Calvin says to know who are his is a prerogative belonging solely to God we leave that with him so we cannot identify the visible church with the elect but we must judge the members of the Christian church with charity but here's the point that I think is important because Calvin isn't always viewed as charitable but he certainly is in many places and certainly at this point he says in 418 we recognize as members of the church those who by confession of faith by example of life and by partaking of the sacraments profess the same God and Christ with us so we see people who are members of the visible church those people hold to the gospel they live good lives and they per take of the sacraments and they profess to believe in God and Christ and Calvin says as far as we're concerned we can call those people Christians we don't have to know whether they are elect or not we can't and we should not judge them harshly we should accept their profession unless in some way they deny their profession by the way they live these aspects of the church we could call them invisible invisible not two churches but two aspects of the church churches God sees it churches we experience it it might be helpful to look at it this way you can use a circle here for the invisible church and then there's a circle for the visible church and these are two aspects of the church and these overlap just to a certain degree you can do it something like this so there is an overlapping of these circles part of the visible membership falls outside the sphere of election so you've got part of the visible church that cannot be identified with the invisible church there's chaff as well as wheat and some of the elect some of the invisible church fall outside the sphere of the visible community for reasons that I discussed a few minutes ago one place where Calvin makes this clear is that unlike the Roman Catholics and unlike the Lutherans Calvin did not insist that baptism was necessary for salvation baptism is necessary for salvation then there is no way that an unbaptized person could be saved and it's necessary then to be a member of the visible church for salvation one place where we see this is Calvin's commentary on John three five Jesus answered I tell you the truth unless a man is born of water and the spirit he cannot enter the kingdom of heaven Calvin deals with that text at some length and actually comes to the view that it doesn't have anything to do with baptism at all water baptism but he says this but even were we to grant that Christ is speaking of baptism here we ought not to press his words so as to make him confine salvation to the outward sign on the contrary he connects water with the spirit because under the visible sign he testifies and seals the newness of life which by his spirit got alone effects in us it's we're born of the water and the spirit the water for Calvin is the cleansing which the Holy Spirit brings in regeneration and Calvin goes on to say it is true indeed that we are excluded from salvation if we neglect baptism in this sense I confess it is necessary but it is absurd to confine assurance of salvation to the sign in other words the outward means is there and we can't reject it if we have opportunity to embrace it but the salvation doesn't reside in the outward means it resides in the inward cleansing of the Holy Spirit which has already been accomplished so by not requiring baptism for salvation Calvin is able to think of people who have been regenerated but for one reason or another not of their own choice it would be wrong if it was of their own choice but for one reason or another have not been baptized as still true members of the church members of the invisible church so that's one way that Calvin looks at the church visible and invisible but there's another way that he looks at the church and this is at the visible church and that is true and false that's what we will come to next time. Some said that the visible and visible distinction is someone comes and you are uncomfortable with that. Yes, certainly not to Calvin he's very clear that this is a useful way of looking at the church. Not to the Westminster Divines they found it a useful way of looking at the church also. I rather like it I think it's helpful because you have the concept of the invisible church which is always there to guard against our identifying the earthly institution as all the church should be. So I think we need it the danger I think is that it can be used by some it perhaps has been used by some to deemphasize the importance of the visible church. I'm a member of the invisible church so I don't have to go to church this Sunday because that's the visible church and that's not so important. So if it's used to deemphasize the importance of the visible church then it's very bad. If we use the idea of the invisible church to speak of a pure church without smart and without blemish which is the church that's going to be in heaven then I think we can use it to judge the failures of the visible church. So I would say let's keep it think it's useful. Okay?