<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Dona Dona mensilmente

The Doctrine of Creation

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

This week and next week on Chapter 15 in my book Systematic Theology, the Doctorate of Creation. And the schedule, as I kind of look through the next few weeks, looks like this. We'll talk today specifically about this question of creation and evolution and the controversy over that topic. Next Sunday, I want to talk about the disputes over the age of the Earth, is the Earth just basically it concerns whether the days in Genesis are 24 hour days or whether they're long periods of time or whether there's something else. And there are different theories. And so I'll give a try at that next week anyway. And then that finishes the Doctorate of Creation. Then we move on to Chapter 16 in the middle of October 15th. God's Providence, God's sovereignty over the world, if God is sovereign over all things, then how does that account for our individual freedom, our individual responsibility? And that's a really tough question. We plan to take two weeks on that question. And then go on to October 29th, the next chapter in the book, Chapter 17, would be the question of miracles, and can miracles occur and what are the purposes of miracles in the Bible? And are there miracles today? Thank you. Pammy already answered the question. She said yes, you didn't hear it. And then go on on November 5th and probably for the next two or three weeks on November 5th and following talk about the Bible's teaching on prayer. And the sequence here is we talked about the Doctor of God and the attributes of God. Now here's what God has done creating the world. And here's how God relates to the world in Providence. And then the question of Providence and God's relation to the world gets us into the question of miracles and God's intervention in the world. And then prayer, how we relate to God who created the universe and who governs it. So that's kind of the progression of thought. That looks like the topics to come. 18th and 19 angels and chapter 20 Satan and demons are the parts of the creation. So that's kind of where we're going for the fall. Summary of the Doctor of Creation. Is there anything else I need to do procedurally? Can't take care of the announcements where I'll set, right? Okay. God created, this is the summary we talked about a few weeks ago. God created the universe out of nothing. It was originally very good and he created it to glorify himself. Now we talked about what it meant to create the universe out of nothing. Special creation of Adam and Eve. We talked about the goodness of the creation, God's purpose in the creation. That's all in past weeks. So now we get to this question. We started on two weeks ago. The relationship between the Bible and the findings of modern science. And this is just a few slides that are just going to be reviewed. And how many of you do? Do all of you have this outline? I'm going to take this one actually for myself. Who needs an outline? That's what I'm supposed to be doing. Hold up your hand and I'll hear some. Okay. Just keep your hand up and one will come around. Okay. So we're under on that handout. We're under number two. Some theories about creation. Well, we're under number one. First, the relationship between Scripture and the findings of modern science. I talked about that last week with the points that Francis Shaffer made in his book, No Final Conflict. Now, I'll just review this. It's often since here Christian faith and strong trust in the Bible. I've led scientists to discovery of new facts about God's universe, as with Newton and Galileo and Kepler and many, many other scientists. And so, surely, it's not true that belief in God and belief in the Bible are incompatible with sound scientific investigation. And a number of you in this class have actually, in your careers, been involved in various aspects of science and scientific research and discovery. And so, it has been throughout history. But as with Galileo, when Galileo said the sun was the center of the solar system, there were some people in actually then at the Roman Catholic church in Italy, who said, no, wait a minute, that's contrary to the Bible, but they were claiming more than the Bible said. The Bible doesn't say that the sun goes around the earth. They were just kind of trying to, they were concluding that incorrectly. And they persecuted Galileo, forced him to recant, but it was a story, that's a story history in the story of conflict between science and Christianity, because people were arguing for more than the Bible actually said. Creation is not something that can be recreated in a laboratory experiment, or they're human observers. So, it stands to reason that if there was somebody watching and then who tells us about it, namely got himself, we should take his words as reliable. In fact, he's the one who made the universe. We should take his words on it as reliable. But then what about the conflicts between the Bible and science? I think, again, I want to repeat this. We should not fear scientific investigation of the facts of the created world, but should do so eagerly and with complete honesty, confident when the facts are rightly understood, they'll always turn out to be consistent with God's inherent words in scripture. I don't think the Bible is just to teach us about our relationship to God, and kind of moral conduct of right and wrong, and to teach us about whatever it does teach us about. And if it has statements about the way the universe came into being, then we should believe those and accept those, because those are also things that God decided to tell us. And so then we started out here at point two. Some theories of creation seem clearly inconsistent with the teachings of scripture. Any secular theories that don't see God as responsible for creating the universe by intelligent design, that is, people will say, well, how did the universe came to being? Well, there was just a big bang. Well, where the big bang come from? Well, it just happened. That's a secular theory. Now, maybe there was kind of a God-caused explosion of a matter that came out, you know, suddenly radiated it out from one point in the universe. But if we remove God from that, then I think that's surely contrary to the biblical teaching. And then I just started to get into this theistic evolution, which is the idea that God just guided the process of evolution proposed by Darwin, though there was maybe God intervening at the point of creating matter, and creating life, and perhaps creating man. So, okay, God said, here's matter, and then it all just randomly evolved. Then here's a very tiny maybe one cell organism that it evolved into plants and fish and mammals, man. But no, it man. Then God said, okay, now I'm going to create man. That's kind of a, it all evolved, as scientists say, by random mutation, over billions of years, but God kind of oversaw it at certain points. And I'm saying, I don't think that that position is consistent with the Bible's teaching, because the randomness of evolutionary theory, which is really the driving force, the random mutation, that's incompatible with Scripture's teaching on the purposefulness of God's work. And so God created things according to their kinds, not just letting them evolve into all sorts of other things. And the driving force of evolutionary themes is randomness. By contrast, God created specific things and according to their kinds, and when He created each thing, it was good. And well, this is just, at any particular point, I think God would, theistic evolution would have to say, God said, let the earth birth, living creatures according to their kinds, and after 300,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, but in fact, God was an important person to order a total of 2,817 attempts, God finally made a mouse that worked. I mean, that thinks that's what you have to say. If you say, well, it was evolution all along, except that matter, life, and man, well, then you've got a whole bunch of failures instead of saying, let the earth bring forth living creatures and all of a sudden, So, but when people say God intervened, then you don't have evolution. So I mean, you're kind of straddling both worlds, and I think that's not a good solution. Now, it's the idea that God's creative word brings immediate response. We talked about that last week. Okay, that's review up to that point. Now, I want to talk particularly about the Darwinian theory of evolution, and that'll expand a little bit more on what I was saying about randomness, I think, being not an accurate explanation of what happened. Before I talk about Darwinian theory of evolution, I want to define some terms. What, in fact, do we mean by evolution? First, there is, well, I'm just going to say micro-evolution and macro-evolution. A micro-evolution is small development within one species. That is, certain kinds of bacteria develop immunities. People, or certain kinds of insects develop immunities to certain insecticides. People can breed roses, so they become different colors and sizes and shapes of roses. And human beings are getting taller over time. That's a variation within the human species. Everybody agrees that happens. No, there's no objection at all. You see it, you observe it. In fact, we can cause it to happen, whether it's hybrid crops or hybrid cattle or whatever. And so that is not the argument. That is not the argument at all. I don't know anybody in the world that disagrees, that that happens. The question is, whether you can extrapolate that little, that small variation within species, whether you can extrapolate that to say, ah, the same thing happened to give rise to all living things. So you had non-living matter, it became a living cell, and then became a more complex cell, and then became some kind of plant, and became some kind of fish, and became some kind of animal, and became some kind of mammal, and became some kind of eventually human being. That's the question, whether you get macro evolution. And that is the idea here that I've just taken from a book by Wayne Fair, non-living substance, gave rise to the first living material, which subsequently reproduced, and diversified to produce all extinct and extant organisms, all organisms, so that here is macro evolution, and in this sense you have no creative direction or plan by God, it just happened. How did it happen? Well, one cell became one cell became one cell, and just there were cells, there were cells, there were cells, all of a sudden there were two cells, and these two cells had an advantage over the one cell. So they decided to have more two-celled animals, or organisms, and then all of a sudden, well, they didn't decide though, it just happened. And so then we have more and more and more complex organisms, and there are, and so then you get that complexity increasing just by random mutation, and the more complex and better ones, then lead to all extinct things. Now, there are challenges, there are current challenges to Darwinian evolution. And Darwinian evolution is actually the same as today, as what Charles Darwin proposed in 1859 in the origin of species, because there's more complexity to it, more refinement of the theory, but in principle it's the same. It's that life began when a mix of chemicals present on Earth spontaneously produced a very simple, probably a one-celled life form, and this living cell reproduced itself. And then eventually there were some mutations or differences in the new cells produced, leading to the development of more complex life form. Now, a hostile environment meant that many would die, but those best suited to their environment survived, and that's called natural selection, or survival of the fittest, and kind of a quick phrase. Those best suited to their environment survived. Now, there have been, I suppose, hundreds of books challenging this theory, from the time that Darwin first proposed it, but in 1991, I think a large step upward in the sophistication of the arguments against Darwinian evolution was made by a man named Philip Johnson. Philip Johnson at the time, he's now retired, but at the time was a professor at University of California, Berkeley, which is a major research university, and he was a law professor, and he had taught there for 20 years, and his specialty was teaching law students how to argue, and so he had a specialist in the nature of argument, and how words are used in argument, and how logic is used in argument. Now, Philip Johnson was rather bright man. He went to Harvard, then he went to the University of Chicago law school, and now, how do you decide who the best student, what's an indication of the best students in the university? Now, the University of Chicago law school is absolutely one of the hardest ones to get into, one of the best law schools in the nation, and then the very best students from that law school go on to clerk for different judges, and if you clerk for a district court or a circuit court judge, that means you're really bright, but if you get to be the clerk for a Supreme Court judge, well, that means you're just one of the very brightest people in the whole nation at that time. Well, Philip Johnson, after graduating from the University of Chicago law school, became law clerk for chief justice, Earl Warren of the United States Supreme Court, so he's pretty bright, and then he went to the University of law school and taught signs of argument. Well, a few years prior to 1991, he began reading in some scientific literature, and he began reading arguments that people were making regarding Darwinian evolution. I think his interest was aroused in this because there were some legal cases where Louise, for instance, had a law requiring that alternative to evolution be explained to students, and then this worked through the court system, and Philip Johnson was reading some of these law cases, and he said, this is very interesting. And the more he read of the arguments in favor of Darwinian evolution, the more he said, this is circular reasoning. It's basically saying, how do we know what happened? Well, because it happened. Or it's reasoning based on defining the words so that no objections count against your theory. And so one thing he said was happening was that the word science was being defined to be only things that are found in the natural world. Well, all right. So only things you can measure touch or record that is the material created. That's all that science deals with. Well, that's fine if you want to define science that way. Unless then you say that science now gets to tell you about how the universe came into existence. Well, if someone says, well, I think God created the universe, people say, well, that's not science. Well, you say, yeah, but that's what happened. Well, you can't say that because that's not science. What kind of an argument is that? That's not bringing evidence. That's not saying God didn't create it. That's just saying, I've already defined the word science to say it can't be created. Well, who told you you get to define the word science to say that something can't be created? Well, we just define science that way. And so am I making sense? OK. So by defining the nature of the word science, the lawyers who were opposing teaching of creation in schools, one, court battles. Philip Johnson said, well, since when does defining the word that you can use in the debate means that you're right? See, and he said, all the objections that were brought against evolutionary theory like, where's any evidence that you can have a simple, can you reproduce this? Can you show me a frog becoming a mammal? No. Can you show me fossils that show intermediate steps between a frog and a mammal? No. Well, if you don't have any evidence, then how can you say this is true? And then he said the evolutionists would answer, well, it happened. Well, then they would say, well, back to people who object to say, well, your answer. People say, well, I think God can. You can't say that. That's not science. Well, what if that's what happened? Well, it can't happen because that's not science. So it can't be that way. So that by saying that science is purely naturalistic, then that's expanded to acclaim about the nature of all reality. That is, the only thing that could have happened in history is what is in the material creation. I hope I'm explaining that clearly. Well, Philip Johnson became agitated of this. And he said, this is question begging argument. This is not sound argument. I wouldn't allow this in my courtroom. And I wouldn't want my students to argue this way. And he said, now, the mortars were muddied a little bit by a group called creation scientists. And then the Louisiana case, people were not only arguing that there was a designer created the Earth, but that it was 24-hour days and the Earth is very young. And then all the questions about the age of the Earth got involved in that. He said, I don't want to go there. I don't want to commit my, I don't want to, I said, I'm not a recreation science. I don't, I'm not arguing for that viewpoint. But I am very troubled that Darwinian evolution seems not to be based on evidence, but on assumptions that people bring to the argument, OK? So that's where his book goes. Now, because his book Darwin on trial, because it did, so he started reading all this, in fact, very sophisticated defenses of Darwinian evolution. And then he started going to these college campuses, major universities around the United States, and debating these proponents of evolution. And of course, he did very well in the debates. And he's just a kind of a friendly guy, and just a jovial guy, but just very, very bright. And he's not the kind of guy you want to get an argument with when the facts are not on your side. So yes, he is a believer. He goes to a Presbyterian church. In fact, he's on the faculty at Biola right now, after retired from Berkeley. So it's, Phil Johnson came two or three times just to talk, to speak at Trinity Divinity School. And I was teaching there. I've talked with him a number of occasions, and he spoke to our faculty. And he began to gather to himself a number of other very bright scientists and lawyers and other kinds of people who were writing and speaking and making arguments against Darwinian evolution. And I think they've had a large impact in the last, what is that, 15 years now. And the intelligent design movement, and Michael Behe in this book, Darwin's Black Box, which talks about the complexity of living cells, and how those just had to have been designed. They just couldn't have happened spontaneously. That those have, I think, made an impact, not to the point where, well, when we lived in Illinois,

a number of the people who are Baptist church that we attended in Libertyville also worked at Abbott Labs, which is a major pharmaceutical research labs. And they were a PhD biochemist or chemist or a biologist, a molecular biologist. And all of them, creationists, that is, they believed that God created the universe and didn't believe in Darwinian evolution. And I would say to them, well, do you know a lot of scientists who are creationists, they say, yes, a lot of them, many, many, many scientists who believe in creation. And I said, do you know of any who have appointments as faculty in the biology, say, at major research universities, and they said, no, not one, because this is kind of a creed of orthodoxy. Well, let me get on to some of the things that Johnson said. But I guess where I wanted to bring that to a close was to say, I think that Johnson and those who follow him are having an increasing impact on the debate, because it's a very high level, high quality argument that they're bringing, and they just can't be ignored. And they're very hard to dismiss. And Johnson's strategy was get others with him,

and then to reach high school and college students who love to have a cause to champion and give them enough evidence so they can raise very difficult questions in the university classrooms and things like that. So I think it's going to increasingly have an impact and a positive impact. Philip Johnson, when I was at Biola three or four weeks ago, he, I'm afraid in the last couple of years, he's suffered some serious strokes. Strokes, and so he's not teaching full-time anymore, and I don't know if he will be able to. He's not very old, he's only 66, but he's given his lifetime

to a very worthwhile thing that's going to carry on after him. All right, well here are some of his art. He said, first, Johnson said, the amount of variation produced in 100 years of research is still evenly limited. He said, you can breed dogs for a champion, for where are you going to eat him more? Is he here today? You have championship dogs, no, you show dogs. And you can breed dogs to become better, you know, I don't know what I'm saying, what am I saying? There's a huge range of type of dog from these little tiny doglets to huge, great names, and, you know, but they're still dogs. And Johnson says, no matter how much you try, you can't breed dogs to become as large as elephants. There's a genetic limitation to the range of variation in size. And no matter how much you try, you still get dogs, and they don't become another kind of animal. Moreover, if you want to see what happens with random mutation, just release these hybrid dogs into the wild, and within a generation or two, they all revert to kind of average mongrels of some sort. And so they're still dogs, but that is, it's not just that randomness doesn't produce anything, intelligent, active, trying attempts to produce variation beyond the limitations of the genetic range of what dogs are, don't produce anything else. So dogs are still dogs, and fruit flies are still fruit flies, even though you can get micro evolution, as I said, as within fruit flies, you can get different kinds of fruit flies, or fruit flies that have resistant to certain kind of insecticides and things. B, almost, and then here's where Johnson's skill analyzing arguments came to play. He said, almost any characteristic of any living animal can be said to give it some advantage in surviving with imagination.

The polar bears have white skin. Oh, it hides them. Why do other animals have dark skin? Well, it keeps them warm. I mean, light skin works, dark skin works. Large skull works, small skull works, everything helps in some way. Having wings is an advantage. You can fly away from predators. What about these little beetles that don't have wings? Well, that's an advantage because of something else, so that it's what Johnson says is a non-falsifiable argument that is, what would count as evidence against Darwinian evolution on the Darwinian viewpoint? Nothing, because everything that you find in every living creature is just argued to be, well, this gives it some kind of advantage. So what natural selection really means is that the animals that survive are those that survive. It's a tautology, says Johnson, but it's not a persuasive argument to support a theory and practice those that survive through generations. Are those that have the greatest number of offspring? This proves nothing about mutations. So whereas Darwinian theory is attempting to say these rabbits, these rabbits survive because they have these characteristics

they can hop and run and I don't know. How do you know that that's why they survived? How do you know it isn't because God created rabbits that way? Well, that's not science. Well, does that really tell you anything that you know as an established fact about what happened? It's just a theory, isn't it? Okay, so he says it's not a persuasive argument. And then the other thing is that the vast and complex mutations required to produce complex organs. That is an eye. Some of you, Rick or others of you or physicians here know that the eye has just so many things needed to make it function or a bird's wing has so much design to it and so many different bold to be in place and joints and feathers and all that it isn't just one tiny mutation so you get a little bit different kind of feather. You've got to have all the bone structure and everything else that those complex mutations could not have occurred in tiny mutations accumulating over thousands of generations because the individual parts of the organ are useless. They give no advantage until unless the entire organ is functioning and then the mathematical probability of thousands of such random mutations happening in one organism all at one time and one generation is effectively zero. In other words, you've got something that's crawling along the ground or it can't fly and it needs wings to fly. We've got to get a mutation that in one animal has a whole lot of different kinds of bones and different kinds of feathers attached to the bones and tendons and ligaments and nerves and then it attaches to the body and then the nerves that make it flap you know that go to the brain that make it do this and that's thousands of mutations in one organism at one time because if you just get one that has bones without feathers it doesn't help it you know it's going like this and it can't get off the ground or it has feathers without bones it's kind of going like this and it can't get off the ground and so and if it has feathers and bones without the nerves that go out of the brain that says I mean that's thousands upon thousands of mutations just happened to happen and all that that happened well look here's a bird it had to happen we know what happened because because birds have wings well wait a minute what about an alternative explanation what about the idea that there was a god who designed it that way so it worked that's not science you can't say that well what if it's true you still can't say it you can't say it and and well so anyway that that well so the mathematical probability of that is effectively zero and people start multiplying out the map of the west statistical ability and the get lots of ways of saying zero and Darwinists are left saying that it must have happened because it happened and now the humorous example I took from another book is this thing called the bombardier beetle and I'm just going to read you a little paragraph about this beetle in a book by co fall and see graves the creation explanation the bombardier beetle repels enemies by firing a hot charge of chemicals from two swivel tubes on its tail the chemicals fired by this beetle will spontaneously explode when mixed together in a laboratory you put these two chemicals together in the laboratory power you get an explosion and it's inside a beetle why doesn't explode inside the beetle well the beetle has an inhibitor substance that blocks the explosive reaction until the beetle squirt some of this liquid into its quote combustion chambers where an end is added to it to analyze the reaction an explosion takes place and the beetle shoots a chemical repellent at its enemy at a temperature of two hundred and twelve degrees Fahrenheit at the beat and it's very effective now so I don't know so so you've got so you've got two chemicals that will explode they don't the there's an inhibitor that keeps it from exploding and then it goes into this chamber and then there's an enzyme that makes it explode so you need the two chemicals the inhibitor and the enzyme co fall and see graves say this note that a rational evolutionary explanation for the development of this creature must assign some kind of adaptive advantage that is adaptive advantage helps it live and give birth to more offspring for the next generation has to have an advantage to each of the millions of hypothetical intermediate stages in the construction process but with the stages of one-fourth one-half or two-thirds completion have conferred any advantage for all a rifle is useless with all its without all its parts functioning so you know what about these swivel tubes you don't have an explosive mixture I didn't do any good hey what are you doing got these hey beetle why do you have these extra tubes oh I don't know maybe in a thousand years I'll get something to explode inside them it doesn't really make any sense to have the tubes without the explosive mixture don't you think they look kind of nice well I'm elaborating before the but now I'm reading before the defense of mechanism could afford any protection to the beetle all of its parts together with the proper explosive mixture of chemicals plus the instinctive behavior required for its use to aim at the enemy would have to be assembled all the parts have to be assembled in the index the partially developed set of organs would be useless therefore according to the principles of evolutionary theory there would be no selective pressure to cause the system to evolve from a partially completed stage toward the final completed system if a theory to explain the data in any science that's a theory should either be revised or replaced with a theory that is in agreement with the data in this case of course now I say the amusing question is what would happen if the explosive chemical mixture developed in the beetle without the chemical inhibitor no more beetle and you can multiply as examples by by tens of thousands even with all the complex functions in our human body then Johnson goes on to say this the the fossil record does not reflect any intermediate species not in Darwin's day nor in 130 years of intensive archaeological activity and so Darwin said well okay I just got a little bit of data and I know I haven't found anything that's between a fish and a bird or between you know a frog and a larger mammals or something I know I haven't found any fossils that are between that but when people investigate more and they disorder fossils then we'll discover the intermediate types the missing links but in 130 years not have been discovered and and and some that have been claimed have turned out to be false and and Johnson has a little discussion of this archaeopteryx kind of half fish half bird kind of thing that in fact wasn't what it was claimed to be and there some other things that are kind of amazing hoaxes that have been perpetrated but no convincing evidence well if it really happened then why don't why why the fossil record have only just known kinds of animals either extinct or extend but no intermediate types well we're not sure but it still happened because that's science and we've defined science to mean can't have God in it and therefore it's got to be true because we've defined it that way so Johnson said this is not a persuasive argument if you if if if if attempting to produce this variation doesn't work so you don't have experimental confirmation if it's based on a tautology that's not a persuasive there's no the evidence isn't supporting the argument the form of argument isn't supporting the argument the difficulties involve in the process are so unlikely as to be impossible that doesn't support the argument and there's more historical evidence that doesn't support the argument so the argument is beginning to look very weak says Johnson and then there are others and you could go on quoting lots and lots of other evidence this way Michael Denton was an Australian physician who a non-Christian but he wrote a book called Evolution of Theory in Crisis 1986 and he says since Darwin's time neither of the mental axioms of Darwin's microevolutionary theory the concept of the continuity of nature there's the idea of a functional continuum of all life forms linking all species together and leading back to a primeval cell and the belief that the adaptive design of result of life has resulted from a blind random process neither of those axioms have been validated by one single empirical discovery or scientific advance since 19 since 1859 so where's the evidence well we have animals and we have people here so it must have happened but that Johnson says that's not a persuasive argument now what about similarities in molecular structures I remember back in a junior high biology book where my friend whose dad taught biology at the local state university he said when you've got to believe in evolution look here's a cell from a gorilla or you know here's a cell from a dog or here's a cell and you blow them up and they look the same as a cell from a human cell from animal blood and human blood or animal skin animal bone you look the same that means the one evolved into the other and Johnson says and I think it's right there is a relationship there but does that imply a common ancestry or does it imply a common designer that is I could go into a museum on the history of automobiles and I could go back to a Model T Ford and then I could go to a Ford from the 1960s and then I could go through a Ford from today and say hey look Model T has a steering wheel Ford today has a steering wheel Model T has wheels has four wheels a 2006 Ford has four wheels and they both have doors I can't remember but you could point out all these similarities and here there's an axle and a driveshaft and whoa modern cars must have evolved from Model T's by a random mutation and you say no I think there was a common designer or a team of designers and they found things that worked in Model T's and they used them in subsequent Ford's and they used them to Ford's today so the fact that cells look the same just mean maybe God found a good idea for a cell and and and he used it in similar ways more over evolution cannot explain how any life could have begun from a random mixing of chemicals and the improbability of that with the complexity of living things again is just a huge impossibility basically in fact Johnson quoting another fellow Fred Hoyle says that a living organism emerged by chance from prebiotic soup is about as likely as that a tornado sweeping through a junkyard might a Boeing 747 from the materials there in chance assembly is just a natural way naturalistic way of saying miracle in fact I think it is more likely that a tornado would produce us and you know how complex the 747 is I mean how it takes years to build and the electric wiring the parts inside that just unbelievable Rick you were inside the Boeing plant recently astounding yeah correct complexity I think a tornado creating 747 is more likely than random mutation producing a living cell or random gender why I here's my evidence people have produced a 747 people have not been able to produce a living cell so it's harder to produce a living cell than a 747 right I think it is out of non-living things okay and that's why I told you I was flying back from Philadelphia last fall sitting next to this atheist religion professor do you remember that and and and the complete and and as we landed Dallas and she had to get another plane out of the plane and my my phone buzzed and and it and all of a sudden up on the screen came this notice that my flight was taking off from such and such a gate such and such a time and that I said oh look she said how do you do that and I said well you go online for American Airlines and you can send them having get to send you a text email oh that's really that's really cool and I said yeah and then I said nobody made this it just happened and she said very funny but but we take it for that has to be produced by intelligence by intelligence and skill and a lot of work and it's not as complex as as a living organism so so why do we say that a living organism could be produced just by randomness by by chance by no direction well because if you say something else it's not science that is they've already ruled out the true answer by a kind of an arbitrary definition of what our answers will be allowed in billions of years and thousands of miles in distance with even generous masses of then there's some another statistical computation by this co-foil and secreties book thousand if you if you say you've got protein covering the earth every square foot of the earth's surface has 95 pounds of protein molecules that could mix freely and they're replaced with fresh protein every year for a billion years they say still the probability that one enzyme molecule would develop that one end you've got protein molecules making an enzyme molecule but enzyme molecule will develop in each billion years the probability is 1.2 times 10 to the 11 there one chance in 80 billion but how do you get the protein there at the first place and then you've got how do you get two active molecules 10 to the 22nd probability that they're identical 10 to the 70th and could life start from a single enzyme molecule in other words they get eventually the possibility of enzymes being formed and finding each other and producing again was they they calculate 10 to the 340 million power well maybe they're off by a factor of a million but but it's really unlikely now here's thing people are basing their entire view of what life is about and where it came from and whether they believe in God and their eternal destiny on this theory would I got out an airplane if the president of the airline said we land safely one in 10 to the 340 million no I wouldn't but but people are doing more than that they're pace placing their whole life in the belief in a theory that has this many probabilities with it why because we've defined science so you can't have so that so that one answer that people have believed throughout history that is that God created the universe what answer that about 70% of the people in the United States still believe that God created the universe that that answer can't be true because we won't allow it to be called science and science gets to define how life came about how do you get to define what life came about well we've just said that we do so that kind of scientific the current scientific community evolutionary establishment Darwinian evolution therefore Darwinian evolution should not be considered an established fact no question is what if someday what if someday scientists actually created a team of research scientists created life in a laboratory from non-living matter and there are sort of micro steps a long way that have happened I don't think this would prove evolution but it would just prove that life takes intelligent design to create that is you get a lot of the right materials to start with and then you have you know hundreds of scientists around the world over generations contributing research and millions of dollars of equipment and then you create something that lives all that proves is that you need an intelligent designer to create something that lives and so I don't think that disproves the theory of evolution although disproves creation by design but I don't know if it'll happen the uncertainty of evolution has troubled many people it and it's created many novel positions France is quick the along with Crick and Watson won the Nobel Prize for discovering of the double helix structure of the DNA molecule Crick in 1973 was so frustrated by the the improbable ability of life actually coming about by random mutate and long periods of time that he said there has to be another explanation I can't I can't say there was a God who created it but I've idea and he called it directed Pemps Pemps Fermia that is life must have come here sent by a spaceship from a distant planet well how is that more likely than that intelligent than a powerful creator God created it well this is science it's at least a spaceship so what's the evidence for this well it happened so I mean and he published this is a serious theory he's a Nobel Prize winner one of the greatest you know scientific discoveries in the in the last century this make any difference for us I believe so there are serious destructive consequences of evolutionary theory in modern thought and here's here's why I think it's important and why I do think it's important to say that well in actual fact the Bible talks about God creating universe and creating life and creating animals and creating human beings in his image and I think that's true so we can't call that science well don't call science if you don't want to it's still true call it fact call it truth call it history but it's true so I still want to say that now I I don't I don't think it's that question of defining the word science to be only naturalistic science people can go different ways on that but the question is if that gets to determine then all that is counted as true but if in fact people believe in evolutionary theory then why felt Johnson's concerned about this he says it becomes the organizing the cultural explanatory story for all that happens and all of our life so it becomes a religion in a way and there are consequences that if man is in fact the product of random occurrences in the universe then there's no real significance to human life that is if I'm just the product of molecules churning around and random mutation what's my life for nothing that leads to despair because there's no grud who gives me meaning and with no creator there's no judge to hold us morally accountable and I think this accounts for a lot of the moral breakdown in society people say why is all this evil why is people doing evil in our society why is all this and this and this and why don't kids why do kids growing up doing evil well because if you're taught that there's no creator but you're just the product of random mutation then who's going to hold you accountable nobody as final at final judgment so do what you can get away with and that results in moral breakdown in society if natural selection brings improvement in life form should we hinder this process by caring for those who are weak or less able to defend themselves this led in the earlier part of the 20th century to social Darwinism that is if people are weak and poor and sick get rid of them don't help them social Darwinism let the fittest survive and we shouldn't I had a research scientist at Abbott Labs say to me it was trouble they've been working there 20 25 years helping people get well with medicine why am I doing all this creating all this medicine to help weak people survive shouldn't aren't we hindering survival of the fittest good question and I think one that's very difficult for a Darwinian evolutionist to answer in fact shouldn't we destroy weaker human beings I think it's a logical conclusion of Darwinian evolution and Marx and Nietzsche and Hitler all justified war on the on this basis on basis of a belief in a Darwinian evolutionary system human beings are getting better and the ones that are specifically getting better we should help and the weaker we should destroy the human beings evolved for the better the wisdom of earlier generations is not likely as valuable and not as modern thought and so that negatively impacts what people think of an ancient book like the Bible leads to unbelief and then if we're a higher form of animal and this is really a dumb this is really a strong influence in society if we are just a higher form of animal then we shouldn't kill animals for food or for leather like this belt are these shoes because why should we kill them they're not and why should we use them for scientific medical research in a lot of protests against using animals in medical research radical human our animal rights groups because they say we're just an animal and it doesn't really allow for God as a creator well that is a summary now take a few minutes here for some questions in interaction yeah what's your name I'm concerned that all this to me boils down to a godship issue so who is the person environment I mean if there is the out this human godship issue yeah and then his principles you know worse or I think yeah yeah yeah the question is who yeah who is God and what but you can ask why is why did his view become so popular if there wasn't evidence to support it be it it was attractive to people who didn't want to believe in God and be accountable to God I think ultimately Mike do you want to say something I don't know you've been interested in this I think we've done a very good job of happening with the fundamental arguments that are not a real challenge is happening in our university is I understand the argument like yeah more we learn more complex it gets and the simplest one cell organs one complex it's buddy and it would bring them yeah yeah we're finding one more difficult to think right yeah yeah you know and and then the universities and the scientists have adopted the methodology of scientific naturalism but the problem is whether it it also translates to the philosophy of scientific naturalism and that's the thing we have to keep out of our you know scientific investigations and that's what's crept in ever since Darwin yeah they've as you said the redefinitions you know at times to suit the purpose of certain arguments and those that do believe in God have real challenge in the scientist sticking to it consistent nomenclature yeah yeah Mike what's your what's your title or what associate director at the BioDesign Institute yeah good anything else you want to say I know it's because this is a your is where you live well yeah actually a fun one just to get everybody to on the same page is a lot of people believed that the conflict with Galileo and the church was a religion science conflict and historians looking back on that recognize that the actual fundamental problem was a a conflict between basically the authority structure at the time and a new theory the problem was a fusion between the beliefs in the church and the beliefs in science the church they adopted not necessarily the basis of the biblical belief but what the scientists were telling them and the scientists the prevailing scientific theory at the time was that the the Sun went around the earth and that was consistent in fact the scientists argued against Galileo they said it was absurd that the earth could be going around the Sun that would mean that the Sun had to be at least 30 million miles away from the earth what is it 93 million it's 93 million but they thought that was such an absurd the scientist's argument in so there was a consistency between the scientists at the time and the church and the and so Galileo was really viewed as being in defiance of authority and maybe some of the lessons are it's not just always conflict between science and religion but you know maybe there's there's well it always happens when a new theory comes along in science and maybe the the challenge was that the church also embedded itself with the theories of science and the of the day and can be a mistake today for us to good thanks me okay what else Joyce think a couple more quickly here I see Joyce's hand and then yeah I don't know our Darwin is out further out on the limb than Darwin himself was well look I'm in the position that I sometimes get in this class where I'm talking about the Bible I know more but when I'm talking about something outside the Bible there are many of you in the class who know more than I do so I'm not sure but I think that there's increasing lack of evidence to prove encounter evidence against Darwinianism so people are believing it in spite of that so there is in a sense being farther out on limb what Darwin would think today if you know if all this evidence lack of evidence came to light we don't know anyway I've got a we've got to get out of here pretty quick today what Ben you want to say something I see way back there Ben's a yeah yeah yeah yeah I think he accepts theistic evolution doesn't he Francis Colin is a professor Colin's a professor yeah he is a theistic evolutionist but the language of God so good Ben is a chairman of our I shouldn't probably say the chairman of our search committee and on the elderboard and also a physician at the male clinic so yeah okay yeah how do I let right Lee Strowwell's book the case-for-the-creator haven't read it don't know his stuff is usually really good so it's probably very good and there's one more gene yes the recent public speech that through all the fire was a world yeah he was trying to make the comment really really pretty good point off it's a yeah yeah yeah yeah good good so the Pope encouraging dialogue between faith and science not excluding religious belief I don't know where it's going no I think I know where my hunch is that the arguments and the evidence against our winning evolution are just going to continue to accumulate accumulate accumulate accumulate accumulate until finally there'll be a break in the night and where where secular people will go on that I don't know but but I just it gives to looking at the ice 15 years it gives me the appearance of one side is making a lot more progress than the other and it's the and and the Darwinian evolutionists are retrenching but I don't think they're getting more evidence in fact in the end are very stubborn things and truth is very stubborn thing and I'm thankful for that so that's where we are let me close in prayers this is the day we have to get out early what we give you thanks for your goodness pray Lord if I've said anything incorrect that that would be that you would correct that and not let it stick in people's minds but Lord that you would give us understanding and subtle convictions and graciousness and accuracy as we represent the views of others and we pray Lord that there would be in the established scientific community and major research universities around our country that there would be more openness that you would work in people's minds and hearts there be more openness the idea that in fact there was a God who created the universe we thank you that you are that God and we can speak to you and we trust you and we thank you for sending your son to be our savior in his name we pray amen next week age of the earth