<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
მიეცით თვიური შემოწირულობა

Results of the Protestant Reformation

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Lecture 13, the last of our lectures in the history of the Protestant Reformation in the 16th century is entitled Reformation and Revival, the results of the Protestant Reformation. Book of Psalms had long been a centerpiece in the monastic spirituality of the Church as the monks would regularly pray through and sing through the Psalms. As we come to the 16th century, the Book of Psalms becomes very central to the piety of the Protestant congregation, as particularly in the Reform side, but also in the Lutheran side as well, the Psalms are to bring the Reform congregations together in words of prayer to the Lord. And also the Psalms became very important to Protestants in public life as Protestants were often tried, brought before judges and tried, because of their faith and many times executed in places like France, the Psalms were a testimony that Protestants used to the grace and glory of God. In fact, it said that all over France, as Huguenots were imprisoned, the Jailers became familiar with the Psalms because these people day and night in prison were singing the Psalms. I want to begin this lecture with Psalm 79, prayer, as the Psalms are generally prayers, and as we think of the results of the Reformation, we will pray in the words of Psalm 79, let's pray. Remember not, O God, the sins of long ago, in tender mercy visit us distressed and humble low, O Lord our Savior, help and glorify thy name, deliver us from all our sins and take away our shame. In thy compassion here, thy prisoners, plaintive sigh, and in the greatness of thy power save those about to die. Been safe within thy foe, we will exalt thy name, our thankful hearts with songs of joy, thy goodness will proclaim. Amen. As I review the history of the 16th century, I'd like to use three words, first is the word division or the word conflict, the second is the word reprimation, and the third is the word revival. Those form the three main points in our syllabus. First of all division, we know of course that the 16th century marked the breaking apart of Christdom was not the first division in the history of the church that had already taken place 500 years earlier between the Eastern church and the Western church. And the Western church indicated geographically by the line to the east on the map, but now there's another division, not east and west, but geographically largely north and south with Catholic territory to the south and Protestant territory to the north. And we know from our study already that not only did the church divide into a Protestant part and a Catholic part, but the Protestant church divided into a number of different traditions, mainly three major traditions, the Lutheran, the Reform, and the Anglican. Now, there were many other smaller groups, particularly groups that made up the tradition that we call the radical reprimation, but perhaps as many as 90% of all the Protestants were either Lutherans, Reform, or Anglicans, 10% everything else with the Anabantus being the largest group within the radical reprimation. Some people very much deplored this division. Philip Malanthan, for one, was constantly trying to find ways to bring the church back together again, even Protestants and Catholics. And for a while John Calvin joined with him in that effort. Calvin soon became the solution that Catholics and Protestants could join, but he maintained his zeal to see the Protestant church united. But Philip Malanthan never really gave up his longing to see the church once again in the West, one church, and he prayed, oh God, we do not desire new contingents and discord. We pray only that the Son of God, our Lord Jesus Christ, to die for us and rose from the grave will guide us that all of us who are in many churches and many Communions may be one church and one communion and one in Him. Well that prayer, God did not see fit to answer in the 16th century, and still that prayer has not been answered today. But Christian people long for the church to be united, but there were very momentous issues that divided the church in the 16th century and those issues, or at least many of them still dividing the church today. As churches divided, as the church divided in Europe, it meant that countries had to come to grips with a new problem, and that is pluralism, religious pluralism. And it's going to take a long time for that to be in any sense solved, because in the 16th century it was really a foreign idea. These divisions, the reformation led to conflict and to what I would call national solutions, some of those solutions were temporary. But that some lasted even into the next century. Some countries remain largely one faith. Spain for instance had very few Protestants. Italy had some Protestants, but they generally did not stay very long in Italy. And England and Scotland were largely Protestant, and even though there were Catholics there, they were in hiding or not much in evidence. But in other countries there were both Catholics and Protestants, and some sharp religious struggles which led to some temporary national solutions. Let me talk first about Germany, or the Holy Roman Empire, as we should call it. The religious piece of Augsburg was drawn up in 1555, and that piece tried to bring some solution to the rising warfare between Protestants and Catholics. That piece was agreed upon based on this principle. Whatever the king or ruler of the territory was, that's what that territory would be. The empire was made up of dozens, really hundreds of small cities and small kingdoms. And the solution was this, if the ruler is Catholic, the people are Catholic. The church is Catholic in that territory. If the ruler is Protestant, then the church can be Protestant. Actually it was really Catholic and Lutheran. It was not the possibility of other Protestant traditions being included in the religious piece of Augsburg. The Latin expression for this temporary solution was, who is the rule, who is the religion? And that would bring to the empire at least for some time a kind of uneasy piece would not last because in the next century there would be the 30 years war. And there would be no permanent piece or semi-permanent piece until the end of the 30 years war. In France, the situation was different. There was a determined Calvinist minority spread throughout France. And there was a very strong Catholic monarchy. So in the 16th century, it was often bitter, although sporadic persecution of the Huguenots as the Protestants were called by the Catholic rulers. The Protestants in France were encouraged and strengthened by John Calvin's Geneva. Calvin of course was a Frenchman and had great concern for training French people and sending them back into France to establish churches and preach the gospel. Many of those French students trained under Calvin and the others in Geneva went back to France to face death. And we have those wonderful letters that Calvin wrote to the five prisoners of Leon as he tries to encourage these five young men who have been sentenced to die for preaching the reformed faith in France. One of those letters, Calvin says, since it pleases God to employ you to the death and maintaining his quarrel, he will strengthen your hand in the fight and will not suffer a single drop of your blood to be spent in vain. Two days later, those five young men went to the stake, singing the songs. Calvin believed that French Protestants should learn to suffer, not to fight. His way of saying it was this, tears and prayers for our weapons. But eventually there were people in France, like John Knox in Scotland, who felt that it was right and necessary for Protestants to defend themselves. And so new theories, Protestant theories of government were developed including resistance, give necessary and the aftermath of that was warfare in France. Between Protestants and Catholics leading up to the infamous massacre on St. Bartholomew's day as hundreds and thousands of Protestants were killed that one day in Paris and throughout France, August 23, 1572. Toward the end of the century, we have the Edict of Knox, 1598. The Protestant king, Henry of Navarre, well he was a Protestant who became king in 1589 but he realized that he would really not be able to serve effectively as king of Catholic France until he became a Catholic. And so in 1593 Henry of Navarre converted to the Catholic faith in order to be king. He said, Paris is worth a mass and so abandoned his earlier faith for Catholicism but Henry had concern for his Protestant friends that he had left behind. And the Edict of Knox in 1598 stated that Protestants were to be tolerated in France. A state within a state would be the way you could describe the Edict of Knox. There were serious limitations imposed upon Protestants. They were not as free as Catholics were but they could not be persecuted as long as they lived in certain areas. And observed the limitations that were placed to fund him. That Edict lasted almost 100 years but it was finally revoked in 1685 and persecution broke out once again. Huguenots, that time many of them had to flee from France but that gets a bit ahead of our story and into well into the next century. So in the empire whatever the king was that is what the people had to be if they did not like that they could move immigrate, go somewhere else. So there was in that just the beginnings of a bit of religious liberty. In France Protestants were tolerated but face grave restrictions. In the Netherlands the low countries it brought war with Spain. Spain controlled the low countries during this time and as many people in the Netherlands became Protestant they not only wanted to worship freely but they wanted to throw all the Spanish control in order to be able to worship freely. It's in this struggle that we have one of the great Dutch heroes which usually referred to as William the silent. This is the statue of William the silent on the Reformation wall in Geneva. He's called William the silent not because he didn't talk much, apparently quite a bit. But he kept his own council. He did not let people know what he was thinking or planning in order to be able to carry out his purpose of freeing the Dutch from Spanish control. He was a far-seeing, fair-minded, gifted, wise and patient ruler. Finally in 1581 the northern provinces declared their independence the northern part of the Netherlands but war dragged on until there was a truce in 1607 which divided the area into a Protestant north. Holland and a Catholic south, Belgium. The Reform Church came to dominate the religious life in the north even though Holland did not have 50% of its population on the Reform side of things until 1650 by that time. Holland was a strong Dutch Protestant reform country. There was greater religious liberty than anywhere else in Europe in Holland until the founding of Rhode Island in America in 1636. You can read the quotation from the great Dutch theologian and Prime Minister Abraham Kuiper about religious freedom in the Calvinistic Netherlands. Well so much for the word conflict, division. We've looked at some of the history of the century and we've seen how different countries try to come to terms with a new situation where you have both Catholic and Protestant people. Let's go back to the word reformation and think about the century this way. What really happened when the Protestant reformation swept through Europe? First of all in terms of ministry, we have now a new type of person, a pastor, a pastor preacher. Of course church had pastors for a long time but the Catholic church leader was a priest whose central place you might say in ministry was the altar and the confessional. As the sacramental system was the system of religious faith. With the coming of the Protestant reformation we have for the first time a religious leader, a church leader who is a pastor and a preacher. His place is the study and the pulpit not the altar and the confessional study and the pulpit and the home is on home as for the first time there is such a thing as a pastor's home with a wife and children. Another place is the home of his parishioners. He would be out visiting and helping people in his churches. 1523, Zwingli, pastor in Switzerland began to wear the scholar's gown. This was not the kind of dress that pastors had worn up until that time but Zwingli began to wear the scholar's gown which led eventually into the Protestant pulpit dress. That symbolized something and that is he was a scholar, he was a student, he was studying the Bible and as he came forth to speak he would do it as one who had studied Scripture and was now willing and ready and able to study it for the people. Of course theology changed as the Protestant reformation moved through Europe, looked last time at the summarization of Roman Catholic theology in the Council of Trent and I have in the syllabus on page 77 a list of the major Protestant confessions. The Schleichheim confession of the Anavabdis to 1527 could be added to the list but the Schleichheim confession as you know is not a full confession but simply gives a few of the distinctive of the Anavabdis faith. The Lutheran confession is called Augsburg was written in 1530 by Philip Millanthin. After that particularly after Luther died about 16 years later there was great controversy, theological controversy in the Lutheran church between the Philippist followers of Millanthin and the Old Lutherans. The controversy arose because people saw Millanthin changing his mind, getting closer to Erasmus on the doctrine of free will and closer to Calvin on the doctrine of the Lord's Supper. It was a very bitter time in Lutheran history and much theological controversy ending finally in the formula of Concord which was published in 1580 on the 50th anniversary of the Augsburg confession. This is why Lutherans love the word Concordia as materials like to use cabinet or Westminster, Lutherans like to use Augsburg especially Concordia because at that time the Book of Concord united the Lutherans. More in the Old Lutheran direction the Lutherans largely rejected Millanthin's synergism and also rejected his openness to the reformed view of the Lord's Supper and with the formula of Concord we have the establishment stabilization of Lutheran theology. The Catholics have one basic document, Council of Trent, the Lutherans have one, the formula of Concord which includes the Augsburg confession but the reform have a number of theological confessions because on the reform side of things each national area of the church tended to develop its own confession. These confessions are very similar but it does mean as we study reformed confessions we have to look at a wide range of confessions and compare them. And the list is given in the syllabus the Gallican or French confession written largely by Calvin the Scott's confession John Knox the Belgian confession by Guido de Bray from the Southern Netherlands reformer executed by the Spanish and the war that I was talking about. That Belgian confession draws on the Gallican confession of Calvin but it's about twice as long eventually translated into Dutch as the Dutch confession. The second Hellbedic or Swiss confession was by Heinrich Bullinger a private confession that he wrote to express his own faith but was so well done that it became accepted by many of the reform groups. The Heidelberg confession comes out of the German reform community of the Galatinit the most significant center of Calvinism in Germany during the 16th century written by Ersinus and Olivionus a wonderful confession catechism with its outline of guilt, grace and gratitude. And then the 39 articles from the Church of England reduced from the earlier 42 articles to 39 articles during the reign of Elizabeth I and reformed in their orientation. Now let me talk a little bit about the arts, ministry, theology and the arts. First of all the visual arts because people do recognize of course that there was some destruction of art during the 16th century religious art in churches. Crucifixes were torn down and snatched pictures were destroyed as Protestants objecting to Catholic use of these religious pictures tempted to purify the churches and get rid of that which they felt was very wrong and misleading. What do we say about all of that? There certainly was certain amount of iconoclasm perhaps not quite as much as some people think I don't think we should see all Protestants going all over the place trying to find any picture they can in destroying those pictures much of the religious art of this period as lived on and still can be seen in churches and museums in Europe today. Sometimes the destruction of a religious picture in the church was ordered by the donor of that picture someone who had paid for it, not always the case but sometimes a person who had actually put the picture there as a good work had been converted to the Protestant faith and now took it down. That perhaps happened more often than we recognize but certain destruction did take place some of it I think was probably very unfortunate that that art could not have been preserved outside of the church if necessary but that may have been asking too much of the people who actually lived at that time. It would take Protestants some time to find a style of art particularly religious art for themselves. I think they would find it later particularly in the work of Rembrandt and look at Rembrandt's life in contribution to the church a little later but even down to the present there is some discomfort on the part of Protestants with art. The religious art how to use it and whether we can use it without violating the second commandment. If the Protestant legacy on the side of art is somewhat mixed the Protestant legacy on the side of music is very positive and very wonderful. Congregational singing now becomes very much part of the life of the church for the first time in many many centuries. On the Lutheran side there were great hymns marked by Luther's famous Amide Fortress and culminating in the 18th century in the work of the greatest church musician of all Bach. On the Protestant reform side there were the Psalms and I was talking about the Psalms earlier. The Psalms really began to mark the life and piety of the reform churches quite early. In fact there was a complete Geneva Psalter by 1562 every Psalm translated into an actual French for the singing of the people. With tunes so lively that some people called them Geneva Jigs and there were people all over France and wherever the reform church went singing the Psalms. The Psalms particularly became identified with the church in Scotland and some Scottish Presbyterians even down to the present sing only the Psalms. They say a word about economics because after Max Weber's book the Protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism there has been the misguided idea that Protestantism invented capitalism. Capitalism was really already in effect potentially and in some places actually from the time of the Renaissance and it's not that the Protestant movement invented a new economic system. Max Weber was unable to demonstrate in this book that Calvin or any other reformed or reprimation theologian actually advocated anything resembling modern capitalism. The only person that he actually quotes in this connection is Benjamin Franklin who is not well known as a Calvinist. Protestantism and Calvinism I think in some ways were congenial with the system of Calvinism with the emphasis on discipline, hard work, thrift, economy all of that is going to make money and create money that can be used in different ways but Protestantism and Calvinism certainly did not create capitalism. Against what many scholars say and what many books teach Calvin never taught that earthly prosperity is a sign of God's blessing. I don't know how many times I've read that in books much to my dismay that Calvin would say that the way to know that you are being blessed by God and that you are elect is if you're prospering in terms of temple things. Calvin never said anything closely resembling that or even remotely resembling that he insisted that Christians must care for the poor because God is an advocate of the poor, the aliens and the fugitives. Remember the last point of Kranber's sermon at the state is just about ready to die. He preached that sermon. At a number of points but his last point was this just before he died the rich should give generously to the poor. The last word that this great English reformer had to say to the people of England and the first book of discipline of John Knox in Scotland attempted to create a national system to help the poor which would have been more effective and certainly more human than modern governmental social security systems. So Protestantism did not create capitalism. There is a strong emphasis in the leaders of Protestantism that people share generously what they have and there is no indication that a sign of God's blessing is how much a person has of this world's possessions. When anaburing aged and wealthy widow of the mayor of Hamburg died people read her will and realized that in 1535 she had changed her will. Not unusual in the 16th century because his people were converted from Catholicism to Protestantism they often changed their wills. And the earlier will left her money to purchase vigils, masses for her soul and other good works who avoid purgatory. The revised will left money for her family for the sick and the poor and the needy. You can read the point in the syllabus related to culture and let me move on to the third major word which is the word revival. Certainly there was war, bloodshed, many sad and awful things that took place because of what was happening in the 16th century. There was reformation we've just been describing. Was there revival or did people just change the label and go on living the same way? There were many defects and disappointments I think in the Protestant reformation and we should not glamorize it and make it more than it really was. Luther was often disappointed and even chagrin with the behavior of Lutherans and at times he threatened to resign from being the pastor and the leader of Lutheran people because he felt they were not living the way they ought to have lived. There were many failures. But even the Catholics recognized that the Protestants were able to achieve something in terms of reform of morals and greater emphasis on personal holiness. Protestants spirituality focused on a number of important things, the word of God for instance, the Psalter, the celebration of the Lord's Day, the Lord's Supper, and in everyday life with Christians living out their lives in their families, in the fields, in the workshops, in the kitchen so that the place of spirituality now becomes public and known as people live for God wherever they are. I'd like to close with a prayer which is the last stanza of a hymn written by the first Protestant woman, him writer. Her name was Elizabeth Crocicca. She was a nun who had come to the Elendelical Faith, married a Lutheran pastor who served in Magdeburg and in Vittenburg. Her hymn which was written in 1524, so you see how early it is as the title Lord Jesus, the One Son of God. The first two stanzas summarized the doctrines of the incarnation and the atonement Christ was born and Christ died for us and in the third stanza represents our response. Here are her words. O let us in thy knowledge and in thy love increase that we in faith be steadfast in no thy spirit's peace. The thy sweetness may be known to these cold hearts and teach them to thirst for the alone.