<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
მიეცით თვიური შემოწირულობა

Worship Leadership & Participation 1

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

We're going to start today with for lecture number 13 with worship leadership and participation. And then we will go to planning worship service. So page 22 in your notes is where we'll begin today. And let's have a word of prayer as we start. Father, we thank you for this new day. The opportunity to live for the praise of your glory today. We confess at the outset that left to ourselves in our own sinful hearts, we don't desire that, nor will we do that. So we ask Holy Spirit that you would come and be with us. And that are time of talking and interacting and thinking together about the implications of biblical worship into who participates and leads and how we plan services. And the use of the good gift of music that you would inform us and instruct us, help us to be faithful to your word as we turn toward the practice of worship in learning how to think through the principles that apply and then what to do specifically in places you are and will call us. So we thank you that you are God who is unchanging in your being but dynamic relationally with us even to this very day. That we're not just learning something about the history of who you are, but we are entering into an ongoing covenant or relationship with you. Where we cry out to you and you hear us, where we ask for your help and you give it, where we acknowledge our need to grow to be more like Christ and you accomplish more of that. So have your way with us today even as we go through these class times together and we ask that you would do these things for we come to you in the name of Christ. One of the important issues related to worship, corporate public worship relates to leadership and authority and oversight of corporate public worship, who decides what should be done and who plans and arranges the biblical elements into a gospel centered worship service for a particular local church. And then who participates and participation is in what I call two ways. One is a solo voice like a preacher, a single person reading scripture, single person and their voice giving a testimony, even a solo musically, a single voice of prayer and so on. And then there's the congregational voice, which is usually it's unison or responsive readings and singing and scripture and prayers. So when we recite the Apostles Creed together, for example, that's a congregational voice. When a pastor gives what we sometimes call a pastoral prayer or growing up in my family with my dad as a preacher, I called it the long prayer. And I would time it. That is when I was about probably nine years old, I would time my dad's long prayer and then announced to him at lunchtime how long he prayed that day. I don't think that was being fully engaged in worship at the time. I was watching the clock rather than what listening to what he said. So part of the question is who for whom is it appropriate to stand up front or out somewhere else in the worship space and lead worship with the solo, single voice? It's going to be one of the questions that will kind of come over this, be present and in the backdrop of what we're going to be looking at under this topic of worship, leadership and participation. One of the places I want to go first is Ephesians chapter four, which I think is a key passage in understanding the ministry of the church in general and the relationship between those who are called and set apart to be leaders and the rest of the flock. And I can put this into a sort of larger context of God's calling of his people. I think in Ephesians four, one to 16 would see four kinds of callings. Let me read the passage for you first. As a prisoner for the Lord, then I urge you to live a life worthy of the calling you have received. Be completely humble and gentle, be patient, bearing with one another in love, make every effort to keep the unity of the spirit through the bond of peace. There is one body in one spirit just as you were called to one hope when you were called. One Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and father of all who is overall and through all and in all. But to each one of us grace has been given as Christ apportioned it. This is why it says when he ascended on high he led captives in his train and gave gifts to men. What does he ascended mean except that he also descended to the lower earthly regions. He who descended is the very one who ascended higher than all the heavens in order to fill the whole universe. It was he who gave some to be apostles, some to be prophets, some to be evangelists and some to be pastors and teachers to prepare God's people for works of service so that the body of Christ may be built up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature. Attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ, then we will no longer be infants tossed back and forth by the waves and blown here and there by every wind of teaching and by the cunning and craftiness of men in their deceitful scheming. Instead speaking the truth in love, we will in all things grow up into him who is the head that is Christ. From him, the whole body joined and held together by every supporting ligament grows and builds itself up in love as each part does its work. Now I think the first calling here is in verse 1. I urge you to live a life worthy of the calling you have received. It's the most foundational calling of the Christian life. It's being called out of darkness from sin and death into the kingdom of God's Son, the kingdom of light of life. It's being born again. It's that calling from death to life into relationship with God through Christ, who's our adoption, referenced in chapter 1 of Ephesians. When it says he chose us in Christ before the foundation of the world, in love he predestined us to be adopted as his sons. It's the calling of regeneration into life in Christ. It's our most foundational calling. Whether you're called to be a butcher, a baker, a candlestick maker, or a pastor, the most foundational identifier of who we are as Christians is. We're called into union with Christ and everything else flows from that. God's will for your life is to be conformed to the likeness of Christ and everything else you're concerned about what His will is relates to that. It's the centrality of all things being in Christ and for Christ and holding together in Him and Him to have first place in everything that we see in Colossians 1. So as you think about planning and leading and entering into worship, as one who may be gifted and ordained and set apart to be a pastor or worship leader preacher, remember that you have a shared identity with all who are gathering that you share the same foundational fundamental calling into Christ into union with Him. The second calling that I think is foundational is there in verses 2 through 6 where it talks about the horizontal relationship of the church. In a sense, I remember John Perkins voice of Calvary Ministries in Mendenhall, Mississippi years ago, and now California saying the last individual thing that happens in your life is when God's spirit takes you individually from death. So I'm going to give you an example of death to life and join you to Christ and then you're immediately incorporated into a body of believers that transcends time and space into the fellowship of the church, the communion of saints. So our second calling, the second thing that's most foundational about who I marked LBM is I am marked LB in Christ, member of the body of Christ. I'm called before I'm called to be a pastor before I'm called to some vocational calling, I'm called into Christ and I'm called into the body of Christ. And to me that elevates the significance of corporate public worship, we're gathering to celebrate our first and second foundational identifiers of who we are. I can be unemployed and my wife and children burned in a fire and dead. But my fundamental identity of being in Christ and being in the body of Christ remains unchanging, despite what could be very trying and difficult circumstances personally and in my other kinds of things that would identify who I am. It could be displaced from where I consider home. And so to think of ourselves as we gather for corporate public worship, as people who are in union with Christ and fellowship with one another, that sets the tone in the context of what we've gathered who we are as we gather. It's not the medical doctor, air examiner and the attorney, Tripp Sanders, and on down the line. But it's people who have been brought from death to life into Christ and into a family that we are brothers and sisters in Christ. And I think pastors sometimes who are called into such leadership positions, such up front prominence in preaching and leading worship and being there in people's lives in the tragedies and struggles and counseling and moderating session meetings and giving speeches on the floor of General Assembly. There's a lot of things that fuel the set apart side that tends to be set above. I think it's important to remind ourselves who Mark Dalby is not first and foremost a teaching elder in the PCA. Who Mark Dalby is is a sinner saved by grace in union with Christ and in fellowship with his brothers and sisters who have been saved by that same gospel of grace. And if that's our heart as we plan and lead and worship and of God's people, then that's not real quantifiable at one level. How well did you pray today? Well, how good was the sermon today? It's more about of entering into this fellowship with Christ and his people that provides the sort of the, that's the context of who we are as we gather for worship. Now the passage he was on to say in verse, verse seven, to each one of us, each one of us who are in union with Christ and fellowship with one another, every believer has been given, grace has been given as Christ a portion to him and then it goes into talking about the ascended Christ giving gifts to his people. Every person who's in union with Christ and fellowship with the church has also been given at least one gift by the ascended Christ for the benefit of the church. So all believers are called and gifted for ministry of some kind in the church on 1 Corinthians 12, Romans 12 or other passages with the talk about one body many members Christ ahead. He gives gifts to all where to not to dishonor what we might consider the lesser gifts and so on. So this is, this passage is talking about every believer is gifted for general ministry in the church of some kind. Edmund Clowney in his book, if you haven't read it, it's a great one to have. It's small. It can help you or people you work with in terms of discerning God's call to ministry. We'll book called, called to ministry about 100 pages and the first half of it he talks about every believer is called to ministry in this general sense and gifted by the ascended Christ with some kind of gift. And some as we'll see in a moment the second half of his book are set apart by ordination laying on of hands to be overseers of that flock. But in his book called a ministry in the first part this great image that that I've quoted here in the outline from page 28. The gifts of Christ grace are like a majestic stained glass window in his church. Each Christian is set in place like a piece of jeweled glass so that the radiance of God's grace may shine through him to add a beam of crimson or emerald or a juror to the orchestration of color blazing within. I remember a couple in the church I served in Cincinnati where the woman had a stroke and was had to be taken around in a wheelchair by her very dear and loving husband and she wasn't able to speak and she could make sounds and she and her husband figured out ways of communicating. But the conversation came up one time about how some people don't feel like they have anything to contribute to the congregation as we gather and it wouldn't make any difference in the world if they were there or not. And I remember saying to the congregation in the midst of a sermon on some passage like this that her name was Peggy that the Peggy's mere presence in worship as a believer who can't speak who can't walk but who's there every week ministers to the body by her mere presence. There's a blaze of light that comes through Peggy because she's there that adds to the brilliance of the body gathered and to view the people who are in union with Christ and fellowship with believers who are gifted by the ascended Christ in some way as being indispensable and essential to the gathering of his church with corporate public worship. If you begin to look at people like that it'll transform how you plan and lead worship and how you relate to people and greet them at the door in that regard. And so I think that one of the hazards of being an seminary is that we're focused on the last calling of some or the few who are set apart by ordination to be pastors and teachers equipping the saints for work of ministry that we find later on in the past. And we tend to think that church and ministry is all about the set of part ones like us. Now it's important that we give good 103 hours longest master's degree in the history of the planet. General training still a generalized degree which every pastor has to be a generalist. You need a lot of gifts and a lot of training. And we keep thinking the way it gets you better equipped and better training is to keep adding hours to the curriculum which may not be the best solution. We'll kill everybody by exhaustion before they ever graduate along the way. And some of you are wise enough to stay home and take this by access and get your degree while still having a life. Anyways, yeah, over, yeah, with that nine year clock, you know, always sort of saying, can I make it or not in that time period. But I think that while it's necessary to focus on the specific things needed for the few, the some who are going to be overseers of the all who are gifted from ministry. We need to have regular reminders to ourselves. That's why field education is important. That's why outside the classroom, things are important for your preparation. It's not all about you. It's all about them that you are being trained for in that regard. And then in verses 11 to 16, some are called to the ordained ministry of word and sacraments. The purpose of in Acts chapter 60 apostles dealing with these administrative and mercy ministry dynamics between these widows and the distribution of food in meeting their needs. We read in Acts 6 of the apostles say we need to devote ourselves to the ministry of the word and prayer. And so let's find and they found seven godly men who were mature in their faith. It wasn't that I'll just do this administrative stuff and anybody can do it. It's still a ministry of service of the one it's one ministry in word indeed, but they were wanting to not diminish the importance of what they've been set apart to do. And so there were there was a division of responsibilities within the church that way. And so some are called to shepherd and equip the all in ministry. Now there is some controversy in some circles including influencing some of our circles within the PCA which obviously covered it. Seminary is a denominational school in this interpretation of Ephesians 4-11. He gave some to be pastors and teachers to prepare God's work for people for works of service. Some think that the pastor and teachers are to do the works of service. But I think that that's not a right interpretation of the passage in its larger context as well. If you look at verse 13 or 15 we and all things grew up into him who is the head that is Christ Christ is the head from him the whole body joined and held together by every supporting ligament grows and builds itself up in love as each part does its work. I think work is work of ministry and it's a particular kind of work of ministry that those set apart by ordination to be pastor teachers. Their work of ministry is the equipping for other kinds of work of ministry. And I think that's very important and the problem is if you go with that first interpretation it tends and I'm not judging the hearts of those who go there. But it tends to then elevate it's more Old Testament priesthood like. You have God certainly working through Jesus as our great high priest and mediator but the pastor teacher to the rest of the body and we sort of become the dispensers of Christ grace in a sense to the rest of the body. I don't think that's the new covenant model so I'll put an extra that and say it's God through Jesus to the church and some are set apart as elders from among the all. There are some who then give overseeing shepherding ministry to this alongside of Christ and I think this is I'm not in any way wanting to diminish the authority and the oversight and the calling and the ordination of the sum for this vital ministry to the all. But I think that we can tend to diminish the priesthood of all believers in this model over here and the gifting of all people for ministry and it gets reflected in how we then plan and lead worship services. And we'll come around to that as we go. So let's look first of all at this biblical concept of ordained leadership as overseers of the flock. You see in first Peter five for example I think I alluded to that passage previously Peter says in first Peter five to the elders among you I appeal as a fellow elder a witness of Christ suffering and one who also one who also share will share in the glory to be revealed be shepherds of God's flock that is under your care serving as overseer is not because you must but because you are willing. As God wants you to be not greedy for money but eager to serve not lording it over those entrusted to you but being examples to the flock and when the chief shepherd appears you will receive the crown of glory that will never fade away. Peter does not diminish in any way his overseeing role or that of his fellow elders who are overseers shepherds the flock is under their care so it's not wanting to diminish the role of elders but it's the biblical concept of leading is one of serving. Eager to serve now verse five says young men in the same way be submissive to those who are older that there is a call to the young men who aren't elders in this case to submit to the elders but then he says all of you close yourselves with humility toward one another because God opposes the proud but gets grace to the humble sometimes in this more elevated view over here the temptation against humility I think can be great and it's not just always the fault of the pastor teachers sometimes it's the fault of the congregants who would much rather have this role I have this model. We want the pastor to do all the work of ministry and when you match that with somebody says I am sort of a mini god here and I will do all the ministry I mean that that was a problem in my ministry for many years as I I had made essentially an idol out of being a pastor teacher to a flock of God's people and I was viewing myself way too much as though I were being as God to the people. God had to break me of that and show me that I was really messed up in my understanding so much so that I did this physical rearranging of how I counseled people in my office there was this little desk and then I had a little table over here and there were three chairs there and I would sit here and the person would sit usually there the tables against the wall it was a round table and then there was an empty chair. And I literally after sort of after being convicted of thinking that I was the one who was going to make things go well for this person instead of sort of directing them to Christ I was creating a sort of dependence on me to keep giving them wise counsel. I literally moved to the other chair and to as a physical reminder to me that the one who was going to help them was the one that was sitting in the chair that I'm no longer willing to sit in which is Christ himself and that I was sort of directing them to him. Now it wasn't you know I didn't announce everybody I was counseling now I'm changing chairs because I really you know but I did tell the congregation that I was standing before them repenting of the multiple year ongoing unrepentant sin of trying to be God to them and I said as I read the ten commandments I don't know what all you're struggling with with sin but I defy you to show me one that's worse than what I just told you. Now some people didn't really like that because they wanted to think you know the pastor and his wife and his family they've got it all together at least somebody's got it together well only Christ has it together and he uses people who don't have it together and he even calls people who don't have it completely together into this office and gives them to be a blessing to the rest of the body because part of modeling Godliness includes modeling repentance.

And I think sometimes we have a view of being an example that subtly suggest we have to so arrange our lives that it appears as always an example of someone in whom there's no remaining sin. Jack Miller I've referenced before talks about how the elders in the church need to be the chief repenters in the church. And in an ironic sort of way you would think that if they're the chief repenters that would disqualify them, disqualify them from being elders but in the sense if they refuse to be the chief repenters maybe that should disqualify them because if Paul is a chief repender saying I'm the worst of sinners at the end of his life. Closer to Christ than before but also realizing that that depth of his sin he's more sensitive to and aware of. But he's delighting in how it puts on display the grace of God to such a chief of sinners and there's power in that ministry from that place of repentance and broken. Can you explain the flow fought for the view that you do not agree with the elders do the work of service? Yeah it has to do with do you have the ESB? How's the ESB read Eric? Does it read any difference? Yes, it starts at an E. I'm sorry, it's verse 12. Start with pastors and teachers. There's teachers to equip the saints for the work of ministry for building up the body of Christ. It has to do with that first part of 12 where it's pastors and teachers doing the work of service. But the body of Christ maybe build up it's almost it diminishes the equipping side as being the focus and puts it more on the serving doing the work of service side. Being the role of the pastor teacher rather than equipping four works of service it's doing works of service to equip. There's a Greek issue maybe how they order the syntax. But see that's why I go to the larger context. I think verse 16 clearly shows that the whole body is to be doing the work not just be in some of that is equipping. Acts chapter 20 Paul doesn't hesitate to talk about the significant role of elders by way of leadership in the church. Don't hear anything that I'm saying in any way wanting to diminish the significance of God appointed God ordained set apart qualified mature strong servant leaders in the church. And when Paul describes his ministry among the Ephesians in Acts chapter 20 we won't take time to read read all of it but look at 2018 when they arrived Paul said you know how I lived the whole time I was with you from the first day I came in the province of Asia. I served the Lord with great humility and with tears although I was severely tested by the pots of the Jews you know that I have not hesitated to preach anything that would be helpful to you but have taught you publicly and from house to house. I've declared to both Jews and Greeks that they must turn to God in repentance verse 22 and now compelled by the spirit I'm going to Jerusalem. And then verse 25 now I know that none of you none of you among whom I have gone about preaching the kingdom will ever see me again. I declare to you I'm innocent of the blood of all men I've not hesitated to proclaim to you the whole will of God there is this bold comprehensive preaching publicly going house to house. It isn't a picture someone who's sort of saying well you know I'm just supposed to equip others to do ministry and then that takes a couple hours on Sunday morning and you know I have this cushy pastures job where everybody else does all the work. That's not the picture here okay. He says in 28 keep watch over yourselves and all the flock of which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers be shepherds of the church of God which you bought with his own blood. Savage wolves will come in people among your number will arise and distort the truth beyond guard you know there's a there's this admonition to lead well following in the manner in which Paul set an example when he was there. So there's there's a but it's serving the flock for whom Christ shed his blood it's it's not a puffing up of leaders kind of kind of picture. And then he doesn't hesitate to in his writing of Timothy to exhort him in 1 Timothy 4 11 to 16 command and teach these things. Don't anyone look down on you because you're young but set an example for the believers in speech and life and love in faith and purity until I come to vote yourself to the public reading a scripture to preaching and teaching to not neglect your gift which was given you through a prophetic message when the body of elders laid their hands on you. I mean this is saying the trip and this is where Timothy was past or he is so the same people he's now exhorting the pastor of the flock to be diligent in this ministry that he was set apart to do. By word and spirit and laying on a hand by the the prosperity the body of elders that's one of our proof text for Presbyterian isn't there by the way and then in Hebrews 13. We see verse 17 in a very sort of short summary kind of statement both both sides of this obey your leaders and submit to their authority. They keep watch over you as men who must give an account obey them so that their work will be a joy not a burden for that would be of no advantage to you. So he's admonishing the flock to obey the leaders but in the process he's telling the flock that the leaders must give an account for the way that they serve and lead as over the flock and that it's sort of this mutual interdependent relationship like husband, wife, parent, child, master slave and in Colossians 3 and as we saw earlier in the course week and strong it's sort of elder congregation there are mutually reciprocal interdependent relationships where there's certain responsibilities laid on the elders and certain responsibility laid on the rest of the congregation. That I think is another one of those kind of relationships but in the context of strong qualified gifted set of heart ordained leaders under Christ over the flock Paul then opens the room up as we've talked about before. First Corinthians 11 to 14 will be revisiting a little bit later but you have all these passages that are in a worship context these chapters that relate to the body of Christ functioning together and exercising their gifts. And Paul's in no way saying that it's in isolation from or in rebellion against these godly overseeing leaders but just as in a marriage my wife and my children if I'm leading well as the head of my home are going to be encouraged to discover and utilize their gifts for the blessing and benefit of the home and beyond the home in the mission God is called this family to to advance his kingdom as a family that there should be there should be delight in being under the oversight of there's a certain sort of safety and freedom that comes to then to explore and utilize your gifts and interests within that. So I think elders in the church should lead well in a way that doesn't deny or abdicate their headship and leadership and authority but in a way that encourages the whole body each one of which is a precious jewel like that clowny quote to discover and utilize their giftedness and who they are in Christ for the benefit of the body the churches that's how the church builds itself up in love and grows into greater Christ like this not when they're passively watching the few desperately try to be in some cases something they can never be the side of glory and trying to keep up this well at least your elders have it together and come come this Sunday and watch how together your elders have it I mean that's not what worship is it's we're coming together into the presence of Christ celebrating the triumphs of his grace in the past week and repenting and crying out to him for mercy forgiveness and enabling empowering grace to walk in greater Christ's likeness in the coming week and the elders lead the way in that the preacher leads the way in that and that doesn't that doesn't abdicate leadership that actually is consistent with Christ-like New Testament call to servant leadership in that regard first Peter 2.4 let's look at that just for a moment as you come to him the living stone obviously Christ rejected by men but chosen by God and precious to him you also like living stones are being built into a spiritual house to be a holy priesthood offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ. Now who is the holy priesthood here is it just the pastor in elders or is it the whole all of the living stones I think it's all of the living stones who's offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ only the pastor on behalf of the people or all of the living stones who are incorporated into the temple of God in which the spirit dwells I think this is a very strong passage that encourages the full participation and entering into what happens in corporate public worship of offering spiritual sacrifices to God as a holy priesthood all of us still under ordained set of hard elders okay it's not a denial of that but it's a bringing together two things in a complimentary way and that's why I think it's probably a better way to draw this than this that maybe has the elders I don't know I want this to sort of be overseers but a long side of and they have direct access to Jesus they don't have to go through us to get to Him which is a model that I think is different than the New Testament has. Okay what are some of the implications of this then for who leaves in a worship service in this sort of upfront solo voice. Think back to the Hebrews two passage we talked about the first the first time Christ stands in the congregation declaring God's name and singing God's praise. The dialogue of worship between God and His people has Christ in the center place leading both sides. Now I don't want to set hard and fast rules here but I think as a general principle the portion of the worship service where Christ is declaring God's name in the dialogue of worship. Ordinarily it seems to me should be led by elders and the parts of the worship service that Christ is leading the congregation in the response I think when there is a solo voice part of that can be led by anybody in the congregation as part of the priesthood of all believers and having access to God. So for instance the elders I think are worship leaders with authority and oversight derived from Christ under Christ declaring God's name responsible for directing the gospel storyline that we talked about previously. And things like the call to worship the declaration of pardon the preaching of the word the administration of the sacraments the benediction authoritative instruction the rubrics that are sort of saying you know this that connect elements of worship generally speaking not in a hard and fast absolutely every time every word that's spoken in all of those things. I think it's helpful to communicate that by having the elders do it and the elders are the ones who are to have authoritative teaching authority and oversight in the church and those are the portions of the worship service where that's most reflective. The congregation is made up of worship responders led by Christ songs prayers of response scripture responses testimonies the eating of the bread and the cup the professing of faith are all matters that the congregation is invited to participate in in congregational voice and at times even in solo voice individual voice. Christ is the worship leader remember Hebrews 8 Christ is one of the connects heaven and earth Hebrews 12 Christ is involved in every detail of the worship service and so when we think about who is actually leading and participating in worship remember it's ultimately Christ he is present in the local church worship through the Holy Spirit he's the one who connects heaven and earth as I just said. The earthly human worship leader I believe is to be a gifted trained ordained elder usually a teaching elder in our kind of PCA context of teaching or elders though there could be a gifted well qualified ruling elder who could be your regular worship leader. The authority in worship comes from the session the body of elders and usually the teaching elder or one of the elders is the one who is delegated to sort of carry that authority not functionally a lot of churches don't have you know the whole session of four to six to eight to 12 to however many elders you may have reviewing every detail of every worship service before it's done. But there should be sort of a general overseeing and a helping to set the direction and I think the dialogue between pastor and elders each about matters of worship or the upcoming preaching series or whatever I'm I used to regularly go to the elders and say when I'm when I'm done with this here a few things I'm thinking about as I try to understand the life of the congregation. What do you think what are you hearing what kind of food needs to be fed to the flock at this point in its in its history in its gospel story as a congregation and I think that that it's important to have regular dialogue and interaction with the other ordained elders in the church teaching a ruling over matters of worship. The corporate congregational unison participation songs, prayer, scripture readings, creeds, vows, responses, the bread and the cup, the corporate Amen which comes from first Corinthians 14 maybe I should read that at this point there is a sort of joining in with the so be it Amen. Let's see if it's 14 if you can find it before me I'll be happy to have you tell me. Oh it's verse 16 yeah if you're praising God through spirit how can one who finds himself among those who do not understand say amen to your Thanksgiving since he does not know what you're saying it seems to imply that at least in our hearts we're saying Amen to things that happen I say that because I'm kneeling in my heart I'm raising my hands in my heart I'm saying Amen to my heart don't ask me to actually vocalize it or lift them or get on my knees. This is a good passage that says that things should be done in a way that people can say Amen but that is that is a reminder to a preacher that it's I find it helpful when people actually give some talking back when I'm preaching. It doesn't happen in most of the churches I preach it. It can be a little disconcerting when you if that one we developed a close relationship with an African American congregation in Indiana and to the state one of my best friends as a pastor that was the pastor of that church now he's in Michigan now. And we did some pulpit exchange thing we would he would preach at a joint service at our church and I would preach their joint service at his church. And then we would combine our choirs which was a stretching experience for our choir to learn to sing stuff without having music in front of them that there wasn't actually any music for. And to have the choir director point to one of our women okay now it's your turn to lead the solo part you know like this woman from our church did you know it's like woo she did fine we're great. But when I preached in their church I mean you know lots of people were saying Amen the lots of things that I was saying and it's sort of raised my emotional level in my preaching which I think is a good thing for me. And afterwards some of the people from our congregation says pastor Mark why don't you preach like that in our church I said well maybe if you gave me as much feedback as I got today I might. Anyway and then they could say well if you preach like this we'd give you more feedback but anyway there's this there's a sense that people actually receiving what you're saying. And it sort of raises the level even of the importance of the preaching but the purpose of it as well. It's not for them to kind of give you a written evaluation at the end like we do in homiletics classes at the seminary but it's actually to impact their lives. Now the question of the utilization of lead worshipers in what I mean by this is the person up front leading usually with their own single voice is the only thing being heard at the time. What does that look like I want to look at first Corinthians 1426 we had a lengthy discussion about this passage in the doctor of ministry course I taught earlier this summer which is also a one week concentrated time with nine pastors there. But first Corinthians 1426 says that discussion made me go back and do some more study of the scripture and I looked at DA Carson has a little book on first Corinthians 11 to 14 I think it is or 12 to 14 maybe. But anyway what then shall we say brothers when you come together and given the context and given that language it certainly seems to mean when you come together in corporate public worship. Though I guess technically it could be in a small group Bible study but there is some coming together there's some corporate gathering everyone has a hymn or a word of instruction. A revelation a tone or an interpretation all of these must be done for the strengthening of the church it doesn't say when you come together listen carefully to the preacher who alone has something to give you. I don't think the Apostle Paul is saying this is in place of the preaching of the word and the oversight of elders. And in fact later in this passage in verse 33 is we'll look at a little bit more also when we talk about women in this regard as in all the congregations and saints women should remain silent in the churches. I personally think what's going on at that point is there is evaluation by the elders of some of these things that have been brought by everybody as to whether or not they're authoritative and from the Lord. And during that time the women and the non-elder men aren't the ones who are to be making the decisions about whether or not what Aunt Bessie said should be received as from the Lord. But the elders are the ones who are equipped and trained and called to do that. So I don't think that the overseeing authority of the elders is somehow missing from 1 Corinthians 11 to 14. But under it there's an encouragement when you come everyone has something to bring. And then this could radically change the way we do worship if you sort of ride this thing out of ways. It seems to be implying a lot more spontaneity than we have in most Presbyterian churches. And granted it's at a time before the canon of Scripture is complete. And the need for words of prophecy and tongues and so on was part of the way God spoke to the people then the way we now have in the fullness of the Scripture. So I'll grant kind of redemptive history. There are some dynamics here that no longer are as necessary as they were then. But at the same time I've been in gatherings. It's usually been like in college fellowship groups or I was part of the campus ministry in the Pittsburgh area for several years. And when we gathered 70 or 80 of us working in college campuses within 100 miles of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, ghost dealers got to get that in again. We have a chorus that everybody understands and join in the corporate amen. That's good. I like the calls on target here. Raise that one. If you stand and raise your hands, then we're up. We would have these extended times when we gathered for staff training of prayer and song and Scripture reading that was not organized by one person. Usually the executive director or somebody else would be up front saying, and we began, we came to that with a sense of this saying, let's go before the Lord an extended time of prayer and singing in Scripture reading. That's all he said. And then there'd be quiet for a while and then someone would read a passage of Scripture and someone would start leading in a song, Occupel. And then someone would pray and then there'd be more silence and then someone else would read another passage of Scripture. It wasn't pre-plant. How is God working in your lives and moving in your hearts in ways that you feel led to contribute to the edification of the body gathered at this particular time? The church that I worshipped in when I was in Italy, one of the two that we worshipped in last November, comes from more of a brethren background. And they had planned preaching in the Word and planned liturgy, but they had a section within the planned liturgy that was just like what I described with that campus leadership gathering where people were able to and they added to that give a brief word of testimony as well. So it's kind of an opportunity based on I think 1 Corinthians 1426. Part of what the body of Christ has to contribute what God wants to bring to the edification of the church may not, it doesn't exclusively have to come from the elder who's prepared the pastor who's prepared the sermon. It's not less than that and I still think that's probably primarily what should be happening, but is there a place? Certainly I think in small group gatherings, this can be very much a part of the participation of the body. And again, depending on the size of the church and the logistics and the history and the background, it's not like for some of you go to a new church unannounced to anybody, it's not in the bulletin, anything you say, now we're going to have a section of our worship service today where I wouldn't recommend you start there. But maybe if you're the senior solo pastor, even assistant pastor of the church or an elder in a church to suggest that you do something like that in your elders meetings and you begin to anticipate in your daily devotional time, I mean even in 101 discipleship things where you're going to be meeting weekly with someone, what's one of the expectations? Well, here's what God's been showing me from His Word and how He's been working in my heart. Well, some of the overflow of that is meant for the edification of others and potentially, I mean to me, the major piece that I see from this that has application to the way I think we should do worship today is what I would call something like a testimony. Not just a testimony of how God first brought me to faith in Christ, though that's certainly appropriate, but sort of a window of God's grace where someone is kind of pulling the shade back and saying, let me show you how God buys grace is working in my life in this two to three minute testimony that I've planned in advance and cleared with the elder or pastor if you need to go that way for the edification of the church. So I think one of the things to think through is where is this place for the participants to contribute to the edification of one another? What we used to do in the churches, I passed it about once a month, usually under prayers of praise and adoration would say we're going to have an open time for men, women and children to just stand up where you are and pray a brief prayer of adoration or praise to God or prayer. And sometimes I would say adults, let's let the children go first. So some of your children, if you're willing, would you please lead us in a prayer of thanksgiving? Because usually when an adult goes and it sounds adult-like in the prayer, then the children are hesitant or newer believers are hesitant. And I sometimes say and let's abide by the ABCs of prayer, audible, brief and Christ-centered. Speak loudly enough, it's God hears it even if I don't, but it's for the edification of the body, so audible, brief. So others have a chance and the preacher can still preach this 30 minute sermon. And Christ-centered, which may be, Lord, help me get the rest of this finger nail off that I'm having trouble getting clipped, sort of prayers. Which sometimes you get, I mean, is God concerned about that, yes, but in corporate public worship it may not be the most edifying prayer. And people aren't going to be audible, aren't going to be brief and aren't going to be Christ-centered, at least you're instructing them and trying to help them to see how that goes. So what are the places where you can encourage the priesthood of all believers to offer spiritual sacrifices, certainly corporate in the corporate voice all the time. That's a primary thing you're planning, responsive reading songs, unison, creeds, etc. But what about one time, we didn't encourage this much in the churches I serve, but one time in the church I served in Indiana, a guy came in late to the service, I just finished a prayer and he stood up and he said, Pastor, I have something I'd like to say. Now this is a man who personality wise, if you'd ever ask him to say something, he'd say, no way. I knew something significant was up for this man to say, can I say something? And he said, on my way to church today, he said, I want to praise God for sparing my life on the way to church today. And I need to describe this situation where by all means he should have been hit and killed. And so we took a moment to praise God and thank him for sparing Tom's life on his way to church. Now is that edifying to the congregation? Certainly was. Reminder that by the grace of God we all ride to church today. And it was encouraging that this man who was a fairly new believer, not always there at church, was wanting to give testimony to God in front of the congregation. I mean it was, I'm sure more people went home and talked about Tom's 15-second testimony than they did my 35-minute sermon. And so be it. If that was the case and that's what God used to impact and identify and encourage the believers that day. So I guess what I'm arguing for is some place, some of the time, for opportunities, for those sort of offering of spiritual sacrifices by individuals in the congregation that can be edifying to the whole body. Okay. Let me finish page 23 here and then we'll take a break and the next lesson time will be the continuation of this. And then into planning. But I think as a pastor I need to let other elders do some of the upfront solo voice leading. I think it's good to have elders read scripture to have elders pray and that may not be their gift to pray but if they're shepherding the flock, it's probably good at least every so often for the whole flock to hear the elder pray for the flock. Okay. So they can kind of get to know the heart of the elders and overseers of the church and so that it's not always the same voice that's leading in that. And some will be very gifted. Some elders may be more gifted than you in actually leading different portions of the service. And by all means you should let them. I pastor to a church where we had an assistant pastor who we knew was sort of getting some experience and on his way to being a church planner who was a great preacher. Graduate of covenant seminary about 10 years younger than me, not having nearly as much preaching experiences me but the congregation was responding with preaching and so I face this sort of dilemma. Am I going to be jealous of that and let him and make him preach less? Or am I going to see that as a gift for this congregation in this season of the church's life and let him preach more? Would it ever be appropriate for an assistant pastor to preach more often than the senior pastor? There's a question to ponder. In some models of ministry, no way. But in other models of ministry maybe so. That's he took a call to another church but you know that was something I was beginning to wonder about a little bit. Not always in the most sanctified way either I'll admit. If that happens do I need to go somewhere else? Not necessarily. Deacons, I think that some churches had to practice when the deacons come up to receive the offering out that the deacons have to be the ones who do that, that the prayer that happens at the time of the offering one of the deacons will offer. I think that's a good thing. I think we need to have words of testimony or a mission moments where the deacons are bringing into the corporate public worship service the acts of mercy and kindness that they're doing to other people both inside and beyond the church not that they're naming names or be lying confidences or whatever. But the mercy ministry element of the church's life is part of our prayer concern and celebration and expression of spiritual sacrifice of the whole church that I think can be done. Non elders non deacons men women and children can give testimonies of God's grace can lead in mission moments can give sentence prayers of praise and thanksgiving occasional scripture readings in my opinion not related to the preaching of the word we'll get into that more after our break when we talk about women. Music leaders a worship song leader leaders of choirs and ensembles soloist instrumentalist these are all ways that that you have sort of lead worshipers that are sort of identifiable as these people are leading worship at this time in a way that's beyond just the whole congregation responding. And I think we need to encourage that and I I sort of like the visual even where possible of if I'm if I'm only preaching in a given service notice I said only preaching and I'm not doing anything else prior to the sermon I want to sit with my family. I don't think that I have to be sitting up in the throne chair up front you know something like some churches overseeing with the stern look is this elder doing things right is this person giving the testimony you know whatever I'd rather be out of my family and then come up out of the congregation it's sort of represents I'm alongside of the church I mean this is the way every church must do it and if you don't then you're not worshiping biblically don't hear that at all. I'm saying one way to make visible the idea of even the preacher being primarily like the rest of congregation in union with Christ and fellowship of the believers and gifted like everybody else is gifted and then coming up to preach can be it can be a good thing or someone comes up I actually like the choir if it can be done to come up from their seats with their families to sing and go back and out to little disrupting but it's sort of you have this sense throughout the service that there are participants from the living stones first Peter to who come up and go back and there's this sort of this movement or ministering under Christ under the oversight of the elders and you know some churches visualize that by all the elders wearing roads and sitting in the front row I don't think that's necessary but it's not wrong but I sort of like that that movement in the churches that I've served well let's take a break and come back and talk a bit more about moving toward planning worship as well.