<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Бериш Ай сайын бериш

Study of Church History

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

We study ancient and medieval church history. You need to have two things in your possession. One is the text book by Husto Gonzales, volume one of the story of Christianity, and you need the syllabus. Those two reading materials, the book and the syllabus, the syllabus will give you the outlines of the lectures, and also some additional reading material, so be sure you have both the book and the syllabus. The beginning of the syllabus, there is the material that you can read through at your leisure, the objectives of the course, the methods, the themes, there are certain themes that I'm going to try to emphasize. In a survey course, of course, there are so many things that we can talk about, and I won't nearly get to everything that is important even in the history of the ancient and medieval church, but there are certain themes that I'm particularly concerned about, and you can see those themes spelled out on page three, the beginning of the syllabus. One of your assignments will be to prepare a timeline or a research paper. Let me talk a little bit about each of those. The timeline is simply a way in which you can get in mind and display in some attractive form. There are dates, dates are part of church history. There's no way we can really study church history without having some appreciation for the dates of church history. In November, a few years ago, there was a man named Brooks Williams, who was giving a concert here at Covenant, some music he had written, and he was talking about a song based on the life of St. Brendan of Ireland, and he said, well, St. Brendan lived in the sixth century, or in the eighth century, or in some century. Well, we need to be a little more precise than that when we come to trying to identify the flow of church history dates, so our important and the timeline will help you get in mind and perhaps keep in mind some of the important dates. Now, you could be very creative with that. I've had all sorts of timelines. Last time I taught this class, one of the students did an ancient and medieval church history monopoly game. Very fine, I enjoyed playing it. In fact, it came with a couple of recommendations, a climate of Alexandria, said it would be difficult to conceive of a more carefully constructed board game. And even the great church father Athanasius approved of it. This is simply the best board game I've ever played, he said. So, use your creativity if you want to do a timeline. If you think that doesn't sound like fun, and you'd rather write a paper, you can't. You can write a research paper on some topic related to ancient and medieval church history, and the syllabus will describe some of the topics that you can write on and how you should do the paper. So, you make a choice as to whether you're going to do timeline or a paper. And then there will be two exams. Now, the good news is that all the questions for the exams are in the syllabus, so you can find out today exactly what's going to be on the midterm exam and on the final exam. There are 100 questions there. The 100 most important things that you need to know for ancient and medieval church history. The way you should go about preparing for this is to do a notebook. I will not take up the notebooks and grade them, but the notebook is for you to get in some kind of good form the answers to these 100 questions. And on the exams, I will select from the list certain questions that you will be able to answer. So, I hope that takes some of the attention out of the course. You don't have to try to guess what I'm going to ask on the final exam or the midterm exam. And also, I think it will help us to focus our attention on some very important things. Now, there are other important things too. This is my list of what I think we could consider the 100 most important things to know about ancient and medieval church history. So, when you finish the class, if you don't know anything else, you will know 100 things. And many of these questions have come from PCA Presbyteria Licensure and Ordination exams. So, I have tried to select from those lists from the various Presbyteria questions that will likely come up if you face licensure or ordination. It will be good preparation for that. For some of you, and for all of you, it helps to focus the material. Much of what you need for the answers will come from Gonzales, will come from my lectures. But occasionally, you should go beyond those sources, and I have listed in the syllabus some important dictionaries. So, I have mentioned in Cyclopedia's of Church History, which you can find in the reference section of the library, and that will help you to round out the answers to the questions. Let's come now to lecture one, centuries deep, and continents wide, the study of church history. For each of the lectures, I will include a scripture text or two, versus that have particular relevance to the theme that we are discussing in that particular lecture. But these verses will come up over and over again. In fact, I will close most of the lectures with one or the other of these verses. Therefore, since we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses, let us throw off everything that hinders and the sin that so easily entangles, and let us run with perseverance, the race marked out for us. Because we are concerned in church history not only to learn about what has happened in the past, but to be able to understand that God has given us the work to do as well. Church history goes on today in our lives, and we must run with perseverance, the race that God has marked out for us. Sometimes I will close with another verse because often in the study of church history, the story is not encouraging or inspiring often it is, but it is not always that way. Sometimes we will see the church in the depths of failure, and having backslidden from the truth turned away from the truth, at least large parts of the church. So those topics, those lectures, will fallibly end with this verse from Isaiah, the grass withers, flower faves, but the word of our God shall stand forever. And we will see that even in the church, the grass withers and the flower faves, but the truth of God, the word of God marches on. Sooner or later it is picked up by some other more faithful group and begins to make its way again in the world. And then all of church history is overwhelming in the sense of there is so much out there. In the history of the church, we are going to study 1500 years of history and just a few weeks actually. And that means that it will be frustrating both to me and to you because we will appear at times to be moving so quickly over the subject matter that we are looking at on that particular day. And I might be tempted at times to say of what more shall I say, I do not have time to tell about all these other church fathers and the imported people of the medieval church and others that we would like to be able to talk about. The prayer for this lecture comes from a modern church historian, Dr. Ford Lewis Battles. He was a Rhodes scholar studied with CS Lewis and then taught church history for most of his career at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary. He is best known as the translator of Calvin's Institutes in the McNeil Battles edition of the Institutes. And we will start with this prayer from Dr. Battles. Let's pray together. Oh, Father, we have not always been faithful to Thy Word. We have not always taken up our cross to follow Thy Son. And too often we have forgotten the church we are called to serve. Renew in our hearts and in our minds the faith that was in Peter and Paul. The faith that strengthened the ancient martyrs, the faith that moved the pins and lips of the fathers, the faith that built cathedrals and universities, the faith that moved the reformers to renew the church in their time. No father teaches how to impart that faith to Thy people. These petitions we lay before Thy Presence in the name of Thy Son, our Lord. Amen. So we think about studying church history. We need to give some thought to exactly what we are doing in this class. What is church history? I saw a definition not long ago of history. And this person said history is what historians do. And I suppose if that's right, which has to be, then church history is what church historians do. So I'm going to do in this class and what you're going to do. But if that is the case, then the word church is very important. What is the church? We're studying the history of the church. The Westminster Confession of Faith in chapter 25 gives us an important definition of the church, both the visible church and the invisible. Now we're going to study the visible church because it's hard to study the invisible church. But it's important to understand what the invisible church is because that will always be there as the standard, the ideal, what God expects of the church. Church will always fall short of the perfection of the invisible church until it's united with the Lord in heaven. But we will study the visible church, which consists of all those throughout the world that profess the true religion. The Westminster Divines meant by that Christian religion and even the Protestant religion. But we're going to study the history of the Christian church from the post-apostolic period. This semester, right up to the time that we're very close to the Reformation, art and Luther was born in 1483. We'll go to about the time of the birth of Luther and in Reformation and modern church history. We look at the rest of the church, the next 500 years, from the Reformation up to the present. The confession says unto this Catholic visible church, this universal visible church Christ has given the ministry, oracles and ordinances of God for the gathering and perfecting of the saints. I think that's probably a good short definition of what I would like for us to do together this semester to study the ministry of the church, the ministry, oracles and ordinances of the church, how the church function in its worship and in its ministry. And also the gathering of the church, how the church grew from tiny, tiny group of people in a out-of-the-way province part of the Roman Empire to a mighty movement that encompassed many parts of Europe and reached out into Asia and to Africa and to Latin America, even in the years before 1500, and we'll study the perfecting of the saints, the spiritual progress of God's people through the years. We'll notice at times that the church is making progress. At times it seems not to be making progress, but we will look at the ministry, the growth and the spiritual progress of the church. Where do we begin with all of this? Well, let's have a look at one opinion on this to students of church history. One is writing a paper and trying to decide actually where to begin, and she finally has it in mind. The writing about church history, we have to go back to the very beginning, which is good thought. Our pastor was born in 1930. We're going to have to go back before that. Heinrich Bellinger, who was the successor to Zwingli in Zurich, the Reformation period, wrote a book called The Old Faith, and Bellinger's point in that book, which was a polemic against the Catholics who had been saying to the Protestants in Switzerland, you have something new. We belong to the Old Church, and you have created a new church. Well, Bellinger was not going to let that go without an answer, so in The Old Faith he goes back to Adam and Eve, proves that Adam and Eve were the first Protestants, and whether he succeeded in that or not, he did make a good point that church history begins at the very beginning with the creation of Adam and Eve. The whole number of the elect, according to the Westminster Confession of Faith, and that includes people all the way back to Adam and Eve. We're not going to go back that far in this class. After all, I have to allow Old Testament department, New Testament department, something to do. So they'll take care of that part of the history of the church for us, and we'll start in the post-apostolic period, which means about the year 100, and we'll trace the history of the church then throughout the two millennia in the two courses that you will be taking. Sometimes people have called church history the third Testament. First Testament is the Old Testament, and the second Testament is the New Testament, and church history is the third Testament. I'd rather like that way of looking at church history because it does continue the history of the church that begins in the Old Testament, continues in the New Testament, a record of both gods. Faithful people and those people who prove to be unfaithful, of course the Old Testament has plenty of that in the New Testament too, and church history certainly does as well. Of course we don't think that this book, our books like this, are in any sense on the same level with the inspired word of God and the Old Testament and the New Testament, but the history of the church continues. As the New Testament makes very clear, and as the history of the church continues, we continue to study the record of God's work in the midst of His people. Now church history is quite I think, at least to me, intriguing, we're studying about people, real people facing real problems, and trying to solve those problems one way or the other, and those people are very much like us and those problems are very much like problems that we face today. I think as we get into church history, we'll feel a connection with our extended Christian family, not only extended now in the world, but extended in the past, we will discover our ancestry and our roots, Christian people who have gone before us and have run the race with perseverance that God set before them. But there are some problems too, and I want to talk about those for a moment. One is the problem of selection, because in studying church history, we study, according to the Westminster Confession of Faith definition, all those throughout the world that profess the true religion. That's a big order, as impossible. History of the church is everybody throughout the world who is a Christian, and Professor Gonzalez has had to select certain topics as he deals with church history in this book, and I have to select certain topics too. There's a list of the lecture topics in the syllabus. Those are the themes, the people that I'm going to focus on. That means I leave out much of the history of the church. Christian History magazine, which is, by the way, an excellent source for timelines and pictures and articles on the history of the church. Some years ago, I did a rather careful survey of church history teachers and pastors and scholars and laypeople, and came up with the list of the 100 most important events in church history. I've included that list in the syllabus, so when you're doing your timelines, you certainly should have those dates, more dates than that. At least the dates in the 100 most important events in church history, but I thought it was very wise that the editors, as they presented this list, to write this sentence, we would not be at all surprised. If someday, we find out that God's list differs significantly from our list of the 100 most important events in church history. I remember Edith Schafer was here a few years ago, speaking in chapel, and there was a question and answer time, and someone asked Mrs. Schafer, who is the most important Christian in the world today? Without much of hesitation, she said, I don't know, and you don't either, and probably nobody does. We could think of some big names that would seem important to most people, but I think Mrs. Schafer was wise in saying that we really cannot make that sort of decision or do not have that kind of wisdom. Well, I'm saying all of that in order to stress that many people are going to get left out of this story, that should not be left out of the story. If God was teaching the class, they would be in the story, but I don't know, so I have to do the best I can, and I'll talk about the people that seem significant to me. And I think to many others as well, certainly on any body's list, St. Augustine is a very important figure. So Augustine gets three lectures. Nobody else in all of church history at these two classes that covered in seminary gets three lectures. Not even John Calvin gets two. Luther gets two. John Knox only gets one. He's a Presbyterian. But Augustine gets three, and I think we'll see why as we come to Augustine. But I do want to try not to forget what we could call the forgotten people, because it's too easy to teach church history from the standpoint of the people who wrote the books, preached the sermons, and did the important things and church history is not only the preacher preaching the sermon, but it's the person in the few listening to the sermon. And that means that we need to be at least a way of the fact that church history is much bigger than often we see it in presentations, in books of church history. I think that means a number of things practically. It means that we really have to work hard to be sure that we talk about the contribution of women in the history of the church, because women have been and continue to be very much part of the church and very important in the history of the church. And so much of the story of women has been left out till recent years when there has been much more interest in trying to understand the significance of women in history and in church history as well. The same thing could be said for children, and certainly there are people in church history slaves and serfs and people on the lower level of the economic ladder and the social ladder who are very important in the history of the church. But we have to work very hard because those people did not write the books and there are ways that historians can try to recover what the forgotten people really were thinking and what they were saying. We read the poem, a worker reads history and you'll see that point made in a rather gripping way. So we're trying to study the history of God's people, the visible church throughout the world. So often church history, particularly as it's taught in the United States, can focus too narrowly on Europe and on North America. Remember reading an account from Professor Andrew Walls who taught at University of Aberdeen in Edinburgh in Scotland for many years, but Professor Walls was at one time a missionary in Africa. And he said that as he set out to teach church history in Africa, he followed the traditional Scottish method of church history which involved three years of training. First year, studied the early church, second year, the Reformation, and the third year, Scotland, after all what else is there, he said. And he became suddenly aware that teaching church history in Africa was a great deal that he was leaving out and it helped him to reorient his thinking about the history of the church. So much of what we will study will a necessity focus on Europe, but we need to also be aware of the developments of the history of the church in Asia. Unfortunately, a new book by Samuel Moffitt on time missionary in Korea called The History of Christianity in Asia, volume one, beginning to 1500, has been available now for several years. And that helps us to understand that the church developed not only in the West, but in the East and the Far East as well, volume two of Dr. Mott's history is not yet out, but should be available before too much longer. The history of the church in Africa will keep an eye on what happens in Africa as well as in Asia. I'm particularly delighted with the book by Mark Shaw called The Kingdom of God in Africa, a short history of African Christianity. These books appear in the syllabus with the bibliographical data that you would need to find them. I'm still looking for a good book, survey book on the history of Christianity in Latin America. I haven't yet discovered that, although Professor Gonzales is Latin, he is Cuban, born and raised in Cuba, and actually this book was written originally in Spanish, translated into English. Kind of an interesting way for church history text to come to a Presbyterian seminary in St. Louis, Missouri. But I think you will enjoy reading it. Professor Gonzales is an excellent writer. He keeps the story moving, interesting, and almost always it's right. Originally I had a little argument with him on a point or two, and I'll try to make that known as we go along, but this is good, lively history. If you really don't like history, I think you'll like this book. If you like history, you'll love it, and you'll probably want to read some others, which is fine. You can read Shaft and Flatterat and Williston Walker and all those others too, but this is one you have to read for this class. Well, that's one problem that we will work on, a problem of selection. Trying to be broad enough to have an understanding of the whole history of the church within the compass of a very quick overview. Another problem is the problem of mixture and of era. You can read those comments from the Westminster Confession of Faith.

Catholic Church has been sometimes more, sometimes less visible, that is the Christian Church. And particular churches, which are members thereof, or more or less pure, the purist churches under heaven are subject both to mixture and era, and some have so degenerated as to become no churches of Christ. Which means as we study church history, at times we'll see the church at a very high point, and we'll celebrate there. We'll rejoice in that. We'll be moved by it. Other times we'll see the church, it seems to be no church at all. Given over to greed and selfishness and war and unbelief, apostasy. So that is something that is true of the history of the church, and there's no way we can change it. It's no way we would want to change it, because we want to study what's true. Remember, teaching this class a few years ago in summer school, and a woman from the city of St. Louis was in the class, and she studied with me for the weeks of summer school, and the class ended. She said, you know, Dr. Caldwell in this class has been a real encouragement to me. I really learned something that I didn't know. I've been so discouraged about my church because it's in such a mess and there's so many problems. But now I know that the whole history of the church is like that. Well, that was not exactly the only point I wanted to get across, but it's not an important point. The history of the church is a history of even the best churches being subject to both mixture and era, which means that there's much to celebrate, but there is also much to simply, I suppose, the best way to say it is to forgive. We can forgive the past, and realize the errors of people in the past who did things in the name of Christ that they should not have done. Someone asked Roland Vainton, the great church historian at Yale once, Dr. Vainton, how can you know so much church history and still be a Christian? Well, sometimes that discouraging thought might come to you. We get into the crusades, for instance. It's not much good coming out of that. A lot of harm that we still live with, all done under the sign of the cross and in the name of Christ. But there's much to celebrate, too. And we'll often see that people did run the race with perseverance and have left us an example to follow. Now, another problem is the problem of meaning or interpretation. It's one thing to say this happened. Now, that's hard enough to get straight to really know what happened. There was a family looking at a historical marker over here. But there's an old man sitting over there with his own sign that says, what really happened? Here's a close-up of that old man. What really happened? So the book is going to say, what happened? I'm going to say, what really happened? It's the picture of me there, pipe and all. No, this is a good book, and you can trust it. There's not going to be too many places where I will say, I think, we should change the account of what happened. But that itself is a struggle, as you know. People have different ideas as to what happened. And the only way we can deal with that is simply the hard work of research and study and talking together, comparing text and so on to try to answer the question. What really happened? But there's another question, and that is, what does it all mean? We really need to deal with both of those questions. What happened in the early church? What does it mean? What is the significance of it? And there will be different opinions too. What made this country great? What did you put down for that question, Marcy? Faith, courage and hard work. What did you put down? Peanut butter sandwiches. Different ideas as to what it all means. Historical study in our time in the modern west is in a kind of confused and trouble condition. It seems to me because there are different approaches to history. You studied history in university these ideas. Three theories, which generally are viewed as antagonistic. There is the pre-modern idea of history or the ideological idea of history. And that is, history is studied with an assumption already in mind. And then history is used to prove that, to undergird that, to establish it. The first church historian is Eusebius of Cessaria. We'll study Eusebius a little bit later. But Euroslav Telekin, the great modern church historian, who recently converted to the Orthodox church. He had been Lutheran, but now in his old age, Orthodox. Dr. Euroslav Telekin said Eusebius is a historian who doesn't believe in history. And by that event that Eusebius has a kind of assumption, and he works from that assumption and the facts are then martial to buttress his argument. That's all pre-modern history. And then we came into a period which we could call modern or scientific history, which historians felt that the way to really do history is to divorce oneself from any ideological conviction. And to try to ascertain exactly what happened as we do in the physical sciences. And to avoid all questions about meaning. So the true historian now is not the man with a thought in his mind that he's going to prove by history, but the man or the woman who can become objective and detached and neutral about everything. One writer has said to be a good historian, it's necessary to be without religion, without country, without profession, and without party. People thought they could do that, but we've discovered you can't do that. Nobody can write history in that sort of vacuum. We bring ourselves to the task. And when I study history, I'm very aware of my personality, my background, my training, the fact that I teach here at Covenant Seminary, and all those things impact the way I look at history and the way I study history. Well, the modern approach has pretty much gone by the boards, and we have moved now into the postmodern or deconstructive period of the study of history. And basically, what that says is that historical writing has never been objective. It's always been full of value or bias. And so the traditional quests for the truth are impossible. We can't really study history anymore in a broad and general way. We have to talk about whose history are we studying? It's the history of men, white Anglo-Saxons. They have their vested interest in keeping the history that way, but the history of women, the history of African-Americans, the history of any group. It's going to be a different history. Well, that leaves us in a kind of dismal place where nobody can talk about history in any sort of overarching sense, but each person's history is personal and directed toward that group, not toward, we would say, the whole church. Well, what are we going to do? It seems to me that we can use, to some extent, all of these approaches. We do have convictions as we start this study. We do want to be as fair as we can. And we do realize that certain people have been left out in the history of the church. So with the help of two great angels, which Margaret Lewis-Dabney put it, research and meditation, we're going to try to do this task of studying the history of God's people for these 1500 years. What are the rewards? Well, there are great rewards, God's glory, which will bring us to worship. Our prophet lead us into greater sanctification and for the good of the church, which will direct us into ministry. Therefore, since we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses, let us run with perseverance, the race marked out for us.