<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Gouf Gouf monatlech

Are Women Human?

November 18, 2023
0:000:00

If you turn your Bible to the second book of Samuel, chapter 11, as this morning's reading was a long one, this evening's reading will be comparatively short, so I just want to read the first five verses of this chapter, but first let us pray for the Lord's illumination as becomes the reading and the proclamation of His Word. The Lord God has become before you this evening, on the evening of your day, we thank you that you have given us one day in seven to set aside to reflect upon you, your being, your works, and your gospel. And as we come to reflect upon this yet another difficult passage within your Word, we would pray, oh God, that your Holy Spirit would be at work in our hearts and minds, renewing them, that we might see even in this most disastrous of moments in the rule of King David, the greatest of the Old Testament kings. We might see something here that allows us to understand our own times more thoroughly and allows us to see Christ more clearly, for we pray these things in Jesus' name, amen. Hear the Word of the Lord. In the spring of the year, the time when kings go out to battle, David sent Joe up at his servants with him and all Israel, and they ravaged the Ammonites and besieged rabbi. The David remained at Jerusalem. It happened late one afternoon when David arose from his couch and was walking on the roof of the king's house, that he saw from the roof a woman bathing, and the woman was very beautiful. And David sent and inquired about the woman, and one said, is this not Bathsheba, the daughter of Eliam, the wife of Uriah, the Hittite? So David sent messengers and took her, and she came to him and he lay with her. Now she had been purifying herself from her and clean this. Then she returned to her house, and the woman conceived, and she sent and told David, I am pregnant. Praise God for his holy word. When I got a note from Kevin last week asking for a title of the sermon, I've never quite got into the American habit of giving titles to servants, so I generally try to give a title that merely is the title of the chapter that I'm looking at. But my eyes were caught by the little book on my bookshelf, written by the wonderful Dorothy L. Sayers, our women, human. It is a great essay that I commend to you if you can get hold of a copy. It is well worth reading. It struck me that that captures a key question that lies at the heart of many of the developments that we've been looking at earlier today and yesterday. So much of the revolution in what it means to be a human, I think has had a most detrimental effect on women. It is dehumanized as all, but it is particularly dehumanized women, and that is not all of what I want to say tonight relative to this passage, but it is a key part of what I want to say relative to this passage. I must summarize it by saying the way David treats Bathsheba in this is a inhuman way. She is dehumanized by what takes place here. I want to make three basic points relative to this passage, which touch on that issue. I want to use this passage to reflect upon the way morality and what I call taste connect to each other, both in the biblical narrative and in contemporary society. Secondly, I want to look once again at the power of sexual desire and what it does and how our understanding of it, what that does, to what it means to being a human being, and then finally, I want to conclude by reflecting upon the seductive nature of the myth of human autonomy and power, which lies, I think, very much at the heart of so much of what I've been talking about the last couple of days. I want to reflect on morality and taste, I want to talk about the power of sex and sexual desire, and I want to talk about the seductive nature of this myth of autonomy, this idea that we are born free and everywhere in chains. But before we come to those points, first of all, a little bit of context for this passage. In many ways, this passage, the tragedy of this passage, derived from the fact that this is the moment in David's career where he is at the zenith of his power. Not only has he succeeded to the throne, not only has he effectively crushed the internal opposition, not only has he dealt very graciously with some of his enemies, and positioned himself really in a fantastic position over a unified kingdom, he is now unchallenged. It is the peak of David's career, and it is that this very moment, of course, that he will plunge his family, his dynasty, and his kingdom into crisis. This passage really deals with what we might say is the fall of David. Yes, David was a fallen human being, he was fallen in Adam as we all are. But this is the moment in his own narrative biography where David's public life and private life will be plunged into a crisis from which they will never truly recover. His family and the kingdom will never be as united, again as they were prior to this. The some foreign policy issue going on here, his amazing general, Joe Abbasov, in the field fighting with the Ammonites. David is in Jerusalem, some people think that there is a hint of condemnation in this passage that yes, the men are off in the field, engaged in war, David is in Jerusalem. It's hard to say if that's the case. The text, I think, is at best ambiguous. It doesn't seem to me to necessarily imply delinquency. The real point, I think, of this passage is this, from that perspective, Joe is off fighting Israel's enemies. But the real enemy of Israel is going to prove to be David at this point. The king himself is going to be the one who undoes Israel and all of the good work that he has done thus far, Israel. The kingdom is going to be destabilized because of what David does in Jerusalem. Not what Joe Abbas does on the field of military combat. So that's the background there. The story, of course, is very straightforward. David is on the roof of his palace. He catches sight of a naked woman bathing. Two preliminary points, I think, are worth making relative to this. First of all, accidentally seeing this woman naked and bathing is not a sin. There is nothing in the text that implies that he went on the roof to be a sort of peeping tom. He was not up there to spy on his neighbor. About 12 months ago, my neighbor told me that we'd had a... He'd videoed a bear wandering through our garden the late one night. And I was left wondering, why is my neighbor videoing my garden at 1 a.m. in the morning? It was slightly creepy, but I think he was a perfect innocent thing. He saw the bear and videoed it. As with David here, I think this is an innocent thing that he's doing. He's up on the roof of his palace. He looks down. He happens to see a naked woman bathing. The sin is not that he sees her. The sin is that he fails to take immediate remedial action. We perhaps all blended into situations where we've seen or heard things. We should not have seen or heard. The right response in those situations is always to back away immediately. Not to indulge ourselves. The problem with David is that he indulges himself. He sees and does not immediately avert his grace. He sees and does not immediately return into the palace itself. So that's the first point. I don't think David is sinning by being on the roof of the palace. I think he sins. The moment he fails to avert his gaze and get out of there as quickly as possible. The second, and this is perhaps a more controversial point, is Batsuba. Does not seem, as far as the text is concerned at this point, to be doing anything wrong. We can assume that the height of the palace roof gave David sight of an area of her dwelling that would typically have been private. We've ever spent any time in a Muslim country if you've gone to the Middle East at all. You'll know that Middle Eastern has his often have fairly tall walls. And I'm told that the reason for that is that the household is to be kept private, particularly the women of the household, as to be given privacy from prying eyes. Presumably she was out there with every expectation of privacy. It was just unfortunate that the building next door gave the king a sight of what should have been a private area. We have told, of course, that she's engaged in a ritual bathing, a ritual bathing required of an Israelite woman after her period was over. The fact that she's engaging in the proper ritual bath at this point, the fact that she's engaged in a religious exercise at the very moment when David is losing the plot makes her look pretty good, I think, in comparison to David. She's engaged in an act of ritual piety, just as he is kind of losing the moral plot. So, those are two preliminary points, but what can we learn from this passage that may be a more perennial significance to us? The first thing is this, sight is powerful. The visual is very powerful. One of the things, of course, that the reformational, certain, more radical strands of the reformation, more reformed strands of the reformation are known for, of course, is iconoclasm, the getting rid of images and stained glass windows. I think Christians can disagree and debate on that particular issue, but one thing that it acknowledges, the very fact that it is an issue, it acknowledges that sight, the things you see are important. One of my favorite passages in church history, relative to this, is found in Augustine the great 4th, 5th Century Bishop's Confessions, when he's talking about his very close friend Olympius, the man who is converted at the same time, actually, as Augustine. Olympius had this dislike of gladiatorial games. He disliked the violence of gladiatorial games, and one day his friends, bunch of young men get together and they sort of drag him to the circus, and he all the way is going there to say, you can drag me there, but I'm not going to watch. And Augustine describes what happens, he says that Olympius is there and he's got his eyes closed, and then one of the gladiators strikes a mortal blow, slays the other gladiator, the crowd roars, and Olympius intuitively opens his eyes. And Augustine has this very powerful literary phrase where he says, the blow that was struck to his soul was more deadly than that, which the one gladiator struck the other one. It's a very powerful passage, and from that moment onwards, Olympius is a fanatical follower of the gladiatorial games. Think of that. That scene of extreme violence changed him. The way Augustine describes Olympius after that is he's a different man, fascinating. It's interesting actually that modern science would kind of confirm that. We know that exposure, I'm told, I shouldn't say I know, I'm told by people who are cleverer than me and know these things more than I do, I'm told that exposure to images of explicit sex and explicit violence actually reframe the brain. The neural pathways of the brain, those things that change depending on the habits we have. If you play a musical instrument or you learn a foreign language, your brain sort of rewires itself. And that's why if you've learned one foreign language, it's easier to learn a second than a third, because the brain is adapted to that. Well we know that as positive as that is with musical instruments, as negative it can be, with things like pornography and violence, the brain rewires itself to expect this kind of stuff. So what Augustine, we might say naively describes the transformation of his friends, his friend Olympius actually has biological grounding. The visual profoundly affects the physiological structure of the brain, reinforcing the moral structure of the heart. And enslavement to pornography falls into that caster he doesn't it. Some of the most hopeless cancelsing situations that pastors find themselves in these days I think certainly in my experience, young men enslave to pornography. Their brains have come to expect it. The moral condition of their soul is dragged down by the transformation that has occurred within them of the things they have seen. It's interesting sight in the Bible is very, very powerful. The Bible acknowledges this and it's understanding of what it means to be human. Adam, when he first sees Eve, this is now bone of my bone and flesh of my flesh. And I commended it was this morning or last night I commended John Milton's, a paradise lost, that section in paradise lost where Milton sort of poetically speculates on what's going through Adam's mind when he sees this beautiful creature standing before him. This at last is bone of my bone and flesh of my flesh. And then negatively of course in the four site seduces Eve, Genesis 3.6. So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food and that it was a delight to the eyes and that the tree was to be desired to make one wise, she took of its fruit and ate. And she also gave some to her husband who was with her and he ate. Notice there are three things involved in Eve's decision. She makes the judgment of practicality. This food is to be desired, presumably to fill the belly and to make her wise. She makes a judgment of appearance, pleasing to the eyes, it's beautiful. I might suggest that her judgment in those two areas is basically correct. Certainly, the fruit must have tasted good because she hands it to her husband. If it was bitter and foul she'd have thrown it away. It filled her belly. It was also beautiful to the site. What she allows to happen there though of course is this. She allows the site of the fruit and the utility of the fruit to overwhelm the moral structure of the garden that God has given to her. There is no larger moral framework. I would suggest a couple of things that we might bear in mind as a result of that. First of all, as I've already said, we should be careful what we see. Images are powerful. Secondly, we should not allow morality to be overwhelmed by utility or taste. That has broader implications than just the visual and very interested in the way language shifts, the particular points in time. It's very interesting isn't it that the language of right and wrong has pretty much disappeared? We tend not to say about somebody that's wrong. What we tend to say is that was a distasteful remark. That was a hurtful comment. That was an off-color joke. Think about that language. That's not the language of right and wrong. It may be saying a similar thing, but it's actually the language of taste. I might say it's the language of aesthetics. It's the language of emotional response to something that's gone on. We must not allow our moral framework to be overwhelmed by utility, or I think more dangerously for many of us in the church today, taste. The world would tell us that being hurtful is the worst sin. We have to affirm people because if we do not affirm them, we hurt them. And that is not, we don't want to hurt people unnecessarily. We really don't. But we do not want our concepts of what is hurtful to stand in opposition to what is moral. We do not want what is moral to be overwhelmed by aesthetics and feelings. The truth has to drive our taste as Christians. I facetiously use myself as an example in class when I'm teaching the students and I say the statement that Truman is a bald guy with crooked teeth is true. It's very hurtful, but it's true. It's undeniably true. We must allow the truth to be the foundation of our moral decision making, not taste. That's the problem with Eve. She allows the beauty, the tastefulness of the fruit. Perhaps the taste, literal taste of the fruit, to overwhelm the moral framework. And that's what we see with David here. He sees a beautiful woman and his moral framework is overwhelmed by that. So that's the first thing to notice then. Second thing to notice, the power of sexual desire. We're probably all aware of that. Every day of the year you can open the newspaper or switch on the news. Or maybe it occurs with somebody you yourself know personally and see crazy stories of people who've thrown it all away for a moment of passion or moments of insane desire. That's what we see here. There is an insanity to what David does. Not only does he not turn away on the roof. He engages in a conspiracy to get this woman into his palace. For well with desire, he first inquires about Bathsheba. At which point he learns that she's off limits. She's married to Uriah the Hittite. She is the daughter of Eliam. She is off limits. And yet still he presses forward. Notice the risk he takes. This is a public act. He's asking other people about this. I'm a big believer in that statement that three men can keep a secret if two of them are dead. Here he is showing his hand to his retainers. Her married status makes no difference to him. Still he presses on. And notice. And this is where we start to get to the question of our women human. Notice this. She is objectified. Verse three and five. She is referred to simply as the woman. The choice of words I think is significant. There is a very interesting and you can read to the end of this chapter. It's very interesting to note when Bathsheba is referred to as Bathsheba and when she's referred to as the woman. She is only ever referred to as Bathsheba in reference to her father and her husband. Why? Because she's a person to them. She's a person to them. You can put it in slightly fancier philosophical language if you like and we could say to them she is a subject, not an object. She is a person, not a thing. There is some debate in this passage. Is this an act of adultery? I don't think so. Okay. We're not told that she resists anyway but we all know that what would resistance look like when the king makes a demand and your husband is away at war. Even setting that aside I think the language of the text lays the moral burden on David because with reference to her she's just the woman. It's only with reference to her husband and her father that she is Bathsheba. So why does he do it? Sexual desire is powerful and in a fallen world that power manifests itself in corrupt, terrible and destructive ways I mentioned this morning or I get so confused when I'm talking about this all the time. Maybe it wasn't this morning. Maybe it was last night. But I talked about the Iliath. I talked about a fellow. I talked about how literature is permeated with sexual desire because it is perennially powerful. And sexual desire when it is allowed to run rampant objectifies people. It turns them into objects hence the language that is used about her here. What we're going to witness in this is not the way sexual desire should be deployed or fulfilled. Sexual desire in the Bible finds its correct locus, its correct place, its correct end in marriage. And one of the beautiful things about marriage is this. It is the essence of a good marriage that each partner treats the other as an end in themselves and not a means to an end. I do have used a couple of relatively trivial illustrations to draw this point out in class. I ask the students often as an engaged couple in class if on the wedding day you hear the music change and you know the brides come in and you the groom turn around and you look down the aisle and there's a beautiful woman walking towards you but it's not the beautiful woman you're engaged to. Do you go through with the marriage ceremony? With only one exception has the answer always come back absolutely not. The answer student said to me probably not and his fiance was away and I actually followed up with a segment that said would you like to reconsider the adverb you used in that answer and then he gave the correct answer. But the obvious answer is no of course not because you're not marrying an object. You could marry another woman and yes you could have children whether you could do all the things you're going to do with this woman that you want to do with your fiance but that's not enough. You want to marry the woman because she is a subject to you and not an object. She's not the woman, she's a nay. It's why we see those tragic stories on the news where a couple get married in hospital because one of them has a terrible terminal disease and sometimes even by the time the news a report has been made in the evening you hear that the one has passed away and nobody watching those news reports ever thinks what a stupid thing to do. We're deeply moved by those reports because we understand that love and marriage is not about using somebody else as a means to an end. It's about the other person being an end in themselves. Here David uses this woman as a means to an end. His own personal gratification. That's the logic of the sexual revolution. What you see in this chapter is the logic of how the world around us thinks about sexual relations. It is recreation that is there for my pleasure, not for the other person. It is not about giving, it is about taking. That's why interestingly and encouraging me enough certain feminists are now turning against a sexual revolution because they've suddenly realized that actually it dehumanizes women. It favors men and it turns women into objects less than human, they're for male gratification. I got an interesting taste of this a couple of weeks ago, chatting to a friend, he happened to be a Catholic. That's sort of important in the story actually. He was with two other Catholic friends, they're all businessmen and he said we were in Rome doing some business and we went to a cafe bar in the evening and we went into the bar and the three of us, three guys, our wives are at home in the United States. We sat down and three English women came up and started to sort of flirt with us and finally to get rid of them, my friend said we said this to them. If you can guess how many children we have, we'll buy you a drink and the women guess sort of four, five, six. The answer I think was 27. They all got eight or nine children, they were all a bit like our friend, Kevin, 27 children. The interesting thing was the response of these women to that answer. They said can we ask you something and my friend said sure and they said where can we find man who will be as committed to us and care for us as much as you clearly care for your wives. These are three good time girls on holiday in Rome looking for a good time and something brought them up sharp and they realized they had been dehumanized by the world in which they live. This is the logic of the sexual revolution that we see playing out here in this passage and it dehumanizes people. David is degraded by it and Bathsheever is dehumanized. It brings us, of course, then to the seductive nature of autonomy. Why does David do it? It's an interesting question, isn't it? Why does he do it? Why does he throw it all away? I think the answer is he does it because he can. He does it because it confirms his autonomy and his power. So far, David has shown himself to be a good king but here the power goes to his head. Some people try to cut leaders slack on this to say, well, the temptation with the leader is, the leader gets, yet he's on the point of the spear, he's the guy who takes all the aggravation, he's the guy who gets beaten up all the time, he's the guy who can never please all of the people all of the time. And so the leader will inevitably, at some point, cut himself a bit of slack. He will think to himself, well, the normal rules apply to everybody but because my life is so rough and I shoulder so much responsibility, maybe I can cut myself a bit of slack. I'm not so certain about that. I read some years ago an interview with a conservative MP in the UK who's Stala Korea had been destroyed by a sexual misdemeanor. And he wrote a very interesting and very honest reflection about it, trying to himself understand why he'd done it. And he said, I did it because it made me feel invulnerable. I did it because I could. I did it because it confirmed to me that I was a powerful and important person that could not be touched. He was disabused about by the British press when they got hold of the story. David will be disabused of it by Nathan when he confronts him in the next chapter. That is David's situation here and notice as well, again, the language, the verse four, he took her. He took her. Again, I said in one of my earlier talks, I was talking about why sex crimes, so heinous. And I said, I think it's because they involve the taking of something that can only be legitimately given. You cannot take it as an object. It has to be given to you by a person, by a subject. David takes. Notice that's exactly what Eve does. She saw that the fruit was beautiful and she took it. It's reminiscent, of course, of 1 Samuel chapter 8, exactly what Samuel predicted. Remember when the Israelite asked for a king, Samuel is disgruntled by this and the Lord says to Samuel, it's not you, they've rejected it's me, he says go and tell them, this is the king that I'm going to give them. So if you read 1 Samuel chapter 8, one of the things you'll notice is that language of take is used repeatedly. The king will take your sons, he will take your daughters, he will take your lands, he will take the fruit of your fields and of your vines. The king who is coming will be a taker and, of course, we read the story of Saul and we think that's a great description of Saul. And then suddenly in the story of David, the language of take rears its ugly head, he saw that the woman was beautiful, he sent for her and he took her. David has wives, he could take any woman legitimately as his wife if he wished but he took that which he should not take, the wife of your rye or the hit eye. He reminds us, of course, the David is not the great king to come. What is the contrast between David and the great king who is to come? David takes Christ gives, Christ gives of himself, he gives of himself for his bride, he does not take the bride of another. David is as good as it gets in ancient Israel, it is as good as it gets, it's not that good is it? When you look at it through the frame of 2 Samuel 11, praise God that there is a greater king, a king who does give unconditionally of himself rather than taking. And that brings us then to the consequences of all this. Again, one of the burdens I suppose of some of the things I've said this weekend is this. We go wrong when we start by thinking of human beings as individuals and autonomous. We are not. We always exist in a relationship of dependency and obligation relative to others. That means that all about actions have consequences for others. And that's what we see in this chapter. David's sin will have consequences, immediate consequences for Bhashiva. She will fall pregnant. That will leave them both with a big problem when Uriah returns from the field and incidentally isn't it interesting that Uriah is more honorable than David when he's drunk than David is when he's stone-cold sober in this passage. But the consequences go much further than that. He will lead to a murderous plot against Uriah, the kind of thing that Saul himself might have engaged in, but it also has significant consequences for David. He will say, well yes, the Lord will plunge David's reign into chaos at this point. He will. And he will partly do it through a very clear personal connection. Bhashiva is the daughter of the lion. You have to do a bit of digging for this, but if you have asked yourself, who a lion is? A lion is the son we're told in 2 Samuel 23 of the hitterfell, who is a hitterfell. A hitterfell is one of David's closest advisors, but he will join Absalom's rebellion. Be a key part of Absalom's rebellion will be the role of a hitterfell. Think about that. Put yourself in a hitterfell's shoes when we read the story of a hitterfell and his betrayal of David. I think our instincts are the thing. You know, what a rat vag. He betrayed David. Think about this though. If David had conspired to murder your granddaughter's husband, how well disposed towards him would you be? How well disposed towards him would you be? David's action cannot be isolated, not just from his relationship with Bhashiva, but from the whole framework of his relied society. The lion is the son of a hitterfell, and the hitterfell will stick the knife in David's back, and one might say, understandably so, even if that is not to say that he was right to do it. It's a catastrophe. It's like Adam and Eve's sin. The language of look and take is there, and the massive consequences beyond the immediate moment are there as well. The kingdom is plunged into disaster. So what can we learn from this passage then in closing? I would say a couple of things. One, realize this. You as an individual, connect to other individuals. Our personal sins cannot be isolated from the body as a whole. That's tough way for us to think as modern people, and when Paul will talk about you, the body being pulled down by the sin of others, that's hard for us to imagine. We tend to think that our sins are singular sins. Maybe they have an impact on those immediately next to us when they find out about them. I think Paul's teaching on this is much deeper in richer. Our sins pull the body down even if the body doesn't know about our sins. There are consequences to our sins. Why? Because we're not isolated, independent individuals. When we act, what we do affects everybody. Secondly, where then should true humanity be modeled? The true humanity is treating others as subjects, not objects, treating others as persons, not things. Where is it to be modeled? The answer is the church. In the Old Testament who was ancient Israel, be hospitable. In the New Testament it's the church. What does Christ say? By this will all men know the true My disciples. By the love you have for each other. There's a very practical lesson here. David should have modeled what true humanity was. He was the king of Israel, the representative of God in the kingly role on earth at that point, and he objectively fails by treating Bathsheba as a thing. As I said, she is always the woman in this passage, except in reference to Euryah and Delayah, to whom she was a person, not a thing. It is the task of the church to model true humanity. How are we to respond to the crazy chaos, the dehumanizing chaos of the world around us? Well, first and foremost, we should be human ourselves in the context of the church, demonstrating the power of true loving community, where one person looks into the eyes of the other, and that person can see that they see them as a person, not as a thing. Thirdly, that points us to Christ. Who is the one who treats us as persons, not objects? Who is the king, who treats his subjects? Not as the man, the woman, those men, those women, but who knows us each by name, who calls us each by name. Who is the good shepherd? Surely it is the Lord Jesus Christ. Who does not treat us as things, but lays down his life for us. Let us pray. O Lord God, we do thank You for the beauty of Your Son, the Lord Jesus Christ and His gospel. We pray, O Lord, that as He treats each of us as a person, as He calls each of us by name. So we might resist the temptation of this fallen world to treat others as objects, to treat others as means to selfish ends, but we might learn to look upon others as You look upon them, as persons made in Your image. We pray this in Jesus' name, Amen.