<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Gouf Gouf monatlech

Civil Government

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Again, as we have in each class prayer from John Calvin, let's pray, grant Almighty God since we have already entered in hope upon the threshold of our eternal inheritance. And know that there is a mansion for us in heaven, since Christ our head, and the first streets of our salvation has been received there. Grant that we may proceed more and more in the way of your holy calling until it length. We reach the goal. And so enjoy the eternal glory of which you have given us a taste in this world by the same Christ our Lord, amen. Well, Calvin ends the institutes, you know, with a chapter on civil government. You might think that an appropriate place to end would have been his chapter on eschatology, which is the end of book three, but Calvin goes on to before with his treatment of the church, sacraments, and then finally, civil government. I think this is another indication of the practicality of Calvin's treatment. He encourages us to look forward to heaven in the last chapter of book three, as well as in chapter nine, meditation on the future life. But as long as we live in this world, till we go to heaven, we have responsibilities and duties here. And so it seems to me it's not inappropriate for Calvin to end his great work on Christian theology with a powerful chapter on civil government. Not everybody has seen it that way. Bondel and his survey of Calvin's theology rearranges Calvin's treatment in book four, so that Bondel deals with civil government earlier and then he's able to end on the high note of the Lord's Supper rather than plunging back down into the nitty gritty life of living in this world. But I rather like Calvin's way of doing it gets us back into the world and in the church, but in the world too, because Christians are citizens of both realms. Civil government is a topic of significant interest to Calvin was also as wingly, less so the Luther, but Calvin has great concern about this topic and deals with it in the institutes also in book three, chapter 19, where he is talking about Christian liberty. He wants to make sure that that is not to be understood as liberty from the state or liberty from government as some radicals were interpreting that idea as it came from Luther. And then Calvin returns to the idea and topic of civil government in chapter 20 of book four, so you're thinking you need to link three 19 and four 20, because four 20 is in a real sense a continuation of three 19. We haven't done too much with the little superstitions, the ABCs that appear in the paragraphs of the institutes, but perhaps from reading the introductory material, we know that you know that is the way the editor tries to indicate the source of each of these paragraphs or sometimes sentences, beginning in 1536 for a 1539 for B and on up to 1559. It's interesting to look at those occasionally. And as we do that in chapter 20 or civil government, we'll see that almost all of this comes from 1536. Calvin does it really re-write. He brings together what he has written and spans and develops as we have already seen, and does add some material to what he has done earlier, but so much of his treatment of civil government is from 1536 with some additions in 1539 and a few additions from the later period. 1536, the date 1536 was also the date of the Munster episode, the Anababdist experience at Munster when the Anababdist took over that city in West Philadelphia and created a kind of Old Testament theocracy there, finally defeated by an army of Roman Catholics and Protestants. And the Munster then becomes a kind of symbol of radical reformation attitudes which caused a lot of fear and concern that whenever the Protestant movement would spread, it would cause the overthrow of civil governments. So I think that is one of the reasons Calvin is concerned in 1536 to think about civil government from Christian point of view and from a Protestant point of view. Also by 1536, Machiavelli's The Prince had been published with its undue reverence for kings and that book would have been in Calvin's mind undoubtedly as Calvin wrote this chapter. Calvin in 421 talks about the flatterers of princes, moderately praising their power. These princes who do not hesitate to set themselves against the rule of God himself. So there is the critique of the moderate praise of princes as would have occurred in Machiavelli's The Prince written first in Italian and then later translated into Latin. So with all of that in the background, Calvin is as early as 1536 concerned about these matters. Calvin also treats civil government in his commentaries and as you would expect the two places where this appears most thoroughly is in his commentary on Daniel and in his commentary on the book of Romans. John T. McNeil, the editor of our 1559 edition of the institutes, has also edited a little book called on God and political duty in which he brings together these sources of Calvin's treatment of civil government institutes, two chapters in the institutes and passages from Daniel and Romans and includes with that a very helpful introduction to Calvin and his views of civil government. We could divide this chapter this way. First three sections, one, two, three of chapter 20, have to do with the function and responsibility of civil government. Four section four through section 13, the work of the magistrate and then 14 through 16, the character of the civil law and finally 17 through 32, the response of the govern people. So we'll work through those different ideas as we seek to understand what Calvin is meaning to set forth on this topic. Calvin often here and back in 319 and in the commentaries we'll talk about a two-fold government. Christians are under a two-fold government. One, of course, is the government of the church, which is already dealt with extensively in book four. That government, Calvin, says, pertains to eternal life, spiritual life and needs to eternal life. But Christians are also under a second government and that is the civil government or the government of the state, which according to Calvin pertains only to the establishment of civil justice and outward morality not to spiritual things, not to doctrine, not to sacraments, but to outward community living, civil justice and outward morality. But for Calvin, this is not an inconsequential thing. Civil government is God's instrument and it's God's gift to us. Calvin has a very positive view of government. It's not merely a negative view, just to keep law and order, but government in Calvin's view is a positive blessing. In fact, he says in 422, it's another help, another help on our pilgrimage. So not only do we have the external means supplied to the church and the sacraments, but also to the civil government, it's not something we merely tolerate, it's something we thank God for because it is a help to us as Christians, not only as citizens, but also as Christians. Remember that book 4 deals with the external means. Book 3 is the Christian believer all the way from faith to heaven. But the Christian believer, Calvin insists in book 4, cannot be separated from the church. Our life is a life that is both internal and external, and the church cannot be detached from the larger life of humanity as a whole. Church is part of life on this earth, and we can't take the believer and take him or her out of the church and just have a kind of spiritual person without the community experience of the church. So the church, nor can we take the church out of the world and have it somehow isolated and standing all by itself. I have written a number of local church histories, as you know, one of the first Presbyterian church in Columbia, South Carolina, and just recently the independent Presbyterian church in Savannah, Georgia, the 250 years old in 2005. And working now on the first Presbyterian church in Augusta, Georgia, which will be 200 years old in 2004. And every time I work on one of these church histories, I'm impressed with this because I really can't write the history of the church just in a vacuum. It involves the history of the city, the history of the state, the people that surround it, the history of the culture of that place. And Calvin, I think, makes this clear in his treatment of civil government. Church is in the state, church is in the world, one sense not of the world, but in another sense very much in the world. So for Calvin, both the church and state are God's means of establishing His order in this world and restraining evil and blessing those who do good. This means, for Calvin, quite in contrast to some people in the 16th century, mainly the Anavabdist and some of the radicals, it means for Calvin that civil authority or leadership in the state is a calling. Calvin puts it this way in 424, not only holy and lawful before God, that is to be a magistrate, to be an officer of the state, is a calling which is holy and lawful before God. But also, I notice his words here, the most sacred and by far the most honorable of all callings in the whole life of mortal men. And if I just read that to you without putting it in context here and ask you what Calvin was talking about, you'd probably say he's talking about the pastor and minister. But almost shockingly he's talking about civil leaders. He calls them God's vice regents 424 and he calls them vickers of God, deputies of God in 426.

That is book 4 chapter 26 and vice regents in book 4 chapter 20 section 4. So Calvin uses some almost extravagant language here to talk about the role of civil leaders.

What are the reasons for civil government? Why do we have such? Why does God give us civil government? And Calvin begins with the fact of sin. That's not the primary thought in Calvin but it's certainly a part of Calvin's understanding of the reason. For civil government. That is because of sin there needs to be constraint, there needs to be order, there needs to be government. And Calvin begins with that or at least includes that in his reasons for civil government. It's almost the primary thought in Luther. Government is there because of sinfulness. But I don't think it's the primary thought in Calvin. Government is there because of the providence of God. And certainly sinfulness enters in. In fact as we come to discuss in a moment the types of government. Calvin prefers a kind of government in which authority is spread out. So it's not concentrated in one person or even a few people because of sinfulness. Because of human sin one person who has all the power can abuse that power so easily. So the fact of sin is one reason but a stronger reason in Calvin's view I think is God's goodness. God's providence he's given us government which is a positive good for 20 section 2, not a polluted thing with which Christians will have nothing to do. And that's of course the criticism of the Anababdus many of whom were saying civil government is evil and we just won't do anything to do with it. But Calvin says civil government is a gift of God and a positive good and Christians should be involved in it. And Calvin says the reason for civil government a third reason is for the preservation and blessing of humanity. So it's to control sin, to keep sin from being concentrated power, sinful power from being concentrated in a few people who can abuse it. And also because of God's goodness and part of God's goodness is that he uses civil government to preserve and bless humanity because without it there is anarchy and destruction and all kinds of evil. And I think we've seen that in recent days just after the war in Iraq when there was almost no government there. There's beginning to be a government there again but almost at first it looked like it was worst to have no government then to have an evil government which at least imposed a certain amount of law in order with a lot of injustice. But you can see the evils that come when there is no government. Going back just a moment on a civil authority calling just that they could example for the classes to remember our representative, Pat Aiken, who is an elder in this church and an embediff graduate of the seminary. Yes. Yes, Julian is mentioning Todd Aiken, one of our graduates who is the US Congressman for our district here in his second term. And a member of one of the PCA churches, Twin Oaks, and our senator, one of our senators too, Jim Talbot. Both of these men I think see their role in government is very much a calling that God has issued to them. I've heard Todd talk about this in some way, how God has called him into this kind of service. So Calvin would agree these are honorable offices and the people that fill them are really deputies of God or vickers of God. So Calvin would not be anti-government just looking at government as a kind of necessary evil. It is for him a positive good. What does government do? What is the function of civil government? And the function is twofold, and Calvin relates it to the decalogue to the Tin Commandments, looking first at the second table of the law, which relates to the commandments that speak of our life in society. I shall not steal, kill, commit adultery, and so on. Calvin says civil government is there to enforce and encourage obedience to these precepts of God. It adjusts our life to society as one way he puts it. It forms our social behavior to civil righteousness. It reconciles us with one another. It promotes general peace and tranquility that humanity be maintained among men. So civil government has to do with all these social relations, these areas of connection between person and person to regulate our life to promote peace and tranquility on this earth. But Calvin doesn't stop there, and here he goes on to apply the role of civil government to the first table of the law as well. And this is where we live in a quite different world from 16th century, but we need to understand Calvin's thinking on it. And then the reason we don't follow Calvin in this, Calvin believed that the civil government just as it had the function of preventing people from stealing from one another also had the function of promoting the true religion, by which he meant the Christian religion and the Protestant religion. Calvin says that civil government protects the outward worship of God. By that he meant it doesn't regulate, at least according to Calvin's desire, the inner workings of the church. The civil government cannot dictate doctrine or control worship or practice church discipline. Although the last of those points Calvin had defied long and hard to win for the church, the sole right to exercise church discipline. One of the reasons he had to leave Geneva in 1538 was because he could not win that point, and Calvin could not stay in Geneva, he felt when church discipline was not in the hands of the church, but in the hands of the state. And even when he came back, he was not able for another decade to actually free the church from state interference in the matter of church discipline. And to Calvin was not trying to separate church in state, he felt that the church had the right to regulate its own affairs, but that the state should work with the church in promoting the church in preventing opposition from forming to the church. And in defending piety and the church that Calvin says a public manifestation of religion may exist among Christians. This meant, of course, in Geneva and Calvin agreed with this, and it was true almost everywhere else in the 16th century, except some of the Adamabdes had different views, but not be until much, much later places like Rhode Island in the American colonies that a true separation of church and state would take place. With Calvin's view of the role of the state to enforce, defend, promote both tables of the law, this meant that Heresy was a civil crime punishable by the state, in the famous example of that of Servetus. Servetus was not put to death by the church in Geneva but by the state, but Calvin agreed, and actually Calvin wrote the other reformers, Malanthan and others, for advice, and all of the reformers agreed that Heresy was a civil crime. Calvin did try to have the Senate's mitigated from burning to beheading, which might not sound like much, but I suppose if we were facing one or the other, we would make a pretty quick choice as to which way we would rather die. Beheading was a much swifter and more merciful form of capital punishment than burning, which was, as you can imagine, scruciating. But Calvin was not able to persuade the state which had the last word in this, and Servetus went to the state and died there by fire. I think with the view that Calvin, everybody else, almost everybody else, held that Heresy was a civil crime, we have to see it in 16th century context as not only just getting an idea wrong about doctrine, but because of union of church and state and the fact that each state had one church, whether it was reform, Lutheran, or Catholic, that Heresy was tantamount to rebellion, something like rebellion or treason would be today. We can easily separate Heresy from treason today, but in the 16th century it was not easy to do that. Heresy looked like treason and treason often was linked with Heresy. So we get something of an idea as to why the 16th century people on all sides, Catholic and various types of Protestants, insisted that Heresy was a crime. And Calvin doesn't really identify church and state, the two are distinct. We've seen that before, see it in Geneva, churches, the churches, the state is the state. There's not a single government, there's a twofold government. There's not a kind of feeocracy, like in the Old Testament there's both church, and there is state, and we can see His struggle to keep the two separate when He insists that the church has the right of church discipline, the state cannot interfere with that. But with His concern to distinguish the two, He doesn't want to separate the two. He doesn't want to sexualize the state. The state is still a Christian state and has responsibility toward the church. Now perhaps a little chart might help us see this. Calvin does make a distinction between church and state. Church has its role, doctrine, worship, discipline, three marks of the church later, but for Calvin the two marks of the church, the pure preaching of the word, sacraments rightly administered. And then discipline being closely connected, although not third mark, and the state has its role, the church cannot dictate to the state what laws to pass, and exactly how to manage its affairs. But with the word distinction, we also need the word cooperation, because there's not a separation church and state, or you might say in the same business, to work together to promote life on earth and to promote true piety and the true religion. It seems to me it works out in Geneva something like this, where you have the line of distinction, but the church is certainly moving over into the territory of the state when it urges the passing of certain laws and the enforcement of those laws. And the state moves over into the territory of the church when it interferes with doctrine, worship, and discipline as it did in Geneva. So the line here is not a clear firm separation of church and state line. There is distinction, but a kind of second line here and here. And these lines could vary depending on exactly what is going on. Calvin would want to push this one back much more to that center line and say this really belongs to the church only, but there were plenty of people in Geneva that felt that the church should have greater control over the laws of the state, not just in suggesting those laws, but in actually forming those laws and enforcing them, Jay. Specifically in worship did this civil government try to change her? The frequency of the Lord's Supper, Calvin preferred every week, civil government said you can only do it once a month and then later only once every three months. So here was a place where the civil government was dictating to the church in an area of worship. I don't know that in Geneva there was ever a time when the civil government tried to establish doctrine for the Geneva church, but the civil government often got involved in doctrinal issues, for instance the matter of servitas. He was tried and condemned by the civil government on the charge of anti-Tranitarianism, so the civil government had interest in that and came involved in that, but as far as I know never really tried to dictate to Calvin or the ministers how to settle an issue of doctrine.

Okay, let's look at types of government. Calvin says there are different ways in which states can be governed and basically his thought here is, however, you are being governed except that and don't be too concerned about it. We must accept the form of government. The Lord has appointed for us and not attempt to change it. In fact, he thinks it's an idle pastime for private citizens to debate the pros and cons of various types of government. Can you imagine how Calvin would feel if he was alive today could read the newspaper and see all the letters and all the editorials and all the debate that goes on about how we run our country and what's wrong with it and it would be a sounding to him, I think. Not saying that we should not have that debate but just stating that for Calvin in his time he was concerned that people, except what God had placed over them in his providence, but even though he says don't talk about it, don't debate it, don't get so upset about it. He does offer some suggestions as to various types of government and Calvin clearly, I think, prefers a government in which citizens share some responsibility. He has a growing revulsion toward the kingship itself, according to McNeil, which we can see in his persistent and often sweeping denunciation of kings going all the way back to his letter to Francis I and 1535. He is very respectful of Francis, he is the king, he doesn't want to create any rebellion, in fact he is so concerned in that 1535 letter to say we're not an abdist, we're not trying to change the government, we're not trying to overthrow anything, we are good citizens and respectful of your majesty. By Calvin doesn't hesitate to subject the king to biblical criticism, or to say that the king stands under the Bible and is not free to do anything that he chooses. So even though Calvin doesn't reject kingship and doesn't hesitate to say the king stands under the Bible, but Calvin doesn't try to change any kind of rule like that. Later when John Knox is in Geneva and writes his first class of the trumpet against the monstrous regiment of women to try to create some sort of unrest in England and in Scotland against the reign of the two marries, Calvin is very disturbed about that. He says this is not legitimate, we cannot overthrow properly constituted governments, even if those governments are Catholic and even if they are ruled by women. So he doesn't accept Knox's view at all, but clearly too I think Calvin prefers what he calls aristocracy or aristocracy tempered by democracy. So this is the first class for 20 section 8. So some kind of representation, not pure democracy, for Calvin that would be tantamount to anarchy, everybody having equal vote and being able to vote on everything. Many pure democracies in the world, if there are any, since the days of the Greek city states. So Calvin thinks that some kind of representative government aristocracy or aristocracy tempered by democracy, I expect what he means by that is a kind of elite ruling class. And the people have some say in some things, but by elite he doesn't mean a kind of born elite, it's not an aristocracy that is by class. So what Calvin has in mind here is a aristocracy not by privilege, but by talent, the best qualified people should govern and the people can have some say in it. Something like what actually did transpire in Geneva, Geneva had three councils, a little council, council of 60, council of 200. And the government was a rather complex interrelation between these three councils and the people had some voice, but not like a democracy. Did you ever report on anything close to this? Well, I think it did, yes, certainly in the republic, it did. Before the empire, after the empire, there's not much if anything, well, perhaps some influence of the aristocracy, but certainly in the days of the republic. It was very close to what Calvin is describing here. Calvin's view I think here that we should have government shared and not concentrated in one person, although he doesn't. As I said, he doesn't really try to oppose kingship or overthrow it, but it's not his preference. It's to have an aristocracy of excellence, according to Daniel's footnote. Another reason for that is the point that I made earlier, and that is the kind of safety in numbers because of men's fault or failing. That's for 20 section eight, so that they may help one another, teach and admonish one another, because we're imperfect, because we're centers. It's good to have more people involved in government. I suppose you could say it's better to be governed by a lot of centers than just one center, because that helps to balance things. I was struck recently in reading articles in books in culture. I was quoting from Samuel Lang's book called Reflections on the National Prayer Breakfast in Washington, D.C. Dr. Lang, he's taller here, some at Covenant, PCA minister, lives in Los Angeles and an expert on China. He is Chinese and a very good friend and a very fine man. This review of some other books, not really Dr. Lang's book, does mention his book. In this context, ironically, some modern Chinese thinkers have come to the conclusion that what Chinese culture requires from the Christian spirit is the teaching of original sin. And the struck me as being most unusual Chinese thinkers saying what we need is the doctrine of original sin. And it goes on to say this, Yuan Xi-min, a philosopher active in China's democracy movement has argued that the Christian emphasis on sin provides, quote, the ultimate philosophical base for the establishment of social covenants, checks and balances of power and the rule of law. Denial of man's sin and limitations is the spiritual root of tyranny, our awareness of such the beginning of democracy. So from a man, I don't know if he claimed to be a Christian at all, but a philosopher says we need a doctrine of original sin in order to develop a government that is more like a democracy and less like a tyranny. Well, it's exactly what we have in Calvin, so anybody wants a doctrine of original sin, we've got one and we'll be glad to share it. But it's interesting to see it come up in that context that it's a felt need we need this because without this we're not going to be able to develop a civil government that will be helpful and harmful to us. Sometimes Calvin, I think this may be a bit of an overstatement, but not entirely untrue, sometimes Calvin has been called the virtual founder of America. And when people use that expression, I think they mean that Calvin's encouragement of representative government, which he does here and his doctrine of original sin is doctrine of sin, which encourages a system of checks and balances, which we have in our government. Our government can be traced back to teaching Calvin, we talk a little about the exercise of force, we have civil government can civil government exercise force use of the sword, the power of the sword. And Calvin says, yes, it's exactly what civil government does without any authority to punish civil government would be weak and ineffective. But Calvin says the magistrate or civil government must avoid both excessive severity, there should be can be punishments but not excessive punishments, and the way Calvin expresses this is interesting, not only excessive severity. But also cruelist gentleness, the civil government doesn't do anything, it's really cruel. So government walks a line between excessive severity and cruel gentleness or weakness. What about the right then to wage war, government can use the sword, can it use the sword not only to enforce its laws but to go to war. And Calvin again, as the Christian tradition all the way back to Augustin and even earlier affirms answers by saying yes, for 2011, this is probably the chief summary sunnets there that wars are lawful, to preserve the tranquility of the state's dominion, to restrain the seditious stirrings of restless men to help those forcibly oppressed and to punish evil deeds. I'm trying to apply that to the recent war in Iraq, at least several of Calvin statements there would fit to help those forcibly oppressed and to punish evil deeds, certainly seem to fit the purpose of that war. Calvin says war then is right and just if it serves those purposes, but it must be governed by extreme necessity for 2012, the last resort. I suppose there the war in Iraq will still be debated as it is, depending on whether US finds weapons of mass destruction or not, it's a crucial issue I think because that was one of the stated purposes in going to war. So war can be justified, it can be right, but there has to be extreme necessity and there cannot be anger or hatred. Calvin seems almost idealistic here, you can fight somebody but you can't be angry with them and certainly can't hate them. And there must not be implacable severity, so there are a lot of qualifications. Yes, war is right if it's for these reasons, but must be extreme necessity, must be fought without anger and hatred. And there must be limitations, there cannot be extreme or implacable severity. And government also, Calvin says, has a right to tax the people. Calvin is rather sensitive about this when he writes he says that is almost the very blood of the people when you're taxing people taking some of their money, it's like taking their blood. So he doesn't, Calvin doesn't view this as just a minor thing that he says governments do have the right to tax, but only for legitimate cause. If it's not for legitimate cause, it is what he calls tyrannical extortion taxes that are raised or illegitimate reasons are viewed as tyrannical extortion for 2013. But proper tax is yes, and Calvin says that is for the public expenses of the magistrates office, or we might say running the country, and he also, Calvin also admits that this money can be used for the proper magnificence of their household. That is the magistrates can live well, they can have not only a decent house, but very nice house, and it's not long to raise the tax for that as long as it's proper, and not too extravagant, and certainly it's not to be squandered. We talked a little bit about the laws that should govern a state, and we did this earlier when we were talking about Calvin's view of law, but repeated again here because it comes up again here. The state should be governed by the common laws of nations, in other words, each state has the right to make its own laws, generally observing what other states do, both in the past and in the present. And these laws must be in conformity to that perpetual rule of love for 2015, so you check laws by the rule of love, but we need not recreate the political system of Moses for 2014. We don't have to go back to the judicial law of the Old Testament, and try to put that in place, it's not what happened in Geneva, that mosaic law can be used as a model or a guide, and certainly the principles of love and equity that were present in those laws of Moses should be present in modern laws. But laws Calvin said indeed very in full warm, but have the same purpose, or the same goal, which is equity, justice, and mercy and love, if that's the goal of the law, it doesn't matter what form the law takes. It's interesting that Calvin also deals with the matter of lawsuits, is it proper for people to sue each other, and Calvin says yes, permissible, if rightly used for 2017. This is how he explains it, this he says is a set principle for all Christians, I don't know that I checked, oh yes I did, first Corinthians 6, I'll comment on that moment because that seems to be a problem to Calvin's view here, but here's his set principle for all Christians that a lawsuit, however just, can never be rightly prosecuted by any man. Unless he treats his adversary with the same love and goodwill as if the business under controversy were already settled and composed, so you can do it, but the attitude and the spirit in it all is to treat the person as though it never happened or wasn't happening or had already been settled. So that speaks to the inner spirit without anger, without desire to avenge or to hurt Calvin admits that an example of an upright litigate is rare. I don't usually find this, Calvin is trained in law, he's a lawyer, so he's kind of in his own territory here, and he knows that when people go to law they don't really love each other very much, even though they should be loving each other, but the trailer, Calvin says. Well, the first Corinthians 6 passage where Paul seems to say, don't go to law, Calvin's comment is Paul invades against that mad lust to go to law not simply against all controversies, where the Calvin is right about that or not, something we could probably debate, but he's saying Paul doesn't say, never go to law, but don't have just a kind of desire to always be suing somebody or going to law at the drop of a hat. Calvin's comment is 4-20-21, and the passage in Paul is 1 Corinthians 6-5-8. Calvin says to sum it up, law will give every man the best counsel. Okay, relation between church and state, I've really already done that with this chart, distinction, not separation, so we can move on distinction, cooperation, because I want to spend the last few minutes on civil disobedience. Is it ever right for people to rise up in opposition to civil government? And Calvin goes through the scriptural passages that command obedience to rulers, Scripture particularly commands us to honor the king, the magistrate cannot be resisted without God being resisted. We're bound to obey wicked rulers. In fact, he says reverence and esteem, wicked rulers, but then he adds in 4-20-24 as far as possible. There seems to be some slight limitation there. Yes, obey the king. After all Paul is writing about it. No, wicked Roman Emperor when he says that. How can we do that? What is the spirit in which we do that? We're bound to reverence and esteem all rulers. Calvin says, one thing it does is teach us patience. We are to consider our own sin. Unjust rulers have been raised up by God to punish the wickedness of the people. Maybe the reason that we have a wicked ruler is because of our sin, which should be patient and dependent and seek God. And implore the help of God. It is not for us to remedy such evils, only this remains to implore the Lord's help. So be patient and pray a lot. You know, when humanites, when the reform were being martyred regularly in France and wanted to begin to raise an army and defend themselves, Calvin counseled against it. He said, no, you cannot do that. But you can pray and you can die. Those were his instructions to those humanites. Later the humanites decided not to follow Calvin much longer in this because they were praying and they were dying. So resistance movements began to develop toward the end of Calvin's life, but he never really countenance that. Calvin wrote to Collignee, the French, Huguenot leader in 1561, it would be better should we all perish a hundred times than expose the gospel to such a disgrace, take up arms in the name of Christ. You better to die, Calvin said. But when Calvin seems to have totally closed the door, there's a little crack that he leaves open and some others will kind of push that crack further and actually throw the door wide open eventually. But Calvin's a crack is this. He talks about the role of the open Avengers in 42030. There's a wicked government, a bad government, unjust government. Then God may choose to raise up open Avengers. People quote armed from heaven or directed by God's hand to punish wicked rulers. God raises up these open Avengers such as Moses who delivered Israel from Pharaoh. And such as the Assyrians to overthrow and punish the Jews, open Avengers. But you never really get in Calvin in this concept of program for revolution. Calvin doesn't say God sometimes raises up open Avengers so you all should become open Avengers. That's more what John Knox wanted to do. But the open Avengers acknowledge this idea in Calvin acknowledges that God is in the overthrow of government. Sometimes God does overthrow governments, but it's not our marching orders. No command is given to us except to obey and suffer. It's for 2031. So you might say that doesn't really tell anybody what to do who's living in an unjust government. But it does serve the function of warning an evil ruler. Calvin says let the princes here and be afraid for 2031. God does sometimes raise up open Avengers to overthrow unjust governments. He doesn't apply that to people that they become involved in some kind of rebellion. But he does apply to the rulers that they be afraid and perhaps then change their ways. So that's not much of a crack there in the war. But the bigger crack comes when he talks about the role of the magistrates of the people. The people can't overthrow an unjust government. But the magistrates of the people have a certain right and even responsibility here. The magistrates whose constitutional function is the protection of the people against the misuse of the king. And Calvin goes back through history and shows how different times in history with the Spartan E4s, the Roman tribunes, the Greek demarks, the German town, Gil masters. There have been these properly constituted lesser magistrates or magistrates of the people. The different governments have had this category of the king or the emperor or the ruler and then you have the magistrates of the people. And they have the right to influence and change the government if necessary. Calvin says if there are now any magistrates of the people for 2031, he's not sure that this category still exists. But he does point out that modern nations have something similar at least on the books in the three estates, the three estates in France, for instance. But the three estates in France had not met for 30 years when Calvin wrote this and still had not met in 1559. So even though technically there was a kind of category there, it was not functioning much like the parliament in England which would only meet when the king decided he wanted the parliament to meet in order to raise taxes. But Calvin does say that properly constituted officials may oppose the king or the ruler and the New York comments that this is more influential in that it came as a concession at the end of a discussion that is anxiously conservative. Calvin doesn't want to do anything to encourage anarchy to him, that's the worst of all worlds. So he's very cautious in trying not to foment rebellion, very upset with John Knox when he writes First Blast of the Trumpet. And even his section on the lesser magistrates is not an incitement for people to revolt, but an appeal to the magistrate to fulfill its legitimate function. Well, that's about the end of the institutes. Let me just as I close read the very end, but since this edict has been proclaimed by the heavenly herald, Peter said we must obey God rather than men. Let us comfort ourselves with the thought that we are rendering that obedience, which the Lord requires. When we suffer anything rather than turn aside from piety, it's almost at Calvin, he ends where he starts. Now almost the first sentence is piety, book one, chapter one, section one. The goal is love for God, piety, devotion. And now he says it's better to suffer anything and to lose that. And that our courage may not grow faint. Paul pricks us with another God that we have been redeemed by Christ at so great a price as our redemption cost him so that we should not enslave ourselves to the wicked desires of men, much less be subject to their impiety. So he seems to say they are again thinking of this chapter. Piety is our goal, and nothing should deflect us from that. But we're not enslaved to the wicked desires of men, but hard to know what Calvin means by that. This means the wicked ruler or does he mean wicked people in general, but whatever he means he's concerned here at the end to come back to the beginning and that is to underscore the importance of our piety. And that's not yet the last word, you know, because Calvin wrote the last word in very large letters, which are translated into English and placed in very large letters in our version, God be praised, that really is the last word. Well, enjoyed going through all of this with you, and hope you all have occasion in the future to bring out your institutes and look at them again.