<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
दान देणगी द्या

History and Methodology of New Testament Theology

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Can I say before we go much further with the class that those first 28 pages in LAD, they're just horrible aren't they, okay, they really are bad, it's very well written if you already know something about the subject but if you don't know much about the subject you know it just kind of fume. At the same time it's important that you realize that there's a lot that you don't know so I don't mind if you're in a little bit of a crisis right now and I'll fill in some of the details and in terms of the specifics of what you need to know from LAD, very little from him but a lot from this next lecture, okay, so that's the scenario with that. Why don't I open us in a word of prayer? Father, as we seek to plum the depths of your holy scriptures and as we seek to be true to the intent, the original intent of the author inspired by you. We recognize that this is a task that is extremely difficult. We are thankful that you have given your church your Holy Spirit and that you have given us also a word that speaks deeply and richly in ways that we can't even imagine and so father, we would ask that your Holy Spirit will illumine to us the text of scripture that we would be diligent in our pursuit of understanding you and you as you reveal yourself in the pages of your Holy Scriptures and that through all of this we would bow the knee to you, worship you, and proclaim Jesus our Lord and Savior in his name we pray. Amen. We normally open with kind of homily. For sake of time I want to plunge ahead here so I'm going to put off the next time what I was planning on bringing in in that context. What I'd like to do instead is plunge right into our discussion coming a little bit out of last time and then move into the next set that's listed as kind of lecture number three on your handouts and in your syllabus. But if I can remind us from last time we had a drawing up here, right? Maybe mentally as I'm drawing this you can try and think ahead of me see if you can draw it mentally in your own mind. By the way I like this drawing. It's the very kind of thing that could come up I don't know, kind of midterm exam. In fact if you're wondering in terms of examination you know the only reason in my mind to do exams is to motivate you to learn. Hopefully you don't even need the exam honestly you know just they're so you know enthralled with the material that's not even there but students are always wondering what do I need to know for the exam? Well at this stage there's certain things that from this the last few lectures for instance how would you defend against an attack on whether you could ever know the intent of the author. Intentional fallacy. How would you argue that the text is coherent enough that the gaps in the text don't prevent us from really understanding what the text is about you know. So those major questions that you saw us answer from your notes those would be great short essay questions okay and I expect you in your own words to articulate a response that's that's one example. Another example is you know there's been three drawings up on the board you know the the author text reader drawing right. There's been the pre-understanding text drawing which I ultimately would revise into a spiral and there's now been another whole drawing about the relationship between author and audience. Those are the kind of drawings that you should be able to of course think about reproduce and also discuss in terms of their ramifications for your personal interpretation and the interpretation of the church of scripture okay. So in case you're wondering what you need to know that's the kind of thing I'm thinking about. Now we ended last time talking about author audience right and what was back here. Mountain so what do the mountains represent cultural context and backgrounds and especially in our context we're talking Greco-Roman and Jewish context. If the author is Paul and he's speaking to an audience in Corinth he is not just so culturally immersed that he's just kind of giving to them culture. He's actually drawing his thought from at least two spheres namely Old Testament and Jesus that's right. Now and where does the Holy Spirit fit into this above on the drawing but what does that represent? Superintending of the whole Shabang right. That's what I was arguing. It's the normal means of inspiration their times when the Holy Spirit simply reveals in the sense of saying you say this and the author says it but usually this is more the way and where are we way over here and we have our own cultural context and then we talked about transcultural application. Now we had after a class I had a number of really fine conversations with people and there've been just some great questions and interaction and I really appreciate you thinking these things through. There's a couple of things coming out of that but I want to make sure that you hear me say if I've said it once or maybe I haven't said it sufficiently. I want to just say it again. That is I am not trying to then say that our culture constrains our interpretation of the New Testament and that we read our culture back into the New Testament. I'm not trying to say that we only let things fit into our culture that we want to fit into our culture. In point of fact one person used the term and this is a very coming at seminary term. Transforming culture right. We do want to see our culture transformed for the sake of the gospel. So what I'm talking about here is not the culture is static but culture does provide us with the kind of situation in which we have to live out the transcultural truths over here. Let me give you another example of that. First Corinthians chapter 16, let me read you a very edifying passage description. 1619 Paul's coming to a conclusion and so he says at the end of first Corinthians the churches of Asia greet you, Aquila and Priska greet you heartily in the Lord with the church that is in their house. All the brethren greet you. Greet one another with a holy kiss. Now do you practice that in your church? Let me tell you I know of a church that did. When we were in England and near Cambridge where we were the there was a church, there's a charismatic church with a godly man who was preaching from the pulpit and he came across that passage and he just got a burning sense that he needed to preach this to his congregation and to instruct them to greet one another with holy kisses. And so he illustrated that on a regular basis for a number of weeks where he'd come in and as soon as he saw a fellow believer from his church he'd run up right to him and give him a peck. Now it was pointed out to him by one of his friends. I'm told this very second hand so I yet I have good reason to believe this is accurate but one of his friends came to him and said do you notice that you have a tendency to greet with holy kisses mostly females you know the little kiss on the cheek. Now he isn't intending anything intimate in it but it was just more natural and it was also noted to him that the kind of women that he might find more attractive he was quicker to. Again he did not mean anything wrong and as soon as that was pointed out to him he stopped the practice but unfortunately he'd already unleashed on his church and so they're still greeting at the time they're still greeting one another with holy kisses and he was like I need to stop this you know because a kiss in our society means something different than a kiss did in the first century. If you guys have seen you know Middle Easterners greet one another you know you come up and I mean I was just in Jordan this past summer right and the people who are good friends they come up to one another and they do this on the cheek and this on the cheek and this on the cheek and that's how they do it. Guys you know right now it's hard to know exactly the context in the first century but it was probably much more akin to the Middle Eastern form of greeting than it would be to me running up and giving somebody a smooch all right. So when I look at that text then I say well you know the culture has changed and people could misunderstand this greeting with a holy kiss. Does that make sense to you? Remember the furor when George Bush you know get a little pack to his his designate you know it was in the news for like several days that was something you just didn't the south you know but in the rest of the nation it's weird and so you have to be careful with these things right. So well then what do we do with the text? Well you've just decided it doesn't apply no that's not what I'm saying and that's not what this diagram says. This diagram says that as we're looking at this relationship between author and audience and understanding what that meant there what he was saying is greet one another in a in a friendly intimate fashion as if you are good friends right. Maybe as if you're even in the same family and that's what's transcultural here. The kiss is just the outward expression of the transcultural value that he's trying to convey to his audience right. So then we come to us and we have to ask what does that mean for us? Well it's going to mean things in a different way. I mean Felix you guys greet one another in a different way and gone it probably than we do in the States. I mean well and when I was in England I mean the typical way of greeting somebody in England is like this so how do you do? You keep the hands firmly in the pocket. Rarely do you shake hands right. It's just that's just not what you do and I came back to the States here and I was actually I was interviewing for the position here at Covenant and I was in the midst of this kind of cultural and I hadn't been off the plane that long and the first thing that happens I'm walking across campus and and this guy comes up and says are you you know are you professor Chapman and he has and he's like well welcome and he pulls out this hand and he's shaking away you know and I think whoa I'm not been in this culture for a while you know but the expression of greeting changes from culture to culture but the point is is that in the church we should greet one another we should interact like we're really in fellowship with one another right now that's perhaps how we should apply it and your context may vary I mean this might mean a handshake this might mean a side hug this this might mean just a gentle nod from across the room or it might mean in an in Asian setting you know a good bow to one another but whatever it means that's the idea all right and if if I was to give a point of a specific application where this is also supposed to transform our culture in a sentence I'm a good Presbyterian and these I've been in Presbyterian churches for a long time and I know the proper way to enter into a pew okay it is to give a vague acknowledgement to the person sitting next to you and if you are already seated your main obligation when the person comes and sits down is just move your coat over a few inches so that they feel welcome to sit at the bench I think there's fundamentally something wrong about that and we're not really applying this text and it's real form there right we need to really greet one another like we're sincerely in fellowship with one another doesn't mean we need to be pecking each other in the cheek but we need to do something more than just moving the coat you know some so some thought there but that that is all to give you an illustration of another illustration of how this thing works okay and I admit that this is a lot more complex than then simply reading scripture and saying oh I need to go and often go give somebody a holy kiss but I think it's also a lot more accurate to what how we should approach scripture okay and it does give complexities because at times it would be easy to write something off as if that's not culturally applicable when deeper down it probably is so I have to be careful that danger too right before we move on I'm willing to take any last few questions you guys have had a couple of days to ponder this do you want to interact with this anymore yeah the the the common is that this seems so subjective in some ways even the last illustration brings that out and the sense that you know the question is well how do we know if something really applies I wish I could give you just a simple matrix for how to make application decisions I'm not sure that it's that easy I mean there's certainly things that we need to take into context what what really is he trying to say here and if he were to come to us what what how would he say that in our categories I mean if you're thinking in those terms that that removes some of the subjectivity from it because you know you're there the good thing about it is frankly it also I think our application has always been fairly subjective this brings out the elements that should be subjective to a certain degree in some that that aren't okay and what you're looking for is cultural analogues if you have an exact cultural overlap then you just bring it right into your culture okay if you if you don't but there's analogous things going on in the culture then you know you have to do this but this also allows us to bring this alive to you know context such as you know bioethical decisions well I mean let's be honest Jesus and Paul did not directly address the issue of cloning of embryos it's it's not there the question is are there some transcultural principles that show up in multiple locations in scripture that then speak to that so there's there's one example I'm sorry one had just occurred to me let's see if I can bring it back oh you know Jesus and Paul do not directly speak to you know you're sitting at work you're in front of the computer can you do personal emails on company time you know now there I think that's an example where it truly is subjective because there's a lot of things to take into account in something like that finding the right principles in scripture and then figuring out exactly what your situation is so some employers are actually happy for you to write personal emails some are not and you certainly have to take that into account too and so that there really is a sense in which application is corporate and it's also individual it depends on your context and yeah I mean somewhat subjective at times not saying it's purely subjective just somewhat there that would I briefly explain the hermitical spiral again it's simply to say that we have enough reason to think that our pre-understanding does not so constrain our interpretation of the text that really all we're doing in interpretation is just confirming our own biases okay I'm trying to say that we can really spiral into a more accurate understanding of the text in terms of what it really meant author to audience is that comprehensible good good question okay good let's let's flip the page now and start talking about lecture number three it says it says at the top it should say nt16 number three history task and methodology of new testament theology okay coming back one one last time to this diagram what I've really articulated here is a reason for understanding new testament history okay you see then in this all this right here that we dare not just abstract scripture into our immediately internal context but we have to understand historically what Paul is saying historically to the church and the historic current historically okay so that's why we do New Testament history and articulated a bit of a rationale for that I want to move into the other half of the title of this class New Testament history and theology and talk a little bit about New Testament theology but on the way I want to talk about the history of the study of the New Testament okay so where I am on your handout there is says history of New Testament theology and then point a why bother studying history now in this regard I don't mean history is in ancient history I now mean history is in 18th 19th 20th century history of interpretation okay so that's what we're going to talk about for a second I brought some extras last time but I'm not sure if there are any others available right now I'll try and bring some extra handout so the question is is there any extra handouts I'll try and bring some next time and maybe you can look on with the person next to you that works Nathan right time why bother studying history well in every field of study academic study there are always some things that are just simply assumed by the people engaging in that study in other words if you're going to be a biologist there's just stuff that you know that a biologist has to know before they can even start talking you're going to be a physicist there's stuff you have to know and it's beyond just knowing principles of physics it's knowing the history of the study of physics so for instance in physics you got to know something about Newton and you got to know something about Einstein right you just have to know something about it because all the time people are going to be talking about physics and they might even use phrases such as Newtonian mechanics or you know Einsteinian physics or the theory of general relativity and if you don't understand those words and the history of association with those words you will not be able to enter into the discourse you won't be able read the books on physics right and physics may not be your strong suit and if if those words such as general relativity speak fear to your heart it's okay we're not doing physics here but it's just a point one of the reasons you maybe you don't like physics is you don't know enough of the history to enter into the discussion biology okay you got to know something about Darwin you know it's almost like Darwin is always behind the picture anytime certainly starts talking about biology listen to the news and anytime a biological issue comes up at some stage there's going to be at least one sentence in the article on the TV interview where really the questions that Darwin raised are back there whether a person is agreeing with Darwin whether they are revising Darwin whether they want to completely throw them out he's always there if you don't know the history of that discipline and what Darwin did you lost okay same deal when you read about New Testament if if you don't believe me there was 28 pages the beginning of lad which I just admitted were horrible right a few minutes ago in case you guys weren't here right when I started why didn't you understand it it's because he's mentioning all these historical figures that anybody who's ever worked in the discipline they know but you don't know which means that sometimes you don't understand why questions are coming up and they're being addressed just just as like if you had come completely out of any any context with in association with the current teaching of biology you suddenly plunged in and people are talking about you know why this species led to this species and at what point in time and history that happened and you don't know anything about Darwin you're just clueless I mean why are they even asking that question right same thing going on with with with here so what I want to do is talk about a few of the movements and trends and some keys to understanding contemporary New Testament study right the names that you don't know that you need to know that's what this is about right tough in terms of talking about movements and trends there's there's some stuff you need to know going all the way back to the Renaissance you remember the Renaissance from world history you know when you were back in high school right it was this this intellectual movement this classical revival and a revival of language coming out of the middle ages now when I mean classical revival I mean a return to the classics the return to the glories of Greece and Rome and this fascination with Roman architecture with forms of politics with forms of economics with forms of literature and forms of art you know that's the the Renaissance revival okay in the midst of the Renaissance there was also this revival of the careful study of documents wasn't wholly missing before but there was an added little twist of skepticism that came in at times and one of the most important things in that regard was a document known as the donation of Constantine get heard of this the donation of Constantine was a document that had surfaced and had subsequently been employed by the Catholic Church in which the great emperor Constantine who was the first great Christian emperor donated certain territories to the church okay and this document was then used to justify the ongoing work of the church in in the Roman Empire it it represented as giving the Pope primacy over all the churches in the Roman Empire but the document in the 15th century was shown to be a a lie it was written probably in the 8th century 500 years after Constantine actually was alive and it was shown to be such on the basis of the use of language that was employed the lack of knowledge of actual historical events in the 4th century this kind of stuff so suddenly this pretty important any it wasn't gigantic but this pretty important a document that was used by the Catholic Church to substantiate the strength of the papacy this important church document was shown to be a completely artificial construct now one of the ramifications of that is then people began asking well what else is there in the church that is a lie okay and so skepticism enters into the church now there was something good about that because the document was false but there's something dangerous about the question as well and as we move into the enlightenment the basic principle of the enlightenment is that reason is the chief arbiter of all that is true faith is not love is not reason is if you want to know what is true it needs to be able to be displayed in logical thought right that's the enlightenment and as the enlightenment progressed into modernity there was an increasing skepticism about the historicity of the Bible subsuming all faith under rationality okay you want here's a great title I mean this doesn't illustrate all of Kant's thought Kant was it was a great 19th century philosopher right 18th century philosopher wait I just lost the time I can't the Hegel was 1850s when was Kant manual just lost anyway that's the time period Kant K&T and I'm so embarrassed I was a philosophy major you know this is what you forget all right anyway a manual Kant wrote this book called religion within the bounds of reason alone in other words what can we know about religion that comes to us simply through the dictates of reason and not through revelation now that's kind of the enlightenment it is highest that wasn't all of Kant's faith by the way but the title itself is just so illustrative of the enlightenment enlightenment thoughts okay so that's where we are in the 19th century now what I want to do is that was point B movements and trends we talked about the Renaissance and the donation of Constantine enlightenment that reason is the chief arbiter of all that is true and the skeet the increasing skepticism in the 19th century about the historicity of the Bible there's a lot of other names I could throw in there but I mean you just need to know that in the 19th century people are becoming skeptical right not everyone but some so point C selected keys to understanding contemporary New Testament study this is this is what I know and this is what I'm almost always speaking to in the back of my head okay so if you hear me say something and then qualify it it might I might be qualifying it because I knew of some of the trends in historical New Testament study and I'm trying to negotiate those trends right so you need to know what some of these trends are first the quest for the historical Jesus if reason is the arbiter of all that is true and if the New Testament documents are not fully historically reliable and as the century progressed are considered less and less reliable then the gospels cannot produce an accurate picture of who Jesus is when a key example of this

reason dictates that events always happen via cause and effect okay there's a lot of philosophical

thought going into that whole issue but but if if you're an enlightenment person I mean that's that's something you would hold reason dictates that events always happen because of cause and effect cause and effect is always understood in terms of natural sequences and natural causes such that if when I wake up in the morning my car is no longer parked in the garage and I find it parked out in front of my mailbox I don't immediately assume oh an angel moved it you know I look for the natural cause that created that event I go ask Tasha my wife I go see if our nine-year-old kid has been practicing how to drive I wonder if some thief broken and so you know you know that's that's what I'm immediately thinking of okay so according to reason then miracles don't happen you may not agree with that I don't agree with it but it is a logical consequence of enlightenment thought you know the Bible again and again especially in the New Testament account of the gospels of Jesus as Jesus running around healing people you know walking on water been raised from the dead all that kind of stuff but we know because we're good enlightenment thinkers that that doesn't happen so that's just a small example okay we're going to return to the whole issue of the quest for the historical Jesus we have a whole lecture on this eventually but the idea is that we approach the New Testament documents skeptically so then it's reasonable for us to ask what was Jesus really like because we can't trust the gospels that was a huge question in the 19th century and into the 20th century and it's still being asked like by the Jesus seminar here in the 21st century okay so that's one thing I know about the history of New Testament interpretation is that people ask that question second Ferdinand Christian Bauer and the Tubingen School. Tubingen is a city in southern Germany it has a very fine university I spent five months studying New Testament there okay in the 19th century Tubingen was all about this man named Ferdinand Christian Bauer he was the teacher there in terms of theological studies especially of the New Testament and Bauer was very much a man of his day he loved Hagel. Hagel is a philosopher okay. Hagel is known for his dialectical thinking so for Hagel being encounters nothingness and the result is becoming I know that if you've never done Hagel that's like what all right but but this is that the two are juxtaposed with one another and they reach a higher synthesis. Hagel's thought was gigantic in Europe in the 19th century it was also big actually in the states you know where there were a lot of Germans he wanted a major center for Hagellian scholarship in the world was Texas so a lot of Germans in Texas anyway this well historical anecdote there all right so Hagel was gigantic an example of somebody who followed Hagel one one that you'd be more familiar with but then completely kind of turned him on his head and instead of applying it to the life of the mind applied it to the life of economics and society is Karl Marx right where where you have things like feudalism encounters its antithesis and it results in capitalism capitalism eventually is going to result in its antithesis of the proletariat uprising because they are being suppressed in a capital of society and the result the synthesis is going to be communism so this idea that you have this this and that thesis and synthesis synthesis okay those are not Hagel's terms per se but that's that's the idea well Ferdinand Christian Bauer asked where in the New Testament do we see thesis antithesis and synthesis and he said we see this in the life of Paul and Peter okay in particular I guess we would have to say Peter came first because Peter represents Jewish Christianity Paul came next and he represents Gentile Christianity okay and these were just they disagreed with one another strongly and vehemently about issues such as do Gentiles have to be circumcised do Gentiles have to keep the law and in Galatians you see that Paul explicitly says I oppose Peter to his face and there's what Bauer was after opposition thesis antithesis and he would argue that basically Paul and Peter never got along and it wasn't later until really the second century church that you ended up with a kind of synthesis and that synthesis is represented in later writings such as the writings and acts and in this supposed first Peter document he found his dialectic good problem with that is if you look at the writings that are associated with Peter like first Peter and second Peter where second Peter Peter explicitly says that the writings of Paul are scripture and those some are hard to understand they you know that they they trample over him on paraphrasing basically like they do the rest of scriptures right so first Peter doesn't work here and actually not all the Paul line documents work here because there's just a few that are really focused on this issue of law he's single about Galatians and Romans but he also included first and second Corinthians okay we'll talk more about this later when we get to lecturing about Paul but but those three document or four documents all right Galatians, Romans, first Corinthians and second Corinthians he called the helped briefah briefah is German for letter helped is for head the chief letters okay and the rest are not written by Paul how do we know this well it doesn't fit into what we expect Paul to be interacting with so in order for all this to work first Peter's not written by Peter second Peter's not written by Peter most of the Paul line letters are not written by Paul etc and acts as a late second century document or as well probably mid second century document early to mid second century well after the time that Luke the supposed companion of Paul would have been in the grave now you know you're you immediately you're just saying well what what's going on there this seems to be very theory laden and we'll talk about that later I mean he's so driven by Eugaly and philosophy that he's making a can of scripture fit that's true in any case what you need to know is that every new testament scholar knows about Ferdinand Christian power and all of Pauline scholarship is either in a praising or reacting against Ferdinand Christian power for decades and the legacy of that continues to now okay that's another thing you need to know by the way in Tudingen where we live for five months there's a there's one of the longest streets in town they name the streets after famous scholars and also famous people so there's a Beethoven's vague Beethoven way right and so they have things like that and also other famous scholars that have ever worked in Tudingen the one of the longest streets that goes right up this very important hill is called the full name of the street and it's all it's written out on this sign Ferdinand Christian power Straussah I mean it's they wanted his whole name on there and the print is so small you can't even read it you're kind of drawn by whoa what was that because they got the whole name there but that's because he was that important just change scholarship in his day right so there's something you need to know another thing you need to know Walter Bauer wrote a book translated into English it's called orthodoxy and heresy okay Walter Bauer was was a brilliant scholar especially in petristics and also in New Testament studies we still use in this you know a a lexicon that's much indebted to him in New Testament studies very important man Walter Bauer argued and I'm not sure if he was the first to argue this but he was certainly one of the most popular people to argue this that typically when we look back on church history we think of orthodoxy and heresy okay so if you've studied church history like here for instance early petristic history you will start talking about Christological Heresies okay people who did not appreciate the deity of Christ people who wanted him adopted and a subsequent adoption kind of a lesser deity an an Aryan view all right then there's issues about the dual natures in the way that they interact with one another and so you you'll talk about all of that and and they'll be framed in terms of the history of Christological Heresies prior to that really in many ways there there was the Gnostic Heresy the talk that there was private knowledge that was taught by Jesus to some of his disciples which is not your New Testament at all but they kind of whispered on the sly and this private knowledge is extremely mystical okay that's that's early Gnosticism well the early church saw that as a heresy and they they were not abashed about calling it a heresy and so therefore church history is typically said there's orthodoxy and there's heresy Bauer said and this sounds so 21st century but he said something along the lines of that's a bit pejorative isn't it these are just alternative christianities

undoubtedly if you were a Gnostic you weren't looking around and saying hey I'm a heretic yes you were probably saying I've got the true christianity and those people are wrong so orthodoxy and heresy as we contemporary use it is really just a study of who won

right now the reason I say that that's very 21st century is I can name half dozen people to you right now that are major scholars often on news on the television on the radio famous New Testament scholars that would that that's how they live there are a variety of christianities and antiquity and it has just been arbitrary the victor has arbitrarily labeled the the loser's heresy's and so this is a legacy that we have a New Testament scholarship is that correct when we need to be willing to ask that question next Rudolph Bultmann another fine New Testament scholar he's known for a variety of things but especially for this slogan the Jesus of history and the Christ of faith coming out of the quest for the historical Jesus he had to simply acknowledge that the gospels are not good historical sources the Jesus of history was probably very different from how the gospels represented them but that is not to say that the gospels are of no use to us because they testify to the faith of the early church to what they believe whether it was historically accurate or not we don't care not really this was the Christ of faith and so he pronounced a declaration of a separation between the Jesus of history wow Jesus really was and the Christ of faith how the early church represented him and he was therefore willing to encourage his people to preach the Christ of faith even if he believed that that wasn't historically accurate in some respects now he had other things he did in terms of de mythologizing is another term that's associated with him and we'll talk more about him later but that's another kind of major historical milestone in the history of New Testament understanding okay another milestone in this this precedes actually Bultmann in some respects so these are taken a little out of order it's what's known as source form and reduction criticism we when we get to our study the gospels we're going to talk about all this in a lot more detail but if your gospels for instance just to stand the gospels is is not wholly accurate historically and in fact is kind of a composite mosaic of a variety of teachings that were known in the early church that were then reframed by the gospel writers in light of their Christ of faith then it would be hypothetically possible to try and go back to the original source documents what was Jesus truly said by asking did he say this parable or not and when you ask that question you're not asking you know did he say everything that said in Matthew but you're asking is that parable does that go back to an earlier source that could potentially go back to Jesus okay so then you start thinking of the gospels as this kind of mosaic quilt of a variety of ancient sources and your job then as a New Testament scholar is not to understand Matthew but to try and figure out Matthew's sources and maybe delineate them into different groups so when a Matthew's sources might be the gospel of Mark another of his sources might be a different source that he had in common with Luke which we would call Q the letter Q which is abbreviation for the the German quella between source okay so that might be another one then Matthew might have his own distinct set of sources and you can delineate whether they come from M1 or M2 because those are special Matthew sources Matthew 1 Matthew 2 et cetera and that's your job and at the end of the day you have a commentary that says something like this came from Q this came from M1 this came from Mark and you're done and the edification factor is fairly low right it also assumes source criticism assumes that these these are all written documents okay that Q it was a written source certainly Mark was a written source et cetera people began to ask was well given the nature of verality oral communication in the ancient world is it not possible that at least some of these sources were just oral sources and then they began to compare this idea of oral sources to what we know about other oral sources in the modern world like for instance the passing down of of of of myths or good stories or fables you know the Grims fairy tales it'd be interesting to see how fairy tales changed over the centuries and how they changed to meet different expectations in their individual communities okay so there were certain problems in the 17th century that caused the fairy tale to be going this direction in the 18th century a little different in the 19th century different still get to the 20th century and you've got Disney and it's you know little mermaid doesn't look at all like how grim told it okay and so through the process of oral tradition things change and they get adapted to their different communities certain forms then we'll stand out and speak to different communities so for instance if your community is going through a time I've persecution then a story that's about persecution will really resonate with you and so you're more likely to pass it on then you would be if it was just a regular time so form criticism developed where they they they isolated different forms and instead of asking written sources they're asking oral sources and they're asking how these oral sources change through tradition and they're doing tradition history that's another thing that happened in New Testament studies okay this also is very intellectually interesting but how do you take it to a congregation you really can't in many ways and partly due to that practical concern but also partly due to just kind of the scholarly awareness somebody finally sat back and said well if we're interested in all these communities through time and what they look like why aren't we interested in the community in Matthew's day so yes Matthew was an editor which in technical jargon is a redactor redactor that's well I'll write it down he was a redactor an editor but we could still be interested in what his point of view is and where are we most likely to find it well we're not most likely to find it in his sources because those are just kind of plug-and-play take the source stick it in we're most likely to see it how in the ways that he weaves together sources and in the little connections that he uses to take this source and then transition us to the next one and those little connections are known as redactional seams okay and then the question is in redaction criticism what is Matthew's point of view all right now that source form in redaction criticism we're going to return to those again when we talk about the gospels I just want to kind of announce that to you now and then I'll have more written definitions and all that we'll see this in practice in a few weeks that's something else you need to know about the history of New Testament scholarship all right so when your university professor gets up and starts talking about Matthew in the back of his mind he's thinking the history of source form redaction criticism Jesus of history cries to faith all of that kind of stuff is going on in the back of his head whether he's reacting to it or she's reacting to it or whether they're embracing it that's just what's going on okay I guess we're about halfway through the list here a little over halfway do you guys have any questions about any of these now any points of clarification yeah it's related in two respects the question was is this where scholars will bring in stories from other religions and such it's related to form criticism because the idea of how forms develop over time it's related there actually we could have put down a point number eight actually you just convinced me I need to put it down for future generations there's another thing which is known as the history of religion research in in German is religion's gashitta gashitta's history religion's religion you know the history of religions and what what you're talking about there comparing Islam and Islam stories to Christian stories is comparing Christian comparing religions and the main goal of history religions has typically been to show the parallels the striking parallels as if there's something inherent going on in the in the person's soul that calls forth for these parallels apart from whether there's any reference to the deity or not that's actually a different area of study called religions gashitta or history of religion study so there's something else that has been going on since the 19th century it's it's building up on itself the quest for the historical Jesus I mean the trends were already prevalent by the 18th century end of the 18th century but it's in the 19th century that it really started taking off about mid 19th century and and it continues to this day for now Christian Bauer lived in the the last half of the 19th century so that's a little later than the quest for the historical Jesus Walter Bauer lived at the end of the 19th century into the 20th century Rudolph Boltman takes us into the 20th century source form and reduction criticisms and kind of pushes us back into the 19th century into the 20th century and CH dot we'll see this 20th century and then the current one is today so giving you a field so they're roughly in chronological order except for the source form and reduction criticism okay good question okay let me move into CH dot then point six and realized eschatology eschatology you think is about the study of the future but you know there's a lot of stuff in the new testament where the author just comes out and says things like

identifies us in the living in the in the first century with the last days okay as if the first century church was living in the last days they are living in the eschaton Dodd came up with the idea of this realized eschatology that the earliest church teaching coming out of the teaching of Jesus is the Messiah has come resurrection is here the eschaton is here we're not looking for something in the future it's already happened and at any moment Christ is going to be back and we'll see this all happened but as time progressed there was this kind of crisis in the church where there was like well you know I thought Jesus was going to be back any day now we're waiting and this produced this kind of crisis in the early church that moved from this realized the end is now to a future orientation and the church has then subsequently taken eschatology into the future but in the first century expression the earliest expression was realized eschatology the end is now okay that was CH Dodd's point this is big for you because you guys are reading a book by a guy named lad right a lot of what lad is doing is is talking about what he calls inaugurated eschatology where he argues that the New Testament the end is now and in the future that the earliest expression in the early church wasn't it's all now and it wasn't it's all future it was both and we're in the last days and their future now if you guys have been around our systematic theology department he might Williams just loves to talk about inaugurated eschatology you know well he's pretty heavily indebted to to to to lad in that regard and it's a good thing I think but lads indebted to this crisis that came out of examining Dodd and realized eschatology so you see that even that teaching which I think is fundamentally correct comes out of the awareness of the history of New Testament scholarship up to his point Schliermarker we're talking 19th century we're talking somebody who was a romantic in many ways and his interests were he assumed the quest for the historical Jesus he assumed that the Jesus of the text is not where the of the New Testament is inaccurate but he also assumed that religion was a lot less about just reason and much more about the kind of the romantic living of life so you just engage in in worship or you engage in in life really within anything with Schliermarker yeah so yeah that's a gross oversimplication but there okay Dodd's view of when this crisis in the church was going on about the the the lack of return of Jesus and the shift from a realized eschatology at the end is now to a futuristic eschatology he would locate that somewhere in the first century into the second century it wasn't like it just shifted overnight but there's this gradual realization in the church that we're still waiting and and that's that's that's how he sees it okay yeah I think by the way lad does an excellent job of pointing out in every in every New Testament book the end is now and its future I just think he's fundamentally right about that so that's a good corrective I think but anyway current now multiplicity or of methods and goals I have given you well six principles up to now if you flip the page there's this in your handout there is a sheet what does it say at the top Charlie I forget I don't have one modern hermanutical approaches I think I was able to come up with 19 and after I had printed it out I thought of another now we may go through some of these at a later point and some of them I'll be talking about at this stage don't worry about this stuff for the quiz until we start talking about it what I wanted to show you more than anything is my goodness how many methods could be employed okay and basically what you've had is source form and reduction criticism just seems so abstract and you're talking about the history of this kind of backstory of early Christianity and how do you bring that to the church today you just can't and so one of the major shifts that's gone on is there's been a shift from the historical study to literary study of the New Testament so that you're not trying to ask historical questions you're just reading the Bible like a book you just read Matthew like a narrative you read the book of Romans like a great rhetorical exercise okay and so when you see that there's this break from the historical approaches to the literary approaches that that's a major shift that's gone on and then the way that that happened academically is there's this kind of awareness of you know my goodness if if you look at the English department or the French department here at the university they're asking very different questions about the text than we as historians are asking so maybe we should adopt the most recent literary methodology but the problem is is that the literary methodologies have just been shifting and shifting and shifting and shifting and shifting and we talked a little bit about moving to read a response and then out to deconstructionist and then you're into feminist deconstructionism and then you're into queer theory and then you're into intertextual readings which is not necessarily as biased as in terms of feminism and queer theory which just engages just says we're going to revises feminist we're going to see how the text instantiates a patriarchal hegemony you going to intertextuality and you're interested in other things and so there's just this this plethora of literary critical methodologies out there so now I mean this is great for PhD students I honestly think this is one thing that's driving it because if you think about it the new testament has just over 600,000 words in it and the number of people that are writing PhDs on the new testament I mean it's and you have to and writing a PhD you have to say something new that's bottom line you can't get the PhD unless you say something new how do you say something new about 600,000 words just over 600,000 words well one of the ways that you do it is you maybe don't say anything new about what the text means but you use a different approach so whatever is currently going on in the English department you you trying there before anybody else does so you know you're the first one off the block I'm being very cynical there but there that's some of what's going on and so there's this kind of constant change in approaches and there's a very common thing going on now in publications of books about the New Testament and the Old Testament this is both you can buy books on the shelf like on the book of Revelation especially several books on the book of Revelation out there and they will have in it eight different readings of the book of Revelation they'll get somebody who's a validly a reader response critic they'll get somebody who's a validly a deconstructions they'll get somebody who's a validly going to give it a feminist reading somebody who's going to give it a validly a different reading okay and and every chapter then is going to come from a wholly different methodology and the conclusion to the book is isn't this great all this different approaches all with different viewpoints different ways we can read the text and appropriate it for ourselves and there's therefore this kind of multiplicity of goals out there and there's really a crisis in a sense if if what you want to do is come to the right interpretation because people of they're beyond that they're just still fighting over which method to use okay so that's that's the scenario today all right any questions about that anybody study religious studies or New Testament someplace in a secular university did you see some of this going on oh yeah oh yeah every professor any story that strikes you I'm putting you on a spot so in short in case you didn't hear him there's no truth claims and there's just a scientific approach and it's it's very kind of out there it's a distance from us in some ways so it's sporing yeah respect yeah so your experience was that his the Bible's literature and you couldn't ask meaning for us in some ways or whatever you but it was just literary different literary forms and you're asking you're studying it like you would any work of literature yeah yeah that's by the way I'll just admit I'm repeating some of these things for the sake of that camera because they can't hear you okay so I'm supposed to do that apologize if I don't summarize well enough okay anybody else want to mention their experience yeah so so Brad has had the experience of talking with a professor teaches this way but really wishes he could believe and broke down crying because he couldn't yeah okay last I see there's two stories but last story yeah that so many of your teachers in the religious studies department Christian ones had started off believers even missionaries and yet have have moved far away from the faith in the process yeah can I say I mean I don't want to bad mouth the university system a couple of things one is the wonderful Christian believers in the university structure frankly we need more who are willing to engage in the university structure it is hard because as in most fields of academia in order to get into the system you have to get your PhD in the system and the PhD in the system is in some ways not intentionally but it weeds you out if you're going to think differently than the current thinking is in the university so it kind of tracks you but there are some wonderful Christian believers making stands for the Lord in the context and it's also to say that we can learn from this there's actually something about nearly every one of these categories that's worth considering it it took CH Dodd for instance to come up with the idea of realized eschatology before somebody came back and realized that no it's really inaugurated eschatology in the New Testament and that is right the end is here and the end is future so you can learn you can adapt you can you can engage people I'm not just saying we we just come up with a knee jerk reaction and secondly I mean to the extent that we do set critique these viewpoints and maybe reject aspects of them we have to do so intellectually responsibly we can't just simply say well I'm going to believe I'm not going to do that we need to have some apologetics some reason for rejecting okay so I'm going to say that and and we'll come up with some of these things later in the class okay let me state now we're going to move into a very different thing here and we're going to I'm just going to simply state what I think is the task of New Testament theology okay so this is the New Testament theology part of our class New Testament history and theology what is what does it mean to do New Testament theology well I suggest in your handout that there are two working goals the first is to inductively synthesize the major theological themes in each New Testament author within their historical backdrop now what I'm saying there when I'm expecting to see there as I'm expecting different New Testament authors to have certain themes things that they really care about Luke talks a lot about poverty and the rich okay James does too but it's not as prevalent in some other authors especially in some books and so that's a theme that they bring out and and that's a real and honest theological theme as an emphasis that is appropriate it's appropriate in the whole inspiration of God and instead of approaching scripture and saying where can I find justification by faith in this text and in this where can I find it in first Peter where can I find it here where can I find it there instead of approaching with a category and saying I want to find this we're going to approach it inductively and we're going to say so what are some of the major themes in Luke what are some of the major themes in Paul what are some of the major themes in James because in the process we're going to encounter some things that maybe we didn't see for instance even in our systematic theology I'll give you an example of this systematic theology is often driven by controversies and responses to controversies so when you talk about Christology the dual nature of Christ fully God fully man a lot of that discussion is still indebted to the series of early Christian heresies and I'm going to use the H word because I think it's right okay early Christian heresies there's a sequence there and so you go through that now that also has a danger in it that if there has not been significant disagreement earlier on in the church then your systematic theology may not emphasize something that's important okay because you everybody just assumes it but they never really engage it theologically here's an example I'm a good presbyterian I'll just I'll confess right here all right I like the Westminster standards the Westminster confession of faith some of you know what that is some of you don't it doesn't matter this is the confessional documents the Presbyterian Church in America holds to be our confession there's this little thing in the New Testament it's called Jesus's resurrection

do you know how many times in the the larger confession of faith those of your Presbyterians and I'm talking about Jesus's resurrection is mentioned once in passing as one of his states of exaltation it's just mentioned that it happened well now it seems to me a little more important than that does it to you but there was never a controversy about the resurrection of Jesus in the main orthodox church so it's not gotten a lot of contemplation in the fact that it's not in the Westminster standards you then look at the major systematic theology books again in a reformed tradition Lewis Burkhoff 800 some odd pages thick honken systematic theology how many pages on the resurrection three out of 800 a Hodge 1500 pages three volumes same reformed tradition how many pages on Jesus's resurrection five is there an imbalance in our systematic theology yeah now how are we going to correct an imbalance like that well one of the ways we can correct it is by doing really good exegesis really good interpretation of the New Testament so that you come out and you see themes that really should be part of our theology so by inductively approaching the New Testament documents New Testament texts New Testament scriptures and seeing what Luke emphasizes in Matthew emphasizes and seeing pretty much everybody has something to say about the resurrection and then you look at your systematic book and say we don't or we have very little to say then you think well I you know I better change something there so one of the great benefits of doing New Testament theology inductively like this is it can help correct our systematic theology so that's one of the things I'm thinking that's why the word inductive is there notice also in this it says inductively synthesize the major theological themes in each New Testament author within their historical backdrop I'm still looking at this diagram here right we're still talking about history when we do our interpretation we're not absolutely off something into some sort of absolute theological proof text in the poorest sense of the of the word proof text so that's one working goal the second working goal is to further appreciate the organic unity of New Testament theology in the midst of the diversity of its expression in other words I'm going to say yes Luke emphasizes poverty and rich the poor and the rich yes James does as well there's a little bit in Paul we tend to overlook that because it's mostly in the pastoral epistles especially first Timothy that is a theme it's not generally in our systematic theology

it might even not even be in our systematic approach to ethics but it's there it's in the New Testament we need to see it but we can also synthesize it and realize that it's not just something that Luke talks about but it's something that's in the whole mind of God and another example is if we look at all the New Testament documents where they talk about Jesus is dying for our sins they might all have different ways of speaking of that different infacies different perspectives on that but they're all speaking to the same reality and trying to understand how a man hang on across for a few hours can suddenly change the whole of redemptive history so that you and I send full human beings belong in God's family and that's what they're trying to do and we can see all the different perspectives and infacies but we also expect there to be a synthesis so those are the two working goals inductively author by author synthesis second goal okay