<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
दान देणगी द्या

Universal Forms of Love, III

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

I'd like to begin class by reading one verse of Psalm 119. It's verse 75. This is the new Revised Standard version. One of the things that's helpful with familiar scripture is to read them in different versions, because there are various ways in which the Hebrew can be translated as you know. And sometimes you get a nuance in one version that you don't get in the other, and I think that the new Revised Standard on verse 75 really is helpful in the way it renders it. I know, O Lord, that your judgments are right, and that in faithfulness you have humbled. Lord, we confess that we are not worthy of your kindness and your faithfulness. All your mercy and your grace that you have poured out upon us in our Lord Jesus, revealing your gracious will for our lives, giving us the Holy Spirit to enable us to see it and to do it. Humbling us in your faithfulness that we might seek out of gratitude to conform ourselves more carefully to the teaching of our Lord Jesus Christ, that our lives may shine forth your glory and respond to all that you have done for us. Be with us to that end in this class we ask for Jesus' sake. Amen. Now a topic for today is the use of the moral law, and I have a couple of sub-points under this. The first one is to talk about classification. We say the use of the moral law, we're talking about how the moral law is intended to function in a fallen world. It's conditioned by the fall. This is the use of the law in a fallen world, and I think actually it's better to think of it not in terms of our use of the law, although we are involved in this. But rather the question is how does God use the moral law in a fallen world? It's for us to read and implement and so forth, but it's really when we talk about the use of the law, talking about the use of the moral law in a fallen world. Now there's a standard classification of the threefold use of the moral law that derives from the 16th century, civil pedagogical and third. Believe it or not, that's the most common designation of in the classification, the civil or political use of the law, pedagogical use of the law, and the third use of the law, which people name differently. Briefly, civil use of the law is to restrain. This is how the law operates in a fallen world, and the use of the classification is that the civil law is used to restrain centers from social injustice, and the figure that's most commonly used as a handle for looking at that is the bridal. The law is a bridal to restrain sin in society. Actually, I think it's a bit broader than that. That's a part of it, but when we come to the role of the state in God's design, we're going to look at it in terms not only of law and order. This is mainly concerned with law and order, but also social justice. There's a positive use of the moral law in promoting social justice, so it's not entirely negative to restrain. It's also to give the impetus in a fallen world or pursuing the good in society, so just bear that in mind that this is a part for the whole. That's the civil use of the law to restrain centers in society by threatening punishment and carrying it out in appropriate occasions, and that is a bridal to keep the earth from being filled with violence as it was before the flood. That's the function of civil government, at least the main function of civil government, is to use the law in that way. That was Luther, who really insisted that that's not the main use of the law. He acknowledged that there is that civil or political use of the law, but he said that civil righteousness is not the righteousness of God. That you can be righteous before the civil law, living upright, decent life, and all short of the glory of God, and be threatened to eternal damnation with your civic righteousness. And so he focused on the theological or is it's come to be called the pedagogical use of the law, which is basically to convict to convict centers of our sin and thereby to drive us to Christ. Again, we're using the convict as a part for the whole. The goal of the conviction is to drive us to Christ. It's really to show us our sin and our need of a savior. And so having seen the how imperfect we are when held up against God's standard of perfect holiness, which threatens judgment for the least infraction that we are driven to Christ, only in him we can have hope of our salvation. That's the pedagogical use of the law. It is using that term that we saw in Galatians in this particular sense to convict us of our sin, show us our need of our savior and to drive us to him. And the figure that's most commonly used to sort of encapsulate this is the figure of a mirror. As long as we just look at the civil law, we can think we're pretty good. Not as bad as our neighbors, but who are in jail, but when we look at the law of God as it's intended to be used with its spiritual searching, search light, then we see ourselves as God sees us. That's the function of the mirror. God holds up the mirror so that we see ourselves as God sees us. And from the point of view of his perfect holiness, we don't look that good and we need a savior. Now the third use of the law is to guide believers in their new obedience, that having been driven to Christ out of conviction for sin, that now the law functions in a third way to guide believers in their new obedience. And the figure that's most commonly used for the guiding function of the law, the third function as it's called, is a lamp. And so these are the three-fold uses. Actually, they're caught very well in this hymn by Matthias Lloyd. The law of God is good and wise and sets his will before our eyes, shows us the way of righteousness and dooms to death when we transgress. It's light of holiness imparts the knowledge of our sinful hearts, that we may see our lost estate and seek deliverance here too late. That's the pedagogical function of the law. To those who help in Christ have found and would in works of love abound, it shows what deeds are his delight and should be done as good and right. That's the third use, that what formerly convicted us now guides us in our new obedience. Now this is standard and it is helpful. It is a little ambiguous because the law continues to convict us of our sin. The law still is a mirror even after we come to Christ, the law still is a mirror. Lutherans, when they speak of the third use of the law, tend to think of the law as for believers in convicting us of our sin after we come to Christ and reminding us of our need of a Savior and even incorporating the threat of the law in this dialectic of law and grace. I think that the threat of the law is done away with Christ. When we come to Christ and embrace Him as our Savior, the threat of the law is gone. We are not obeying out of the threat of the law. We are obeying now out of the motivations of grace. I think that there is a better way, a more accurate way of dealing with the various functions of the law, which we are thinking primarily about the specially revealed law of God in Scripture and then our proclamation of that in evangelism. Here is the way the Westminster defines understood of the law. Instead of looking at it in that three-fold rubri, that is the 16th century way of looking at it and it is still useful, still has its place, but it does have its limitations, especially since we can't agree on a title for the third use of the law because it is complex in the life of a believer. I would say, considering the way the Westminster defines it, it's in the larger catechism, what is the general use of the law for to all men, what is it used to the regenerate and what is it used, sorry, unregenerate first and what is it used for the regenerate. Now here I think we get a more accurate presentation. The use of the law with respect to all men is to inform and to humble. That is what it always does, no matter whether you regenerate or unregenerate. It always informs of the nature and will of God and it always humbles us. Now that really seems to me to be a better way of thinking about it. They are leaving aside whatever its political use may be to talk about its use within as it is the scriptural revelation of the law of God and it is of use to all to inform and to humble. It is of particular use to the unregenerate to awaken and to drive to Christ. That is parallel to the pedagogical use here but they are thinking of it in terms of strictly speaking the pedagogical use of the law is for the unregenerate. They do not assume baptismal regeneration and so the gospel is preached both to all who are professing Christians as well as those who are in evangelism and the purpose of the usefulness of law to all is to awaken and to drive to Christ. Now when it comes to the special use they say or the regenerate, the special use that it has for the regenerate is to show how much we are bound to Christ and to provoke us to thankfulness, greater thankfulness for us in. Now I think that there is a great advantage in looking at it this way, the law always informs and humbles. No matter who the, remember this is the function of the law in a fallen world and in a fallen world it always informs us of the holy nature and will of God and doing that your centers are always humbled. Particularly with respect to the unregenerate is to awaken the realization that we fall short of the glory of God and to drive us to Christ. It is actually the large ecaticism goes on to say or else the render of the more inexcusable but don't receive the teaching then they are in a worse condition. Having heard the offer full and free offer of Christ as a savior to meet their need they resist either the awakening aspect and not that bad or God will forgive. Surely that's God's business to forgive and so they resist the idea of being driven to Christ and they are more excusable for rejection of Christ. But then the special use the special use to the regenerate is to show us how much we are bound to Christ for his fulfilling it in our stead you see how to remove the threat of the law. You can look at the law you can be informed and humbled by the law to its fullest extent if you've come to Christ that only shows you how much you're bound to Christ for his fulfilling it in your stead. Bearing the penalty and completing its righteousness so it's the doctrine of justification by faith alone that gives us the freedom to look into the law as a mirror and to see what it teaches us with respect to God's holiness. You don't need to be afraid of that. It shows us how much we are bound to Christ for his fulfilling it in our stead and to provoke us to thankfulness. It provokes us to gratitude when we see what Christ has done for us it provokes gratitude and the desire to conform ourselves more perfectly to the obedience that it requires. I think that we should make more of this scheme than we do of the other. Lutherans have a slogan the law always accuses and I think that they're right in that slogan but I think that there is a difference in the way in which it functions in the dialectic of law and gospel and Lutheran theology so that the law never has a quite the positive thrust that it has in the reform tradition but we should agree that the law does always accuse. It does always accuse but for those who are in Christ it doesn't threaten that accusation doesn't threaten it motivates us to grant to. It motivates us to thankfulness. It's a different way in which the law functions in depending on our relationship to Christ. That's the key difference in how the law functions and when we're in Christ and we want to please our Savior then what do we do? Well Jesus said the part of the great commission teach them to observe all things whatever I commanded you. We follow his teachings and his teachings bring to full expression the gracious instruction that God has given us in his law. Do you have questions about this? Yes. Well it serves to form in form all men of the holy nature and will of God and therefore it would refer to society in that the will of God for society is a part of what that does. But actually the larger catechism sort of sets that aside for the moment to look at the function of how the law functions in its scriptural context in its scriptural context you get to get this it informs all all men of the holy nature and will of God and God does use the moral law to inform society of what his will is. But that is that also functions in a natural knowledge of the moral law. I'm going to expand on that later. I think it's an important point but the Westminster devines leave that aside now because primarily we're talking about the scriptural context especially reveal context for the law. And it is given to hump us and you know in this context that's its function. It's not doesn't deny that it informs a society but I'm going to ask the question you know what is the secular use of the decalong that's a different question from what is the civil use of the moral law that is known also by virtue of our constitution as human beings in the image of God. The question is whether the Westminster devines in moving away from that typical schema and developing this one were implicitly criticizing that for because of its deficiencies and I don't know the answer to that question in detail they tended to go their own way and not be so dependent upon formulations that have been in the past. Now it's true in the question of the threefold analysis of the law of Moses they use the standard threefold designation so it would be a good question why did they move away from this I think part of it is because of the debate over the third use of the law. But I don't know for sure be a good research question what what's behind this chain rethinking how to present the same material but in this this context I think that it I think it's extremely helpful for us to have it done this way. So that the law still form has this convicting function for believers but not with a threat so it always informs and humbles that and that's its purpose in a fallen world and you know we are still sinners that are progressively being sanctified so we need to hear that. I think what got me started on this on some one nineteen seventy seventy five I read that and we're not supposed to talk about our I don't know if you were there at gyrms gyrms sermon yesterday but if you didn't you need to get the tape of that use the ceremony on the mount and how our private worship should be the same as our public worship so often what we do in by way of prayer and alms and fasting is all public use of the sermon on the mount for that and really does it match in our heart well that humbles you know I even you had to say at the end of into that sermon the Lord's judgements are right you know they're right but in faithfulness you have humbled me we needed to hear that message I think that this is that's an example of what is doing not that we felt threatened not that we felt guilty it was a searching message but it gave us hope it gave us comfort believe it or not you know we want there's a better way to live and it's possible by God's grace. We're provoked to greater thankfulness and greater zeal to conform ourselves law I think that this works better it also distinguishes what what they're doing is is is thinking through all the implications now after you know about a hundred years they've had to read to thank all this and they they thank that now what what about the unregion what how does it function well to awaken some to their need. To drive them to Christ but if they don't come it leaves them in a worse condition that's also its function to render them inexcusable so that in the last day it can you know that can be held against them as part of the judgment. The Westminster Divines characteristically thank through all the implications the thread is still there to the unregion there's no question about that that's right that that's right notice they they even vary the language what's the particular use to the unregenerate and the particular use the unregenerate is to drive them to Christ what's the special use to the regenerate you know there's a special. It's that you know it's there's something you know heart warming about this use all the credits gone and it shows us how much we're the same same search flight shows us how much we're the same bell that awakens the unregenerate rings in our hearts too but not with the fear. But rather to show us how much we're bound to Christ or or his ability instead I think that it's the more I look at the more I consider this is useful this can be done and we should I did do want you to know about this but I do think that we have in the larger catechism which isn't well known even in the reformers those of you who are not Presbyterians need not think that you know. You're way behind those of us who are because we don't know this either the larger catechism is the orphan of the Westminster standards but here and there it has extremely helpful stuff that's not in the other catechism I think this is one you beat a judge but it shows that God's purpose in giving the law. Okay any other question question is what use does the law have in sanctification especially when we make the strong distinction between its pedagogical use to convict us and to drive us to Christ what's the third use of the law in sanctification I think that we need to remind ourselves that salvation is by grace through faith. That means justification is by grace through faith and it means that sanctification is by grace through faith. Now in sanctification God uses his word the spirit works by and with the word in sanctification and part of the word is the law of God the commands of God. And so the spirit that uses those not the threats of the law because we've been driven to Christ for that so that they're not threatening but the Holy Spirit use works by and with the word we're not sanctified by law sometimes reform theologians have make the mistake of saying we're justified by grace we're sanctified by law that that's a poor way of putting it we're not law has no power to make a lot. There were two problems in first centric Judaism that Paul addresses in Galatians the one was justification by works and he said if if justification is by works then Christ died for nothing you know if we could be justified by our works the other part the other error was sanctification by law the idea was that the law has an inherent power to do the evil impulse in Paul and humanity and to bring the good impulse to fruition the law itself law says if there's been a law that could make a lot if there could be a law that would do that so do the evil impulse and bring the good impulse that salvation would be by the law but it's by the spirit that's in the context where he's talking about the spirit and the necessity of the spirit to enable us to live a life that is pleasing to God. But the standard for a life that's pleasing to God is the same standard that brought us to Christ in the first place the standard of God's perfection and so the Holy Spirit uses that standard to enable us more and more to yield obedience out of a childlike love and a ready mind. I haven't read that sonship but material so I don't know particularly what I may be addressing but that's the way I put it together that sanctification is by grace and the spirit works by and with the word and the all scriptures inspired by God and useful for instruction for correction or review and for training and righteousness. So we accept it and there's a gracious use of the law of God that is non-threatening because we're justified but it does it is a lamp to our feet. I think there is a mistake in Calvin on this point Lutherans make much of this I'm quite satisfied with the idea that we use the figure of a lamp or this third use of the law. The Calvin used the figure of a whip and I just bottle it that if you read it in context and the context is in the text but if you read that you I mean Calvin is aware that the motivation comes by the spirit but why then does he say that the law is a whip as to a bulky ass you know to get us moving if the spirit doesn't get us moving why should we think that the law will get us moving. I think Calvin misspoke I don't think that I find I don't think that I find I don't think that I find that metaphor of a whip in the life of a believer his idea is that we should be serious about this and I agree but I think it's the spirit working buying with the word and the spirit doesn't work by a whip I think that may be part of the mistake when we understand when we look at it that way is the law isn't kind of whip to us beat up on us until we do it that's not God's way it seems to me what we need is more grace not more law. Okay well I think that to provoke us to greater thankfulness is really the special use of the law to believe that you look for a moment at the Ten Commandments in the Church the material that I gave out before let me highlight some things that are in this we should put this as a as a second point the Ten Commandments in I begin actually with Hellenistic Judaism because by law of Alexandria his dates are there you know 20 BC to AD 50 so it's right at the time the New Testament is being formulated right at the time of Christ and he apparently it's the first to use the Ten Commandments as the comprehensive summary for the whole law of Moses so he puts the other laws of Moses under the Ten Commandments he also divides them into two tables his he divided them equal in terms of five and five and the first containing our duties toward God which would include the fifth commandment as duty toward God honor your father and your mother and that is in some respects a transitional commandment because parents do represent God in a unique way in the family so there's there's some rationale for him doing it that way just to have them evenly divided you might think why are there 10 anyway they are comprehensive but my guess is that you know we are we work that way we're we're working on these questions and remembering 10 things on your 10 fingers could be one good way it's done and then by law says five and five not a bad idea but he also recognizes that only those who practice both tables are whole in virtue that is you cannot consider yourself virtuous without love of God as well as lovers of human time of the Dachalog and it's picked up in the early church the first teaching that we have is the Dittike this was wasn't until 1875 that we recovered this and it's unsure how to date it but the opening paragraph expounds the summary of the law to love the Lord your God with all your heart and your neighbor as yourself it in the light of the sermon on the mount and won't go through that but you can see how it is how it expands the Dachalog in the second paragraph it begins with the two twofold commandment of love and then it it uses the Dachalog is a way of organizing that material and then the third paragraph it didn't include here gets to the root sense anger in the lust and so forth it's it's really a remarkable document begins with the what's primary love uses the Dachalog is a way of showing us the norms of love and then searching the root of our sins in these irony is picks up on the Dachalog serial of Jerusalem Augustine but Augustine's treatment is brief Augustine more or less does this in principle and all of the early church fathers use the ten commandments as sort of basic instruction it's the instruction when you first are considering the Christian faith and after that they move to the sermon on the mount now this work is still in progress on this I got interested I was asked to do some lectures last summer on the ten commandments and I did the ten commandments in the Bible and in the church and in contemporary society we'll get to that too but I began to ask you know where is the first exposition of the ten commandments in church history and as I went and I was looking for sermons on the ten commandments or treatises on the ten commandments or catacasms on the ten commandments and you don't find them in the early church the early church expounds the twofold commandment of love recognizes the ten commandments but that's basic instruction we should put that in fact it's what they're saying and they don't use that and they don't use that to organize the material of the Christian life they use rather the sermon on the mount now the content of the moral law is in the sermon on the mount and so it's by way of the exposition of the sermon on the mount with this they say is at a higher level which it is but that was the way the early church did it they there are no to my knowledge there are no expositions of the ten commandments either sermons catacasms or separate treatises in that whole period of the first millennium which is sort of provocative why is that well probably to to because of their understanding of the distinctiveness of the Christian way of life that goes beyond what you can pour into the ten commandments that's likely the reason that they thought that way in any case it's interesting to go through that material but you don't get as far as I know exposition of the ten commandments until you come to the middle ages you may have in commentaries on Exodus or commentaries on Deuteronomy you would expect that there would be some there but I'm thinking in terms of special instruction to the church not commentaries in which in the course of your commentary you would give analysis of the ten commandments but rather instruction to the church that waits to the middle ages page three of my handout following the division of the church east and west in 1054 there was a revival of interest in the decalogue among western theologians Gregory the Great had actually put down the ten commandments in favor of dealing with the instruction in terms of the seven deadly sins and the corresponding virtues but it was Hugh of Saint Victor Hugh of Saint Victor that gave a brief exposition of each commandment and love as the fulfillment of law his institutions Hugh goes institutes about here to be the first of these and as you can see the early 12th century then Hugh directly influenced Peter Lombard Peter Lombard apparently heard those lectures as they were first given then published as his institutes and Peter Lombard included a section on the decalogue in his sentences that was the prime textbook of systematic theology in the middle ages and that was a first that is the inclusion of the decalogue in the systematic exposition of the fate was a first in Peter Lombard then the next point is Alexander of Haley's who was professor at the University of Paris in the 13th century what he did was introduce commentary on Lombard's sentences replacing traditional commentary on the scriptures you've had Lombard's systematic theology goes by the title of sentences the sentences is he used the sentences use quotations from the early church to organize his materials he expanded on it but Lombard's sentences then became the basis for instruction in the university rather than the traditional commentary on the scriptures and that was a key step then it's picked up by Thomas Aquinas who provides a complete account of Christian ethics in including a detail exposition of the decalogue and ever since it has been standard as the way in which we do things but it developed late and the catechetical tradition develops after the 4th Latter-in-Council there is this canon of the 4th Latter-in-Council omnisutrisca all the faithful of both sexes that somebody's called the most important legislative act in the history of the church all the faithful of both sexes after they have reached the age of discretion must confess all their sins at least once a year to their own parish priest and perform to the best of their abilities the penance imposed reverently receiving the sacrament used on Easter Sunday otherwise they shall be cut off from the church during their lifetime and shall be without a Christian burial in death that men became church law and it that's the sacrament of penance it's now called the sacrament of reconciliation but the content is the same it's in in response to that requirement you've got to come to your parish priest every year and confess all your sins how do you want to know what to confess and then the catechisms began to develop and including John Wickliffe's one I've given a couple of lines from Wickliffe's but these were basically at first oriented toward the sacrament of penance and confession and Wickliffe's all is in rhyme they shall have one god and no more or all thing love him also and thy neighbor both friend and foe and so it goes and steal thou not by neighbor's thing with buying selling nor wrong getting anybody wants the whole thing I've got it and also I should say I've got a complete bibliography if you're interested in pursuing this but the end Wickliffe says these are the ten commandments these are the commandments ten that that god gave to all men Michael joy much joy shall be to them that keep well and truly them if you skip down to number seven detrick kolda coming right up to the eve of the reformation and cold as a fruit from mirror or small handbook for christians will give you the tone of where things are at the time of the reformation it was the first print of catechism in german printed nineteen times before fifteen hundred least twenty eight times afterwards and it was to be carried by christians at all times since it contains everything that is necessary for the well-being and salvation of the soul so cold it claim this then became the Bible in effect that you carried with you creed decalogue five commandments of the church seven deadly sins nine alien sins the openly discussed sins the mute sins against nature six sins against the Holy Spirit great sins of the tongue six conditions of forgiveness seven signs of the state of grace repentance confession satisfaction and various devotional instructions and prayers including the paternoster and ava maria how to die the sacrament of penance is of central importance and notice what the paragraph that I've isolated you should know that according to count and law penance we receive from the priest is not sufficient even for the least mortal sin that we have committed therefore it is necessary for us to do even more penance for example by groaning crying out begging help giving arms and he goes on and on that's the legalism that that Luther faced at the beginning of the sixteenth century now that's what that's why the first of the ninety five feces is when christ said repent he did not mean do penance he meant to have this change of heart toward god and his law that leads us to trust in Christ now for Luther's catechism the way they came about is interesting I've given some of the material there quoting the logic of Luther's order the the creed and the Lord's prayer had become standard Luther adds to that the ten commandments so that his catechism is a short form of the ten commandments of the creed and the Lord's prayer the logic of Luther's order decalogue creed boards prayer is our conviction of need through the ten commandments where to find aid exposition of the gospel through the creed and how to ask for it the petitions of the Lord's prayer the interesting thing that I found about Luther's publication of his catechism is that it was first published in poster form to be posted in homes and schools as well as churches and it was an immediate success it sold out immediate and then he published it in in typical book form but it was a it was a very great very great success people were so hungry for something besides these ten potential books like covis and I'll give you an example the after the in the sample treatments of the commandments first you shall have no other gods what does this mean we should fear love and trust in God above all things the fifth commandment in our enumeration the sick you shall not kill what does this mean we should fear love God so we should not endanger our neighbor's life or cause him any harm but help and befriend him in every necessity of life can can can improve it's really it's really it's really set a new standard or catechical material picked up by Calvin said adopted in the in the Anglican catechism and it is the comes to wonderful expression in the Heidelberg catechism this is page seven of my handout Heidelberg catechism begins with the famous question what is your only comfort in life and death that I am not my own but belong body and soul in life and death to my faithful savior Jesus Christ then it goes on to expand on the gospel is fully paid for all my sins with his precious blood set me free from the tyranny of the devil it also watches over me in fact all things must work together for my salvation begins with that great hopeful note and what must you know to live and die in the joy of this comfort first how great my sin and misery are second time set free from all my sins and misery and third how to thank God for such deliverance now the thing about the the Heidelberg catechism is that it it's been a brief period brief number of questions focusing on our our need and misery but then it does the exposition is actually through the exposition of the creed and then our gratitude is expressed in good works and as you can see questions 32 through 115 is where the exposition of the ten commandments comes in in other words the there is a brief section of our sin and misery by the perfect standards of God's word to love Lord with all my heart and my neighbor as myself which we obviously have not done then there's the exposition of the gospel through the creed and then you get to the the dachal log as the way of life that's the the emphasis that it gives to the what's called the third use of the law is is very obviously differs from Luther's conception and and then it takes the Lord's prayer given for comparison say the Heidelberg treatment of the sixth commandment and notice how it gets to the the full attitude that lies behind the commandment I'm not to belittle insult hate or kill my neighbor not by my thoughts my words my look my gesture certainly not by actual deeds and one of six does this commandment for only to killing by forbidding murder God teaches that he hates the root of murder in the hatred anger vindictiveness is it enough that we'd not kill our neighbor in any such way no we must be we'd love our neighbors to be patient peace loving gentle merciful friendly to him protect him from harm as much as we can and to do good even to our enemies now that's the the full exposition of in light of the whole teaching of scripture and particularly read in light of love for our neighbor what is this love require now just just a couple of other notes the as you would expect the these Lutheran reformed catechisms left Roman church at a disadvantage and so Peter Canisius wrote a much better catechism than it had appeared in before the 16th century for Roman Catholic instruction and then the Roman church itself in 1566 published the catechism of the council of Trent for parish priests this was not a catechism to be learned on the part of the people as the reformed catechisms were this was a catechism for the priest to learn what is required of them in their teaching creed sacraments 10 commandments and and lords prayer okay any questions about those those developments by the end of the 16th century the pattern is pretty well said and the Westminster confession is really I think the culmination of those catechetical works yes I think that one reason I do this history is to show that how much western culture has been affected by the 10 commandments I mean now for you know 800 years well and 700 because we don't even in the churches I don't have been teaching the 10 commandments as we we should many of us but I think that you know that for that whole period where that becomes the making ethical instruction organization of the moral law of God on the 10 around the 10 commandments that had its impact on western culture that's undeniable that and that needs to be needs to be taught I have a section on this section e on page 9 the 10 commandments and civil society that I make some of these points I'll go beyond them but next time the new weight one author writes the new way placed on the 10 commandments raise the stakes for magistrates by making it possible to apply the lessons of Israel salvation history to the local territory neglect of God's law held dire political consequences sin and dangers the common goods and magistrates must therefore prevent it as John Husse exhorted kings and princes counts nights and lords should always see that the commandments of God are not broken it is in a way understandable but now with the emphasis on the 5th commandment honor your father and mother applied in its wider sense to civil magistrates then the discipline of the parents becomes it seems the obligation of the state to discipline the community rather than the church where discipline rightly belongs it became the order of the state so a few weeks after hearing a sermon of the 10 commandments in 1452 Duke Willum of Saxony issued an ordinance for the reform of public morality mandating officials to enforce all of these provisions and some of them we may think are appropriate for civil magistrates but others are questionable point to the decalogue in a divided chrysanthem that is in the period after trying to do here was to look first of all when before the reformation this started in the already in the after the reformation the application of honor your father and mother to civil authorities in the reformation was overly paternalistic that's a judgment on my part play toy referred to magistrates as guardians of the law and you get this some twofold guardianship thing and it didn't work very well Calvin at first this is page 10 did not expound the guardian of the two tables doctrine but rather concentrated on the office of the civil magistrate to do justice that the laws the common word well must be in conformity to that perpetual rule of love the key principle which is equity the goal and rule and limits of all laws quote from Calvin it should be clear that the law of God which we call the moral law is nothing else than a testimony of natural law and of that conscience which God has engraved upon men's hearts it's only later that he develops the the two tables doctrine I think we need to sort that out and talk a little bit about that so I wanted to include as a third point the secular use of the decalogue the secular use of the decalogue and I'll I'm going to start that next time but I just to alert you in advance what I understand by the secular use of the decalogue is different from the civil use of the moral law there's a difference between using the decalogue in its redemptive historical context in a secular way and using the moral law that's going to be my thesis we should distinguish between the civil use of the moral law and the secular use of the decalogue the secular use of the 10 command it seems to it seems at first that since the 10 commandments embody in definitive form God's moral law that we ought not to make this distinction I think that I think we run into difficulty unless we do and I really would really think we need to go back to Calvin's original view of the civil magistrates and the principle of equity which the moral law is appropriate for governments today we'll have to start that next time