Father, we agree. We praise you for answered prayer. We ask you to work in these lives and situations that we've brought before you. Thank you for answering our prayers in the past, even in the few weeks that we've been meeting, Lord. It gives us greater occasion to praise you. We thank you, Father. We commit our class time to you tonight. Teach us further about the way you made us. Teach us about sin and its ruinous effects on our lives that we might be quicker to confess our own sins, that we might be burdened to reach unsaved people who are burdened down with the guilt and misery of their own sins, Father, and maybe don't even realize it. Lord, use us to reach the lost. Make this time profitable tonight in your sight. And for our lives, we ask through Jesus Christ, our Lord and Savior, amen. We welcome our students taking this class by videotape and I ask the students here to remind me on the first break to pass out the quizzes for next time. I wouldn't want you to be without. Said the executioner. I mean the teacher to the our goals today are to finish up our discussion of the doctrine of man, especially the nature of human beings in the first hour and then get on and make some real inroads into the doctrine of sin. You remember last time we talked about these really three views, the fourth being a different, giving a different spin to the second. Different views as to the constitutional nature of human beings.
Monism claims that we are indivisible and thus are not made up of any parts. When we die, that's the end of us. There is no separable soul or spirit. This is the view of modern philosophy and theology. For the most part, dichotomy disagrees and says no on the basis of the biblical teaching concerning an intermediate state. We have to affirm that we are made of two parts, a material body and an immaterial spirit or soul. Trichotomy says that's right but we can go one step further. The immaterial part is subdivided in scripture into two separate entities, two separate parts of our makeup, a body soul and a spirit and these are distinguishable in definable ways. Holistic dualism is a modern spin on dichotomy and I'll anticipate my conclusions and tell you that I receive it heartily for it emphasizes that although we are made of two parts, we know that because of what happens at death. So in that sense, I would describe to anthropological dichotomy or dualism, the normal state of affairs is a holistic dualism. Is that body and soul are united together in one? This is the way we were created by God. It's the way we live in the present state. It is the way we will be after the resurrection of the dead and henceforth forever. The only exception is that aberration called death which involves the abnormal separation of our immaterial and material parts. Now God's grace is such that an even conquers death so that Paul could say to be absent from the body for a believer is to be present with the Lord. That is, it is good now in our present state to be alive in the body and to know God. We are forgiven but we are forgiven sinners and the effects of sin are still with us. It is better since Paul says so in Philippians 1 to depart the body and to be with Christ. But the best is yet to come in which will again be unified in body and soul and be able to enjoy the Lord forever. So those are the three positions. Last time we eliminated the monistic position by virtue of our study on page 17 of the notes wherein these three biblical passages, we could multiply passages. Hebrews 12 speaks of the spirits of just men made perfect. That is not speaking of the resurrection of the dead. Revelation 6 speaks of souls under the altar crying out for vengeance from God. It is before the last day and before the resurrection and those human beings are existent separated from their bodies. They have been martyred but there are passages, a number of them which teach the existence of this interim or intermediate existence because of that we disqualify monism. We reject it. Compare the Westminster confession of faith chapter 4 which speaks of creation. Section 2 says God created man male and female with reasonable and immortal souls. There is a notion of immortal souls mean that our spiritual part, our souls, survive bodily death. On to page 18 because now it's a debate between dichotomy and tricotomy and here
I want to look carefully at the two proof texts for tricotomy. I'm convinced if it were not for 1 Thessalonians 5.23 and Hebrews 4.12 there would be no such thing as tricotomy. By the way to anticipate a discussion a little later on you might be asking the so what question? So what? Let's say the tricotomists are wrong and they subdivide us into an extra part. So what? Does it necessarily mean somebody gets into theological or practical trouble? No. Have people gotten into theological and practical trouble by virtue of that division? Yes. Give me some examples you say. Hold your horses I reply. Let's work with these texts and then I will cite names and books and examples of people. In the end I will say you could be a fine Bible believe in Christian and hold a tricotomy as long as you do with your tricotomy what the Bible does with it which is nothing. Well if it does nothing with it should that not make me question that distinction? Well I think so but if you're an inactive tricotomist and don't build a doctrine of the Christian life upon it it could end up being a harmless distinction but let's look at these two texts and see if they really do teach that we are made up of two immaterial entities that there are distinctions in the Bible at times between spirit and soul I don't deny and nobody needs to deny but tricotomy says much more than that tricotomy says these are separate constituents of our being they are divisible parts of human nature. So I'm not saying soul and spirit are always absolutely identical although I can show you some context in which it looks like that to me but I'm not saying they're always identical and they may well be distinguished in these two passages but the question is do these passages intend to teach that they are distinct entities of our makeup it seems to me the best answer to that is no first Thessalonians 5 after some final instructions we have a wish prayer may God himself the God of peace sanctify you through and through may your whole spirit soul and body be kept blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ the one who calls you is faithful and he will do it brothers pray for us greet all the brothers with a holy kiss I charge you before the Lord to have this letter read to all the brothers the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you please give attention to page 18 of the notes Paul has completed a list of practical expectations in the previous verse he now uses two optitives I'm sorry to speak Greek he uses two unusual verbal forms in Greek to express a wish prayer we can talk about different types of literature within the New Testament there are gospels there's a book of Acts there are letters and there's an apocalypse okay within those four genres there are sub genres and a wish prayer is such a thing it is both a combination of an expression of good will for somebody else hence wish but it's also at the same time it's an expression of good will but it's directed toward God in the form of a prayer hence the designation wish prayer ff Bruce in the word biblical commentary on first esolonians sites more of this including a reference which I have forgotten to somebody's dissertation on this whole matter if you're really interested in pursuing it further Paul offers up a wish prayer for the Thessalonian Christians he prays that God might sanctify them that's the first verb verse 23 and the middle of the verse he says that it he prays that it might be kept it is their whole spirit soul and body Paul puts the word God up front and even uses a form that causes him to underline it as it were and hence the NIV translates may God himself the emphasis is on God God's doing what Paul is praying and by the way there's guarantee verse 24 the one who calls you is faithful and he will do it so this is not a wish in the sense of our wishing somebody will okay or hoping against hope no there's real confidence here in the apostles prayer the wish prayer of 5 23 24 can be profitably compared with an earlier one that we find at the end of chapter 3 for the sake of time let me just summarize okay each of these points can be proved so this is not speculation or anything each begin with with a himself reference each follow it with a reference to God himself including Christ in the first place third both use the same verbal form to express the actual wish prayer 4th both speak of holiness and 5th both end on an eschatological note they both go to the future okay what's the big deal of that nothing although I will be back to it later on I'll just note in passing in the earlier wish prayer Paul prayed may God strengthen your hearts so that you will be blameless and holy in the presence of our God and Father when our Lord Jesus comes with all his holy ones just tuck away in the back of your mind this reference to hearts okay Paul had earlier said important things about sanctification in first Thessalonians now he prays so he gave instructions about sanctification for example chapter 4 this is the will of God for you your sanctification or NIV that you should be sanctified that you should avoid sexual immorality in particular is the aspect of sanctification he speaks of there now he gave instructions about it earlier now he prays that God would bring about this sanctification concerning which Paul had taught earlier he asks God to consecrate the Thessalonians verse 23 of chapter 5 holy the word means through and through may God himself the God of peace consecrate sanctify or make you holy through and through this prayer for sanctification is so important to the apostle that he basically repeats in another sentence the thought just expressed what I'm trying to say is the two sentences the second one doesn't add a whole lot of new information it's more of a reinforcement of the first although they're not identical but it's a reinforcement of the same idea he prays this time that the Thessalonians would be kept obviously by God blamelessly until the Lord Jesus comes again he expands on the concept of verse 23 of the first part of his readers being holy sanctified there he prayed may God himself sanctify you holy or through and through okay now he amplifies that he says may your whole spirit soul and body be kept blamelessly understand through and through or holy now becomes opened up and now it becomes your whole spirit soul and body you say I get it it's more emphasis it's giving more detail exactly
he prays that their whole spirit soul and body might be preserved blamelessly at the coming of the Lord Jesus your whole spirit soul and body is an expansion of holy Paul asks that God might keep the Thessalonians in the entirety of their beings at the time Christ comes again his emphasis is on the unity of their persons even those who would who would appeal to this as proof for tricotomy ought to agree with this because it's not speculation or anything his emphasis is clearly on the unity of their persons why do I say that because the verb is singular may it be kept so he's viewing them holistically may your whole spirit soul and body viewed as a unit be kept blamelessly furthermore the adjective whole is also singular the emphasis is on the entirety of their beings rather than on their individual parts nevertheless we must admit their whole beings are spoken of by listing various aspects of human nature some would say parts well in fact there are at least two parts man is body soul and spirit body refers to our material part spirit and soul either refer to two more parts or together they refer to our immaterial part I certainly acknowledge some difference between spirit and soul in this text okay although it is easier to say that than to biblically define it and the definitions I read last time from the new scofial reference Bible which takes a tricotomy position in the definitions of soul and spirit do not hold up to a complete induction in scripture as we'll see in a couple of pages you could do it selectively the only way to make it work is by excluding quite a bit of the evidence and say it works here and it works there but it doesn't work in these other places I don't think we ought to do our word studies that way but in any case I do not think that two distinct constituents of human nature are implied here any more than by similar expressions of man's total being in both testaments for example in Deuteronomy 64 Paul says Israel hero Israel the Lord our God the Lord is one love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength did he intend for us to understand heart and soul as different aspects of our being no you say you're missing the point it's his way of saying love the Lord your God with all that you are in half but he communicates that in that beautiful it's not poetic but it's beautiful prose by expanding exactly I agree my contention is it's it's the same type of thing that he's doing in first esolonians five or how about Jesus words in which he refers back to Deuteronomy and says love the Lord your God with all your heart with all your soul and with all your mind Matthew 22 37 it's listed in the notes there did Jesus really intend for us to say that we have three immaterial parts heart soul and mind no you say it was never intended it's a way of emphasizing by listing aspects of our makeup I agreed completely why do we do it in one place and not in another maybe we should be tetra-cottomists and have four parts if you pushed this way of interpreting the Bible well what the others think FF Bruce comments on this verse in the commentary I mentioned at the top of page 18 quote it is precarious to construct a tri-part tight a three-part doctrine of human nature on the juxtaposition the putting right next to each other of the three nouns pneuma psuke is actually the wrong Greek letter I'm embarrassed it should be a pussy rather than a fee if you're knowledgeable of the Greek alphabet and soma that's spirit soul and body the three together give further emphasis to the completeness of sanctification for which the writers pray actually Paul Silas and Timothy according to first I'm sorry yes Paul Silas and Timothy according to the first verse of the letter the three together give further emphasis to the completeness of sanctification for which the writers pray but the three together add but little to the sense of your hearts in three thirteen the distinction between the bodily and spiritual aspects of human nature is easily made I might add in my own brackets if you will from other scriptures but to make a comparable distinction between spirit and soul is forced he says his point is it was not intended by Paul it is a beautiful literary way even as the other passages I cited say love the Lord your God with all you are and have this says God will sanctify you completely in the totality of your being notice two bottom of eighteen moving on the nineteen now Bruce's comparison of your hearts from the wish prayer in chapter three with body soul and spirit from this wish prayer where would heart fit in a tricotimus view of human nature you say it wouldn't he never intended that in chapter three well then why is he intended now in chapter five so here is my claim that our tricotimus brothers and sisters are making a mistake they are sort of literalizing the Bible and missing the all the purpose of the language which is rather to make an emphasis in the toward the entirety of our sanctification and not to give us a list of entities of immaterial entities comments or questions from you then let's go to Hebrews four often I have found we students have just maybe if they were taught tricotimus it just was done in kind of a dogmanic way by simply reading the verse and saying well Hebrews 4-12 says separation of soul and spirit that proves it right man what else could it mean I find a careful examination indicates indeed it could mean something else and that it does in fact Hebrews 4 the writer of the epistle to the Hebrews has been warning his readers of the danger of disobedience in the preceding context in verse four he speaks of God's word oh Hebrews 4-1 I'm just going to read a little snatch from here and there in the middle of that verse let us be careful that none of you be found to have fallen short of it the promise of entering God's rest and then verse 11 let us therefore make every effort to enter that rest so that no one will fall by following their example of disobedience if I had taken Hebrews 4-12 out of this context not giving you the reference giving you the verse you would be a pretty good bible student if you could put it in the context in your mind because it is one that is often just ripped out and of course we shouldn't do that for the word of God notice the prep of the conjunction 4-4 the word of God is living and active sharper than any double edged sword it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit joints and marrow it judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart nothing in all creation is hidden from God's sight everything is uncovered and laid bare before the eyes of him to whom we must give account how do these verses fit in the context well the word of God is the further described here whoops I'm skipping down I want to be in that first paragraph 1119 in verse 12 the writer to the Hebrews speaks of God's word being able to penetrate to the depths of a person's being to reveal disobedience within don't be faithless don't be disobedient and he says for here is God's instrument to root here's God's spiritual x-ray machine if you will to search us out in the nooks and crannies of our hearts God's word will expose disobedience God's word will expose faithless lack of faith understand that seems to be the contextual tie-in okay five adjectives to describe the word in terms of this dynamic heart searching function I don't claim all the five are identical but they're not totally different either they are five ways of saying something pretty similar and again the five are given by way of emphasis he begins for the word of God is living and active God's word is here spoken of as dynamic or living alive and active means powerful that is it is able to accomplish the purposes for which God uttered it compare Isaiah 55 God's word doesn't return to him empty or void without accomplishing the purposes for which he sent it it's the powerful word of the living God the word of God is further described as sharper than any double edged sword in that it pierces human beings both without and within the word is able to penetrate the human heart and disclose any disobedience lurking there contextual interpretation it pierces to the division of soul and spirit that's how minutely it works and it penetrates to the separation of joints and marrow here is God's instrument for really getting deep inside of us are we to understand these two pairs of nouns as designating the constituents of man's non-material makeup soul and spirit and material makeup joints and marrow enhance parts on each side non-material parts and material parts one may say yes indeed and give us evidence the fact that joints and marrow are indeed distinctive entities in our bodily makeup one immediately encounters a difficulty however there are many other parts of man's physical being skin bones and so forth joints and marrow do not exhaustively describe man's material position composition rather it seems to be used as that which is very hard to separate some commentators think that it is a reference to the priestly function in the preparing of sacrifices and an experienced priest similar to an experienced butcher could make that cut you and I might hack away at the sacrifice for quite a while and saw I try to try to do it properly and the experience priestly just go chump and do the job perhaps that's the background as far as the terminology goes in any case here it's used of human beings and it's used of a very delicate if you will a very tiny separation furthermore our text goes on to describe the word of God as able to judge the thoughts and the liberation of the heart the word of God is living it's active it's sharper it penetrates and fifthly it judges it judges the thoughts and deliberations of the heart how does heart cardia is a Greek word relate to soul and spirit is man composed of three non-material entities they know that was never intended and you're missing the point oh I agree with that statement it is safer to regard the division of soul and spirit as quoting ff Bruce in another commentary rhetorical accumulation of terms to express the whole being of man that is similar to first accellonians it's rhetoric it's a way of speaking there to speak of the total holiness God will give us here to speak of the of the delicate divisions that the word can pierce unto the point is quoting ff I'm sorry filip edge commu's in his commentary and he was the point is quote that no separation could be more intimate than that between soul and spirit or between joints and marrow end of quotation the penetrating word of God is able to judge our inmost thoughts quote it probes the inmost recesses of our spiritual being and brings the subconscious motives to light exactly the point in the context well said thoughts and deliberations are not to be construed as minute differentiations of the mental life of human beings they are virtually synonymous and describe further the searching qualities of God's word the next verse goes on to tell how all creation is open and laid bare to God's eyes nothing is hidden from him in context again to emphasize the reader is urging the writer is urging his readers to obedience by describing God's intimate knowledge of the human heart questions or comments yes if tricotomists agree that this is a very minute separation okay a very these are very hard thanks to separate so that no human being could separate soul from spirit only God could do it presumably something like that wouldn't that contradict wouldn't that be a contradiction no it wouldn't have to be a contradiction of their own theology they could say this is in fact it indicates that they are separable parts but very hard to separate so it wouldn't necessarily be that and furthermore I don't mean to overstate the case they could get the point of both of these passages so that's not the problem the problem is when in my estimation when they take these this rhetorical accumulation of terms here or very similar in Thessalonians and not only indicate understand them that way but further literalize them as if they were giving a schematic of our immaterial life and saying that these are different constituents or parts of our makeup it doesn't seem to be the intention the definitions that the Schofial reference Bible gives or nowhere given in the Bible nowhere do we have so in spirit this distinguished and defined in some type of way this is that these are the this is the basis for making a distinction it looks to me like an inadequate basis for making a theological distinction in terms of parts yes the point is made that this passage speaks of the word of God meaning the scriptures may be especially preached but that Christ is also in oh John 1 and 1st John 1 and revelation 19 spoken of as the word of God and in the gospels we have records of Christ dealing with people even especially his opponents and he is able to read their hearts and so forth and the comment is made is this not a demonstration in the incarnate word of the of the heart searching function of the word spoken of here I agree heartily it's a perceptive comment I know you weren't saying I don't think so that it speaks of Christ here I don't I don't believe that it does other comments or questions about trichotomy yes comment is made about 1st Corinthians 12 and spiritual gifts I don't understand their gifts that are given by the Holy Spirit that's why their spiritual gifts it doesn't especially tie in with either spirit or soul per se spiritual gifts are they're gifts given by the Holy Spirit to the body of Christ especially to individual members of the body to contribute to the life of the body and so I don't see that per se okay before I point to passages problematic for trichotomy I hinted earlier at errors I feel even bad criticizing some of these people because they have far more good than bad and the things they've said but there have been examples throughout Christian history especially more recent history of abuses along these lines I'll say what I said again I'll repeat it why I said before again you could be a trichotomist and be a perfectly spiritual Christian and not get into any trouble with it okay as long as you didn't build a doctrine of the Christian life upon it where some people have they've gotten astray examples the godly even martyr for Christ so I say that first watch me knee taught a doctrine of the Christian life that involved the epitome was releasing the spirit this is simply not what the Bible teaches as the epitome of the Christian life how about Bill gofford his institutes for basic use conflicts have helped many people my wife and I went once and we profited but I am told on good authority by pastor friends who have gone to his pastor seminars that there is teaching bill holes to trichotomy he does things with it and ends up with a teaching on marriage that is potentially destructive of the marriage marriage relation of view of spiritual marriage that downplays the physical aspects of marriage and if you think you understand what I'm implying you are right bill seems to have the gift of singleness himself and he doesn't need a wife okay the Bible acknowledges that such a thing for him to discourage husbands and wives to enjoy sexual intercourse in the name of a view of spiritual marriage is runs a foul first Corinthians 7 where couples are encouraged to frequently enjoy each other in that way and in the context of abstaining in order to devote themselves to prayer and so forth but be careful as you be tempted and so forth I mean actually a little encouragement to frequent to marital relations in that way uh pentecostal pastor friends have told me of an older teaching they abandoned that was based upon a trichotomist view of human nature whereby the deep teaching of the holy spirit was given directly to the human spirit bypassing the mind and so I know a man who's a pastor he said at at that time in his ministry he would not study the Bible for hours instead he would pray for hours seeking these deep things the spirit to be impressed directly immediately upon his human spirit bypassing his mind now he says he wouldn't blame on the holy spirit what he said in his messages in those days he's a godly man and not afraid to laugh at himself I could tell you further stories but I won't they don't pertain to this class what a good fellow but he says now he does pray and he keeps praying but he also prays while he studies and looks for the Holy Spirit to guide him as he studies the word of God Charles Solomon is a psychologist Bible teacher who likewise make some distinctions and ends up with what we call a chesic theology of the Christian life kind of a let go and let God approach which has some good things to it certainly God is the primary actor in the Christian life but the New Testament pictures of the Christian life do not encourage us to let go think of the images of farmer of athlete and of soldier those people don't let go they work hard and we too are to work hard at the Christian life under God's Lordship and trusting utterly in his power again I'll say it people holding these views don't have to get into error one of the abiding concerns of my own studying the Bible's teaching teachings for years now it's not only to know what the Bible teaches but to know why it teaches what it teaches when you study the doctrine of X doctrine of predestination why does the Bible give that doctrine minister it and use that doctrine for the purposes God gave it originally and you'll be safe you'll be protected from harm if we all consistently follow this it would even blunt the effects of our errors because if we kept within the function of scripture I call it we would be much safer in any case the Bible never uses try economy I think it doesn't even teach it but it never uses it to build a teaching on the Christian life when we come back from our break we will briefly survey some passages that are problematic for try economy and then get on with the doctrine of sin let us take a break