<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Tnabar Tnabar Kull Xahar

"In Order that You May Believe": Johannine Theology

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Do you remember, I think I showed you guys a map, like a third week of class or something like that, of the diaspora that is the Jewish population around the Mediterranean world, and you'll remember that there's basically points that go all the way to Rome and actually somewhat beyond, but especially to Rome and come all the way via Greece and to Asia Minor, certainly Palestine, obviously, but in the Babylon as well, and then on through to Egypt and across to areas that used to be called like Sirenica and stuff into the areas that we would associate with Libya today. So basically, if you think of the whole Mediterranean, it was ringed by a population of Jewish people and on into Babylon in the Mesopotamian area. And so when you get to Acts 2, you find Jewish people coming from every nation under heaven, is how he describes it, Acts 2, 5, there were Jews living in Jerusalem, devout men from every nation under heaven, and then he goes off to list them, and in verses 9 and following, you have Parthians, Meeds, and Elimites, and residents of Mesopotamia. So that's all that area heading out to what we would have once called Babylon. Judea and Cappadocia, Pontus, and Asia, he's coming across Asia Minor now, Frigian, Pemphilia, and then he goes south, Egypt and the districts of Libya around Sireen, and visitors from Rome, both Jews and Praselites. Cretans and Arabs, we hear them in our own tongues speaking of the mighty deeds of God. Now that's a list of the people and then they're of course hearing the apostles and the disciples speaking in the tongues of all these different languages.

What you have there, obviously he explicitly even says Jews and Praselites, so you have the Jewish diaspora, and the people who because of the Jewish diaspora have been convinced that the Jewish religion was the right religion, and so you have Gentiles who had converted to Judaism and likely even just God-fearers there as well. And so of course they raised the question of all these people drunk, because what's going on is just so incredibly wacky. Peter's approach is to quote the Old Testament, and especially to quote three main passages of the Old Testament, and this parallels various sermonic forms that are known in ancient Judaism. It's not identical in all aspects, but it parallels it. And then he starts off with a prophetic text, and often Jewish sermons, there's some evidence from fairly early on, would start with a prophetic reading. There would be a set group of readings, if you would, for particular days of the year, much like if you're in a Episcopalian tradition, or you're in a high church tradition that uses electionary, that uses a regular set of readings every day of the year. Well, that's possibly what was going at this point in Judaism, and they would often start off again with a reading from the prophets and eventually get to a reading from the law, and in the process they might very well go through the Psalter. Now what you have going on here is something akin to that except that he doesn't actually end on a reading from the Pentateuch. But he starts off with this reading from the book of Joel, and he reads through the book of Joel. Now I want to highlight some of the kind of theological themes that are going on here again for Luke, and in Luke Acts. Now that's not to say that those weren't the themes that were going on in Peter. Certainly, historically, this is what Peter's conveying. But Luke is also necessarily in telling about 20 years of church history and 28 chapters. He's having to focus on certain particular events, and in focusing on those, he's drawing out themes that again are consonant with his infacies. If you look at the passage of Joel that is quoted at the beginning of Acts chapter 2, it is fairly surprising because there's parts of it that are clearly tied into what's going on, the phenomenon that are actually going on in front of them, namely the Holy Spirit, giving utterance to God's people. But then he doesn't shut up. It's kind of like, you know, Peter, why didn't you just quote the one verse that clearly was tied in? Why do you keep talking? Okay, so let me read it. Quote starts in chapter 2 verse 17. And it shall be in the last days, God says, that I will pour forth of my Spirit upon all mankind. Okay, we've seen that, pouring forth of the Spirit. And your sons and your daughters shall prophesy and your young men shall see visions and your old men shall dream dreams. That's a little unclear whether visions and dreams and prophecy is specifically what's going on in the utterances that are in the foreign languages that the apostles and disciples are giving. There's certainly points of contact. Basically the idea is the Holy Spirit comes upon people and they start talking. And so you see that tie in. So so far we're all right, doing all right. Even upon my bond slaves, that is my slaves, both men and women, I will in those days pour forth of my Spirit and they shall prophesy. We're doing fine all right. And then he goes on because this is how Joel goes on. And I will grant wonders in the sky above and signs on the earth beneath blood and fire and vapor of smoke. The sun shall be turned into darkness and the moon into blood before the great and glorious day of the Lord shall come. Now wait a second. I'm trying to remember in Acts chapter 2 just exactly where it was that the moon turned to blood and all of that. Can anybody put your finger on the verse? Sun darkness? No. Well that's a trick. But then afterwards of course we can affirm this and it shall be that everyone who calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved. Well he's proclaiming salvation and that's where he's going. So maybe those two verses in between about the wonders in the sky, etc. All of that is a little kind of off the point. But he wanted to go from the spirits outpouring to the salvation offered to all of mankind. You guys, does that make sense to you? It makes me a little uncomfortable. I think we actually have a bit of a clue here in two respects. First if we look at the very first clause in this quotation and secondly if we realize that we're not just dealing with the book of Acts here, but we're looking at Luke Acts, all right. So the very first clause in the quotation sheet says and it shall be in the last days God says. By invoking that clause Peter is effectively saying right now here at Pentecost you are in the Eschaton. The Eschaton has started. You are in the last days. Now having read Ladd through as much as you guys have at this stage, that shouldn't come as much of a surprise to you because you'll remember that Ladd kind of stakes out a mediating position between the idea that the Eschatology is a holy future event and the idea that Eschatology is holy a present event in the early church. The idea of realized Eschatology. We're in the last days and everything's happening now. Crisis is returning. It's going to happen any second. So just wait for a few days and then we'll be with the Lord and glory. That's the view of kind of a realized eschatological position. Ladd stakes out a position in between which is deemed as you may know inaugurated Eschatology, where the last days have begun but they have yet to reach their consummation. And I want to say that if you take that view and I think that's a consistent view throughout Luke and Acts as well and works very well for this material, then when Peter proclaims that we are in the last days, he's effectively saying, as I mentioned before, that the last days have begun. They've been initiated. They've been inaugurated and we wait a future consummation. Now if you start with that and then you go back to this idea of the sun being turned to darkness and signs on wonders in the sky above and signs on the earth beneath and you think of the gospel of Luke, is there any place that happens in the gospel of Luke? Sun turning to darkness? It's mentioned in the Olivet discourse. It's mentioned in kind of the future eschatine, so it's mentioned there, so we expect that event in the future and at the crucifixion where the sun is actually turned to darkness. And in that respect then, I want to say that what goes on then in kind of the whole flow of Luke is that Jesus is death and resurrection inaugurates the eschatine. The sun did turn to darkness as a kind of preliminary foretaste of the events that will lead up to the consummation of the eschatine when Christ comes back to judge all people of the nations.

If you see it in those terms then you start looking at the rest of the events in this passage of Joel then I would argue and I admit that not everybody would follow me here but I would argue that what's going on then is this pouring out of the spirit on mankind is again evidence that the eschatine has been inaugurated and people are prophesying etc etc but the fullness of the spirit has yet to come in the sense that everyone will partake of the spirit and it will be as if God's community is a spirit encamped community in a fuller sense than we can expect even now and then finally the other aspect of this kind of inaugurated eschatology is in verse 21 and it shall be that everyone who calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved. Well the salvation is now and future and again this is fairly consistent with what's going on in Luke. Salvation means right now I am brought into a new relational status before God and yet the full evidence of salvation is again when it has to do with one's eternal state and the eternal state of all of God's people. All right so I want to view this whole Joel passage as in the context of inaugurated eschatologies the last days have begun. Again not everybody would follow me on that but I think that that's a helpful way to view the beginning of Peter's sermon. Now having said that and having thus given a rationale for the phenomenon that people are seeing in front of them that the last days have come the spirits being poured out so now's the time to hear the call of salvation. Peter then goes on. Many of Israel listen to these words Jesus the Nazarene, a man attested to you by God with miracles and wonders and signs which God performed through him and your midst just as you yourselves know. Each clause as we go through the rest of this this this this sermon is so extremely well constructed. He's basically going to tie into the very recent experience of these people who within less than 60 days have actually known and experienced Jesus in their midst and he's going to remind them of the facts again that we know from the gospel of Luke that Jesus was attested by God through the miracles, wonders and signs which God performed through him and your midst and you guys know this. This man delivered up by the predetermined plan and foreknowledge of God you nailed to a cross by the hands of Godless man and put him to death. Now we did that last time noting the indictment therein primarily of the Jewish people because that's the people to whom Peter is speaking there but also bringing in the Gentiles as responsible and ultimately God himself as having foredained all of this. And then here's the other thing that I want you to note and I would encourage you to look through all the speeches of Acts and try and find common elements. One of the elements you'll find is the death of Jesus the other element that you will find is right here in verse 24 and God raised him up again putting an end to the agony of death since it was impossible for him to be held in its power. The resurrection of Jesus. And then he's going to spend the bulk of the rest of the sermon arguing for the resurrection. This sermon is not principally about the death of Jesus which certainly everybody would have admitted to right in front of him because they just experienced it. This sermon is primarily about Jesus's resurrection and that's actually fairly consistently true throughout the rest of the book of Acts. For David says of him, I was always beholding the Lord of my presence for he is at my right hand that I may not be shaken. Therefore my heart was glad of my tongue exalted, moreover my flesh also will abide in hope because thou wilt not abandon my soul to Hades nor allow thy holy one to undergo to K. That was made known to me the ways of life, thou wilt make me full of gladness with thy presence. Now here comes his argument. Brother and I may confidently say to you regarding the patriarch David that he both died and was buried and his tomb is with us to this day. And so because he was a prophet and knew that God had sworn to him an oath to seat one of his descendants upon a throne and there's a very quick citation of the Old Testament. He looked ahead and spoke of what the resurrection of the Christ that he was neither abandoned to Hades nor did his flesh suffer to K and there he goes back to verse 27 quoting from the Psalter there. So he's saying that David, how could this be true of David? You won't abandon my soul to Hades. How could that be true? The Holy One to undergo to K. It can't be because he's buried to this day. So this merst referred to great David's greater sign. You know that we worked through some of the Old Testament passages about six or seven weeks ago and saw how frequently this theme of what David says, David actually says of the whole Davidic line culminating in the Messiah who is great David's greater son and that's what's going on here. This Jesus God raised up again to which we are all witnesses. Now note in that context again Peter's not just saying take it on my authority. He then like pointing out to this whole community of people who have just been speaking in tongues and saying we're all witnesses of this. If you want to check the facts come to us, we're eyewitnesses. And so there's this recognition in the sermon and throughout the book of Acts that the resurrection needs evidence and it needs evidence primarily from people who have actually witnessed Jesus risen from the dead. And so he asserts that. It's not you know just take this on on the word of one or two. It's it's recognized that we have evidence for this this resurrection claim. They're for having been exalted to the right hand of God and of course that ties into the ascension theme in Luke and Acts and having received from the Father the promise of the Holy Spirit. He has poured forth that which you both see in here. And that goes back to the promise that Jesus makes in the beginning in Acts chapter one. For it was not David who ascended to heaven but he himself says the Lord said to my Lord sit in my right hand until I make thine enemies a footstool for their feet. This is another passage that Jesus himself quotes earlier in the gospel showing that there's two lords. There's the Lord God Almighty and then there's this other Lord that David also calls Lord who then is going to have everything under his feet and everything's going to be in support nation to him. Therefore let all the House of Israel know for certain that God has made him both Lord and Christ. This Jesus whom you crucified. Now my translation here puts a subtitle in right there as if that was kind of the end of the sermon. It's the end of the the prolonged quotation from Peter but it was natural in synagogues and in Jewish context for people to respond by asking questions. They did it all the time with Jesus' ministry. So we're not really at the end of what Peter has to say. So the people appears to the heart and said to Peter and the rest of the Apostles brethren what should we do and then Peter gets back into the fray and he says repent and let each of you be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of sins of your sins and you so receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is for you and your children and for all who are far off as many as the Lord our God shall call to Himself. Now what's very interesting in that phrasology is you and your children. Where does he get that from? This promise of the Holy Spirit. Well Joel chapter 2 that he quoted at the very beginning, I will pour forth of my spirit upon all mankind and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy and then he draws the conclusion from that that promises for you and your children, your sons and your daughters and all who are far off hence all mankind as many as the Lord our God shall call to Himself. What's so interesting about that is that Peter is effectively acknowledging the universal extent of the gospel even though the church didn't really truly recognize that until you're about halfway through the book of Acts and Gentiles are beginning to been brought into the fold okay but he recognizes the universal extent and with many other words he solemnly testified and kept on exhorting them saying be safe in this perverse generation and then the result is that about 3000 souls came to the Lord in that day. Now I want to say that in this we have to recognize two things in this one is this is a culturally appropriate sermon he is addressing a particular audience namely an audience of Jewish people largely Jewish people some proselytes who are in place in Jerusalem shortly after the death of Jesus therefore he did not need to emphasize as much the death of Jesus they recognize that he did need to emphasize the resurrection so there is some cultural appropriateness to to what he's saying however there are some elements that you then also find to be common throughout the speeches of Acts namely the element of acknowledging Jesus's death acknowledging this as part of the plan of God in Scripture and of emphasizing the resurrection of Jesus and if you go through and study the sermons and acts that is true of almost everyone the major exception is when you get to Acts chapter 17 he doesn't quote Scripture as much Paul in Athens because he's dealing with a Gentile philosopher group that doesn't understand Scripture as much so he actually starts in some other places but even there he emphasizes the death of Jesus and the resurrection of Jesus and you'll know from our discussions at the very beginning of class years well years ago it seems now weeks ago that the stoic and epicurean philosophers naturally responded you know laughing about the teaching of the resurrection but it was so important to the proclamation of the gospel that Paul couldn't back down from that so I remind us again that the resurrection is very much part and parcel of our proclamation of the gospel the other aspect of the proclamation of the gospel is this call to repentance baptism and forgiveness that is part of the proclamation of the early church and that's something that we need to recognize as well repentance baptism and forgiveness is what is being offered in the gospel so you see that now I want to use that as kind of a paradigm then for the rest of the sermons and I've already alluded to Acts 17 and Athens it you couldn't get two cultural contexts that were any different in the ancient world Jewish people in Jerusalem on the day of Pentecost and Greek philosophers and Athens and so it is particularly illuminating to study how the two sermons are crafted and how they are inculturated into the group that there's being talked about too but also how they are all contain certain common elements including the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus and I would submit to you that that is a great model for our spreading of the gospel culturally appropriate communication so that people hear what we have to say and yet staying true to the the very core of the gospel Jesus's death and resurrection the call to repentance faith in him forgiveness of sins ultimately then bringing people into the church through baptism had they not been baptized before all right do you guys have any questions about that that's kind of a a homily it also finishes up our Luke Acts lectures before we pray here but do you have any questions or thoughts concerns care this test is common among some groups listening strictly to speaking of the prophesy and in Acts comparing it in Acts that as you happen then and then it continues on to happen where do we stay in as far as the culture then they stop there and I know we talked about the resurrection and the baptism is all about the homie goes I mean but I'm not all aware of it because there's a lot on the home coast for this study that has to consider the resurrection and the baptism and the forgiveness of sins and inviting people to come out to the community so it seems like it's a sin context of some of the things that people talk about the invisible truth and I'm just not sure what we need to be focusing on more of the resurrection of Acts as we give us on the Holy Spirit out to come from the field just in that situation of culture and continue on yeah well it's a great question Carol and I'm thinking okay how do I do about two or three lectures worth in two minutes here it's I mean it's very big I'm actually kind of feeling like the president at the press conference you know where he's asked a question about foreign policy that involves about five different nations and try and boil it down into a nice little something that'll make it in the paper there's a range of views on prophecy today there are some who who would argue that a prophecy in the full sense that you find in the New Testament continues and by that they mean foretelling predictive utterances that are in some sense binding on the church because they're clearly coming from the Holy Spirit the other extreme would argue for a full cessation of prophecy because for instance the in the book of Ephesians the the church is founded on the apostles and the prophets so the the apostles and the prophets were necessary for the foundation of the church but once that foundation was laid then one could build an edifice on top of that via other gifts for the church which in the context and Ephesians would include evangelists and pastors and teachers so that's the other end of the spectrum you got you know fully seized and prophetic as as a form of revelation in between positions consider prophecy in different ways for instance one could hold that prophecy in the early church was more important than it was for that it would ever be for us today because they simply did not have the New Testament canon we have a fuller scripture because we have the scripture that has been produced by the apostles and by the apostolic band through the prophetic inspiration of the Holy Spirit so we have a fuller sense of revelation therefore we do not need a another revelatory experience that is viewed as revelation per se but in saying that one could also hold that it is possible that God through his Holy Spirit can produce prophecy even in the form of foretelling in his church as long as we do not then consider that to be revelation on par with scripture and therefore something that Christians ought to obey there's not an ought there there is a information that's coming to the church that way so there's another position a final position which is similar to the one that Wayne Grudem holds for instance in his his book on prophecy is to argue that the definition of prophecy needs more nuance than that the prophecy isn't just foretelling that prophecy is basically any kind of inspired utterance given by the Holy Spirit and that could be a word of encouragement it could be a a simple bringing to mind of a particular scripture in a particular context that's done by the Holy Spirit in a way that can't truly be humanly explained otherwise and so he would argue that that's the definition of prophecy that's going on there's some problems with Wayne Grudem's work but I'm closer to that personally and then I want to understand prophecy is having a broader set of aims than mere foretelling and I would do that based on what prophecy looks like in the Old Testament principally prophecy in the Old Testament though it does have foretelling at aims it's clearly produced by the Holy Spirit but it's often directed to the exact historical circumstances that people write then and there and he's speaking to the circumstances and really just correctly apprising the the circumstances in light of the Holy Spirit if that's the case then I'm inclined to allow the definition of prophecy to be much more broad than just foretelling now I have colleagues within the PCA for instance who would argue a very strong cessation is position I also want to say that we do need to take into account the change in the

history of redemption between the first century church and the church that we have today there is a sense in which we already do have a foundation and it's primarily an apostolic foundation it's primarily found in the revelation of scripture so I very much do not want to say that there is revelation today I would not want to use that term because as soon as I say revelation then I'm going to say it's an authoritative word from the Holy Spirit that has to be obeyed by all of God's people or by all the people that it impinges upon and I'm not sure that we can proclaim that oughtness to it because of the change in the position we're in in the history of redemption so I'm going to go there am I answering your question Carol is that more long lines

yeah well and I think we have to recognize that what's going on also in the book of Acts when he quotes Joel the Holy Spirit's ministry is much broader than mere prophecy in the rest of the New Testament canon old Testament as well but especially the New Testament canon and to then focus on prophecy only because Joel focuses on it is to not then do benefit to all of what the Holy Spirit does in gifting people in a variety of callings within the church including such seemingly mundane tasks as administration which is one of the the tasks that specifically mentioned in I believe it's Romans and and so the Holy Spirit we have to say is working in the church but maybe we look too often to the splashy things that the Holy Spirit could be doing instead of acknowledging the Holy Spirit working through the most mundane aspects of the of the church to bring its in unity under the body of Christ to to the Lord and to his glory so I want to affirm that as well so I think there are imbalances that can happen and one imbalance I would say is I just be cut a strong here for me one imbalance is to deny the work of the Holy Spirit that is actually going on in certain congregations even in the giving of utterances that come from the Holy Spirit on the other hand another imbalance is to seek after the splashy gifts of the Holy Spirit as if that's the measure of true spirituality and I think we have to recognize that what you see in the in the New Testament you see splashy stuff throughout the book of Acts but if you read through the epistles of Paul it's a lot more mundane and so I think we have to keep that balance in there allowing the Holy Spirit to have that to be free and God to be free to act in in miraculous ways and yet to also recognize that the vast majority of what he does is through day to day interaction between spirit gifted people encouraging one another in the body I mean that's a a lot to say in just a short period of time and I'm not saying you have to agree with me I'm just if you're looking for a position that's that's where I would argue all right I'm going to pray for us since we haven't done that yet we're almost halfway through class but that was a long intro so Father we do thank you that there is a new age and that we are part of that new age that the last days have dawned and that they have dawned through the death and resurrection of our Lord and that we stand at a privileged position in the history of redemption to know who our Redeemer is to know what he has done to know the very basis for our salvation for the forgiveness of sins in a way that even those in the Old Testament could only see glimpses of and that we also have an assured hope in the eternal gift of the resurrection which vouchsafes our own resurrection before the Lord and in all of these things we give you thanks we are also thankful that you have sent the Holy Spirit into our midst that we would be gifted for your service in the variety of callings to which you have given us and Father we would ask that through your Holy Spirit you would unite your body which at times in our world today is so separated that you would use us to that end and that you would use us to encourage one another and ultimately to spread abroad your gospel of repentance and faith and forgiveness in our Lord Jesus Christ in His name we pray. Amen. Okay, I'm going to take a bit of a hiatus here before we get to Johanine theology which is our meat of the day could I get two people to help distribute this? This is a final exam study guide so some of you might want to see this.

I haven't yet posted it on the web I'll try and remember to do that here over the course of this weekend for those of you who prefer to have it in an electronic version. The study guide as it's coming out let me just mention it is very parallel to the one that you saw in the midterm exam in fact the exams will be very similar the final exam it's a final exam but in reality it just covers the second half of the class okay so I'm not going back to the material it was covered on the midterm there are occasional things that were covered on the midterm that also overlap with material that are that we focused on in the second half of the class so for instance the names of form critics and reduction critics that are mentioned on the first page here and you should know who those people are. I think I neglected to mention these names earlier in class Schmidt Debeleus and Boltman is form critics you'll notice that's the same Boltman who was famous in some other contexts that we talked about earlier as well and then Borncom Conflumann and Markson as Redaction Critics let me mention this do you see where I am I'm about a third of the way down this the first page of the study guide. Borncom is especially famous for his work on Matthew. Conflumann is famous for his work on Luke and Markson is famous for his work on Mark okay. I actually brought the works by Borncom and Conflumann into class so you may recall me stating those and especially Conflumann's book called The Theology of St. Luke so we did cover those in class the other names that you see their Bower and Sanders we'll get to next week as we talk about Paul all right I have tried to anticipate what we'll get through next week as well frankly this may come as a surprise I'm way behind on the syllabus that's no surprise where we are at actually is in comparison to last year we're only about one lecture behind so I'm not that surprised and I actually brought in more material in the front end of this class than I did last year more emphasis on history more emphasis on canon and I really felt that that was important in the 21st century church so I'm I'm actually very happy with where we're at I mean I could have wanted you know a whole year with you guys but I'm sure you'll be glad that we didn't you didn't have to undergo all of that. Again the structure of the exam multiple choice short answer the kinds of questions that could be answered in both sections are broken down according to section the kind of stuff that's mentioned in the short answer stuff to the extent that there's kind of bare facts that can be tested objectively that could also impinge on multiple choice and fill in the blank questions as last time. The readings come in as last time in in primarily in the multiple choice and fill in the blank section that's where we'll focus on those and again it has to do with major topics in each section and subsection of any of any chapter so if you think through say lad any kind of sub chapter heading you should be able to know the two to four main points that are in that sub chapter heading and then I will ask you to recognize that and mostly in a multiple choice context okay so things like that I think that's all I want to say about this now I guess what I would encourage you to do is to look at this over the course of the weekend and then on Tuesday I'll provide opportunities for you guys to ask any questions about material that's on this right yeah I'm sorry as it was being distributed you might not have heard I I will try and post it in the portal before our next class so that you can use it for studies there okay very good all right our next topic and our main topic for the day is joining theology there was a handout that was distributed last time and I believe I did bring in extra copies the right behind Patrick and then a video camera they were they look like they're gone now you have an extra okay anybody needs a copy there's an extra up here with Susan okay all right what I'm gonna set out for myself here is a virtually impossible task and I'm not sure we can do it but got a half hour to cover five books in the in the New Testament and the books are the gospel of John first second and third John and the book of Revelation because all of these are traditionally held to been authored by one person namely John the Apostle okay so again the gospel of John first and second and third John and the book of Revelation now when I said that traditionally these are held to be authored by one person namely John the Apostle I will note that that is not the position of many modern scholars although many modern scholars would have sent to that and it's also not the position of even a few members of the earliest church and so I want to interact briefly with the authorship issues here before we move into some of the purposes of the Joannine literature okay now first of all we should acknowledge that these books do not explicitly say John the Apostle writing to UNAsia or something like that all right so unlike Paul's letters which are signed by him as Paul the Apostle or Paul the slave of Christ Jesus or some such title these are not explicitly signed by him it's up to a few respects and I note here under room number one point A that second John and third John both say the elder writing to so let me give you an explicit quote there so you'll see how that works I'm going to turn to second John second here second John the elder to the chosen lady and her children or third John the elder to the beloved guys whom I love in truth okay so second and third John explicitly say that they are written to a written by the elder but they don't say which elder John the elder and they don't really define what is meant by elder there all right B the book of Revelation at the beginning in chapter one in three different verses and at the end in chapter 22 both say that it is written by John so excuse me I'll just take one four from the book of Revelation as an easy one he says John to the seven churches that are in Asia okay so there of all the works that are associated with the name John this is the one work to explicitly say it's written by a guy named John okay it doesn't say John the Apostle so we haven't yet vouch saved his apostolic credentials we just know that he's calling himself John right the gospel of John and first John are anonymous they do not mention the name of the person and they do not give his technical status such as elder they simply are anonymous however I note as you'll see on your sheet there that the gospel does have a number of references to the disciple whom Jesus loved and the one that I especially highlight for you there's several that are on your sheet there but John 21 24 says

by the way here's the context Peter looks back and he sees the disciple whom Jesus loved following them that's in verse 20 of John 21 20 and this is the very person who leaned back on the breast of the Lord at supper okay which of course when you ate in the ancient world you ate written in a reclining position many of you will know this the traditional kind of Greek form that was used by the Romans and others as well was the trichlinium where you had three couches kind of lined up in a U shape and these couches often were quite long and three or more people could sit at some of these couches depending on the exact circumstance and where they're meeting and that kind of thing so by reclining on Jesus's breast it probably means that they were just on the same couch lying down eating in a reclining position because that's how you ate in the ancient world you didn't eat sitting down at a table knife and fork you scoop with your fingers and all of that so he was the person who was closest to Jesus and there is certainly an intimacy that is that is enveloped in that term but it's it's a very common intimacy in the first century and so Peter looks at this person says to Jesus Lord what about this man and this Jesus's response leads to a rumor and then in verse 24 it says this is the disciple who bears witness of these things and wrote these things and we know that his witness is true

so the beloved disciple is the one who is being attributed the authorship and the writing of these things and the gospel itself but again he is not explicitly named in the gospel so we're left to infer that he's John and of course that's been inferred throughout church history the connection of the gospel itself with the apostle John is fairly universally recognized in the early church with John the apostle and again correlating that series of verses there helps in making that identification although his John's name is not explicitly mentioned the the other thing that can be said about this literature is is that there's strong stylistic similarities between the gospel and certainly the epistles and I would argue the book of Revelation as well the book of Revelation does depart in some ways from traditional Johanine terminology that you find in the gospel and in the three letters especially first John but not in any ways that are that remarkable so for instance love is a major theme in the gospel and in first John you'll recognize that well of course what is wrong with the church when they don't follow their first love so love is mentioned again in the book of Revelation so you recognize that there is a lot of extra terminology in the book of Revelation but I would note that this has to do with the kinds of visions that are being seen you don't have dragons showing up very much in the gospel all right so when you start bringing in those and the list of stones that are given and things like that the vocabulary in the book of Revelation is much more extensive than that in the gospel in first and second John and but the core terminology in the gospel you also find in Revelation and there's striking structural similarities in the kinds of sentences the Greek in the gospel and in the rest of the Johanine literature including Revelation is very simple okay evidence of this can be in comparison say to one of Paul's letters I may have given this to you before but you know I'm teaching through Ephesians in my Sunday school class and we got through the first chapter of Ephesians and halfway into the second chapter and then there was a break and as because of the the structure of the Sunday school and I told my class tell everybody else in the church that we've been studying now for four or five weeks and we've only made it through three sentences because that's true in Ephesians chapter 1 verse 3 through 14 3 through 14 one sentence verse 15 to the end of chapter 1 that's your second sentence chapter 2 verse 1 to verse 10 that's your third sentence okay so Greek sentences can be very long and obviously very complex so complex that you simply cannot room that way in English you got to throw in some periods you got to give us a breath because we're not used to super long sentences in English so Greek can be very complex Greek sentence structure in the gospel of John and the rest of the Johanine sentence structure usually a sentence equals a verse often a verse will have two or more sentences in it okay so the sentence structure in the gospel and the rest of the Johanine literature including the book of Revelation is very simple in comparison to the rest of the New Testament just a quick aside on that you know how people can say very profound things in a simple sentence I mean the book of Proverbs does this everywhere that's how I view the gospel of John he speaks in a very simple words but the wisdom and the understanding of the gospel are so immense that in that simple terminology there is great complexity and I think that's very key to understanding the gospel of John it seems very simple that's one of the reasons that we say you know to a young Christian you know the typical advice is to a young Christian read the gospel of John and I want to say there's there's some good to that advice but the gospel of John is a lot more complex than that would make us think and hopefully we'll have a chance to talk about some of that it's not complex because the sentences are hard it's complex because the concepts are extremely deep and that's I think how to view kind of the whole of the Johanine literature so I want to argue that the Johanine literature presents itself as a unified corpus including the gospel the three epistles and the book of Revelation on a variety of grounds and it is natural especially understanding the book of Revelation which explicitly says it's written by John and the book of Revelation is we'll see in a moment is the hard one of the five books that we have in front of us to say that all of it's written by John but as we'll note in just a second there were some doubts about this in the ancient church now this is where we go to external evidence that is evidence that that early church fathers give us about what they thought and who they thought wrote what okay so one of our earliest mentions of the gospel of John and the church fathers occurs in Irenaus against heresies where he explicitly says that lastly John the disciple of the Lord who had lent back on his breast once more set forth the gospel while residing in Ephesus and Asia now this is in a section where Irenaus is is trotting out for us the different authors of the gospel so that we'll know what is is written by the apostles as opposed to what are written by Nostec heretics he's writing in the middle of the second century and he explicitly shows that he understood the gospel to be written by John if you go through canonical lists including the moratorium canon and such the gospel is associated with John so there's this kind of universal acclaim that the gospel is written by John however the issue comes up primarily with the book of Revelation and here we have this citation from Eusavius the first paragraph of this citation that you have in front of you is actually Eusavius quoting Papius Papius is an early to mid second century church father who unfortunately we only know from fragments because his original extant works are lost but he's quoted by many other church fathers including Eusavius so that's who Papius is so the first paragraph is what Papius says as quoted by Eusavius the second paragraph is what Eusavius how Eusavius interprets it okay now what Papius says is the following I shall not hesitate to furnish you along with the interpretations with all that in days gone by I carefully learned from the presbyters presbyters by by the way is a Greek term presbyteros which means elder and obviously that would be the similar to the term the elder in second John and third John okay so the presbyters and have carefully recalled for I can guarantee its truth unlike most people I felt at home not with those who had a great deal to say in other words I didn't listen to people who were just clamoring about but with those who taught the truth not with those who appealed to commandments from other sources but with those who appealed to the commandments given by the Lord to faith and coming to us from truth itself so he's he's saying you know I didn't just listen to every voice I let listen to the true voices and specifically which voices did you listen to Papius well he's going to listen to us and whenever anyone came who had been a follower of the presbyters the elders I inquired into the words of the presbyters of the elders what Andrew or Peter had said or Philip or Thomas or James or John or Matthew or any other disciple of the Lord let's stop for a second what did he just list for us who were those names disciples they were the apostles right we're talking to twelve apostles so he says are any other disciples of the Lord and what Aristion and the presbyter John disciples of the Lord were still saying for I did not imagine that things out of books would help me as much as the utterances of a living and abiding voice now let's note that the name John shows up in two places in that quotation right first of all it's in that list with Andrew Peter Philip Thomas James or John right and then secondly it is in the second list and what Aristion and the presbyter John disciples of the Lord were still saying you say this is interpretation of this is as follows here it should be observed that he twice includes the name John the first John he puts in the same list as Peter James Matthew and the rest of the apostles obviously with the evangelist in mind now there he's using a technical term with the gospel writer in mind the evangelist is the gospel writer the second use of the word John with a changed form of expression he places in a second group outside the number of the apostles giving precedence to Aristion because he shows up first and clearly calling John a presbyter that's an elder he thus confirms the truth of the story that two men in Asia had the same name and that there were two tombs and Ephesus each of which is still called John's this is highly significant for it is likely that the second if we cannot accept the first saw the revelation which brings the name of John so what you say this is claiming based on the citation from Papius is that John the apostle wrote the gospel and a different John John the elder wrote the book of Revelation what I want to say then coming back to this is Papius himself is second century in fact Papius dwelled in Asia minor so he's from the very region that historically John the Apostle ends up because you know John the Apostle ends up in Patmos but he's especially associated with the church in Ephesus and historically he's held to be buried in Ephesus had been to the church that was built over the site or at least claims to be built over the site where John's grave is in Ephesus okay so so Asia minor so Papius is from that region Eusabius is writing in Caesarea which is kind of back in Palestine and Eusabius is beginning of the 4th century so you have a 4th century church father arguing that based on a 2nd century church father that there were two different John's and we need to divide the Joining Corpus up okay here's what I want to say I think Eusabius misreads Papius okay I think Eusabius misreads Papius and this is fairly important because modern scholars continue to say Eusabius tells us that Papius had two different authors and therefore the book of Revelation wasn't written by the same as the gospel okay so you'll see that in sources that especially want to impinge the apostolic authorship of the book of Revelation all right here's how he misreads him he claims that there is a different expression that is used a changed form of expression when he refers to the 2nd John well in point of fact note what the apostles are called what are the apostles called here by Papius Presbyter's he calls them elders if you would okay now that seems a little striking to us because in our current church formulation and certainly actually very early in the church churches were established to have their own elders leading that individual church we have evidence of this in the book of Acts where there's the elders from Ephesus who meet with Paul the Apostle and so you have an elder rule in the church however I would note that the apostles themselves identified themselves at times as elders so first Peter chapter 5 Peter says therefore I exhort the elders among you and I would argue that in that context he's not talking about older people he's talking about a group of leaders in the church because he's going to go on to talk about the character attributes of leaders in the church I exhort the elders among you as your fellow elder and witness of the sufferings of Christ in a partaker the boy that is to be revealed he witnessed the sufferings of Christ this is the apostle Peter after all but he calls himself a fellow elder so the apostles themselves would refer to themselves as elders and so that's a little different whereas by Eusadius' time the term Presbyteros had become the term for priest as opposed to bishop and you had a much more defined church hierarchy there and priests Presbyteros if you were were fairly low on the wrong okay and so it's hard for him to imagine a Presbyter named John as being the apostle but Papi's himself calls all the apostles Presbyters elders right so when he comes back and he refers to the second John as the Presbyter John he's just calling him the same name that he called him earlier all right secondly I would note there's a distinction between the two lists starting with the Presbyters Andrew and Peter etc. and then going back to Aristion if you read that sentence carefully and this is born out in the Greek of Eusabius' citation of Papius he inquired whenever anyone came who'd been a follower of the Presbyters and in other words anyone who came who'd been a disciple of one of the apostles he inquired as to what the apostles taught his followers okay so the first list doesn't he's not claiming I met Andrew Peter John etc. he's claiming I met people who followed them and so therefore I could carefully investigate what was being said by them the second list with Aristion and the Presbyter John is and what Aristion and the Presbyter John disciples of the Lord were still saying in other words by Papius' time most of the apostles had met their demise but there was still a living voice in Aristion and in the Presbyter John Aristion being a mere disciple of the Lord not one of the apostles but John being singled out by the term Presbyter and thus equated with the Presbyter John before so I don't think we're dealing with two different John's here I think we're dealing with one John and on the one hand he's saying I listened to the disciples of the disciples the disciples of the apostles but then he also had access because Papius was still early enough at the beginning of the first of the second century to hear what John was still saying okay now here's why this is significant aside from now establishing that Eusavius is wrong about saying there are two different John's in the early church Eusavius also had a second motive going on here and there's a word a term that you should know killiism this word comes from the Greek word killius which means a thousand and it has to do with the thousand years that are mentioned in the book of Revelation the Millennium if you would in Revelation chapter 20 all right in the early centuries of the church there was a significant debate between the killius and the ancient and the anti-killius the people who believed that the thousand years in the book of Revelation constituted a real earthly reign for a thousand year period of time of Jesus before the final judgment we would hold that position today to be the pre-millennial position okay and the anti-killius position which believed that that thousand years was a symbol if you would and did not stand for a literal thousand year earthly reign of Jesus okay Eusavius was an anti-killiist papius was a killiist Eusavius has a as this kind of love hate relationship throughout his church history with the book of Revelation because it's that book that's proclaiming the position that he opposes and so therefore by associating that book not with the Apostle but with John the Elder it serves some of Eusavius's other motives for kind of downgrading the book of Revelation he still doesn't toss it out of the canon although you'll remember from his canon discussion he says that there are some who do and he almost implies that he would go there but the issue really has to do with this kind of theological debate that's going on it was fairly divisive in the ancient church okay so much so that Eusavius when he talks about papius shortly after this part I should have brought my copy and I forgot to bring him my copy of Eusavius when he talks about papius he basically calls a bit of a backwards fool he kind of impinges on his intelligence and again I think that has to do with Eusavius being against the Killius position that's proclaimed by papius one of the issues that comes out of that then would be see if papius has a claim to have actually heard from John himself what John was still saying then papius is claimed to a thousand year literal reign might have a stronger historical precedent then Eusavius's own position which can't be associated with specific teaching with regard to the Apostle John right actually the striking thing in my mind is that if you correlate papius's position with the position of some of the others in the church namely Paulic harp and also Irenaus Paulic harp clearly knew John the Apostle Papius possibly knew John the Apostle Irenaus didn't but all of them work in Asia Minor where John the Apostle is from they all hold the Killius position they all hold to a literal thousand year reign whereas it's the people outside that region that hold to what we would deem today to be more of an omel position an omelennial position so I think there were theological motives in Eusavius's misinterpretation of papius's words here okay do you have any questions on that before I move on what I'm essentially trying to do then is argue that the gospel first second and third John and revelation were all written by the same person namely by the Apostle John and that the main evidence to the contrary which can even be found in the early church is dubious because it involves a misreading of papius who would have actually known that the author of the gospel so I see no no strong grounds then for separating the corpus from one another I think it's all written by basically that it's all written basically by the same person you say is this correct to say that there's multiple burial sites for John, but this is hard burial sites for the Apostle yeah that's right that's right there are multiple burial sites from most of the Apostles like there's debates over where Peter was buried and things like that that's right and there's there's stronger tradition usually for one side as opposed to the other but there's usually multiple traditions so that could be what's going on here as well that's right yeah so make sure I'm talking to the first seven people that he left you say he was talking to people who have heard from those seven guys and secondly he's saying John's still alive he's saying John's still alive and it's possible that he actually learned from John directly but he doesn't go his words are a little too careful to know whether he knew that or not he's saying that John's still around Aristion who was also a disciple of the Lord presumably one of the many other than the Apostles who followed Jesus around they were still around so in other words their eyewitnesses still around to Papi's his day because he called the first seven guys known the presbyter's but also disciples and then he calls John the disciples still saying that would be your link well he calls Aristion and the presbyter John disciples still so there he's distinguishing between the disciples and that these people followed the Lord even Aristion followed the Lord but he highlights John as a presbyter which associates him with that first group which we're all called presbyters yeah and that's with the presbyter John okay all right purposes of the Johnine literature what I want to say is is that here the gospel of John and the first epistle of John have explicit stated purposes and if you read John 2031 this is very important in understanding what's going on in the gospel and we'll come back to this next time when we talk about keys to interpreting this gospel John 2031 but these have been written namely these signs and these things that Jesus performed and did these have been written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ the Son of God and that believing you may have life in his name okay so what's the purpose of this gospel it's so that you may believe now just as a quick aside here and I'll I'll expand on this further next time we then immediately think oh good this is the perfect text to hand to an unbeliever so that they may believe this is the great evangelistic track this is the one that if we're going to if we're going to publish one gospel attach a little gospel track to it we're going to distribute it we're going to distribute the gospel of John the downs and that's certainly true the downside of that is then once you have believed well you kind of move beyond the gospel right because you're already believing you've already accomplished his purpose I want to say that's a serious misreading of the gospel of John because the gospel of John does not have does not view belief as a light switch you're off and then you're on but it views it more like a ray of stat or a knob that you turn right and the gospel of John speaks to us in our unbelief wherever we're at whether we be a person who's never considered following Christ to whether we be a follower of Christ and yet still have some level of doubt like Thomas okay like Thomas did or like Peter did or like Martha and Mary did when we even though we are believers there's a sense in which there is unbelief in us and he's trying to move everybody to a position where they are wholly believing and trusting in the Lord Jesus Christ okay so therefore the gospel of John is very pertinent to us today and I'll try and develop that next time the second purpose statement in the that I wanted to look at is in the first epistle of John so first John in particular 513 and you'll note that a lot of the language like belief and such is very evident in in first John as well as in the gospel but in first John 513 he says these things I have written to you who believe there's our belief word again in the name of the Son of God in order that you may know that you have eternal life so there's a sense in which he wants to increase our confidence and our walk in Christ and in the eternal life that we have in here and so these become explicit purpose statements for what he's wanting to accomplish there now I would argue this is not all that he's trying to accomplish in first John but it's the explicitly stated purpose and then we'll move into some keys to understanding the governing literature on Tuesday and then we'll head into the apostle Paul