<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Nikela Nikela Nyanga Zonke

History and Methodology, Continued

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

But today, what I'd like to do is we're going to finish the lecture from last time. And then we're going to launch into our discussion of canon, those are the two kind of goals today. We probably won't finish our discussion of canon this time, but that's all right, we'll get there. I, in light of all that, I'd like to just go ahead and pray for us, and then we'll launch right in and talk a little bit about Matthew at the beginning of class next time, okay? Shall we pray? Father, as we continue into our discussion of these complex issues, issues that have to do with the history of the study of New Testament, issues that have to do with how we ought to study the New Testament, and also issues of the inspiration and authority of your canon, and of the way that we, as your people, should submit to that God-given Word. If we look at these issues, we desire that you would give us wisdom and that you would illuminate us into how we as your people can better serve you as we think of Scripture. Father, I pray for these students as we are entering into the throngs of the semester here, and as many have colds, I'm sure, including my own daughter, I would pray that you would protect these students as they don't need a cold right now, and also that you would excite them about all their studies, and even the work they're doing for this class, that they would see it as worship unto you in the way that they serve you by learning here to take that knowledge to others, and to spread abroad your gospel, and your wonderful name we pray. Amen. Okay, where we ended last time is we were on the handout, I think most of you will have for a New Testament lecture number three, and again, I brought some extra copies of those in the back, Nathan, I see you got it, that's great. We had just finished going through some movements and trends in New Testament study, including some, what I call selected keys to understanding contemporary New Testament study. It seems like basically every 20 years or so, I mean, I'm just making a rough estimate, but every 20 years or so, somebody comes up with a new way of doing New Testament studies, and sometimes it's a positive advance, sometimes it has some very negative consequences, and our, as a consequence, the people have to think through, afterwards, New Testament scholars have to think through, how are we going to employ these new techniques or these new thoughts, and to what degree are we going to critique those? So we talked a little bit about some of those trends that you need to know, as you're reading FF Bruce, and as you're reading Lad, because they are living this stuff, they know about the quest for the historical Jesus, they know about contemporary methods, and the variety of methods that are being employed, including source form and reduction criticism, and all of that stuff that we talked about five days ago, isn't that, it's probably not quite fresh in your memory, but that's what we were talking about, remember. At the end of class, I kind of almost switched gears right in the middle of the lecture, and I said, apart from understanding the history of the study of New Testament theology, let's talk a little bit about our task, and we had just entered into that discussion last time. In other words, what can we say about what I think to be the most correct way to approach

the study of New Testament looking at it from a theological viewpoint, not from a systematic theological viewpoint, but from a viewpoint of understanding inductively what the individual authors of Scripture are trying to say to God's people in terms of how we should think about God, our relationship to God, and how we should act as a consequence. That's basically what we're talking about when we talk about New Testament theology. I stated, as we entered class last time, two working goals, and I unpacked those a bit. Those goals are in front of you, I think. First was to inductively synthesize the major theological themes in each New Testament author within their historical backdrop, and that was the idea of looking at author by author, understanding them in light of their historical context, doing good exegesis, we would call it good interpretation. You guys know the word exegesis? Have I written that on the board? I'm not sure if I ever have. It's a word you should know. When I first heard this word, I thought, now who in the world wants to ex out Jesus, right? So that's not at all what the word means. It's exegesis that comes from a Greek word actually that basically, I mean, being a little loose here, but basically means to lead out. The idea is that you're leading out what is in Scripture, you're seeking to understand what's there and lead it out. As opposed to exegesis. The difference here is between a preposition in Greek, that means out, ex in this context, ice means in, isegesis is to read into something, in other words, to read your own presuppositions in to the text of Scripture, and that's not what we want to do, right? Not doing this, we're doing exegesis here, so if I use that word, you know what I mean. So we do good exegesis of the individual New Testament authors, and we seek to understand what their particular infacies are. That's point number one. Point number two is to further appreciate the organic unity of New Testament theology in the midst of the diversity of its expression, is we're having done the work to see the distinct theological infacies in Matthew versus Mark versus Luke versus John versus Paul versus Jude, you know, you name it. We now then seek to understand the organic unity that is there. So those are the two working goals. Having said that, then you should be aware of some presuppositions that I am working with, and I want you to work with as well, but their presuppositions, let's put them out on the table, so they can be critiqued, should they not be correct. First, the superintending work of the Holy Spirit does not obviate individual human expression in the writing of inspired and inherent documents, it's just a good turn of phrase. You know, you should just say that at a party sometime, see if you get a good reaction out of that. But basically what it's saying is, the fact that the Holy Spirit inspired and inherent word of God does not mean that he overrode the human agents, so that they lost somehow lost their humanity and just became kind of divine vessels. Rather, and this isn't keeping with that diagram, you'll remember about author, audience, and the Holy Spirit overseeing that whole process, the idea is that the Holy Spirit uses the humanity of the authors to create an inspired and inherent word, something that is truly God-breathed, and like any other work of literature, and that it is without error, and all that it seeks to affirm. That's what I mean by an error, okay? Let me give you some examples of that. It is striking to me the number of times in scripture that you see the combination of the human author with the divine author put together. So for instance, Matthew 22, 43, he said to them, this is Jesus said, into them, then how does David, in the Spirit, call him Lord? Did you hear human agent, David, then how does David, he's talking about the Psalms and the Psalter, and this is the Psalm of David, then how does David, the human author, in the Spirit, there's the divine author, call him Lord. So you have divine and human together. In Acts 1.16, rather in the scripture had to be filled which the Holy Spirit foretold by the mouth of David concerning Judas who became a guide to those who arrested Jesus. So again you have the divine author, the Holy Spirit, and the human author, David, working together with one another, and David's the mouth of the Holy Spirit, and yet David is very much there, okay? And that's an expression that's used a few different times in Acts. So in Acts 4.25, who by the Holy Spirit through the mouth of our Father David, thy servant did stay, why did the Gentiles rage in the people's devised futile things? Peter 1.20 and 21 says the following, but know this first of all that no prophecy of scripture. Now this is especially focusing on prophecy, but we realize that the Old Testament by ancient Jewish people was largely viewed as a work of prophecy. Do you know what the prophetic books are in Jewish canon? Well you'd think Isaiah, Jeremiah, Daniel, Ezekiel, you know, and then the minor prophets, right? It's only half of the books that are called the prophetic books in the Jewish canon. The other half is, let's see, Joshua Judges, 1st and 2nd Samuel, 1st and 2nd Kings, those are considered prophetic books, you see? Because even the historical books of the Old Testament were understood to have been written by prophets, okay? And certainly Moses was seen as a prophet as well, and hence the Pentateuch was considered a prophetic act, but in any case, in the first century then when he says prophecy, he's probably referring to a lot more scripture than you think of when you think of prophecy. But know this first of all that no prophecy of scripture is a matter of one's own interpretation, for no prophecy was ever made by an act of human will, but men moved by the Holy Spirit spoke from God. So you have men moved by the Holy Spirit speaking from God, not an activity he says of the human will, and yet we see humanity in the human situation, the human living situation of the people in bread and scripture the same way. So how do we reconcile these things? Well we have to acknowledge that there is divine in there's human in scripture, and the human is in no way obviated, in no way destroyed by the divine intent. The major, this is wholly consistent with certainly recent and I think long held evangelical interpretation of scripture. Some of you guys may have heard of the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inherency, okay, which is the statement where some of the most profound evangelical thinkers of generation ago got together and said, okay, what is in herancy? We're affirming in herancy, this is something that's much debated in our society, we need to sit down and define what we mean. And so they came in a large committee and formed, what is a wonderful document called the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inherency. Let me read to you two of the articles from it, and listen carefully because this is a lot of academic speak, but it's worth hearing, okay, ready? Article 7. We affirm that inspiration was the work in which God by His Spirit through human writers gave us His word. That's what inspiration is, God by His Spirit through human writers gave us His word. The origin of scripture is divine, the mode of divine inspiration remains largely a mystery to us, so we don't know all the complexities that are involved. There's an affirmation and there's a denial, denial. We deny that inspiration can be reduced to human insight or to heightened states of consciousness of any kind. In other words, this is something beyond just mere human insight, there's something divine in it, but then they quickly follow that up with the human nature of scripture. So article, that was article 7, that was article 8. We affirm that God in His work of inspiration utilized, listen carefully, the distinctive personalities and literary styles of the writers whom He had chosen and prepared. So He used the divine agents as He had prepared them, especially with regard to their personalities and the literary styles. We deny that God in causing these writers to use the very words that He chose overrode their personalities, okay? So somehow when you look at scripture and you're talking about the inspiration of scripture, you're living again in that kind of human divine intersecting together, okay? Now that's very important because we're going to go on to talk about Matthew as an author and Paul as an author and such, we've already begun to do that. And so we're going to speak of them as real living human beings, and we're going to allow them to have their own distinct personalities, their own distinct literary styles. I would add to that their own distinct infacies in terms of things that the perspectives that they have, and yet I would argue that that's consistent with our understanding of the doctrine of inspiration, okay? So that was a pre-supposition number one, I don't know about you, but this feels like a Monday, you know? We're all kind of just barely here, all in need of a caffeinated beverage or some equivalent tool, that's why. Okay, let's pre-supposition number one, I'll do two, three, and four, and then I'll see if you guys have any questions at that stage. Number two, each author makes a distinct theological contribution. Now, when I say that, I am not saying that each author always consciously sought to write theologically, so for instance, when Matthew is recounting the gospel of Jesus, he's not sitting down thinking, okay, now I have my checklist of things I want to emphasize in this book, let's see, I've done numbers one, two, and five, I better make sure in this next narrative I have of Jesus that I emphasize points three and four, okay? So I'm not saying that he had laid out this systematic theology that then he wove in, but I am saying that they do have their own distinct infacies that they're going to make, so three points here, in terms of justification for point number two, a pre-supposition number two, one, each author was writing to a different situation, and so that naturally called forth for different infacies. You see that even with Paul when he writes, I mean there's a profound difference in the tenor of say Galatians compared to First Corinthians compared to Romans. They sound very different in terms of how he's treating his audience, and in part because he's extremely annoyed with the Galatians. He's fairly annoyed with the Corinthians, but he's fairly happy with Romans, okay? So each different situation called forth a different response, and therefore different infacies because they also had different problems going on. So they were writing to different situations. Secondly, the nature of human beings is we all see things from a finite perspective, though we may all be looking at the same thing. Now that's to say that, let's say that you were to walk out the door here, and suddenly out in the courtyard in front of the library, you have somebody singing opera. That would be an unusual event, okay? Chances are if I sampled any three of you, you would have a slightly different take on that event, okay? Some of you might find it extremely annoying, you've never liked Italian, you've never liked people singing in Italian, and why they are breaking the piece, you might have a different take on that. Somebody might be enthralled with the quality of their vocal utterances. Some of you might have been so enthralled in your own conversation that you barely noticed the person was there, you know? That's the nature of human observation when you go out and you see something like that. Now if I were to pull all of those three things together, chances are I could synthesize a pretty accurate understanding of the event that occurred, even though it's seen from three different perspectives. And there's a sense in which each of the perspectives has some level of validity, okay? That's kind of the nature of human observation. If you add to that, if you change that scenario too, Jesus giving us sermon to His disciples, and there's Matthew sitting there at the feet of Jesus. There's John sitting there at the feet of Jesus, and afterwards people give accounts to Mark and Luke about what happened there. Then what you're going to have is several different perspectives on the same event, and they all have validity to them, and they all draw out particular infacies in what terms of Jesus was teaching. So for instance, Jesus probably taught for hours at a time. And yet if you read the discourses in Matthew, you know, you could go through them in terms of an oral reading in 15 minutes or less. So clearly they are condensing and constructing and bringing things together so we get a gist of what went on. And that means that there's a possibility that one has one perspective and somebody else brings in something new that we also should take into account. Now the difference is we, in holding the inspiration of Scripture, hold each of those infacies in those distinct perspectives to being the very perspectives God would have us take into account. We'll return to all that later with regard to the Gospels. But have you ever wondered why you have four Gospels instead at just one? The early church at times wondered about that. So there was a man named Tation who put together a, what is known as the, I just lost it. Anyway, it's his accounting of the four Gospels, I can't believe I forgot, anyway, he's accounting of the four Gospels, he brings them together in one continuous narrative. That means he drops something in Mark, if it's already a Matthew, and he just drops it, it's not there anymore. Well, that sounds much more efficient than having four Gospels to me, doesn't it you? But what's missed there is is that the distinct infacies looking at the same situation, Mark and Matthew, Luke, John, all looking at the same events, each of their infacies provides not just a valid perspective, but a God-given, inspired perspective, and therefore we don't discard the Gospel of Mark even though that 93% of the material in its found in Matthew and Luke. Right? That's why we still have Mark in the canon. So just something to consider there. So the nature of human beings is we all see things from a finite perspective that we may be looking at the same thing. And finally, I would add to that that all these authors were all working under the superintending inspiration of the Holy Spirit. So my three justifications for point two, for pre-step position two, is that each author makes a distinct theological contribution they are. They were writing to different situations. They were each seeing things from a human and therefore a finite perspective and therefore had different infacies. But all of this was under the superintending work of the Holy Spirit, the Inspirational Holy Spirit. Okay? So that's point number two. Pre-step position number three, each author's contribution must be viewed in its historical context. I've emphasized that already before in the class so I don't probably need to say much about it, except to say that that is not to say that the results cannot be transcultural. Rather, what I have here is the first point of contact with the author is in relation to his writing within a specific historical situation. So we need to view the authors in terms of the historical situations in which they're writing. But they still have something transcultual to say, okay? The reason for pre-steposition three there is if you look under working goal number one, I say, in each New Testament author within their historical backdrop. And so that's the pre-step position that's undergrading now. Finally, point number four, there is unity to New Testament theology. This is the one that I'm most interested in you guys being able to defend because most of my New Testament colleagues in broader theological circles would happily go with me in this idea that different authors have different infacies. But the idea of then ultimately hoping to come to a synthesis where there's a unity to New Testament theology, that they may doubt. So I'm interested in you being able to articulate a defense for that as well. So I have at least four points to make. Why is it that we can expect a unity to New Testament theology? One point is on a very human level, these authors were in contact with one another. The early church was a fairly small entity. That was a fairly international entity. And most of the authors in the New Testament traveled fairly widely. So if you go with the historical identifications of Mark and Luke, these were traveling companions of Paul and Barnabas and ultimately possibly a Peter in Mark's case, and possibly Luke as well. Paul was obviously traveled very widely. John, in his life in Asia Minor, from all historical accounts. So these people traveled widely. They interacted with one another and therefore you would expect that the early church is cross-fertilizing with one another. So it's not a surprise on a human level to find some degree of unity in their own constituent theologies. That's one point on a human level, second point. But also on a human level. The authors were working in fairly similar situations. Now there was a significant cultural variation between, say, Palestine and say the city of Corinth. But the elements of continuity were stronger than the elements of discontinuity. So they're working within similar situations and they're working within similar situations and that they're all speaking to a church. That knows very well its Old Testament, knows very well the teachings of Jesus et cetera. So the similarities, not just in the human contact they have with one another, but the similarities in situations also leads us on a human level to expect some level of unity. So it's defensible even there on a human level. Also in a human and now moving to a quasi-divine level, point three is the authors were consciously reflecting on the same material. They were consciously reflecting on the same material. Namely, they were reflecting on the teachings of Jesus and the Old Testament, which they held to be their authoritative scriptures. So they were thinking about the same stuff, which also leads to a great possibility of unity, at least on a human level. So in a human level, we've got people who are in contact with one another in similar situations thinking about the same stuff. So that leads us on a human level to think about some possibility of unity and synthesis. Finally, and this is the point that I think we'd all ultimately turn to in terms of our expectations of unity and New Testament theology, this is a purely theological point. The authors were all working under the superintending inspiration of the Holy Spirit. Because this is God speaking through human authors, we expect there to be a unity and the thoughts that God would have us know. So we start off with the expectation that we'll be able to synthesize the different theologies. That's the expectation. Ultimately, from an academic perspective, I have to say that that's our starting point, we have to ultimately prove our starting point by ultimately synthesizing, proving that it can be done. You can synthesize between the distinct theological infacies in Matthew and Paul or something like that. But I hope to show that in the course of this class. Now, there are probably other points that could be made in terms of why we would expect a unity to New Testament theology, but those are at least some kind of rational reasons that you could give to somebody else who's saying, well, why are you bothering to say that Paul said the same thing that James said? Those are some reasons. Any interaction you guys want to have on any of these presuppositions? Mary looks so good. Martha doesn't. Yeah. Okay, the question, it's a very good one, and it's fairly complex. Mary and Martha are portrayed differently in some respects, slight respects, between Luke and John, and your Bible studies said you can see how Martha had grown up between one narrative and another. I would argue that that is probably inappropriate. I'm not ultimately against trying to do character studies like that, but we have to admit that we don't have a lot about Martha. And what's really going on there is probably that you've heard untold number of stories about Mary and Martha and how Mary was willing to sit at Jesus' feet, Martha was all running around in the kitchen, etc. She really hacked off with Mary and how Jesus corrected that. And so that, since all you have is, if all you have is that narrative about Martha, then Martha doesn't come off so well. And so the preacher then has this wonderful sermon, pitting Mary against Martha in terms of the way that it's structured, the sermon's structured. And there's a real danger in that because we don't know enough about them to say, we can empathize with character traits in both. And so it's not wholly wrong to make a comparison there, but then to abstract that as if the main character trait we know about Martha is she's a busybody and can't sit down even at Jesus' feet when he's there teaching. And then go to the hospital of John, especially with the Lazarus account, and see that that's not quite her response there. Well, that breaks with our character understanding. Well, that would be like taking any one episode from your life, a major episode from any of your lives and saying, your whole character can be revealed in this one episode. That's just not fair to Martha. The broader issue, ultimately, is does John want to portray character development in Martha? Did Luke want to portray character development there? And if they wanted to do that, then that's valid to see it. But to say that John was wanting, in the back of his reader's minds, them to be thinking about Martha in the kitchen, and then he brings one other narrative that shows she's better off than they realized, that's making a lot of assumptions about what John thought his audience understood. And so I would be very cautious about that. I mean, probably the better thing to say, the safer thing to say is that by looking at both narratives, we get a fuller picture of who Martha is and just leave it there. Can I revise what I would just have you do? What he said is he said when he sits down and reads scripture, and he's reading through first Peter, for instance, he looks at it and he says, I'm reading the word of God. And you don't think I'm reading the word of Peter. Before you even got a chance to go to your question, my reaction to that is it is extremely good that when you sit down and you look at first Peter, you're saying, I am reading the word of God. That's absolutely the foundation starting point. And I'm happy for people on one level. I'm happy for Christians for that to be the first and foremost thing in their mind. But I don't see why that means that. You can't also say, I'm reading the words of Peter. See what, basically what I'm contending right here is, I want you to look down and you want to say, I am reading the words of God as spoken through Peter. And Peter was a real person, speaking to a real group in Asia Minor. So let's see what Peter is saying to those people, that author is saying to that audience, locate it there, and then realize that all of that was under the divine superintendent power of the Holy Spirit. So do both. I wouldn't pit the two against each other. Now I didn't even give you a chance to ask your question. Did that interact with something you were thinking though? Yes, fully God and fully man in the incarnation, fully human as well. The question is, can you apply the idea of fully God, fully man, the incarnation to Scripture? I've been actually very careful here not to mention the word incarnation. There are many people who would teach exactly what I'm teaching and they would be very happy to use the incarnation word. I want to reserve incarnation because it's a very special word in my mind. God in human flesh, but it's especially refers to the one God man Jesus Christ. I don't want to say that Peter ever approached that same status, fully God, fully man. And so I don't want to use the incarnation word. By the way, people love to use incarnation vocabulary about like in Christian missions or in counseling. They'll say that we are Christ in that moment when we're presenting God to people. And therefore we're incarnating God. We are Christ's representative. We become the human expression of God and I don't like that because I think the term incarnation needs to be reserved for Jesus. It's been very popular and there's a lot of theologians that have gone that way and it's been picked up on in kind of popular Christian writing but it makes me really uncomfortable or queasy. So I want to reserve the incarnation word for Jesus as the God man, fully God fully man. Now at the same time, I think your point is well taken or your question is well taken in that there is something similar going on in Scripture. Even there was something similar going on when David and the Old Testament wrote Scripture that David became the human agent through which God was speaking and the two work together to produce a divine inspired word that was spoken to a particular historical situation. And so I see the analogies there but I mean it may just be me but I don't like using the incarnation word there. So that's why I was careful not to say it. But it's natural to draw some connections and some analogies. Is that good? Okay well two things. I hear actually two things going on at least in your question. You're saying you're discouraged at this point in the class for two reasons. One, this is not kind of how most people approach the Bible. They don't approach it with such care. They certainly don't approach it with such theological infacies. And so you know we setting ourselves out as a kind of elite here. That's one issue. The other issue I hear is you said that you know you're lazier than this. Most of your friends are lazier than this. So you know help me here. I'm discouraged because I want to be lazy but you're not letting me be lazy. Okay. You might guess how I would respond to the second one. I mean part of the whole point of this class is that yes most people are lazy when they approach Scripture and that's extremely dangerous because this is the word of God. Here let me just say something. Set aside the question for a second and ask. Is it normal for people in our Western society to take a book off the shelf. Let's say himmingway and to hang on every word in every sense as if it's divinely inspired. No. I mean I hope not. Would you do that with Melville? No. Would you do it with Shakespeare? No. That's not how we normally are taught to read literature. Therefore when we come to Scripture we often bring the same level of kind of laziness. Let's just read it through you get the big picture. Or we read it with such detail because we want this first to apply to my life but we've never been taught how to read in that level of detail. Because our English classes have taught us how to read 300 pages and write a book report instead of reading three sentences and talk about how each word is important in our lives. So anytime that you're approaching Scripture because you see it as divinely inspired and because you want every word to matter inevitably it's calling forth a different approach to it as literature than you would use to any other book. And it's something that requires therefore more rigor and study. So when I'm interacting with the laziness thing I want to just say sorry it's a word of God. There we approach the word of God lazily. I'm glad you use the word because I don't think most people would be honest enough with us to use a word that really is the case. Most people are lazy in their Bible study. They've got ten minutes they're going to read their passage for the day and they're weekly reading cycle. And they're going to try and get something out of it and they're going to leave. Instead of going through the hard process of all the things that have to go into understanding each and every word. And I think that's to our shame rather than let's adjust our understanding of interpretation of life. So that's to the second point. Again, thank you for bringing that up. At the same time I do not want us to create this kind of ultra-spiritual elite because we suddenly have the right way of approaching Scripture and the right tools to approach Scripture so that we can feel better and more superior than the person next to us in the pew. In point of fact, I know people who they could not articulate a single word of about how to interpret well but because they've read Scripture for 50 years they're much more holy and they know Scripture much better than I do. And I acknowledge that that happens and it's part of just the way that the word of God impresses on people's souls and that's a good thing. So I want to acknowledge that at the same time I think there's some helpful correctives here to how most people approach their study of Scripture. And so we need to take those correctives into account and then try and bring them to God's people as well. I would estimate that most people because of the clarity of Scripture, technically it's the perspicuity of Scripture, Scripture is so clear that if you sit down and you read it you get the big picture. Again, I keep coming back to Jesus died for our sins and he was resurrected on our behalf. And you can't miss that in the New Testament if you're reading at all carefully and with the Holy Spirit working in your life. You can't miss that. What I'm thinking about is how can we be more precise with that smaller percentage so that everything we say about Scripture is more increasingly accurate. And part of what I'm doing here is I'm speaking to a group of people who are training to be Christian leaders in a variety of contexts but you're all going to be Christian leaders. And I'm thinking that James chapter 3 actually bears here. Can I borrow your Bible for half a second? You guys ever encounter James chapter 3? Good. Somebody just said that she has and it scares her and there's some reality to that. Here, listen to this words. James 3 verse 1, not many of you should become teachers my brothers for you know that we who teach will be judged with greater strictness. Shall I repeat that just in case you didn't hear the first time? Not many of you should become teachers my brothers for you know that we who teach will be judged with greater strictness. For we all stumble in many ways and if anyone does not stumble in what he says he is a perfect man able also to bridle his whole body. If we put bits into the mouths of horses so that they obey us we guide their whole bodies as well. Look at the ships also though they are so large and are driven by strong winds they are guided by a very small rudder wherever the will of the pilot directs. So also the tongue is a small member yet at both of great things now. It is easy and appropriate to see in this passage a broader point about being careful with what we say in all avenues of life. But he starts off with a very specific application which is to teachers because there is a greater there's a strict judgment on teachers and that makes sense. I mean I bear very seriously the fact that I'm speaking to 70 people plus a videotape right now and what I say could influence you guys for the good or for real and therefore what I say matters quite a lot. And especially if we're in a Bible study we're opening God's word and we're suddenly looking at a few verses what we say matters a lot and how we lead people into understanding that in a Bible study a small group Bible study matters quite a lot. So therefore we need to take that responsibility very heavily and therefore we need to hone our skills so that we are indeed better off than the people who are not teaching. I mean does that make some sense? So I guess I'm kind of talking around your question in a lot of ways and saying this is good to be even more precise in the way that we interpret scripture. I also say this I mean I think even in a private conversation I think we've discussed about something similar to this before. I would readily acknowledge that the history of interpretation in the church is often full of very unsound exegesis with good theological implications because very often people approach scripture with an allegorical approach where instead of trying to understand each word they read into it their theology. This is especially done in Old Testament narrative. Well this was done actually throughout the history of the church just in martyr in the second century. Any time he saw wood in the Old Testament the word wood was a cross. It was a symbol of cross. It was a type of the cross. It's every time. Was that right? No. But there was good theology there because he still was talking about the cross of Jesus, the death of Jesus on behalf, Jesus's justification and how he dealt with our sins and all of that. So the theology was good, the exegesis was bad. Somehow God in his good providence has often used bad interpretation with good theology to his glory. So I wouldn't acknowledge that too. At the same time often it has been to the detriment of the church that somebody misinterpret scripture with bad theology which they don't realize is bad theology. They might be doing it with the best of motives. But suddenly a teaching about Jesus as born, begotten later and not fully God in the sense of always in eternity existing in trinitarian form gets out there because somebody's interpreting a few texts and a few ways. And suddenly you have arianism spreading throughout the ancient church and heresy spreads and it gets worse and worse. How do you prevent that from happening? Well, honing our interpretive skills prevents us from reading bad theology into a text and also helps us to read the theology that's in the text, the exegesis and the advice of Jesus. It's always good anyway. So that's something to say to the history of the church there. I had another thought that occurred to me but I probably gone on enough. Does that help a little bit? I mean, I'm saying yes, we're doing something that is perhaps different than a lot of the rest of the church. But I think this is something that we can bring to the church to help the church interpret scripture better. And that's a good thing. And it requires us to be more careful in our work and less lazy and all that. Did that interact with your question sufficiently? We still have these complex thoughts. Yeah, well, I would affirm that. The point was, what about unbelievers? Do we say that do we want them to have the word of God? And I want to say yes. We hand them the word of God because, again, the perspicuity, the clarity of scripture is such that the major points cannot be lost. What I'm really talking about is honing our skills so that when we are called to exegete a passage that's 10 verses long, that we do so with a greater degree of accuracy than we would if we just went into it very sloppily and lazily. There's something different required of Christian leaders than of people who are young in the faith. And we dare not say people who are young in the faith, they just read scripture. They just open up and read. So therefore, Christian leaders should do the same. We have to recognize that there's something that involves growth in our approach to interpretation and do that as well. And at one last point, this afternoon, I'm due to go into Nelson Jennings God's World Mission class and do my annual semester spiel on the way that New Testament interpretation relates to missions. And one of the things that I do in there, and when I talk about the historical context in which scripture is written and the whole transcultural approach to understanding it today, I mean, one of the benefits of that, by the way, is it makes the word of God not an American word of God. It can be owned by people in any culture because all of us are approaching it as something written to a different context was not written to Americans was written to first century Christians in terms of the New Testament. But one of the other things that I do is I say we start drawing up on the board a whole category of ways in which 21st century American society is like first century. And then we draw up a whole list on the board of ways that 21st century society is unlike first century society. So similarities in the similarities between the two cultures. The similarities are part of what make it so that it is transcultural so people can understand both. So for instance, the fact that the people that there was decent transportation in the ancient world, the fact that there was there were highways, the fact that there were robbers back then make it possible for us to understand the narrative about the good Samaritan. We know what it would be to be walking from one place to another and somebody knocked on the back of the head. So that immediately speaks to our context, we understand that even if we don't quite envision it exactly how it would have been envisioned in the first century. So that's what allows us to immediately have contact with scripture. The danger is where our 21st century society is unlike the first century society and so we start misreading first century teaching and light of 21st century teaching. So we read passages on slavery and light of American slavery, the horrors of American slavery, you know, 120 years ago. And there's elements of continuity, but discontinuity there. So we have to be careful that when Paul talks about how slaves should interact with their masters, now masters should interact with their slaves, that we understand that in the first century setting and not in a kind of 19th century setting or something like that. So the possibility of interpretation is increased by areas of continuity and it's handled by all the areas that the cultures are dissimilar. So that's another reason why somebody in the 21st century can open the Bible and understand it. And the main point that I want to make with people in that context is one of the main similarities between the 21st century and the 1st century is, let's see, they were sinful and were sinful too. They need the blood of Jesus to tone for their sins and we do too. So the very spiritual makeup of us as human beings, that is true for all time, the very nature of who God is, that's true for all time, so all of that when we open scripture it just immediately speaks to us. So that allows for us, for anybody to open scripture and understand it, even if some of the dissimilarities can hinder us and make us misunderstand scripture. So a little more on that. That's a great question. I want to move on and let's see, dangers and benefits. Let me just give you some stuff here in terms of dangers and benefits, dangers. With this approach we can over-theologize choices that New Testament authors make. So the fact that Matthew chooses to include something that's not in Mark, we can suddenly draw big theological consequences from it, it might just be that Matthew kind of like the story, it might not be a big theological choice. So we can over-theologize choices that New Testament authors make. We can end up emphasizing distinctives to the points that one ignores commonality, this is often done, especially for instance in contrasting Matthew and Luke. You know, Luke talks a lot about the poor. Matthew doesn't. Does that mean that Matthew didn't care about the poor? Probably not. In fact, I would argue some narratives point to the contrary. But the fact that Luke talks more about it causes some people to say that these are distinct theologies. But there's actually more commonality there than we sometimes realize. So two dangers so far. Can over-theologize choices that New Testament authors make can emphasize distinctives to the point that one ignores commonality, point three. We can emphasize unity to the point that one ignores distinctives. That's I think the main danger in the Evangelical Church today. We assume that Matthew and Peter and Paul are all talking always about the same thing and then you end up with troubles, for instance. When Paul talks about justification coming by faith and James talks about it about justification coming by works, how do we deal with that? Well, one way is that we immediately assume that justification, the term, is a theological term that would be used exactly the same way by the two authors. And so that they're talking about the same thing. Well, they might be talking about a different meaning of the same Greek word, justify. I would argue ultimately that they are. But if we too quickly and blandly say, oh well, we can synthesize this. Let's not worry about the tension there. We can lose the distinct emphasis that are going on in James and Paul, which we need to listen to. We'll talk a lot more about that later. Next. Also, this can become a mere historical enterprise without applying it to the church today. In other words, at the end of the day, if we've interpreted Paul, what Paul said to the audience in Corinth as simply that, Paul said this to Corinth. This is what he meant to say to Corinth. This is all that he was saying to Corinth and we're done. Then we've lost application for us today. And that's also commonly done in a lot of New Testament commentaries that you can read and such. So, we don't want this to become a mere historical enterprise without application to the church today. Some benefits? First. This can provide new insight into New Testament teaching. Second. This can provide new material for the work of systematic theology. First point was provides new insight into New Testament teaching. Second, this can provide new material for the work of systematic theology. You remember my illustration about resurrection and how most systematic theologies have not dealt enough with the resurrection of Jesus. And yet, when you read the New Testament, it's everywhere. And you see that's a theological emphasis in nearly every New Testament author. Well, that can cause you to sit back and reevaluate your systematic theology. And that's a good thing. Finally, it can also help us read, better read the work of the author. So, for instance, what is the word believe mean in John, the gospel of John? Well, you think you know what belief means. But I dare say you don't understand all the nuances in John because you haven't spent the time to understand the levels of belief in the different ways that belief works out in John. And how somebody who claims to believe in Jesus can then walk away, understanding what's going on there. Well, understanding the distinct theological emphasis that John has with that word belief can be very important to then understanding John himself and understanding the work of the author. The last bit is in terms of method of New Testament theology, I've laid out here working goals, I've laid out presuppositions. And I've acknowledged that there's some dangers, but there's also some benefits to approaching the New Testament theologically as we're doing here. So, I just wanted to be transparent with you all about all of that. Too often in class, especially in an MA level class, you just kind of plunge in and you just kind of do the stuff without ever taking the time to step back and do the hard work of acknowledging what your method looks like, what presuppositions are going into that method, so that you guys can have a chance to critique on your own as you were thinking the other night. I mean, is this the right way to approach Scripture? I want you to think it through and see if you think this is the right way to approach it. So, I'm trying to be transparent here, even if it isn't what you were thinking you were going to get your second week or so of our third week of New Testament theology. In terms of a diversity of methods, I'm interested in you knowing these individual sentences by knowing I mean like they could show up in a quiz or an exam kind of thing. For these next six people that are listed on your sheet there, Ferdinand Christian Bauer. Each of these Rudolf Blutmann, Adolf Schlider, Donald Guthrie, who's different than the Donald Guthrie by the way who teaches here, just in case you're wondering. George Eldenlad and NT Ryder, Tom Ryder. These are just a few big names in the field of New Testament theology. You'll find that many of them have books that say in their title, the theology of the New Testament or something like that. So, these are people who have avertly done what I'm doing here, but they've all had slightly different approaches. So, Bauer coordinated New Testament evidence with a philosophical system, a Higadian system. Remember that was that juxtaposition of Paul and Peter and a dialectic and such. I want to say I don't like that method because it's so theory-laden. He has a philosophical presupposition and he's just going to make sure that it fits. The New Testament fits into his theory and I don't want to approach it that way. I say we do things much more inductively. Rudolf Blutmann, who's a name that will come up with again later, I had mentioned him earlier about the Jesus of history and the Christ of faith. And because he holds the historical Jesus to be very different from how the early church understood Jesus, then he actually has two parts to his theology. The first is where he actually talks about what Jesus actually did. And then there's this huge leap to what the church thought about Jesus. And there's no continuity or very little continuity. I don't think that's appropriate either. We need to see continuity between Jesus and the people who follow Jesus. And therefore I'm a lot closer to say Adolf Schlotter, who wants to associate the work of the apostles with the historical reality of Jesus. Yet still begin with Jesus and witness the development in the apostolic tradition. I'm a lot closer to Schlotter than any of these other guys. Donald Guthrie, who's an evangelical author, and whom I have great respect for, again the New Testament scholar, not the educational scholar, what I don't like about his approach is that he tends to use systematic categories. And he goes author by author, but in each case he tries to find his systematic categories in the author. And that's not inductive enough for me. So the description there I want to contrast with. Lad, I very much appreciate the way that he goes through corpus by corpus. And let's each corpus speak by corpus. I mean he lets Luke speak. He lets Paul speak. He lets John speak. And he has chapters on each, seeing the theological distinct infacies and contribution of each. That I very much like. Do you know what most bothers me about him? About Lad, since you're reading his book, you might be interested here. What most bothers me about Lad is that he puts Matthew and Mark in the same chapter. That bothers me. Because I think Matthew might have some particular infacies that are distinct from Mark and vice versa. So by putting him in the same chapter he doesn't allow them each to have their own say. That bothers me. What I like about it is that he has some attempts at synthesis. And then Tom Wright's project is still very much in development. But he starts off, and I think this is a helpful way to start off, talking first of all about the historical context. So he has this projected five, six, how many volume New Testament theology that he's doing. And every year, he's suddenly, it's grown from four books to five books, and it's going to be six books next year. So he keeps growing. He's been a whole book, or the better part of a whole book, talking about the historical context of first century Christian. I think that was very helpful. What a great way to start. And that's something that he's contributed. Most people haven't done up till now. At the same time I have some questions with other ways that he's approached things, but that's a different matter. Okay. I'm not so worried about point B on your handout there. Do you guys have any questions about what we've done so far? Okay. We have about five minutes left. And I'm going to start you out in our discussion of canon. We're going to completely change topics now. Okay? So just change gears, shift gears. Okay. We were in third gear, shift back down to first, reverse, take a left hand turn, and we're going down to different street now. All right? Up to now we've been talking about our presuppositions and the way that we should approach interpretation. We've been talking about how we synthesize theology. We've been talking about the importance of studying history. What I want to do now is talk about the canon itself. If you were to study New Testament at most religious studies places in universities today, there would be an assumption about the relationship of us to this idea of canon. What is the canon? Well, the canon is this idea that we've got 27 books of the New Testament that we're not going to add any to that, and we're not going to subtract any to that. That we see all of those 27 books as inspired and inherent from God Himself. And we don't see any other books in that same category. That's what a canon is, right? I mentioned to you, I think our last meeting, that there was a guy named Walter Bauer, who talked about orthodoxy and heresy, right? And Bauer held that what we considered to be orthodoxy was just one of several paths that Christianity could have taken, and it's the one that had the more power behind it and ultimately won as a result. But these other so-called heresies were just alternative paths. This same point has been taken as a critique of this idea of canon, so that the New Testament canon is simply the books of the winning party. And therefore, some people would basically say we should reopen the issue of canon today. Okay? Let's consider some of the nostic literature, and whether it's actually in some sense spiritually edifying. That's the question they want to ask, right? So we need to add, before we go into studying the New Testament, as if this is the only gist for our theological mill, we need to ask why is it that you guys aren't reading the Gospel of Thomas, or the Gospel of Philip, or why aren't you reading the so-called Acts of Paul and Thekla, or why aren't you reading the Apocalypse of Peter, all of these being second and third century books written in the name of the apostles, that were contributions from people outside of the so-called Orthodox branch of early Christianity. Okay? So why don't you read them? By reading them there, I don't mean I'm happy for you guys to glance through them and read them, but why don't you read them as if they have something to really say about your theology and about the way you live your Christian life? That's an issue with New Testament canon. By way of introduction, and this is all we'll have time is to do some introduction. First, why bother? Well, one of the reasons to bother talking about canon is you're going to encounter people who have been in religious studies programs who've been taught, you know? That there are other books out there, and the stuff that you're reading in your New Testament is just a limited corpus, and it's a theologically biased limited corpus. So that's one reason to bother. I'll talk more about this actually next time because I want to bring in an example of a contemporary who reads a lot of other books as if they're as important as your canon. Within the Christian Church, there are basically five contemporary views about the canon. The first is naive conservatism. You don't know, for instance, the naive conservative doesn't know I should say, for instance, that the sum total of the 27 canonical books that we have never received official church sanction until the end of the fourth century, over 300 years after Jesus lived and died. So some people will then come to you and say, did you know that it wasn't until the fourth century that all this came together? Now the danger for the naive conservative, the naive conservative simply believes the Bible, because they've always been told this is a Bible, is that when suddenly they are told something about the history of the development of the canon, it kind of rocks them for a bit, because they don't know about the historical context. So the second position and one that ultimately I'm going to push for is a historically informed conservatism, a conservatism that says, this is the canon, these are the inspired books, this is all the inspired books of the New Testament scriptures, yet understands the way that it took the church a while to recognize all of the books that should be in the canon. So I'm going to start and push towards that. The third position is the position held by the Catholic Church or the Orthodox Church. And what they say is, it doesn't matter how long it took, the church itself is its own authority. The Pope and his and the Cardinals and the church councils, these still bear the inspiring work of God to the extent that the pronouncements they make are infallible. This is the Catholic Church, not the Orthodox Church, but to the extent that when the church decides this is the canon, and this is all you read, you trust them why, because you trust the Pope and you trust the church councils. That's the Catholic or Orthodox position, and that's how they think of canon. There are a couple of other positions, one is very well of the historical issues involved in the development of the canon, and yet argues from a purely historical perspective without a lot of theological argument that this should remain the canon of the church, why? Well, basically because it's too late to change it. In the last position, antagonistic historicism is what you see in most college campuses today, where with some glee, the religious studies professor looks forward to the lecture on canon, so they can shock you with that. The canon wasn't put together till the 4th century, what do you think about that? With a goal of breaking down people's assumptions that you should only read the 27 books of the New Testament is inspired Scripture. What I want to do in the course of the next lecture that we'll do next time is to move what I think probably most people in the room are approaching Scripture from the first point of view. Now you've conservatism. You simply believe it's Scripture, and that's not bad. I mean, that's better than certainly the last position, but I want to bring some history in and talk about the development of the canon so that you have something to say to somebody who comes to you from position 5 and says, you know, you're an idiot. The canon wasn't put together till much later, and there were a lot of different options in the early church, and you're just going with the people who were the major power brokers. So how do you interact with that? And we'll do that next time. Thank you for your time today. I look forward to seeing you guys in a couple of days.