<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Nikela Nikela Nyanga Zonke

Subject Matter of Ethics

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Well, welcome to Christian Ethics. I'm David Jones. The goal of which is to understand the structure and content of Christian Ethics, to grow in grace and knowledge of what God is calling us to be Antidude, and to develop skills in the resolution of moral issues. And then I have those subordinate objectives that will sort of guide you as you come to examinations and doing the paper and so forth. The required texts are my book on biblical Christian Ethics. The lectures will will follow the same outline, but they will be different. They will overlap obviously in some places, but I will abandon certain themes to not repeat them in class. I just mentioned them. And you can judge where you are by the lecture of the day in terms of the reading. So that should be there. CS Lewis book, the abolition of man, continues to be relevant, continues to be cited very widely. And if you haven't read that, that's a good time to read it. Good time to review it if you had before, and I'll incorporate that into the course. John Sanderson's book on the Fruit of the Spirit is a good and necessary supplement to down this book on the Ten Commandments. The Ten Commandments give us the scope, a comprehensive view of the principles that God has laid down for, Godly living. The Fruit of the Spirit treats more the dynamic, the internal dynamic of the Christian Ethics. So we need that kind of balance in our thing. You should have the Westminster standards, any standard edition of those will do. And the PCA position papers own ethical issues. I've had selected, selected ethical issues. I've had photocopied, and it's available at the bookstore, including some material on race relations and a very good paper on homosexuality that are not in the PCA material. So I tried to supplement all those, those are not official PCA documents that still they're part of the tradition. And I have work on some of those papers, so I'm familiar with them. So I will, I will give you when we come to the issues section past the midterm, I will alert you to those. The bookstore gives an extra discount if I recommend books. The required books has a standard discount. There's a little less discount, but still a discount for recommended books. And I recommended these four. If you're thinking about doing a paper in one of these areas, I thought I would give you the key text in those. Stanley Grins, new book welcoming, but not affirming on homosexuality. Christine Pol, who is a professor of social ethics at Asbury, has written an excellent book on hospitality. She was really strengthened in her faith at the English Lebris, when Jerem bars first went over there. So there's a connection here. And Lebris is one of the institutions that she treats in this book on hospitality. So by the way, I've been told that there's in the current Christian century, there's a rave review of this book. So I might want to get that in any case, whether you write a paper on it or not. Scott Ray, brave new families, this is a good comprehensive book on reproductive technologies. That went out of print, only published in 1996, but already out of print. So there may be a few copies around. And then a cider's new book, just generosity, a new vision for overcoming poverty. Those I recommended for term papers. A reference book that I recommend is the new dictionary of Christian ethics and pastoral theology. You need a reference book in this area to quick look up issues as they arise. And it's wise to get that while you're taking the foundational course, there are many things that you can cross check in there. So as you're building your library, this would be a good time to build the ethics section of your library. And it's broader than ethics, it doesn't include pastoral theology. And that's been well used. In addition, I have put articles and position papers on those areas that are listed there on reserve. They're in notebooks. And so you can have access to them if you want to do that. I have some English Bible required reading and I will alert you to these as we go through when to read them. But these primary ethical sections of the scriptures, I think we need to read as we're learning. The giving of the law, the exposition of the law in the Vedicus 19, similar on the mountain Christian life in Romans 12 to 14, exposition of love in first Corinthians 13. And then these key new testament texts that you should be familiar with that I will go over in class. And the Westminster standards on the issues that are there. And I will alert you to how to incorporate those in your course. I want you to memorize the 10 commandments for the midterm in case you haven't done that. I found when classes were smaller, I would begin the first day of class by asking students to take out a sheet of paper and number 1 to 10. And a great panic ensued and that's them to write out the 10 commandments. And I got some interesting variations. I didn't know the 10 commandments when I came to seminary. I wasn't to show people up. I just know that we don't know the 10 commandments. And I tried to be cute one year and I asked them to name the big 10 and I got Michigan in the highest state. So I stopped that and just asked you give the 10 commandments. That's hard enough. So forth. Then there is a term paper. An original paper. I don't want one you've submitted to gerum. Sometimes the courses do or parallel in certain respects and some of his electives that he teaches. You can go beyond what you've done for another paper, but I want it to be an original paper. You can build on something you've done before, but alert me to that. Do the work for this course and submit your topic on the midterm. Yes, that will be on the midterm. There will be a question on there. What is your term paper topic? So put it on the midterm and the papers do first day of finals week and there's some things there about style. Purpose of it in style of the format that I require you to use. It saves paper without a cover page and it enables me immediately to sort through papers that come from different courses. I give a little recommended procedure here. First getting started. First step is to consult the relevant reference works. Sometimes that step is omitted, but the dictionary and encyclopedia articles are the first place to go. To get to the state of the question thing pros and cons of an issue and usually there's a little bibliography to get you started. The key things that have been written up to that date. Of course for more more recent literature you will need to consult the periodical index tools, which now with the internet is easy to do to gather information. Then narrowing the topic. This is also important. Look for a focus that is interesting, relevant and manageable. For example, instead of writing a paper on the biblical view of abortion, take an issue such as the ethical treatment of rape victims. If you do that, it will pre-suppose the other background and know you're working with a pro-life view or whatever, but how it relates to that particular issue is a challenge and it's also useful. Treatment of rape victims is one of the explosive issues in terms of the abortion debate. Instead of euthanasia is a general topic deal with the question of assisted nutrition and hydration of the dying. Are we always required to give food and water no matter what the circumstances? Are we starving people to death when we don't give them artificial nutrition during those stages of illness? I recommend that you read Psalm 119 as you take this course. This is not a requirement, but this is something I recommend for devotional reading. And you can get a glimpse into why I think that is a useful thing to do from this little paragraph from Derek Kidner on Psalm 119. That Psalm is extolls the law of God. It is at the same time a prayer for the Holy Spirit to enable to its fulfillment. It weaves those two things together to spirit and the word very effectively. Next stage is a virtue list in the New Testament that I will have a section on the virtues and I want you to have these available. Self-control got put on page six instead of the bottom of page five under the fruit of the spirit. So just remember that that's there. And just a word about select bibliography. If you're into the area of bioethics, the encyclopedia of bioethics, now five volumes, most recent addition in 1995. So up to that point it has material that's current, but that feel so fast. You will need to get additional periodical literature. That feel as you know is the most advancing feel with the most challenges in the area of ethics. Welcome to Christian ethics. I'm David Jones. If I were to assign a course verse to this class, it would be Philippians 1 versus 9 to 11. And I'd like to begin this class with Paul's prayer for the Philippians making it our own prayer. Let me pick up just a little bit of the context by reading starting at verse three. Paul, writing to the Philippians, I thank my God every time I remember you in all my prayers for all of you, I always pray with joy because of your partnership in the gospel from the first day until now, being confident of this, that he who began a good work in you will complete it until the day of Jesus Christ. It is right for me to feel this way of value since I have you in my heart for whether I am in change or defending and confirming the gospel, all of you share in God's grace with me. God can testify how I long for all of you with the affection of Christ Jesus. And this is my prayer that your love may abound more and more in knowledge and depth of insight so that you may be able to discern the things that are excellent and may be pure and blameless until the day of Christ filled with the fruit of righteousness that comes through Jesus Christ to the glory and praise of God. Let's pray together. Father, we make this prayer our own for this course that as we study and learn, our love may abound more and more in knowledge and insight that our own lives may show forth the excellencies of you who have called us out of darkness into your marvelous life, that we may be discerning and that we may be filled with the fruit of righteousness that comes through our union with our Savior. These things we ask in his blessed name. But the first topic is the subject matter of ethics. There's a way of introduction to the field and to this course in particular. What's all this? What's it all about? Whenever I meet somebody new and they ask me what I do, I tell them I teach at Covenant Seminary and invariably the question comes back. What do you teach? And I resist the temptation to say students. I admit that I teach theology and ethics and I get one of two predictable responses. Either their eyes glaze over and they suddenly are thirsty for the punch bowl and we move on to other things. Or their eyes brighten and they present me with some ethical issue that they've been thinking about. It could be something in the news. What about cloning? Is that right? And I try to answer as best I can. Thinking of ethics in terms of rules of conduct and they want to know how the rules apply. That's the first thing that comes to people's mind when they're thinking about ethics. It's rules. And how do they apply in complex circumstances of life? We had friends, long time St. Louis residents who moved to Georgia after the husband retired and they come back from time to time to visit St. Louis because they have contacts here. And so last time they came back we went out to our favorite Japanese restaurant for a meal together. And as we were sitting there they were telling us about life in Georgia. And how Georgia has a lottery and they use the money for education and there are these great scholarships that are available in Georgia through that way of raising money. And as the wife is telling us this she's reflecting out loud and she says, you know, is it is it right to oppose as a matter of principle a state run lottery and to accept one of those scholarships that are funded in that way? She turns to me she's, you're the ethicist. What do you think? I think I'll have a little more of that shrimp tempura. Well, I answered as best I could, you know, sorting through the various issues that are there. Now somebody wants a term paper topic, you know, there's one you might explore. What are the implications? Is that a compromise to accept the scholarship money that's produced that way? She's thinking about rules of right and wrong. And how do they apply in this situation? There must be a rule. And we must be able to find out how it fits with this somewhat complex circumstance. Now ethical issues are legion and multiplying day and night. Hardly a month goes by without some scientific breakthrough that poses new questions of right and wrong. Meanwhile, the old questions persist. Is it ever right to lie? Never right to break a promise? Never right to get a divorce? Have an abortion? To refuse medical treatment? To execute a criminal? To assassinate a ruler? The list is literally endless. And ethics does have a good deal to say about rules and how they apply to issues of right and wrong. Stem cells research has now been able to isolate stem cells from a human embryo and keep them alive in a petri dish. They've been labeled the ultimate spare part because by the proper manipulation, those can become any organ in the body. Is it right with so much good that can be done for those stem cells? Is it right to use them? After all stem cells don't just appear, stem cells are isolated from an embryo, an organism that has to die. You have to kill an embryo in order to maintain isolated stem cells alive. Is it right? What do we think about this? But ethics is not just about issues of right and wrong. It's also about the kind of persons we ought to be, the kind of persons who, for openers, think issues of right and wrong really matter. The kind of persons who love the right and hate the wrong and who can be counted on to do the right thing under pressure. Now that's the character issue. Whether we are committed to the right to such an extent that we think that the right exists and we want to do it. The kind of persons that we are have very much to do with ethics. It's about ethics is about the content of our character as well as the rules of right and wrong. Now when we talk about persons and character we use this dichotomy virtue and vice, that standard terminology. And virtue is the branch of ethics that deals with moral agents and their motivations, rules deal with actions. Of course the attitude that lies behind those actions whereas virtue deals with persons as they are in terms of these character issues and motivations. Now over the last four years there has been enormous interest in virtue ethics in the field of philosophy and growing interest in theology with respect to virtue ethics. In philosophy the reason why the interest has been developed is because of the dissatisfaction with the impasse that's been reached between Kantian ethics and utilitarian ethics. So come to those later in the course but philosophical ethics has just reached an impasse and so from that impasse about the rules which so much ink has been to spilt in order to try to figure that out. They turn to away from rules to persons. Now actually you need both. You need rules but you need also to examine motivations and qualities of persons. But virtue ethics has become in the popular culture the phenomenal success of Bill Bennett's book of virtues signal a felt need for to talk about something about values. Now values as much to vague in general a term has a original place in philosophy but it became more subjective whatever I value is value and it became lost its objective place in terms of what that originally had in mind. And to talk about values has public discourses long centuries the saturation for that so it's good to talk about virtues. But I have something of a problem with the book of virtues as a way of learning virtue I don't mean to critique that book it's for developing virtue in children but the kind of persons we ought to be is really linked to some unifying vision of the way things ought to be. Bennett takes stories from this and that and the other place and they're all about virtue in some sense but there's no overarching narrative no overarching vision in which they find their real coherence. And I think that what we need to talk about in ethics what ethics does talk about in addition to rules and persons are goals in terms of good and evil the choice of the goal what is the goal of human life what is the good that we should seek in everything the evil we should avoid. That reacts upon both the kind of persons that we become and the kind of rules that we seek to follow but the goals is the overall perspective that we should we should ask in in addition to the content of our character. We need to talk about the borrow phrase the chief end of man where are we headed with respect to this and in other words all three of these questions belong together and all three are dependent ultimately on some world and life view for their significance and they're really their understanding now world and life view has to deal with three basic issues. The origin of the universe in man where do we come from how do we get here we can't know what we are unless we deal with the issue of origins also has to deal with the present human condition what the dilemmas that we face in terms of what you feel the problem is whether it's oppression or whether it comes from inside ourselves is the fault in our spars or you know is it in ourselves. That's what a world view does basically is to address those three kinds of questions you're studying world views you look in terms of what they say about the origin of the universe in man their analysis or diagnosis of the human condition what's the problem and the proposal that they have for an answer. We can recognize in that free-fold thing the biblical perspective on it is creation fall and redemption the redemption which brings everything to its consummation in terms of God's will this is this threefold rubric will affect our thinking and ethics all along the line we want in this course develop these three things but it's there it affects everything. In terms of the ethical display that we make now I use the biblical term shalom for the goals of the overarching goal that affects our ethics the Hebrew word shalom is biblical shorthand for universal flourishing, wholeness and delight that is God's design for the creation biblical word shalom translated into English as peace is shorthand for the universal flourishing wholeness and delight that is God's design for his creation. That's Cornelius planting in his book not the way it's supposed to be book that you will be required to read at some point in this curriculum and I think that he's right on that's a treatise on sin but of course he does explore the way things ought to be as well as the way things in fact are the goal in the broadest sense the will of God his shalom for his creation. Defines for us the good it is the will of God that defines for us the good that goes back all the way to the beginning in which Satan's challenge to God in terms of the effects of the eating of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil is the is made the issue the focus point of the probation test. Will we will we identify with what God says is good will we identify with his kingdom of righteousness or will we side with the dominion of darkness you have the kingdom of light and the kingdom of darkness that dichotomy all the way all the way through. To be a responsible person just to quote planting a once more to be a responsible person he says is to find one's role in the building of shalom the rewebbing of God humanity and all creation in justice harmony fulfillment and the light. It's a comprehensive definition we need that we need that in efforts but we need that goal as as the perspective the vision in which the kind of persons we're aiming at becoming and the kind of rules that we follow make sense responsible person finds one's role in the building of shalom that is the rewebbing of God humanity and all creation. In justice harmony fulfillment and the light now this free folk perspective you know is why they recognize want you to know that I'm not just making this. C.S. Lewis in his little book mere Christianity started out as a series of broadcast talks during the second world war that's become a best seller it's still in print translated into Russian I'm going to use it when I go to Ukraine it is a marvelous treat us and the section on Christian behavior begins with a section or a discussion of the three parts of morality. The three parts of morality he says are fair play fair play between persons harmony within a person and third the purpose of life as a whole well that's that's rules and virtue and goals rules persons and goals he gives the illustration of the convoy of ships. This is wartime so this occurs to him for a convoy of ships to fulfill its purpose it must have well rules to keep them from bumping into one another. There are certain certain rules that you keep a certain distance and follow and so forth and what they are. Then there are certain observances for staying afloat you got to take care of your own ship you know not just keep out of the way of the others but you've got to take care of your own ship to stay afloat and arrive in good condition and then you need directions for arriving at your destination. The mission is not a success if you end up in New York when you're supposed to be headed for Calcutta. Well now that's the that's the threefold aspect of ethics or the threefold core that is interwoven into ethics which we need to see in terms of our Christian ethic. If we rephrase these in terms of the questions of ethics I would do it this way what goals are we to pursue in life what goals are we to pursue in life what goals are really worthy of human pursuit. Notice I said human pursuit because the Christian ethic is the ethic we are followers of the one who said I am the way the truth and the light. And although others are in partial knowledge of what the rules are and what kind of persons we ought to be it's only in the biblical ethic that you get the full world and life view that gives a basis to all of that. So what goals are we to pursue in life secondly what sort of persons are we to be what sort of persons are we to be when we look at this in the biblical frame we will see that in terms of vice it's the works of the flesh in terms of virtue it's the fruit of the spirit. There's a distinctly biblical perspective on all of these things but formally these three are all involved and thirdly what rules ought we to follow or as I said some time put it what standards ought we to practice. But I think it's simpler and clearer as to talk about rules ought we to follow and understand rules in a broader sense than just a narrow rule to drive on the left to the right side of the road. Now in answering these three questions we need to remember as Jonathan Edwards said moral matters are ultimately subject to divine assessment what they are worth in the sight of God we want to know what what goals we ought to pursue as the will of God what kind of persons we ought to be. We ought to be according to the will of God and what rules we ought to follow are the will of God so I think that the question of ethics question of ethics is really comes down to to one question what is God calling us to be and to do I think it can be encapsulated in that single question the purposes of exposition we really do need the threefold exposition but it comes down to one question. What is God calling us to be and to do we say God we mean of course the triune God who has revealed himself in price and the Holy Scriptures. When we say calling we mean summoning his authoritative call but also enabling because God's calls is effective God doesn't call us to do anything he doesn't give us his Holy Spirit to enable us to do. So what is the triune God who has revealed himself in Christ and the Holy Scriptures someone enabling us his redeemed people individually and properly sometimes on the midterm students have rephrased this question what is God calling me to be and to do and that there's partial credit for that. But really we want to understand what he's calling his redeemed people we are members of a body and our sanctification is progressive in connection with the body to be of course is what we become as persons and to do has to do with the activity that we implement in life. So to be into do gets that the the whole problem and I think that that one phrase if we unpack it contains our whole summary form a whole ethic just one one more of these threefold summaries for you and that is when we're thinking what goals is we ought to pursue that the controlling purpose. The controlling purpose the goals we ought to the goal of life the controlling purpose of our line is in biblical terms the glory of we think what kind of persons we ought to be the we can think about the what impels us to become the kind of persons God is calling us to be the impelling motive of the Christian life is the love of God. That's intentionally ambiguous does that mean God's love for us or our love for God well I mean it both because the impelling motive of the of the Christian life or the covenant way of life is God has loved us and we love him in return and our neighbor flows from that relationship. So the impelling motive of the Christian way of life or the covenant way of life is love of God and then the directing principles by which we live is the law of God God's instruction God's Torah God's directions for for living and those we will those we will be expounding there but we need all three of these together. Let me illustrate in a couple of ways why did I all belong together Paul says first Corinthians 13 if I bestow my goods to feed the poor and have not loved it profits me nothing it's useless now to bestow ones goods to feed the poor that is a worthy goal. But if it's pursued or selfish reasons it in terms of how it looks to God who judges the heart it looks very different. We need the three the three things three things together or you could take an issue such as some procreation. Procreation is certainly a good that is worthy of pursuit in fact God says in the creation mandate be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth. But what is your motivation in bringing children into the world it's a serious question are you bringing children into the world for the glory of God or are you bringing children into the world because of the satisfaction it gives you to have children now if that's the overriding motive then you know what happens if the child is born with some physical handicap.

What's your motive in bringing children into the world are there are there rules to follow in bringing children into the world well first rule is that couples who bring children in the world should be married heterosexual couples that that's God's rule for bringing children in the world and children who are brought in the world some other way we welcome them but they are at a disadvantage in the way in which they have been brought into the world. And you can go on with the questions in terms of the use of reproductive technologies the fact that the goal is worthy of bringing children in the world and that your motivation is for the glory of God doesn't settle all issues you have to think through whether there are any limits in terms of the way in which we may manipulate the process of conception in order to bring children into the world. So lots of issues that belong together that come out in this freefold exploration that's basically the outline that I wanted to present there are a couple of scripture texts that bear more or less directly on this discussion. The first is Romans 12 verses 1 and 2 so let's look at Romans 12 1 and 2 these are these are familiar verses to us and yet they're so profound in terms of what they present before us in terms of our developing a Christian ethic. Romans 12 1 therefore I urge your brothers in view of God's mercy or in the King James by the mercies of God that you present your bodies a living sacrifice holy pleasing to God which is your reasonable service the three things about human nature that are indicated in Romans 12 1. First of all human nature is affectional notice Paul makes his appeal to the mercies of God I urge you by the mercies of God the tender mercies of God that to get the proper response Paul seeks to evoke the motivation of gratitude what are the mercies that he's talking about. Well back in chapter 5 Paul says that while we were helpless and hostile sinners Christ died for us we couldn't save ourselves none of that we didn't want to be said we were God's enemies Christ died for us. Paul begins by and this is characteristic of Paul in ethics he begins by addressing the affectional level by the mercies of God that you present your bodies as living sacrifices there is the volitional element that's a matter of conscious choice. There's a sense in which we God has created us to be self-determining beings that's different from being autonomous self-governing beings he retains his sovereignty over us but he calls us to choose the good. Once our Francis Schaeffer says that there are three great mysteries in the Christian faith the mystery of how God can be one in three the mystery of how Christ can be God and man and the mystery of how God without any abridgment of his sovereignty can create beings whose choices have true moral significance. We may not be able to put that together in a totally satisfying way but both aspects of that mystery we must adhere to just as we adhere to God as one in three in Christ as God and man without being able to explain all difficulties that those issues involve. And this is the volitional element that Paul addresses it's a conscious presentation of our self the God which he says is our a reasonable service human beings are rational and the ethics is not a matter of unthinking offering of ourselves to God it requires deliberation as well as choice it requires discernment. Thinking through issues and how the rules apply in any given case the I.B. translates this word spiritual service I think that's a mistake Paul uses a different word for spiritual and pneumatic costs is the Greek word he uses for spiritual this is logica and you can see the the root of logic in there has to do with the mind. So our ethics must take account of these three components if we can use that term of human nature that we are affectional, volitional and rational beings then Paul goes on verse two to say three important things about the will of God do not conform any longer to the pattern of this world that's the way we've been living. Paul says until we become united to Christ do not conform any longer to the pattern of this world would be transformed by the renewing of your mind then you will be able to test and approve that is to identify and to put into practice God's will and God's will is described with three be good. That's the distinctive thing about biblical Christian ethics the only authentic understanding of ethics is that we identify the good with the will of God everything every aspect of the good has to be identified with the will of God what he sets forth as receiving his approval. Now the the profit Amos long ago called for adherence to what in philosophy is referred to as the first principle of practical reason see good not evil hate evil love good that's Amos five fourteen and fifteen and good is the most comprehensive term for what human beings ought to be and to do so we identify the will of God with the good that's like a six eight he has shown you oh man what is good and what does the Lord require of you but to do justice to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God that's the good that is the goal that we seek in everything that we do the will of God is first is further describe as the acceptable or what is better probably a better translation the pleasing that is pleasing to God but that adds to the thought of that the will of God is the good or defines for us the good is that whether it's pleasing to God or not is a more personal aspect of that same thought. It's God's approval that counts in ethics not man's approval or our approval it's God's approval and it's the personal relationship that's brought out in the description of the will of God as the pleasing it's what receives his blessing and approval that we we seek in what we. Do in following his will it makes the law giver rather than the law as supreme we're not following rules for the sake of rules we're following rules for the sake of being well pleasing to God there's an additional motivating factor there and it is finally described as a perfect and I think that our understanding of that should be. That it is perfective of human nature that is if we follow the will of God we will find that fulfillment and satisfaction that is lacking in every other system of ethics because it falls short of the glory of God it is the will of God is what is our most basic definition of the good the good is what is pleasing to God and perfecting. Of human nature so that the true fulfillment of human nature consists in being conformed to the will of God which is essentially God's own moral perfection being transcribed for creaturely imitation Matthew 548 says be perfect therefore as your heavenly father is perfect. And sometimes we shy away from it I had a student in Latvia tell me that he it was very much helped in his personal life when someone told him that that word met mature be mature so you could take account of the growing process well I think we must take account of the growing process I think God does deal with us as children is children and he knows that we grow from stage to say we're growing toward the image of Christ. It doesn't make much sense does it to say be therefore mature as your father in heaven is mature it's talking about a standard that's here and we really don't want a mediocre standard we don't want to we're not attracted so much by thought be slightly improved you know the goal is perfection there's something about perfection that draws us out and onward something that's admiral about it even if we don't attain it. It's something that's there for us to recognize and to adhere to and God's standards as the perfect will of God is that which alone will fulfill human nature even though it's only entirely true and glory nevertheless it is the standard toward which we aim. Some you know that I played the tuba this is one of my lesser known gifts indeed one of my lesser gifts but I found great fulfillment in playing the tuba. Some years ago I went down to the Mary tuba Christmas deal that's when all the low brass you know euphoniums and under go and play Christmas music for the folks that are walking the malls and well we attracted attention it's hard to ignore you know a herd of elephants and after each carol you know there would be polite applause. And we accepted that and then we had an intermission and four tuba players from the St. Louis Symphony or other symphonies gave a mini concert and it was it was marvelous I mean the tuba is an instrument that when it's played well with excellence has a considerable range and color to it. And after their pieces of people stoned and applauded and we did who applauded most well it was it was us it was the bad it was those of us who recognize how difficult it was how wonderful it was how inspiring it was to see that kind of excellence well that's that's why we shouldn't shy away from the perfection of the will of God that's there for us to it's the perfection of Christ how can we accept the lesser standard than Christ of course we know we we fall short of the glory of God we fall short of the the image of Christ but that's the goal toward which we are headed and that is God's purpose in us now to work that which is well pleasing in his sight.