<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Sina Sina Bulduu

Council of Chalcedon

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

We are at lecture 18, last of the lectures in this section of our course. The title is two-hole, perfect, and distinct natures, the council of Calcedon. Before I introduce what I want to do today in this lecture, let's join in prayer using an ancient collic or prayer from the fifth century about the time of the council of Calcedon. Let us pray. Bless all who worship thee from the rising of the sun and to the going down of the same. Of thy goodness give us, with thy love inspire us, by thy spirit guide us, by thy power protect us in thy mercy, receive us now and always amen. We've been spending some time thinking about St. Augustine, while St. Augustine was doing battle with the Donatist and the Pelagians and the Pelagians. There was another issue that was troubling the Church, the theological battle. Augustine lived and worked in the West. This particular theological problem affected both the East and the West, but particularly the East. The West was able to settle it at the Council of Calcedon, but the issue lived on in the East and continues to be a matter of discussion and controversy in certain parts of the Church of the East all the way down to the present. This lecture is going to be a kind of roadmap, I hope, to help us get through the theological thicket of Christology in the fourth and fifth centuries. This is not an easy topic. You have already been reading something about it in our text, and I will attempt to say some things that might help us to make our way through this history. There are some very helpful charts and diagrams in the syllabus too that you can use to try to understand exactly what is going on here. The apostolic fathers, when they talked about Christ, they were concerned to assert that he was God, although before the Council of Nicaea, the language was not there for them to know exactly how to say that. On the other hand, and even more so at first, they were very concerned to say that he was a real person because the earliest heresy related to the person of Christ was the heresy of the Nostics or Dositicism, as we call it, that the real Christ could not possibly come into real contact or union. Or union with a sinful or even a material body, and so the fear of having Christ contaminated by contact with a body that necessarily was material, even though it may not have been sinful, was something that most people, many people, could not really conceive of. So the apostolic fathers kept saying in opposition to Nosticism and Dositicism he had a real body just like us. Then we came to Nicaea in the early fourth century, and in opposition to those who were saying that Jesus Christ is similar to the father, but not exactly on the same level with the father. We have the Council of Nicaea bringing forth the great word, Homo UCIC, is of the same substance as the father. But in the aftermath of this, you can understand that another question is going to come, and that is if he is a real person, and if he really is God, fully God, then how do the manhood and the deity combine or unite in the one person of Jesus, of Nazareth? And so we have to come to trace this debate, which goes on for several centuries as the church tries to answer that question. We could call it the two natures debate. One of the early attempts to answer the question came from a church leader whose name was Apolinaris. So we called his teaching Apolinarianism. He was from the city of Leodicea in Asia. And as Apolinaris thought about all of this, he said, if you have two perfect entities, perfect deity, perfect humanity, two perfect entities cannot combine. You can't have two full whole entities, things coming together in any way because that can't happen. Apolinaris did not find that in the Bible, but that was a kind of philosophical concept that guided his thought. And so he said, with that in mind, Christ's human body, his human nature, his human side must have lacked something, a place for the divine to fit in. And the more he thought about it, the more he thought that Christ really was a kind of human body, but the man Jesus did not have a human soul, human body without a human soul. So the human soul was missing and the soul of the man Jesus was the divine Christ, the second person of the Trinity. One of the best ways to illustrate the teaching of Apolinaris as people have pointed out from time to time, although I'm not sure this goes back to Apolinaris himself, it's like slipping a letter into an envelope. You have the letter that is the divine person of Christ, and the envelope is the human body, the human person. So the divine is placed into the human and serves as the soul or the rational part of the human. Well for some time people thought that might be a way to explain it, but it wasn't too long before others were pointing out that there's a very serious problems with this teaching. That means if you follow Apolinaris that Christ is really not a complete real human being like us, but some sort of partial human being with a divine part that fills up what is lacking in the human part, a kind of God in fleshed. And that, to some people, correctly, seemed too much like the old, doccetic, eresy. That's not a real person, but a divine person who has taken in some kind of way the use of a human body. Well the teaching of Apolinaris was the determined, was attacked by that very determined little group of theologians, the capidotian fathers that we talked about earlier. They saw that this would lead the church into some very serious problems. Gregory of Nazionza said what was not assumed was not healed. In other words if Christ doesn't take our human flesh, our human bodies, our humanity in its totality in his incarnation then he does not provide salvation for whatever he has not assumed. He has to be fully human to be our Savior, just as Athanasia said, he has to be fully God to be our Savior. The church in the Ecumenical Council which met at Constantinople in the year 381, the second Ecumenical Council, condemned Apolinarianism and said Jesus Christ is truly human, not just partly human, but truly and really human. Well that stopped that heresy, at least it answered that particular heresy, but it still doesn't answer the question just how then does this true full humanity unite with his true full divinity? Before we go on to try to deal with that, let me take a moment to explain something else that's happening because what happens here in the Christological debate is not just pure theology, there's a lot of rivalry, personal rivalry and jealousy between church leaders and also rivalry between cities. Particularly the cities of Alexandria in Egypt and Antioch in Syria and then later Constantinople. Alexandria and Antioch were very bitter rivals, something like Chicago Cubs and St. Louis Cardinals, they really had a hard time with each other. Remember that Alexandria expiles the spiritual interpretation of the Bible, Antioch the literal interpretation of the Bible. Alexandria is going to stress the divine side of Christ, the divinity, Antioch the human side of Christ, the humanity. So these two cities are quite different in the way they think of the Bible and how to interpret it and the emphasis that they will place on the person Christ. As this rivalry was going on, another city became very prominent just five years after the Council of Nicaea, Constantine founded his new capital, Constantinople. Nicaea, the Council of Nicaea had actually established a kind of understanding of precedence of the churches. The Church of Rome was to be viewed as number one and the Church of Alexandria is number two and the Church of Antioch is number three and there were some other churches too that we won't talk about this moment. But it was not long before Constantinople had pushed ahead of Alexandria and had become number two. So you can see why rivalry exists there between these two cities and the rivalry between particularly now Alexandria and Constantinople to take an over from Antioch. And that rivalry soon expresses itself in a very bitter dispute between two Church leaders, one from Alexandria and one from Constantinople. Nestorius was Bishop of Constantinople, he had been trained in the Antiochine tradition and very much insisted upon the full integrity of Christ's human nature. And as Nestorius thought about all of this, he was particularly disturbed because there was an expression that was being used in Alexandria which greatly upset him. That was the Theo Tacos. That was a word that was being used for Mary and it meant the bearer of God or translated into Latin something like the mother of God. So it's proper to think of Mary as the mother of God. The Alexandrians insisted on that phrase not to elevate Mary at this point but to make very clear that the person who was born of Mary was indeed God. So the Alexandrian saw it as a very orthodox statement that insisted on the full deity of Christ as set forth at the Council of Nicaea. But Nestorius was afraid that that expression would confuse people's understanding of Christology. He said if you're going to use Theo Tacos, you need to also use Anthropos Tacos. That is Mary is not only the bearer of God but also the bearer of man. And he said really it's best to avoid both expressions and just talk of Mary as Christos Tacos, the bearer of Christ, the person who was born of Mary was Christ, who is both God and man. Nestorius also said just to be on the safe side let's not use the word union because if we talk of the union of the human and the divine, if we use that word union then we're going to be in danger of bringing together those two in an improper way. He was concerned that there not be a mingling or a confusion of the human and the divine. So when speaking of the Godhead and the man who had in Christ since union can imply some confusion it's better to use a word like conjunction, the human and the divine conjoined rather than unite. Well he was very much opposed in all of this by Cyril who was the Bishop of Alexandria. So we have a royal battle between Nestorius, the Patriarch or Bishop of Constantinople and Cyril the Bishop of Alexandria. It's really not very edifying to read this particular place in church history because the debate on the two natures is probably one of the most bitter in all of the history of the church and Cyril certainly doesn't help matters. Cyril was a very intelligent acute theologian who is more often right than wrong but a very hard-headed stubborn and belligerent type of church leader. So it's hard to admire and like Cyril because of his personality while at the same time being very impressed with his intellect and his intelligent writing. What Cyril did was to accuse Nestorius of so stressing the independence of the two natures as to make really he said two signs. If Nestorius felt the Alexandrians were pressing it together too much destroying the reality of the two natures the Alexandrians thought that the Nestorians were pushing the two natures apart in such an extreme way that really you end up with two signs. One illustration that we could use of Nestorianism to try to understand how to see what Nestorianism was standing for is the oil and water illustration. You have two substances put them together but they never really mix the oil is always there the water is always there they stay apart they can be in the same barrel or the same jar but the oil does not mix with the water. Well Cyril was able to win this battle with Nestorius and the council of Ephesus in 431 which was a council that also condemned Pelagianism, condemned Nestorianism and said Jesus Christ is one person not two one person. That was the right decision but it was a rather disgraceful affair the council of Ephesus the third ecumenical council was a kind of farce because membership was stacked on one side against the Nestorians the Nestorians actually arrived a bit late and Cyril had already started the proceedings and condemned them before they got there. So there was not a real valid discussion of these issues. Now before I go on let me ask an answer a few questions first was Nestorius a Nestorian might seem that it's obvious that he was but church historians since this time studying this period have felt that Nestorius probably greatly misunderstood. He was trying to avoid an error and his enemies pressed his views to heretical conclusions. Paul Tillic writes if we say that Nestorius became a heretic we could say that he was the most innocent of all heretics actually he was a victim of the struggle between Byzantium or Constantinople and Alexandria. John Imel Young writes Nestorius himself vigorously denied that he was a Nestorian as his enemies describe Nestorianism he died a man misunderstood by the Western church rejected by the Eastern church and unjustly condemned by the politics of both. I think most people now think that Nestorius indeed was misunderstood and that his teaching can be judged orthodox by the standards of calcidon but if that is true and giving him the benefit of the doubt that his intentions were good to protect the integrity of the two natures. Much of what he said was provocative and he did not always explain himself very well and his terms and his ideas were often open to misunderstanding. Perhaps we could summarize that whole battle between Cyril and Nestorius by saying that Nestorius' ethics were probably superior to his theology and Cyril's theology was certainly superior to his ethics. Some Christians particularly in the East, the far East as we would call it at this time, East Syria and Mesopotamia, what we call the Church of the East, living mainly outside the bounds of the Roman Empire in the Persian Empire, broke away from the Catholic Church. That is why we have a church that we can now call the Nestorian Church of the East. That church was heavily influenced by the theological school of Odessa, one of the main centers of Antiochine Christology and by Theodor Mapsuestia who was a teacher of Nestorius. So the Nestorians center now in Persia and it's really the Nestorians, as we'll see later, who conduct the famous mission to China. Nestorians spread Christianity into the far, far East in the next several centuries and we will look at that later. These people probably should not be viewed as true heretics anymore than Nestorius was viewed today by church scholars as a true heretic but as a person misunderstood and misrepresented. With Nestorianism put down, there was the opportunity now for the Alexandrian side emphasizing the oneness, the divinity and the oneness to come to the fore and that's exactly what happened with a mountain named Utikis and a teaching called Utikianism. This monk was pro-syril but went further than Cyril and as a result fell into the chasm that yawns on the extreme edge of Alexandrian Christology that is to deny the reality of the two natures. What Utikis said was that the human nature is there but at the incarnation it is absorbed into the divine nature. This is the way he put it, before the union of the two natures, I recognize two natures. You have the human and you have the divine but in the incarnation after the union there's only one nature and he went on to say something that people could not let stand. The flesh of the Lord is not like ours, it's a divinized nature, a human nature that has become divine. We could use the illustration here of wine and water. You mix wine and water, you get something else altogether. The two don't stay apart, they actually mix, it's not like oil and water, wine and water. Christology is the Utikian Christology and the incarnate Lord, the divine and human merges into one single unique nature which is as Utikis says not like ours. Well, it looked like that view might win for a while, in fact there was a church council that met at Ephesus in 449 which supported Utikianism. But very much angered the Pope in Rome, Pope Leo I, one of the first of the great strong Catholic popes of Rome and Leo called it a robber-centered and a den of thieves because he understood correctly that Utikianism was not true Orthodox theology. Leo had intended that his writing on the subject called his tome, T-O-M-E, Leo's tome, be read at the council and harken to after all he was the Pope of Rome when the council just ignored him and his tome he was understandably irritated and set out to try to reverse what happened at the council of Ephesus in 449. The story is by this time exiled to the Egyptian desert where he ended his life, read Leo's tome and it was greatly encouraged he rejoiced because he felt that Leo was saying what he had said or closer to what he had said against the Christology of Utikianism which we can now call the Christology of monophysites. Monophysites are the one nature people, mono one and the word of the Greek language which means nature. Monophysites are monophysicism, one nature people like the Utikians. The result of Leo's determination to reverse all of this was the council of Calcidon in 451 which condemned Utikianism and stated that Jesus Christ has two distinct natures. Now, all of us is led up to this point, 451 council of Calcidon. That's the background of it. It is complex and it is confusing I know and I really have left that a good bit of it. So let's look at the council of Calcidon in 451. The fourth ecumenical council, the largest that it met up to this time over 500 bishops present although all but four came from the east. The west is in a state of being convulsed by the Barbarian Visions in 451 so most of what happens here comes from bishops and theologians from the east and the council of Calcidon created the statement that most of the church has accepted right down to the present. So it parallels Nysia, 325 Nysia, Trinity, 451 Calcidon, Christology. And it says this, Christ is one person in two perfect natures that's against the Polynesianism. Polynesians remember said the human nature is not perfect there's a vacuum there into which the divine nature enters. But Calcidon said no one person in two perfect natures and then adds these famous words without confusion or conversion. That is the two perfect natures are not confused are not mingled. This is against Uticianism, no water and wine view is to be allowed. But then Calcidon goes on to say that Christ is one person in two perfect natures without division or separation. That is against, of course, the story in this and that these two perfect natures come together in a real basic hyphostatic union. Now if you ask me to define the word hyphostatic, I can't really do it. It simply means that this is a real union, not a voluntary kind of union. Perhaps you can see what we mean by this if you say that there is a hyphostatic union or a real union between your body and your soul. You didn't decide to unite these two things so it's not voluntary, it's just there. It's just what is a real union. And so the union of the divine and the human in Christ is a real union. Calcidon, it seems to me, does not explain how this works, certainly doesn't solve the problem, how the divinity and the humanity were united in the one person of Jesus of Nazareth, something that really is inexplicable. We can illustrate the heresies, letter and envelope, oil and water, wine and water, but I really don't have an illustration for the true doctrine. It's always very hard to illustrate truth in theology. It's much easier to illustrate heresies in theology. I'm not saying there isn't one that can be used, but it's very difficult to think of exactly how to illustrate this because we're dealing with a mystery. And Calcidon acknowledges that doesn't explain how the divinity and humanity were united, but it states that they were united. Really united and that they were united without confusion, change, division or separation. I like the way the Dutch theologian GC Birkauer puts it. He says the Calcidonian pronouncement is comparable to a double row of beacon lights which mark off the channel in between and worn against the dangers which threaten to the left and to the right. There's kind of a channel there, and if you go too far this way, you're going to fall into eutichianism. If you go over here, you're going to crash on the rocks of historianism between those lights. There is a safe channel, even though Calcidon does not empty the doctrine of its mystery. It at least tells us that there are bounds and we cannot go past those bounds on either side. Now it'd be nice to say this solved everything. Never quite that simple. And the battle raged for a long, long time after for 51 in the east. The west accepted Calcidon, so it's not really a problem with Rome in the west. The far east had already become the historian and broken away the church over in Persia. But it's now the near east that struggles with this and continues the controversy. And it is a very dismal story because you have church leaders and political leaders all involved in this. This is both a religious and a political struggle. It's often as not the emperor in Constantinople is trying to settle things usually on the wrong side. But the battle is between the Calcidonians and the monophysites. People that say as Calcidon did that Christ is one person in two natures and the monophysites who say he's one person in one nature. So it all boils down to two natures or one nature. Eventually there will be another church council, Constantinople number two in the year 553 that says that Calcidon is right and the monophysites are wrong. That didn't settle it either. And so over a hundred years later in 680 there's another church council, Constantinople three which once again reaffirmed Calcidon. That didn't totally settle it either. By this time there are some churches beside the historian church that have broken away from the Catholic church to found their own monophysite churches. And by then a lot of unsavory things have taken place in this long dispute in the history of theology of Pope of Rome. Excommunicated the patriarch of Constantinople over this issue. The patriarch in turn in effect excommunicated Pope of Rome. Another Pope of Rome was kidnapped by agents of the emperor in Constantinople. Now brought to Constantinople where he was vlogged and imprisoned and starved until he finally died in prison, Pope of church of Rome, kind of last of the martyrs according to some people as far as the Bishop of Rome is concerned. And then there was a theologian and a monk whose name was Maximus who was arrested by the emperor. His tongue was torn out because he kept saying the wrong thing and his right hand was cut off because he had signed some documents that the emperor disagreed with. All of that has to do with discussion of the two natures of Christ, rather overwhelming to think of the bitterness and the extremes to which people went in order to win their point in this debate. By the time the dust has settled down, as it eventually does, there were separate monophysic churches, primarily in Egypt and in Syria, although also in Armenia and Ethiopia and India, these churches are now called the Oriental Orthodox churches. So you might say by this time we've got four churches, we've got the Roman Catholic church, we've got the Eastern Orthodox church, those two have not split yet, that will really not happen until 1054 but with popes and patriarchs excommunicating each other, we're not going to be too long before we see the division between those two major bodies of the church. By this time we have an historian church, way over in Persia, and we have the monophysic church, Syria, Egypt, Ethiopia, Armenia and India. These monophysic churches still exist, there are these five church bodies today, they like to make the sign of the cross which they do in their service, they will do it with one finger to indicate the one nature, and they make the sign of the cross, there's one finger, not two fingers, that would be the calcedonian heresy, and they don't use three fingers which would stand for the Trinity, they're different ways to make the sign of the cross but the monophysic use one finger. So when you see the one finger on a coptic church or Ethiopian church, then you know that they're making a theological statement. There is a coptic church very close to Covenant Seminary, it's over in Greek war, some of us went over for a visit the other day and the other class that I teach and talked to Father Cedric there and saw the church. It is the church that is called St. Mary and St. Abram, coptic orthodox church, and that church, coptic or Egyptian church, is part of the group of Oriental orthodox churches. It's interesting that the leaders of these churches and some leaders from the world alliance of reform churches have been in discussions for some time to try to see if they can solve the old dispute going back to Calcadon. That group, those groups will meet again in the year 2000 in Scotland, which they hope to by that time have some sort of statement that can satisfy both the reform calcedonians and the monophysic or Oriental orthodox churches. Well, that is something that we'll have to see what transpires, if there can be a true coming together on this or not, certainly seems to me it's going to be important or orthodox Christians to maintain what I think is the orthodox view and that is what Calcedon said for. The Christ is one person in two natures and even in the person of Christ the human doesn't cross over into the divine, nor the divine cross over into the human, but these two natures are there without confusion, but without separation either, simply affirms the mystery. The grass withers, the flower fades, but the word of our God will stand forever. Okay, I totally confuse everybody on that. That is probably the two natures, which a Pope being a calcedonian advocate would stand for. Sometimes the church leaders will use three fingers, and I think that is more prominent in the eastern orthodox church, and that stands for the Trinity, but the one finger for the monophysic, the one nature. Yes. Pope Shannuda, yes. They have their own Pope. Pope Shannuda actually came to the dedication of this church a few years ago. I was over there for that dedication and sawing. Well, that may be, that's the issue that the world reformed alliance is trying to deal with now. Are we saying the same thing, using different words? You know, maybe. These words are hard to use. There's another problem in that sometimes people are using Latin words, sometimes Greek words, that makes it even more confusing. And then any view can be pressed to an extreme and be pressed into heresy. So, it may be that the cops, the Jacobites, the monophysites really misunderstood Calcidon. It may be that the Calcidonians misunderstood the Coptic view. But you see in that quote, how do the cops explain the two natures of our Lord? We believe that he is perfect in his divinity and he is perfect in his humanity. But his divinity and his humanity were united so far, Calcidonians would say, right, in one nature, that's the big problem. Well, they want to stress the union so much so that they really don't like to think of two natures. So, they say one nature. They think if you say two natures, you are going to be on the Nestorian side and really create two persons. The Calcidonians say, if you say one nature, then you mingle the two like Uticius did, and that is a heresy. It's a tough issue. Well, that's kind of a trick. Let's look at it. We've got a minute and see. Meekness and majesty, manhood and deity. Here is the two parts, the manhood and the deity. In perfect harmony. What does that make you sound like? Perfect harmony, Nestorianism. It could really, I would say, if you were singing that back in the 5th century, you'd be accused of Nestorianism. Because you've got harmony here. Now, that was the kind of Nestorian word. Perhaps to protect yourself, you would have to say something like imperfect unity. The Lord of Eternity dwells in humanity. Well, that's okay. That's even biblical language, but in the heat of the battle, that would probably sound like a Polynarianism. Lord of Eternity slips into the envelope, dwells in humanity. Maybe you should sing Lord of Eternity, became humanity, kneels in humility and washes our feet. No one will ruin that song for you, but I think if you're going to be very precise in terms of Christology, you have to think about those words. Yes, Utichianism and the monophysicism are the same, one nature. We've got a lot of big words now. You can impress your friends with it.