<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Przekaż Darowiznę Przekaż Darowiznę Miesięcznie

The Church, III

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Covenant Theological Seminary presents Calvin's Institutes with Dr. David Calderon. Okay, once again, on the Church Book 4, perhaps we'll get into sacraments today. I think we will. If we don't, we will look at sacraments, baptism and Lord's Supper on Tuesday, and civil government next Thursday for the last two classes. We have moved through this outline through into Roman numeral four church offices. Head of the Church's Christ, Christ works through the Ministry of Men for three reasons that we've looked at. And now we come down to categories, the different categories of ministry that Calvin sees in the Church. Let's look to the Lord in prayer before we look at what Calvin says about the ministry. And I'll use a prayer from John Calvin, let's pray. Grant Almighty God, since you prove our faith and constancy by many trials. As it is our duty in this respect, as in all others to submit to your will, grant that we may not give way to the many attacks by which we are tossed about. For we are assailed on all sides by Satan and all the empires, and while their fury is ever burning and raging cruelly against us, may we never yield to it. May we proceed in our warfare, in reliance on the unconquered might of the Spirit, even though evil doers prevail for a season. May we look forward to the event of your only begotten son, not only when he shall appear at the last day, but also whenever he shall please you for him to assist the church and raise it out of its miserable afflictions. And even if we must endure our distresses, may our courage never fail us until it lengthen. We are gathered into that happy rest which has been obtained for us through the blood of the same, your only begotten son, our Lord Jesus Christ, amen. We look at the categories of ministry. Calvin says God for good reasons works through the ministry of people, and then he proceeds to describe the different offices or categories. And he divides these into two large categories. One is temporary, and another is permanent. He talks about temporary offices which he also calls extraordinary, and then permanent offices in the church which he also calls ordinary. So I'll comment first on Calvin's category of temporary or extraordinary offices, and here he places apostles and evangelists and prophets, those are the three temporary or extraordinary offices. Calvin says in 434, which God raised up at the beginning of his kingdom, and now and again revives as the need of the time demands. So it's kind of a startling statement, isn't it, because we think of apostles that office not continuing prophets, that office not continuing, and then we'll have to see what Calvin means by evangelists, because in some sense we see that office as continuing. But Calvin says these offices were temporary, but God can raise them up again if he so chooses. And as you probably know, Calvin on several occasions, including an inference in the institutes, several occasions, Calvin remarks that God has indeed done that in the 16th century so that we could think of Martin Luther as a new apostle. It's quite interesting both for Calvin's esteem for Luther, seeing Luther as a new apostle, and the fact that Calvin is willing to see the apostolic office as an office that could under certain circumstances be established again. Calvin, in some ways I think, would put himself in the same category in the other reformers, he writing to the king of Poland in 1554, he talks about the charge which the Lord gave us has been altogether extraordinary when he employed our work to restore the churches. So Calvin sees the work of the apostles in establishing the church in the first century, and then the church had so deteriorated to history that by the 16th century it practically had to be reestablished. And so there is the possibility of the office of apostle being reinstituted. Now Calvin never connects that new office or that reinstituted office with revelation of scripture, inspiration, or anything like that. But he does see a kind of extraordinary role for some people, namely Luther, in bringing back what had almost been destroyed in the church. Well, with that introductory comment on Calvin's view of the extraordinary offices, let's look at apostles, prophets, and evangelists, and see how Calvin treats these.

The apostle for Calvin was the person, primarily the persons, primarily given the Great Commission. The Lord said to the apostles, go and breach the gospel to every creature. And then he sees evangelists, the category of evangelist is, as he puts it, next to the apostles in office, there are the apostles, and then there are evangelists that assist the apostles. For instance, Peter, as an apostle, and Mark as an evangelist, Mark is Peter's assistant, or Paul as an apostle, and Timothy and Titus as an evangelist. They're very close to the apostles, they assist and work alongside of the apostles, but they are not described as apostles in the New Testament. By defining apostles the way Calvin does, I think it creates something of a problem. He links it so closely to the Great Commission that apparently in Calvin's mind as in the mind of a good many 16th century people, the Great Commission to go into all the world and breach the gospel everywhere was given to these apostles and only to these apostles. And that's what they did. They went and preached the gospel in other places, starting in Jerusalem, in Judea, and then to the outermost part of the earth, but limiting the Great Commission to the apostles, hinders a development, I think, in Calvin of full appreciation of the fact that that commission is meant for all Christians, we think, not just for the apostles, so it's not that clear that the apostles went into all the world. In fact, the apostles were pretty reluctant to move out of Jerusalem, it took God's special effort to get Peter and the others beyond the limits of Jerusalem, even going elsewhere into Judea. So there isn't the rapid obedience of the apostles but a kind of slowness to obey that has to be overcome by some special works of God in the hearts of these people. And to not link the Great Commission to the ongoing responsibility of the church to take the gospel into all the world, kindered, I believe, the development of the Protestant missionary movement. Calvin was missionary-minded in many ways but his understanding of the role of the apostles as fulfilling what we call the Great Commission was, I think, exegetically a mistake and did not allow that text to function fully as a missionary mandate. It did not really come into its own, you might say, until the 19th century. When Christian people began to think, well, this is for us too, we need to obey this. It's not only for the apostles, but it's for all people, and the apostles fell for a short of fulfilling that. In fact, they could not just 12 men, 11, and then another added could not have taken the gospel into all the world. I developed that idea in some detail of an article in Presbyterian that I wrote, good many years ago now, 1979. The first came to the seminary called John Calvin, missionary hero or missionary failure developed that idea further. Some ways Calvin has, in his theology, a great deal of missionary theology, missionary dynamic, and in his own practice, missionary heart. But at this one place I think there is a kind of misconception of the understanding of the Great Commission by limiting it to the apostles. But anyway, that's Calvin's view, the apostles were the people commissioned by God to take the gospel into all the world. I think that's the way he can see the office of a apostle being reconstituted in times of great emergency. When the gospel has been lost, and you might say it has to be taken again, we have to start over just like in the New Testament period. And so God raises up this time a man named Martin Luther, and he's the one that reestablishes the gospel of Calvin says we can call it an apostle. That's the sense in which Calvin would see Luther as an apostle. He had no thought that the words of Luther could be inspired, as the words of Paul were inspired. But Luther was a man called to do a job in a critical age when everything practically had been lost, just as the apostles were men called to establish the gospel where it did not exist. Well, what does Calvin say about prophets? This is another temporary extraordinary office. Prophets are those who excelled in a particular revelation, he says. So we've got a category now of New Testament offices, people that excel in a particular revelation. Does that class end? Does that office end? Well, Calvin says that's temporary and extraordinary. But then in 434, he puts it this way, this class either does not exist today or is less commonly seen. So he kind of opens the door again for the reemergence of the office of New Testament prophet. You try to describe what I think Calvin means when he says that. And the best way is to look at his commentaries on a number of New Testament passages, 1st Ephesians 4-11. He describes prophets this way, outstanding interpreters of prophecies who by a unique gift of revelation applied them to the subjects on hand. So that sounds like he's saying the prophets were people that God spoke to in order to give them an understanding of the revelation of Scripture so that they could apply that revelation in a very direct and powerful way. But Calvin goes on in that same passage of Ephesians 4-11 to say, but I do not exclude the gift of foretelling so far as it was connected with teaching. So apparently his understanding of the New Testament prophets was a person that could apply the Scripture in a direct and powerful way. And yet there would also be the possibility of what we call predictive prophecy. And you know we see that at the New Testament prophets with people like Ag of us and others who foretell the future. Well let's look at his commentary on 1st Corinthians 12-10. I take the term prophecy to mean that unique and outstanding gift of revealing what is the secret will of God so that the prophet is so to speak God's messenger to men. There it seems to come very close to what we call prophetic preaching, not he doesn't mention foretelling here, but being able to take the secret will of God, which I understand Calvin to mean by that will God that he has revealed in the Scripture so that the prophet is so to speak God's messenger to men. Calvin may mean more than that, he may mean there is some revelation to that prophet apart from what appears in the Scripture. But he seems to be bringing two ideas together constantly as he looks at New Testament prophets. One is what we would call prophetic preaching today and the other is predictive prophecy. Commentary on 1 Corinthians 12-28. I'm certain in my own mind that Paul means by prophets not those endowed with the gift of foretelling, but those who were blessed with the unique gift of dealing with Scripture, not only interpreting it, but also by the wisdom they showed in making it neat the needs of the hour. There he definitely rejects the idea of foretelling and defines the prophet as a powerful preacher, a person that understands the Scripture and knows how to apply it to meet the needs of the hour. But then he goes on to say this. From this verse, 1 Corinthians 12-28, let us therefore learn that prophets are one, outstanding interpreters of Scripture, and two, men endowed with extraordinary wisdom and aptitude for grasping what the immediate need of the church is and speaking the right word to meet it. That is why they are so to speak, messengers, who bring news of what God wants. So that whole passage deals with powerful preaching, correct interpretation, powerful preaching. So that we could think of the number of people, John Piper, people like that, that would seem to be modern day prophets in that sense, powerful preaching and application, the word of God, to what we need. We should also add Brian Chappell and many others that we could think of. Well, what does Calvin mean when he says this class does not exist today or is less commonly seen, and I'm not sure how to solve that. Calvin seems in some places to say there is also that predictive element, and I'm not absolutely sure that Calvin is saying that occasionally there could be people in later epochs of church history who would be prophets in that sense, or if he's saying the New Testament prophet was primarily a person who could powerfully proclaim. The reveal truth of God, and if that's his meaning, is this office not often seen. There is quite a debate you might know related to people like John Knox. Did John Knox really think that he was a prophet? He would often use that expression about himself. And even at times predict the future, so there are some people that think that Knox saw himself as a prophet, really certainly saw himself and Calvin and Luther and the other reformers as a prophet in the sense of proclaiming the reveal truth of God, but Knox seems to go a bit further than that. My own thought on Knox is that he does not view himself as receiving revelation from God about the future which he can then speak to the people, although he does give some very explicit prophecies as to what's going to happen to certain people. Mainly the enemies of the Reformation and what he prophesies is that they'll come to no good end, but can be rather precise as to how that's going to happen. My guess is that what Knox is doing is taking Scripture, Knox found in the Old Testament particularly a kind of pattern for the history of Scotland. So if he gets everything lined up just right, you know, then he's got a kind of history beforehand. And I believe that's what Knox is doing. He's reading Scripture in a certain way and he says, here's Jezebel, and here's what Jezebel did, and this is what happened to Jezebel, and here's Mary Queen of Scots, and that's what she's doing. This is what's going to happen to her. So my idea is that Knox's view of himself as a prophet was not that he was having words from God saying this is going to happen, but this is how God has worked in the past in Scripture, and this is how he will work again, and he makes some pretty astute guesses as to how things will turn out and sometimes seems to hit it right on the head. But that's a different issue, although it's related to what we're talking about here. So I think about the best we can do on prophets is to say Calvin saw these people as New Testament people present, of course in the Old Testament too, but in the New Testament as well. And they were people that could understand and proclaim the Word of God with urgency and appropriateness and power, and at least in some passages, he says they can also predict the future. So God enables them to do that. This class either does not exist today or is less commonly seen. That's the problem. I expect what Calvin means there is that if you take both parts of this definition of prophet, you don't have much of that. Maybe nine. It's like with the apostles. Don't see apostles. But occasionally one appears and Luther is case in point. You don't see prophets in the sense of both powerful preaching and the predictive element, but Calvin doesn't seem to want to rule it out entirely as an impossibility question. But can Calvin be a little bit hesitant because of the end of office because a lot of them claim to be prophets? The question is, could Calvin be hesitant on this because of the claim of the end of Baptist? Are you saying that Calvin would want to reject that claim and consequently he's trying to restrict this as much as possible, but he doesn't really have to be on their side. Yes, I think that is true. The end of Baptist or the radicals to extend the definition even further did claim some of them that they were recipients of revelation and that their words could stand alongside his scripture. Calvin certainly would want to fight against that. He certainly doesn't want to open this door too far, but he doesn't seem to want to close it just tightly shut and say he can't be again. But certainly Calvin's context is influencing him there. Well, we have a temporary extraordinary. We've looked at apostles and their associates evangelists and we've looked at prophets. So let's move to the permanent and ordinary offices of the church. Calvin doesn't really like the word clergy. You might pick up on that. He says, I would have preferred that is pastors, elders, and so on, deacons, preferred them to be given a more proper name for this appellation arose from error or at least from the wrong attitude. That's wrong with using the word clergy for the ministry. Now what that means was word clergy mean. Well, it means belonging to the Lord and Calvin says the whole church belongs to the Lord. So we should not use clergy, a word that comes from Greek word that means belonging to the Lord or the inheritance of the Lord. See that in 1 Peter 5, 3. That's not a appropriate word for part of the church. That's a word that should be used for all of the church. He might say that Calvin was not attempting to abolish the clergy. He certainly has offices that he thinks should be preserved. He's not attempting to abolish the clergy but what he is attempting to do is to abolish the laity. So everybody becomes clergy but within clergy, all those who belong to the Lord, they're some that are called to specific offices. Calvin doesn't talk as much as Luther does about priesthood of all believers but I think you can get the same idea from time to time. She certainly can't hear. She should not make a distinction between some in the church and others and say these belong to the Lord and these belong to the church or these belong to the pastor or something else. Everyone belongs to the Lord. And within that category of the church, everyone belonging to the Lord, there are certain specific offices to which certain people are called and these are permanent and these are ordinary in the sense of not being extraordinary. These are typical modern day puzzle, modern day profit, be very typical. These don't exist anymore or at least not very often do they appear. But with these ordinary offices, we have a whole continuity of people that fill these offices. First, pastors, some ways, very significant ways, pastors correspond today to the role of apostles and evangelists in the New Testament period. Calvin says in that they are sent by the Lord and are his messengers. But the difference would be this. Calvin saw the apostles and their associates, the evangelist, is having no set limits. They are sent into all the world. But pastors call to a particular church, although Calvin makes it quite clear that even though a pastor is called to a particular church, he is at the same time a minister to the whole church. And that's how we conceive ordination in the Presbyterian Church today. A man is called and ordained, some of you will be, or long, to a particular church, but your ministry is not limited to that church. You are ordained to be a minister of the whole church. And in the Presbyterian system, of course, we have plenty of opportunity to do that in your work in Presbyterian and General Assembly. And Calvin seems to me is very clear on this, but he does want to see the office of apostle and evangelist as open-ended. And without limit, and the office of pastor is more specified and definite. The pastor in Calvin's understanding is responsible for preaching and for the sacraments and for church discipline. He's going to share his role as one responsible for church discipline with some other officers of the church, but that would be included in the list of responsibilities for pastor. Calvin puts it this way. The function of the pastor or minister is to instruct the people to true godliness, to administer the sacred mysteries, and to keep and exercise upright discipline for three, six. So it's all there. The two marks of the church and the third later mark, Calvin doesn't make a separate mark, but brings very close to the two marks to preserve the church. The pastor has the ultimate responsibility in all of that. The church is going to remain a true church, and the word must be preached, the sacraments administered correctly, and discipline exercised. In thinking of preaching the word, Calvin asks this question, why are pastors so important in the church? Does not everyone have a chance to read the scriptures for himself? Why do we need preaching if we have Bibles? Can't we just have people read the Bible and apply it for themselves? Yes, Calvin says that is true. They should do that. But this is from the commentary on 2 Timothy 2, 15, pastors carve and divide the word, like a father dividing the bread into small pieces to feed his children. That's a rather beautiful image that Calvin uses. People can read the Bible for themselves, but they don't always get it right, and they don't always understand it, and it's complicated, and it's big, and it's hard. But the pastor stands up and takes the bread and divides it into tiny pieces and ends it down to his children. So, keep that in mind when you prepare your sermons, that is what you're going to be doing. Calvin has an office here that has not continued to be utilized in the reformed tradition. He thinks that the office of teacher is a permanent office. And an ordinary office, he sees it as a separate office, both in the institutes and in his ecclesiastical ordinances. Which he brought out in 1541 for Geneva. I think Calvin was conscious and believed that the office of pastor and teacher could often be combined in the same person, as in Calvin's own case. I think we would say he was pastor and he was teacher. It's how he describes himself in his will, his final will, his pastor and teacher for the city of Geneva. By the way, you know Calvin really, as far as we know, and I think we know this, was never ordained. He just skipped over all that. He believes in ordination and he teaches ordination. But he was never a priest in the Catholic church. He was trained as a lawyer. And then he was kind of taken hold of by Farrell and thrust into the work of the church. And there was nobody to ordain him. He ordained other people, but he was not ordained by anyone. He doesn't really say that, doesn't make that point. But we can see that by reading the history of Calvin. But his role was as a as pastor, teacher. You know, Calvin doesn't do something in his description of the pastor that modern pastors would think rather astounding. And that is, he doesn't say anything about church administration or organization. And he had to do a lot of that. But that doesn't really come forward here. He's conscious of the importance of preaching, administering the sacraments and exercising discipline. And I suppose under exercising discipline, he would think of the organization of the church, the administration of the church. All the responsibilities that go into that. Somebody has said that we can kind of see the shift in the ministry and the modern period from preacher to administrator. I noticed seeing how pulpit said shrunk to something more like this. And offices have gotten bigger. And maybe that is an illustration of the signs of the time. Well, you get back to teachers. The teachers, I believe, in Calvin's view, correspond to the prophets, not in the predictive sense, but in the sense of skill and applying the scripture to the needs of the people. And to the times, the ministry of the teacher is scriptural interpretation and teaching. And the pastor, of course, does that. But Calvin saw the possibility of a separate office for teacher so that this person would have responsibility not for the sacraments and not for discipline. But along with the pastor for the exposition of God's word, the fact that this has dropped out, you know, has really left almost no clear place in the ministry of the reformed church for a seminary professor. We have to be called as evangelist because we do have a category for evangelist. But that's not exactly what we are. We're more like Calvin's teachers. And I would like to see that recovered with a separate calling for a teacher. Some churches now, as you know, have teachers, basically it's what Dr. Doriani was at the court before he became senior pastor at central. He was theologian in residence, I think, was his title, but he was a teacher serving as a teacher in a local church alongside of the pastor who was and is also teacher. Calvin, as the pastors think of or use the word shepherding or discipling, we would think of them today. Well, I'm sure he does. He would use shepherding and discipling. We would take some searching to find the specific places where he would do that. But he does it in the institutes. He certainly would in the commentaries. I think he would see that as a role for pastors that would come under discipline, shepherding, discipling, sounds like discipline. And Calvin, as I will point out in a moment, I think I already said this too, exercise of church discipline is not just correcting people when they go wrong. It's helping them go right. So he's very concerned with that positive aspect of discipline as well as the negative aspect of discipline. Along with pastors and teachers, there's a third office, elders, primary responsibility of the elders is the spiritual welfare of the people along with the pastors. The elders are concerned about the spiritual welfare of the people and consequently with church discipline. Calvin says in 438 that the elders are chosen from the people. Calvin's Presbyterianism is not fully fleshed out and it's limited by certain church state problems that he struggled with in his day. So not everything is done in Geneva as would be done later. We get the first full expression of Presbyterianism that seems very comparable to what we have today in the second book of discipline of Andrew Melville in Scotland. But Calvin has certainly pointed in the direction that Melville will later follow. I said that because when Calvin says that elders should be chosen from the people, it's not exactly the way it worked in Geneva. Geneva had a concessory like a session or a Presbyterian and there were 12 elders, but they were chosen by the councils. It would be like elders for the church today being chosen by county government and thinkable for us. But in those days of union of church and state you have a much closer connection between church and state of course and the elders were not chosen by the people but by the councils. It was not the way Calvin wanted it and he attempted to change it but was not able to completely reverse that policy by 1560. The elders were chosen by the little council. There were three councils in Geneva, three levels of church government. The little council was the more day-to-day operation and the little council chose the elders with advice of the ministers, subject to the approval of the congregation. So at least the congregation had a word there, finally, in 1560. Calvin wrote in a circular letter for several churches. You have among you men who have been chosen and appointed to correct scandals, to warn those who are sinful and to acknowledge those who conduct themselves on Robely. That gives Calvin some emphasis on not only correcting but promoting. So the elders are to warn those who are sinful, correct scandals and to acknowledge and further the work of those who conduct themselves on Robely. Next, the deacons. Calvin has four permanent offices in Baster, Elder, Teacher and Deacon. During the Middle Ages, the New Testament office of Deacon had degenerated into a kind of liturgical adjunct. If you go through the polity of the Catholic church, deacons in the Middle Ages are not anything like deacons in the New Testament, where they have responsibility for the benevolence of the church. And what Calvin does in the office of Deacon is to restore this office to the original function of caring for the sick and caring for the poor. Calvin calls this a highly honorable office. And he also says that the deacons have the responsibility of the church's benevolence, the church's charity, the church's outreach in practical ways, in compassion for the poor and needy. But he says deacons must also be skilled in the Christian faith, so it's not just people that have good business sense, but people who are skilled in the Christian faith, since they will often have to give advice and comfort. It was a kind of a ministry there that the deacons have to in advice and comfort, and that would mean spiritual advice, as well as practical advice. There are two categories of deacons, two classes of deacons. One is the class of financial officers who administer the church's benevolence. These are deacons. They receive the gifts that the church gives for the poor and the needy, and then they distribute those gifts like the deacons in acts. And this was a pretty big undertaking in Geneva. You see today in this country and in almost every country, if not every country, we have all kinds of social programs in effect. So the government does a great deal of what the church would have done back in the 16th century. In Geneva there was what was called the French fund, and the money was collected. And this fund was staffed by deacons of the Reform Church, and it served to provide for poor refugees from Catholic countries, feeding the poor, providing housing, caring for the city, paying school fees, providing vocational training, all these things that kind of provided in social services of the state today. So being done by the church in Geneva in the 16th century, so deacons had to be competent and work hard in order to do all of that. By the late 1550s, the French fund extended beyond the poor to become part of the missionary endeavor, emanating from Geneva. So it took on not only care for the poor and needy aspect, but it became a fund that supported missionaries. And what is particularly in view there is the support to help financial help given two men from France who come to Geneva, train in Geneva with Calvin and the others and then are sent back to their homeland to France, great danger. And you have them died but to establish the French Reform Church that you cannot church in France. That is one category, the administrative officers leading to the development of the French fund, the other category of deacons would be the people who really actually take care of the poor. Almost like social workers or well-fair workers. And this is the office in Calvin's view that women could feel. So Calvin does have a place for women as deacons. I remember he has two categories of deacons. This matter is still discussed today, as you know, whether women should be deacons or not, not going to go into that. But just to remind you of Calvin's view, sometimes Calvin is quoted here, Calvin favored the office of deacons being open to women. It is true, but he had two categories and it was the second category, the actual work that was done by people, which could mean women, and thinking in some ways especially would mean women to reach out personally and practically to people in need in the community, in the church, and the refugees coming into the town. I will come back to women in a moment, but I am going to say word about bishops, first of all. Those are the four offices. The outline perhaps doesn't make this as clear as it could, because bishops is not a fifth office. Calvin says about the role of bishops and what does he say about the role of women in the church? Those are the two things that will take up next. Calvin is very clear on what I think is very clear, and that is the word bishops equals the word elder. We have already seen that Calvin has two kinds of elders. He has the pastor and he has the elder. You have Southern Presbyterian terminology, you have teaching elder and ruling elder, that is certainly present in Calvin. The elder, he says, is the same as bishops. I don't think there is any debate about that, even people that support the development of Episcopacy. As a appropriate church polity, we will say that in the New Testament there were no bishops or put it another way. All elders were bishops. Calvin puts great stress on the parity of ministers, parity of the clergy as a Presbyterian theme. You certainly see that in Calvin. Last, anyone should aggregate to himself the sole bishopric of Christ 426. There is a sense in which Christ is the bishop, the chief elder, there is another way to say it, and all his servants are equal. No one stands above another. His commentary on 1 Corinthians 5.4 says there is nothing in greater opposition to the discipline of Christ than tyranny, and the door is wide open to it if all the power is surrendered to one man. So Calvin opposes the emergence of monarchial bishops, leading eventually to the papacy. It is true though that Calvin has a kind of flexibility here that has not always marked people in the reform tradition. Calvin recognizes Paul's authority over Titus, so goes back to the New Testament period and says the point that he's made about the equality or the parity of all clergy. That's not a word he likes of all ministers, pastors, is qualified by Paul's authority over Titus. He says we learned from this passage that there was not then such equality among the ministers that none had some authority and counsel above the others. Paul was able to tell Titus what to do where to go, how to carry on his ministry. That seems to be the role of a bishop, and Calvin says it's true Paul did have that authority. Well that's right. I think that is right. Paul isn't a apostle. Titus is his associate. The Calvin would say we could bring that up today and say Luther had the same kind of authority over my length and would be an interesting question that Calvin would probably laugh at and say starting to speculate now. But he does recognize that that's a point that those who favor Episcopacy will make and those who favor Presbyterianism often deny we try to assert that there was parity within the New Testament, but Calvin says not that there's certain special authority, but I think you're right. This is in the commentary on Titus 15 and Calvin, yes question here. Is there also just related to elder being elder in the sense of experience, being an elder in the faith being elder in the having more experience in this work as far as, and then Paul was an apostle. What if that was the same situation today as far as a head pastor over an assistant pastor helping him and training him? Well you know that certainly is there too because Paul is the pioneer and he is mentoring these younger men and of course he's going to know more and they're going to defer to him. So I think that point is well taken too. You know as much as we talk about parity of the clergy in the Presbyterian system, we hold of that, we think it's important. One since we don't have that because it's impossible. One man will stand up at General Assembly and say something and everybody's votes for him and somebody else will stand up and say something and nobody pays much attention to him because some people are more persuasive, they're more powerful in their presentations, they serve big churches or something. So I think it's important to have the principle of parity in the clergy that we probably should recognize that it's impossible for everybody to be exactly equal in influence and authority. It's a kind of authority that comes along with some people and they carry a lot of weight but they're still not bishops. Yes, these are parity. Does that commit this insult perhaps more in say a vote whereas a ruling out of elder carries the same weight as a well-recognized senior pastor? Yes, there's certainly parity there because the influential person has one vote as well as the ruling elder who never says anything. So it's important principle but there's a certain reality that goes along with it and I don't think it's something we need to be concerned about just the way things are. Calvin also felt that in the early church there were bishops, I mean there were bishops in the early church, the situation that we find in the New Testament shifts by the second century. So there are monarchial bishops, we use that expression that means single bishop over a number of pastors, single bishop over other bishops, monarchial means one bishop is over against the New Testament idea of all bishops being elders, all elders being equal. Calvin says the ancient bishops, this is four, four, four in the institutes. The ancient bishops did not intend to fashion any other form of church rule than that which God has laid down in his word. So Calvin says there were bishops at Emerge but I'd say there were good bishops, they were bishops that were not lording it over the Lord's flock and demanding authority and creating a tyranny in the church. Because you see Calvin likes to find support in what he calls the consensus of the first five centuries now. He doesn't think that the church always got everything right in the first five centuries but Calvin sees things deteriorating, not right away in the second century but about the fifth century. And looks to the first five centuries as a time in which the church basically was still on track until the papacy becomes the papacy and all the evils that accrue after that. And Calvin could also say that for the sake of order he would be willing, he did not do this in Geneva but if it was necessary for it to be done elsewhere, he would be willing to see a hierarchical government with archbishops and bishops. He wrote two Christians in Poland that felt that that was the way they wanted to structure their polity and basically said that that was all right. And you might remember too that when John Knox did his first book of discipline in Scotland, he had a place for bishops. They were not bishops in the sense of dictatorial bishops but of administrative leaders in the church. Presbyterianism has generally in area opposed to bishops and whenever we hear that word in the modern sense we get very upset. But Calvin is more flexible on that. His own preference is no bishops but rather than destroying the church he would say if it's necessary then he could permit it. Okay, the last few minutes here on the role of women in the church. We've seen that the office of Deacon was open to women based on description of the work of the widows in 1 Timothy 5. Now that's where Calvin would find his scriptural support for this. Those women are not called Deacons but he feels that they're doing the work of Deacons of this sort where the widows whom Paul mentions to Timothy he says in 439. So you have the description of the work of the women 1 Timothy 5. We also have the example of Phoebe commentary on Roman 161. Calvin says exercised a very honorable and holy ministry in the church. And there she's called a Deaconess. It's debated by people as to exactly what that means. Does it mean an office or does it mean simply a servant because the word Deacon means. But Calvin did have a place under the category of Deacons for women as we have seen. The modern day Calvin scholar, LCN McKee, teaches at Princeton, print of mine, wrote this, the subordinate role Calvinist gave to women was typical of the age. It is notable however that John Calvin himself could in theory see women's exclusion from real leadership roles in the church as a matter of decency and order and thus subject to change when social customs changed. I want to kind of keep that in a dance for a moment and test it a bit. But what Dr McKee is saying is that Calvin certainly gives a subordinate role to women. That was typical of the 16th century. But that Calvin in theory could see that women could be included in real leadership roles. I suppose she means there as pastor and as elder and when social customs change that it would be possible for women to serve in these other offices. Now Calvin does have some remarkable passages on women and the role of women. You just read one or two of those. Mark 161 says there's Christ made a start with the women except the resurrection. And not only let them see him but gave them the message of the gospel for the apostles making them their teachers. So here for a moment in time the women are teaching the apostles become the women who go to the empty tomb teach the apostles about the resurrection. Calvin goes on to say though the intention to anoint Christ was not free of censure they were reckoning him still to be dead. He pardons their weakness and honors them with exceptional distinction taking the apostolic office away from the men for the moment and committing it to them. The apostles were to bear witness the resurrection of Christ and the apostles were not doing that. So at least temporarily that office was removed from them and given to the women. It seems that Calvin does suggest there that when men don't do what they should do then God could use women to do what men do not do. Like Deborah yes which was the example that he raised with John Knox when Knox wrote the first blast of the trumpet. Another interesting passage on this is Calvin's comment in the institutes which we read about Paul's teaching concerning head coverings and women silence in the church. These requirements that is women should always have hats on and should keep quiet in church. Apparently for Calvin these were in different matters to be solved practically. These were not permanent injunctions. This is what Calvin says when he writes about this in the institutes. Does religion consist in a woman's shawl so that it is unlawful for her to go out with a bare head? Is that decree of Paul concerning silence so holy that it cannot be broken without great offense? Just ask some questions here he doesn't really give an answer but he suggests an answer. Is there in bending the knee or in bearing a corpse any holy right that cannot be neglected without offense? It's not at all here comes his answer for if a woman needs such haste to help a neighbor that she cannot stop to cover her head she does not offend if she runs to her with her head uncovered. It's not a big deal. It's not time to put on your hat. You want to go out and do a good deed and just don't worry about the hat. In this sentence and there is a place where it is no less proper for her to speak than elsewhere to remain silent. Calvin doesn't flesh that out so we don't quite know what he's talking about but he seems to say there is a time and there is a place for women to speak. The injunction women's head must always be covered and women must always keep quiet with the matters that are indifferent and to be resolved practically and not made a permanent rule. That is 41031 page 1209 but to go back to Dr. McKee's comment that when things change then Calvin would have been able to see women in other roles in the church. It seems to be that it's not true that it overstates the matter. Calvin's view of women in church office except Deacon does not appear to be open to change when social customs change as she said. We have in 41521 and 22 Calvin's argument that women are not permitted to baptize in the Roman Catholic Church. A woman could baptize in an emergency. Of course, the Catholic view was that baptism was absolutely essential for regeneration and if a midwife was delivering a baby and that baby was not going to live and there was no priest there that a woman could baptize and that was permissible. The Calvin said no women cannot baptize because the function of the sacraments is tied to the preaching of the word and if women are not permitted to preach, they are not permitted to administer the sacraments. It seems to me that in a passage like that as well as the commentary on 1 Timothy 2 11 through 15 and 3 1 in 2 where you have Paul's statements about the role of women and the role of church officers that Calvin would not have been open to change when social customs change. But having said that, there is a kind of theme that runs through here in Calvin remarkable for the 16th century and that is appreciation for women for their contribution to the church, for their role in the church. And I suppose I cannot say absolutely dogmatically what Calvin would have or would not have done or said if he had been alive today, that's always a risky sort of thing. But to go back to the 16th century he does believe that women should be in a subordinate role in the church, I don't think influenced primarily by culture but influenced primarily by scripture. But he has certain flexibility there it seems to me there are some places and some times when women can speak appropriately and there is at least the positive message that all God's children are part of the church. We're all clergy we all belong to the Lord and that God has gifted us all in certain ways to serve each other and to serve him in the church. Well Calvin doesn't solve this issue for us and it's one that we're still going to have to talk about long and hard in order to get good understanding of what we should do. Well time is up next time sacraments and then the last class on civil government.