<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
اهدا اهدای ماهانه

Universal Forms of Love, II

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

I'd like to begin class today with the prayer of St. Benedict. His dates are 84, 80 to 5, 43, and yet the content of this prayer is for every age and for good for us today. Let's pray together. O gracious and holy Father, give us wisdom to perceive thee, intelligence to understand thee, diligence to seek thee, patience to wait for thee, eyes to behold thee, a heart to meditate upon thee, and a life to proclaim thee through the power of the Spirit of Jesus Christ our Lord. We started last time in exposition of the universal norms of love and I made a presentation of the Ten Commandments. The Ten Commandments were promulgated at Sinai. I think we need that word. The Ten Commandments, that is the Comprehensive Summary of God's Law, was promulgated at Sinai. But the content of the Ten Commandments, the content of the moral law, quite obviously is assumed and the whole biblical narrative up to this point. So it's not for the first time people learn that it's wrong to murder. It was wrong for Satan to lie to Adam and Eve. He is a liar and a murderer from the beginning because the consequence of his life, his lie, was that death entered into the world. It was wrong for Cain to murder Abel, wrong for the earth to be filled with violence at the time of the flood, wrong for Potiphar's wife to attempt to seduce Joseph and wrong for her to bear false witness against him when he refused. It was wrong for the Egyptians to enslave the Israelites. So the moral law is known, apart from the Ten Commandments, but God's moral law is promulgated, that is given definitive form in at Sinai with the publication of the Ten Commandments. And we went into their distinctives last time. What we want to talk about today, I put under the heading of the Mosaic Administration. One reason why I do this is because the word law is used for both the Ten Commandments and for the whole Mosaic Administration in the New Testament. And so sometimes the law refers to the moral law summarized in the Ten Commandments, which love puts into practice, but sometimes the law refers to the Mosaic Administration. Now my language here is chosen because of the language of the Westminster Confession of Faith. In this section I want to use that language to expand upon this point. And in the Confession of Faith chapter 7, which is on the covenant, paragraph 5, express themselves this way, the covenant of grace was differently administered in the time of the law and in the time of the gospel. Under the law, it was administered by promises, prophecies, sacrifices, circumcision, the Paschal Lamb, and other types and ordinances delivered to the people of the Jews, all four signifying Christ to come. The covenant with Israel is the Mosaic Administration of the Covenant of Grace. We live in the Christian Administration of the Covenant of Grace, that is with Christ the mediator, but God's people from Moses time until the coming of Christ lived under the law that is the Mosaic Administration of the Covenant of Grace. And there are some differences between the new Administration and the old Administration, and I think that this term Administration helps us to keep that in focus. Two things in focus, one is that it's a Administration of the One Covenant of Grace, but it's a temporary Administration and as an Administration it gives way to the new Administration. The new Covenant, we could call it the Christian Administration of the Covenant of Grace, not that Christ is not present in the Old Testament, obviously all those promises and prophecies and typological ordinances pointed forward to him, but he's foreshadowed in the Old Testament, now that he has come, there are some important changes. Now the Christian Church, in keeping with a high view of inspiration, actually the view of inspiration held by Christ in his apostles, receives not only the Ten Commandments, but the whole Old Testament as the Word of God, particularly relevant as Jesus' own Word of caution with respect to the abiding validity of the Torah. Matthew 5.17, don't think that I came to destroy the law of the prophets, I didn't come to destroy, but to fulfill and not a jot or a title will pass away until all have been fulfilled. Now as always, we must compare Scripture with Scripture to avoid misinterpretation and the change from the Mosaic to the Christian administration of the Covenant of Grace, brought with it a change in the form of God's people, under the Mosaic administration, God's people were in the form of a nation, under the new administration, under the Christian administration, that form moves from nation to the community of the Church, so that the change from the Mosaic to the Christian administration of the Covenant brought with it a change in the form of God's people, from nation to church, and a change in the laws to which God's people are subject, the change in the form of God's people, and there's a change in the laws to which we are now subject. Two major changes, one, the abrogation of the ceremonial laws, abrogation of the ceremonial laws are precepts. But once again, I'm using the language of the Westminster Confession of Faith, put myself in the context of our reformed tradition. It's the Confession of Faith, chapter 19, paragraph three, besides this law, the Ten Commandments, commonly called moral, God was pleased to give to the people of Israel as a church under age, ceremonial laws containing several typical ordinances, and notice partly of worship, pre-free-green Christ is grace's actions, sufferings, and benefits, and partly holding forth diverse instructions of moral duties, all which ceremonial laws are now abrogated under the new covenant. All the ceremonial laws, both those that had to do with worship, and others which it was a moral duty to perform, such as the dietary laws, all those are now abrogated under the new covenant. Now let's look at the scriptural basis for this. It is clear that Jesus brought an end to the mosaic administration by fulfilling its redemptive shadows. The book of Hebrews throughout makes that clear. All the sacrifices are, find their fulfillment in Christ. They're not to be offered again. The sacrifice has been offered once and for all. All of the tabernacle furniture is completed in him. Everything that had to do with those ordinances that pointed forward to him are now fulfilled, and so it's no longer a matter of being held to do them. So he abrogated by his fulfillment the distinguishing legislation of the mosaic administration. Looked I would recommend on this topic is Vern Poirthris, the shadow of Christ in the law of Moses. That's the most comprehensive analysis of Christ's fulfillment of the law of Moses that I know of, and it's just excellent in every way. And it includes how the civil law is pointed forward to Christ. It's a very thorough and useful book to have, and it goes into a great detail in terms of how we can learn from the Old Testament without being subjected to it as far as our obedience. So Jesus abrogated the distinctive legislation. That's the whole book of Hebrews. There is this half verse in Mark, Mark 917b that counts for all the more than all the book of Leviticus as far as dietary rules are concerned. Mark 719b in saying this, Jesus declared all foods cleaned. That's it. No more distinction between clean and unclean. No more restriction on pork, no more restriction on shrimp. The whole dietary legislation is abrogated under the new covenant. Now, the significance of this, we ought to more fully, I think, to appreciate indolations. Paul is adamant that the Gentiles do not have to conform to the mosaic administration. Actually, that question had already been addressed in Acts chapter 15. Verse 5 is, I think, the key verse. Then some of the believers who belong to the party of the Pharisees noticed then some of the believers. These are Christians who belong to the party of the Pharisees. There were Pharisees who had become Christians. Some of the believers who belong to the party of the Pharisees stood up and said, the Gentiles must be circumcised and require to obey the law of Moses. We're going to incorporate the Gentiles into the people of God. They have to be circumcised and keep the law of Moses. Well, the apostolic council decided that that was not the case. You don't have to become a Jew to become a Christian. If you are a Christian from outside the Jewish community, you don't have to keep the law of Moses. You don't have to be circumcised. The only rules that they presented to the Gentiles churches were for the sake of not giving unnecessary offense to the Jews. So avoid meat strangled, avoid blood. Some of the Jewish things out of concern for not offending them, they were required to do. But that was a temporary regulation for the sake of the Jews in every place, for the sake of the progress of the gospel. And Paul's treatment of those things is, as you know, very different when it comes to Romans and first Corinthians. But it was a temporary measure to show significance for the Jews. But the Gentiles did not have to become circumcised and keep the law of Moses. In fact, as Paul addresses the assembly, he says that in verse 10, why do you try to test God by putting on the disciples, that is the Gentiles, a yoke that neither we nor our fathers have been able to bear? The mosaic administration, while it had its purpose to lead us to Christ, was a guardian. It did keep the people of God him in certain ways. In Galatians, Paul calls it a pedagogos. Not quite represented by the English word pedagog, we think of a pedagog as a teacher of children. This was more the servant who kept children in line so that they would get an education. And the goal of that guardianship of the law was to bring us to Christ, as Roman says in 10-4. The goal of the law is Christ. Now that the goal has arrived, it brings with it the full status of censorship for both Jew and Gentile. That's Paul's point in Galatians 4 verses 1 to 3. It's also his point in Ephesians 2 verses 14 to 18. The middle wall of partitions, the thing that divided you from Gentile, has been done away. What was it? What was the mosaic administration that put Gentiles in an inferior position? They did not have all the privileges of Jews. Now it was aggravated by the assumptions of superiority that went with it on the part of Jews. Not that they're unique in that at all, but that's a typical response to a position of privilege. Paul Ephesians says that's been done away with. That middle wall of partition has been broken down. And he also makes that point in Galatians 2 verses 16 and 17. So you have this quite important that we recognize that this is not a side issue. There's something fundamental about not being bound to the ceremonial law of the old administration. In Galatians especially, Paul is strong on the point that Gentiles do not have to conform to those old boundaries. And what it amounts to, if we look briefly at chapter 2, what set Paul off on this was Peter's action. In it's recording Galatians 2 verse 11, when Peter came to Antioch, I opposed into his face because he was clearly in the wrong. Before certain men came from James, he used to eat with the Gentiles. But when they arrived, he began to draw back and separated himself from the Gentiles because he was afraid of those who belonged to the circumcision group. The other Jews joined in their hypocrisy so that by their hypocrisy even Barnabas was led astray. There's to be no segregation within the Christian church. Everyone comes into the Christian family of God as an heir of Abraham, heir of the faith of Abraham, and united to Christ Jesus. That's Paul's point in chapter 3 that in verse 26, you're all sons of God through faith in Christ Jesus. For all of you who are baptized into Christ have clothed yourself with Christ. There is neither Jew nor Greek. The three primary markers that distinguish Gentiles from Jews were circumcision. Paul spends a lot of time on that, but also the food laws and the keeping of special days. Those three markers are in Galatians and also in Colossians. And it is clear that those are not to be those divisive things that separated people have been abrogated. It is, I think, great interest to us that although Paul up to this point, up to Galatians 328, has been talking about the divisions of Jew and Gentile as a consequence of the Mosaic administration, he goes on to include, neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, slave and free participate in the body of Christ on equal footing. And he also says there is no male or female. The way that reads in the Greek is whether we put in an English translation, there is neither male or female. There is no male and female. The things that separated table fellowship and co-labors in the body, in the under the old covenant have now been done away with. And we still are working out the implications of what that means. But it is clear that the things that were in the Mosaic law that separated people, primarily Jew and Gentile, have been done away in Christ, they have been abrogated, the goal has arrived and it brings with it the full status of sonship for Jew and Gentile bond and free male and female. Now obviously the law of Moses contained some permanent universal moral norms. Leviticus 1918 I think is the best example. You shall love your neighbor as yourself. That's not abrogated. Okay, it's what's distinctive to the Mosaic administration that's abrogated but not the commandment to love your neighbor as yourself. The moral law summarized in the Ten Commandments and fulfilled in the double commandment to love God and your neighbor as yourself. Those are the permanent commands that continue into the present age. And Jesus alongside precepts from the second table of the decalogue in Matthew 19 verses 16 to 22 puts, puts, you shall love your neighbor as yourself next to his citations from the second table of the decalogue. And as we saw last time the decalogue continues to be used in the New Testament as a summary of the covenant way of life. James calls, you shall love your neighbor as yourself. The royal law of Scripture, this is James 2 verses 8 to 11, and he argues that when Christians discriminate against the poor in favor of the rich, they go against the standard which love fulfills. It won't take time to look at him. And in James 2, 8 to 11, James begins with the royal law. Love your neighbor as yourself. His context is you're discriminating against the poor in favor of the rich. And he says you're not fulfilling the law of love. And if you do this, if you continue in this kind of discrimination and favoritism, you are a lawbreaker because the one who said do not commit adultery also said do not murder. And although you may not commit adultery, you still commit murder and are convicted by the law as lawbreakers. In other words, their attitude toward the poor was when it comes down to it, taking away their life. It wasn't literally murder, but under the principle of the equal regard that we have for human life, they are not fulfilling the royal law of Scripture by their discrimination as showed that they were lawbreakers. And so they're held to the standard of the moral law, although it's important to understand the abrogation of the ceremonial precepts. Now Augustine, and I put him in the book and you can look it up more definitively there, Augustine distinguished clearly between the universal and permanent from the particular and temporary. His terms for it were moral and symbolical. And that designation is very helpful. And he gives examples of both kinds. The command to be circumcised is symbolical. The command not to covet is moral. So the church has always made these the moral law precepts of the law are observed by Christians. The symbolical precepts were properly observed during the time that things now revealed were prefigured. In other words, all scriptures inspired by God and is profitable. But some of it is profitable for our learning, not for our obedience and the dietary laws and the other ceremonial laws, all those symbols are profitable for our learning. Now there is a second category of laws under the mosaic administration. And using once again the language of the west minister confession, we refer to these as the expiration of the judicial precepts or expiration of the judicial laws. The confession of faith chapter 19 paragraph 4 to them also that is to God's people under the law as a church under age to them also as a body politic. He gave sundry judicial laws which expired together with the state of that people, not obliging any other now further than the general equity thereof may require. So what we have in the west minister confession is a pre full analysis of the mosaic administration. There is the universal and moral principles, the ten commandments and their exposition. There is the ceremonial law which is abrogated and there is the judicial laws which expired along with the state of that people. Now those three classes of laws, moral and what Augustine had is just twofold, moral and symbolical, Thomas Aquinas took him we owe the idea of a threefold classification. He refined Augustine and noticed that there is something a little different about Israel's state laws, the civil laws of Israel as a nation state. So you have moral ceremonial precepts and judicial and I think that as I say in the book, I think that Thomas Aquinas is analysis is good. He understands the moral law as the universal principles and they are applied. He calls the ceremonial and the judicial applications of moral principles in the area of worship. And there is a little more of the worship as the west minister confession notes, there are some moral duties that particular of that. And the judicial are matters of justice. They were applications for Israel as a God's special people as a covenantive nation of the moral principles that they are embodied in the ten commandments. So moral universal temporary applications in terms of worship and in terms of justice and the the hermeneutical key to distinguishing the applications from the universal is the place of Israel in the history of redemption. Now Calvin followed Aquinas on that he doesn't put note him but he is that would not have been the politic thing to do but he is he is relying on what by this time 300 years has become standard way of looking at the mosaic administration. And the other reformers also, Malinthan or Sinus, all the reformed confessions embody this threefold distinction. Calvin the way of doing this, the moral law he understood to be the ten commandments and their exposition, it's not just the bare ten commandments because the ten inferences are drawn from the ten commandments. And for example, you shall not steal means you shall have just waits and measurements because not have just waits and measurements is a form of stealing. So the moral are the ten commandments and their exposition. The ceremonial and the judicial he calls supplements to the moral law. What's permanently binding of the ten commandments and their expositions what is clearly derived from them the ceremonial and the judicial he understands to be supplements that were peculiar to the mosaic a and he say will be wrong just to enact the mosaic law for a nation state today. You may judge that something has a general principle of equity about it and thus apply it and that was also a point is a point is said that the ceremonial we may not reintroduce as a matter of obligation but on the judicial laws it takes some discernment there may be a principle of equity there that our government ought to apply today as a matter of wisdom to search for that principle of equity. Now the Westminster that language of the Westminster Confession I say that the laws the civil law expired together with the state when it when it expired except and they're not obligatory on any nation now any further than the general equity may require. It's a rather vague phrase but it's sufficient in terms if you look at their proof text for that they relied mainly on first Corinthians 9 verses 8 and 10 this was the crucial text so let's look at first Corinthians 9 verses 8 to 10. I have to begin at verse 7 so we pick up a little feel for the context first Corinthians 9 verse 7 who serves as a soldier at his own expense who plants a vineyard and doesn't eat of its grapes who tends to flock and does not drink the milk. Do I say this merely from a human point of view doesn't the law say the same thing for it is written in the law of Moses notice how law in this context means the mosaic administrative. It is written in the law of Moses do not muzzle an ox while it is treading out the grain is it about oxen that God's concern surely he says this for us doesn't he yes this was written for us because when the plowman plows and the fresher thresches they ought to do so in the hope of sharing and the harvest. Now comes the point that was the long slow curve now here's the fast break if we have sewn spiritual seed among you is it too much if we read a material harvest from you he's arguing about the support of the Christian ministry through the gifts of God's people the financial support of the Christian ministry on the basis of don't muzzle the ox when he treads out the corn. There's a general principle of equity that text in Deuteronomy creates a sensitivity to people's needs through animals Paul's Paul's argument is actually from the lesser to the greater he puts it in absolute terms God doesn't care about oxen he cares about us but actually that's a typical way of expression in Bible to make a relative contrast to put it in an absolute terms. For example the law was given by Moses grace and truth came by Jesus Christ well that's a relative contrast it stated more absolutely than than is intended because you read the Old Testament it's full of grace and truth. In the Old Testament as attributes of God that then or be reflected in God's people so I think that this text is useful to us to to alert us to how we learn principles of general equity and apply them in new situations as they arise. Now this has worked for centuries but it's been challenged in recent times by the movement that is known as theonomy and so let me let me give you a brief excursus on the theonomy. First of all just the essential bibliography I have a full bibliography in the notebook on theonomy on reserve in the library if you want to pursue this you want to pursue it as a paper topic it would be a good one and a full bibliography is there but the the two books that will get you to the essence of it. One is by Greg Bonson he's now deceased but he was the prime spokesman for this movement the title of the book is by this standard it's it's small paperback it's the most accessible form of each very clear writer and it was this is 1985 so it appears after his groundbreaking work theonomy and Christian ethics but the essence is all here and he clarifies something. There's a lot in there that we agree with the reform theologian and a lot of what I've said about the ten commandments he says also a lot that we say about grace and salvation by grace he also says he's not a legalist in the sense he's teaching justification by works or sanctification by law so that's the thing to read if you want to get it straight from Bonson that's a very readable understandable book. I would say read along with it a book edited by Barker it's Will Barker a form of president here now Dean at Westminster Seminary in Philadelphia and Godfrey who is president of Westminster Seminary in California and the faculties of those two institutions got together and produced a book with the title theonomy a reformed critique which was published in 1990 and that's the best to interaction Bonson me wrote a response to that so the argument goes on but this is the essential bibliography there's a chapter I think probably the best chapter in the reformed critique is by Sinclair Ferguson on the Westminster assembly you know if there's one thing you want to read as you go for licensure ordination that would be the chapter to read you should be familiar with Bonson and I recommend you get to read it just read by the standard that's that will give you the the basic idea but then for whether you adopt his position or not you need to be aware of especially the analysis of the Westminster confession that the Sinclair Ferguson very helpfully gives in theonomy reformed critique now my second point as we get into this is to focus on the distinct pieces about theonomy what makes theonomy theonomy the title itself theonomy is mean simply being subject to God's law and it's in contrast to autonomy autonomy and of course if the choice is between autonomy and theonomy we're all theonomists if we believe the by-law so it's taking the term theonomy and applying it to a particular movement of subject to God's law but it's not the term itself it's not the idea of being theonomist that is what we want to be here's the distinctive thesis it can be expressed in two sentences or you can join them with a conjunction here's the first part of it the civil precepts of the old testament so we're talking about this area judicial that confession says is expired the civil precepts of the old testament parenthesis standing judicial laws that's his parenthesis that's his other term for civil precepts the civil precepts of the old testament standing judicial laws are a model of perfect social justice for all cultures even in the punishment of criminals that's his praise because he wants to be clear that that it's the whole civil precepts so even in the punishment of criminals and here's where I run the sentences together with an an that I insert an ruler that I'm going to do the same thing I insert and rulers are morally responsible to obey the reveal standards of justice in Old Testament law rulers are morally responsible to obey the reveal standards of social justice in Old Testament law I say that too but what makes bonds and distinctive is it's that governments today ought to implement implement the mosaic case law the standing judicial laws of Israel they are for us today they have not been abrogated and they have not expired with the state of that people because they are a standing their standing judicial laws that are a model of perfect social justice for all cultures and so as as you have it in the Old Testament children obey your parents you can paraphrase it to say merchants have just measures and magistrates execute rapists those are all the other death penalty crimes that had capital punishment in the Old Testament it is obligatory for governments to implement today now that we live in a democratic society and Bonson acknowledges that and so we our goal is to persuade governments to implement the mosaic law so it's not that you know just a we expect that there will arise a dictator who will do it but rather it will come about through the democratic process we want to be honest typically take the long view on that but as a matter of principle that's what that's what we're after yes sir yes rulers are morally responsible to obey the reveal standards of social justice in Old Testament law in other words it's a duty to put people to death for the crimes for which they were put to death under Moses it's a duty it's a duty it's a duty it's not a judgment call there's a principle of general equity here it's a duty now I offer a critique of this so this is my third major heading here the three major headings to it the first heading has to do with the ground of law it's a Bonson's view that the whole mosaic administration derives from the holiness the holy nature of God and since God is immutable the law is immutable now I have that's on page 113 top of page 113 the animus characteristically argue from the immutability of God's holiness to the immutability of God's law here's the quote from Bonson the law is a transcript a writing out of the details of God's moral perfection as such the law can no more be changed abrogated or improved upon then can God's perfection well that's a you know that's a powerful argument you know if the law is a writing out of in the tale of God's perfection and God is immutable then the law can't be abrogated now I point out in the in on this page that when you look at that more carefully it actually contains an equivocation because the Bonson acknowledges that Christians are not obliged to practice circumcision or keep the dietary laws I say that the animus saved their position by an equivocal use of the term law on the one hand they say that the law is the transcript of God's perfection on the other hand the law that's immutable is not the transcript it's the principles embodied in the precepts that are immutable not the precepts themselves as he says and by the standard this I think clarifies his meaning the principles of God's law are perpetual because they reflect the character of God who is unchanging well Thomas Aquinas can say that the civil law was an application of the moral law or for Israel but it's the principle that is immutable and unchanging but the civil laws themselves can change and certainly the ceremonial laws can change now that leads me to think that we need a better analysis of the ground of law in the Bible and I rely on a treatment in Charles of Charles Hodge any systematic theology Hodge does talk about this question and he distinguishes four categories of divine commands I've reduced into three so this is this is not Hodge this is this is Hodge through Jones's grid and I always shrink a little when I do anything and so here's what here's what here's the analysis basically from Hodge the three kinds of divine commands that we observe in in the scriptures first of these are laws founded on the nature of God they could not be otherwise because they are founded on the nature of God himself for example to love God supremely it could not be a moral obligation to hate God oh that's in the nature of the case it's founded on God's nature God is love and therefore the creatures that he has made are obligated to love him and creatures of who are made in his image those derived directly from the nature of God as love God is a God who cannot lie and therefore the commandment for truthfulness is dependent upon the nature of God I think that the three primary forms of love justice mercy fidelity could not be otherwise because they reflect the character of God now in a certain way this is contains a topology because we know what justice is from not some category that's higher than God but from God himself but yet to say that God is just to say that God is love is meaningful even though ultimately it may be circular it is meaningful to us who are creatures that are made in his image and we understand that meaning some of God's commands are derived directly from are founded on the nature of God there are other laws that are founded on can I put this founded on let's just put human nature but actually the reason I'm pausing there is that it's actually God's will for human nature it's the way it is laws that are founded on the way God has constituted human nature for light in this world in other words these are due to the will of God in creating us the kinds of beings that he made us for an example marriage between one man and one woman that's the norm because the human nature that's what God that's the way God has made us and it is fulfilled through that following that norm theoretically there could might have been other ways in which social relations such as marriage might have been formed but God made us kind of creatures we are that this is the this is the permanent principle for human beings in the present age this is age long it is universal and age long due to the will of God in constituting us the way that we are way Hodge puts it is it laws founded on the permanent relations of human beings in the present age I add in the in view of the way God constituted human nature in other words there's a there's a there's a point to we get it right if we use scripture rightly there is a point to natural law arguments if we understand that it's refers back to God's will in creating us in certain ways that are known through general revelation and actually in 1950 there was an important study of cross cultural study of 250 societies and all of them found some form of the family relationship husband wife and dependent children it existed in combination with polygamy and other things but the distinctive relationship between father mother and child existed in all those cultures I think it it reflects in the by God's common grace that that that norm has been embodied in practice there are very there are cultural relic culturally relative features in terms of polygamy but not in terms of the what I in the mid 50s began to be called the nuclear family that is the nucleus of father mother children either by natural or birth or adoption. So those are both of these are universal and permanent but the ground is different laws found it on the nature of God are immutable cause of the immutability of God laws found it on human nature are unchanging because human nature is unchanging it's it's God has created us for this age in terms of the way that we are in his laws reflect those permanent relations. And there are laws that are founded on God's say social purpose still working with the language here but these are God's purposes for human beings in temporary relationships such as you have under the theocracy where God for a specific social purpose the formation of his people in terms of a nation relations that define the discipline of that nation were unique to them that will lead us into the into the next aspect because how do you how do you distinguish between laws found on human nature and laws founded on God's social purpose which may be temporary as God's purpose changes then the responsibility changes there's a point here that the idea that the law is grounded in the perfection of God and the and because God is immutable the law is immutable doesn't take into account the complexity of the way in which God imposes his will upon beings that he has made in his image sometimes derived directly from his nature sometimes it derives from the way he has made us sometimes it derives from his purposes in the redemption. The social condition hard just way of putting it was that it their laws that are founded on the temporary relations or conditions of society. I would say that they are they're founded on God's temporary purposes with respect to those societies. Now my my second critique or objection to our adopting Bonson's view has to do with the uniqueness of Israel as a covenant nation. The uniqueness of Israel as a covenant that probably should be but anyway a covenant nation a nation covenant with God and there are I think at least four subvoids here to be appreciating. The first one is that the covenant way of life we're talking about a national way of life. The covenant way of life is a religious and political unity in a way that's impossible with any other nation. God has not entered into a covenant with any other nation the way he entered into a covenant with Israel that's distinctly that's unique. There are a lot of references that to in the text it's it's a unique period in redemptive history in which God took to himself a people as a nation. And there is within that a religious and political unity that's absent from from other nations other nations are held accountable for justice and mercy and fidelity. And they are held accountable to the moral principles that are promulgated into ten commandments but that is a religious and political unity in which the discipline or religious failure is the responsibility of the civil government. Now the second point is that when you look at the Old Testament you find that there are some social structures that are unique to the theocracy. We may learn from them principles of general equity but they're unique to the theocracy particularly the legislation concerning the land. And the Jubilee year in which every 50 years everything reverted to its original owner that is the tribe of the original owner those allotments of the land were symbolic they were typological. And so the structure that's provided there has a beneficent benefit in terms of matters of social justice to avoid concentration of land on the part of the rich until there's no room for the poor in the earth. That's a general equity principle but the social structure is unique to the theocracy and there are many others of those. There is also especially to be noted the vocation of Israel as a symbolic community. It is a nation but it's a nation in which to use meritous crimes very helpful term as the eschatological judgment of God intrudes into the present. So Israel's vocation is to uphold God's character and God's law in a way that he hasn't commissioned any other nation. Thinking of the conquest of the land of Canaan the iniquity of the Canaanites isn't full and when Israel goes into conquer the land it it's typological of hell it prefigures hell the kind of destruction that they're commanded to do. But it's not just those special commands you could say well that's just a special command but in Deuteronomy 20 there is the provision as a standing judicial law that when Israel set siege against any of its neighbors not the group that they're commanded to exterminate that's another category but if they see someone else offer them terms of peace and if they accept it then they'll become your servants. They'll become your slaves but if they don't then kill all the men and you may have the women and the material stuff is plunder. Now that can only be explained in terms of God's special vocation of Israel there's a typological community and I think that it's important to recognize that. And it affects I would say it affects the civil law as a whole in terms of the death penalty you have to bear in mind that this is a national typological community that has death penalties for various infractions that relate to that calling. It's impossible just to generalize from Israel's penal code it's not that you can't make the mosaic law into a model penal code because of the special vocation of Israel. The civil code is this it doesn't work because of the social structures the criminal code doesn't work because of the vocation of Israel. Now there's a third fourth sorry fourth thumb thing that I would say it has to do with the burden of proof. Bonson is very repetitive on this that if anything in the mosaic legislation is not to be enforced today then you have to prove it. I would say the opposite is the case because of the expiration principle the expiration of the late and the whole judicial system with it. I think the burden of proof is on those to show that we ought to implement any particular any particular principle in the in the Old Testament. I think we should not accept the burden of proof in a positive way but rather just the opposite you have to go to the scriptures as Paul did and show that there is a principle of equity in those laws. There is a third problem that sometimes passes without notice and I didn't mention it in my book either but I think that we have to say something about this. The distinctive thesis of theonomy is that the civil precepts the Old Testament are a model of perfect social justice for all cultures but as a matter of fact when you look at the Old Testament there is some accommodation to existing social conditions. There is some accommodation to existing social conditions that fall short of the perfect ideal what I mean that the accommodation of judicial precepts to tolerate less than perfect conduct. The clearest example is Deuteronomy 24 versus 1 to 4. Deuteronomy 24 versus 1 to 4. For man bears a woman who becomes displeasing to him because he finds something indecent in her it's really he found something that's repulsive in her. And he writes her a certificate of divorce gives it to her and sends her from his house and after she leaves his house she becomes the wife of another man and her second husband dislikes her. And writes her a certificate of divorce gives it to her and sends her from his house or if he dies then here's the point only comes at verse 10 all the others description here's the case law if and then those of the circumstances then her first husband who divorced her is not allowed to marry her again. This tolerates divorce that's arbitrary on the part of the man. Now this is not divorce for adultery this is divorce for arbitrary reasons on the part of the man and Jesus in Matthew 19 you know this this comes up because Jesus you know the sermon on the mount says if you divorce and remarry you commit adultery. And so the Pharisees ask him about this they present a test question to him. In verse Matthew 19 three is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife for any and every reason because that's what Deuteronomy 24 implied was taken that way by some of the rabbis. Having you read he replied at the beginning the creator made the male and female and said for this reason the man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife and the two will become one place so they're no longer two but one therefore what God is joined together let not man separate. They got him you know why then why then they asked did Moses command that a man give his wife a certificate of divorce and send her away. Jesus replied Moses permitted you to divorce your wives because your hearts were hard but it was not this way from the beginning you have an accommodation within this perfect social justice that reflects the whole of this of God is immutable in the theonomy system you know I just think it doesn't work here that God. Through Moses accommodated to this civil situation he tolerated arbitrary divorce because there were things in arbitrary divorce at least the woman is alive with a certificate that defines her status rather than being shunned off and with an anomaly of or worse murdered that happens. You know in cultures where you have the strict laws against divorce and a man wants to be rid of his my heart hit man people's hearts are hard and there was a combination within the the civil law for conduct is less than ideal another example is polygamy that wasn't so from the beginning either God tolerated that is he allowed it to continue without discipline not that he approved it. Now slavery is in a different category and we'll talk more into tale about slavery slavery isn't isn't tolerated. Some forms of slavery are not tolerated stealing a human being is not tolerated what is tolerable and it's not tolerated in slave of fellow israeli you can have an indentured servant for seven years but after that he goes goes out free with the gain that he has gotten it gives an opportunity for the poor. To get him get back on their feet you may enslave a foreigner but that that is related to the vocation of israel that's unique that's a part of ruling over the nations that's unique to that that vocation so I don't know now there may be some of the regulations of slavery that are accommodated to the situation but you're not to rule over your fellow israelite harshly don't rule with rigor and there are generous provisions including not sending a slave who's escaped back to his master there's a subversive and even in the Old Testament there's something subversive about the institution of slavery but arbitrary divorce and polygamy are allowed to continue and there's legislation on polygamy. It doesn't approve it but it regulates it make sure that the first wife is fully attended to if a man takes a second wife so I think that for those reasons we need to recognize that the mosaic administration was temporary although the moral law which is partly embodied in the mosaic administration is permanent.