<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
اهدا اهدای ماهانه

Worship & Music 2

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Okay. We're ready to begin. We're on lesson 18. Thank you. Continuing music and worship. Let's pray. Father, we thank you for the gift of music in our lives as a creational gift that beautifies and enhances and expresses many things. We thank you for the gift of music in worship to in wonderful ways carry forward and upward and inward the truths and the realities of the gospel of Christ as we continue to strive to understand how to effectively steward this good gift in the places that we are or places you may send us in the future. Give us wisdom, put the gospel song in our heart that would would just be ceaseless in its expression in our lives. For we ask it in Jesus name. Amen. Okay. Psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs are the references that are used in both Ephesians 5 and Colossians 3. I don't necessarily see these as precise categories and some people work hard at trying to put them into precise categories. I think that Psalms certainly include the Psalter but I guess I find it helpful to think of the Psalms as being already existing inspired words of scripture that can be sung. So Mary's song or Simeon's song or the song of Moses or some of the songs in Revelation or if we're right about like Philippians 2 and some of those other places that are hymn-like scripture songs. I think hymns, there are at least these categories even if this isn't what these words are most precisely supposed to mean. Okay. So there are inspired scripture songs that include the Psalms and other portions of scripture. There are hymns which I think fit the category at least broadly of human compositions that develop biblical truths and can it be arise my soul arise come now found every blessing, great as I faithfulness. There may be biblical illusions here I raise my Ebenezer that we sang this morning. Okay. That's a biblical illusion a lot it gets lost on a lot of people but it's basically saying thus far the Lord has brought me in this Christian pilgrimage that I'm on and I'm gonna mark this point and say thank you for bringing me thus far and look to you to continue to bring me even though I'm prone to wander I'm asking you to give me a zeal and a passion. These are this is a development of biblical gospel truths and then spiritual songs probably in the original context and time of the church where Paul in 1 Corinthians 14 talks about speaking in the spirit and singing in the spirit actually at one point. It's it probably was an expression of what were spontaneous songs that were sung as the spirit led people to sing at the time. Sort of like you know my life when I'm driving with my family is spontaneously led to singing or my brother-in-law who likes to sing about everything and silly little ditties you know I'm not sure how spirit inspired some of our singing is but in worship to have people just break into song rather than words so spiritual songs the way the spiritual could you know modify songs could could relate to that but I find it a helpful category to think of the simpler musical expressions so you have inspired words a scripture in song you have human compositions that develop biblical themes and doctrines and the biblical story and you have scripture songs that maybe you're your simpler chorus type things that we have. Have I pointed out I think I gave you a copy of some ways to evaluate him. Did I give you that in a packet yesterday? I have this recollection of yes it's called thoughts for him paper I think it was right after the women in chapel in terms of the order in which I gave it to you yesterday. What is a him? What's a him definition for this project? Did you guys find out? That's after the women in worship one. Words that would be the equivalent of at least two verses or stances of a him book type him. Repeating courses are okay or fine. Something like shout to the Lord would barely make it but it does because it has one stanza and one chorus but the chorus also is a development it's almost like a two stanza song that's repeated. So he is exalted would not qualify for example there's not enough development of the him like I mean it's a great song that focuses on God being exalted but for this assignment it's a lot easier to write what I want you to write if it's has a little bit of substance to it as well. Then I've given just a number of ways of analyzing hymns based on Colossians 3. I've got an even Vernon Whaley in a book understanding music and worship of the church asks six questions for selecting music and worship are the lyrics of the composition consistent with the biblical truth. There's a composition teach doctrinal truths. There's the composition admonish warner and courage does the composition utilize the words of scripture, a psalm, a focus attention on God a him or emphasize what God is doing the life of a spirit-filled believer you see how he develops those phrases does the composition call more attention to its musical style or form of presentation than the lyrics or the melody when you walk away you say wow that was really cool when they did this and use the saxophone to accomplish that or something and then so I said oh what's the sermon about I mean what was it the song about well I remember I just remember the saxophone solo in between the stanzas now less we make too much fun of music that way that can be done about a sermon too I know some sermons that I remember some great illustrations and I have no idea the point they were trying to make but they were great stories so sometimes we have orators more than we have preachers and remember they're great gift of or oration is that the word okay thank you but we don't remember the content so music could be the same does the composition cause those who play it sing it and listen to it have an inward spirit of thankfulness toward God these are just some things by which you could evaluate some of it you can't because you don't know how the people who are actually singing in a service are doing it okay rough talks about what kind of music does God like music that's played skillfully with the right volume and joy and creativity invites participation and has motivation of love toward God Jiren bars when he taught the demon course that I had on worship talk he organized much of the course around these nine aspects of worship principles that are to govern all of worship and which I'm saying could be applied to our selection of song in worship it's a God center Christ and redemption focus spirit led according to the word filled with the word is involved the worship are totally does it embrace every aspect of our life now every him can't do everything let me just insert that there okay what you're going to be looking for and this is part of looking at the whole of the service the prayers the songs the readings the sermon all of the different elements or it's almost like you have the you're supposed to build something and you have all these elements that are building blocks on the floor and together you're you're building something that's beautiful and accomplishes worship purposes and so you can't make every song or prayer or even the sermon by itself or the Lord supper by itself accomplish everything that God wants to do in corporate public worship so when you look at music can I you know somebody want a critical well I can't use let's see what was the song you remember the song right now but oh a song that may not overtly name Christ in it or say something about his redeeming work so well if I analyze a song I can't use it in worship because it doesn't name the name of Christ to which might come back to him was well what about the Psalter did I mean we can't sing the Psalms so I think you want to make sure that in the course of the service you're not coming across as a unitarian church or an Old Testament synagogue okay it should be clearly gospel that's always a gospel center but exalting God in a way that doesn't mention overtly the name of Christ or redemption at a point in the service that's responding to maybe even his redeeming work is appropriate so you're looking at the whole of the picture of it worship arises from the community of God's people it's directed out and toward the world and up to God and I love this phrase from general worship must be contemporary and culture specific you know just look at the incarnation Jesus was born in a particular place at a particular time to a particular particular into a particular ethnicity or people that spoke a particular language and the importance of worship not being in some sort of vacuum or timeless sort of situation but that it's relevant to the people who have gathered and contemporary this is that it happens in this moment even if you're singing an old old song it's still contemporary in the sense that we're singing this old old song in this moment in history with these people who are gathered in worship on this day I sometimes say we could repeat the exact same worship service next week that we did last week sermon and all all the same songs all the same prayers all the same readings and the sermon I don't recommend it but you could do it and it could be edifying to the congregation all of whom were there last week because you're freshly engaged in God around the same timeless eternal truths and the God who shows up to meet with us in this moment of this week oh they're just doing the same thing next week I'll go meet with someone else okay he comes to me with us because we're gathered and they were Christ I don't think that's a wise thing to do but it makes the point about freshly engaging contemporary meaning in this moment as well some further thoughts that I put here to song selection is the musical expression appropriate to the context what effect will the musical expression have on the ears is the quality of musical expression good or bad does the song promote and facilitate heartfelt emotion to the glory of God are the words faithful to the biblical text as a musical expression match the content of the words I love this one I remember a Johnny Carson show years ago that a singer by name of Neil Sedacca was a guest performer on and Neil Sedacca sing his song it says breaking up is hard to do and I just have this image fixed in my mind of Neil Sedacca sitting at the piano facing the camera this way with this huge happy smile facing they say that breaking up is hard to do you know it's like he's singing about how hard it is to break up with this syrupy smiley happy face and so there's a disconnect between the words of the song and the way the song is being sung now to his credit when he recorded it in the studio and if you want to hear the recorded version of it you see our associate dean of academics Diane Preston who has the CD in her office which may say as much about Diane Preston is Neil Sedacca I'm sorry Diane please don't watch this film no she made me listen to it on a ride back from General Assembly one year but I of course made her listen to a lot of music that I like to listen to that she didn't particularly care for and it actually sounds pretty good on the CD he actually has it as much slower it doesn't have bouncing us to it they say that breaking up is and you know it's kind of it has more of that you know bad feeling of breaking up with someone that you love so same tune same words just the style and manner which it's done there needs to be a consistency between a match of the expression of music and the content of the words is the congregational song singable already known by most of the people are fairly easy to learn I would guess of the three songs we did this morning come now found from depth from the depths of woe based on song 130 and in Christ alone probably the least number of people would have known from depths of woe but it's easy to pick up and sing it's very very singable to as is in Christ alone if you've never heard it before you probably are joining in if you have any sense of memory and music by the third or fourth standard you're probably able to sing much of it even without notes in the bulletin okay then the next page worship music evaluation form one of the students I had in doctor ministry class did his major paper for the class on evaluating worship music and he came up this was an appendix to his paper of his wave evaluating song again there's no this is a good one it's not that you can find problems with all of the things I'm giving you here I'm just giving you lots of things to use if you want you can take you know this sheet of Brian Jansen or you can use the Vernon we waily thing you can sort of fit your evaluation and let this be your your outline if you want okay I don't just want you to fill in the numbers on this chart and turn that in okay but you could do that and then write me a couple pages as to why you did what you did but preliminary concerns of a song whether or not you would use it these words are biblically true doctrinally correct in every way that's a pass fail if it's not biblically correct you're not going to use it okay these words are distinctively Christian either Trinitarian or referencing the atoning work of God in Christ some mention of grace mercy redemption or both for example it would be awkward to sing this song in a Jewish synagogue okay now okay he says or caution see what he's saying is some songs that would be acceptable in a Jewish synagogue could also be acceptable with Christian worship if that's all that all of the songs and all of the prayers and everything were that would be a problem so he says caution okay if it's not it doesn't fail in that regard the song is about God as the subject of worship some aspect of God's character or works as developed these words evidence of progression of thought not merely repetition of thoughts he's not failing it because it has a repetition of thoughts but he's saying him that he generally should have some progression of thought you may use something that doesn't in a connecting way but not necessarily your media or hymns that you would sing in the service the song is to God now there's some songs that are about God that are not expressed to God one of the blessings of much of kind of scripture songs and choruses and what someone considers simple songs or repetitive songs is a lot of times they are sung directly to God like I love you Lord you're speaking directly to him it's not bad to have songs that are about God what I sometimes have done more in the past than the president have used this but I put together oh worship the king there's a great hand that develops the trinitarian nature of of God and has lots of needy subject about worshiping God as king and then immediately sing and it worked out well in the in the more simple musician things that I would do sometimes in the same key so I don't have to have to transpose from one to the other when I'm sitting and playing the piano you could sing oh worship the king and then go directly into I love you Lord what's that doing it's it's giving you time to sort of process and say to God in light of who you are we want to express love to you and so the simple repetitive I love you Lord which in frames follow up book contemporary worship music he talks about an experience he had one time of being in a worship service where I love you Lord was sung over and over again for what he clocked to be almost 20 minutes and he says now there may be some value to that to me it was having diminishing value after about two minutes sort of things so effective use of some of these things this song helps to form Christian character these words avoid excessive narcissism for self-absorption there are more about God's work for us than our feelings our work for or feelings about God again none of these things would disqualify any given him but you know if they have multiple things that score them low then you may it may have an impact on it and then the song's music this music appropriately matches a tone of message exhibits excellence and composition and is musically interesting see to be singable and interesting it's part of what you have to kind of hold intention in composing songs for congregational singing now there's been clearly a movement in the last five to ten years five to eight years I guess I would say from Christian contemporary music being performance driven at a concert and contemporary Christian music being for the worshiping people of God almost every contemporary Christian musician who does the concert circuit now has a worship CD now part of it is there's a market for it but part of it I think is there gifted musicians who have devoted their lives not to writing pop songs will hit the Christian charts as much as songs that will feed and nourish and be able to be used by the people of God in worship and that doesn't have to be an either or and I think that's a it's a good movement to have some of the the very gifted people who could be doing more of the concert direction which I think can be done to the glory of God don't hear me sing anything other than that but to use your gifts to serve God's people in worship and that's a different song some some of it has overlapped some songs were able to sing in worship that are also done you know that were done more for concerts or special music and there's some great special music songs and gifted musicians can do an offer to God on our behalf that we wouldn't try that at home or at church we let the gifted musicians do it so anyway there's there's some helpful things there I think for analyzing music and worship okay let's see dynamics of corporate congregational singing congregational singing happens in a cultural context with the particular people living at particular place at a particular time the whole person is to is involved it's language in action because it's coming sort of out of our hearts through our vocal cords out into the worshiping congregation where it can be heard by others okay so it's language in action it's not just in our minds we're not just thinking about a song we're singing it it's expressive of emotions join to and responding to content and like I said in in most churches particularly in Presbyterian churches the most emotional thing we do usually in worship service is sing and I think that's good it's good to have it this is a vehicle expressing emotions that should be joined to and responding to content there's I think it was the Guthrie that article from Jets that I talked about talks about the words come off of the page or the video screen into and back out of our bodies we read them with our eyes and it sort of come in and then join with with our vocal cords and the voice coming out and then they come back in our ears as we hear ourselves sing and so there's a there's a physical dynamic that happens when you sing that is more fully entering in a torsion by I see I speak I hear I feel okay and I'm responding to and expressing biblical truth Paul ran wrote a book called praying twice it's in our covenant seminary library also I don't agree with this theology completely in this book but he says some interesting things Luther is the one I believe it was who who called singing praying twice because you're both praying words and singing words at the same time and Calvin particularly viewed song and worship as prayers and so this is that's where the title of the book comes from but the characteristics of corporate singing are it is corporate together with others it's corporeal it involves the body it's inclusive he says don't let all the men of your church tell you that they're monotones as an excuse for not singing it's proven scientific fact they're only about 5% of the population are monotones and they all happen to be in my Presbyterian church I think one of the one of the great contributions of promise keepers to the church is it helped to get men to to feel okay about singing out loud with other men in worship one of the promise keepers T-shirts was real men sing real loud okay just popped in my head remember seeing that several times it's credal it expresses our faith it's ecclesial it connects us with the communion of seats past and around the world today it's inspirational and it can be evangelistic before the watching world so we talked about the ologians and musicians a little bit with Claudia earlier I think I mentioned before that the value of having a pastor and a musician working together in composing songs is is a good thing that the idea of a singer-songwriter is relatively rare in the history of the church and somewhat of a recent phenomenon where you have people who aren't trained biblical in theologically writing the words and the music and part of the reason I give the assignment to challenge you all to think about writing him words as those who are studying and being trained theologically is in response to a music director who challenged me to say if you're going to complain about musicians writing the words to him and not do anything about it why don't you who teach these future pastors about worship and and other ministry leaders urge them to apply their biblical theological training and try their hand at writing some poetic expressions of doctrine in biblical truth that we musicians then have something to work with and we don't have to come up with the words as well the whole movement with particularly with Kevin Twitt at Belmont College urging these musicians to write songs and saying don't just come up with your own words you 19-year-old who haven't had much study of the Bible and it doesn't mean that God can't give good words for a 19-year-old okay but here take this book of Gatsby's hymns are these great you know 1200 hymn words in this one little book that you can almost fit in your back pocket and meditate on those and see what the spirit may lead you to is something that is expressing what's in your heart that God has put there that you have this musical giftedness to be able to have come off the page for other people to be blessed by the singing of these hymns many of which have been lost to the church because they've either not been popular or they've been attached to an unsingable tune that sort of was good for a while and that it's earned a people for a time but it hasn't been in lasting I mentioned before Paul Jones in music director 10th President Philadelphia saying that the role of song in corporate worship is prayer praise and proclamation and I think that's that's helpful sometimes when we're singing there's a new tune to the old hymn Jesus with by church abide that's I think on the latest in noble grace CD and whenever we sing that I sometimes will tell the congregation or people in chapel remind them that we're praying to God the words are a prayer to God Jesus with thy church abide you know we're we're praying we're interceding for the church as we sing just like within Christ alone we're expressing what we believe as we sing it's proclamation in that in that regard a couple of books that if you want to explore some of this kind of thing that are helpful I've listed at the top of 30 today I'm the church of music and then unceasing worship by Harold best who taught for years at Wheaton college biblical perspectives on worship in the arts again when I when I list these books I'm not saying I agree with everything theologically and so on about all of them but there are some very helpful there's there's a lot of helpful information and they ask some good questions that we need to explore and have answers for style of music on the top of that worship chart thing I gave you that kind of went from the one day in seven at the top I have this the same quote biblical reformed gospel driven worship glorifies God transcend style edifies the church and evangelizes the unbeliever I think that too often the focus of our discussion about song and worship is on the style and that that turns a manner of expressing something into what's most important itself rather than what what are we serving in terms of gospel worship when we when we write or select or sing songs best on page 145 of his book biblical perspectives on worship in the arts looks at Psalm 961 singing new song to the Lord and he says it's a command to sing it's not optional all believers are are to sing it's to the Lord it's an offering the Lord not to people though it's to be edifying to people some I'm sorry Ephesians 5 and Colossians 3 it's singing to the Lord first to the Lord and then to one another and choirs in soloist aren't primarily singing to the congregation they're singing to the Lord on behalf of the congregation who is sort of joining their hearts and their worship to the choir or the special music people and I think that's that's helpful and how you you know how you handle that you know some churches you know for big clapping after special music because they want it to not be a performance I think there are some people who their clapping can be unto the Lord okay and just because you say let's give a clap offering the Lord doesn't necessarily mean that everybody's clapping to the Lord they may be clapping for the performer you can't make everybody's heart be where you want it to be when you do that so I'm not going to sit a hard and fast rule against clapping and it's interesting when our little children choirs come up and sing and from a musical excellence standpoint they aren't necessarily doing all that well and anybody claps why because they they want to encourage the children to offer their voices up to the Lord so I guess you could say that the adult choir could be encouraged similarly if that's what's what we're praising God we're encouraging those who are who are using their gifts and music but I think probably it's important to give some definition to what a clap means because it's fairly confusing in our if we just figure what's done in our culture you know in sporting events and rock concerts and you know whatever let's see singing a new song whether it's borrowed repeated or brand new it should be a fresh fresh expression of our faith it should be new in this moment whether it's sung for this thousandth repetition or for the first time we've talked about songs hymns and spiritual songs we were I was showing trip yesterday that in the back of of most hymnals there's a metrical index this is the Trinity hymnol and it says meters okay and it has like CM partway down common meter amazing graces in there and then it lists the titles of hymns and the pages they're on so if you find words in hymnol that you really love and you look at the tuner you give the tune to your musician they say that's not too single now one thing you say well do you think you could write something that's more singable if you're a musician happens to be a into composition or you can look down here this 418 oh King eternal sovereign lord and the the the meter says 8884 so you turn back here and you look and see if there any other 8884's just experiment here no this is the only 8884 in the hymnol so you're stuck with this one if you want the words okay but a lot of times like under 8787 you've got you know 20 hymn tunes listed that could be interchangeable means the words will match up with the notes is basically what it means so you're not trying to put three syllables in one note that's a quarter note okay you can't but I can't quite get it in time and that was not speaking in tongues for those of you listening only on tape that was an attempt to put a long unknown word into of three or more syllables into one quarter note in a song okay one of the things I find very helpful with best is he talks about the danger of idolatry in music I think this speaks right into where some of our our struggles are he says there are three kinds of idolatry and usually we stand in one of them and accuse the other two of being idolatrous the idolatry of quality would say if it's beautiful we should use it whether it's effective or not and the pure quality of the beauty of something whether it has any gospel purpose or impact on people's lives okay the second idolatry is the idolatry of effectiveness if it's effective we'll use it whether it has quality or not okay so we'll take our you know campfire songs and bring them into worship and it it moved the youth of yesterday or so surely it will move the youth of today or people love it even though it doesn't have any substance to it and all you sing are only repetitive courses which would have some value but not necessarily as much value in a more balanced musical diet if I can put it that way or the idol of stasis if it worked well in the past don't change it now I love this next quote taken from page 169 there is no church larger small richer poor ethnically diverse or homogenous that will not face one two or all three of these elements but it usually works out that the high culture high taste arts face the first idol quality the church growth seeker sensitive leadership the second and the traditionalist the third so I think it's he's sort of kind of an equal opportunity admonition to all kinds of people or some combination of these sometimes there's a problem of association with music we've talked a little bit about this before from bot to walk rock there are is a wide range of strong associations most people they think of association I think of you know sixties rock and roll drug culture music but I read an interesting story about a young man who was converted out of a cult that denied essential biblical truth and in that cult they used a lot of the time the music of Johann Sebastian Bach and so he had closely connected in his mind the music of Bach with the teachings of this church well after he's converted he went into a worship service friended by them and the the long opening prelude was a Bach number on the organ and the man left because it was just so troubling to him because of these things he had just sort of been delivered from there were in his mind associated with the music of Bach now what do you do well I think Romans 14 15 would say out of love for this weaker brother we probably shouldn't use Bach for a little while until what does it mean forever because he's a weaker brother in this bad association you would never use Bach again well hopefully not hopefully would help him understand that the problem with the cult was not the music of Bach the problem with the cult was the bath theology and in fact you would instruct him here's who Bach is and how God used him to write music to the glory of God for the church that believes the truth of the gospel and so he needs to grow and matured his understanding of Bach in that regard when I was about 16 or 17 years old over Christmas vacation when there was lots of snow and I was I was captivated by two things as I stayed in the living room and didn't do much else but eat and read a book and listen to music the music I listened to that I loved was then the chakowsky's not cracker sweet the book that I was reading the captivated me was the rise and fall of the third right about eight off Hitler and so in my mind over about three or four days that I read that book I listened it would be if it was a CD it was the old you know 33 and a third going around so I had to get up and move the needle over every time it came to be on but if it was a CD it would have been on repeat for three days okay I so what ended up happening in those three days was the connection between not cracker sweet and eight off Hitler was deeply seared in my mind and understanding so much so that every time I heard chakowsky's music of the not cracker sweet all I could think about was eight off Hitler and the third right now is that chakowsky's fault no it's great music it wasn't intended to you know like stole and praise Nazi Germany so finally many years later I attended the ballet of the not cracker sweet and was able to actually have something else associated being there with Beth and watching the not cracker sweet and all the ballet stuff from you know 100 yards away probably in my seat but so gradually that's been disconnected what was never intended me to be connected but in my circumstances was okay the improper use of something does not negate as proper use we've said that several times I've talked about the church in Indiana that I served and and associating certain instruments in this case a full drum set with certain potentially bad rock music experiences and how people had to grow past that I remember telling a woman who said to me all I can hear in worship is the beating of the drum I said well I'm sorry about that and and I feel bad about that and you know it is probably because you're thinking too much about how much you don't like the drum that you hear it and awful lot it's like saying okay guys don't think about a pink elephant would you immediately do you think about a pink element or if you listen to music on the radio or Sarah don't listen for the bass sound it's pretty soon the bass is overpowering everything else so I said to this woman I said I long for the day that you'll greet me at the door and say pastor it happened today I went through a worship service and I didn't notice the drums okay not we played him on every song or played them loudly though at times I'm sure we did and once on this you actually can't you said it happened today Mark I didn't hear the drums so thank you for encouraging me to to think beyond that sort of thing the heart language of worship is reflected in song music they're aspect of you people say music is a universal language while there are aspects of it that music does transcend some language things sometimes but music and in other ways is its own language it's peculiar to a particular culture a group of people or subculture within that for somebody who's never heard rap or hip-hop music to say that this is a universal language that transcends culture that everybody can understand is quite a bit of an overstatement you have to kind of get into the genre and for some of us actually have the words in front of you if you can understand what's being said sometimes of course I grew up in the sixties and seventies where our parents were saying I can't understand a word that that rock and roll singer is singing okay whereas we're mouthing all the words without even thinking about them because we're able to hear them understand now we've got the rising generation with certain musical genres having the same problem generationally it's it's amazing how that happens with people but the meaning of music is understood by its cultural context the customs traditions and circumstances of those who are in a particular time and place making use of particular musical forms and instruments in the gathered worship service and I think we need to learn to appreciate generational and ethnic differences in musical expression it's back full circle to our first lecture on expanding our musical palette and exercising heroic forbearance where we can't I think that for whatever reasons in my own life experience I have a broad appreciation of musical genres and I'm thankful that I do and I'm not sure what all contributed to that but all those unknown shapers of my life in terms of learning to value a wide range of musical expressions I think has served me well as a pastor in churches that reflects diversity of personal preferences and and likes and dislikes but part of it is just you know considering other people's music that's meaningful to them and because it's meaningful to them and and powerfully expresses their faith I shouldn't disvalue that or devalue that because it doesn't do the same thing for me we story that I sometimes tell is when the Mark Dalby family the five of us are driving on a long car trip three teenage children and Beth and me and Beth and I don't have the complete exact same likes and music and the question is what music will we listen to in the Dalby family car driving across Kansas on the way to Colorado got to have something to get through that long stay until you can see the mountains in the horizon you know I mean and I love Kansas most of my family lives there but so at that particular time Kristen our daughter like country music kind of new country not old country sort of country rock there with a little bit of blue grass mixed in Alice and crowd style anyway and I like that too Neo tradition wasn't there got Beth like oldies okay which oldies to her were not you know 80s 90s you know I love these 80s station we're playing music from the 80s in the 90s we went to 60s in the 70s anyway she likes oldies and and Eric loves close harmony from Barbara shop to take six to you know he just loves the acapella close harmony stuff he's always loved that he would he'll be playing that on the on the CD and he was when he was real little he was just sort of experimenting with different harmony things which obviously is part of his life story and the trajectory that he's he's on now doing so well with his acapella and Stephen loved rap okay so how do you solve this problem well the way you all have CD there weren't MP3 players ever you all have you all have headphones and listen to the music you like I thought that's what we can do in church you just like on the airplane the cross you know the inner continental cross the ocean flights you know you dial up what you want you listen to it and your headphones you're not bothering the person next to you and we could say okay the next two minutes and 50 seconds choose your song of praise and you plug it in you turn it on and then you or you the best way to do it be to cut it all off at once the music starts and ends a two minute 53 second clip of a wide range of music would that solve the problem well probably not now on our trip across Kansas it's solved some problems at times but we also we weren't a family traveling across across Kansas together we were five individuals absorbed by the music we love now obviously Isaac driver most of the time couldn't listen with headphones it's not a safe thing to do and so I had to put the speaker on front and left and only have it loud enough that I could hear that it didn't bother the other people with their headsets and we had a system worked out pretty well but so then we came up to say let's listen to music together I mean sometimes it's let's turn it off and talk okay there are other elements in worship besides music and there are other elements of a vacation and listening to music on your headphones so you need the preaching everyone so which I've been known to do to my family in the ways that they haven't appreciated but okay here's what we say what music are we listen to we'd say okay pick we would say it's Stephen especially with the rap music okay pick two rap songs out of your repertoire and thankfully was into Christian rap okay pick two songs that have what you think your parents might consider the most musicality that we might be able to if I used new the words in exercise heroic forbearance and say Stephen that's great that you like that and we tolerate it while it's played okay that doesn't like country and so you know Kristen I had to figure out she likes Allison Kraus okay so you sort of find things that people like in your genre as much as possible to help them learn to appreciate their some value to those things okay so I think that's maybe a family all right then imagine a local congregation the five of us couldn't agree how can you get 500 people to agree okay well it's you develop worship music personalities and local churches but it's not a static thing it's a dynamic thing some old people go home to be with the Lord or some people move away and the next generation comes in or you reach out all of a sudden you have these Hispanic Spanish speaking people that start coming to your church praise God and you figure out well what what would be meaningful to them and expressions of worship in that regard so appreciate generational ethnic differences recognize in the Bach Baba and Blues Brothers part of kids with one voice there is high culture Bach there is folk culture Baba and there's popular contemporary that's the Blues Brothers okay most of the hymns in this hymnal answer this question for me multiple choice are most of the hymns in this hymnal in the category of reggae kids Bach Baba or the Blues Brothers Bach being kind of high culture like Bach himself Baba being folk culture that comes from a people that usually doesn't even have an author associated with it and the Blues Brothers meaning what we call contemporary hymns at this point turning to hymnal how many say Bach how many say the Blues Brothers may say Baba and I think it's Baba okay written kind of it's more folk I would probably say the second category is Bach and the Blues Brothers in terms of contemporary expressions are few and far between in this particular hymnal wouldn't necessarily be true of others I assume that you had a knowledge of the trendy hymnal that you may not have also but most hymns and most hymnals would come from the Baba now Baba may not be the best term some people stumble over that you know that's that's a kind of a southern almost term of derision is that the right word looking down talking somebody down by calling them a Baba actually reggae kid is valuing Baba okay it's it's an expression of a people that withstands the test of time that grows out of a sort of folk culture be like Celtic music would be Baba now we don't we think of Baba as you know bad you know country music in the south or something but it's it's a generic term that I know some of the guys in my doctor minister course sort of stumbled over the Baba term and didn't get the point that was being made but if you think of Celtic music is Baba music in the sense that it comes it's it's an expression of the common people of a culture that has a distinctive sound to appallation from which we got amazing grace and the original tune to hand can it be that that's kind of Appalachian folk music it has some roots actually interestingly in some of that Celtic mountain people that came from Scotland and Ireland and came to the mountains of Virginia and Tennessee and West Virginia that it was incorporated into that which is why it has some bridge musically to that okay last quote and then we'll see if you have any questions and go to lunch this quote from Hughes Olephant Old in a book called Leading in Prayer says this and I find this very helpful very balanced and and he spoke at our worship conference here two years ago and he's generally a hero to the traditionalist maybe it's because he had this long white beard and you know he's written he's probably knows more about reformed worship than any living being on the planet right now he spent several years in Europe traveling around learning about the roots of reformed worship and has written probably his best known book and most scholarly book that he's done is called the patristic roots of reformed worship showing how in that early church fathers there are a lot of things under the roots for what Calvin and others did it's also written whole series of books on preaching as well but anyway then this little book leading in prayer is really quite excellent as well he says him that he needs to be popular it is more closely related to folk song and to art song because him that he is in his very essence a kind of folk song we must never close the door to new hymns written in the idiom of our day time has a way of selecting the classics we do not have to worry about that what is important is that we give each generation its turn at expressing its devotion in the idiom of its day Christian hymnity is like a great art museum it has treasures from a great variety of ages and cultures but it always seems to have room to show the best of contemporary works as well I might add to that quote if I dare to try to add as I think it's such a great quote but to sort of expound on a little bit if you go to the art gallery down a forest park there's probably a room right now in which there's contemporary art and everybody there and we'll say right it walks through knows that a pretty small percentage of that will be in that art museum a hundred years from now okay most of it won't stay on the test of time though they may be meaningful and engaging to people now same thing with with new hymnity there are a lot of songs are being written right now that I love that my grandchildren probably if they're on a hymnal selection committee if there are such things if it's not all electronic or you know we all have it in other you know forms that we press a button it comes out in in front of us you know whatever wherever technology goes but there are hymns that I love now songs that I love the same worship that my grandchildren probably won't they'll say man my grandparents that's that's my grandparents music okay this is what I like and so who decides what stands the test of time I love these guys who write we only sing music that will stand the test of time well how do you know living now whether this music will stand the test of time until the time test comes after your day so right songs that engage people today right songs that serve a wider community and hopefully some of your songs and your hymn words your hymn words are more likely to withstand the test of time if they're well written and people love to sing them they'll find new musical expressions for them the tunes are more I need to say this but a lot of music in worship the musical expression is more disposable most great hymns have words have had multiple musical expressions over generations and from one ethnic group to another and that's okay as you go so some do I mean can you imagine the number of I don't can't remember I have to look at up the number of hymns that we know that Charles Wesley wrote it's it's thousands okay and in the Trinity hymnal written by a non-precipitarian Charles Wesley though we've altered some of the public domain words a little bit to make them more presbyterian at times which are liberties you can take with most songs in the public domain but not with songs that have copyrights don't don't mess with them don't use them if you don't like them don't change them to what you think the author should have said but let's look up Wesley okay Charles Wesley 1707 to 1788 there's 22 hymns in the Trinity hymnal written by Charles Wesley I was gonna say more than anybody else but I look over here it says the Psalter so there's more from the 1912 Psalter then there is Wesley and it looks like Isaac Watts has more than Wesley also but Wesley wrote so many more than that these are sort of what the editors of the Trinity hymnal considered the best loved and most theologically sound and useful for the purposes of we can have a hymnal of you know a thousand Wesley hymns and we don't have tunes to a thousand Wesley hymns and Wesley didn't write tunes to any of his hymns I remember being at a general assembly one time in Louisville where our state of clerk of the Presbyteria we were the host Presbyteria in Ohio Valley and he and I plan to the worship services and we incorporated the Scott Rollie version of Anne Cannon B along with the number of other different songs and so on somebody somebody made a complaint against the actions of the host committee and having music that was entertainment oriented I think was the phrase it was used they set up and said we the undersigned and it was this guy and one other person and they wanted to complain against the action of the assembly and allowing such worship and so this is in 1999 and I just finished my dissertation and I said to the person sitting next to me I think I'm going to have to probably do something to listen I'm going to have to give a speech on the floor here pretty soon so I'm joining a couple things down on a napkin or a piece of scrap paper or something and a guy got up he said I think Charles Wesley would be rolling over in his grave today to see what we did with his tune tonight to which Larry Roth who wrote let us sing stood up and said who's who's known as loving traditional music but being open to the value of some contemporary things and I know Larry and we're friends at Larry stood up thankfully because he's the general assembly organist every year and people see him as probably being sympathetic with this complaint perhaps and he said well just want to correct the previous speaker Charles Wesley didn't write any tunes to any of his hands and the original the tune we most sing to and can it be was an Appalachian folk tune of its day and then he sat down and some people started cheering in the moderate and said we know clapping a general assembly you know it's indecent and out of order to do something so anyway well by parliamentary Roberts rules there's not supposed to be clapping and cheering the British parliament obviously doesn't abide by that you know with all the cheering and cheering and cheering and so on that happens when an prime minister says something you know it's pretty hilarious if you ever watch that it's almost as entertaining as some British comedies trying to be entertaining that might not make the edit but anyway it's Friday afternoon that's right that's right that's right so that was interesting and so I made my little speech and and then the moderator which rarely happens he I made a little speech it's a summary of much of what I say in this class that's more balanced about things and and so on and the moderator said well does the assembly wish to make this response my speech it's response it's sort of like beating the general assembly and the moderator's not supposed to do that and they voted like you know 90% to say yeah well our response our official response to the complaint will be my speech usually they point a little committee if they think it needs a response and then they report back the next day but this was the last night they weren't going to meet the next morning we're finishing our business so it sort of worked out pretty well that way Brian Chappell standing next to me I just accepted the call to come to come to seminary and when this discussion was going on I brought up to Brian I said you sure you want me to come to the denominational seminary he said oh yes I'm glad you're coming so anyway we should go to lunch after lunch we'll do sacraments weddings funerals contemporary issues we'll get through it it's fun it's Friday