<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
दान महिनावार दान

Doctrine of the Atonement

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

So we're on today the doctrine of the atonement, and last week, we talked about the cause of the atonement, not just the love of God, although that's true. But God, it couldn't be that God would just love us and say, oh, your sins are all forgiven, and no penalty be paid. So the cause of the atonement was the love of God and the justice of God because sin had to be punished in some way. And Christ dying for our sin is therefore the result of the love and justice of God. Anybody need an outline? Everybody have one? Okay, Clyde and Garth, thank you for doing that. And we did application to our lives that we too are to reflect God's character and exhibit both love and justice in our lives. We talked about that a little bit. Then the necessity of the atonement, God didn't have to save anybody, so it wasn't absolutely necessary. But if God was going to save any sinners, then the atonement was absolutely necessary. And I think there wasn't any other way for our salvation to be earned. And then the nature of the atonement, we talked about this, that it was not just Jesus dying on the cross, but he lived a life of perfect obedience to God. Through his whole 30, 33, 34, 35 years, however old he was, it's a little uncertain when he died, about 30 years when he started his ministry, Luke said. But his whole life was a life of representative obedience so that that record could be given to us. And then also there was suffering, what was sometimes called his passive obedience, that is he was the recipient of the sufferings that come through living in a fallen world. Through his whole life he was a man of sorrows and acquainted with grief, but that suffering culminated in the cross. And then, oh yes, the application to our lives is that God calls us to some kinds of suffering in this life, in imitation of Christ's life. Not to bear the punishment for our sins, but that God would be glorified in us in the midst of our suffering. And Don, I don't know where you are, raised a question last week about what I said there, and I had to go back and look at it. When I say if we do suffer in this life, it's not to bear the punishment for our sins. Well okay, if for instance if a person abuses alcohol for many years there are consequences, there is a medical deterioration that affects his body. And so there are consequences, but I don't think that's God punishing for the person sins, if the person is a believer, that punishment has already been taken by Christ. So it's just the way things work out in the fallen world. So I distinguish between consequences that come from sin or actual punishment from God. Chuck Colson committed some crimes and went to prison, even though he was forgiven as a Christian. He had to pay the civil penalty of being in prison. I don't know, Don, if that helps. Go ahead. Good question. Was God punishing Adam and Eve when he sent him out of the garden after they sinned? Yeah, I think that was a partial pouring out of punishment. I do think that there was a point where Adam and Eve came to saving faith. It's just hinted at. It's not really explicit. The fact that God made garments from the skins of animals kind of symbolized that a life had to be given and certainly able their son learn somehow how to offer acceptable sacrifice to God with faith. Before a person is a Christian or before a person has forgiveness of sins, then some of the things that happen in this life can be punishment for their sin. But I don't think I want to say that for a Christian. I don't know if that helps. I think it's good because I don't want us to think that God's going to just keep punishing and punishing and punishing us as Christians. He'll discipline us for our good and there are consequences for sin. But I don't think we should feel that God has wrath poured out or anger against us to harm us, which punishment does. I don't know if that's a good question and maybe you haven't gotten to the bottom of it. Thanks. Okay. That was from last week. And then just as Jesus suffered, so we imitate him and I just mentioned I don't think there's anybody in this life who's free from some kinds of hardship and suffering whether it's physical illness or financial or relational or other kinds of things that happen in this life. And of course in other countries, there's also much hostility and persecution against Christians, which we at least from the government don't face that kind of. We're not thrown in jail here for being Christians or things like that. And then Christ's sufferings culminated in the pain of the cross and I mentioned four things and this is where we came to an end last time. There was the physical pain and death involved in crucifixion and we talked about that last week in some detail. There was the pain of bearing sin which Jesus has perfectly holy, instinctively rebelled against and didn't want but took on himself for our sake. And there was this Old Testament background of putting the sin on the goat and then as a 53, the Lord has laid on him the iniquity of us all or he made him God made Christ to be sin, who knew no sin. And there was the pain of abandonment both his disciples for so come and fled all of his disciples for so come and fled and also God the Father turned away his face from him and abandonment by the Father as well in some sense. That we probably don't fully understand and then the fourth and I think the most difficult aspect of the atonement was bearing the wrath of God and we talked about this word propitiation which means a sacrifice that bears God's wrath and turns it to favor that makes God propitious or favorable toward a person and that word was used in pagan Greek religions about a sacrifice that would propitiate a God or make the God favorable in Greek. In Greek mythology or thinking about Greek God so it was a familiar term, a Greek term and this is the term the New Testament uses a Helosterion of propitiation that is a sacrifice that bears the wrath of God in Romans 3.25. Jesus is a propitiation, a Hebrews 2.17 he's to make propitiation for the sins of the people and there were other verses in 1 John and then at the end of the time of Jesus suffering on the cross his suffering was coming to an end and he could sense that and the wrath of God was satisfied and he said it is finished and then he laid down his life and died and said into your hands I commit my spirit. So and this was I think it was at this point that we ended last week and Isaiah 53-11 talks about this talking about he shall bear there iniquities he poured out his soul to death so that's where we were. Now I want to go on and kind of fill that in more and talk a little bit more about the death of Christ and what happened. First the penalty was inflicted by God the Father I mean we might just think of Jesus dying as he was crucified by these Roman soldiers and they were put up to it by his Jewish opponents who didn't believe in him many of his disciples also of course all his disciples were Jewish and they did believe in him but some of the Jews did not. And so we might think on a human level that the punishment came about because of these human factors these human people who were opposed to Jesus the Jewish leaders and some of the Jewish people and the Romans but ultimately it was the work of God the Father who inflicted the penalty on his own son. He was not in Corinthians 5.21 for our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin that is he God the Father made Christ to be sin who knew no sin. I have spent some time looking at that verse and studying it and I don't know and reading a lot of commentaries on it and I'm not sure that anybody fully understands what that means. That means, I think it means that the father thought of Christ as being, I didn't think of him as actually having sinned, but as if he were a sinful person, made him to be sin, made him to bear the sin, have the penalty or the guilt of sin, the liability to punishment on him. And so that was God the Father who did that. And again, Isaiah 53.6 is very explicit. The Lord has laid on him the iniquity of us all. It wasn't just human punishment. It was God the Father putting that on him. And Isaiah 53.10, it was the will of the Lord to crush him. He has put him to grieve. When his soul makes an offering for sin, he shall see his offspring, he shall prolong his days. And then I asked by way of application because I said last week, I'm going to try to put more application in more frequently here in the lessons. Will we ever be able to understand what this was like for the Father to direct his overwhelming wrath against the Son whom he loved and who had done no wrong? So yeah, I think human analogies fail us. We can get some small sense if you've raised children. And sometimes maybe you can remember where one child has done something that's really wrong and your anger or even wrath is aroused. You know, that was wrong. Maybe one child was really mean to another child or lied or just was disrespectful to his mom or her mom or something. And you discipline. And there is some anger against the wrong even though you love the child. But in those cases, you think it's right. You know, it's deserved. And it's part of our role as a parent. But what about for a child who hasn't done anything wrong? And then not just a little bit of anger that would maybe be involved in discipline, but the full force of all your wrath to be poured out on a child who had done nothing wrong. See that is really hard to comprehend. And yet here's the picture that the Bible gives us that the wrath of the Father that was due to sin that contradicted his nature and aroused his righteous burning anger. That was poured out on his perfect son who had done no wrong. How could that be? It's mystery beyond what we can understand. I just to think about it is it's troubling in a way and it's awe-inspiring in a way, isn't it? To think of that's what I deserve. And there is Jesus taking it in my place, that wrath of the Father. And hour after hour it goes on. Point B by way of application is that Jesus' life was therefore one of suffering and sacrifice for the good of others. And the question is, are we willing to follow in his steps? And verse Peter, I had that verse earlier in first Peter that said Christ also suffered for us, leaving us an example that we should follow in his steps. And I started to think, well, how do we suffer? Well, the question is, do we want to live a life pleasing to God, a life that knows God's blessing? Because that is what Jesus knew. That is even though he chose the path of hardship and suffering and obedience. It was a path of blessing, wasn't it? And he rejoiced in the Father and for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, but also he delighted to do the will of the Father, even though it was difficult in this life. So simultaneously, there is hardship or suffering that comes from without, but on the other hand, there's the favor and the good pleasure of the Father. And Jesus put say, I always do what is pleasing to him. So he knew God's favor and blessing on his life for his whole life. And then I thought about this in Arizona or in the United States in general, we are able to avoid several kinds of suffering that affect Christians in other parts of the world. The government doesn't take all this off to jail and put us to death for being Christians. As happens in China, as happens in a number of Muslim countries in Africa and Asia, we don't have our children taken from us. We don't have refused jobs being refused to us because of being, just you can't get any job at all because you're a Christian in some countries, that kind of thing. But and I suppose also in terms of healthcare in some countries or societies, they don't have nearly the healthcare we have which is able to alleviate some of our suffering. I can take allergy medicine so I can breathe and there are countries where that doesn't happen and there are a lot of ways and there's always food in the grocery store and we go to buy it. I mean, in a lot of ways, it's easy to live in the United States, isn't it? It's easy to live in Arizona. But God often calls us nonetheless to a life of sacrifice for the good of others. And so I think that Jesus' willingness to suffer for us should cause us in our hearts to say, yes, Lord, I want to follow in your steps. And even if there are things that you call me to do that are hard and that are inconvenient or there are difficult. If I can do this for the sake of your church or if I can do this for the sake of for the good of others, then I'm going to do it and believe that there will be your blessing and your favor. And O'Keefe was just talking about some missionaries to do that. But also here in this church, there are people who work with youth groups. There are mommens and dads who are devoting a lot of care to sometimes difficulties with children or other relatives. There are husbands or wives who sacrifice for the sake of the other and there are many others in other ministries here in the church who are following in price steps. And though it's a path of obedience that's difficult, it's also a path of blessing. And so I just wanted to say that Jesus' example encourages us in that. You want to give me some feedback on that at all. Am I making sense here? Help me figure out what I'm trying to get. What am I trying to get at? Yeah, okay, what's your name? Okay, hi. Ketta. Okay, get that. I was just going to say that working with the missionaries that I do and learning from the studies that we've done here at our church even in the services, I think that depending on how we step out in our faith and our communities, that's the long suffering that Christ is experiencing. I mean, we can actually experience that more so even within our families, some of us who have become Christians and our family members are still not, there's different opportunities for us to express ourselves that way. Good, thanks. Ketta, anything else? Don over here? Particular positions. Are there, some people may be there for selfish reasons, but I think truly down in the Christian's heart, when they're doing any of God's work, it's a joy. It is the pleasure of life. And it's joy and serving, isn't it? Yeah, and I feel for those who don't have that joy, that pleasure and serving, that are maybe serving for who knows how many other reasons. Good, okay. Well, it's got still Bible church, it just has an incredible number of people who serve, who, and I'm looking around the room and I'm seeing many of you and I can tell how, you know, there are many of you who are doing this, but I'm thankful for that and just to reassure you and reaffirm that and saying, God didn't call us just to make our lives as easy and pleasant as possible, sort of in the worldly material sense. He called us to a life of service, to be useful for others and useful for the work of the kingdom and so that we bring glory to him. And that's where there is true joy and fulfillment. And Jesus' pattern is an example for us. Yeah, Keith. Yeah, thanks, Wayne. And yeah, I'm just, I'm trying to connect what you're saying today to what Tim Kimmel talked about last week about grace-based parenting and I was particularly resonating this week on that issue of building into ourselves, a heart of servanthood. And perhaps one of the things you're talking about here is there's a lot of measures or barometers in our life on our personal sanctification journey and certainly one dimension of that is this year is Keith less selfish and more selfless than I was a year ago. And I think a lot of this is speaking into that space. Yeah, okay, that's really helpful. Keith, thank you. It's a good, man, a good question, a hard question to ask ourselves. And I'm looking at Keith, a lot of you through your jobs do a lot of ministry others as well. So as a physician. Okay, well that was just application. Now there's another question that kind of I wondered about from time to time. If we don't have our sins forgiven, then we face eternal punishment. Well, if Jesus paid the penalty for our sins, why didn't he face eternal punishment? Did you ever wonder about that? How did that work out? How could he just suffer for, well his lifetime, but particularly that time on the cross and then how was that enough? Well, I think we have to say that Jesus did not suffer eternally, but he made a complete payment for our sins. And there's a difference because we would have to suffer eternally if we paid for our own sins because we could never make our sinful nature righteous. And we just go on having a sinful heart and we'd still be angry at God and not caring for him and not trusting him and no matter how long we were punished if our hearts weren't changed, we'd just go on sinning and the sins would never be paid for. But Christ had a sinful nature. In fact, the fact that unbelievers go on suffering forever means that the payment is never complete, doesn't it? See, if somebody has suffered eternally it implies that it's never complete. But Jesus, when his suffering came to an end, that prove that his suffering was complete, that he bore the wrath of God to the end. In fact, Christ alone was able to bear the full measure of God's wrath to the end. There's this hymn, there is a green hill far away outside a city wall where our dear Lord was crucified who died to save us all, dearly dearly as he loved and we must love him too and trust in his redeeming love and try his works to do. And then there's another verse, there was no other good enough to pay the price of sin. He only could unlock the gate of heaven and let us in. And there's just a heart of the gospel is there. There was no other good enough to pay the price of sin. And so, when Jesus had received the Sorrow White, he said it is finished and he bowed his head and gave up his spirit. And that means that he sensed that the wrath of God that had been poured out on him finally had come to an end. And it was it was exhausted. The wrath that was due to us and his suffering was finished. And so, there's no condemnation for us for those who were in Christ Jesus. And Hebrews 9.25 says the same thing. It wasn't to offer himself repeatedly as the high priest enters the holy place as yearly with blood not his own, for then he would have had to suffer repeatedly since the foundation of the world. But as it is, he has appeared once for all at the end of the ages to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself. Jesus was offered once to bear the sins of many. And then he will appear a second time to save those who are eagerly waiting for him and Hebrews 9. So, his work of atonement on the cross came to an end. It was finished. It was sufficient. Now, I have to say here at this point we differ with our Roman Catholic friends because they have a different doctrine of the atonement. And it has to do with what Roman Catholics believe about the sacrifice of the mass. I want to quote two things here. First, the catechism of the Catholic Church, which came out in 1994 and is approved by the Pope as teaching the official doctrine of the Catholic Church. And here it says in paragraph 1364 to 67. As often as the sacrifice of the cross is celebrated on the altar, that means in the Catholic Church at a mass. The work of our redemption is carried out so it's picturing it as ongoing. The Eucharist, that's their word for the Lord's Supper or what we call communion. The Eucharist, the bread and wine, the Eucharist is also a sacrifice. In the Eucharist Christ gives us the very body which he gave up for us on the cross. The very blood which he poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins, the sacrifice of Christ and the sacrifice of the Eucharist are one single sacrifice. So it's ongoing and there's a Catholic teaching that at the at the mass, when the priest says this is my body or this is my blood, the sacrifice of Christ continues to be acted out or not just symbolically but actually acted out or performed during the mass. Ludwig Ott, an earlier book, Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, a widely used theology book, in every mass Christ also performs an actual immediate sacrificial activity. So that's a very different view and it seems to me that for Roman Catholics then there's a failure to appreciate that Christ's sacrifice is complete. It's done. It doesn't go on as long as the mass is being celebrated. We think of communion as just a symbol, a reenactment that makes us look back at what Christ has done but his sacrifice does not continue on. So that's just, do you want to talk about that at all? I'm going to interact with that. Yeah, Ann. Okay, Ann says where does that come from? Where did they get that? And I'm going to take a guess from maybe I'm remembering something and maybe I'm just reading that. But my first answer is I don't know for sure. That's my main answer. My second answer is I think it may come from the idea that this is really Christ's body and really Christ's blood. So something must be happening. But I'm not sure. Okay, as opposed to just being symbolic. But for me, there is great peace that comes from realizing that the atonement is finished, that Christ's work is done, that the penalty is all paid. That gives me great relief and there's no no punishment left that I have to bear. Another thing that I think, and I'm just kind of adding little extra understanding, extra facts of understanding here about the atonement, the atonement was primarily something that happened between Christ and God. And so it has an objective reality. I'm going to emphasize this because there are people denying it today. I'll explain that in just a minute. The atonement has an objective reality is something that happened out there. That is not in just in my heart, but out there that is between Christ and God. There was something that happened 2000 years ago and that's the heart of the atonement. It's apart from us. It was for us. But the focus of what happened was apart from us outside of us. The atonement is not in the first place, something that just affects us. Well, I'm forgiven and things like that. That's true. But first, it happened in history. It was a decisive moment where God previously stored up all that wrath against sins from Adam and Eve and Abel and Abraham and Moses and David and all those people who had been forgiven. And then he poured it all out on Christ. And also the wrath that was due to you and me and poured it out on Christ. So it's an objective event that happened in history. And I want to emphasize that. I'm going to read these two passages from Hebrews because as I say, there are people who deny that today. And usually when people go wrong on the doctrine of the atonement, they start denying the objective reality of what happened between God and Christ. But here it is. When Christ appeared as a high priest of the good things that have come, then through the greater and more perfect tent not made with hands. That is that not of this creation. He entered once, fall into the holy places. What in the world does that mean? What's going on there? Through the greater and more perfect tent not made with hands. Well, what is the tent made with hands?

The Old Testament Tabernacle. Okay. Where Moses had the people set up this elaborate tent with the the two rooms, the holy place and the Holy of Holies. And they had the table with bread on it and the seven prong candlestick the menorah and the altar in the incense was burning. And then the curtain that separated out and then the Holy of Holies. And in the Holy of Holies there was the ark of the covenant covered on all sides with gold and the cherubim with their wings over covering it. And God was there over the ark in the Holy of Holies. And only the high priest could go once a year. That was a tent made with hands. Now the author of Hebrew says that was just a copy. That was just a copy of the real thing in heaven. But when Christ appeared then through the as a high priest the only the high priest could go into the holy of Holies. So Christ appeared as a high priest. Then through the greater and more perfect tent not made with hands. That is not of this creation. So he's meaning in heaven. Where God not just where God temporarily dwells among his people but the permanent dwelling place of God in heaven. Then Christ entered once for all into the holy places. That means the holy place and the holy of Holies both into the holy places in heaven. The real one not by means of the blood of bulls and goats and calves but by means of his own blood. It's something that happened. That's his death on the cross. He entered into the greater tent by means of his own blood thus securing an eternal redemption. It happened. It's objective. It's real. And then 14 how much more will the blood of Christ? You see it is a contrast again with the Old Testament. If the blood of goats and bulls in the sprinkling of defiled persons with the ashes of a heifer sanctify for the purification of the flesh that's Old Testament. Then verse 14 how much more will the blood of Christ who through the eternal spirit offered himself without blemish to God purifier conscience from dead works to serve the living God. This is objective reality. Christ by means by virtue of his own death his blood is representing his death here. And the he through the eternal spirit there was the help of the Holy Spirit in making this offering. He offered himself as the sacrifice without blemish to God. Objective reality something truly happened in history. Christ on earth dying and then presenting himself as a sacrifice before the Father in heaven. Thus it was necessary for the copies that's Old Testament. The copies of the heavenly things to be purified with these rights but the heavenly things themselves with better sacrifices than these that is better than the animals that were sacrificed under Moses. For Christ has entered not into holy places made with hands which are copies of the true things but Christ has entered into heaven itself now to appear in the presence of God on our behalf. Nor was it to offer himself repeatedly as the high priest enters the high holy places every year with blood not his own then he would have had to suffer repeatedly since the foundation of the world but as it is he has appeared once for all at the end of the ages to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself. So he actually entered before the throne of God in heaven to present his perfect work as accomplished. John what would happen if I asked a Roman Catholic friend to explain verse 25. I don't know but I do know that a number of former Catholics having come to the book of Hebrews find that it just transforms their understanding of Christ's death that it is all finished. It's completely done. It's completely done and there's such freedom in that that I'm forgiven now there's no condemnation left for me. I stand before God and there's no guilt that he's going to give to me. It's wonderful. It's wonderful. Sandy. Well with the with the tabernacle the priest never sat because the work was never completed and so the sitting down at the right hand of God symbolized. Yeah what you're talking about the completion of it. Read the verse again Sandy. Yeah it's Hebrews 10, 12 and it says but this man at man capitalized speaking of Christ after he had offered one sacrifice for sins forever sat down at the right hand of God. I do think that sitting down at God's right hand shows the favor of God and shows the completion of his work. So that verse also it shows there's something objective that happened here. It's real. It happened in history, in heaven. Good. Good. Application. Christ's atoma was accomplished once for all. Trust him and be at peace. I mean that just gives us a wonderful sense of peace that this is done. We don't have to struggle for paying for our own sins. Application number two it's interesting that the book of Hebrews goes on to say that Christ remains there in the presence of God the Father as our great high priest and he welcomes us to come before God as forgiven people. We may take that for granted but if we had a glimpse of the burning holiness and justice of God we would tremble to think we could come before him. But Christ says don't fear if you've trusted in me I'm going to welcome you into the presence of God and here's Hebrews 10, 19 a remarkable passage. Therefore brothers since we have confidence to enter the holy places just think if you're a Jewish person and you couldn't even get near the holy place to say nothing to the holy of holies in the Old Testament you had to stay way outside the tent and then you read this and you've trusted in Christ and it says we have confidence to enter the holy places the holy place and the holy of holies by the blood of Jesus by the new and living way that he opened for us through the curtain that is through his flesh and since we have a great priest over the house of God he's gone before us and he welcomes us he represents us to God we have a great priest over the house of God let us draw near with a true heart in full assurance of faith and then this again with Old Testament imagery in the background with our heart sprinkled clean from an evil conscience that's Old Testament image of sprinkling for cleansing and our bodies washed with pure water and Old Testament image of ordaining as priests but this let us draw near and the Greek verb here is in the present tense and I think we can legitimately say that it means let us keep on drawing near let us continually draw near to God let us draw near to God again and again and again and that word phrase draw near is repeated several times in the book of Hebrews calling us come into the presence of God come before him to worship come before him to resent your needs come before him to pray come before him without fear come before him with boldness and confidence because Jesus is there welcoming you to come before the very creator of God a creator of the universe the all powerful God the all holy and righteous God you can come right into his presence amazing because Christ has gone before all right it doesn't make your heart want to spend time in prayer want to spend time in worship I think it does I stop and think about that let us draw near draw near draw near draw near says the book of Hebrews

okay next point number four in terms of further understanding of the atonement what does this phrase mean the blood of Christ and I don't know if you grew up in Sunday school and you were hearing these songs about the blood of Christ or you see hear these hymns and what is going on there blood and you cut your finger and it bleeds and you put it bandaid on it you know something about what blood is but what does blood mean well in the Old Testament shedding blood meant pouring out someone's life it meant to you you have the the the the lamb or the or the other the goat or the cow that is the heifer is going to be sacrificed and and they would cut its throat and its blood would just pour out and then the animal dies the pouring out of blood means that the life has been given and then the priest takes the blood and it goes in and sprinkles it on the altar it's a way of saying God here is the proof that a sacrifice has died giving you the blood poured out and the life was gone so therefore the blood proves that our death has occurred and so here the blood of Christ I think in the New Testament mainly means it's the evidence of payment of Christ's life as a ransom for us Matthew 2628 this is my blood of the covenant which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins they didn't sacrifice human beings in the Old Testament they sacrificed animals but now Jesus says this is blood of the covenant the new covenant and my blood is poured out not just the blood of animals and of course the the wine of the Lord supper was the couple then was the symbol of that and Romans 325 God put forward as a propitiation by his blood that means by his death for us but I was surprised to look through the New Testament and find that the blood of Christ also has other applications to the life of Christians and so here the blood of Christ let me read some I didn't print out all these verses but the blood of Christ cleanses our consciences he brews 914 that was one I just talked about how much more the blood of Christ who through the eternal spirit offered himself without blemish to God purify our conscience from dead works to serve the living God so our conscience before we come believers may be distorted and defiled and hardened and it's purified by the blood of Christ so it's sensitive to God's will but it also has a sense of being forgiven another verse on the blood of Christ it gives us access to God in worship and prayer Hebrews 1019 we have confidence to enter the holy places by the blood of Jesus I think that means that that God sees the sacrifice of Jesus his blood that was spilled on the cross God sees that and that that is evidence that Jesus has died and so we come into God's presence as a result or it cleanses us for remaining sin first John 17 if we walk in the light as he is in the light we have fellowship with one another and the blood of Jesus his son cleanses us from all sin so that's ongoing there's a sense of Jesus' death and his blood poured out at least in a spiritual sense God thinks of that as applied to us and it keeps on purifying us or revelation 15 to him who loves us and has freed us from our sins by his blood revelation 1210 it enables us to conquer the accuser revelation 12 now the salvation and the power and the kingdom of our God and the authority of his Christ have come for the accuser of our brothers who's that Satan accuser of our brothers has been thrown down who accuses them day and night before God and they have conquered him by the blood of the Lamb and by the word of their testimony for they love not their lives even unto death how do we conquer Satan by the blood of the Lamb I think when he attacks us we believe and we can say Jesus has cleansed me from sin he's forgiven me of sin Satan you have no you can bring no accusation against me it's all forgiven we conquer by the blood of the Lamb it's probably more to it than I understand but at least that and then it rescues us from a sinful pattern of life you were ransomed from the feudal ways inherited from your forefathers not with perishable things such as silver or gold but first Peter 119 with the blood of Christ like that of a Lamb without blemish or spot well I think when we think about Jesus death and his blood poured out we it would be good for us to to remember that that means that our conscience has been cleansed we don't have these accusations of guilt anymore we've we have triumph over the enemy our sins are forgiven those kinds of things questions on that

okay Trent keep on thinking this I didn't mention somehow I've got really bright lights in my eyes um I don't know if that's changeable or not care Carol when I have been tempted by Satan or I I see myself giving in to something that I know isn't right I actually say out loud I claim Jesus Christ blood who is my Savior and Lord who died on the cross for my sins and it works good wow and Satan hates that because reminder to him that he's been defeated he couldn't couldn't triumph over Jesus through Jesus death because Jesus death brought the forgiveness of our sins good Carol I chuckle when you say that because there are people today who don't like talking about the blood of Jesus oh what kind of religion is that you know talk about all this death and blood well it's at the heart of the whole Bible and then the enemy doesn't like it it reminds him that he's lost and so I like it okay now point five and now I'm getting into an area that shouldn't be any controversy but that is a controversy today and I thought I would bring this up because it started out with one or two people starting to deny this and then more people starting to deny it and my prediction is they're going to be more yet starting to deny it that is I believe that what I'm presenting here and what is in the New Testament says that Christ's death was a death of penal substitution in the law we have the penal code or the law code with regard to penalty and there's a penal system that has to do with penalizing criminals and things penal has to do with punishment penal means that Jesus bore a penalty and substitution means he died as a substitute for us sometimes this is also called vicarious atonement a vicar stands in place of another so Jesus substituted for us or he stood in our place and took God's punishment some prominent evangelicals have recently denied this doctrine the idea of penal substitution or propitiation that Jesus bore God's wrath Joel Green and Mark Baker in the book recovering the scandal of the cross unfortunately published by Interversity Press in 1990 what do they say they have different ways of understanding Jesus' death oh it's reconciliation in terms of personal relationship it's sacrifice for worship it's triumph over evil it's redemption but but the one thing they don't want is to say that it's penal substitution now listen to this sentence what is required is not a transformation within God's heart towards sinners but a transformation of their sinful existence before God let me read that again what is required is not a transformation within God's heart towards sinners but a transformation of their the sinners sinful existence before God that's denying what I call the objective character of the atonement they're saying nothing had to happen with regard to God it was just our hearts had to be changed Joel Green is a professor of New Testament at azbray seminary he was recently the academic dean that is basically number two person who was in charge of all the academics at azbray seminary azbray seminary is the has been for years the only remaining Methodist seminary that really believed the Bible the now Joel Green is teaching there and denying substitutionary atonement in another passage that's that's hard for me even to read or to say he says well many people think that the atonement where God punished Jesus for sins was divine child abuse I hate even to say that but he's saying we shouldn't believe this anymore and I was on a moody radio nation wide call and show at one time actually James McDonald and I were on together and they were doing some question answer and I said I'm really troubled that the academic dean at azbray seminary Joel Green has published this book with the University Press denying penal substitution in the atonement or denying propitiation and James McDonald said yes I'm I'm really troubled by that too and other people are reading this and following it and so then I got letter from Joel Green saying I heard you were on moody radio and you said I denied penal substitution I can't deny penal substitution because if I denied it I couldn't be dean here but I said I wrote back and said well you said this and this and this and this in your book and so that didn't resolve itself but he does deny it and there have been others in the evangelical theological society reading papers about this book and he hasn't changed what he said so so that troubled me then Judith Gundrey Wolfe taught it fuller taught New Testament a fuller for several years she's now been appointed as a professor at Yale but in this again intervarsity press book called dictionary of Paul and his letters it's a standard standard reference book she says the need of sinners can be said to be not the transformation of God's attitude toward them but the transformation of their sinful existence before God again do you hear what that sentence is saying it's taking half of the truth and making it the whole truth yeah our hearts need to be changed yes but first of all God's wrath had to be satisfied and the penalty for sin she oh no we don't need that

the idea of appeasing a wrathful God is intention with Paul's understanding of Christ's death and she says it's not propitiation that we should use to understand Christ's death and then Steve Chalk Steve Chalk in the United Kingdom in England is a very well-known evangelist and pastor Baptist pastor very very well-known he'd be of the status of I don't know a swing doll or a child Stanley or something like that here in the United States Steve Chalk came out with this book in 1994 the lost message of Jesus and what does he say he complains about the church's inability to shake off the great distortion of God contained in the theory of penal substitution with its inbuilt belief in retribution and the redemptive power of violence it has cost us dearly it produces a twisted justification of violence and encourages selfish individualistic abuses of power so these people are objecting they're saying this idea that Jesus bore the wrath of God is too violent and it leads people to be violent and it's divine child abuse and it's too individualistic makes people focus too much on themselves and their own forgiveness my response is well does the Bible teach it so yeah I can remember when I and I was in college and I was in college in the 60s and in seminary in the early 70s there were people denying propitiation they were denying penal substitution but they were all liberals they weren't evangelicals they were CH. Dodd at Cambridge University who didn't like the idea of wrath of God then I went to Cambridge for PhD work in New Testament and there was a New Testament seminar on the atonement and the and every single professor there was saying I just can't see this idea of the wrath of God against sin and of course see what's behind that that came out of the 1920s liberalism in the United States where everybody saved God loves everybody and what they did was they took half a truth and made it into the whole truth they took the truth of the love of God said God's love is so great there can't be any wrath against anybody now why would anybody want to believe that because what's the result of that

we don't have to yeah well yeah if there's no wrath of God against anybody because God's love over comes it all there's no hell or punishment how by magnifying the love of God you get rid of the doctrine of hell huh and you get rid of the idea that anybody's lost oh and also everybody saved

well you might find you know you might say oh I might like to believe that but that's now with the Bible teachers and so yeah that that came out of liberalism but now intervarsity press publishing it and zonder van sadly and these are evangelical published it used to be you could trust everything that intervarsity press published in college when I was in college that was the case but sadly they're they're publishing things like this denying penal substitution which has been at the heart of the gospel my answer to that is the only question is does the Bible teach it yes it's got that word propitiation there yes God made him to be sin who knew no sin he bore our sins on the cross the Lord has laid on him the iniquity of us all rightly understood the doctrine doctrine of penal substitution should never cause us to be violent or aggressive or abused children I mean that's that's a foolish ridiculous stupid misinterpretation of the Bible because the Bible commands us to imitate Christ in his love we can't ever take it to ourselves to be God an exact you know pour out wrath on on sinners God has done rightly understood the doctrine of penal substitution Christ bearing the wrath of God it should cause us to tremble at the horror of our sin it called forth such a response from God denial of penal substitution is a left over product of 1920s liberalism that hated the idea of the wrath of God or the idea that some are not saved but my response is penal substitution is at the heart of the gospel and without it there's no way to satisfy God's justice and enable us to be saved when I was in England two months ago I found out that this largest Bible conference in England I think it's largest called spring harvest every year the British Intervarcity which is more conservative than American Intervarcity British Intervarcity called Universities and Colleges Christian Fellowship they would sponsor the Bible teaching at this spring harvest conference but spring harvest invited Steve chalk this year to be a major teacher and Intervarcity went right up to the board of Intervarcity they said okay we're not going to participate anymore and so Intervarcity withdrew from that 30,000 person Bible conference I may not have the numbers exactly right but it's huge they withdrew because they said we cannot share the platform with somebody who denies penal substitution and I am glad for that they took a stand they said this is a doctrine we're going to stand on and we're not going to we're not going to let the denial of it be something unimportant do you want to ask more about that or talk more about that yeah Joyce say it again Joyce that doesn't that philosophy philosophy more or less than the gate and necessity Jesus Christ yeah see they come up with all sorts of other theories of what the atonement meant why did Jesus have to die always an example of how we are to suffer or it was just shows how bad sin is and all that but if you take out the wrath of God I really don't think you've got a good explanation for why Jesus had to die I really don't think it is yeah so I think that's right you've got it the heart of it anything else what else yeah over here when I grew up in a Methodist church and one Sunday a known communist came to take the pulpit church now that's when dad stood up said that's enough and we left along with half of the church yeah but what we have tend to learn I think that the Methodist seminary has been taken over and what they are teaching there seems to be a social gospel and they're getting further and further away I I we call it communism to be exact but I don't know how strong it is that's from what we learned gosh when I was 17 or so okay it doesn't look too good for the seminary yeah yeah it's it's very troubling wait now I've got to say I mean my friend Al copage a godly faithful man still teaches theology there and he's completely sound it is doctrine and there are others there who are grieved over over what has happened and what has been allowed so it's not a hundred percent and there are Methodist churches that are Bible leaving churches so it's not all but the control of the seminaries and the control of the denominations is in the hands of liberals no sadly yeah one other yep um I forgot your name and I Tina yes as evangelical Christians and saving faith don't we believe that Jesus Christ was the son of God we have faith in that and we have faith that he died for our sins so how do they define saving faith they would trust in Jesus but not be quite sure why he saves them well I'm I'm really simplifying but I've known some people who deny propitiation and they they have to say well it was it was something else than bearing the penalty for our sins and then the other theories just that that's kind of a mystery in the end well okay I tell you what I was going to finish this outline today but it looks like let me just let me just say don't be tempted here's the application don't be tempted to abandon some teaching of the Bible just because people in our modern culture don't like it or object to it or find it offensive and and Joel Green went to a really liberal seminary I think Perkins school of theology and so what did he learn there in Judah well anyway Joel Green went there um and and this doctrine should not be embarrassing to us it should be something we rejoice in in fact when we think about Jesus bearing the wrath of God against sin it should cause us to experience amazement that the eternal son of God was the object of the wrath of the of the eternal father amazement and awe and deep profound joy as we contemplate Jesus bearing the wrath of God it was due to our sin you know the words of that old spiritual oh sometimes it causes me to tremble tremble tremble were you there when they crucified my Lord I think that should be our response

well let's see we're going to have to come back two weeks from today and finish this up Lord Jesus we give you thanks for this wonderful wonderful teaching of your word and this wonderful fact that you did pay the penalty for our sins that you did bear you willingly bore the wrath of God that was due to us Lord though though the world doesn't understand and in many cases just does not like this doctrine because it humbles us Lord it tells us that we can do nothing to earn our salvation Lord we delight in it we treasure it we thank you for it we are amazed at it keep this in our minds Lord your sacrifice for us and the great peace and freedom from condemnation that it gives us Amen